Chapter Text
This might be the first time that Bilbo had ever known the Great Smials to be quiet during a meal.
Partly, of course, it was that most of the family was eating elsewhere this night. Only Fortinbras, Lalia and Adalgrim were present to represent the Tooks. It left them somewhat outnumbered, but at least they all fit into the best dining room. It really wasn’t meant to feed an army of distant relatives the way that some of the other rooms in the Smial were.
The other reason for the silence was sheer awkwardness. Hobbit practice was not to discuss business during a meal. Dwarven practice, Bilbo suspected, was to deal with business whenever it suited them or whenever it inconvenienced their hosts, depending on which concern was paramount at the time.
Either way, after Fortinbras had gently shut down any discussion of the dwarves’ purpose for being here, King Thorin had retreated into silence and his Company had followed him.
Bilbo, never exactly garrulous, had not felt up to rescuing the situation.
Luckily, Lalia Took was not easily perturbed. She also appeared to have resigned herself to the necessity of dealing with their guests at some point while Bilbo was scolding her husband.
‘Your people travel far more widely than our own, I am told, King Thorin,’ Lalia said into the silence as they ate their main course. ‘You must have seen some wonders on those travels.’
‘Some, Mistress Took,’ King Thorin replied. He raised his eyes from his plate for the first time in some minutes and clearly made an effort to act like a proper dinner guest. At least he had some manners. ‘Though few more impressive than the greenness of this land. We are mountain dwellers. Far more used to arid climes than the lushness you have here.’
‘Yes,’ Lalia agreed. ‘We are lucky indeed. Though luck does not account for all that you see. Farming is hard work, both in bad years and good.’ Having made her point, Lalia allowed herself a very small smile. Bilbo immediately became nervous. It was not that Lalia never smiled. She was not that much of a dragon, even if she had scared off every prospective wife her son had ever looked at.
It was just that usually she smiled because she was about to be amused at someone else’s expense.
‘There are also dangers that come along with having such fertile lands,’ Lalia continued. ‘If you do not keep it in check, plant-life has a tendency to try and swallow you whole. Bilbo could tell you all about that.’
‘Lalia,’ Bilbo groaned in horror. Though mostly only because of the presence of their guests. He knew exactly which story she was aiming at. Bilbo would be the first to admit that the story was entertaining for his fellow hobbits, and his mother had pulled it out at many a family party to amuse guests. It was just that he was usually related to the people who heard it.
‘What happened?’ Prince Kíli asked, ears pricking up as he sensed a story. A number of the others also looked livelier than they had since dinner began.
Bilbo resisted the urge to bang his head on the table.
‘Nothing half as diverting to others as it is to my family,’ he assured the dwarves, giving Lalia an unimpressed look. She smiled a little wider and, though it had a sly edge to it, the expression invited Bilbo to smile with her. His cousin-in-law wasn’t all bad, Bilbo supposed. She was just far, far too used to getting her own way.
‘Humour us, Master Baggins,’ Balin interjected. ‘As Mistress Took no doubt intended, we will be dying of curiosity all night if we do not find out.’
‘Speak for yourself,’ Dwalin told his brother. Balin rolled his eyes.
‘I know you,’ he told Dwalin, the comment loud enough to be heard by all, but still clearly meant for his brother alone. ‘You were dying with curiosity the moment Mistress Took finished her sentence. Do not try to pretend you’re above the rest of us, young one.’
Dwalin hmphed, but he didn’t seem to have anything further to say on the subject.
Seeing expectant eyes all turned towards him, Bilbo decided to accept defeat gracefully. Sitting back in his seat, he made sure he was comfortable before starting.
‘Many years ago…’ Bilbo began, then paused. ‘Well, many for us anyway. Some people probably think 40 years is merely the blink of an eye, old as they are,’ he grinned at Bofur and saw several pairs of eyes widen, including King Thorin’s. Bilbo wondered if his jest at their expense had caused offence, then decided if it had they were all far too sensitive and moved on.
‘A young faunt – a hobbit child – decided that he had had quite enough of being tied to his mother’s apron strings. He was a sturdy lad now, had turned 7 years old weeks before, and he was ready to go out into the world for an adventure. His mother did not agree, of course, but she was always distracted on washing day and his father could be relied upon to fall asleep for an hour or two after lunch. The chance for escape was easy enough to grasp.’
A few of the dwarves chuckled, perhaps thinking of mischievous children they had known. Lalia and Adalgrim did as well, but then both of them, older than Bilbo by around ten years, remembered this adventurous young hobbit well.
