Actions

Work Header

hargrove paradox

Chapter 7: mirrors

Notes:

final stretch of the fanfic ♡⁠(⁠>⁠ ⁠ਊ⁠ ⁠<⁠)⁠♡
Jonathan and Will are here!! i feel like Billy and they have so much in common, they could totally become great friends in the series… screw the Duffer bros, long live headcanons and fanfics!!(⁠ノ⁠*⁠0⁠*⁠)⁠ノ
hope you enjoy ♡ sorry for any mistakes!!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Despite what Billy had imagined, the night’s sleep was peaceful.

Before going to bed, Steve showed him everything in their bedroom; which side of the closet belonged to Hargrove, his drawers, where his shoes and other belongings were kept. He also showed him his cellphone and his pager, which Billy mainly used for work, and Billy found himself fascinated by that technology.

Harrington eventually fell asleep while Hargrove explored all the features of those new (to him) electronic devices.

The next morning, Billy woke up to Mel tugging at his blanket and purring loudly. He rubbed his eyes and realized Steve wasn’t in bed. Soon, he caught the smell of coffee, eggs, and bacon and knew exactly where Harrington was.

He got out of bed and went to the bathroom attached to the bedroom, splashing water on his face and brushing his teeth. He grabbed the first pair of swim trunks he saw in the drawer, scratched Mel between the ears, and headed downstairs.

Only to find Steve, Max, Jonathan, and… a guy he didn’t quite recognize at first gathered around the kitchen counter.

Then it clicked.

He remembered his conversation with Max and realized he had somehow ended up getting close to the Byers boys: the freak one, Jonathan, and the “zombie boy”, Will.

Everyone froze, staring at him like Hargrove was about to punch someone or do something even worse.

“Good morning…?”

“Hey, Billy.” Jonathan was the first to approach him. “How are you doing, amigo?” he greeted him.

“Fine… amigo. As fine as you can be when your mind time-travels.”

“You got this, man!” The older Byers gave him a few pats on the back and headed toward the living room. “I brought a bunch of Hawkins memorabilia. My mom even sent some records you forgot at our place.” He pointed to two boxes on the coffee table and started rummaging through them.

“Did Billy really forget them, or did you just steal them?” Will asked as he came closer.

“Friends don’t steal. They borrow.”

Everyone laughed, except Billy, who was still trying to wrap his head around how close he apparently was to the Byers family.

“Hi, Billy,” Will greeted him. “I missed you.”

“Hey, kid.”

Billy barely remembered what Will looked like. He only knew he was Max’s age and that he had disappeared and been presumed dead a year before Hargrove arrived in Hawkins.

Will hugged him tightly, catching him off guard. Billy noticed Steve, Max, and Jonathan exchange glances, but none of them said anything. He chose to ignore it and returned the boy’s hug, stiff at first, unsure what to do with it.

“You’re going to make it again, Billy. You always do.” Will pulled away, his eyes slightly watery, which surprised Hargrove.

“Thanks, kid. I know I will.”

“Before we start with the deep, emotional conversations,” Max said, drawing everyone’s attention, “can we please have breakfast already? I’m starving, and Steve’s pancakes are literally screaming my name.”

Billy noticed how Harrington’s eyes lit up at those words, filling with pride.

“The table’s already set, kids. Go eat,” Steve said by the sink, still busy with something.

“You’re including me in ‘kids,’ right?” Jonathan asked, even as he was already sitting down with Will and Max.

“Of course, Jonathan. Your back’s already worse than mine, somehow.”

Everyone laughed, and before Jonathan could reply, Will cut in:

“Oh my God, Max, at this rate there won’t be anything left for Billy and Steve to eat!”

“I’m really hungry! They need to hurry up!”

Billy walked over to Steve.

“Good morning, Harrington.”

“Good morning, lo-Billy.” He laughed awkwardly. “Sorry.”

“You don’t have to apologize. It’s fine.” Billy gave him a small smile. “What are you still doing up?”

“Oh, I remembered you like whipped cream on your pancakes, so I decided to make it for you.” He picked up a spoon and offered it to Billy. “Want some?”

Billy accepted without a word, tasting the sweetness of the cream as the sugar melted on his tongue.

