Chapter Text
Nobody was naming it for what it was. The dining hall, which was quickly dropping in temperature with the night fast approaching, felt all too sudden like a tomb—a resting place for the young stability in the lives of the dwarves, for the hope they’d had that everything was finally over. How naïve had it been to think so, when no peace ever seemed to last for more than a fortnight.
Perhaps that was why nobody was naming it for what it was. (A goodbye, a farewell, a ‘will you think of me when the trees shed their orange leaves and I will be gone with the wind?’)
But maybe that is a sentiment too dramatic for what it is, a voice in Bilbo’s head considered. He looked at the Company around the dining table, some seated, some standing. Everyone had their eyes blown wide, the gleam of them visible in candlelight and the leftover humidity of cooking steam.
“Khazad-dûm?” Nori asked as his brain caught up to the moment, his eyes trained on the sitting form of Ori even through the thief’s persisting brain fog, courtesy of his concussion. His leg bounced up and down under the dining table, worn leather boot making a repeated squeaking noise as it lifted off the floor in a pattern. “A suicide mission, why?”
“To reclaim her halls for good,” Balin answered diplomatically, stating his motivations loud and clear. He had always been great at de-escalating any situation before the Company came to the wrong conclusions, a mediator to the core. “It is nae a thing to worry over—the plan is trusty. We have poured many long evenings into it.” His hands came to rest at his sides, making him look stiff like a wooden statue. “And nae a suicide mission either, as we intend to live. We’ll leave come morning light.”
From his spot at the table, Bilbo glanced at Thorin. The dwarven king looked calm, having known the revelation that Balin had to share, but the minimal shadow of a frown line next to his mouth spoke of an unvoiced dissatisfaction anyway. The hobbit could relate to it. He didn’t like the ring of ‘Moria’ or Khazad-dûm for that matter, not with how he knew the place was practically a death trap.
But it is also more than that to them, Bilbo remembered a talk with Dwalin from a winter months since passed. The hobbit should’ve known this was coming. Maybe he did, and it just wasn’t an easy thing to accept. (A parting, that was what it was.)
He didn’t have to dwell on the thought for long as Nori slammed a fist against the dining table, rattling the entirety of the furniture piece. The thief’s voice was teeming with concern or anger, maybe both at the same time. “And then why’s Ori going too? Y’know, to the black pit?”
“Better have a bloody good reason,” Dori added, his sharp, pale eyes fixed to stare at the wisest dwarf of the bunch. “You are a dwarf I respect, Master Balin. Reclaiming Khazad-dûm, respect is all I can have for you, but tell me why my cousin is being dragged into this. Was him risking his life for this mountain not enough of a service?”
It was an accusation. Accusations never went down well with the dwarves.
Balin’s mouth opened to answer, but it was Ori who spoke instead. “Stop it.” The young dwarf stood up to look at his cousins properly. “Use your brains, cousins. Master Balin did not order for me to come along. I volunteered.”
That wasn’t what the rest of the Company had expected to hear, not with Ori always having been so timid and unassuming and one of the youngest in the group. However, with his back turned to most of the dwarves and his posture prouder than usual, the scribe looked taller than he had before.
The apples of Ori’s cheeks only turned a slightly darker shade of red in the dark as he addressed the whole group. “Truth be it, I approached Master Balin about Moria all the way back at the Misty Mountains. We had our deadline approaching, but he assured me he was still working toward the reclamation of the dwarrowdelf. I want to see it reclaimed.”
It was Bombur who spoke next. “Ya aren’t just doing this for the library, right?” he questioned, sounding a bit like he did with his kids. “Scriptures aren’t worth a death sentence.”
Ori shook his head. “If Master Óin and Master Dwalin have deemed the mission feasible, I want to be brave like them. I need to be brave like them, how else will we get back the dwarrowdelf?” He inhaled deeply, his chestnut eyes staring somewhere far away. “When I joined the Company to take back this mountain, it was not because I felt courageous enough to join a quest that dangerous. It was not because I knew this mountain like my heart, because I did not. But Dori and Nori did.” His gaze landed on his cousins, who were listening attentively. “Erebor was home to you two, even if I was too young to really know that. I never knew these halls, but I knew I wanted to be there when you two got them back. And now Moria... maybe I can give someone else their home back, too. All of dwarfkind.”
In the quiet acceptance that followed, Dori slowly stood up to walk in front of the scribe. A second passed. Then two. And then the silver dwarf hugged the younger one close, despite the protest his injured shoulder must have given him. Face buried in crocheted fabric, Dori looked shrunken against his young cousin. “...You’ve grown up,” he muttered. “When did you grow up so much?”
“Let us come on the quest with you,” Nori offered almost immediately, a shine to his eyes. It was a strange thing to witness the two brothers not bicker endlessly but instead get along for once. They never did that.
Still, Nori didn’t even get to stand up before Ori was shaking his head again. “No,” the scribe rejected the offer gently, letting go of his oldest cousin at the same time. “You two are still injured, it would not be wise for you to come along. I need you to look after each other. Besides, I have great warriors fighting at my side and Master Balin is a leader I wholly place my faith in. We will triumph.”
Balin piped in with an empathetic smile on his lips. “Ori’s safety is our highest priority, ye have me word.”
“Keep it,” was Nori’s reply. The thief looked unhappy at the turn of the situation, like his pint of beer had turned too pissy-tasting. “Or I’ll come hunt you down myself.”
“Aye, I shall keep that in mind.”
Dwalin grunted something in between the gaps of the conversation, brawny arms crossed over his chest, looking taller than everyone else in the room. “...Daín’s soldiers have agreed to join the quest. They will be of help.”
At that, the king’s advisors at the back of the room nodded their heads and murmured amongst themselves. They’d been so quiet, one could’ve assumed they had left the room at some point.
