Chapter Text
Centerville, Iowa was almost nothing. Bilbo, having grown in London and seen New York City, thought Centerville didn’t even earn the name “town”. The team gathered around the first gas station they saw, debating on what to do for dinner. Bofur was adamant that they shouldn’t cross the street to the little diner because they would be too noticeable. Bilbo turned to him, eyes begging Bofur for one last dinner, and Bofur sighed.
In relatively high spirits, the team crossed the street to the diner. It was late but the diner was packed. Bilbo vindictively thought that it was because this diner was the only eating establishment for miles around.
Despite the fact that everything was swimming in grease and the only drink was beer and coke, the diner wasn’t half as bad as it could have been. Bilbo almost enjoyed himself, settled between Bofur and Bombur, jokes flying across the table. Fili and Kili exclaimed that they left something in the car and ran off to get it.
It was when Ori started nodding off between Dwalin and Dori that Thorin called the meal to a halt. They all pulled out their cash to pay for dinner and stumbled out of the diner, some more drunk than others. It was a merry meal, despite the threat of Saul Fischer and Azog Decker looming over them. Bilbo secretly believed that it was for the best.
They sauntered to the cars, laughter still bubbling between them, when Bilbo realized something was wrong.
A certain blonde teenager and his little brother were missing.
Bilbo didn’t know how long they had been gone, being too busy with the other members of the team, but he knew that they were gone for a long time. Something didn’t sit right with Bilbo. Even in a crowded parking lot, he felt like there were eyes watching him. Like someone, or something, was waiting for him. Waiting for the other men to leave so they could strike and take Bilbo.
He shivered and leaned closer to the Bofur, not liking the darkness. Bilbo was used to the city, with streetlights and headlights and buildings lit up like stars. There was nothing out here but inky blackness, waiting to swallow him whole.
“Fili! Kili!” Thorin called for his nephews. So Bilbo hadn’t been the only one to notice the two young boys were missing.
Thorin, growing more frantic with each passing moment, searched the entire lot, desperate to find his missing nephews. The rest of the team, waking from their drunken haze, started looking as well. Bofur asked if anyone had noticed two teenagers with no news. Ori and Nori scouted around the diner. It was Bilbo who found the clue. One of Fili’s silver bracelets in the grass behind the diner.
“This was no accident,” Thorin said, picking up the bracelet. “Fili would have dropped this on purpose.”
“Where do you suppose they are?” Bilbo asked.
“That direction,” Dwalin said, pointing out to the empty field.
“You’re kidding me!” Bilbo exclaimed. “There’s no way we can make it through all of that by tonight!”
Ori and Nori ran up to them, skidding in the dirt, both out of breath.
“There’s a light!” Ori said, gesturing out to the open field. “It looks like a little farmhouse. Nori saw some tracks in the dirt, like two bodies being dragged out there.”
That was enough proof for Thorin and he started moving towards the field, letting Nori lead the group to the farmhouse. They had all pulled their guns out and Bofur kept a comforting arm around Bilbo, winking as they pressed forward.
As they came closer, the light grew brighter and bigger. Nori was right; it was a farmhouse with a dozen cars waiting out front. It was a large house, two stories and a basement, with peeling white paint on the walls. The light was coming from a single window. No sign of life and no sign of Fili or Kili. A shadow passed over the window and the team dropped to their knees. Thorin turned to look at Bilbo; his eyes glinted in the darkness.
“Well, Burglar, go on,” Thorin gestured to the house.
“I beg your pardon!” Bilbo spluttered.
“Go see if my nephews are in the house,” Thorin gave Bilbo a little push. “If you see them, run back and tell us the news. If you run into trouble, whistle three times, then pause for four seconds, and whistle twice more.”
With a great number of hands pushing him along, Bilbo was creeping up to the farmhouse, alone and unarmed. Still, he was the official burglar of the team and this was his chance to prove himself. Now, if only there was a way to prove himself without putting himself in danger.
