Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Abomination.

Summary:

Steve Harrington secretly dates Billy Hargrove until Billy dies at Starcourt, then falls in love with Eddie Munson, only to lose him too. Raised to believe loving men is a sin, Steve becomes convinced their deaths are God’s punishment for his sins, and swears he’ll never love a man again.

Haunted by guilt and the ghosts he can’t outrun, Steve swears he’ll never make the same mistake again… even if it means breaking his own heart.

Notes:

First time writing angst #nervous
Hope you enjoy!!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

The first time Steve Harrington kissed Billy Hargrove, it tasted like blood and bubblegum.

They were parked too close to Lover’s Lake in Billy’s Camaro. The radio played a classic rock song, but neither of them paid attention. Later, Steve would tell himself it was an accident: an argument that went too far, a shove that lingered, a challenge that changed into something else.

But that was a lie.

It started in the way Billy looked at him.

Not the public look, the sneer, the rivalry, the sharp-edged taunts that cut just deep enough to get a reaction. It was the private look. The one that lingered a half-second too long in the hallway when no one else was watching. The one that burned at the back of Steve’s neck in the locker room when Billy thought he was alone.

Steve had known that look.

He’d seen it in the mirror.

They were both so angry back then. Angry at their fathers. Angry at Hawkins. Angry at themselves.

The first kiss came after a fight, of course it did. Billy shoved him against the side of the Camaro, hands gripping Steve’s jacket, breath hot and furious.

“You think you’re better than me, Harrington?” Billy had spat.

Steve didn’t know why he did it. Maybe he was tired of pretending. Maybe he was tired of being the version of himself everyone expected: King Steve, the golden boy with the perfect hair and the perfect girlfriend.

“Maybe I just don’t like you looking at me like that,” Steve had said.

Billy froze.

“Like what?”

“Like you want something.”

The silence between them had been electric. Terrifying.

Billy’s grip tightened. “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”

Steve swallowed. His heart hammered so loud he was sure Billy could hear it. “Then prove me wrong.”

It was desperate, furious, and clumsy. It was teeth and heat and fear. It felt like jumping off a cliff without knowing if there was water below.

When they pulled apart, both of them were breathing hard.

“Don’t tell anyone,” Billy said immediately, like it was a threat.

“I won’t,” Steve replied, just as quickly.

And that was how it began.

 

It stayed secret.

It had to.

Hawkins was small. Hawkins was cruel. And Hawkins went to church every Sunday.

Steve’s mother sang in the choir when she wasn’t travelling for work. His father shook hands with the pastor after the service, a firm grip and a tighter smile. Steve had grown up beneath stained-glass windows depicting saints and martyrs, had memorised verses about sin and damnation before he’d even understood what they meant.

Man shall not lie with man.

The words had carved themselves into him long before Billy ever had.

Every time Billy touched him, behind the bleachers, in the back seat of the Camaro, in the shadows of Steve’s bedroom when his parents were out of town, there was always a second voice in Steve’s head.

This is wrong.

This is filthy.

God is watching.

But Billy’s hands were warm and insistent, and when Billy looked at him in those private moments, there was something raw there. Something vulnerable. Something that made Steve feel less alone.

Billy never said “I love you.”

Steve never asked him to.

They weren’t that kind of couple. They didn’t hold hands in public, share slow dances, or whispered promises. They fought, made up, and fought again. They hurt each other’s pride and then tried to fix it. Sneaking through the window some nights, climbing up like a delinquent Romeo. He’d collapse onto Steve’s bed and complain about his father, about Max, about the suffocating boredom of Hawkins.

“You ever feel like this town’s trying to choke you?” Billy asked once, staring at the ceiling.

“Yeah,” Steve admitted.

Billy turned his head. “We could leave.”

It sounded like a joke.

It didn’t feel like one.

But Steve thought about church pews, his father’s expectations, and the way people in Hawkins whispered about anyone different. He thought about what would happen if anyone found out.

“Maybe,” he said, because it was easier than saying no.

 

The summer of 1985 came heavy and hot.

Billy started working at the pool.

Steve started working at Scoops Ahoy.

They saw less of each other in daylight, more at night. Billy would show up smelling like chlorine and sunscreen, skin golden and gleaming, and Steve would feel that same rush of want and fear tangled together.

The first time Billy said something that almost sounded like hope, it was in the dark.

They were lying in the back of the Camaro, parked somewhere quiet. Billy’s head was on Steve’s chest.

“My dad would kill me,” Billy said, voice low.

Steve’s stomach tightened. “For what?”

Billy snorted softly. “You know what.”

Steve did.

“He’d say I was weak,” Billy continued. “Sick.”

Steve closed his eyes. The words felt familiar.

“We are,” Steve whispered.

Billy didn’t answer.