“But you could still be gone for years,” Bilbo blurted, the full gravity of the situation hitting him. He imagined the caves of Moria and felt the itch to scratch at the skin under his jaw, mind reeling at pictures of Balin’s group getting lost in the caverns and tunnels, injured when fighting orcs. Or worse.
“Years, months...” the white dwarf acknowledged and adjusted the eyepatch on his face. “Time is but a small sacrifice for the reclamation of the dwarrowdelf.”
The voice of Thorin interrupted, “But don’t sacrifice your lives. I expect raven mail from the Lord of Moria, in which he tells me of a reclamation gone well. That is an order.”
Balin bowed his head. “As me King requests.” Beside him, Dwalin nodded as well.
The next dwarf to voice his thoughts was Glóin, who’d allowed the others to get their concerns out first. He addressed his words to Balin and Óin alike. “Would a warrior more be fit fer yer quest?”
“THE PLAN BE SET IN STONE. ‘TWAS NAY EASY THING TAE MAKE.”
“Better odds with un more, ye ken or ye deaf, mate?!”
“NAE A CHECKMATE YET.” Óin fixed his ear trumpet some. “DAÍN’S SOLDIERS BE THERE TAE FILL YER ROLE. JUST TAKE CARE O’ THE WEE LAD AND THE WIFE.”
With a surprising lack of fire, Glóin backed down at the mention of his child and wife almost immediately, though the regret on his face didn’t budge anywhere. His eyes darted around a couple of times before landing back on his older brother, and it seemed that whatever he saw on his older brother’s shadowed face was the bullseye he’d been aiming for. He held a fist up to bump it against Óin. “...Then from un warrior tae another.”
“FROM UN TAE ANOTHER.” And a returned bump.
“And I don’t suppose you need a burglar for this quest?” Bilbo asked.
Ori, Balin, Dwalin and Óin all exclaimed at the same time.
“There is no need!” — “A thousand times nay.” — “No.” — “HA?!”
The hobbit deflated instantaneously.
Crow’s feet appeared beside Balin’s eyes, the patched and unpatched one. He took a few steps forward to be in front of the hobbit. “Ye just got married, laddie. Ye enjoy that, and we expect ye to take care of Thorin. A brash one he is, as ye know.”
The mentioned king scoffed. “Well, I have a kingdom to run.”
“Ye’ve been the same way since ye were but a pebble.” Balin looked up at his king with a knowing look. The smile on his face was reminiscing. “Always giving me a headache. Take care of him, Bilbo.”
The hobbit reluctantly nodded. “...Alright. I’ll be waiting for that letter too.”
“Aye, laddie.”
The group of dwarves leaving for the quest was thus agreed upon, Balin leading part of the Company and soldiers from the Iron Hills to the dark depths of Moria, a maze of tunnels where nobody had ventured to and survived in ages. The oldest tales, passed around in writings and stories, claimed that an ancient evil resided in the pit of the labyrinth. What kind of evil? Nobody was quite sure. No one had lived to tell the tale in full.
To show their respect for the parting group, the house of Ur lifted their arms in salute.
“Free the dwarrowdelf, mates,” Bifur spoke unexpectedly. “Give those orcs a taste of what we dwarves are made of.”
The rare spoken words in Westron from him stunned the Company into silence for a moment—since when did the dwarf speak so coherently? The silence was broken when Bofur looked to Thorin before speaking a request. “What says our king to a song in honour of those leaving, eh?”
“With haste,” the dwarven king accepted. “I know of one for the occasion.”
At the far end of the dining table, Kíli glanced at Fíli. “I’ll get our violins,” the younger prince said before hurrying outside the hall. Bilbo watched as the rest of the dwarves retrieved their own instruments, a harp for Thorin and flutes for those in the house of Ur. In the deep blue of the dining hall at night, lit only by candles, the hobbit thought he could hum along this once.
He thought of a night in Bag End, the night before the quest had started and the dwarves had sung in front of his fireplace.
It seemed like great quests always began with a song.
The song that they picked now was a melancholy one, and it went as such...
“ By Fanuidhol and Celebdil
By Caradhras and Mirrormere
There lay in caverns Durin’s tomb
In Moria, in Khazad–dûm
Ere the Sun was forged and lit
Ere the skies were smelt and split
When Mahal shaped yore caves of dark
The dwarrowdelf His hammer’s mark
Where rest our gold and mithril heaps
Their tales we sing as Durin sleeps
The earth is grey, the mountains old
The forge’s fire is ashen–cold
No harp is wrung, no hammer falls
The darkness dwells in Durin’s halls
The shadow lies upon His tomb
In Moria, in Khazad–dûm
But still the sunken stars appear
In dark and windless Mirrormere
There lies His crown in water deep
Till Durin wakes again from sleep “
“We will meet again,” said Balin, his features glossed over with an unnamed emotion. Behind him, Ori, Dwalin and Óin hoisted their bags onto their ponies, all saddled up and ready to go. “This is nae goodbye.”
“Take care of yourself,” replied Thorin, standing in front of the rest of the Company, Bilbo at his side. The dwarven king clutched the white dwarf’s hand before he bumped the sides of their heads together.
Balin smiled, and in the curve of his mouth was held a promise—the promise that they would survive, that the white dwarf would be back one day to say ‘I told ye so’. But instead of saying that, he pat the king on his shoulder and whispered, “Aye, laddie.”
Outside of the mountain, the Sun would soon rise.
Save for the birdsong of an approaching summer, the ramparts were devoid of signs of life. Moss clung to the cracks in the stone, pillowing the walls with soft green. The hobbit leaned his arms against them, letting his face droop into moss and pumice. They would probably leave an imprint onto his cheek.
