Chapter Text
The hobbit did not stop begging to be killed. For a moment, when they finally managed to cut the charred clothing from his body and ease him into a well scrubbed tub of pure, cool water, it seemed his pain might be less. He stopped shrieking at least, but Thorin soon realized that was only because the little hero had passed into unconsciousness. Bilbo looked like a corpse floating there, his blood slowly coloring the water. The tub was solid gold, edged with pearls from the sea and precious stones. Vaguely, Thorin recalled it from his childhood. Once, the treasure had been in a private bathing chamber attached to a guest room for visiting royalty and other dignitaries. Cursing it for useless, Thorin ordered the others to find linens and a room small enough to sterilize. If Bilbo was losing blood in the bath, he could not stay there. They needed to wrap his burns in clean cloth and staunch the bleeding, but there was no fresh linen in the long abandoned mountain.
Dwarves made do. Thorin was proud of how quickly Balin was able to mix up a batch of bleach from chemicals left in the forges. Dori was a weaver by trade, and his brothers had lived with him long enough to be able to aid. They found old cloth somewhere. Before Thorin could do more than frown at the dusty, moth-eaten stuff, the brothers had it snow-white and mended into both sheets and bandages. Dwalin and Gloin searched their memories as well as the mountain and found a little guard room near the hoard. Scrubbing it from top to bottom with Balin’s help was the work of half an hour. That left Bifur and Bombur to find a bed, clean it, and make it ready for the soft mattress Dori, Nori, and Ori quickly produced.
While all of this was done, Thorin reserved the most important task for himself. Kneeling at the side of the tub, he kept his hands lightly on the back of the hobbit’s neck, holding Bilbo’s mouth above the water. Counting the burglar’s breaths, Thorin ensured that the little hero’s chest continued to rise and fall. That mattered more than anything else ever could.
In his long life, Thorin had seen far too many friends die from burns like the ones that now covered the hobbit from head to toe. The king wondered if Bilbo would be more upset by the loss of hair on his head or his once-furry feet. Then he wondered if any of it would grow back. Sometimes thick red scars took the place of hair. Thorin was painfully aware that Bilbo would never again cut the fine little figure of a hobbit who only ever read about suffering in books. If he lived, Thorin would find some way to make it up to him. Somehow.
Bilbo woke when they moved him to the bed. He did not speak. He screamed. Like a dying rabbit. The sound pierced Thorin like a morgul blade—a stab that wounded flesh, bone, heart, and spirit together. The king stood firm. Working together, the dwarves gently wrapped Bilbo in bandages and laid him upon the bed. Though they were careful in their work, it could not have taken more than a quarter of an hour. Yet his screams did not stop. As he lay upon the best bed his friends could offer, Bilbo continued to whimper, cry out, and sob in pain. And there was nothing any of them could do about it.
Surprisingly, Dwalin broke first. “You should go seek the Arkenstone,” he said.
Staring at his friend, Thorin wondered if the warrior was mad with grief. “You think of treasure at a time like this?”
Dwalin met his eyes, and Thorin saw the tell-tale shimmer of tears. “You should all go and search. I will remain here. Alone.”
Thorin’s sword arced through the air with no conscious thought. Had Dwalin’s own reflexes not been honed by long years of war, the king would have struck his head from his shoulders in an instant. Instead, sword met ax with a clang. “I will not let you harm him!” Thorin cried.
“He is harmed,” Dwalin said, weeping openly, not bothering to keep his ax up. “You know it as well as I do. Be it today or a week from now, these burns will kill him. The only question is how long his pain will last.”
In his heart, Thorin felt the truth of these words. How many dwarves died of lesser wounds as they fled Smaug all those years ago? The number was beyond count. Some had only taken the dragon fire on a shoulder or an unlucky foot. Even they were killed by infection and pain, though a fortunate few merely lost their damaged limbs. Amputation was not an option for Bilbo. Every last inch of the hobbit’s skin was burnt.
