Chapter Text
‘You have everything prepared?’ Thorin asked Glóin as his cousin entered Bilbo’s dining room and sank into a seat. Most of the Company were sitting around the table, entertaining themselves in some form or another. The Thain had held a special celebratory dinner last night to mark the successful conclusion of the negotiations, with plenty of ale, and there were more than a few sore heads being nursed this morning.
Thorin’s was not one of them, of course. He didn’t get drunk in public for a number of reasons.
Most of which involved preserving his dignity, but at least one of which was Dwalin’s strict rule about ‘Not making my job any harder than it needs to be, damnit, Thorin!’
Thorin humoured him, because they had always known he had a number of enemies in Ered Luin who would like to stab him in the back. There was no need to present it to them and hand them the dagger.
‘Of course,’ Glóin responded to his query. ‘Don’t I always? We can leave in the morning. We’ve even got ponies to go as far as Bree, though we’ll have to leave them there. If they go any farther, then the stable-master can’t retrieve them.’
Any further conversation was interrupted by the arrival of Bilbo, with Fíli and Kíli as his ever-present shadows. Thorin was more than slightly curious about why the boys were so firmly glued to their hobbit friend. He knew that Balin had asked the hobbit to take them under his wing while they were in the Shire, but the boys seemed to have taken it even farther than that. Bilbo was rarely without them at his side.
‘Serious discussions?’ Fíli asked Thorin carefully, as the three took seats around the table. Thorin had been relieved to see the lad lose a little of his sadness and gravity in the last week or so, but Fíli still checked with him instinctively every time he entered a room and kept tabs on Thorin wherever he went.
Thorin knew a lot of people assumed he had no idea how devoted Fíli and Kíli were to him, and how seriously Fíli took his position as heir, but that was not the case. Thorin knew, and did his best to reassure, but he could only do so much to ease their concerns about Ered Luin’s future.
You could not force the sun to shine when the clouds were pouring rain upon you.
‘Only making sure all is ready,’ Thorin said now, letting the calm in his eyes ease Fíli’s tension. ‘Glóin has done well. We are prepared to leave for the Iron Hills come morning.’
‘Time to visit Cousin Dain,’ Kíli commented wryly, and a few of the dwarves chuckled. This was far from a typical family visit.
‘I wish I had known you were planning to leave tomorrow,’ Bilbo interjected, with a slight irritation which surprised Thorin. Was the hobbit not looking forward to being free of his unwanted guests? Thorin had thought this was a good way of thanking him for the mysterious help he had clearly given them; getting out of his hair as soon as possible.
Even more puzzling, Thorin saw Kíli perk up suddenly, while Fíli’s eyes locked onto Thorin’s face as if he was expecting Mahal’s own wisdom to spill from Thorin’s lips.
Chance would be a fine thing.
Wary, because such excitement in his nephews was out of character at the moment, Thorin asked, ‘Is there a problem, Bilbo?’
‘Not as such,’ Bilbo replied, waving his hand dismissively, ‘but I’m going to have to move very quickly to be ready to go by tomorrow, and Fortinbras will not be amused when I disappear yet again without much warning. I had meant to actually tell him I was going this time. In person. Goodness knows letters are a sore subject between us at the moment.’
A worrying suspicion was dawning in Thorin’s mind but, determined to be fair, he settled on asking another question first.
‘Were you planning to go somewhere?’
‘Of course,’ Bilbo responded, as if that should be blatantly obvious. ‘I need to travel to Rivendell, to speak with Lord Elrond. Your Company are going in that general direction, I might as well travel part of the way with you.’
There was a long moment of quiet in the room, and Thorin took a deep breath before asking Bilbo tightly, ‘Did you not think it might be helpful to ask me about these plans before you settled on them, Master Baggins?’
***
Bilbo had no intention of letting the dwarves see how close he was to quaking in his boots.
What he was doing went beyond rude. It was probably approaching the edges of unwise. He ought to have spoken to Thorin about his plans days ago. He could have explained his intention to go to Rivendell, asked to join the Company on the journey.
Answered the questions Thorin would undoubtedly have about his fitness to fight if the need arose, based on what had happened with the orcs. Thorin had let it go then, but this was different. This was a journey that would last hundreds of miles, through some dangerous lands.
He could have done all of this in private, where the dwarves’ leader could make his own mind up about the risks without needing to consider anyone else’s opinion.