He hadn’t slept. Between the break of dawn and the moment he’d decided to go outside for some fresh air, at least four rings of the bells had gone on by and yet the hobbit hadn’t gotten a wink of sleep. It hadn’t come to him when he’d gone to lay in his bed, snuggling up to his blanket that no longer smelled of oakwood and smoke. He’d even considered seeking Thorin out at some point, but ultimately settled against it. They both liked their own space at times, even if the dwarven king—God forbid, his husband—was often very clingy.
An idea sneaked its way into Bilbo’s mind, one in which he’d wait until evening and then seek Thorin to ask him to make some space on his king-sized bed. Actually, Bilbo was sure he’d be moving to the king’s quarters soon, whether he approached Thorin about it or not. It was a miracle it hadn’t happened yet. A miracle or a curse.
Get a hobbit and a dwarf into the same bed and watch them fumble the rest of the way through the night. Honestly, Bilbo was quite excited at the thought of having Thorin all to himself. Some eve soon, he promised himself.
Anyway. Speaking of types of clingy, Kolya was back at the hobbit’s side. He’d appeared sometime between dawn and morning, sitting outside of Bilbo’s room with a sword at his hip and his helmet in his lap. The hobbit had already tried to dismiss him more than once. Even though the dwarf was good company, Bilbo couldn’t help but feel bad that Kolya’s days went into following after his every whim.
“I appreciate the offer, Your Highness,” the young guard had said with an even tone (and it still felt weird to Bilbo to be referred to as such now), standing up and putting his helmet back on. “However, I take my duty as your guard seriously. You’ve slipped by me one too many times already, and I cannot allow for that. Yesterday was... an exception, ordered by the King’s company.” He had said the last part with a bit more finesse and Bilbo, mortified, was left to ponder upon just how many dwarves thought he and Thorin had spent their wedding night getting... rowdy? What the hell, sure.
Bilbo had sighed. “I feel bad, making you run around instead of spending time with your family. How’s your lass anyway? Would the Guard fire you if I told you to just spend your time with her instead of little old me?”
Kolya did look sympathetic then. “She is well, thank you. The due date is approaching in June.” He had breathed in as if to pause himself before answering the second part. “And no, the Guard would not fire me as I’m one of the head guards now, but my resolve hasn’t changed with the development either way. This is the job I signed up for and I’m proud of it. My wife has no objections either.”
The words meant that Kolya had known about the arrangement with Dwalin leaving for Moria. They must have planned the shifting of duties accordingly. Bilbo had wondered if Thorin had a new assigned bodyguard, or if the luxury of one was only forced upon the hobbit. There were “privileges” that came with being seen as unable to defend yourself. It was ridiculous, because all the dwarves knew Bilbo was more than capable of knocking himself out on a rock while invisible and sleeping through most of the action (Hey! Mean!).
Whatever the case was, Kolya had at least learned of Bilbo’s preferences by then—the young guard kept his distance where he could and Bilbo only really noticed his presence as they would move around and chat. He did appreciate the soft-spoken guard’s ability to hold a conversation.
Right now, it was just Bilbo, the cold stone of the ramparts under his feet and the moss against his cheek.
“Hello Bilbo.”
Oh, and Gandalf was there too, apparently. If he wasn’t hallucinating the wizard’s voice, which was possible with his lack of sleep.
The hobbit groaned as he lifted his head to look at the wizard, who did not look even a tad different than the last time Bilbo had seen him in what felt like months ago. Gandalf was still all imposing greys and crooked hats with fraying edges and wrinkled faces getting hidden by beard and hair.
“Gandalf,” Bilbo greeted back, surprise slowly making way into his voice. He tried to blink grogginess from his eyes but only succeeded in making the world even blurrier. “It’s really you? You’ve returned to Erebor so soon? What brings you here?”
The wizard smiled, adjusting his robes. “I would like to say ‘old friends’, but that would not be the wholly truthful answer,” he conceded. “It was in my hopes to reach this mountain before your friends parted for Moria. Regretfully, it seems I’ve arrived too late.”
The sentiment surprised the hobbit. “You knew they were leaving for Moria?”
“Naturally.” The wizard turned his attention to the lands around the mountain. “The plan was mentioned to the council and we deemed it feasible. Matters arose, which called for my return to your mountain. That reminds me, Lord Elrond sends his regards and a gift for your engagement.” He reached deep into the pockets of his gown and pulled out a neatly folded cloth, made of nearly translucent fiber. “It is an undershirt. He said it would keep you cool during the summer but warm during winter. I do not know how it works exactly, forgive me.”
The wizard handed Bilbo the gift and the hobbit looked at it with awe. “It’s insanely beautiful,” the hobbit said, before a thought hit him. “Hold on– he knew of the engagement? Has the news spread that fast?”
Gandalf chuckled, a deep sound. “No, but he made an educated guess. It is true then, my friend?”
The hobbit turned red. Lord Elrond had met him once in Rivendell, almost a year ago in passing, and deduced that the hobbit and the dwarven king would eventually end up making out under an awning? The thought was horrifying. Who else had made the same deductions? Radagast? Beorn? The trolls under the Misty Mountains?
“...It is true,” the hobbit said through gritted teeth, still going over the revelation. “We got married a few nights ago.”
Gandalf smiled. “Be merry. I have seen few courtships between dwarves and hobbits in my years, but the few that there have been have always been strong. It is believed that the Green Lady and the Great Smith have made it so.”
With those words, Bilbo’s mind suddenly reminded him of words pronounced at his wedding officiation. Ones that had made him feel uneasy, ones that had planted a seed of doubt in his mind. His mood soured even further.
‘And may it last for many ages, from life till death, till reunition in the halls of Mahal after.’
The hobbit shifted his braids beside his ears and lowered his head in thought. He wasn’t religious enough to know answers to the question brewing in his mind, but not faithless enough to feel unbothered by it arising in his head. That put him between a rock and a hard place.
The wizard by his side immediately recognised his newfound troubled mind. “What ails you?” he asked gently, moving closer.
