Chapter Text
‘Your grandfather had a real talent for buggering stuff up, didn’t he?’ Bifur said thoughtfully in Khuzdul, once Uncle had finished summarising his conversation with Dáin for them. ‘He didn’t even have to rule a kingdom to ruin it.’
A moment of shocked silence changed to a burst of shocked, nervous laughter as members of the Company took in what Bifur had just said and tried to decide whether they were allowed to be entertained by it or not.
Fíli was fairly sure that they were all amused by it, because Bifur really had hit the nail upon the head there, despite the inappropriateness of his timing.
All but one, of course.
‘Do I want to know what Bifur just said?’ Bilbo asked Bofur quietly, viewing them all with a jaundiced eye. ‘Something about Thorin’s grandfather, that much I did get.’
‘These two,’ Bofur responded, jerking his head in the direction of his brother and cousin, ‘have been telling me for years that there are some things that should remain unsaid, or in this case untranslated. That was probably one of them. What in Mahal’s name did you say it for?’ he muttered lowly to Bifur. Then, when Bifur muttered something in response to the question, he exploded indignantly. ‘What do you mean you were pretending to be me?’
Luckily, Uncle stepped in before a brawl could break out and, rather than appearing ready to explode with anger, he simply seemed mildly entertained. Bifur received a raised eyebrow instead of the tongue-lashing Fíli had been half-expecting him to get.
When the miner winked at Uncle cheekily, Fíli realised he had been testing the waters, checking to see what Uncle’s mood was like.
Making himself the target of any potential temper because Bifur, much like his cousin, was utterly immune to Uncle’s fury and always had been.
It was an unexpected reminder of how often, and how easily, they all managed each other now. How much they knew of each other after all these months together.
It did not shatter the lump of rock which had taken up residence in Fíli’s stomach as he’d heard Uncle describe how completely alone they were in their troubles, but it chipped a few of the nastier sharp edges off.
Fíli would take what he could get.
‘To answer Bifur’s question,’ Uncle said, voice almost as arid as Harad’s deserts, ‘yes, Thrór does appear to have done severe damage to the stability of the Iron Hills, though I do not believe we can entirely acquit Grór of his role, either. Regardless, the result is that Dáin has not the power to help us save Ered Luin. He’s more in need of saving himself.’
‘I’ve a mind to go and give him some advice before we leave,’ Glóin said impatiently. ‘Strikes me he’s making a great deal out of nothing!’
Fíli was fairly sure that he was not the only one practically boggling at his cousin.
‘He owes the guilds more money than he could ever repay,’ he pointed out slowly, trying to work out which part of the whole scenario Glóin was failing to comprehend.
‘They have more seats on his Council than any other group in Ered Luin,’ Kíli added helpfully, also eyeing Glóin with great confusion.
‘And the nobles won’t help him fight them off because they’ve half-decided they’d do better getting Thorin to be Lord of the Hills instead,’ Balin said regretfully, patting Uncle gently on the arm as he did so, as if trying to ease the blow that that discovery must have been.
‘Load of bollocks,’ Glóin dismissed quickly. ‘The important thing is whether the Guilds have any of it down on paper or not, and I’ll bet they don’t. Not from back then. It’ll have been verbal agreements, that’s all Grór would have allowed, a promise to put so many Guild members on to the Council in return for however-much money. If they haven’t got it in writing then Dáin’s got every option in the world open to him. A restructuring of the Council, a re-haul of the treasury system, a review of taxation practices; any or all of the above will let him do exactly what he needs to do. I don’t know what he’s making such a fuss about!’
‘Glóin, those are debts of honour!’ Uncle objected strenuously, appearing entirely stunned at the idea that such things could simply be shrugged aside.
‘And what honour are the Guilds showing when the power-grubbing bastards attempt to steal Dáin’s kingdom out from under him for their own purposes?’ Glóin asked emphatically.
‘Dáin can hardly be expected to sink to their level,’ Uncle spluttered, looking at Glóin as if he had suddenly grown a second head. Fíli was partially in agreement with him. A debt of honour was sacrosanct, after all; one did not simply throw it away when it became inconvenient.
On the other hand, however, there was a certain beautiful justice in Glóin’s manner of dealing with things.
‘Even when the welfare of his kingdom is at stake?’ Glóin challenged Uncle, refusing to back down. ‘Thorin, sometimes a dwarf has to be prepared to get his hands dirty when the other side is determined not to fight fair! How many times did we put that tactic to use in battle?’
‘That was different,’ Uncle argued. ‘Damnit, Glóin, sometimes you’re such a…’
‘Such a what?’ Glóin demanded, when Uncle appeared either unable or unwilling to finish the sentence.
‘Merchant!’ Uncle exploded, throwing his hands in the air, then irritably yanking a piece of hair out of his face when it had the temerity to fall into his eyes at the sudden movement.
Glóin snorted angrily, folding his arms across his broad chest and glaring at Uncle in a manner which never boded well.
‘Never minded that merchant when he was funding your hopeless bloody expedition without the slightest expectation of a return on his investment, did you?’ he uttered, the words a blatant challenge.
