Actions

Work Header

The Time for Home

Chapter 35: Another Hopeless Cause

Summary:

That's the last thing Thorin needs.

Chapter Text

‘Your Majesty,’ a young messenger said humbly, entering only a little way into the room. ‘Lord Dáin requests the honour of your presence when it is convenient.’

It wasn’t at all convenient, of course - Dáin’s timing was abysmal, and always had been – but Thorin had only just been thinking about the responsibilities of kingship and the necessity of serving his people to the best of his ability.

He was hardly going to tell either the messenger or his cousin to sod off now.

‘Of course,’ he said instead, letting the moment of peace with Bilbo fade into a dearly-held memory and pulling a lifetime of royal duty to the fore instead, ‘tell my cousin I will be with him shortly.’

‘Yes, Your Majesty,’ the young lass replied. ‘He’s in his study when you’re ready.’ Her tone was one of great relief, which suggested she had expected a much rougher time of it than this. Clearly rumours were flying about his last encounter with the Lord of the Iron Hills.

Thorin wondered idly if that was why they had sent a female messenger instead of a male one, then decided it didn’t really matter. The lass backed out of the room hastily and shut the door, and Thorin turned again to Bilbo.

Bilbo, whose expression made it quite clear that he was about to pretend nothing out of the ordinary had happened this afternoon at all.

Oh.

Well.

That should make things easier, shouldn’t it?

Thorin had determined that nothing was to happen while the situation with Ered Luin was still up in the air. That would be a great deal easier if they continued to act as friends only and ignored the moments when Thorin lost his grip on his self-control.

Not that there were going to be any more of those.

Truly.

He was going to act like the King he was, not a dwarf scarcely past his majority, and he was not the slightest bit disappointed that Bilbo had the good sense to encourage him to do so even when no one else would.

Truly.

‘We had best make our way to Dáin,’ he managed to say to Bilbo, voice perfectly even. ‘A little delay does no harm, but I did say shortly.’

‘Certainly,’ Bilbo agreed. ‘It wouldn’t do to appear tardy. I’m at your disposal, Thorin.’

Thorin nearly cursed. Perhaps it wouldn’t be so hard to keep control of his wayward tongue and mind after all. If they were going to become this awkwardly formal after every lapse, he’d have an excellent deterrent to bear in mind.

Rather than saying anything further, he turned and made for the door. Bilbo followed him without hesitation, and Thorin forcibly shoved all thoughts of anything except Dáin, Ered Luin and the Iron Hills out of his mind.

There were important problems to resolve, which required his full concentration.

He must remember that.

***

The Dáin who met them in his study was not one Thorin was familiar with. No longer betraying any of the anger that had filled him at Thorin’s insult in the Council Room, he looked tired, slightly haggard, and old.

It was enough to stop Thorin before he’d fully cleared the threshold, and have Bilbo colliding with his back. Only a firm shove in the small of said back got Thorin moving again and allowed Bilbo to shut the door.

Dáin, apparently aware of the reason for Thorin’s abrupt halt, gave a wry laugh that was equally dissimilar from his usual booming tones.

‘No Balin, Thorin?’ he queried, just the slightest hint of bite to his voice. ‘It’s not like him to leave you unattended when things are at such a critical stage.’

‘I thought perhaps we would do better to put the diplomacy to one side for a moment,’ Thorin countered evenly, trying not to be goaded at such an early stage. ‘Balin didn’t think himself necessary for a talk between cousins.’

‘And yet you’ve brought your hobbit companion with you,’ Dáin pointed out, surveying Bilbo in the manner of someone drawing attention to an obvious flaw in argument.

‘Bilbo has proved to be good at… providing me with an outside perspective,’ Thorin answered, perhaps a bit more cautiously than he should have done. He’d been trying to avoid blurting out, ‘Bilbo might as well be family so there’s no reason why he shouldn’t be here,’ but Dáin’s raised hackles proved he’d managed to put his foot in it another way instead.

‘I thought we were putting the diplomatic bullshit to one side, Thorin,’ he rapped out, half-rising in his chair, though to what end Thorin had no idea.

Slightly exasperated with both of them, Thorin shot back with the first thing that came to mind.

‘Oh, fine; I thought he might be able to stop me punching you if you pissed me off, you over-sensitive arse! Is that better?’

Dáin was silent for a brief second, then he snorted unattractively before beginning to laugh genuinely.