‘He charged out into the world with no real understanding of what he would find. He had only ever been allowed to play in gardens within the sight of someone’s parent, and when he went out with his mother she made sure she had a firm hold on him.’
‘With good reason,’ Lalia pointed out. Bilbo shrugged, conceding the point.
‘With good reason. Regardless, the temptation to slip out of the garden was great. He had some difficulty with the gate, and with avoiding the hobbits out about their business, but with some careful ducking and a little crawling, soon he was further from home than he had ever been alone.
‘Clearly the next step was some decent exploration, and the most likely-looking candidate was a field of long grass. It was being allowed to lie fallow for a few years, though our faunt did not know it, and it had got a little out of hand. He plunged in, certain that all sorts of wonders must await, and indeed they did. A woodlark on her nest, familiar enough with hobbits not to immediately be scared away. A rabbit disappearing back into its warren as it sensed him approaching. A cracked egg shell, which he didn’t understand the significance of at that age… it merely made him realise he was a little peckish.’
Fortinbras snorted, and Bilbo gave him a stern look. They had wanted him to tell this story, he would tell it however he chose.
‘Unfortunately for our adventurer, any field of this type has its dangers. As he ventured further in, he was startled by a squirrel which wasn’t at all happy to see him. He shrieked, the squirrel did a very good impression of a shriek in return, and our faunt bravely turned to run away. Alas, he had no idea which way ‘away’ - or rather ‘home’ - actually was. He had become completely turned around, and he could not see above the grass to find his way. He ran on rather blindly, somewhat in a panic from his unexpected encounter, stumbled, tripped, and promptly fell into a rut full of water from the rain two days before.
‘Completely overcome by these trials; scared, disappointed and, worse, wet through; our brave adventurer promptly curled up in a ball and began to scream at the top of his voice for his mother. He was found some minutes later by a hobbit who happened to be walking down the lane about fifteen feet from where he sat, still sobbing his little heart out. His hobbit rescuer soon called for our faunt’s mother, and she arrived shortly after to find her son still sobbing and insisting that both the animals and the field itself were trying to eat him, much to the later amusement of all who knew him. And never has he been allowed to forget it since!’
Bilbo finished with a flourish, and a small round of applause ensued. It was hardly the most exciting of stories, though it was embarrassing enough in front of these well-travelled dwarves, but Bilbo had tried to make it entertaining at least.
‘Oh, we all have those tales in our families, Master Baggins,’ Dori told him kindly. He looked at his younger brother as he said it, and Ori frowned mightily in his direction. Dori held his hands up to placate Ori.
‘Not that I have any intention of sharing any of them,’ he assured Ori patiently, and the young dwarf’s dander went down quickly.
‘I assume the lesson we are meant to take from that story is that travelling away from what you know is a dangerous business,’ Glóin commented dryly.
‘The lesson,’ Bilbo responded, his tone even drier, ‘is that the young are always certain of themselves, even when they should not be. Alternatively: if you are going beyond what you know, try taking a map!’
King Thorin snorted a laugh, eyeing Glóin with amusement.
‘You walked into that head-on,’ he told the red-headed dwarf. Glóin sat stone-faced for a moment, then broke into a grin that made his eyes twinkle.
‘Reminded you of Gimli, didn’t it?’ King Thorin said mysteriously.
‘Mmm,’ Glóin agreed.
Bilbo had no idea what they were talking about, but he didn’t let it concern him. At least two of the grumpiest dwarves had finally thawed a little.
***
Meal finally over, and all of their party enclosed in one of the parlours, the talk turned to business.
That was probably for the best. If Thorin had been put off much longer, he would have had to make a good attempt at strangling someone. The hobbits might not understand how precious time was in this situation, but Thorin knew it only too well.
‘I am afraid Gandalf explained precisely nothing of the reason for your visit, King Thorin, except to inform me that you would wish to discuss food supplies with us,’ Fortinbras opened the discussion. ‘Perhaps we had best start there.’
Oh, for… the sake of Mahal. No wonder they did not comprehend Thorin’s urgency. Gandalf might have at least mentioned the imminent starvation.
Though not in those words, obviously. There was such a thing as being too honest about one’s problems.
‘We come in the hope of arranging a deal which would see my people through the winter, Master Thain,’ Thorin informed him. ‘We have had ill luck in recent months and cannot afford the prices that the Men near to us would charge for food. Ered Luin is a mining colony, we have no good land for farming, so we cannot produce our own food. My steward, Balin, suggested – and Gandalf agreed wholeheartedly – that your people might be willing to help us at more reasonable prices.’