Instead, Bilbo was trying to force Thorin’s hand in front of his Company, to escape the need to answer those questions at all.
It could so easily explode in his face, the tentative truce he had with Thorin failing to withstand the weight.
Because the King of the Dwarves knew what he was doing, Bilbo was sure.
He had not bought Bilbo’s irritation about leaving without speaking to Fortinbras for a second, even though it had a shred of truth in it. Bilbo was regretful that he was about to disappear on the Thain for the third time in a two months, but it could not be helped.
He had to go to Rivendell and speak to Elrond and the twins.
The Bounders had found and spoken to a Ranger on the borders of the Shire a few days ago, and he had sent a message to Bilbo. There were only a few Rangers assigned to guard the Shire. The majority had other tasks, and lately those tasks required help from the Shire’s guardians more often than not.
If they were to protect the Shire fully from the orcish threat, then they would need help. More help than one armed hobbit could provide.
Bilbo could think of only one place that help might come from.
The elves had ridden to their rescue before. Perhaps, if asked, they would do so again.
Bilbo did not trust that the orcs would leave the Shire alone when the dwarves left.
For a start, how would they know the dwarves had left? It was not as if any of the orcs were left to report the Company’s movements and Bilbo had little faith in the orcs’ desire to check their facts before attacking.
Killing a few dozen hobbits before finding that their quarry had already departed would hardly present a major moral dilemma to orcs.
Bilbo wanted to make sure his fellow hobbits were protected, and that meant getting to Rivendell to persuade the elves in person.
A task that would likely be quicker and easier if he was travelling with Thorin’s Company than if he was on his own. Alone, no matter how much faith he had in his own skills, he could not even be sure of making it to Rivendell alive.
The things a person would do for pride. He should have just had the conversation with Thorin.
He should have just admitted why he found orcs the most difficult of enemies.
But he had not. Could not. The waking dreams made him feel weak, and he hated to admit to weakness.
Of course, all of this could completely backfire, particularly if he did not stop wool-gathering and actually answer Thorin’s question.
‘I did not think it would be a problem,’ Bilbo replied, which was probably the most dishonest answer he had ever given to a question. ‘I will provide my own supplies and be sure to pull my weight, and it is not as if I will be going with you all of the way. Once we near Rivendell I will strike off on my own. I am only one more person.’
Bilbo met Thorin’s eyes reluctantly, and shivered at the suspicion which filled them once more.
It should not matter what the dwarf thought. If he refused to allow Bilbo to accompany them, as Bilbo was sure he was about to, then they would never see one another again.
If Bilbo lost his good opinion, what of it?
Yet, somehow, the thought still made his heart ache.
***
What Thorin simply could not understand was why Bilbo… Master Baggins… had not simply asked if he could accompany them.
It would have been simple enough. It would have been polite.
It would have given Thorin a chance to think about whether he wished to take the hobbit along on this journey or not.
Why the subterfuge? What was the hobbit hiding? What did he hope to gain?
‘It can’t hurt, can it, Uncle?’ Kíli asked innocently, when Thorin did not immediately respond to Master Baggins’ words. ‘Bilbo’s right, he’s only one more person.’
And that, Thorin suspected, was exactly what Master Baggins had been hoping for, and was the one thing Thorin would have wanted to avoid.
For, now, he could not refuse without upsetting his nephews. They had become fond of their hobbit friend and obviously wanted him to join them. They were also not alone. A number of the Company were now friendly with the hobbit, and would be annoyed if Thorin refused his request.
All of this would cause disharmony, just as they were about to embark upon a months-long journey.
The temptation to refuse anyway, to make the point that he would not be pushed into doing something by anyone, was very strong. Thorin did not have to be liked, he only needed to be obeyed. It did not truly matter what his Company thought.
Except that he did not enjoy being at odds with those he travelled with, and conflict within his own group could be dangerous if things did go amiss.
Then Thorin remembered his certainty that he owed Master Baggins for the coin they had saved. If this was the repayment that the hobbit wished to insist upon then, as a matter of honour, Thorin had little choice but to accept.
‘Master Baggins is, of course, free to join us,’ Thorin said, deliberately hiding his irritation. ‘In fact, we will accompany him all the way to Rivendell. It is on our way,’ he continued, speaking to Bilbo now, ‘and I would hate for you to come to harm we might have prevented. We could hardly allow you to travel alone when the danger would be so great.’