“I don’t know, Gandalf,” the hobbit admitted. “I don’t really want to think about it.”
“Well don’t think about it, talk about it.”
“I don’t really want to talk about it.”
“I’d recommend you do.”
Bilbo’s lips drew back in a taut line, his tail flicked back and forth slightly. He chewed on the question before he said it aloud. “Well then, you might think it an odd question, but... do you know if when Thorin and I pass, we will go to separate places?”
The question clearly took the wizard aback. He didn’t answer immediately, instead turning his head to look at the distant horizon and the few blackbirds flying against the blue sky like ink stains on a tapestry. “Questions about the afterlife,” Gandalf finally started, “...I cannot tell you for sure. I am only a wizard, not a guide.” After a moment of silence, the wizard lifted his staff and waved it in the air. Bilbo couldn’t see whatever magic it was that Gandalf was making, as it was invisible to the hobbit’s eye. However, looking far into the horizon, the wizard said, “Why don’t you seek the Valië you pray to for advice?”
The hobbit huffed. “How would I do that? I’m not even sure She listens to my prayers, rare as they are. And I’m not the greatest at making offerings. I don’t even practice any faith most of the time.”
Gandalf looked at him with wise eyes, the universe swirling somewhere beneath his irises. He looked ancient. “Oh, but Bilbo, it isn’t the offerings that matter.” He put his staff down. “It is the heart. You should seek Her out with your heart.”
“I suppose you’d have the confidence to say that. You know, being a wizard and all. I bet the Valar talk to you all the time.”
“Time is a manmade concept, my dear friend. It might have been a day since I last spoke to the deities, or it might have been an Age. Time, as a label, doesn’t apply in this case.”
A tired smile pulled at Bilbo’s lips. “You surely always speak in riddles.”
“Not riddles. I am only an old wizard in a funny hat.”
“A funny hat and an even funnier gown.”
“Preposterous. I shan’t allow this bigoted kind of insult on my character.”
Someone would’ve wondered how, but the two settled into a comfortable silence after that. Bilbo tapped his fingers against the green moss, eventually spotting the unusual lichen in the mix. He did suppose they were quite far up North. He hadn’t spotted any reindeer though.
He was glad to see Gandalf alright. The last time they had talked, Bilbo had felt in his gut that somethings were still awry and the wizard was roped into them. Truth be told, he still had that feeling, but he couldn’t name it.
After his gaze had passed over the landscape, Gandalf turned to speak to the hobbit once more. “...I did actually have something to ask of you. It is part of why I came here to the Lonely Mountain.” Bilbo hummed a noise to show that he was listening and thus Gandalf continued. “Do you remember passing the Misty Mountains after that heavy rainfall? How your Company thought you lost in the caves, in the auburn forest?”
And suddenly Bilbo knew where the wizard was going.
“There was something you were keeping from us.” Gandalf looked at the hobbit and his expression was ablaze with white-hot flames. They flicked at Bilbo. “A magic ring. Where do you keep it?”
Bilbo felt as if the ground under him had been pulled out, like there was only a void underneath his feet that threatened to swallow him whole. He opened and closed his mouth but no words came out, as if someone had tied a string around his tongue. He could hear a voice in his mind telling him keep it secret, keep it secret, keep it secret. It’s in the nightstand. Keep it secret.
Gandalf looked at him for a very long moment. His eyes were knowing.
“I am not here to take it away,” he said, pityingly. Bilbo hated feeling himself relax some at the wizard’s words. “I only ask you not to wear it anymore.”
“I– I wasn’t planning to.” The hobbit bit his cheek.
“Good,” Gandalf said and pat the hobbit on his back. He sighed deeply, taking his hat off before looking at Bilbo with much more tiredness than before. “I want to say this as your friend, Bilbo. There will come a day when you need to pass the ring along to me. It is an evil artefact. It needs to be destroyed as such.”
An ugly possessive feeling grew in Bilbo’s heart, but he fought against it. Gandalf was his friend. “I know that already,” he bit out.
The wizard nodded. “Until that day comes, keep it hidden. I trust you have found a place.” The way in which he said it made the hobbit think Gandalf knew the ring was in his nightstand. That’s creepy.
Bilbo didn’t respond. He physically couldn’t.
Gandalf didn’t seem to find that a problem. “Then I shall be off. The council agreed unanimously that I should head south to Gondor. There are humans for me to meet.”
“Travel safely. Don’t mingle around danger for too long,” the hobbit managed.
“Fear not. No vile force shall take me down so easily.”
“Well, Lady Galadriel might but...”
“I beg your pardon?”
The two of them, the hobbit and the wizard, they couldn’t quite stop bickering. But that was just the way things had always been. It was a sign of everything being at peace.
And once Gandalf had walked off, bidding the hobbit farewell (“We will meet again, Bilbo. Do remember that.”), Bilbo had glanced once more over the landscape, going over the greens and the greys alike, because together they were the full picture.
The hobbit made a plan.
The first step was to find a way to contact Yavanna, maybe through a chapel or a shrine or with the flame of a lit candle. In truth, he still had to figure that part out. The second step he was sure of: ask Her about the afterlife. She was known for being the gentlest of the Valar, so the likelihood that she’d at least consider answering was pretty high. The third step... Bilbo wasn’t sure yet. It depended on what She revealed to him.
Worst case scenario, he received no answer to his prayers. Best case scenario, all the myths were true and a Valië could be reached via spoken prayer. The most realistic scenario? Bilbo would reach out, hear a voice in his head and have an epiphany. That way he would never know if it had been the Green Lady herself or if it had just been his brain. That seemed like it could very well happen.
He wasn’t even sure why the question bugged him so much. So what if Thorin and he wouldn’t be together in the afterlife? They still had decades to go before that would be relevant. He supposed it was his natural curiousity that made a big deal about it. If he didn’t get the answer now, it would keep bothering him until he was old and grey and looked like Gollum. Bilbo shuddered at the thought.