‘It’s more sincere, at least,’ he responded. ‘Though what a little scrap like that is going to do against you…’

‘He disarmed Dwalin the first time they met, and he’s the one who started Azog’s deathblow, even if he was kind enough to let me finish it,’ Thorin shot back. ‘Underestimate hobbits at your peril, Dáin. Cousinly advice for you.’

‘Indeed,’ Dáin replied, eyeing Bilbo with dawning respect. Bilbo was looking a little irritated by the whole exchange, which made Thorin rather nervous, but then he just shook his head in exasperation.

‘Dwalin would do well to remember more of the lessons in manners that Balin tells me Lord Fundin tried to drill into him,’ he said briefly. ‘As for Azog, that was a joint effort. I told you, Thorin, it was a very dense chest and I needed some dwarven muscle behind the blow. Now, are we going to sit down or shall I stand here all evening?’

There was, of course, only one answer Dáin could give to such a question, and soon they were all seated around Dáin’s desk in a semi-comfortable silence.

‘You spoke with your Guildmaster, I assume?’ Thorin asked after a minute or so, to break the silence. Dáin heaved a sigh, and nodded.

‘Aye, I did,’ he agreed. ‘Supercilious bastard. He informed me it never occurred to the Guild that an offer of employment with them could be anything but a great honour, or that I would consider it necessary for the Guild to inform me of such offers before they were made to one of your entourage.’ Dáin paused, twisting the seal around his neck as he had in the Council chamber earlier. ‘Complete bollocks, of course. They knew exactly what they were doing, although I’m half-inclined to believe they’re so up their own arses that they truly believe working for them to be a great honour.’

Thorin absorbed that, entirely able to believe it was the case even from the very little he’d seen of the Dean of the Miners' Guild. Still, there was quite a lot it did not explain.

‘What is going on here, Dáin?’ he asked quietly, meeting Dáin’s gaze head on and refusing to let Dáin avoid his eyes. ‘Everything here has been wrong since almost the moment we arrived. As soon as I told you Ered Luin was in need of help, everything changed. It has been oddity after oddity ever since, but none of it seems to come directly from you. Tell me what it is.’

‘You haven’t figured it out yet?’ Dáin asked bitterly, leaning back in his chair, slamming both booted feet onto his desk and spreading his arms out expansively to encompass not only the office around them but everything that surrounded it. ‘I am powerless here, Thorin. I am little more than a figurehead in my own kingdom, permitted to make decisions only as long as they don’t run counter to the wishes of those with the real power.’

Thorin just stared for a moment.

It was not that he had not suspected something of that nature. It fit all of the facts that Thorin had seen so far.

It was just that it seemed so… unlikely.

How on earth had Dáin allowed things to get into such a state?

Thorin must not have been the only one staring, for suddenly Dáin uttered a gruff, ‘Don’t look at me like that, Hobbit. A dwarf is entitled to act as he likes in his own study.’

‘I do not believe I looked at you in any particular way, my Lord,’ Bilbo said blandly, ‘except perhaps surprised. I would not have guessed the situation was so bad as that.’

‘Nor I,’ Thorin interjected, not wanting Bilbo to be caught in the crossfire of Dáin’s temper. Apparently it worked, for Dáin deflated. After a moment, he sat up, took his feet off the table and looked at them sombrely once more.

‘It’s a bloody mess, Thorin,’ he said softly, quieter than Thorin had ever heard him. Though his words were addressed to his cousin, they encompassed Bilbo as well. ‘I’ve never had to explain it all before, so you’ll forgive me if I’m a little reluctant.’

Thorin nodded, fully able to understand the feeling. How much had he hated the knowledge that everyone in Ered Luin, and shortly afterward some of those without, had known of Wikan’s treachery and what it had cost his people?

Of what Thorin had allowed to happen right under his nose.

He hummed a little under his breath, not entirely realising he was doing so. Perhaps that was the answer; a fair exchange of information, a salve to Dáin’s pride.

It would hurt like bedamned to give it, but if they were to get the help they needed, sacrifices would have to be made.

‘You remember Wikan?’ Thorin asked, receiving a raised eyebrow from Dáin at the sudden change of topic. Bilbo showed no surprise at all, but then Thorin had not expected him to. Thorin was not a fool. He was well aware that someone had spilled the beans about the cause of the mine collapse to Bilbo during their journey, and likely earlier than Thorin would have preferred.

It mattered little now.

‘Aye, I remember,’ Dáin confirmed, tone questioning. ‘Pompous windbag, arrogant too, thick as thieves with Thrór.’