Closing his eyes, Thorin spoke. “While he yet breathes there is hope. As king I command that you leave him the chance.” Opening his eyes, he looked sharply at his company and saw how Bilbo’s pain oppressed them all. “Go now. Find the ravens if they have truly returned to the mountain. Send word to Dain and to my sister that Erebor is reclaimed from the dragon, but guarded by our company alone. Then, do what you can to shore up defenses. It may be that others witnessed the explosion which signaled Smaug’s end, and we cannot forget that Azog is hunting us still. I will tend to the hobbit until Oin comes.”
The dwarves bowed obediently and left to carry out Thorin’s will. One or two cast lingering looks at Bilbo’s bed, but most hurried away gratefully. Thorin did not blame them. Groaning in agony, Bilbo began to tremble as if chilled, shuddering convulsively. It was likely that Thorin would soon witness his death. At least the others would not have to.
Death did not come for Bilbo while Thorin maintained his vigil. A few times, Thorin was even able to help the hobbit to drink some water, though he was impotent to offer any other comfort. It seemed many long years passed this way before Oin came.
Oin’s arrival was like fresh air after a tunnel collapse. He bustled in with his potions and poultices, immediately pouring something down Bilbo’s throat that quieted the hobbit’s screams. Indeed, the draught sent him into peaceful sleep. Then the healer changed Bilbo’s bandages, soothing the raw burns with ointments and salves.
“Can you save him?” Thorin asked when Oin finished his work. For the first time since Smaug’s destruction, Bilbo slept deeply. That alone was a miracle.
“I cannot even keep him asleep,” Oin admitted unhappily. “Too many doses of poppy syrup and he will never wake. But he might surprise us and save himself. Balin says he has been like this for three days. A man would have died in the first hours. Even most dwarves could not last as long as he has.”
“He is strong.”
“Aye,” Oin agreed. “Hobbits have more iron in them than you notice at first glance.”
“Or perhaps we dwarves do not give credit enough to the toughness of tree roots and blackberry brambles.”
A ghost of a smile passed across the healer’s craggy face. “Perhaps we do not, Oakenshield.”
Thorin was started enough by this reply that his own lips twitched upward in response.
“When was the last time you ate or slept?”
Thorin’s spine stiffened.
“Three days, then,” Oin said, needing no confirmation. “I cannot tend him properly if I have to worry about my king as well. Go. Eat a meal. Sleep a little, if you can, but try for at least an hour.”
“Can you promise that he will not die while I am not here?”
“Aye,” Oin said, so steadily that Thorin’s heart leapt joyfully before the healer crushed it. “If he takes a turn, I'll have someone wake you. With burns like these, he won't go quietly.”
Nothing could be said in answer to such a prognosis, so the king obeyed. After eating a few fistfuls of cram, he slept for six hours. The worst part of this chore was that it really did make him feel better. Seeing Kili whole and hale even lifted his devastated heart a little. Before returning to Bilbo’s side, he took a second meal with his sister-sons, though guilt gnawed at him for not rushing back to the hobbit.
“It was Tauriel,” Kili explained urgently. “The captain of the Mirkwood guards, the one with red hair. She was chasing the orcs and found us instead. She cured me with her elf magic.”
“We would not be able to track her.” Fili spoke with the air of an often repeated argument. “Her woodcraft is too great. Honestly, after a full day’s head start, I am not even sure we would be able to track the orcs she was chasing.”
“No,” Thorin agreed. “Your point about the healing art of elves is well made, but I will not waste your time by sending you to bumble alone in the wilderness, searching for an elf maid that might already have gone home.”
Disappointment furrowed Kili’s brow, but Fili did not look pleased to have won the argument. Thorin’s heir looked only tired and sad, as they all were.
“Search the treasure,” Thorin ordered.
“The treasure?” his nephews chorused in surprise.
“The white gems of Lasgalen must be found without delay. Gloin and Balin both know them well and can advise you as to their appearance.” Offering no further explanation, he returned to Bilbo’s sickroom.
While the hobbit still whimpered and wept with pain and fever, having Oin there was a blessing. Thorin was no longer powerless. Instead, he played nursemaid. Helping Oin change bandages, feed Bilbo potions, apply poultices, and mix medicines sped the hours of waiting. If Bilbo did not get better, he did not seem to get worse either. Every hour that the hobbit lived encouraged Thorin. Every minute gave him greater hope.
