Chapter Text
After battle and celebration, ruling was nothing but hard work. This came as no surprise to Thorin Oakenshield, though several other things did.
First, Thranduil and his army of elves did, in fact, leave in peace, taking nothing but the gems of Lasgalen. Begrudgingly, Thorin’s gratitude went with them as well. Mirkwood would never be a friend to Erebor under Thorin’s rule, but he could not deny the alliance.
Second, rewarding Dain’s army for their work in the battle brought labor and new citizens to Erebor. Every dwarf was given a large sack of gold in thanks for their service. These were only coins, and the Company agreed that the measure should be taken from the hoard before any other divisions were made. On top of this monetary reward, any dwarf who did not wish to return to the Iron Hills with Dain was offered a home in Erebor. Nearly half of them chose to remain. Some were dwarves Thorin recognized. When Erebor fell to Smaug, Dain welcomed many refugees in the Iron Hills. Others he knew to be new settlers. For those, he apologized to Dain. It was never his intention to weaken his cousin’s army.
“I did not think so many would accept the offer,” the King Under the Mountain told the Lord of the Iron Hills.
“Ach. Don’t apologize. It doesn't suit you. Makes you look like a constipated elf.” Dain clapped Thorin on the back. “The Iron Hills don’t have veins of gold that run like rivers, nor the promise of building something new. We’re safe and settled, which isn’t nearly as much fun. If thirteen of my soldiers follow me home, I’ll count myself lucky.”
“You could stay,” Thorin offered, though he knew it wasn’t fair. Dain had responsibilities to the Iron Hills that could not be easily ignored. Even so, it had been too long since they were last together. Thorin found that he did not like to part so soon. Dwarven hearts were jealous, possessive things, after all.
Smiling, Dain crashed their foreheads together. “I’ve too much iron in me to chase after gold. An iron foot, an iron skull, and the Iron Hills for me. But it’s not so far away as the Blue Mountains. You’ll be sick of my visits soon enough.”
“Never,” Thorin said. And although the Lord of the Iron Hills prefered steel to gold, Thorin sent him home with gold by the wagonload. He also gave his cousin a crown of rubies, mithril beads for his beard, a suit of fine armor, a shield born by their great grandfather, a jeweled goblet, a set of jade combs, and many other wonderful things besides. When no one else would aid the homeless dwarves of Erebor, when Stiffbeards and Blacklocks turned them away, Dain sent an army. Thorin would not be miserly with his gratitude.
Most surprisingly of all, even after everything, some still found him so.
Alfrid Lickspittle had a hunched posture that made him look like a coiled weasel waiting to strike. Moreover, his manner of speech was undignified. He sniveled and groveled while at the same time making demands of those he considered inferior. It was clear that all dwarves were inferior in his eyes, even the King Under the Mountain.
“I do not understand you,” Thorin said plainly. “We have kept our promise to Dale. I withhold nothing which belongs to that once-fair city. Just this morning another cart went to Bard full of coin and other treasures that were recognized as belonging to Men.”
“Forgive me, Your Highness, for speaking so directly. Dwarves are said to like that sort of thing, so I’ll dare it. Bard and Dale would be the problem.” Alfrid ducked his head and peered up at Thorin. The king could not openly call his expression insolent, but it was.
“I thought the rebuilding was going well.” Thorin looked to Balin, who understood him well enough to play along.
“Indeed, sire. More than a few stonemasons from the Iron Hills have found employment in Dale helping the Men rebuild the city. By all accounts, most of the buildings will be habitable before winter comes on in force. Their life is no more comfortable than our own, for they are spoiled in metal and stone, while wanting for cloth just as we are, but they will weather it until better trade comes with the spring. And of course, they trade with Laketown as we do.”
“Trade.” Alfrid snorted. Then, seeming to remember himself, he bowed very low. “My apologies, your majesty, but we were not promised trade. We were promised rich reward for aiding you on your quest. Yet all of it seems to go to Bard and Dale, not to the Master of Laketown, who gave you shelter, food, transportation, and weaponry at his own expense.”
Thorin wanted to sneer. To ask for payment for a single night of feasting, a single boat ride across a lake, and a few poorly-forged swords was as churlish and parsimonious as dwarves were always reported to be.
Gandalf’s voice was so soft that Thorin alone heard his words. “Do you want them to be able to say you owe them a debt?”
Thorin blinked. It was always something of a surprise when the wizard proved to be truly wise. “Very well. Fair payment will be given for the Master’s aid. Let us say one hundred gold coins for the room and board of each member of my Company for each night he hosted us, and two hundred for myself. One hundred gold coins for each member of my Company ferried across the Long Lake with me to reach the Mountain by Durin’s Day. Fifty gold coins for each and every weapon or piece of clothing given to our Company, be it sock or sword, based on an accounting agreed to by Mister Lickspittle and Lord Gloin. Does that suit, Mister Lickspittle?”
With each sum mentioned, the greedy man’s eyes widened until Thorin thought they might fall from his head. In the end, he said, “Very fair, Your Majesty. Very fair indeed. Thank you.” Then he rushed off with Gloin to see to the accounting.
“See to it that Bard is given the same for the many nights he hosted our Company and my nephews, and twice as much for bringing Oin when we most needed him,” Thorin instructed Balin.
It was done. When Alfrid disappeared with the gold intended for Laketown, Thorin sent the same sum again with Dwalin. The dwarf put the money directly into the Master’s hands. What happened to it after that was no business of Erebor’s. Gandalf was right. It was not wise to owe debts to such people.