Bilbo crept up to the house, peering into the window, hoping that no one would see him. The interior of the farmhouse was a dull gray, a thin layer of dust covering everything. He was looking into a den, a moth-eaten sofa against one wall, a rickety fireplace against the other. A wide door led to a grimy kitchen with rusty tools hanging from the ceiling. A man was in the kitchen, cleaver flashing in the light as he brought it down.
A door creaked open and two more men came in, dragging two bodies behind them. Bilbo’s heart lurched. It was Fili and Kili! They were tied up with ropes and thrown onto the floor of the den, unconscious. Bilbo should have done something at that moment, be that running back to Thorin, doing the whistle code that he couldn’t remember, or charge in and save the boys himself. Instead, he stood and debated with himself.
Fili woke up, mumbling and rolling around. When he caught sight of where he was, and his little brother by his side, he started shouting up a storm. Bilbo, still unsure of what to do, stood in the window, watching as Fili swore on everything he held dear that he would kill these men if they touched his brother.
Unfortunately, one of the men, the redhead that looked like a pro-wrestler, turned around and caught sight of Bilbo in the window. Squealing, Bilbo sprinted from the window and ran all the way back to the field where Thorin and company were waiting.
“They’ve got the boys!” Bilbo gasped. “Three men in the farmhouse. Fili and Kili tied up. One of them saw me!”
That last fact, which left Bilbo a quivering bundle of nerves, only excited the others. They pulled out all their guns, exchanging rounds and whispering a plan to take the farmhouse by storm. Bilbo pleaded with them not to, telling them that something that dangerous would only attract attention.
Instead, they decided to see if, perhaps, Dwalin and Bifur alone could rescue Fili and Kili. They sent the two of them, with Bilbo, back to the farmhouse. They had clear instructions; come back with Fili and Kili. If return was impossible, they were to whistle and two more of the team would come forth.
Bilbo didn’t doubt the skill Dwalin and Bifur had, but they had no concept of how to be stealthy. Their footfalls were heavy and they kept clicking the safety on their guns. Still, they managed to creep right up to the front door, and that’s where it all went wrong.
Dwalin and Bifur, guns drawn, reached the door. Bifur nodded and Dwalin braced himself to kick the door open. Before his foot even left the ground, the door flung open and two men jumped out, a thick rope between them. Bilbo, thinking quickly, dodged out of the way and ran inside, jumping into the first closet he found. Peering through a crack, he saw Bifur and Dwalin, tied tightly together, dragged into the den and tossed next to Fili and Kili.
“There’ll be more, ‘m sure,” the man from the kitchen came out, holding a bloody cleaver in one hand. He was tall, wide, and bald, wearing an apron splattered with blood. He knelt down beside Kili and grinned. “Aren’ there, boy?”
“Don’t you dare touch him!” Fili shouted, struggling against the ropes around his arms. “I will kill you if you lay a finger on him!”
“Oh ho, possessive, aren’ we?” the bald man chuckled. “Don’ worry, boy. I won’ touch yer brother as long as ‘e tells me wha’ I wanna ‘ear.”
Bilbo, frozen in the closet, could only watch in horror as Kili shook his head violently. The bald man lifted his cleaver up, the blade touching Kili’s neck. Fili froze.
“Tell me now, little one,” the bald man growled. “’Ow many more are ya?”
“None! I swear!” Kili said, leaning away from the blade.
“He’s lyin’,” another man said, this one wiry with dirt brown hair. “Hurt ‘im, Bert. Make ‘im squeal!”
“NO!” Fili screamed, struggling harder against the ropes.
Bert, the man with the cleaver, chuckled and pressed the blade into Kili’s neck, just enough for a trickle of blood to show. Kili turned to Fili with wide eyes and Fili put on a brave face, whispering to his brother.
Bilbo, in a moment of courageous stupidity, jumped from the closet. It didn’t matter to him that he was a pudgy man from London with no weapons. It hardly mattered that he was facing three very strong men who were armed with knives and guns. He only knew that he couldn’t let Kili get hurt. Thorin would kill him.
“I believe you’re looking for me!” Bilbo announced as seven pairs of eyes locked onto him.