There was always hope. After all, a gentlehobbit who preferred chestnuts to weaponry had slain a dragon. If that was not a blessing of fate, Thorin did not know what could be.
Some time passed before Kili came quietly to Bilbo’s sick room and reported that the necessary gems had been found. “And something else,” he said gravely. So Thorin and Oin followed him out to the treasure hoard.
Foreboding filled Thorin’s heart. Clearly, something particularly hazardous was uncovered. All the company gathered atop the hoard, solemnly awaiting him. They stood upon the shifting carpet of gold as though it was any other stone. There were better halls in Erebor, more fitting for such a meeting. Arraying here among the treasure was only necessary if the matter was urgent.
He could see Smaug’s curling tail in the distance, the dragon’s corpse still buried in gold and rubble. Something would have to be done about that soon. The gold of Erebor was cursed by that fell beast. Thorin was not the first to think it. Those searching treasure steeped in such malice could only have found some new danger. Straightening his spine, the king faced this next challenge unflinchingly. “What have you discovered?”
Stepping forward, Fili dropped to one knee. In his outstretched hands, the lad held the Arkenstone. “Your birthright, my king.”
The stone was just as he remembered it, large enough to fill his dreams for so many years. Shining with internal light, its every facet was perfectly polished; truly, it was the most beautiful gem ever to exist. Thorin barely heard his heir’s oath of loyalty as he took the stone and held it in both hands. One by one, each member of the company knelt before him, swearing fealty to him as king. Thorin found the words to accept them, for swearing in the light of the Arkenstone was a binding tradition, but his heart remained in the little sick room at his back.
“I thank you, all of you, for your service,” he said formally. “Dwalin, Fili, ready yourselves for a journey. I would send you with a platoon of guards, but that is not yet within my power. Instead, you must outfit yourselves as best you can with ancestral arms and armor. Take whatever suits your fancy, but mind that you can fight in it.”
“My King,” Balin said slowly, “Our strength to hold the mountain is not great. Even the loss of a single dwarf must change our strategy. If you would send a message, can we not use a raven? Or wait until your cousin Dain comes to support us before so doing?”
Looking to his oldest advisor, Thorin allowed some part of his immense sorrow to show upon his face. “I do not think it wise to wait, my friend. Outfit yourselves,” he ordered, then turned quickly back to Bilbo’s sickroom.
Oin did not follow, and so Thorin knew that the company remained to whisper behind his back. That did not matter. What he needed to do next did not require witnesses.
Setting the Arkenstone upon the hobbit’s chest made the little fellow shriek in pain, so Thorin quickly moved it to the pillow beside Bilbo’s head. Hopefully that would be close enough for any virtue the stone possessed to pass to the hero. Kneeling at the bedside, Thorin Oakenshield prayed in Khuzdul, the sacred language of his people. He prayed as he had not done since the Mountain was lost the first time, when so many dwarves were killed by burns just like Bilbo’s.
“Lord Mahal, you crafted the Fathers of the Dwarves from stone. I believe that it is within your power to repair us as a mason might heal a cracked statue. Accept my offering, I beg you. Take for yourself the Arkenstone, the most perfect of all jewels within my kingdom, and salve the wounds of the hero who saved it for your people. Please.”
Nothing happened. The Arkenstone glowed, and Bilbo whimpered, and nothing happened.
“Of course one jewel alone is not enough. I insult you by attempting to buy the work of your hands with so little, great lord. I do not mean to offer the Arkenstone only as itself, but as a representation for the vast treasure hoard of Thror, my grandfather. A whole mountain full of gold and gemstones shaped by generations of your people. Will you not take all of it in exchange for one life? Only save Bilbo, and take the treasure as your fee. Not a single member of our company will quibble over price, for all of us value his life above all things.”
Still Thorin’s prayer was not answered, and he felt hot tears spill down his cheeks.