‘Thank you,’ Master Baggins replied, and Thorin was sure there was regret in the tone. ‘I will make my preparations today, and be ready for the morning.’
‘Nori, take a message to the Thain informing him that Bilbo will leave with us tomorrow,’ Thorin commanded. Nori rose, looking somewhat confused at Thorin’s choice of messenger, and Thorin realised what he had done.
‘No, not you,’ he corrected, with a wave of his hand. ‘Apologies, Ori, I meant you.’
‘Of course,’ Ori agreed, looking pleased to have been given a job to do. The group began to scatter as Ori and Bilbo both moved away, and others of the Company joined them. Thorin heard Bofur exclaim happily about Bilbo joining them, and Dori check that his brother was sure of the way to the Great Smials.
Amongst all the movement, he signalled to Balin and Dwalin, and the three of them slipped out of the room to find somewhere to talk.
***
That was it, then.
Bilbo had his answer, and it was the answer he had wanted.
So why did he feel so let down?
Bilbo laughed to himself, chuckling over his own foolishness. He knew exactly why he felt let down.
First, because King Thorin had made it quite clear that he was allowing Bilbo along because he did not trust Bilbo’s skills to see him safely to Rivendell.
And second…
Because he was, once again, only Master Baggins.
He had preferred being Bilbo.
***
‘What in the blazes was that all about?’ Dwalin asked as soon as the three of them were alone.
‘I wish I knew,’ Thorin responded bluntly.
‘He may truly have thought it would not be a problem,’ Balin pointed out fairly. ‘The protocol is different here, we have seen it time and again.’
‘I’m pretty sure that inviting yourself along on someone else’s trip is rude wherever you are,’ Dwalin objected. ‘Mahal knows it’s not as if I object to the lad coming, Balin. I just don’t understand why he felt the need to do it like that! None of his arguments were anything but rubbish, even I could see that. He didn’t believe them any more than we did.’
‘No,’ Thorin said, and Dwalin could hear his own confusion reflected in Thorin’s voice, ‘he did not. Either way, it does not truly matter. We owe him a debt, I am sure of it, and it is a debt we will pay. My only concern is to be sure he is safe in battle. I will not endanger the Company or our aim because Master Baggins… loses his focus. The incident when we fought the orcs worried us all.’
‘Yes,’ Balin said slowly. ‘It did.’ Dwalin watched his brother carefully, curious about what had caught his imagination. Usually when Balin’s mouth slowed it was to compensate for his brain working at ten times its normal speed. After a second, Balin’s eyes cleared and he focused on the two of them once more.
‘Why not let me speak to Bilbo about that?’ he suggested to Thorin. ‘I am not the warrior the two of you are…’
‘Bollocks!’ Dwalin announced, not willing to let that stand, and Balin gave him a pleased smile.
‘The blade is clearly my second choice,’ he amended, ‘whereas it is your first. It makes me less intimidating. Also, I am old…’
This time it was Thorin who interrupted, his eyes twinkling as he also exclaimed, ‘Bollocks!’
Balin began to laugh.
‘Very well, very well,’ he conceded. ‘I am slightly older than Thorin, which makes me little more than a spring chicken, but for some reason encourages people to confide in me. Perhaps I can convince Bilbo to tell me about whatever affected him that day. I presume you will trust my judgement about whether we need to worry?’
‘Of course,’ Dwalin answered, at the same time that Thorin said, ‘Completely.’
‘Good,’ Balin concluded. ‘I will speak to him tonight.’
***
‘Master Baggins, might I come in?’
Bilbo’s head jerked up, startled by the voice coming from the slightly open door. He had not pulled it all the way shut; enjoying, for one more night, the sound of cheerful voices echoing around Bag End.
None of the dwarves had ever come to Bilbo’s rooms to find him. If they had, Bilbo would have expected it to be one of the young ones rather than Balin.
‘Of course,’ Bilbo replied after a moment. ‘Please, have a seat,’ he directed as Balin entered, gesturing at the armchair he kept near the fireplace. Bilbo himself knelt by the bed, checking that he had everything he would need. Now, he rose and sat on the foot of the bed instead.
‘I think I am almost ready,’ he told Balin, assuming that the dwarf had come to check on him. ‘I have travelling gear, of course, and I managed to purchase enough food for myself in Hobbiton earlier.’
