Actions

Work Header

A Loophole in the Tapestry

Chapter 8: Emerald for Wisdom

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

            Parting with Beorn turned out to be a bittersweet affair, and Bilbo would lie if he told he wouldn’t miss the bear-man. He was gifted with a generous bag of tobacco, that was supposed to last him till he ‘settles in the mountain well enough’. As Bilbo laughed and Thorin furiously blushed at such words, Beorn promising to bring Bilbo another one twice as big for the guarantee of being invited to the wedding. Then, he turned into his bear form to oversee them making their way towards Mirkwood, all after giving the hobbit one last nuzzle with his snout.

 

“I still have no clue how you befriended that beast” Thorin grumbled, mood worsening deeper they stepped into the woods

“The same as I befriended you: by acting cute and being polite” Bilbo smiled, eyes trained on the path

“You didn’t win me over by being polite”

“I said befriended, not wooed” he sighed

“Would you be so kind and shut up for a damn minute, Your Highness?” Dwalin groaned somewhere behind them “We’ve been going in damn circles for good two weeks now! My thoughts and vision are starting to blur, and your chatter ain’t helping!”

 

            Thorin snorted and rolled his eyes, pulling out Orcrist to whack off the quickly thickening vines. Hobbit looked at his dwarf, who didn’t grace his best friend with a response. Oh.

 

“Aren’t you ‘your Majesty’, Thorin?” Bilbo frowned

“That’s right. You are ‘your Highness’, bunmel” the dwarf laughed “Or will be, at least”

 

            Bilbo flushed, throwing a piercing glare at the laughing Dwalin and the Company. Soon, they subsided, walking around as if in a fog. Bilbo grew more and more uneasy, flinching every time there was a spider web woven between the branches. As they made it to the cursed river, both Thorin and him made it a big deal for dwarrow to proceed strictly in pairs to avoid being submerged, monitoring that each member covered their mouth and nose with the collar of their garments not to breathe in the sedative fumes.

            As they made it out without the accidents, all sluggish but awake, Thorin sighed in relief that no one will need to be carried. He clutched onto Bilbo’s hand as the spider webs became thicker and thicker. There was no need for the hobbit to scout, not when they would eventually get captured by elves anyway.

 

“Quiet” Thorin whispered “There are spiders lurking in the shadows”

 

            The Company stilled, hearing the scratching of something along the mossy tree barks far above their heads. They proceeded as quietly as they could, which still wasn’t as untraceable as hobbit’s or elf’s stride. It wasn’t a surprise they were eventually found out after the spider carcasses started to rapidly fall, struck by thin but deadly arrows.

 

“Behave!” Thorin hissed at the confused and frightened Company “You are to represent the dwarrow before the eyes of Mirkwood elves!”

 

            Shadowy and lithe figures begun appearing all around them, and Thorin held onto Bilbo’s hand not to draw out Orcrist. Dozens of ageless faces stared at the Company, bows drawn and ready to strike. His posture remained unwavering even with an arrow pointed right between his brows.

 

“Prince Legolas” Thorin bowed slightly “Didn’t think we’ll meet here”

“This is the realm of my father, is it not?” the elf frowned “It is only natural I will be guarding it”

“We only meant to pass this forest, and now ask your folk of the permission to do so” the king noticed confused stares the elves exchanged between one another

“Why do dwarrow feel the need to pass through the realm of elves?” Legolas asked

“Because this is the quickest route to the Lonely Mountain” there was no need to lie now

“What is the reason of you to go there?” elf prince looked somewhat younger, eyes shining with curiosity

“The birds are returning to their nests” Thorin stated simply “Surely you must know”

 

            Legolas called Tauriel over, and Thorin tried not to smirk as he heard Kili fervently whispering something to Fili. Bilbo have his head a squish and the king rolled his eyes at that.