“My life, then!” he cried. “My life for his! Full well did I know what retaking this mountain might cost. I was ready to die for it. I am ready to die for it! Only do not make him pay such a price. Do not make him pay for my dreams of glory when all he ever wanted was to see me safely home. Please. Please. Please.”
But the mighty Valar made no response, and Thorin was left alone to weep.
When Oin returned, Thorin rose from his knees. The old healer did not ask for explanations. The last time he’d treated burns like Bilbo’s there had been no beds, and loved ones had been forced to kneel in the dirt around filthy campsites, but that did not mean he failed to recognize the posture.
“Stay with him,” Thorin ordered. If his voice was hoarse and full of gravel, the half-deaf healer was unlikely to notice.
“Don’t think he’s up to playing, just now,” the elderly dwarf said, holding his horn to his ear.
Thorin looked at him and did not laugh.
“Aye,” Oin said seriously. “I’ll not leave his side.”
Nodding once, the king left the sickroom to do what was necessary. The moment he stepped out into the treasury, Kili came rushing over. Clearly the young dwarf was ready to interrupt Bilbo’s rest with his news. That he did not have to was the first piece of good luck since Oin’s arrival.
“An army approaches!”
Thorin felt a furious satisfaction settle in his gut. It would be good to kill something foul. An unlucky thirteen defenders might yet prove inauspicious for those who attacked. Erebor was a fortress, and could hold against a siege for a long time. Those who came would pay for the affront with many lives. “Azog.”
“Nay!” Kili’s face twisted. “We cannot be certain, but it looks like men from Laketown. Their numbers are small, only a few hundred. If they were alone, we could hold against them easily. For they are mostly fishermen with boat hooks, the sort Bard tried to offer us in lieu of swords.”
“But they are not alone?” Thorin raised an eyebrow.
“They are not. The elves of Mirkwood march alongside them. Ravens count their strength to be at least ten thousand.”
The satisfaction soured in Thorin’s belly and molten iron flared within his chest. He took a deep breath. “Then I must dress to greet our guests.”
By the time the armies reached the makeshift gate, Thorin wore full plate mail, shining like gold, and the Raven Crown perched upon his brow. All the dwarves of his company arrayed beside him behind their hastily constructed parapet, outfitted in the finest dwarven armor to be found.
Far below, he saw the elven army stop as one, regimented in perfect lines, unmoving as the pines, awaiting the word of their king. They carpeted his doorstep in numbers like to autumn leaves, their golden helms and shields shaped to put one in mind of a forest, but there the similarity ended. Nothing about them evinced the disorder of natural things. Next to them, the men from Laketown looked shabby indeed. No armor shone among their ranks. If they had any, it was only leather. A few bore hunting bows, but as Kili said, mostly they carried only boat hooks and similarly improvised weaponry. They were the scattered acorns, looking cracked and broken beside the orderly elven trees.
Three riders come forward. Bard he recognized at once. The smuggler who once aided their company at great risk to himself rode upon the back of a handsome brown mare. Thranduil was beside him, riding a great elk with his usual ostentation, but Thorin did not spit. Nor did he offer acknowledgement to the third rider, who was only an old man in gray rags astride a dappled stallion.
Bard spoke first. “Hail Thorin, King Under the Mountain! We heard the explosion from across the water and feared that Smaug yet lived. It is good to see you well.”
“Bard, descendant of Girion, Lord of Dale, wise were the words of caution which you spoke to me in Esgaroth. Indeed, the dragon was alive when we arrived. Yet we are in no danger now. The explosion you witnessed was that vile worm’s demise.”
Honest relief shone in the bargeman’s eyes, and he smiled easily up at Thorin. “Glad tidings are these, O King. When we thought the beast might have awoken, we rode out to face him rather than await his anger in our homes. You give us a great gift in removing his danger from our doorstep.”
Thorin judged the truth in these words, and he nodded once to Bofur. The tinker quickly cut a single rope, and at the base of the mountain a canvas fell away, revealing twelve great works of gold crafted at the height of Erebor’s wealth and skill.