‘You need not worry about that too much,’ Balin assured him. His demeanour was as friendly as always, but something about the way he was studying Bilbo closely made Bilbo feel oddly nervous. ‘We will hunt as we go, and Glóin will have fought for the best possible deal, so we should have plenty. I would be more worried about tonight’s food, actually. Bombur is determined to waste none of what we cannot take with us. I have a feeling it is going to be a very eclectic meal.’
Bilbo chuckled, though it was less enthusiastic than it might otherwise have been.
‘We are all set, then,’ he said with forced cheerfulness.
‘We are,’ Balin confirmed. ‘Bilbo, there is something I need to ask you.’
‘Yes?’ Bilbo replied, and he knew he sounded wary even though he told himself to relax. The question could be about anything.
‘What is it about orcs that causes you such trouble?’ Balin continued, obviously choosing his words with care.
Bilbo sighed, and tried desperately to think of what he could say that would be truthful and still give little away. He could understand why Balin felt he had to ask – wasn’t this exactly what he had feared would happen if he told the dwarves he would join them? - but this was such a personal thing.
‘If you ask anyone in the Shire,’ Bilbo said, at length, ‘they can tell you about the Fell Winter. Even those too young to remember it. It was the coldest winter we had ever had. The Brandywine River froze, and it left us vulnerable. Very vulnerable. The wolves came first, but the orcs followed. Not many – Gandalf tells me few had made it this far from their usual haunts – but any is too many in the Shire. It… did not end well for us.’
‘I am sorry,’ Balin said quietly, and Bilbo could hear his sincerity. He forced a small smile.
‘Thank you.’
‘How old were you?’ Balin asked.
‘Too young to do anything about it,’ Bilbo replied. ‘Old enough to understand how bad things were. We began to starve, and we could not stop the wolves when they attacked. The Rangers and the elves saved us in the end, but it was already too late for some.’
He paused a moment, trying to think of some way to bring the conversation to an end without revealing any more.
‘I do not care for orcs, Balin,’ he finally stated. ‘That sounds obvious, I know. Who does?’ He sighed. ‘I have only faced them once or twice since the Fell Winter. What you saw is memory taking over, but not dangerously so. I have never hurt anyone but an orc. I did not hear Thorin’s command, true, but I did what I thought we were there to do. I killed our enemies. It is not ideal, but none of those I have fought with considered me a risk. I am told I am simply – overenthusiastic, when it comes to orcs.’
‘In that, lad, you are in good company,’ Balin informed him, trying to lighten the mood. ‘I’ve never met a soul with as much enthusiasm for killing orcs as my brother, and Thorin is not far behind him. Thorin might actually be worse, he’s just less obvious about it.’
Bilbo allowed his lips to twist in amusement.
‘If we do find the orcs on our tail,’ Balin continued, ‘Dwalin will stick close to you.’
Bilbo started to protest, but Balin held a hand up to prevent him.
‘I am sorry if that offends you, Bilbo, but it is how it must be. I believe that you are unlikely to be a danger to any of us, and I know that you deal with orcs well enough, but if we do need to stop you – either from hurting an orc or from hurting yourself – Dwalin is best placed to do so. You wish to travel with us. That is our only condition.’
Bilbo considered arguing further, hurt and annoyed at this show that he was not trusted completely, especially after the sting of Thorin’s words earlier, but he knew what Balin was saying. Accept this, or make your own way to Rivendell.
And truly, was it so harsh a condition? Did it really matter if it was Dwalin next to him, or someone else? He could fight either way.
‘Agreed,’ Bilbo replied, and Balin stood and bowed.
‘In that case, I will leave you to finish,’ he told Bilbo courteously. ‘I know I check everything at least three times before I am sure I have remembered all I need.’
‘Not four?’ Bilbo asked, hoping that a joke would restore their usual friendliness.
‘Ah, it probably would be,’ Balin smiled, ‘but at three my brother takes the pack from me and refuses to let me touch it again before we leave. Younger brothers are a great trial, Bilbo!’
With that, he left Bilbo alone. Bilbo sat still for several moments, then turned back to his packing once again.
He felt rather a fool, right now. He had created a mountain out of a mole-hill, enacted a scene that morning all for nothing.
Balin had not pushed at all. Bilbo was still able to travel with them. No one was insisting on every detail of his past.
What an idiot he was sometimes!
Perhaps Fortinbras was right.
Maybe solitude really had destroyed his knack for dealing with other people.
******