 

“Very well, I see you all posing no threat…yet” Legolas nodded “You and your Company will be taken by our squad to the halls of King Thranduil, where you will repeat your request. Do not try to sabotage us or draw your weapons, for you will be shot quicker than you blink”

 

            Thorin felt the murmur of the Company more than he heard it, and hoped his dwarrow would listen to his command. He couldn’t risk their safety due to his bruised pride, not this time, not when pride didn’t matter to him anymore.

 

“Of course, Prince Legoals” Thorin sighed “Lead on”

 

            The Company was led to the hall before the throne room, elven bows still drawn between the guards’ nimble fingers. Thorin was asked to enter, and he stepped forward with Bilbo’s hand clutched in his. At the guard’s protest, he stated that either both of them will see the King, or Thranduil could lift himself from the throne and go out to see them with his own two eyes. Legolas approached them upon hearing such a bold statement, but after seeing the king unyielding, he sighed, opening the heavy doors.

            Seeing the Elven King was as uncomfortable as it was the last time around. Thraduil wore a mast of indifference and arrogance, regarding both of them as one regards a dirt underneath his shoe. But if this act was meant to enrage Thorin, the elf king was failing to do so. Bilbo’s presence eased his mind and nerves, grounding him with tangibility of a warm soft hand clutched in his.

 

“Good evening” Bilbo cleared his throat

“It was good, up until King Thorin decided to breach the borders of my realm” king scoffed

“We are merely passing by, and, as you see, visited you to be granted the permission to do so”

“Ah, so he speaks” Thranduil frowned at Thorin “I thought you would let your accomplice lead the whole conversation himself”

 

            Thorin watched the king standing up, eyes trained on the figures below him.

 

“I had been informed you wish to visit your mountain” elf began “How many years had passed since you’ve been there?”

“A hundred and seventy-one” Thorin spoke through the lump in his thorat

“Not so long ago, then” Thranduil begun his descent “For an elf, that is”

 

            Bilbo nudged him, and Thorin tried to take even breaths at such blatant provocation.

 

“And who is this halfling?” Thranduil looked down coldly

“This hobbit, you wanted to say” Thorin puffed up “This is Bilbo Baggins of Hobbiton, the future Consort of Erebor”

“Oh…” elf perked up “You dwarves decided to seek help in the Shire by means of political marriage? How interesting, not once have I heard of this folk cooperating with other races”

 

            Thorin took another measured breath, and reminded himself of the price of non-compliance.

 

“This will be a union of love, King Thranduil” he said evenly “And I would ask you to treat Bilbo with the same respect you are treating me, if not more”

 

            Thranduil rose his dark brows, eyes drifting from one figure standing before him to another. Seeing the confidence in Thorin and Bilbo’s content smile, he stepped back, lip pursed in thought.

 

“And you, hobbit. Will this union be loving to you? For I have no clue why would you tie yourself to the king without a kingdom” the elf paused as Thorin stepped forward, continuing after a beat “The path you are taking will lead to Lake Town, and then towards ruins of Erebor and Dale. There you will see only the charred remains of the glory that once was, the kingdom dwarves lost because of their own greed. Their king’s greed”

“Us hobbits do not believe in kingship, and govern ourselves with humble mayors and thains” Bilbo placed a stilling hand on Thorin’s forearm “So Thorin being a king was of no matter to me, and it didn’t matter whether he had a kingdom to rule or not. As for us heading over to the Lonely Mountain…His lineage has a weakness, yes, but it doesn’t mean it isn’t noble and ready to retake their right to rule”

“Retake the right?” Thranduil loomed over them “And how, pray, they will retake it? Fight the dragon with the force of thirteen dwarves?”

“Precisely” Bilbo nodded

 

            Thorin looked at his hobbit. Bilbo’s eyes looked older than the rest of him, mouth set and posture rigid. Thranduil slowly made his way around them, like a lynx ready to strike its prey. But neither hobbit nor dwarf waivered, not when they knew it could be done. Not when they knew where they went wrong. In that moment, it felt like Smaug himself was of no threat to them.

