Chapter Text
Thorin’s pie, last to enter the fair and last to the stage, was the last to be judged, and a tense hush had fallen over the usually chatty crowd as everyone waited to see whether Maisy Brownlock could possibly have met her match at last.
Bilbo just wanted to see the look on Lobelia’s face.
She’d maneuvered herself so that she was the first of the four judges to try each pie, and it was her over-the-top reaction that always set the trend.
Behind him, Thorin was tense. Bilbo snuggled further into his embrace, and the arms around him relaxed just a fraction.
The first slice of pie came out of the tin - a proper one for this most important of pies - like a dream. The crowd sighed in admiration as the judges complimented the smoothness of the curd, the ratio of curd to meringue, and the flakiness of the crust. So far, it seemed a match for Maisy’s pie, and so it would come down to taste.
As she’d planned, Lobelia was the first to take a bite, and the look on her face was as if someone had served her a mouthful of raw lemon.
Bilbo let out a shrill little giggle, unable to help himself. Thorin gave him a squeeze and a kiss on top of his head, and he was ashamed he’d ever considered sabotaging his husband’s plot. It really wasn’t hurting anything at all, and they’d all have a good laugh over drinks later, and Bilbo began to hope that all might be forgiven in the name of a good joke.
But then the queerest thing happened.
The second judge, Posco Proudfoot, tasted the pie, and he smiled.
Salvia Cotton was next, her cheeks bright with excitement as she chewed, and finally stern old Rondo Bracegirdle, who went back for a second bite.
Aside from Lobelia, none of them appeared disgusted, horrified, traumatized, or otherwise the least bit put out by Thorin’s pie, and Bilbo could not understand it.
The judges conferred for a minute with each other, then the Gaffer, before he stepped forward once again. He waved his hands importantly, though the field was already dead silent in anticipation. “Ladies and gentlefolk,” he began, “the results are in, and I am very pleased to say that we will very shortly be adjourning for dinner, supper - and quite possibly breakfast tomorrow, if the drinks flow free.” He paused for the cheer that went up across the field. “Now,” the Gaffer continued, “all of our entrants today made a very solid showing. Let’s have a hand for all our fantastic cooks, bakers, crafters, and gardeners!”
“Get on with it already!” shouted someone from the back.
“Don’t get your toe hair in knots, Master Proudfoot,” the Gaffer called back. “I'll get there. Third prize goes to Mrs. Flora Brandybuck’s blueberry pie with cinnamon crust.” He waited for the polite applause and the hooting from the Buckland hobbits to die down. Flora, beaming, scurried forward to collect her white ribbon. She pinned it into her auburn curls and did a quick twirl, much to the audience’s amusement.
“Second prize - and my, this is unexpected, to say the least - to Miss Maisy Brownlock for her legendary lemon meringue.” There was a great deal of murmuring at this, but Maisy accepted her red ribbon with admirable good grace and a grin in Thorin’s direction. His hold tightened around Bilbo, who began patting his husband’s hand consolingly.
“And first prize goes to first-time competitor Thorin Oakenshield-Baggins!”
“What?” Bilbo blurted as the crowd went wild.
Thorin was immediately engulfed in a crowd of well-wishers, but Bilbo was too confused to be proud. He ducked out of the throng and marched up to the stage, where Lobelia was once again looking as if she’d swallowed a lemon. He picked up a spare fork and carefully lifted off one of the leaves from Thorin’s pie. He gave it an experimental sniff, then a lick.
It wasn’t mint at all.
It was lemon balm.
He steeled himself and tried a bite of the pie.
It was perfectly sweet, perfectly tart, perfectly smooth... It was sunshine on a plate.
Thorin’s booming laugh rang out, and Bilbo turned, stunned, to see most of the crowd was now watching him in no small degree of confusion. “I thought - “
Frodo was laughing too. “You should have seen your face, Uncle!”
“But the squash, the peppers… cornmeal… I saw your setup.”
“All safely hidden in Master Gamgee’s pantry,” Thorin rumbled, stepping up onto the stage to accept his blue ribbon from the Gaffer. "I've had a great deal of practice at getting pies wrong, Ghivashel, but that is still a great deal of practice at making pies." He turned to the crowd, throwing an arm around Bilbo's shoulders. “You all may remember a certain tent full of flowers that a great many of you helped me engineer, but I believe my husband owes you the story of the pie that went with it. Come on - drinks are on Bilbo!”
"They're free," Bilbo squeaked.
Thorin kissed his forehead. "Then I'll pay."