‘He collapsed the mine,’ Thorin said bluntly, and watched Dáin’s eyes widen. Just saying it made Thorin feel as if someone was dragging sandpaper up the inside of his windpipe and over his tongue, as if the words themselves were sharp and bitter, but he forged on. ‘Night-mining. He insisted I was wrong to heed Bofur and Bifur’s warnings about the stability of the richest tunnels. Insisted they were perfectly fine and should continue to be mined. I denied his arguments and continued the ban. So he went in with night crews, dwarves desperate enough to take his money and ignore the law. They brought the whole lot down.’

‘Mahal’s sweet mercy,’ Dáin breathed, a look of pure horror on his face.

‘Thirty miners killed,’ Thorin continued, not quite able to stop. ‘Our entire livelihood gone. I had him put to death for treason, of course, but what did that avail us really? The damage was long since done.’

‘Thorin,’ Dáin began, then stopped as if he had no idea how to continue.

‘We all have our shame, Cousin,’ Thorin told him solemnly. ‘I would happily have let Azog kick my arse to Moria and back before uttering those words again, but it has not killed me. Come, say it and have done.’

Dáin met his eyes, and whatever was in Thorin’s in that moment must have decided him. He nodded sharply, and sat up straight, clutching his seal in his hand.

‘It doesn’t all start with me,’ he informed them, ‘though that’s no great comfort to me. Years ago, Grandfather needed money for the War with the Orcs, just as Thrór did, and the Guilds were only too happy to provide it… for a price. They wanted seats on the Council, and at the time it seemed like a perfectly fair request. It hadn’t been done before in the Iron Hills, we’d been too traditional for that, but for Mahal’s sake we were a kingdom founded on mining and smithing. Why shouldn’t they have their say? So the deal was done, and no one thought much of it.

‘Only it wasn’t the only deal that was needed. That war drained us dry, Thorin. Thrór drained us dry. Nothing was enough for him, it was always more warriors, more arms, more money, and Grandfather saw a brother who had lost his kingdom – a brother whose kingdom he had refused to help reclaim – and would deny him almost nothing. So there were more deals, more seats, and soon the Council was growing and growing, and the Guilds were reminding Grandfather and Father more and more often that it was their money keeping the Iron Hills afloat. The taxes had been raised as high as they could possibly go and they weren’t even touching the sides. So on top of the taxes there were ‘gifts’ from the Guilds being given; but we all knew damn well those gifts would have become loans quick enough if they hadn’t got their way… and what were we going to repay a loan with? All the money was going to Thrór.’

‘You never said a word,’ Thorin murmured, mind desperately trying to take it in. He hadn’t guessed a thing. None of them had guessed a thing, unless Fundin and Thráin had known and never told him. Mother had been close to Dala, Náin’s wife, once upon a time. Had she known?

‘Grandfather swore us to secrecy,’ Dáin told him, answering that question at least. ‘The whole family. Not a word to anyone. By the time he realised how it was going, the shame was almost killing him. Our kingdom was no longer our own and he would not have Thrór know that. We were to say nothing.’

‘But surely your nobles would have...,’ Thorin began, only to be cut off by Dáin’s bark of humourless laughter.

‘Oh Valar, Thorin, we do not all have a Fundin or a Balin, but we are not stupid either. Grandfather’s Steward might have let us get into this mess but he thought of that!’

‘Then what happened?’ Thorin demanded, thumping his hand on the arm of his chair, past caring if he was being rude or not. This made some sense, yes, but still… not enough.

‘Grandfather gathered the nobles together,’ Dáin said shortly, ‘all those who had not died in the fighting. He told them their support was needed for a push against the Guilds, a reminder of who truly ruled in the Iron Hills. We learned two things that day.

‘First, that half the noble families were in debt to one or other of the Guilds as well. Second, that they could see their power waning, and they blamed us for the loss. They considered it our responsibility to solve the problem. They had fought, they told us, quite hard enough for the Iron Hills. They had sacrificed and lost enough in our name. I could hardly blame them for that assertion, not after the carnage at Azanulbizar. If they still had their original head of the family, chances were his heir was dead in his place. It was a bloody nightmare. Either way, when Grandfather tried to force the issue, they tried to force his hand in turn.’

‘How?’ Thorin asked, almost reluctantly. Dáin’s expression was as bleak as he’d ever seen it. As bleak as the desolation Smaug had left behind, and Thorin had a sudden premonition that he did not want to know.