“The bells of Dale.” Bard gasped. The towering bells were huge and heavy, each one as large as three men. By weight, it was enough gold to buy the whole of Laketown seven times over, but their worth was not in their weight. Clearly, Bard knew that.
“Smaug’s murders were only one of his many crimes,” Thorin said. “The despoiler stole much from your people when he robbed the dwarves of our homeland. Take these now with my promise that anything of Dale found within the treasure horde will be returned to you.”
The men who marched with him gave a great cheer, but Bard said nothing, staring at the bells in silence.
Thorin continued. “If you choose to settle again at the base of my mountain, Lord Bard of Dale will have the full support of Erebor to rebuild. For when we were lost and unwanted, you gave us aid, though it might have cost you dearly. When all others turned them aside, you gave my nephews medicine, shelter, and care. A dwarf does not forget his debts. I know what I owe to you, Bard. Be a bargeman no longer! Let us work together to rebuild all that was lost.”
“We will,” Bard said, finding his voice. When his eyes looked up at Thorin once more, they shone with a ferocity like dragonfire. “What was lost can be rebuilt. The future can be greater than the past.”
The cheers of the Men were deafening, full of hope and promise. Thorin knew that they were with him now, and would not attack even if Thranduil did. Though matters were yet too tenuous to rely on their aid in fighting the elves if there was a battle. Hopefully, such a time would not come. Despite the sanctimonious way the elven king clapped along, lightly tapping his hands together with a sneer, Thorin could not afford to antagonize him.
“Yes, well done,” he said snidely. “For a pittance the King Under the Mountain buys off the army at his gate. A bargain, I would call it. Have you a gift for me as well, to assuage my displeasure that you did not die in flames?”
“Perhaps, King Thranduil, my words when last we spoke were less diplomatic than they might have been,” Thorin said, nearly choking on the admission.
Smiling like a snake, the elf tilted his head to one side. “I am quite willing to entertain a material apology. Indeed, if the price is right, we might even go in peace. A few gems in exchange for the help my people gave to you in the Greenwood.”
“What help?” Thorin shouted. “What help have your people ever given to mine? What debt could I possibly owe to you? No, Thranduil, I owe you no debts and you will get no gifts from me! The gems of Lasgalen will not be handed over, except as fair payment.”
“Payment?” Thranduil hissed. “Do you imagine I will give gold for my own property when I know there are only thirteen dwarves between my army and my belongings?”
“Nevertheless, I will not hand them over freely,” Thorin said firmly, just barely bridling his temper. “One of our company faced Smaug in single combat. Though he slew the dragon, he was badly burned. He lives, but he suffers. The gems of Lasgalen I will give in exchange for his salvation. For my own healer says that such a thing is beyond his art.”
Far below, at Thranduil’s side, the old man dressed in gray spoke. “Who was it?” he asked softly.
Finally, Thorin turned to acknowledge Gandalf, for of course that is who the gray rider was. “One who had no business throwing his lot in with dwarves or facing dragons! One who would never have known fire beyond his own hearth and the lamplight used to read his books without your interference old man. Do not think I will forget that this is your fault! Did I not say I would not be responsible for his fate?” Tears pricked at the corners of Thorin’s eyes, but he once again mastered himself. Emotions had no place in a negotiation.
“Bilbo.” The wizard bowed his head for a brief moment, as though overcome by grief. Then he turned quickly to Thranduil. “Your majesty, I beg you, send a healer as Thorin requests. Mister Baggins is not a dwarf, but a hobbit. A halfling. He is no enemy of the Greenwood. Indeed, Elrond Half-Elven declared him an elf friend in Rivendell for his manners and learning. Please, show mercy.”
“We do not ask for charity or kindness,” Thorin said quickly. How well he knew that neither was in Thranduil’s heart! How many dwarves died of burns less severe than Bilbo’s while the healers of Mirkwood sat idly by? But it would be different this time. It had to be different. “I can pay this time. The gems of Lasgalen for the life of a single hobbit. Surely it is a fair price.”
Thranduil’s face changed, but Thorin could not read the elf’s remote expression. Still, he knew well enough that the king was weighing his options. In response, he felt his own face twist with wrath.