Fíli was fairly sure he heard Kíli give a little gasp of horror, even as Uncle opened his mouth to retort.
‘I think that conversation has descended quite far enough, thank you,’ Bilbo interjected tartly, before another word could fall out of anyone’s mouth. ‘There’s enough infighting in the Iron Hills without us adding to it.’
‘Yes,’ Balin added hastily, frowning mightily at Glóin and Uncle both. ‘Stop it, both of you. Thorin, there’s no need to be nasty when Glóin’s simply offering advice. Glóin, please stop going for the jugular and saying things you don’t really mean every time someone offends you. It will make everyone’s life easier.’
The two culprits looked as sheepish as either of them ever did, and exchanged curt nods of apology. Fíli suspected that Dori’s mutter of ‘idiots’ summed up the feelings of most of the Company.
‘Dáin could always just get rid of the troublemakers,’ Nori mused airily, returning to the original point as if the disagreement between Glóin and Uncle had never happened. ‘Change the leadership of the Guilds to those who are willing to work with him and the problem will go away soon enough.’
‘Nori!’ several voices exclaimed all at once, Fíli’s own among them. He could not possibly be suggesting… could he?
No.
Surely not…
No. He couldn’t be.
Nori had never been accused of murder, no matter what other charges had been brought.
Besides, Dwalin would never allow…
‘Sounds sensible enough to me,’ Dwalin said equably, seemingly speaking directly to Balin in response to his brother’s look of, Well? Do something! ‘Cut the head off the snake and it won’t be causing you trouble any time soon.’
Fíli nearly choked on nothing (he really had to stop doing that, it was becoming a very embarrassing habit). Balin didn’t appear to be very far behind him. Uncle looked like he’d been clouted over the head with a club, and several other members of the Company were gaping unattractively.
‘Nori will not,’ Ori said from his position seated at the table, speaking with a calm firmness that Fíli had never heard him use before and apparently addressing the room at large, ‘be getting rid of anyone in a manner that might get him, or any of us, in trouble with the Guard. Whether he has Dwalin’s approval or not.’
‘Of course not, little brother,’ Nori agreed, smiling brightly and slyly, ‘but if the blackmail is choice enough then the Guildmasters are hardly likely to go to the Guard, are they? And I can’t possibly get in trouble for something I’m not reported for. Particularly if it works in the favour of the Lord of the Iron Hills.’
Ori appeared to contemplate this for some moments - whilst various members of the Company picked their jaws up off the floor and tried to pretend they’d known Nori was talking about blackmail all along - then he nodded decisively.
‘That you can discuss with Dáin,’ he told his brother magnanimously, ‘as long as you have Thorin’s approval, after we have taken care of Ered Luin.’
Several heads swung round to look at Uncle, who merely shrugged.
‘Far be it from me to dare question Ori’s judgement,’ Uncle told them all. ‘Or to deny Dáin the sort of good advice that I am given so freely by my own people. Once we have seen to the safety of our own kingdom, you may all offer him any help that you see fit.’
It was possible that Uncle muttered, ‘Mahal help his soul,’ after that last bit but, as no one heard the words clearly enough to swear to it, even Kíli felt obliged to offer a caveat when recording the conversation for posterity in his chronicle.
***
Thorin was not the only one feeling rather sorry for Dáin at this point. Bilbo could also see how the combined expertise of the Company could be a little overwhelming when turned your way (the enthusiastic discussion they were currently having about the best method of resolving Ered Luin’s problems was perfect proof of that), and he suspected the ruler of the Iron Hills was in for something of a shock when his day of reckoning finally arrived.
However, Bilbo was rather more focused on what came before that.
He imagined Thorin was too.
They still had not decided what they were going to do about Ered Luin.
Or had they?
Thorin seemed… calm, almost.
Settled.
As if perhaps he had come to a decision in those moments of quiet he had asked Bilbo to buy him and, despite the flare-up with Glóin a few minutes before, having some certainty at last was steadying him.
Bilbo could understand that.
It was half of the reason he had taken up the sword after his mother’s death. The other half, admittedly, had been a burning desire to be able to kill any orc that ever again threatened his homeland, but the reason he had clung to the idea so strongly had been the quiet he had felt in those initial moments after making the decision, and during every lesson the twins had given him.
He could only hope Thorin’s decision worked out so well for him.
He caught Thorin’s eye now and gave him a questioning look, wondering if their leader was ready to bring the Company back in line so they could discuss their next move. Thorin took a deep breath, then nodded, and Bilbo whistled shrilly to draw attention back to him.
‘Ori is right,’ he told the Company firmly. ‘We tidy our own house first, then we look to our neighbour’s.’
‘Aye,’ Dwalin agreed almost immediately, giving Thorin a look of apology, ‘we’ve been getting carried away. Dáin’s problems seemed a little easier to fix so….’
‘Yes, I’ll admit I would still rather have his troubles than our own,’ Thorin agreed, smiling wryly, ‘but the Valar tend not to negotiate on that front, alas. We get what we are given. And what we have been given is very little choice and, as far as I and one of my closest advisors can see,’ Bilbo saw Thorin shoot Ori a quick smile and Ori’s face flush bright red in response. It was utterly adorable and he made a mental note to ask Thorin about it later, ‘only one option still open to us.’