He just held on tighter.

 

When the Mind Flayer took Billy’s body like a vesal, Steve knew something was wrong before anyone else said it out loud.

Billy stopped showing up at his window.

Stopped staring for that extra second.

When Steve saw him at Starcourt Mall, after crashing his car into his, there was something hollow in his eyes. Something that didn’t look like Billy at all.

They didn’t get a chance to talk. Not really. The world was ending again, and Steve was too busy trying to keep the kids safe.

But there was a moment.

In the mall.

In the bright artificial light of Starcourt, with everything crumbling around them.

Billy, battered and bleeding, was standing between Eleven and the monster.

For a split second, Billy looked at him.

Not at Max.

Not at anyone else.

At Steve.

And in that look, Steve saw it, the real Billy. The boy who climbed through his window. The boy who whispered about leaving Hawkins. The boy who was terrified of his father, terrified of himself.

I’m sorry.

The words weren’t spoken.

They didn’t have to be.

The Mind Flayer’s tendril pierced through Billy’s chest.

Steve didn’t scream, but his throat hurt afterwards, a lump, a crucifix lodged in there.

He didn’t remember falling to his knees, but he found himself there.

 

Billy died a hero.

That’s what they said.

Billy saved Eleven. Billy saved the world.

But no one knew about the nights in the Camaro. No one knew about the kisses behind the bleachers. No one knew about the way Billy’s hands trembled sometimes after church.

Steve went to the funeral in a black suit that felt too tight.

He stood near the back.

He watched Max cry.

He watched people talk about Billy’s “troubled soul.”

He wondered if God had finally decided Billy was too much of a sinner to keep around.

And then the thought came, sharp and poisonous:

Or maybe it was me.

Maybe God saw.

Maybe God punished me.

That night, Steve knelt beside his bed for the first time in years.

He tried to pray.

“I’m sorry,” he whispered to the dark. “I didn’t mean to. I didn’t, I won’t do it again.”

But the sky felt empty.

 

Grief hollowed him out.

He told himself it was normal. Anyone would be shaken after something like that. Anyone would have nightmares about a monster ripping through someone they cared about.

But his grief was quiet. Hidden.

He couldn’t cry in front of anyone.

He couldn’t say, “I loved him.”

He had to pretend that Billy had just been a rival. A guy he knew. A guy he didn’t even like.

The secret sat in his chest like a stone.

Robin noticed something was wrong.

She was the only one who ever really saw him. Maybe because she shared a similar secret. Maybe because she knew what it was like to be afraid of being found.

“You okay?” she asked one night at Family Video.

Steve shrugged. “Yeah.”

“Bullshit.”

He laughed weakly. “I’m fine, okay?”

She studied him for a long moment. “You don’t have to tell me. But you don’t have to carry everything alone either.”

He almost told her.

Almost.

But the words stuck.

 

He tried to be better.

He went to church more often.

He volunteered.

He dated girls.

But every time he closed his eyes, he saw Billy in the mall. Saw the way he looked at him before he died.

Every time he felt even the smallest flicker of attraction toward another guy, a random customer at Family Video, some stranger at a party. His stomach twisted.

Don’t.

You.

Dare.

You know what happens.

 

He told himself it was a coincidence.

He told himself monsters killed Billy.

But late at night, when the house was quiet, and the world felt thin, he imagined a different version.

A God who watched.

A God who judged.

A God who punished.

 

Then Eddie Munson crashed into his life like a thunderstorm.

Loud.

Unapologetic.

Impossible to ignore.

Eddie was nothing like Billy.

Billy was all sharp edges and smirks. Eddie had wild curls and manic laughter. Billy burned hot and angry, but Eddie burned bright and strange.

Steve met him properly in the chaos of 1986. In the middle of panic and accusations, a town is ready to tear itself apart.

Eddie was terrified.

Steve saw it immediately.

The bravado was a shield.

The sarcasm was armour.

Steve recognised it because he’d worn something similar once.

They didn’t start as anything close to friends.

Eddie called him “King Steve” with exaggerated bows.

Steve rolled his eyes and told him to shut up.

But somewhere between hiding in boats and fighting off nightmares, something shifted.

It happened slowly.

A shared look.

A joke that lasted too long.

A brush of hands that neither of them pulled away from immediately.

The first time Eddie touched him on purpose, it was almost gentle.

They were in the boathouse, adrenaline still thrumming through them after a close call. Eddie reached out and wiped blood from Steve’s cheek.

“You’re gonna get yourself killed, Harrington,” Eddie muttered.

Steve huffed. “You first.”

Eddie’s hand lingered.

Their eyes met.

And there it was again.

That look.

It was the same as Billy’s, maybe softer, but just as undeniable.

Steve’s heart dropped.

Not again.

Please, not again.