 

“I would like to see you try” the elf scoffed “And I would like to see you fail, all due to your arrogance and stupidity. I myself fought the great drakes of the North, I know what it is like. And I know, that the meager power you hold will be of no match to the wyrm laying under the mountain”

“We understand your concerns-“

“I do not concern myself with the fate of you nor of the dwarves, hobbit” Thranduil loomed over Bilbo “My people are my only priority”

“And yet, concerning yourself with the fate of Mirkwood is directly linked towards the Lonely Mountain” Thorin stated “The same darkness that fell on the treasure, fell on the woods of your realm, Thranduil! Do not try to deny it, for the wizard himself said so. The Green Lady Herself said so! It poisons the trees and the soil, corrupts the animals and air. We were there, we saw the beasts that lurk under the branches. Protecting the borders of your kingdom could only last for so long, but one day, it won’t be enough”

 

            The Elven King was visibly struck at the words directed at him. Bilbo’s heart soared with pride at the steadfastness of his dwarf. The ring felt heavy in the pocket of his waistcoat, his hands itching to take it, and-

 

“And what would you have me do?” elf frowned “Do you expect my army to come and aid you? As I said, I will not risk the lives of my people for such stupidity”

“We ask only of the safe passage of our Company through the borders of your realm” Thorin sighed “And I personally ask you not to turn your back on my kin when the right time calls for it”

“And what that right time may be? As you run from the dragon once again? As you and Dain Ironfoot fight for the piles of gold?” Thranduil paced around “Or as you decide whether or not give me the White Gems of Lasgalen back?”

 

            Thorin stilled as he recognized the look in the ageless eyes of elven-king. There was a trace of pain and longing at the mention of the one to whom those gems were dedicated to, a trace of a dull ache that subsided with time, but never truly went away. It was a sense of grief over the bond that was cut off too soon, the same look Thorin wore every time he caught his reflection on the polished bronze mirrors of Mahal’s Halls. Thranduil also lost his love, but unlike Thorin, he had no opportunity to bring her back, to once again have her beside him.

            Dwarf lowered his gaze toward the roots that formed the throne. There were distinct unnatural cuts to the left side of the platform, the side of the Consort, the side he subconsciously always placed Bilbo in. He could easily remember how painful it was, to gaze toward your beloved and find the place empty, longing to be heard and understood but being met with deafening silence.

            Wanting to protect his people, his home, the memory of his love…Thorin have never thought he would understand Thranduil, feel anything towards the king but resentment, yet it seemed they were more familiar than he previously thought.

 

“I will give them to you as soon as I reclaim my home” Thorin bowed “And if I become sick with the madness that doomed my grandfather, Bilbo would bring them to you regardless”

 

            He could feel hobbit’s eyes on him, even as his head was still lowered. Thranduil stilled his pacing. The bare feet shifted forward in the corner of Thorin’s vision.

 

“I promise, King Thranduil” Bilbo asserted “I know you have little faith in Thorin, in us. But I assure you, that you will get the gems from my own two hands if Thorin refuses his end of the bargin”

 

            There was a faint sound of birds chirping, and the rustle of leaves overhead was louder than the tree of them. Thorin tried not to stagger, not to lash out and plead with the elf to trust the one person who could have Thorin’s heart on the silver platter if he wished so.

 

“Raise your head, King Thorin” the elf said solemnly “It is unfitting for you to bow so low”

 

            Their eyes met. Thranduil was still wearing the mask of indifference, but inclined his head towards the two of them. Thorin cast Bilbo a hesitant glance.

 

“I see you and your betrothed are aware of the sickness” the elf sighed “And I am wary it cannot be fought back”

“Even in madness there are moments of clarity that bear the promise of being able to be cured” Bilbo frowned, clutching Thorin’s hand in his “There has to be a way”

“Really?” there was the barest hint of smile on Thranduil’s face “And what are you willing to do to cure it, Bilbo Baggins of Hobbiton?”

“I am ready to do whatever it takes” Bilbo stated determinedly

 

            The elf laughed.