Walking through the mountain halls, the hobbit wondered if there was someone he could ask for more advice before making an attempt at contacting a Valië. He briefly considered Glóin, even Bofur and Kíli, however he figured they wouldn’t be able to help with the Green Lady too well. They were devoted to their own Vala and quite secular in their ways of faith.
Dori and Fíli seemed like reasonable candidates, but in the end something was drawing the hobbit to choose Bombur. Maybe it was the dwarf’s connection to food and family? He was quite similar to the hobbits in the Shire and Bilbo also knew that the dwarf had a pretty strong connection to his faith. Apparently having fourteen children meant fourteen naming ceremonies and those supposedly brought you closer to the Valar? (Who was Bilbo kidding, he didn’t understand the first thing about any of it.)
Therefore in the afternoon, the hobbit sought after Bombur in the dining halls but didn’t find him there. After searching the marketplace and the living quarters of the house of Ur, he eventually found the dwarf near a square. Bombur wasn’t alone—on one shoulder, he hoisted a small dwarf boy, and on the other was an older girl, probably a teen by dwarven standards. They looked alike with their father, ginger hair framing round faces with dark brown eyes.
The trio noticed the hobbit approaching and turned their attention to him.
“Master hobbit!” said the boy, Bumdur. Bilbo knew it had to be him, because Bombur only had one son, who was one of the youngest of the flock. The rest of the children were all daughters of varying ages.
The girl, Davura, scrunched her face at the sight of the hobbit and grabbed the hem of her tunic into her fists. She clearly had something against the hobbit. Bilbo had met her very few times before and always in passing, but the girl had always shown him varying levels of hostility. Bombur had once described her as “feisty” and it had definitely been an understatement.
“Atta girl,” said the ginger dwarf, letting his daughter down onto the mountain floor so she could stand, leaning herself on a cane. That was part of why Bilbo remembered her from the rest of Bombur’s identically red-haired family—Davura had been born with one leg shorter than the other and she used a cane to aid her walk. “Show some respect to the king consort, eh?” Bombur urged.
Davura turned her head away as if to further show disrespect, but she did speak a few words in acknowledgement of her father’s command. “Good afternoon, Your Highness.” The words were polite, but her tone was not.
Bombur sighed, moving his gaze away from his children onto Bilbo. “I’m sorry about this Bilbo, I think she’s still mad Thorin chose to marry someone from outside the mountain. She’s idolized him so.”
The hobbit bit down a smile, seeing the child’s petty jealousy for what it was. The girl was practically glowering at him, her face shadowed and broody like Thorin’s often was. Bilbo tucked his hands behind his back. “It’s all good. I hope with time, I can prove myself worthy of this honour. There is certainly some insight a person like me can bring to the table.”
Unprompted and completely out of the blue, Bumdur presented a question. “Will King Thorin and ya have kids some day?” he asked to the absolute mortification of both his father and his sister. They both shushed at the boy, visibly flustered.
“Me apologies. He’s at that age where he starts questioning things like that without thinking,” Bombur explained hastily, his forehead drenched with sweat. He was often red in the face, Bilbo had noticed that during the journey. “Just ignore him.”
The hobbit couldn’t help but laugh at the absurd but endearing question. He wiped at his eyes once the laughter had turned into humoured tears, the saltiness of them irritating his eyes. He faced Bumdur, who didn’t understand why his question had been met with such a reaction. Bilbo took in a breath before he said, “Who knows? Maybe we’ll adopt someday.”
It wasn’t the first time the thought had come to him. Bilbo had known pretty early on that he had no inclination for any of the lasses in the Shire, and while that wasn’t the norm, it wasn’t too frowned upon either. Hobbits cared more about taking care of your own, whatever form that took.
Bilbo had always assumed he’d grow up to be a bachelor, look after any young cousins he might still get, tend to his garden and eventually pass on after an uneventful but fulfilling life. He had been perfectly contented by that image he’d conjured of his future. He never imagined finding someone like Thorin, someone who made his heart beat a little quicker and his days a little more colourful. He didn’t know if it had been fate or sheer luck when the dwarven king appeared at his doorstep, expression sultry and an insult ready on his tongue.
They riled each other up. It was invigorating to have someone who matched you like so. He could see himself adopting a child, if that was something Thorin also wanted.
“Middle-Earth to Bilbo Baggins, yoohoo.”
The hobbit blinked. “Oh, sorry. I was imagining it—having kids– adopting, kids that is.”
Bombur arched an eyebrow, the expression on his round face wholly amused. “Right ya did, mate. Let me remind ya that kids are a whole lotta hassle and passle. Is that a word? Hustle and bustle.” Beside the dwarf, his two children started protesting at the insinuation that they were some kind of trouble. “Easy now,” Bombur soothed them. “That doesn’t mean I don’t love y’all to bits.”
That was enough to get Bumdur grinning, while Davura shook her head with a roll of the eyes. A smile betrayed her true feelings.
“I thank you for your words of advice,” Bilbo said. “I actually needed to ask for a couple more.”
“About making kids? Óin would know best, but I guess I am the second best option–”
“Not about that.” Bilbo coughed into his hand. He swore these dwarves would be the end of him. “Rather, I was wondering if you could help me with a question of faith?”
The widened eyes of Bombur meant that the inquiry surprised him. The dwarf scratched at his stubbled chin. “That might depend on the question, but hit me with it,” he said with a nod.
“I want to reach out to Yavanna. You know her as the wife to Mahal, but she is the deity we pray to in the Shire. I want to ask her a question, but I do not know how to get her to hear me.”
Bombur nodded along with the hobbit’s explanation, his eyes closed as he listened to each word. “It isn’t like the Valar have ever appeared to me,” he admitted, though he didn’t seem saddened by the fact. “I don’t know if they’ve appeared to anyone in recent ages. That is why so many are losing faith. But...” The dwarf looked to his children for help. “What do ya say kids? How should Master Bilbo go about it?”