Thorin reached inside the pocket of his coat and produced two items, placing them on the table before him. The whole Company pressed closer to see, and Bilbo ducked under a stray elbow so that he could do the same.
What he found when he got close enough was an old piece of parchment, clearly some sort of map, and a huge dwarven-style key.
‘Gandalf gave these to me at Rivendell,’ Thorin explained quietly. ‘The map was Thrór’s, passed to Gandalf by Thráin. Here,’ he traced his finger over one area, ‘were moon runes which I managed to read some months ago. They tell of a secret way into the Mountain, opened by this,’ and now his finger ran over the key.
‘Thorin,’ Balin gasped. He said no more, but Thorin nodded as if he had spoken a full sentence.
‘I have a suspicion this is what Azog wanted me for,’ he informed them. ‘Perhaps our enemy’s aim was the opposite of Gandalf’s, for I know the wizard wished me to reclaim Erebor, to destroy the dragon,’ he informed them. ‘I told Gandalf I would be no one’s pawn. That I was interested only in seeing my people fed and safe, and a dragon-infested kingdom could offer us neither.’ He shook his head tiredly. ‘I might have known a wizard would always get his way in the end.’
‘We’re going to try and kill the dragon?’ Kíli asked disbelievingly, reaching for and grasping Fíli’s forearm convulsively.
‘No!’ Thorin exclaimed, meeting his nephew’s eyes dead-on and shaking his head emphatically. ‘I am driven to desperation, Kíli, not to insanity. We’re going to try and steal from Smaug, not kill him. Legend has it that he sleeps now, has slept for years. Much as I despise trusting anything to legend… if it is true, we may yet have some chance. Even the smallest part of Thror’s treasury would help fund Ered Luin’s recovery for a few years, if we can manage to retrieve it.’
‘Steal a Silmaril from the Iron Crown?’ Nori commented ironically, everything from his tone to his stance betraying his scepticism at the idea. Bilbo could not wholly blame him. He was ready to follow Thorin on this quest, of course, he would not dream of turning back now, but even he could admit that the chance of success seemed as remote as Beren and Lúthien’s.
Admittedly, they had succeeded, but he did not think any member of this Company resembled a hero of the First Age.
Not even the dwarf who seemed to consume so much of his attention these days.
‘Perhaps,’ Thorin responded to Nori, and his own voice was a challenge. ‘Have we the thief who could do it, Nori?’
Part of Bilbo knew that he ought to be intervening somehow, reminding Thorin that adults used reasoned argument to achieve their ends, not the equivalent of a childhood dare.
The other part was fascinated by the light in Thorin’s eyes as he all-but taunted their companion, and the way that Nori himself responded. Dori’s gaze was flickering between the two as if he wanted to intervene, but then he settled on Nori and took an unconscious step back, removing himself from the encounter.
Bilbo caught Dwalin’s gaze, wondering if he would intercede, but Dwalin shook his head in response to the silent question. Clearly this was between thief and King.
Nori said nothing for a long moment, and after a few seconds of silence, Thorin spoke again.
‘For years you have stolen from my people,’ he told Nori, ‘and we knew it was you, even if we could not catch you. There are kingdoms, Nori, that would have taken Dori and Ori and used them to draw you out. Or simply punished them in your stead. There are certainly very few kings who would have offered you their protection when you found yourself in too deep with your fellow criminals, but that is exactly what I did when I accepted you on to this quest. I am not a naïve dwarf - I do not expect you will suddenly repent of your old ways - but I do believe you have a debt to pay to Ered Luin. What I am asking is, will you pay it now?’
Nori’s face was practically blank, only the movement of his eyes betraying how fast his mind must be working below the surface. They glanced from Ori, to Dwalin, to Dori, and even to the Princes, all without a word said. Then, suddenly, he went utterly still.
‘I’ll need help,’ he told Thorin, and the room appeared to let out a collective breath. ‘Quiet help. Two will need fewer trips in than one, and I’m not doing this any more times than I have to.’
Realisation hit Bilbo like an orc boot to the face, as he thought back to the day he’d confessed his darkest memories to Thorin.
He actually would rather take advice from Gandalf than face a dragon from the old tales, even if he wasn’t doing it single-handed.
Although he’d still rather face the dragon than have Lobelia live at Bag End.
That was something, and made it easier to say what he had to next.
‘You won’t go in alone,’ he told Nori, managing a pretence of calm. ‘We’ll do it together.’
Nori offered him a short, sharp nod, and Dwalin a clasp of his shoulder in gratitude. Bilbo tried not to betray the fact that he felt sick. He imagined Nori did too, and if he could hold it together then so could Bilbo.
Oh Valar, what had the two of them just done?
‘There’s one other thing,’ Thorin said into the silence that had fallen. They all looked at him nervously, waiting for the next axe to fall. ‘We must be there by Durin’s Day.’
Balin cursed furiously.
‘Thorin, we’re running out of time!’
******
