Chapter Text
Thranduil was an oathbreaker and a coward, but, having met Thorin’s demands, he deserved to be paid. Calling on his nephews, Thorin offered the two chests to Thranduil with what words of civility he could muster. Long did the elf gaze upon the jewels, taking the finest necklace in his hands and watching it shimmer in the light of the setting sun. Eventually, a second elf came up to the battlements, bearing away the chests, though Thranduil did not release his hold on the necklace.
“You have given me all of them.”
It was not a question, but Thorin bristled. “I keep my bargains.”
Thranduil inclined his head slightly. “I mean no offense,” he said, still not leaving. “I find you are not what I expected, King Under the Mountain. When you were in my dungeon, I thought you would prefer to burn yourself alive rather than speak a single civil word to me.”
“Perhaps that is so, for my own sake,” Thorin admitted. “Unfortunately, a king does not have the luxury of being ruled by his feelings. Though perhaps an elvish king may feel differently.”
Thranduil snorted. “And so dwarvish civility comes to an end.”
“What more would you have of me?” Thorin demanded. “I have thanked you. I have paid you. Would you have me abase myself to gratify your pride? Very well! You have done what no dwarf could do. Indeed, the First People have some cause for their vanity. Your gifts of healing vastly outmatch those given to my folk, though your long lives mean you have less need of them. Go! Go and live untouched by mortal grief, safe in the knowledge that you will never need to beg me for such aid.”
Unmoved as any marble statue, Thranduil did not go. “I would have peace.”
“What?”
“You ask what I would have of you, and it is this: peace.”
“Then go in peace. You cannot think I would be foolish enough to fight your army with a force of thirteen dwarves while Bilbo lies in bed as weak as a newborn kitten.”
The hint of a smile twitched at the corner of the elven king’s mouth. “No, you will never again risk harm to Master Baggins.”
Cold iron settled in Thorin’s heart. “Is that a threat?”
“It is a fact. Our war will not start today. It will not start for another ten years at least. Erebor needs time to rebuild its strength. But there is war for us on the horizon, Thorin son of Thrain. You hate me too much for anything less.”
“I do not hate you.” It was a surprise to realize it, but Thorin’s heart was too full of Bilbo’s plaintive request for breakfast. He had no room in it for hate.
“Today you do not, for I have done you a service. But as you say, I have been well paid. Tomorrow or the day after, you will rediscover your hate. You owe me no debt.”
“What then? Speak plainly. Will you kill me now to avoid this future you claim to see? You are welcome to try, though you will not find me as starved or exhausted as you did at our last meeting. Ware that you are in my stronghold, surrounded by my people this time!”
The elf did not blink. “Even now you distrust me. Even today, when you do not hate.”
“You are not speaking as one worthy of trust would!”
“You were so young when the dragon came. Younger even than your nephew whose beard only hints at growing, I think,” Thranduil said.
Thorin did not answer. If the elf would threaten Kili, there was no need to tell him that Thorin had, indeed, been nearly five years younger than his nephew was now.
“I must have seemed a miracle to your eye that day. Appearing as I did out of the ruins and the dragon-smoke, high on the hillside with a host of elves armed and armored for war. How well I recall the hope on your young face turning to confusion as you looked up at me and I did not at once lower a lance and charge the dragon. You called out for my help, as if to remind me of my purpose.” Recounting this did not seem to affect Thranduil in any way. The elf might have been recounting a history of tax gathering for all that it moved him.
“Help that never came.” Thorin did not see a point to such reminiscence.
“Have you never wondered how I marched a host to the mountain from my forest within the short hours of the dragon’s attack?” The elf arched a single eyebrow, as if to prove that he was not, in fact, a marble statue.
“You knew. You knew in advance.” The magnitude of that awareness barely had a chance to settle in Thorin’s mind before his hand went to the hilt of his sword. Perhaps there was room in his heart for hate, even on this day.
“In fact, I did. I saw the dragon-sickness in your grandfather’s eyes. When Thror could not part with the gems of Lasgalen even after I paid him and abased myself before his throne, I knew what he would summon with his greed. So it was that in returning to my own kingdom, I issued a declaration of war and made preparations.”