“If you try to buy them with blood, you will pay dearly, I promise you. Every dwarf in this mountain will sell his life for Bilbo’s revenge, and you will lose more than you can possibly imagine.”
“Peace.” Thranduil held up a single hand. “I will make this bargain, Thorin Oakenshield. Though your pride may yet refuse it. The elf on this field most familiar with dragon fire and most skilled at healing such burns is me. So I myself will see to your wounded companion, if you will welcome me into your mountain.”
From the utter relief on Gandalf’s face, Thorin judged this to be the truth. He did not want to owe Thranduil any kind of debt, but the gems of Lasgalen meant there was no risk of that. It did not matter who came to heal Bilbo, so long as it was the elf most suited to the task. “Be welcome then, King Thranduil. Erebor is open to you.”
Yet Thorin did not stay upon the wall to help Balin find a dignified way to allow a king entry into the mountain without destroying their defenses completely. Instead, he drew his sister’s sons aside.
“This is good,” Kili said, his eyes shining with hope. “If Tauriel could heal me, surely the King of the Elves can save Bilbo.”
“Or he will betray us,” Thorin said darkly. It was always a possibility when dealing with Thranduil. “The two of you must split the gems of Lasgalen evenly between you. Fili take the jewelry, and Kili, you take the unset stones. If Thranduil proves false you must flee the mountain and stay well away from the fighting. Go in separate directions, one to Dain in the Iron Hills and one back to the Blue Mountains and your mother.”
“We will not run from a fight!” Fili looked offended. This was a natural sentiment for one of Durin’s folk when faced with such a cowardly proposition, but Thorin needed more strategic thinking from his heir.
“You will retreat from a battle to win a war,” Thorin commanded. “Thranduil thinks all that he desires will come to him in time. That the jewels will be his if he simply outlasts those who would keep them from him. Should he prove true and save Bilbo, then perhaps his arrogance is only pride.”
“But if he proves false, he will never get them,” Fili said. The young dwarf straightened his back, standing firm as stone itself.
“Then you understand what I ask of you. If I fall here and the elves of Mirkwood ransack Erebor, they will get none of the gems they most desire with their pillaging. Both of you must teach your heirs to guard the gems and keep them from Thranduil at all costs. No matter what the future holds, nor what lies he whispers. If the elf betrays Erebor a second time, he must never have a third chance to grasp his desire.”
Fili nodded. “From our children to our children’s children and even unto the breaking of the world,” he swore. “If Bilbo Baggins dies, Thranduil will not touch the gems of Lasgalen while the line of Durin survives.”
“If he proves false,” Kili agreed, though there was a hesitation in his face that broke Thorin’s heart.
Placing a gentle hand on Kili’s neck, Thorin pressed his forehead against his nephew’s. “No one hopes more than I that this precaution is unnecessary. But go now with your brother and prepare.”
As the young dwarves rushed away, Thorin turned back to the gate to greet his guest. Gandalf entered with the elven king, but ignoring the wizard was easy enough. If he did not meet the old man’s eyes, he would not have to acknowledge who was really at fault for letting Bilbo face a dragon alone.
Fortunately, Thranduil had no more desire to suffer proforma niceties than Thorin did. The elf allowed the dwarves to usher him quickly to Bilbo’s sickroom, only lithely craning his serpentine neck a little to view the vast treasure hoard and the headless body of the dragon as they passed. Upon viewing the bandaged, groaning hobbit, Thranduil sniffed once.
“I suppose this is the best you could do under the circumstances,” he said disparagingly. Then his eyes fell upon the Arkenstone where it rested still on Bilbo’s bleach-white pillow. Cocking an eyebrow at Thorin, he continued. “I see that I am not the first you tried to barter help from. Lord Aüle did not answer you?”
“Do not waste time with pointless questions!” Thorin snatched up the symbol of his kingship and pocketed it furiously. “Have you come only to mock us, or can you help him?”
“I suppose that since I am here, I might as well help him,” Thranduil said. Before these lazy words could fully incense Thorin, they were belied by swift action.