‘Could you not have come to a compromise with your neighbours?’ Fortinbras asked. Thorin felt himself bristle. ‘Surely there must have been something you could have traded them instead of the coin.’
‘The offer was made, and rejected,’ Thorin answered abruptly. He could not entirely hide how badly that had stung. The Men could forge nothing of the quality that Thorin and his people could provide, even years after they had lost their home, much of their equipment and some of their best people. The rejection had been a clear message to Thorin of how little the Men thought of the dwarves’ friendship. He would not forget it in better times.
There would be better times. Thorin would make sure of it.
Starting now.
‘Our relationship with the Men around Ered Luin has always been… difficult to balance,’ Balin added, putting as diplomatic a slant on it as possible. ‘They had their eyes on Ered Luin around the time that Thorin’s grandfather arrived, with most of Erebor’s exiles, to take up residence. With us in place, Ered Luin was a far more formidable target and the Men’s plans came to nothing. Though a number of lifetimes of Men have passed since that day, the resentment remains. Perhaps they do not even remember where it came from.’
Thorin had been watching his hosts keenly during this speech, using the time Balin had given him. Fortinbras was clearly not a hobbit comfortable with conflict. He had sunk back into his seat and a frown creased the skin behind his eyes, though he might not even have noticed himself.
Was he assuming that, despite their story, the dwarves must be at fault for the dispute? Would this make him reluctant to support their cause?
‘Like the Bolgers and the Bracegirdles,’ Master Baggins suddenly interjected, though his voice was quiet. ‘They will never forgive each other for the insults that were given. But have you ever found a single Bracegirdle or Bolger who can tell you what those insults were? Of course you cannot. The enmity is far more important than the cause.’
Fortinbras looked over at his cousin and rolled his eyes, though it appeared to be more in agreement than derision. Maybe the Thain had suffered the consequences of that rivalry the way Thorin had the disputes amongst his people. A King’s subjects did like to know that he shared in their problems.
Either way, the Thain’s frown lines had disappeared for the moment.
‘In the long-term,’ Thorin now chose to reassure the hobbits, ‘we will seek help from our own people. My cousin, Dàin, rules in the Iron Hills and he has long been a good friend to us. However, the Iron Hills are many months’ travel from here. I need to be sure my people are taken care of before I leave.’
‘You have an idea of what you would need?’ Fortinbras queried, expression now thoughtful.
Thorin turned immediately to Balin, who produced a long screed of parchment from somewhere upon his person. Thorin was half-convinced that there were magic pockets sewn into that coat of his.
On occasion, when Balin had fooled him into “just dealing with this small pile” and had then produced another stack from somewhere within the coat, Thorin had considered burning the thing.
‘I have an account of what we would usually use in a month here. Further details of how many months we would need and how payment would be organised we can, of course, discuss later.’
‘Of course,’ Fortinbras murmured. He scanned the parchment, then returned his gaze to Thorin.
‘It will take me time to speak to all of those I need to,’ he clarified. ‘As Gandalf likely explained, I merely represent the Shire when needed. I will have to make your case to those who could provide what you require and see what arrangement they are willing to come to. Not all of them will see the need to supply those outside our lands when they are already making a living as they are.’
That, Thorin thought, was a pretty way of saying that they might not wish to enter into a bargain with dwarves. Valar, was this place truly so small-minded? The Men had turned their gold down from malice, or perhaps excessive greed.
Did people truly deny themselves a further source of income through fear?
Thorin looked up and caught Mistress Took’s eyes upon him. She must have seen something of his thoughts, for her face hardened.
‘You said yourself that you prefer to ask help from your own, King Thorin,’ she pointed out. ‘Is it so strange that some amongst our folk might prefer to sell solely to their own? At least then they know who they are dealing with.’
That was not actually what Thorin had said, but it was a fair representation of his reasoning, so he did not object. The Thain’s wife was a shrewd woman.
‘I would have you be honest with me,’ he stated instead of arguing, focusing on Mistress Took. ‘Will your people work with us, Mistress Took?’
‘Yes,’ she answered plainly. ‘Some. We just need to tip the balance in your favour, particularly with those who are reluctant.’
Before Thorin could respond, Master Baggins interjected once again.
‘There, I had an idea,’ he informed them all.