“You’re not working today?”

“It’s Saturday, so no school. I thought you could decide what we’re doing today, and maybe throughout the day we can talk. About memories, see how you react to things. What do you think?”

“Great idea.” By the time he answered, the spoon was completely empty. “Have you always known how to cook?”

“I wasn’t very good before. I lived off frozen food for a long time, but after I graduated, I decided I should learn and… turns out I’m pretty damn good at it.”

“You’re the best, Steve Harrington!” Max said with her mouth full of pancakes.

“We should probably go eat already!” Billy noticed the pancakes disappearing and grabbed Steve’s hand without realizing what he was doing. With his other hand, he picked up the bowl of whipped cream. Soon, they were all sitting at the table, having breakfast together.

~~~

After breakfast, Billy decided he wanted to enjoy the sun and stay in the pool while the heat still lingered. Jonathan was the only one who complained, but he went along with it anyway.

Max and Will decided they wanted to tan, stretching out on the lounge chairs to soak up the sun, but it didn’t last long. Hargrove dove into the pool, sending water flying everywhere and provoking the two younger ones to jump in. Maxine never let one of her brother’s provocations go unanswered, and Will wanted to have fun. Soon, the three of them were racing to see who could swim fastest to the deep end of the pool, almost forgetting they were supposed to act like adults.

Steve and Jonathan watched them by the pool. Harrington was smiling, already prepared to strip down and enjoy a bit of sun before joining them in the water, while Byers planned to stay in his shirt and thoroughly coat himself in sunscreen.

When Steve took off his shirt, what caught Billy’s attention immediately wasn’t the defined chest beneath a dusting of hair or the narrow waist that had always drawn his gaze (and his more inappropriate thoughts) but the tattoo Harrington had along his ribs.

Etched in dark ink were the letters–

B.H.

Hargrove’s initials.

Billy definitely needed that memory.

“I won! Slowpoke!” Max teased, taking advantage of the fact that her brother was completely distracted, splashing water straight into his face.

“Did Will give up?” Billy wiped the excess water from his eyes, tossing his curls back.

“Yeah, he’s on the float now.” She nodded toward their friend with her chin as she sat beside Billy on the edge of the pool, her feet still dangling in the chlorine-scented water. They were facing away from Steve and Jonathan, who sat on the lounge chairs across the pool. “So?” She nudged his shoulder lightly. “How was last night?”

“It was… a lot of things.” He didn’t know where to begin, even though with Max he felt he could be honest about every ugly, confused thought tangled in his head.

“Steve told me you remembered…” she said, as if needing confirmation that it had really happened.

“Yeah. I did. Not much, but I remembered.”

“That’s still progress.”

“I… I can’t believe I told Steve about Neil. About… what he does.”

Billy had sworn no one would ever find out.

His father could kill him or Billy might kill his father in a fit of rage when he finally couldn’t take it anymore, but he had always believed that secret would die within the four walls of that house.

Maxine grew thoughtful, her red hair, now wet, falling back into loose waves.

“You decided to ask for help. That’s why you told him.”

Billy laughed.

“I didn’t ask for any fucking help, Max.” He shook his head. “I just dumped my problems all over Harrington like some pathetic, desperate wimp… He wanted to take me to the police station and all that shit, and I refused.” His gaze drifted to the bottom of the pool.

“But after you told him, you finally had someone to support you. Someone to anchor you. You weren’t going through it alone anymore.” Max noticed he didn’t want to believe her words and sighed. “Look, it’s not my story, so it’s not my place to tell you this, but that’s why you got closer to Jonathan.”

“What?”

“His dad was a piece of shit too, basically. For a long time, he turned the Byers lives into hell. He was cruel, especially to Will. One of the reasons Joyce asked for a divorce was to protect him.”

“Will’s gay too, right?”

“You’re only noticing now, asshole?” Max laughed.

“Fuck no.” He laughed too, nudging her back. “I’m just… still learning how to deal with all of this.” Billy watched Will, still floating atop the watermelon-shaped float. “I’ve always handled my shit on my own. I’m not exactly the best person to talk about these things.”