“’E’s tha’ fella in the winder!” the redhead who spotted him earlier said. “Ya went and got these two, didn’ ya?” he gestured to Dwalin and Bifur. “You tell us ‘ow many more of you there are!”
“None,” Bilbo said, keeping his face straight.
The three men looked like they didn’t quite believe him, but Bilbo kept his face as impassive as he could. Bert took his cleaver away from Kili and put it on Bilbo’s chest.
“You better not be lyin’,” Bert growled.
Bilbo was going to protest that he was a very honest man and of course he was telling the truth, but instead the front door burst open and the rest of the team charged in. Bilbo groaned to himself.
The team fought well, aiming a few shots at the three men, but it was soon a mess of bodies and shouts. One by one, the men caught the team, tied them up, and threw them onto the ground. Bilbo made a dash for the door in the confusion, only for Bert to pull him back by the ankle and put the cleaver to his throat. Thorin and Balin, the only two who hadn’t been captured yet, dropped their guns and let the men tie them up. Bilbo too was tied and thrown into the pile. They were completely at the mercy of these three men.
“Tom!” Bert shouted to the wiry man. “Get the pot.”
Tom grinned widely, showing several missing teeth, and ran out the back door. The team of fourteen, who had been struggling against the ropes, stopped at those words. They all exchanged worried looks and something cold slipped down Bilbo’s spine.
“A-are you going to eat us?” he couldn’t help but ask Bert.
“Not all of ya at once!” Bert chortled. “Only the biggest tonight. The rest of ya we’ll hafta keep in the freezer. Ya’ll be enough ta keep us goin’ ’til winter!”
Tom came back into the house then, dragging a huge cast-iron pot.
“Oi! Bill! Help me out, would ya?” Tom shouted.
The redhead bumbled over and tugged the pot into the kitchen with ease. He and Tom filled it up with water while Bert mused about the seasoning.
“We’ll make stew tonight,” he said, heavy cleaver working on vegetables. “Better than tha’ farmer from last nigh’. No meat on ‘im.”
“Aw, not stew,” Tom moaned. “Ya know I ‘ate your stew. Not enough sage in it.”
“I’m the cook!” Bert snapped. “You keep yer mouth shut!”
“We should jus’ squash ‘em,” Bill put in. “Take ‘em downstairs and crush ‘em ‘til they turn to jelly.”
“Oh, tha’ sounds nice!” Tom agreed heartily.
“It doesn’ matter how we cook ‘em,” Bert growled at the two, waving his cleaver around. “We need ‘em diced up and hidden away before dawn. Don’ wan’ the cops ta hear ‘em screamin’.”
Bilbo’s ears pricked up at that. What happened when dawn came along? Did the police scour this area every morning to find missing persons? If Bilbo could just keep these men distracted until dawn, they might have a chance of survival.
“Wait a moment!” Bilbo shouted, standing up to his feet, arms still tied behind his back. “You are going about this all wrong!”
Bert, Tom and Bill turned around, looking at Bilbo curiously.
“Oh, shut up!” Dori groaned from the floor. “You can’t reason with them!”
“I’m talking about the cooking bit,” Bilbo shuffled away from the others.
“What about the cookin’ bit?” Bert asked, taking half a step towards Bilbo.
“Have you seen these men?” Bilbo leaned in conspiratorially. “These are strong men with thick muscles. Not tender at all.”
“What d’ya suggest we do?” Bert asked, taking another half step closer.
“Sautee them!” Bilbo hopped away from Fili, who looked ready to bite his ankles. “Over a nice low heat with plenty of seasoning.”
Bert’s eyes gleamed.
“Tha’s a load of crap!” Bill said from the pot. “I’ve ‘ad plenty of strong men before! Nothing wrong with a bit of tough meat.”
“Yeah!” Tom agreed, reaching for a knife and stalking towards the group. He picked up Bombur by his curly hair and pressed the knife to his throat.
“Not that one!” Bilbo screeched. “He’s infected!”
Tom’s jaw dropped and he threw Bombur back into the den. Bill stopped what he was doing by the pot and Bert almost dropped his cleaver.