He pulled away first.

“We should get going,” he said, voice tight.

Eddie watched him carefully. “Yeah. Sure.”

 

It took weeks.

Weeks of dancing around it.

Weeks of pretending.

Until one night, sitting on the hood of Steve’s car under a sky full of indifferent stars, Eddie finally said it.

“You ever feel like you’re pretending to be someone else?”

Steve went very still.

“Sometimes,” he said cautiously.

Eddie swallowed. “I get so tired of it. Of acting like I don’t care. Like I don’t…” He trailed off.

“Like you don’t know what?” Steve asked, even though he knew.

Eddie looked at him.

Really looked at him.

“Like I don’t look at you and think about kissing you.”

The world stopped.

 

A God who watched.

A God who judged.

A God who punished.

 

Steve’s chest tightened so hard he thought he might pass out.

He could walk away.

He should walk away.

He’d promised.

He’d knelt beside his bed and promised.

“I can’t,” Steve whispered.

Eddie’s face fell. “Oh.”

“It’s not-” Steve ran a hand through his hair. “It’s not you. I just. can’t.”

“Because you’re straight,” Eddie asked, trying for lightness and failing.

Steve almost laughed.

If only it were that simple.

“I’m not,” he said, barely audible.

Eddie’s breath caught.

“Then what?”

Steve thought of church pews. Of Billy bleeding out on the mall floor. The bruising on his knees.

“Bad things happen,” he said finally.

Eddie frowned. “To everyone.”

“Not like that.”

Eddie stared at him, confused.

Steve didn’t know how to explain the superstition that had rooted itself in his bones. The certainty that loving a man was like painting a target on his back.

On their backs.

“You don’t want to be with me,” Steve said, forcing the words out. “Trust me.”

Eddie was quiet for a long time.

“Too late,” he said softly.

 

Steve gave in.

Because he was weak.

Because he was lonely.

Because god is not responsible for the actions of wicked people.

Because when Eddie kissed him, it didn’t taste like blood and bubblegum.

It tasted like hope.

It was slower than with Billy. Gentler. Eddie cupped his face like something precious. Like something worth protecting.

Steve cried afterwards.

Eddie didn’t make a big deal of it. Just held him.

“You’re not the problem,” Eddie murmured into his hair.

Steve wished he believed that.

 

Their relationship was even more secret than his had been with Billy.

Not because Eddie demanded it.

But because Steve did.

“No one can know,” he insisted.

Eddie tilted his head. “Why?”

“Just- please.”

Eddie nodded.

For him.

They found quiet places. The trailer when Wayne was at work. Steve’s car was parked far from town. The edges of the woods.

With Eddie, there were no angry fights. No sharp words. There was laughter. There were long conversations about music, fantasy campaigns and dreams bigger than Hawkins.

 

“California,” Eddie said once, eyes shining. “Or New York. Somewhere loud and weird.”

Steve smiled faintly. “Yeah. Somewhere loud and weird.”

“And you are coming with me,” Eddie added casually.

The words landed heavily, sending ripples through him.

Billy had said something similar once.

We could leave.

Steve’s chest tightened.

“I don’t know,” he said.

Eddie nudged him. “You don’t have to decide now. Just… think about it.”

Steve did think about it.

He thought about a life where he didn’t have to kneel beside his bed and beg forgiveness. A life where loving someone like this didn’t feel like a crime.

But every time he imagined it, another image followed.

Billy dying.

A warning.

A consequence.

A God who watched.

A God who judged.

A God who punished.

 

And the gates were open, and the sky was cracked, and had town turned on Eddie, Steve felt the old dread crawl back in.

Not him, too.

Please.

He told himself it was different. That the Upside Down didn’t care who he kissed. Those monsters didn’t answer to God.

But fear doesn’t listen to reason.

 

The night they went back into the Upside Down, Eddie squeezed his hand before letting go.

“Hey,” Eddie said lightly. “After this? We’re getting the hell out of here.”

Steve forced a smile. “Yeah.”

“Promise?”

The word lodged in Steve’s throat.

“Promise,”

He watched Eddie climb onto that trailer roof.

Watched him play his guitar with wild energy, fearless and bold.

For a moment, Steve felt something like pride. Like awe.

That’s my-

He never finished the thought.

The demobats came like a storm.

Steve ran.

Of course, he ran.

They all did.

It was the plan.

It was supposed to be a distraction.

But when he realised Eddie wasn’t following, when he heard the screaming and the tearing and the sickening sound of wings, something inside him snapped.

“No,” Steve breathed.

He turned back.

He shouldn’t have.

He did anyway.

He found Eddie on the ground, bleeding.

Too much blood.

Always too much blood.

Eddie looked up at him, dazed.

“I didn’t run away this time, right?” he said weakly.

Steve dropped to his knees.