First, the elf examined Bilbo’s bandages with light fingers that did not make the hobbit scream as Oin’s hands always did. Taking a crystal vial from somewhere under his armor, the king fed a strange potion to the hobbit. Then he cast herbs into the golden tub, which made the water within boil. Sweet smelling steam filled the room as Thranduil began to salve Bilbo’s many burns. This might have been mummery, but as the elf worked, he chanted in a strange language. Though Thorin knew some elvish from the short, peaceful years of his childhood, he did not recognize the words. Even so he felt a power grow as the elf spoke.
Thranduil of the Greenwood began to glow with a white light, like the moon of Durin’s Day shining upon the secret door to Thorin’s ambition. The voice of the elf rose and fell, as though in recitation of some poetry, until suddenly it was no longer a formulaic song. Blazing like a star to outshine the sun, Thranduil was not an elf, but a king. Thorin did not need to understand the words to hear the forceful undercurrent of command. When Thranduil spoke it was an order, not a prayer. It seemed that the Valar, or perhaps simply Bilbo’s little body, listened and obeyed.
Slowly, so very slowly, the bandages fell away from the hobbit’s wounds like the red leaves of autumn and Thorin saw soft, pink skin underneath. It looked like the untouched flesh of a newborn babe, but it was not burned, bleeding, or scarred. For the first time since the beginning of this impossible quest, hope no longer felt like a desperate dream. Thranduil was healing Bilbo, and Thorin stood by in awe as the terrible burns smoothed over with the power of the elven king’s magic.
At last, Thranduil stepped back. His ageless face looked weary for a moment and he sighed. “That is all I can do,” he said quietly. “Though I flatter myself that even Elrond of Rivendell would have been hard pressed to do as much.”
“Will he live?” Thorin’s hand reached out toward the fresh, clean skin of Bilbo’s cheek, but he did not touch it. “Is he healed?”
Thranduil blinked, as though surprised to find Thorin still in the room. Indeed, now that it was over, Thorin could acknowledge that the working had been long. Perhaps a day passed while Thranduil chanted. Perhaps two or three.
“I have healed him as well as any in Middle Earth could do,” the elf said, “but the light has gone from his eyes. It will not return.”
Fear swelled in Thorin’s throat and he choked. “What does that mean? He will not wake? That cannot be called healing! You have only worked some elvish illusion to make me think that you have helped him!”
“Peace.” Thranduil raised a tired hand. Thorin had never seen an elf appear so wholly exhausted. “He will wake. Indeed, I am surprised he has not done so already with your shouting.”
“Then tell me what you mean,” Thorin whispered urgently. “Elves may speak riddles about light, but if he is yet hurt, I would have you tell me plainly.”
“He is yet hurt,” Thranduil said calmly. “His body will be weak from the healing for many days. If he were a Man I would say two seasons, but I recall that halflings are a hardy folk. Some part of his strength may return before midwinter, at least enough to rise from his bed and tend his own needs.”
“Oh.” Suddenly, Thorin felt tremendously weak himself. All of the anxious anticipation that wound the dwarf’s muscles tighter than a spring snapped away, and the king nearly collapsed with relief. “That is well. Thank you. Of course that is well enough. I would not expect you to magic him up and about like a puppet. It is natural that he should need to rest and recover.”
“I tell you he is yet hurt,” Thranduil said. If the elf were any other, Thorin would have sworn there was compassion in his voice. “His body needs only rest, warmth, and good food to recover. His eyes, however, cannot be healed.”
“His eyes?”
“Are beyond the healing art of elves or men. To look upon such brilliance as the explosion he witnessed is impossible for mortals. His capacity for sight burned entirely away. There is nothing left to heal.”
For a moment, the words did not seem to make sense. Then the scope of what had been lost crashed around Thorin.
Perhaps Bilbo would not mind overmuch. He would yet have music, ale, and good food, which he seemed to like best of all things. They could teach the hobbit runes! Many dwarves had cause to read in absolute darkness, at the bottom of a mineshaft or in the black of night. Runes were a practical way to do it, and could be read easily by touch. Bilbo need not lose the books he enjoyed.