“In fact they’ve all got them!” Bilbo continued. “They’re absolutely riddled with parasites. It’s a horrible, nasty business. I really would not risk it if I were you.”
“PARASITES?!” Kili shouted from his spot by Fili. “We don’t have parasites! You have parasites!”
“Don’t mind him,” Bilbo said smoothly. “He hasn’t quite accepted the truth yet.”
“What d’ya suggest we do?” Bert towered over Bilbo. “Let ‘em all go?”
“Well,” Bilbo shrugged.
“This little limey is having us for fools!” Bert lifted his cleaver. “’E’ll go first!”
“He wouldn’ make more than a mouthful,” Bill said. “Not when ‘e’s skinned and boned.”
“Whichever one screams the most will be next,” Bert said, swinging the cleaver down at Bilbo’s throat.
Bilbo never figured out who screamed the loudest when he nearly died, for at that moment a long rattle of gunfire echoed in the house as buttery sunshine streamed through the windows. Bilbo fell onto the ground, gasping for breath, his heart pounding hard enough to break through his chest.
Gandalf Gray stood in the doorway, a rifle on his hip and spraying the three men down with bullets. In a few seconds, the men were on the ground, peppered with bullet holes and blood covering the floor. Gandalf sighed, as if he gunned down men all the time. Though, Bilbo thought, Gandalf probably did. All at once, the team started cheering. Gandalf pulled out a knife and cut the ropes off the team, setting his rifle on the ground.
“Where the hell have you been?” Thorin demanded as soon as he was free.
“I was looking ahead,” Gandalf said simply.
“Then what brought you back?”
“Looking behind,” Gandalf winked.
Thorin threw his hands in the air and turned to help free his nephews. Nori, Bofur, and Gloin, however, turned to exploring. Bilbo followed them, having nothing better to do. They found a hidden staircase and, with much trepidation, descended into the basement. Thorin and Gandalf joined them soon, the rest of the team scavenging the upstairs for anything useful.
The basement stank of rotting flesh and the single light that Gloin turned on flickered and buzzed. All over the walls were meat hooks, various knives, guns of all shapes and sizes, and a table. All of them covered with blood; some of it still red and dripping. Bloody bathroom curtains hung around the room, partitioning it into four areas. Plastic bags were piled into a corner and Bilbo moved to look into one.
“I wouldn’t do that,” Thorin pulled him back.
Bilbo yanked his arm free and looked into the bag, just to spite Thorin. He then promptly turned around and vomited on the floor.
“I warned you,” Thorin rolled his eyes.
Bilbo glared at him, wiping his mouth on his sleeve. How was he supposed to know that cannibals put all the undesirable guts and things into trash bags? Was Bilbo supposed to know that inside that plastic bag were intestines and eyeballs, slimy and crawling with flies? Bilbo stood up straighter, the smell still sickening and his limbs shaking. To prove himself, he turned and yanked open one of the plastic curtains.
He let out a shriek and fell backwards. Hanging upside down was a woman. She was naked and deathly white. Her neck was cut open and crusted with blood. A bucket was beneath her, nearly filled and congealing in thick clots. Bilbo stood up and shut the curtain quickly, hands shaking.
“Makes sense,” Nori said, though he too looked sick to his stomach. “You always bleed out an animal before you butcher them.”
Bilbo retched, his stomach protesting violently against him. He leaned against the table, taking deep breaths through his nose. He once went to a butcher in London. He’d seen the racks of beef and pork and watched as the man behind the counter took a cleaver and cut off the parts he wanted. He once watched a video of how to properly kill and butcher a chicken on a bet.
“Hey, you okay?” Bofur put a hand on his shoulder. “If you don’t feel good you can go.”
“No,” Bilbo shook his head. “I’m fine. I got ten quid on that bet.”
“What bet?” Bofur asked.
“Chickens!” Bilbo said. “Don’t you know about chickens?”
“I think our burglar needs some fresh air,” Thorin said. “Bofur, take him out.”
“No, I can do this!” Bilbo protested as Bofur put an arm around his shoulder.
Gloin opened another curtain to reveal dozens of severed limbs hanging in a row and Bilbo promptly fainted.