***
Bilbo had been thinking hard during dinner, and since they had finished. He still did not like the King of the Dwarves. He found Thorin rude, abrasive and overly suspicious, at the least. However, he could admit that the dwarf had brief moments where he was… easier to deal with. Not amiable, exactly – Yavanna forbid the King should bend that much – but bearable.
More to the point, Bilbo did feel sorry for his Company and his people. Remembering his own pangs of hunger when he had returned from his travels, and then imagining truly going hungry, with no food in sight, distressed him greatly.
Imagining some of these dwarves - Balin, Kíli, Ori, Bofur, Bombur - starving in such a way made him deeply sad.
It was not right that good people should suffer just because those nearby would do nothing to help.
Bilbo had received help once, from those who could easily have denied his pleas and returned to their lives with little concern for his wellbeing. He had tried, in the years that followed, to help others in turn to balance out the debt.
They had not seemed to want his help, but he had tried.
Maybe now he could kill two birds with one stone. Help his own and get these dwarves what they needed at the same time.
If it finally got Fortinbras’ attention and knocked him out of his complacency, then Bilbo might actually consider himself blessed for once.
So, when the right moment came, he interrupted Lalia’s conversation with King Thorin.
‘There, I had an idea,’ he told those collected in the parlour.
‘You did?’ Adalgrim asked in surprise. He looked a bit embarrassed afterwards, and Bilbo was almost certain what he’d been thinking. How could Bilbo Baggins, pariah of the Shire, know how to persuade his fellows to abandon their prejudices?
Bilbo did not reply to the comment. It was not meant to hurt, he knew. Most of what his closest remaining family said to him was not meant to hurt. Bilbo had learned not to respond to the unintended slights. Such constant arguments only upset everyone and exhausted him.
He and Bungo had argued so often in those last years that he had been almost permanently exhausted. What was the point of doing that again if he did not have to?
‘The farms of Stock are some of the most fruitful, are they not?’ Bilbo asked Fortinbras instead. When his cousin nodded, Bilbo allowed himself a small smile.
‘Then you need to get them, particularly Farmer Maggot, on your side,’ he told King Thorin. Thorin raised an eyebrow, as an invitation to continue.
‘Tell me, King Thorin,’ Bilbo said easily, ‘can your Company fight?’
‘Almost all dwarves have some skill at fighting,’ King Thorin responded. ‘It is how our people keep ourselves safe. How would that help us here? You do not seem to have much cause for fighting in your land, Master Baggins.’
‘No, Bilbo,’ Fortinbras said pointedly. ‘We do not!’
‘Fortinbras, for goodness’ sake, just hear him out,’ Adalgrim insisted. When Bilbo looked at him in surprise, Adalgrim shrugged. ‘If anyone knows about fighting around here, it’s you,’ Adalgrim told Bilbo. ‘Yavanna knows the rest of us don’t have a clue.’
That, Bilbo was happy to agree, was more than true. At least someone had the sense to see it, and to listen.
‘I went out three weeks ago for a reason,’ Bilbo told the dwarves. ‘On my travels I had seen signs of evil where no evil should be. Nothing obvious, nothing that anyone else believed, but enough to make me uneasy. I know the Shire well, Master Dwarves, and the creatures that inhabit it just as well. Wolf-prints are not unheard of, unfortunately. Prints three times the size of a normal wolf paw are not normal. Not at all.’
‘You have found these prints?’ Master Dwalin asked him sharply. His face was already drawn with concern.
This was what Bilbo had expected when he had brought these concerns to his own people. This was the sense of danger they seemed to lack so completely.
It was refreshing to see it at last.
‘I found more than that,’ Bilbo replied harshly, anger rising at the thought of what he had seen. ‘I found the wargs, and the orcs they serve too. Thirty or so of them.’
Lalia shrieked and clutched at her chest.
Fortinbras paled and sank back in his chair.
Adalgrim continued to pleasantly surprise Bilbo. He sat forward and, without questioning the veracity of Bilbo’s statements once, asked, ‘Where?’
‘They are camped on the other side of the Brandywine, at the edge of the Old Forest by the Barrow Downs. Still close enough to do plenty of damage should they choose. So far the only thing that has saved us is their decision to ignore us.’
‘And you think that if my Company helps to rid you of these creatures, it will earn us goodwill with the farmers who live in the area?’ King Thorin clarified.
‘I cannot see how it would do anything else,’ Bilbo told him with a grim smile. ‘We may be an insular people, King Thorin, but most of us are not stupid. They will not want to die.’
******