Bumdur and Davura didn’t waste a second. “Make an offering! Like mam does sometimes!” the former beamed.
“Dunno. Write the prayer on a slip of parchment and burn it?” offered the other.
Satisfied with the answers, Bombur nodded along. Then he turned back to look Bilbo in the eyes. “Very practical suggestions,” he started, “I’d say... try what the kids suggested. But it needs to be at a place which is meaningful to ya, somewhere where ya feel connected to your faith. That is how we make offerings to Mahal and some of us dwarves do feel his presence—some similar form of prayer could work for ya.”
The hobbit breathed in deeply. Okay, so he might have had a chance at contacting a deity who hadn’t been known to appear to people in the current Age. He just needed a place, a piece of paper and an open heart. “Thank you Bombur, Bumdur, Davura. I feel a bit more confident.”
“Any time, mate. Didn’t take ya for the religious type.”
“I haven’t really been, but I see the good sides to practicing.”
The bells started to ring, seventeen times in total. Their sounds echoed off the mountain walls.
With a wave of the hand, the hobbit bid goodbye to the family after they’d talked for a moment longer. With Bilbo opening up about his worries and allowing himself to appear vulnerable to the bunch, even Davura seemed to re-evaluate her prejudices and forgive the hobbit for... being a hobbit, or the king consort of the mountain. She offered him a piece of fudge as an amendment.
Bilbo popped it into his mouth before he departed. It was a bit chewy, with chopped nuts and berries in it, but overall delicious.
The hobbit walked with brisk steps. He knew exactly where to go.
Let it be written down in history that in the year 2942 of the Third Age, the hobbit Bilbo Baggins made contact with a goddess. The details of the event would remain shrouded in mystery, but they did involve a piece of fudge and an apple tree. The chronicle got a bit incomplete with the details, only the connecting thread surviving: the hobbit couldn't tell which parts of his story were real and which parts weren't.
His recount started, as some stories would end, in a garden.
At the root of the apple tree, which was covered in white flowers and small, soft green buds, the hobbit rushed to write a prayer in ink. He allowed his letters to loop in a style of cursive he'd been taught in school. The prayer went as followed:
‘Yavanna Kementári, Giver of Fruit, Bearer of Life, I call upon you at the altar of an apple tree. It is a sign from my lover of devotion to me, and it is also my sign of devotion to you.’
Once he had written the prayer down, he procured a match from one of his pockets and watched as the match lit the parchment in a small, controlled fire. Soon the words were only ash flying away with the wind, their form vanishing but intent remaining.
His throat was tickling. He attributed it to the pollen which he could see floating in the sunlight, but it surprised him anyway. Most of the plants he was allergic to had already finished pollinating. He supposed some of the flowers in the flowerbeds that weren’t all budding yet could have been the cause.
Getting back to his mission, Bilbo crossed his fingers, kneeled down and closed his eyes, doing his best impression of a person who knew what they were doing. Remembering Gandalf’s advice, he tried to keep his heart open, but it felt difficult to do with how tightly he'd learned to guard it. It felt like every wall he tore down from it revealed three more and they were getting harder to break with each demolition.
Only Thorin had successfully made it through most of the walls, but even he had a few remaining in the way.
Still, Bilbo tried.
Yavanna Kementári, he spoke in his mind. Please, answer my prayer.
He allowed a long moment to go by. The world grew a bit quieter. The leaves of the apple tree rustled in the slight breeze. And then...
Nothing.
Eventually, Bilbo opened his eyes and the Green Lady was nowhere to be seen. He sighed. It was worth a shot, his mind tried to consolidate, but he couldn't help the hurt spreading in his heart.
The itch in his throat was getting worse. He tried swallowing repeatedly to mend it, but it proved futile. It was thwarting his focus terribly, keeping him from standing up or trying again. Worse yet, his skin was breaking out in a rash. It was getting difficult to breathe.
With a harrowing realisation, he wondered if he was having a proper allergic reaction, but to what? The fudge? As far as he knew, he shouldn't have been allergic to any food ingredient, at least not seriously. To look for an explanation, he searched his memories. He came across one. When he'd been a young faunt, he remembered his mother taking away a batch of cookies from him because they'd had a type of groundnut in them that only grew far in the East. Was he allergic to those? He couldn’t remember ever having tried one.
...Furthermore, this wasn't the way he was going to die, was it? He’d survived orc attacks and trolls and a murderous, cave-lurking creature lunging at him, only to be beaten by a piece of fudge of all things. This had to be a new low for him.
Bilbo tried to get up and shout for help, but his throat was closed up and his tongue was swollen and he couldn't make a sound any longer. He clawed at the bark of the apple tree, gasping for breath, his vision starting to swim. He felt helpless and completely, utterly terrified.
That was when it happened.
Like the warmth of the Sun on his back on a summer day, or the brush of the wind on his arm, he could feel a presence just behind himself.
“Breathe,” said a voice, singsongy and deep, and suddenly the air was making way into his lungs again, unobstructing his throat. He gasped and heaved for oxygen as if he'd been drowning, as if he’d been thrown into a lake with boulders tied to his ankles.
Once he was able to compose himself a bit and look back, he saw the strangest sight. It was a hobbit, but not a hobbit. She was only there as an illusion, as wind moving through the garden—Yavanna Kementári, an unknowable entity from an unknowable land.
“Am I dead?” was the first thing Bilbo asked, understandably. The entire scene that was unfolding in front of his eyes didn't make any sense to him. Maybe the fudge had taken him out after all and this was his way of finding out about what came after your last breath.
The wind chuckled. “It is not time for that yet.”
“...Then, are you really here?” He couldn't believe his eyes or his ears.