“But you were there for Will.” Max smiled at him, warm and fond. “You and Steve.”

“What the hell?!”

“Yep! That’s another story that isn’t mine, so…” She raised her hands in surrender.

“I hate you, Maxine… Stop leaving me in the dark.”

“Memory works better when it’s told by the person who lived it with you,” she explained. “Relax, hothead. By Monday, everything will be back to normal.”

“We’ll see, Red… we’ll see.”

Jonathan suggested they start drinking, and everyone agreed. While the older Byers handed out the beers, Max went back into the pool, knocking Will off the float and making Billy laugh.

“Your sister is just like you, man,” Jonathan said as he handed him a can, which Hargrove cracked open and took two long swigs from.

“Stepsister,” he corrected automatically. “But yeah… I guess I agree. That household messed both of us up.”

“Now that you know what the future looks like, you know it didn’t mess you up that badly.” Billy never would’ve expected that, of all people, Jonathan Byers would be the kind who always saw the bright side of things. Maybe this was Nancy Wheeler’s influence.

“This whole thing is so insane. The Upside Down, time travel, memories, all that crap… And the part I still can’t accept is that I somehow deserve such a good life in the future…”

Hargrove knew he wasn’t a good person. He had never considered himself one, had even despised those who wore that adjective proudly. So after his mother abandoned him, after years of enduring Neil’s abuse, Billy accepted as truth that nothing good would ever happen to him, because he didn’t deserve it.

What he did deserve were all the bad things that happened, one after another. Billy grew worse with every passing day, and that, he believed, was the natural order of things.

“And who the hell told you that you don’t deserve a good life? Your shitty father?!” Jonathan looked genuinely outraged now. “Men like Neil and my dad, Lonnie: they’re insignificant little shits. They think taking out their frustrations on their kids will fix something, that punishing, neglecting, or hurting a child will solve any damn thing… But it won’t, Billy. We know that.”

He sighed.

“When we came to California for the first time, it was me, you, Steve, Nancy, and Robin. I was really excited about the trip. I’d saved money from that photography job I had that summer, but my mom was anxious. Bills were overdue, and the heater had broken again. So I gave her all my money. I didn’t want to cancel the trip; everyone was excited, especially Nancy. It was our first real trip as a couple. So I had the stupid idea of asking my father for money, and he basically humiliated me. Said I didn’t deserve to travel, or money, or anything that came at his expense. He talked shit about my mom and my brother and told me never to show up there again. I’d never felt so much hatred toward him, so much disgust… When I found you to tell you the trip wasn’t happening and explained everything…”

Jonathan laughed softly at the memory.

“First you got pissed that I’d gone to my asshole father. And then you said I didn’t need to worry about money, that you’d figure something out. That I was going with you because I deserved it, and that it wasn’t some bastard like Lonnie who got to decide that.”

“I said that?”

“You did, man,” he said fondly. “And the trip was amazing. The best week of my life. You gave me that, Billy.”

“How did I get the money?”

“You never told me, but Steve probably knows… My point is, it doesn’t matter what happened in the past. What matters is the present and the choices we make. Everyone deserves a truly good life.”

“Yeah…” Billy said, thoughtful. “That’s a pretty damn optimistic way to look at things.”

“Learned it from the best.”

“Who?!”

“You.”

“Go fuck yourself, Byers!”

Jonathan burst out laughing.

“Okay, okay. Maybe ‘optimistic’ is a strong word. But you believe in people. You know they can change. You changed,” he added more softly. “Doesn’t someone who’s grown deserve a good life?”

“Guys!” Will’s voice called out. “Steve wants to know what you want for lunch.”

Only then did Billy notice it was just him and Jonathan by the pool. Max was inside the house, wearing shorts and the top of her bikini as she picked through some CDs, and Steve was in the kitchen, still shirtless.

“I want to make barbecue. Does the grill still work?” Jonathan asked as he stood up.

“Ask Steve, man. I still don’t remember shit.”

Billy watched the Byers brothers head inside and decided to take one last swim.

The conversation with Jonathan, and that memory, hadn’t brought anything back. But it had planted hope in his heart.