The elven king continued like an implacable tree root, which cracked any stone in time, unmoved and unmoving as he described marching his host forth from Mirkwood for the sole purpose of slaughtering the dwarves of Erebor in bloody war. His eyes were blue. Long had Thorin known that the creature’s eyes were an unnatural shade, a perversion of the sort of blue that was often considered lucky in the line of Durin. Looking at them now, with their strange, alien shape, Thorin realized that they were not the eyes of a snake as he always believed. No, strange though they were, they seemed to be the eyes of a bird. A vulture, perhaps, or a hawk. Some predatory carrion eater, no doubt, but not one that lay hidden to strike at the heels of the unwary.
“To your mind, it is a mercy that you did not fall upon us and push us back to be destroyed between your army and the dragon.”
“Not so to your own.” Thranduil cocked his head to one side, trying to read Thorin’s expression. Definitely birdlike, the elves, except all the ways in which they were more alien than any raven or thrush.
“There are greater mercies in this world.”
“There are.”
Thorin took a deep, slow breath. “I owe you nothing, Thranduil. No love or trust lies between us, but perhaps no blood does, either.”
One corner of the elven king’s mouth twitched upward, but it was not a smirk. He inclined his head toward Thorin fractionally. “Let it be so. Let us go forward from this moment and seek peace between our peoples. For we are neighbors once more, and I would not have that change.”
Thorin returned the nod, and that seemed to appease Thranduil.
“By your leave, my army will remain until more of your people come to defend the mountain,” the elf said. “The temptation of so much gold is great, and it would be inconvenient to have to make peace with some other king when I have only just achieved it with you.”
Thorin did not laugh, though perhaps he smiled a little at the elven king’s back. If he did, it was only because Bilbo lived. Bilbo lived, and while he did, Thorin was not capable of scowling. Even the idea of elves on his doorstep did not disturb him. They would help keep Bilbo safe.
Indeed, it was not long before Thorin had cause to be grateful a second time for Thranduil’s presence. When Dain arrived, at the head of a dwarven contingent, the elven king readied his own host to march away. Then Kili’s elf arrived in the company of Thranduil’s own son, warning them all that Azog approached with a vast army of orcs, trolls, wargs, and other foul things.
An hour of warning was better than none. Before Thorin could leave the mountain for battle, he needed to address his Company.
“The time has come,” he told them. “We crossed half the world to reclaim Erebor, and now we will fight to keep it. Even so, there is a greater duty. Who among you will forgo the glory of this battle to remain by Bilbo’s side?”
Kili and Dwalin both stepped forward. Thorin’s heart swelled with pride. He looked first to his nephew. Kili longed to prove himself in a great battle, as all princes must, and it cost him more than most to miss the chance.
“It is our family and our line that owes the greatest debt to Bilbo,” the young dwarf said. “It is right that we should protect him. I will not let you down, Uncle.”
Thorin looked to Dwalin, wondering if he would dispute this claim. “Kili is noble to offer, and a fine fighter, but he is not yet my match. I failed Bilbo once, when I lost hope. As a friend, I ask for the chance to redeem myself.”
The king considered, but he did not consider long. His thoughts were soon interrupted by a third member of the Company.
“That’s all well and good, then,” Bofur said, “and I hate to put myself up against royalty, but you’re all ignoring the real danger. Picking the person most likely to kill an army of orcs if they make it past our folk won’t help Bilbo any.”
Thorin raised an eyebrow at the toymaker.
“What do you think our hobbit is going to do if he realizes all of us are off fighting a war without him?” Bofur asked.
For a moment, the Company stood in silence, contemplating this. Then, the decision was made.
“The task is yours, Bofur. He will not question your presence as he might wonder at spending time with Dwalin alone, or Kili without his brother. If we fall and Erebor is taken, I trust you can bring Bilbo safely to the secret passageway, and from there return him to his homeland.”
Bofur nodded gravely. “You will not fall, my king. You’re too stubborn to let that sickly bastard win.” Then he grinned, “But if you do all manage to get yourselves slaughtered, I’ll just tell Bilbo that you’re too honorable to look upon a mighty hero who can’t look back. If I phrase it as an ancient dwarven custom, he might even believe it.”
Some laughed. Most rolled their eyes. Thorin gripped the toymaker’s shoulder. He was not noble or well born. Bofur was as crass and common as a dwarf could come. Yet kindness and loyalty such as his were not common at all. A heart like his was more precious than gold. Minstrels would not sing of Bofur’s deeds this day; yet if Thorin could trade places with him, he would do so without hesitation.
“I will not fail you, my king,” the toymaker promised. Thorin knew that he would not. Even so, there was one more thing he needed to do before leaving the mountain.