 

“You have found yourself a mighty Consort, Thorin Oakenshield” Thranduil nodded approvingly “Very well, I will hold onto my end of the bargain if you promise to fulfil yours. If I see no gems, you will see no aid”

“Of course” Thorin nodded, tension slowly lifting from his shoulders

 

            Thranduil rounded on them, and crouched on Bilbo’s level. It was startling, to see the intense and scrutinizing eyes shining with a barely present trace of mirth, but Bilbo refused to cower. The corners of elf’s mouth twitched upwards, and hobbit was met with extended hand.

            He hesitantly outstretched his, and was met with surprisingly warm handshake.

 

“Never once I had met a hobbit” Thranduil rose, and nodded to the guards “Send a note to the kitchens to prepare a sufficient meal to the company of fourteen before the guests depart from Greenwood”

 

            The guard nodded, and the elven king returned his attention towards them.

 

“Our race is very stealthy, and refuses to be noticed by those who may do us harm” Bilbo flushed “But we like elves, though”

“Truly?” the elf gestured for them to follow

“Yes, but I never spoke to a Greenwood elf before” hobbit refused to let go of Thorin’s hand, not trusting himself on thin woven bridges “Well, if we wouldn’t count your son, Your Majesty”

“Ah, Legolas” Thranduil’s gaze softened at the mention of him “I hope he left a good impression on you”

“He almost left an arrow in my skull” Thorin grumbled

“He is a gentle soul” the elf smiled “At least, when he is not under a threat”

“When he is not being a threat, you mean” dwarf smirked

 

            Thranduil turned to look at him, pausing their stroll. Thorin stilled, heart quickening its pace at the thought of misstepping and putting the Company at risk of being locked up. Bilbo too clutched him a little tighter. To the surprise of them both, the corners of elf’s eyes crinkled in glee.

 

“I think we will get along, Your Majesties”

 

            As soon as they entered the grand dining hall, they were met with twelve bewildered and wary pairs of eyes. Dwarrow were sitting around the long table like timid children, not knowing whether to speak or act, legs not reaching the branch-weaved floors. Thorin and Bilbo were sat at the head of the table along the elven King, and soon, more and more elves started to emerge.

 

“Greetings, the Company of Thorin Oakenshield” Thranduil stood up after the meals were brought over to the table, slightly bowing towards the guests “Please enjoy the meals prepared to you before you part ways with us. Tonight there will be festivities and merriment, for the celebrations of the Autumn are here. Eat and drink, sing and dance under the starlight, because the next step you take on your journey won’t be as merry as this”

“I think this is his manner of reassuring us, dear” Bilbo whispered to Thorin, eyeing a piece of roasted meat

“I still have no clue how he manages to sound so condescending while doing so” the dwarf smiled, reaching over and placing the roast of Bilbo’s plate along with potatoes, fried mushrooms and beets

“How romantic of you” Bilbo grinned at his plate “Thanks, dear”

“Is this considered romantic to your kin?” Thorin begun plating his own serving

“Yes” hobbit begun to eat “Shows how much you prioritize me and my well-being”

 

            Thorin only smiled at that. As the evening progressed and stars lit up the sky, elves begun to make their way out of the tables and towards the empty center to dance. It was quite peculiar to watch the elven King sing along to the songs, clapping to the beats of the drums, but it made Thorin further reconsider his previous prejudices. Bofur managed to take over the music, good half of the Company setting the melody and the other singing along to it. Bilbo pointed at Kili managing to coax Tauriel to learn the typical dwarrow dance steps, and Thorin hoped the shaky relations between the two races wouldn’t be ruined by the giddiness of his nephew. The scoff Thranduil sent the pair was reflecting Thorin’s own, so the dwarf assumed it wasn’t as bad as he assumed.

 

“Gloin tells Legolas of Gimli” Bilbo pointed out at the dwarf and elf further along the table “Look, he’s showing him the picture pendant!”