Only the color of the flowers that he plucked happily as they walked, the joyful sparks that leapt from a campfire which the hobbit always followed with his gaze, and the vision of a sunset over a mountain range that transfixed him for long minutes. That was all that he would lose. How many times had the little fellow hinted to a smirking Gandalf that when Erebor was reclaimed the wizard should celebrate with a firework show? It would never happen now. No, Thorin’s cause was responsible for crippling Bilbo, and dooming the hobbit to a life without the natural beauty he seemed to prize.
“Would that you could pluck the eyes from my skull and give them to him,” Thorin muttered.
“Such a thing is not possible.”
Thorin hated the pity in Thranduil’s face. Of course it was not possible. The elf need not condescend. Could a dwarf not make a simple wish without elvish judgment falling upon him?
“Thorin,” Bilbo said weakly. At once, the king rushed to his side. All anger with Thranduil was forgotten as Thorin took the hobbit’s hand without making the little fellow shriek in pain.
“Here I am.”
“Thorin, you must do something for me.” The hobbit’s voice was pitiful, a reedy note barely piercing the heavy air of the sickroom.
“Anything,” the king swore.
“Thorin, I need—please—a kipper.”
Thorin blinked at the hobbit in surprise.
“Or perhaps,” Bilbo amended with a pathetic cough, “a bacon sandwich. Scones, maybe. Tea. With milk, if there is any to be had. Though porridge would do in a pinch.”
Laughing, Thorin rushed to the door and threw it open. “Bring food,” he ordered. “The hobbit must have his meals, or he will pester like a buzzing fly.”
“It is not a laughing matter,” Bilbo said fussily, looking just as he always did when dwarvish mannerisms offended him. “You have been starving me! I feel like I have not eaten in a month.”
“It has barely been a week.” Thorin felt a grin stretch wide across his face.
Huffing, Bilbo turned his face to Thranduil. Thorin noticed that the hobbit’s eyes were unfocused and angled slightly left of where the elf stood, but the little fellow’s intent was obvious. “Allow me to thank Your Gracious Majesty for healing my wounds and saving my life. It speaks to a greatness of character that you came to my aid when you and Thorin have your differences. I shall never forget it.”
Thranduil inclined his head slightly in acknowledgement and might have made some pretty, elvish answer had Thorin not snorted.
“You needn’t thank him,” the dwarf said gruffly. “I am paying him well enough.”
The hobbit looked truly shocked. “Thorin! You cannot be serious. One ought to be twice as polite to people in one’s employ!” It was exactly the way Bilbo would have scolded the king had he been rude to a gardener or a serving maid, and Thorin laughed once more to think of King Thranduil of Mirkwood as Bilbo Baggins’s social inferior. He felt suddenly that as long as Bilbo lived, he would spend the rest of his days laughing.
“I am corrected.” Thorin quickly pressed his forehead to Bilbo’s, though the little fellow jerked in surprise at the unexpected touch. Bowing deeply to Thranduil, the king of Erebor offered his gratitude. “Thank you, King Thranduil. For saving my burglar.”
To Thorin’s surprise, the sentiment came out more sincerely than he intended. In fact, Thranduil did not appear insulted at all. The elven king simply nodded. Though his face was ageless and beautiful as elven faces always were, his eyes seemed very old.
“It pleases me that you did not perish in the fire before we had a chance to speak, Bilbo Baggins. When next you come to the Greenwood, you shall be an honored guest. In fact, I would have you tell me how it was that the thirteen dwarves you travelled with vanished from my dungeons. For my heart advises me that it will not be your first visit to my halls, though you and I have never met before now.”
Laughing, Bilbo agreed. “It is quite a story, Your Majesty. I should be very pleased to find an appreciative audience!”
With that, Thranduil took his leave and Bombur came into the sickroom. A grin plumped the cook’s chubby cheeks like two ripe apples, and he carried a tray laden with food for the hero. For a time, Thorin was able to sit and watch the little hobbit eat to his heart’s content, but only for a time. The duties of a king could not be neglected long.