Bilbo was awake. At least, his blank eyes were open and his breathing was not the slow, steady rhythm of healthy sleep. Thorin tapped the door once, softly. It would not do to disturb the convalescent if he was resting. Fortunately, the hobbit’s head turned slightly, his expressive face pinching in confusion.
“Is someone there?” Bilbo asked.
“Yes.” Thorin stepped fully into the little sickroom. Now that moving the hobbit would not cause trauma enough to kill him instantly, more appropriate chambers would need to be found for the Dragonslayer.
“Thorin?” Bilbo still had his face scrunched up, as though if he squinted hard enough at the door, he might be able to see his visitor. Thorin wondered what he did see. Was it only darkness? A plane of white? Were there shadows or colors? Did he feel lonely? Trapped? Isolated?
“It is I,” said the king. “How do you fare?”
“Unreasonably tired,” the hobbit admitted. “I was sleeping until a moment ago, and I expect I shall be sleeping again soon. How is the mountain and everything?” Bilbo waved a hand, though clearly doing so cost him a great effort. “Has your cousin Dain arrived from the Iron Hills yet? Are you still getting on all right with Thranduil?”
“All is well, or will be soon,” Thorin vowed. “No enmity remains between the kingdom of Mirkwood and the Lonely Mountain. The armies of Dain and Thranduil will do no harm to one another, as Thranduil will make no war upon the dwarves. He has what he came for, and moreover does me a second service by remaining to defend Erebor against any orcs or dark creatures.”
Bilbo’s smile upon hearing that the elves and the dwarves were at peace was so bright, Thorin wondered for a moment if his vision returned. “I am glad,” the hobbit said softly. Reaching out, he fumbled until he found Thorin’s hand, taking it in his. “You are a great king, Thorin Oakenshield,” Bilbo said. “And great kings make peace, not war.”
The guilt Thorin felt over not mentioning Azog’s approaching army had no place in the sickroom. Bilbo needed rest and safety, not another enemy of Erebor to face in his weakened state. The king squeezed the hobbit’s hand gently.
“Speaking of Dain, it may be that he will wish to see you,” Thorin said.
“Well, I am in no fit state to entertain visitors. Though I shall, of course, be happy to meet any family of yours.” Bilbo hesitated. “As long as you do not think he will be greatly offended if I do not remain entirely alert. I nodded off while Balin was speaking to me a little while ago, I am quite mortified to admit.”
“That is no matter,” Thorin said quickly. “And we will certainly not disturb you or impose upon your time. I thought I would offer, however. That is, I should like to give you a gift.”
“A gift?” Bilbo sat up a little. Thorin swiftly manipulated the pillows to support his new position. “Well, what are you hesitating about? Perhaps you do not know, Thorin, but hobbits dearly love presents.”
“If that is the case, I shall shower you with them.” Thorin smiled as Bilbo huffed.
“I was not hinting,” the hobbit said.
“Even so, here is the first of many,” Thorin said, pressing his little bundle into Bilbo’s hands. “It is a mithril shirt of the finest dwarven make. No blade can pierce it.”
Bilbo laughed. “You just want me to wear something finer than a borrowed nightshirt from Laketown when I meet your cousin!” His hands traveled over the smooth rings of the mithril.
“I would have you wear this,” Thorin said. “As a token of the great regard that the king of Erebor holds for you.”
“Oh.” Bilbo looked down at the mithril in his hands, though he could not see it. His face was flushed with the effort of sitting up and making conversation. “Yes, then. I mean, thank you, Thorin. You are too kind.”
“Here,” Thorin said. Taking the armor back from Bilbo, he slipped it over the hobbit’s arms and down to cover his soft belly. The hero did not yet have hair to straighten. Beyond that lack, Bilbo’s cheeks were crimson with exertion and his eyes gazed sightlessly at Thorin’s shoulder. He was no longer the handsome little master of Bag End who charmed dwarven visitors with his strange manners. Here was a great warrior: marked by trials no other would have survived. Mithril suited Bilbo well. Very well.
“I’m sure I look a fool,” Bilbo said, resting his rosy cheek against the pile of pillows supporting him. “Wearing armor in bed as though I could stand up and fight if I wanted to. Still, it is not heavy. In fact, I would go so far as to call it comfortable, though it surprises me greatly that metal should be so. Thank you again, Thorin.”
Thorin found his voice. “All that I have, I have because of you Bilbo Dragonslayer. I will not forget it.”