Maybe if Billy tried, if he really made the effort, gave himself a chance, and had people around him who believed in him, he could truly change, improve, and deserve that good life without regrets.

A few minutes later, his skin already wrinkled from being in the water for so long, Hargrove decided to get out.

He was alone, drying off near the lounge chairs, when Will returned to keep him company.

“Can I talk to you?” the boy asked, a little shy. Maybe that was just how he was, or maybe, even as friends, Billy would always be intimidating.

“Sure, kid Byers. Have a seat.” Billy put on his sunglasses and leaned back in one of the chairs, waiting for Will to do the same.

“I’ll be honest with you, Billy…” Will fidgeted with his hands, restless. “I never know how to start these conversations with you. I worry so much, wanting to help, that I end up not helping at all…”

That concern, that care, caught Hargrove completely off guard.

“Relax, man. You do what you can.” He didn’t want to be a burden to anyone else; it was enough that he already was one to Harrington.

“Right…” Will took a deep breath, clearly trying to steady himself. “The memory I wanted to share with you is about the day Steve babysat me.”

Billy blinked a few times.

“And… how the hell do I fit into that?”

Will laughed, running a hand through his straight hair.

“Steve was there to watch me while my mom was out of town. Jonathan and Nancy were busy working. Mike, Dustin, and Lucas were over for a sleepover. Then you showed up with Max and El.” He smiled faintly at the memory.

“Everyone got distracted right away when you arrived. We started arguing about what movie to watch, or whether we should stay up all night playing board games. And that’s when I noticed Steve wasn’t in the living room anymore…”

Will hesitated.

“I got worried.”

Will seemed to relive every scene vividly, as if the memory wasn’t sixteen years old.

“I left the others and went looking for him. Your Camaro was still parked outside. I called for Steve, but he didn’t answer. I walked around the house and still couldn’t find him… until I got closer to your car and saw the two of you. Kissing.”

“Holy shit.” Hargrove rubbed his eyes beneath his sunglasses. “So your memory is about the time Steve and I traumatized you?”

“No! Jesus, Billy, of course not!” Will shook his hands emphatically. “I… I’d always been different and didn’t understand why. Not really. Until that day.” He smiled softly.

“The way you looked at each other… you were so in love. And the way you touched Steve… It was so careful. So gentle. Like something I’d only ever seen in the movies.” Will’s voice wavered, but he kept going.

“At the time, I panicked because you saw me there, and I ran off. But later, when I was trying to fall asleep, all I could think about was how much I wanted that too. To live that. To allow myself the way you were allowing yourselves.” His eyes were watery again. “The next day, when you came to pick up Max and El, you and Steve called me over to talk. You were really nervous, fidgety, and Steve barely let you speak because he was afraid you’d scare me.”

Will laughed softly, wiping away a single tear.

“But then I told you guys I wouldn’t tell anyone. That you could trust me. And I asked what it was like to kiss a boy, and you said-”

“It’s the same as kissing a girl,” Billy said without thinking, “but it’s better when you’re in love.”

“Y-You remembered?!”

“No…” Billy shook his head slowly. “That’s just the conclusion I came to after kissing a boy for the first time.”

“Oh…” Will swallowed. “W-Well… that sentence was really important to me.”

He hesitated, then went on.

“I didn’t tell you two I was gay that day. I wasn’t sure of anything yet, not at thirteen. But you were always around at school. Defending me. Watching out for the kids who messed with me while the teachers looked the other way.”

Will smiled, small but sincere.

“You were incredible, Billy.”

This was the first memory in which Hargrove could truly see himself.

Maybe because helping a confused little kid defend himself from violence he didn’t yet understand had felt almost instinctive.

Or maybe what had driven Billy to change, to become better, was the chance to prove that everyone had been wrong about Billy Hargrove.

Notes:

i think this might be my favorite chapter of all (⁠ ⁠◜⁠‿⁠◝⁠ ⁠)⁠♡
if you feel like leaving a comment, ill be more than happy to reply!! thank you so much for reading all the way to this point (⁠。⁠♡⁠‿⁠♡⁠。⁠)(⁠。⁠♡⁠‿⁠♡⁠。⁠)(⁠。⁠♡⁠‿⁠♡⁠。⁠)

see you in the final chapter!!