‘They told us that if we could not control the Guilds ourselves, perhaps Thorin Oakenshield would have more luck. He was without a true kingdom to rule now, and they would be perfectly willing to ask him. To have the chief descendants of Durin’s line on the throne of the Iron Hills instead.’

Bilbo let out the gasp that got stuck in Thorin’s throat. Thorin’s mouth opened and closed but no sound came out. Not for long minutes, until finally he felt Bilbo’s hand on his back and his muscles seemed to unlock and air circulated properly once more.

‘I would not,’ Thorin told Dáin in shock. ‘Surely you knew I would not?’

‘Wouldn’t you?’ Dáin asked, haunted again for a moment. ‘Even with your people starving, Thorin? Even with nowhere else to go?’

‘That’s why,’ Thorin murmured to himself, the final piece of the puzzle clicking into place. ‘As soon as I told you why we had come, everything changed.’

‘Aye,’ Dáin agreed, ‘because I knew damn well what every nobleman in that room was thinking, just as I know what they’d think if they heard the story of Azog’s final demise. Here’s one who could rule us. Here’s one who could put the Guilds in their place. You’re the biggest threat my rule has faced in a hundred years, Thorin. And you’re my own cousin. What do I do with that?’

‘Get rid of him,’ Bilbo interjected. Thorin thought they had both almost forgotten he was there, despite his hand on Thorin’s back keeping Thorin steady, and they each turned abruptly to face him. ‘Not like that,’ Bilbo objected, seeing the shocked looks. ‘Honestly, Thorin, anyone would think I hadn’t spent the last several months trying to keep you and yours alive!’

‘Well, you did threaten to abandon us if he turned out to be a bloodthirsty tyrant,’ Thorin said, so quietly Dáin would not hear, letting Bilbo’s familiar grumpy teasing ease him out of his appalled shock. Bilbo pinched him in revenge, and Thorin pretended it hurt to keep up appearances.

‘Can someone please explain in what way I am meant to be rid of him, then?’ Dáin queried, then saw the look of wry amusement on Thorin’s face. ‘Oh, you know what I mean,’ he groaned.

‘If you give the help that Ered Luin needs,’ Bilbo pointed out, ‘then Thorin will have no reason to stay and your nobles will have to quiet down again.’

Dáin’s momentary optimism disappeared immediately.

‘The money is out of my control,’ he reminded them, and it might as well have been a death knell for the way it dropped into the room, ‘and the Guilds will never let a penny of it go to anything but the Iron Hills’ gain. Their money for their kingdom. I have heard it often enough. It would almost be admirable, if it weren’t so clear that they consider it their kingdom rather than mine.’

Thorin could only suspect that the look on his own face must mirror Dáin’s, except that his own hopelessness must be twice as clear to see.

It was done.

There was no way to get what they had come for.

The sons of Dáin I had been cursed indeed; doomed themselves and dooming their descendants just as completely in their turn.

‘I am sorry, Thorin,’ Dáin said, and it was so sincere that any bitterness Thorin might have felt towards his cousin drained away. ‘Were it mine, you might have had it for the asking. I simply have nothing to give you, until Raig,’ Thorin recognised the name of Dáin’s chief advisor, ‘and I can find a way out of this hole.’

Thorin nodded, unable to think of anything to say that might help the situation, or even that wouldn’t make it worse. Finally, he simply rose to his feet, careful to avoid stepping on Bilbo as he did so. His hobbit had not moved from his place by Thorin’s side for the latter part of the conversation.

Dáin, never comfortable with silence, looked nervous and was twisting his chain again. His distress was apparent enough that Thorin forced himself to speak rather than simply walking out.

Besides, that would only lead Bilbo to accuse him of being melodramatic, and he would come to think it a family trait.

‘I will need to make other plans,’ he informed Dáin, as gently as he could. His voice was probably still harsher than most people would like, but Dáin was of the Line of Durin. He would understand. ‘May we continue to rest here while I do?’

‘Of course,’ Dáin said quickly. ‘You are welcome here, Thorin.’ Thorin nodded, reaching out to clasp forearms with his cousin as a final reassurance. Dáin took it gratefully, and Thorin was glad he had managed to avoid completely burning this bridge. Perhaps Balin was right, and there was much to be said for listening to people after all.

And also for hobbit companions in times of great stress.

Still, as Thorin walked away from Dáin’s study and back to his own rooms, all he could hear in his mind was an echo from several months ago.

Dís’ voice.

What will we do, Thorin?

******