“Is it a bad thing?” Thorin hummed “The prince looks…repulsed”

“This is a great thing, dear!” Bilbo was grinning “He’ll grow out of it, you’ll see”

 

            Thranduil approached him later at night as Thorin watched Bilbo dancing in distinctly hobbitish way, all footwork and laughter, both dwarrow and elves watching and trying to follow the lead. Elf gestured towards the quieter part of the dining hall to an opening overlooking the bronze autumnal trees shining from the lanterns.

 

“King Thorin, I must apologize” the elf begun

 

            Thorin choked on ale he had been drinking, looking up at the elf king in bewilderment.

 

“My previous treatment of you and your betrothed was unjust” Thranduil shook his head “It was unbecoming of me to treat you with the same attitude I treated your grandfather, who was the one who had actually done me wrong. You, on the other hand, were merely making a request, and I acted as if you were taunting me”

 

            Dwarf kept silent, hand clutching the pint, heart hammering at the honesty of elven king’s words. Bilbo’s laughter reached his ears, the instruments quickening their pace.

 

“You are not the dwarf I had expected you to be” Thranduil continued “I expected more rage, more resentment. I waited for you to snarl at me, to curse me and my folk for refusing to aid you. But you never did…Why?”

“Because my kin would have done the same thing had the attack happen to your kingdom” Thorin responded humbly “I understand your refusal, even when my heart still pains at the reminder of it”

“Oh, I see”

 

            Thranduil fell silent after that. The lanterns flickered, and the crowns of trees moved along with the night breeze. Thorin watched his beloved dancing with his nephews, and his soul rejoiced with them.

 

“I respect you, Thorin Oakenshield” the elf emptied his wine glass “It takes a lot of willpower to speak with grace at the house of those who wronged you. And it takes a lot of determination to try and regain your home back from the wyrm”

“I would not have forgiven you if it weren’t for the most merciful creature I had ever known” Thorin gestured towards Bilbo “He taught me the meaning of home, of virtue, of what is truly valuable. And what I now cherish doesn’t involve the hoard of cursed gold, nor the king’s jewel”

 

            Thranduil smiled sadly at him.

 

“I had forgotten the lessons my starlight taught me, then” he sighed “She was as compassionate and merciful as your hobbit, lighting up every room she walked into, softening my resolve. With her passing, I let my heart wither away, having no nourishment from the darkness that came with her absence”

“You still have your son” Thorin didn’t know how to aid the person that was once his enemy

“I do love him, and yet it hurts me every time he acts in her manner, or looks at me the same way she would look” Thranduil knit his brows “The shadow is lifted for only a moment until it falls again with even more force…I suppose you won’t be able to comprehend it”

 

            Thorin wouldn’t be able to, but he knew the hobbit who could. He remembered the unseeing eyes, the tears, the guilt and onslaught of feelings Bilbo unleashed as he talked about Frodo, at him seeing Thorin in his nephew, dwarf’s heart aching at the sheer tragedy and desperation of it all.

 

“I am sorry for your loss” Thorin met Thranduil’s eyes “I truly cannot console you, not in regard of such personal matter…but if it helps, as we wandered after the loss of our home, exhausted and without a trace of hope, it was easier to reminisce about the fact that we were graced with Erebor’s embrace once and were given the honor to traverse its halls and mines, than to ponder at the loss of it all”

“The loss of your beloved hurts even more, because while you can make yourself feel at home if you try hard enough, no person can replace the one you lost” Thorin continued, breaking off the eye contact when the gaze of the elf king was overcome with grief “But it may bring you some comfort, to cherish the fact that the love was there once, that it was real. That you had an opportunity to share your soul with someone, to see the world cast in light, even if it couldn’t last. I think it is always better to love and end up hurt, than to never experience it and live in the world with dulled colors”

 

            There was a hand on his shoulder. Thorin glanced up at the elven king.

 

“Thank you” Thranduil nodded, looking both forlorn and relieved “I…thank you”

 

            Thorin found Bilbo on the balcony of their guest room, lit up by starlight.