The wind picked up. “I am always here.” It ran through the grass and the stems of budding flowers. “I am in the birdsong.” A yellow-blue great tit sang somewhere in the sky. “I am in the vines that grow.” They drooped down from the ceiling, bountiful with fruit. “I am in all that is green and overlooked.”
All in all, the garden seemed lusher with life than just moments before. The blades of grass were softer under Bilbo’s feet, the flowers blooming as colourful little dots all around and the air smelled faintly of sweet petrichor. The most remarkable thing of all, though, was the apple tree, from which the white flowers had turned into red fruit, bright among the leaves and branches like stars in a night sky.
The hobbit stared in awe, both at the garden and the form of another hobbit he could barely discern. “You...” he started, then paused. If Yavanna was a Valië, could She read his mind? Did She know the purpose for which he had called upon Her?
The rush of the wind slowed down ever the slightest. “You have questions,” it said. “I have answers.”
That was certainly some kind of confirmation for Bilbo’s guesses. His mouth stammered to find the right words, to present the questions he had prepared. His voice stammered as he spoke, his brain feeling mushy, “You, um, well you are a hobbit? Or, err, you take on the shape of a hobbit? But your husband—Mahal, he takes on the shape of a dwarf, right?” Off to a great start, Bilbo.
Yavanna’s head seemed to tilt, a smile playing upon Her lips. “Like you and your dwarf, little one.”
Okay, so this hobbit and dwarf thing could really work after all. Bilbo breathed in and considered how best to formulate his next question. He didn’t want to appear disrespectful of the Valië’s time. “Well, I...” he inhaled, “I was wondering about what happens after death. If Thorin and I will pass onto different lands, and if so, what it would, what it... No, I don’t even know if it would matter. This must be the most irrelevant question I could ask—Gosh, and I’ve been granted the opportunity? I’m so stupid.” The last thought was emphasised by the fact that he was rambling on.
“Curiousity was one of the first traits Ilúvatar gave the elves and men of His creation. It is the greatest gift He gave you,” Yavanna stated as if it was obvious.
“...Yet we don’t get all the answers we crave,” Bilbo rebutted. He looked down, knowing it was useless to chastise a figure much more powerful than himself.
“There is mercy in not knowing everything,” the wind whispered back.
“What if I want to know?” the hobbit asked, looking to the wind for answers. “I want to know—the good, the bad, the ugly. I don’t want it to be a mystery I have to dread for the rest of my life, never knowing where I am heading.” He knew he was pleading at that point and he couldn’t find it in himself to feel ashamed.
Yavanna looked at him with kind eyes, neither pitying nor resenting. “Is that your wish?”
Bilbo nodded. “I want to know.”
Like the currents of a sea, the wind seemed to sway as it came up with an answer. Yavanna stepped around Bilbo and held a hand up to the trunk of the apple tree, feeling the bark of it under Her palm. She said, “Aulë is the one who built me my garden in Valinor. He made the meadows so that I could lay down in them, so that the grass would run more green. He planted flowerbeds so that I could water them, so that the flowers would bloom brighter. Each day, he kisses my fingertips so that there can be more love in everything I create.” She turned her head back to look at the hobbit. “And at the end of the day, he returns to his halls while I stay in my meadows. Does that answer your question?”
That was the answer.
Their afterlives would probably be separate. In truth, Bilbo had assumed so, but hearing it said out loud made him feel... he didn’t know what he felt. What was he supposed to do with the information? Anguish seemed like the appropriate reaction to a revelation of the scale, but the hobbit just felt emotionless. How would Thorin react if he found out?
The hobbit must have looked desolate, because the wind picked up once more.
“Do not overthink it, little one,” She comforted, letting Her voice caress the air around the hobbit. “Life isn’t only about the beginnings and the ends.”
And then, as if to plant a kiss on his nose, the wind rustled past the hobbit’s face and he felt woozy again. The tickle returned to his throat, although it had dampened like a campfire doused with water.
“Wait!” he called out for the Valië, but her form had already vanished from sight.
This time when the hobbit’s vision began swimming, he could feel his consciousness slipping away fully. And then, without further delay, the world escaped his vision and went black.
“...o...Bi...bo...Bilbo!”
The hobbit tried to open his eyes against orange and purple light, blurriness greeting him. The first thing he registered was that his entire body felt laden with sleep and there was something warm against the back of his neck. A hand, he realised. When he blinked a few times, he could make out dark hair and a face twisted with worry, blue eyes looking right at him.
“...Thorin...” he mumbled, eyes trying to fall closed again. He felt drowsy, but also ecstatic to see the dwarf. It was a very confusing mélange of feelings that were familiar to him on their own but not really as a mix. All he knew was that 1. Thorin looked really, really handsome under the dimming light of a sunset and 2. The world looked swirly.
The dwarven king muttered something in khuzdul, his voice overwhelmed with emotion. “Bilbo– Hey! Don’t close your eyes!” Thorin said, and it was the desperation in his tone that forced the hobbit to comply. Bilbo groaned, letting the world come fully into view.
They were still in the garden—still? Bilbo knew he had been in the garden, but he couldn’t immediately remember what for. His eyes glossed over small flowers and green grass, finally landing back on Thorin. The dwarven king was kneeled down, supporting the hobbit’s body, which would have otherwise been glued to the ground.
Thorin’s gaze flitted from the hobbit’s face over his body, a deep furrow between his eyebrows. “What happened to you?” the dwarf asked, looking at Bilbo with equal parts concern and relief. Bilbo focused on his eyes and on the scar going over the dwarf’s eyebrow, never-changing and pale. “Do you feel ill? Do you need me to call a healer?” Thorin asked, trying to figure out what was wrong.
With a deep exhale, the hobbit lifted a hand to cup the dwarf’s cheek, watching the blush blossoming there. “Thorin,” he mumbled, swiping his thumb over a cheekbone. “Lean down a little, will you?”