“Oh, Thorin.” Bilbo frowned. “I hope you do not feel you owe me anything. Any peril I faced was of my own choosing, and I have been happy to share in your adventures. After all, I pray you will forgive the presumption, but I consider you to be. Well. That is to say.”
Thorin’s heart pounded in his ears like the footfalls of an approaching army. The mithril gleamed like a looking glass in the soft light of the sickroom, emphasizing how delicate and deadly the heroic hobbit truly was. Bilbo was quick, clever, and sharp tongued. If he hesitated to speak of his feelings for Thorin, then those feelings must be strong indeed. Marriage had never been the goal of this adventure, but it now seemed the best and most fitting end to their story. Bilbo should possess in equal measure all that his deeds granted Thorin. Their course of action was obvious.
“We are friends, aren’t we?” Bilbo asked, almost plaintively.
“Friends.” Thorin coughed. “Yes. Naturally we are friends, Bilbo.”
“Oh.” Bilbo did not looked pleased by this pronouncement. Perhaps because Thorin hesitated so long before offering confirmation of the simple fact.
Before Thorin could correct this interpretation, Balin and Bofur appeared in the doorway.
“It is time, my king. Dain calls for you,” Balin said.
“Not to worry, Bilbo. You’re trading up, as far as company is concerned. Though not in terms of presents.” The toymaker gave a low whistle. “Is that mithril you’re wearing, then?”
Thorin ignored them both to put his hands on Bilbo’s shoulder and slowly press their foreheads together. It was a gesture of friendship, brotherhood, and simple affection. Bilbo sighed, and Thorin could feel it whisper across his beard. With great effort, the king mastered his desire to take a kiss from that clever mouth.
“If there are no debts owed in your version of friendship, Bilbo Baggins,” Thorin said, “there must always be fairness in my own. It is now my turn, and I will brook no argument. My turn to give gifts. My turn to protect. My turn to show that you are valued.”
“If you like.” Bilbo sounded breathless and his face was now flushed almost to the point of fever. Thorin did the hobbit’s health no favors by imposing his conversation and company.
So the king took his leave, of Bilbo and of the mountain. It was time to defend both. Azog was on the horizon, marching with a host of orcs that covered the hills in darkness.
Between Dain, Bard, and Thranduil, the three armies were already arrayed as a single force. The dwarves took the front to shield, the elves fell back to shoot, and the men filled in at the mid-range, their boat hooks as good as pikes in a pinch. Thorin’s Company joined the dwarves in places of honor. They would be the first to fight when the enemy arrived.
Thranduil’s son Legolas found Thorin as he waited at the front of the dwarven contingent for the orcs to approach.
“I believe an apology is owed to you for my part in waylaying your quest,” the elf said.
Thorin waited impassively to see if such an apology would be forthcoming. His eyes were fixed on the distant orcs, and he said nothing.
Legolas lifted Orcrist in both of his hands and extended it to the dwarf. “Gandalf tells me that this sword was reclaimed by your Company from a trio of cave trolls. Although it may have been forged by elves long ago, it was dwarven valor which reclaimed the blade from darkness. I should not have despoiled you of it. Please accept it, and my promise that in the future I will no longer assume the worst when dealing with your kin.”
Taking the blade, Thorin turned at last to the elf. “When one is used to looking like a beggar, one expects to be taken for a thief. I accept your apology, son of Thranduil. Let there be no quarrel between us. Instead, let us take the quarrel to those who most deserve our enmity.”
Nothing more needed to be said. The elf nodded and returned to his rank among the archers. Inexorably, Azog’s army marched closer. Then Thorin heard Legolas’s voice again. A single command, loud and clear, echoing across the desolation. At once the sky filled with elven arrows. To Thorin’s eye, every single one found mark in an orc, though perhaps only half of them killed their targets. The orcs shrieked and broke into a charge. Orcs were not slow, but there was time for a second volly before they crossed the full distance to meet with dwarven steel. Many more were struck, and some fell tripping on the bodies of their comrades.
It was an unruly mob that broke across the dwarven shields. Orc after orc fell to dwarven axes and elven arrows, but they were only meant to tire the defenders and weaken their ranks. Thorin could see the trolls looming behind the first wave.