 

“Bunmel” Thorin smiled

“Thorin!” Bilbo sputtered on the smoke “You startled me”

“Sorry” the dwarf nuzzled his nose into the warm crook of his hobbit’s neck, enveloping the smaller figure with the ends of his cloak to fight off the autumnal chill “I have something for you”

“What is it?” Bilbo sighed, leaning onto him, savoring the warmth

 

            Thorin took out a generous slice of seed cake wrapped in leaves.

 

“Still have no clue why elves don’t use plates all that much” he smiled “But it means no one noticed me stealing the biggest slice there was as there was no evidence”

“What a burglar you are” Bilbo laughed as he took the offered gift “What was the occasion?”

“We left Beorn somewhere in the middle of September, and with the absence of sunlight in the forests of Mirkwood, I failed to keep the track of what date it was” Thorin putted out the main gift, which was wrapped in a bundle of blue velvet “And during our perilous wanderings, someone very dear to my heart had his birthday occur”

 

            Bilbo gasped, clutching the fabric, not yet unwrapping it, choosing to turn and stare at Thorin instead.

 

“This lifetime, I finally found out the day that the Green Lady chose to bless this world with one Bilbo Baggins, who continues to amaze me and make my knees weak just with his dimpled smile” Thorin smiled bashfully “I am sorry the greetings came so late, bunmel. But I promised we’ll celebrate it, didn’t I?”

“Yes” hobbit chuckled, wiping a stray tear “This is the best celebration I could get. To be in your arms, in safety and merriment, us lit up by starlight and lanterns…”

“And not in the dungeons” Thorin pecked him on the lips

“And especially not in the barrels!” Bilbo shuddered, laughing

 

            Thorin gestured towards the gift, Bilbo pulling away slightly to unwrap the knot. There, nestled in the fabric, was a golden necklace. The chain was weaved like a thin, delicate rope, and on it rested a pendant with an orange-yellow gem. The stone was rounded, and the gold wrapped around it only held it on the sides. Bilbo lifted the pendant against a nearby lantern, seeing right through it.

 

“It is like looking through the freshest honey” Bilbo murmured

“The pendant is inlaid with amber” Thorin whispered “It was very unusual for a dwarrowdam to request it instead of similarly colored gemstone, but my grandmother persisted. She assured me, that pearls and amber were rarer than the rarest gems, because they required actual life to form them. I kept it, since my siblings chose different heirlooms as she grew older and frailer. She smiled at me as I was for some reason drawn to it, jesting that my One would be happy to have it as a courting gift” Thorin snorted “I was twenty at the time, scoffing that no dwarrow would choose amber over sapphires and emeralds, but look at me now, thinking that it would suit my hobbit best”

“And why do you think that?” Bilbo smiled

“Because it is both a gemstone and a fossilized tree sap” Thorin leaned in, resting his cheek against Bilbo’s “Both dwarrow and hobbitish”

 

            The hobbit hummed, wrapping his hands around Thorin’s middle.

 

“I know you don’t adorn yourself, but I still would like you to have it”

“Just because us hobbits like ribbons and buttons more than jewelry, doesn’t mean I won’t wear it” Bilbo broke off, turning around and giving Thorin the necklace “I’ll love it even more, knowing it is a courting gift” hobbit whispered “For whoever sees it will know, that I am yours, and you are mine”

 

            As Thorin clasped it on, hands never truly leaving hobbit’s neck. Bilbo turned and let his dwarf admire how the pendant laid against his chest. Thorin ran his fingers over it, and drew Bilbo into a slow and tender kiss.

Notes:

I adore the description of the elves in the original book. They were mirthful and mischievous, almost fae-like. I like the wise and elegant interpretation the movies did, but also very much enjoy the teasing songs they sang in the book and Legolas’ long spiels about trees and forests and whatnot (Gimli comes close second with his tangent about Glittering Caves, I like to think they still will become lifelong buddies this time around too, meeting on some ambassador trip or something). That’s why I added a touch of humor to Thranduil, well, as much humor as he will let show to the outsiders, at least. Book readers know that he was at the center of the autumn festival after all :)