Actions

Work Header

I Was a Lonely Soul

Chapter 25

Summary:

A necessary conversation.

Chapter Text

“I had meant to come back,” Bilbo began. “Retrace my steps.”

Thorin smiled. “There are safer ways to travel to Erebor now.”

“No, no. I mean my steps.” Thorin’s expression grew confused. It was Bilbo’s turn to smile. “The steps of my journey back to the Shire. I thought that maybe doing such a thing would remind me how I managed to believe my lies all those years ago, all the justifications and excuses and arguments in favour of returning there instead of staying here, and why believing all of my falsehoods and pretexts was better than…”

Bilbo trailed off. Thorin danced into his reach then, his hand clutching Bilbo’s, his forehead touching his own. They had never bumped foreheads before. He found it more intimate than kissing. He would definitely not be against the idea of doing it more often. The years he had spent deprived of Thorin’s touch were too many, and Bilbo intended to make up for every second they had lost.

“All this time,” Thorin said, “I thought you felt regret.”

“Regret?”

“Over agreeing to the quest,” said Thorin, his voice soft, “and everything that took place after.”

“Oh, Thorin.” Bilbo gave a light tug at one of Thorin’s silver braids. “You know I would never. I could never. I’ve told you a thousand times already.”

“Reading it in letters isn’t quite the same as hearing it.”

“So do you trust my words now then?”

“Perhaps.” Thorin’s shoulders bowed under an impossible weight. “Our parting was so bitter—”

“Our parting was sad,” Bilbo corrected, “not bitter.”

“I thought you wished to forget.”

“I never wanted to forget,” said Bilbo, bringing the end of Thorin’s braid to his lips. “Not everything. Not most of it. And the things I do wish I could forget are my own failures and what they caused.”

“Bilbo—”

“You can’t say I’m not to blame, Thorin. I am.”

The Arkenstone had been a shortcut and a trapdoor. Bilbo hadn’t realised that until after the damage had been done. World-weary and homesick, he had just wanted the quest to end at last. The dragon had been slain, the treasure recovered, the Mountain reclaimed. Yet there had been armies on their doorstep, and Bilbo had—well, he had misjudged things terribly.

He still felt a deep shame whenever he thought of what he had done and how easily he had been forgiven afterward. Thorin’s hand clutching his as the King struggled to draw breath, the bedridden Princes asking him to stay, the entire Company faring him well the day he had left. And then there had come the letters. Oh, the letters. So much love poured into words, given mortal shape in mortal symbols, and flown across an entire world to reach its intended recipient, time and time again.

He hadn’t deserved those letters, much less the feelings they confessed.

“Who’s free of blame then?” Thorin challenged. “Who in our Company can claim to be free of it?”

“Most of them, I’d say.”

Thorin sighed. “Bilbo, we’re old now. It’s been years. Our mistakes and misdeeds were swiftly forgotten in the wake of our victory, and we shouldn’t forget, but we should forgive. We should forgive ourselves.” Thorin’s hands came up to cup Bilbo’s cheeks. “Don’t you think we’ve repented enough, all these decades? The distance, the isolation, the yearning, all that festering fear and time wasted, all those prayers and questions unanswered. Don’t you think we deserve to lay all that to rest?”

“I think we must be held accountable for what we did and didn’t do.”

“Don’t you think we have?”

“I do.” Bilbo disentangled himself and took a step back, once again, and looked down. “You know I do. But it never feels like enough.”

“Well, it is,” said Thorin, his tone firm.

Bilbo wiped at the corner of his eye with as much surreptitiousness as possible. Thorin held out his arms, and Bilbo stepped forward again, still looking down, and let himself be pulled into an embrace that smelled of furs, snow, and warm stone.

“Amrâlimê,” Thorin sighed against his curls, a gentle victory.

After a beat, Bilbo said, “So that’s how you pronounce it.”

Thorin laughed. “Fifty years I’ve been calling you this. You could have asked.”

“What for? There was no point.”

“Isn’t the pursuit of knowledge something of a hobby to you?”

“Yes, but it would have been a sorry business indeed,” Bilbo pulled back just enough to gaze up at Thorin, “knowing how to say it but not having you there to call you that.”

Thorin’s smile was dazzling, dizzying, devastating in the best of ways. He leant down, and Bilbo had no trouble agreeing to the ensuing kiss. It was firm, steady, certain of its welcome and in no rush to leave. Bilbo had no rush in cutting its visit short, either. Tasting the curve of Thorin’s smile was something that Bilbo doubted would ever becoming a task.

When they finally broke the kiss, Bilbo was sporting a smile to match Thorin’s.

“So,” he said, “we’ll be living here?”

The uncomfortable tug of guilt made itself known again. How could he be so happy when he was, by all intents and purposes, speaking of deserting Frodo? The lad wouldn’t want to stay, and Bilbo hated the fact that he knew he wouldn’t go back if Thorin wanted to remain in Erebor. He loved Frodo, and a good guardian would put his charge’s happiness before his own, wouldn’t they? So why couldn’t he? Why wouldn’t he?

Because he wanted this second chance. It had begun before the proposal, the little traitorous whispering which told him that maybe it would be nice to stay for some time in the north, reacquainting himself with both Dale and the Lonely Mountain, reacquainting himself with old friends, reacquainting himself with his dwarf-King.

He wanted to stay and live a life he had denied himself out of shame and guilt decades before. He wanted to let himself want it, deserve it, seize it. When it was ripe for the taking, was it really so awful that he found it impossible to deny himself any longer? He thought of Frodo and knew the answer to that question, but he still wanted to think he could have it.

“I absconded the throne to give you the chance to decide,” Thorin said.

Bilbo blinked. “What, really?”

“If you wished to return west, I would join you. Erebor has had me long enough.”

“You’d give up a kingdom—this kingdom—for me?”

“Yes,” Thorin said, that simple answer making Bilbo’s eyes sting. “I never reclaimed it for myself. It was for my people. I know I’ll leave the Mountain in good hands, and so I have no fear about going.”

Bilbo considered this, then smiled ruefully. “I know what I want, but I must speak with Frodo before taking any more decisions. He is my charge and my heir. He has a right to have a say, even if he may not want the same things I do.”

“Of course,” Thorin said.

“But, between us,” Bilbo lowered his voice as though revealing a secret, “I haven’t really had time to see Erebor as much as I wanted these past few days, and I doubt all of winter will be enough to become properly acquainted. I’d like to stay and come to know its halls the same way you have.”

Thorin smiled. “I would love to introduce you.”

“And I would love that.” Bilbo closed his eyes. “But I must speak with Frodo first.”

Thorin kissed Bilbo’s forehead. “I will fetch him.”