“Don’t,” he choked out. “Don’t you dare.”

Eddie smiled faintly. “It’s okay.”

It wasn’t.

It wasn’t okay.

Steve pressed his hands over the wounds like he could hold Eddie together through sheer force of will.

“You’re gonna be fine,” he lied. “You’re gonna be fine.”

Eddie’s fingers curled weakly into his shirt.

“Don’t hide,” Eddie whispered.

Steve froze.

“What?”

“Don’t… hide,” Eddie repeated, voice fading. “You deserve… more.”

Tears blurred Steve’s vision.

“Stay with me,” he begged.

But Eddie’s hand went slack.

And just like that, he was gone.

 

The town called Eddie a freak.

A murderer.

They didn’t give him a funeral like Billy’s. They didn’t cry over his sacrifice.

They hunted his memory.

Steve carried the truth alone.

Again.

He didn’t go to church after that.

He couldn’t.

The stained glass felt like it was watching him. Judging him.

God warned him, and he didn’t listen.

 

First Billy.

Now Eddie.

 

Twice is not a coincidence.

 

Steve stopped sleeping.

Stopped eating.

He replayed every moment in his mind. Every kiss. Every whispered promise.

 

Maybe if he’d said no.

Maybe if he’d walked away.

Maybe if he’d been stronger.

Maybe if he practised what he preached.

 

Robin found him sitting on the floor of Family Video one evening, staring at nothing.

“Steve?” she asked softly.

He didn’t answer.

She sat down beside him.

“What’s going on?”

The dam broke.

“I kill them,” he said hoarsely.

Robin blinked. “What?”

“Everyone I-” His voice cracked.

Her face softened. “Steve…”

“Billy,” he whispered. “Eddie.”

Robin’s breath hitched.

He’d never said Billy’s name like that before.

“They died because of me,” he continued, spiralling. “Because I- I can’t stop-”

“Stop what?”

He squeezed his eyes shut.

“loving them. liking them”

The words hung between them.

Robin was very still.

“Steve,” she said carefully, “Were they-”

“They were mine,” he choked out. “I loved them. And they died. And I know it’s, it’s because-”

“Because of what?”

“Because I loved them.”

He points upwards, as if to the sky.

“he doesnt take kindly to that.”

The silence that followed was thick.

Then Robin reached out and grabbed his face, forcing him to look at her.

“That is not how this works,” she said softly.

“You don’t know that.”

“I do,” she insisted. “Bad things happen because we live in a nightmare hell dimension town, not because you kissed someone.”

Steve let out a broken laugh.

“You don’t get it.”

“Then make me get it.”

He shook his head. "You shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination”

Robin’s eyes filled with tears.

“people like me... like us, we burn.”

“We don’t burn,” she said. “You survive. You fight. You save people.”

“Not the ones I love.”

Her grip tightened.

“You are not that powerful,” she said bluntly. “You are not some cosmic curse. Billy died because of the Mind Flayer. Eddie died because of the bats. Not because you loved them. Because they saved us.”

Steve wanted to believe her.

He wanted to.

But guilt is louder than reason.

 

He stopped seeing men that way.

Or tried to.

Whenever a spark flared, he crushed it down.

No.

Not again.

He dated girls. Nice girls. Safe girls.

He told himself it was easier.

Safer.

If he never let himself feel that way again, then no one else would die.

 

He told himself he was done.

But grief doesn’t fade just because you deny it.

It lingers.

In quiet moments.

In songs on the radio.

In the way sunlight hits the passenger seat of his car, he expects someone to be there.

Sometimes he dreams of them.

Billy stands by the lake, sun on his shoulders, and says nothing.

Eddie sits on the hood of the car, grinning, and asks, “You coming?”

In the dreams, Steve always reaches for them.

In the dreams, they never die.

He wakes up with tears on his face and the same thought echoing in his head

It was my fault.

 

Years later, Hawkins will rebuild.

The cracks in the earth will scar over.

People will move on.

Steve will still carry the ghosts.

He will smile. He will laugh. He will babysit, flirt and pretend.

But there will always be a part of him kneeling beside a bed in the dark, whispering apologies to a God he isn’t sure is listening.

He will swear, again and again, that he will never let himself love a man like that, and he will call it protection.

But sometimes, when the night is very quiet, and the world feels thin, he will think of Billy’s almost-hopeful “We could leave.”

He will think of Eddie’s dying plea: “Don’t hide.”

And something inside him will ache.

Because he knows the truth.

The monsters didn’t kill them because he loved them.

God did.

And maybe. Just maybe, The cruelest thing God ever taught him was to believe.

But belief is hard to untangle from blood and bone.

Notes:

Hiya, here just to twist the knife before pulling it out.
Lots of love, hope you enjoyed <3