He did not await them patiently. “For Bilbo!” he cried, charging forward. No trollish club would have a chance to break through the dwarven shield wall. Orcrist was sharp enough to pierce their rock hard skin. With Orcrist, Thorin could hamstring a troll. With Orcrist, he could climb the felled body of a warg to strike a troll’s head from its neck. With Orcrist, he could stand his ground against the massive creatures, cleaving their limbs away.
“For Bilbo!” Dain cried, burying his ax in one orc while headbutting another to stun it until he could free his ax to slay the dazed creature. “By the way cousin,” he said. “I’ve been meaning to ask you. What’s a Bilbo?”
Thorin smiled at his antics and looked around the bloody chaos of the battlefield. Only orcs attacked now. The massive siege weapons hauled forward by the trolls were abandoned, too far from the walls of Erebor to be of use.
“The trolls are the only real danger to our shield wall. Without them our lines will hold.”
Nevertheless, there were other dangers. A warg and rider charged at Thorin, bearing down on him with tooth and spear. Stepping smoothly to one side, Thorin beheaded the mount with one stroke and the rider with his backswing. Orcrist slipped through flesh and bone like gold through the fingers of a spendthrift: freely, swiftly, and to devastating effect.
“Aye,” Dain said. “But you’ve taken care of this batch. Almost single handedly. And well away from our lines, I might add.”
Thorin blinked. His Company and his cousin were with him, but they were surrounded on all sides by orcs. For the most part, this did not seem to matter. Many of the cowardly things rushed past to take their chances with the main force instead of the fell warriors who charged out at Thorin’s side. Even so, it was not a safe position. Fili and Kili at least should return to the lines, now that there were no trolls in this wave of Azog’s forces.
“Bilbo the Dragonslayer is one of our Company,” Balin told Dain. “After felling Smaug in single combat, he was wounded, and lies now blinded within the mountain.”
“Then the orcs must not reach the mountain,” Dain said. Obvious as this was, it was well put.
Taking his cousin by the arm, Thorin slammed their heads together joyfully. “I trust you will hold the line, Cousin.”
“And where are you going?” Dain asked, playfully spinning to block an enormous mace aimed at his back and slaying his attacker easily. “The trolls in the next ranks will be here soon enough, if orcs are not enough of a challenge for you.”
Thorin looked up at the flags on Ravenhill. They seemed to mock his efforts, urging wave after wave of the orcish army to attack. “I go to finish what I started long ago,” he said.
Of course the Company followed. Their loyalty was too great to part from Thorin, even as he waded through danger into greater danger. Some fought to clear his way. Some stayed behind to hold it. Though it was at his behest and on his command, Thorin knew they did not fight on his behalf. “For Bilbo!” they cried, and for Bilbo they made it to Ravenhill despite the odds.
Only Fili, Kili, and Dwalin reached that final destination with Thorin. When they arrived, the ancient watchtower seemed as empty as the desolation. Wary of Azog’s treacherous cunning, Thorin sent Fili and Kili to scout while he and Dwalin destroyed the command flags. This insult did not draw out their enemy. Worse, Fili and Kili did not return at the appointed time. Snow fell on Ravenhill, muffling the distant sound of battle and covering the world in silence.
Dwalin and Thorin went to seek the princes. Finding Fili was the work of a minute. Azog had Thorin’s heir by the throat. Sneering at the king across a vast precipice, the Pale Orc threatened to end the line of Durin. Time seemed to slow. Snowflakes danced between them. Thorin’s mind drifted to Bilbo Baggins, Dragonslayer. What would Bilbo do? The king wondered. Then he threw his sword.
No blade but Orcrist could have flown so true, like a javelin over the vast divide. Thorin’s aim was sure. The sword of Gondolin struck Azog between the eyes, sliding into the orc’s skull like a foot slipping into a boot.
Deftly, Fili reached over his shoulder, withdrawing the blade from the Pale Orc’s face as the body fell. Landing on his feet, the prince turned and screamed in defiance to the rest of his captors. Seeing their leader so easily defeated, their courage broke. Shrieking, the orcs fell back to regroup. Fili followed them with Orcrist, cutting them down as they fled.
Thorin did not have time to savor the defeat of his grandfather’s murderer. Instead, he took the dwarven sword from his belt and turned with Dwalin to face hundreds of charging goblins. Azog’s death would not end the fighting or disarm all of his traps. But every goblin split by Thorin’s blade was one fewer to charge the gates of Erebor. The further Thorin could keep the battle from Bilbo, the happier he would be. Ravenhill was as good a place as any to make a stand.