The dwarven king tilted his head in question but obliged anyway. As soon as his head was lowered, Bilbo reached up to place a kiss on the furrow between his eyebrows. “Gotcha,” the hobbit grinned lopsidedly.
Surprise passed over the king’s features, smoothing the furrow, and he was without retort for a moment. After a few heartbeats, he huffed and asked, “What is going on with you?”
“Fine. Ate some fudge,” the hobbit answered nondescriptly, placing another kiss onto Thorin’s cheek, then his jaw. His entire body felt overtly warm. “I missed you. I talked with a Valië, you know?”
“...You haven’t eaten any strange mushrooms, have you?” Thorin asked, but his voice was too breathy—affected—from the soft press of Bilbo’s lips against his neck. “Slow down there, amralimê,” he quipped, pushing a hand down to feel the hobbit’s forehead for signs of fever. “You don’t feel feverish, but... are you sure you are feeling alright?”
“Tip-top.” This was accentuated with a nudge of his head into Thorin’s hand and a small kiss on the inside of his palm. His tail curled around one of the dwarf’s legs, his hand reached for strands of dark hair.
Thorin’s face was too concerned for Bilbo’s liking. “That’s it, I’m having someone look you over,” the dwarf said.
“You can look me over.”
“Bilbo.”
“What? I would like that,” the hobbit pouted as he was pulled to piggyback on Thorin, the dwarf starting to carry him out of the garden. Bilbo placed his head onto the dwarven king’s shoulder. “...I was thinking I should move into your quarters.”
“Is that so?” was all Thorin said in return, but Bilbo could see his ears turn red. He found it adorable.
“Mm.” The hobbit nuzzled in closer, before whispering, “I want to kiss you.”
He felt the slight stumble in Thorin’s steps and smiled. However, the dwarf did remarkably well in not taking the bait. “We’ll see to that once you’re a bit more like yourself,” Thorin replied.
“Bore.”
“You would do the same for me. You have done the same for me.”
Bilbo supposed that was true, but for the moment he was too loopy to think straight. There was something he wanted to tell the dwarf. “Thorin,” he said and waited for the dwarf to respond.
“What is it?”
“I really think I talked to a Valië. She was the wind, you know? Or I think she was the wind. We had a conversation and...” his words drifted off and he went silent. What was he telling Thorin? The dwarf would be crushed if he found out what Bilbo had learned.
“...And?” Thorin prompted gently. He didn’t sound like he particularly believed Bilbo’s tale, but he was giving the hobbit a chance either way.
Sighing, Bilbo reminded himself not to say too much. “Say,” he started quietly, “What do you want us to do? Now that we’re together, I mean...”
He felt Thorin lower his head at that. A long moment of silence passed, one during which they travelled quite the distance. In the end, Thorin didn’t need many words to get his feelings across. “Being with you is enough for me.”
“Even if we only have some decades left?”
“If it means getting to love you.”
Bilbo buried his face into Thorin’s hair, hiding the blush on his face. He felt flustered like a kid. He could feel the dwarf laugh and he heard his own heartbeat. “...Alright,” he finally said. “Just wanted to check.”
“Now let’s get the healer to check on you, Master ‘Strange Questions on Piggyback Tonight’.”
“Don’t you start with it...”
And with a beginning battle of unflattering nicknames, they finally reached the medical ward.
The final verdict was hallucinations caused by the oxygen deprivation from anaphylaxis, although it left many symptoms unexplained and also didn’t explain the hobbit’s miraculous recovery. Bilbo’s mind cleared within the hour and he had to apologise to Thorin for his odd behaviour. The dwarven king was completely understanding about it, which the hobbit was grateful for.
The whole fiasco left the hobbit unsure of what had gone down. Had he really made contact with Yavanna? It would remain a mystery, but he was sure she had played a part in him ending up just fine.
When the Company learned of the incident, they were quick to investigate its causes. It turned out that the groundnuts in the fudge had indeed been a rare species and that Davura had bought the treat from a merchant visiting the Lonely Mountain from the Iron Hills. The poor girl had been devastated to find out her gift of solidarity had almost cost the hobbit his life, but Bilbo had assured her he placed no blame on her. It had simply been a series of very unfortunate events.
For now, Bilbo took it easy. He and Thorin decided they’d move the hobbit into the king’s quarters the following day, so Bilbo got one more night of sleep in his own room. He tucked himself under a pile of blankets, turned his nightlight off and closed his eyes.
He made himself a promise that night, just before he fell asleep.
If there is one rule to obey, he thought, it is that you should never mess with groundnuts or the Valar.
Somewhere across the plain shores of former Esgaroth, a group of dwarves riding on ponies stopped for the night. They were already nearing the forest pathway of the elves, having made steady progress in just one day. If they could keep the pace, they could reach Moria before winter.
“Here,” said Dwalin, handing a quilt to Ori, who had just finished his bowl of dinner. “Óin is taking first watch. Get some sleep.”
While it was true that the lands were less infested by evil than they had been months before, that didn’t mean wolves and other predators couldn’t stumble the group’s way as they slept.
“Thank you,” the young scribe replied, accepting the quilt. He pulled it over himself, settling onto a nest of pine needles and soft earth. The other dwarves settled around him and it didn’t take long before Dwalin was snoring and Balin was coughing in his sleep.
Ori, sleep evading him, looked up at the night sky. There were constellations there, some which he could name and some which he couldn’t. It didn’t matter though. The stars were beautiful on their own. Someday, he thought, mind slowly drifting off to sleep. Someday, we’ll look up at the night sky and there will only be the stars and the Moon staring back at us, nothing to make us feel scared. We won’t have to fear orcs or trolls or evils we would never understand. And no matter what, this earth will always hold a home for those lacking one.
Ori had always been a dreamer and that was what made him so special. The world was always in need of those who dared to hope.