“Do you find it difficult, to part with so much gold?” Gandalf waited until they were alone to ask, so Thorin considered the question and did rush to his own defense.
“I do not like giving it to Laketown,” he said. “Esgaroth is a miserable place, and more gold in the pockets of its Master will not improve life there. As far as Mister Lickspittle goes, I hope he fell into the lake and sank from the weight of his riches. Giving to Bard and to Dain, though? That is easy enough. If I gave them all the gold in this mountain, I would still not pay my debt to them both. Gold cannot buy life, and well do I know that is what I owe.”
Gray eyes twinkled underneath the wizard’s bushy brow. “Good. You have resisted the temptation, Thorin Oakenshield. I was worried that a dwarf of your line might have trouble going from abject poverty to owning gold enough to fill the Long Lake, but you have been able to break up the hoard. No more dragons will be called to this mountain while you rule.”
Thorin stared at him. “Do not speak to me like a schoolmarm to a clever pupil! I know my own failings well enough. I require neither condescension nor consolation from you, old man.”
Gandalf’s eyes went wide. He took a step back, away from Thorin. “Failure? You have accomplished everything you set out to do. Erebor is retaken. Smaug and Azog are slain. Indeed, I would call the casualties from your battle remarkably low, given the numbers you faced. What failure do you speak of?”
There was a fine marble statue of Durin the Second in one corner of the room. Thorin admired the way the sculptor captured the draping fabric of the statesman’s robes. Every hair of the dwarf’s mighty beard was expressed in stonework so lifelike that Thorin was tempted to fix his ancestor’s braid. It was a work of art too long unappreciated in a dragon’s den. Such a masterpiece should be seen.
“Thorin. What happened to Bilbo is no fault of yours.”
“I know that,” Thorin snapped. “It is your fault. I told you as much when you insisted he should come. One hobbit alone against a dragon. What kind of strategy is that?”
“It is a strategy Bilbo agreed to,” Gandalf said sternly. “He is no subject of yours to be ordered into danger. Nor is he a fool. Grant him the valor of one who understood the risk, feared it, and took it anyway because it was the right thing to do.”
“For friendship,” Thorin said, even though the admission pained him.
“Exactly,” Gandalf said. “All that is left now is for you to be worthy of his friendship. Guilt helps nothing, Thorin. And I tell you now, he will not tolerate it. Already he fears that you will coddle him or treat him differently.”
Considering the hobbit’s rage at being left in the dark about Azog’s army, Thorin thought this point was justified. Moreover, the conversation was finally getting interesting. “And is there a way? For me to be worthy of his friendship?”
The old man looked confused. “So long as you are a friend to him, you are worthy of his friendship, Thorin. The most important thing is only making time. A king has many demands on his day, which Bilbo will certainly understand. If you take a meal together now and again, I am sure he will find your company adequate.”
“You know that is not what I mean,” Thorin growled. “Wizard: I ask you. Is there no magic bauble, no questing beast, no elvish silmaril that can restore his vision?”
Gandalf sighed. “There are many miraculous things in this world, Thorin Oakenshield. If you spent the next few years of your life questing, I do not doubt that you might find something suitable. Or die nobly in the attempt. In the process, you would make it quite clear to Bilbo that you value his eyes more than his friendship.”
Recoiling away from the wizard, Thorin said, “You cannot be serious.”
“Does the iron foot make your cousin less of a warrior?”
“No. But it pains him. Every day he wears it, it pains him.”
“As the loss of his vision will always pain Bilbo.” It was Gandalf’s turn to look away. “Life in this world is full of pain.” Suddenly, the wizard met Thorin’s eyes once more. “It is in the darkness that we see starlight.”
Thorin wanted to be pedantic. To grumble about the fact that there would be no starlight for Bilbo. Something about the wizard’s expression made that feel impossibly childish, though, and he conceded the point. “I should not have sent Bilbo to face the dragon alone,” Thorin whispered. The confession could no longer be contained.
The warm hand on his shoulder was a surprise. Few dared lay hands on the person of a king without invitation, but Gandalf was always a law unto himself. “Apologize to him then,” the wizard said. “When we feel we have wronged our friends, all we can do is apologize.”
Clearly, this was terrible advice. Once again, Gandalf was condescending to Thorin, treating him as a child. A king could not apologize to a great hero for granting him the opportunity to cover his name in glory. Adults did not take responsibility for the actions of their friends. Besides, Thorin was far too busy to concern himself with such matters.
Every dwarf that could be spared was needed to repair the aqueduct system, but that work would be easier once the forges were up and running. The forges could not be useful until there was fuel for their fires, so the coal mine at least must reopen. The coal miners could not work without water to run through their wheels, so the aqueducts were needed more than ever. One problem solved inevitably lead to six more difficulties, and Thorin spent his days and nights fighting to make his home habitable once more.
Leaving it all to Fili and Balin while he quested after some trinket from the First Age to restore Bilbo’s sight would have been much easier.
“You need a barn raising,” Bilbo said, when he heard of the difficulty.
Thorin paused, wondering if the hobbit was too unwell to listen to the troubles of a kingdom, despite the king’s promise. “Usually, we leave the matter of livestock to Dale, other than our war goats or the occasional boar. Animals do not do well within the mountain.”
Bilbo laughed. “I don’t mean an actual barn,” the hobbit said.
“In the Shire, digging out a new smial is the work of years, maybe even generations. ‘Anything worth doing is worth doing right,’ as my father used to say, and we would never rush the building of something as important as a home.”
Mentally, Thorin added a few more flourishes to his personal project, but he listened attentively to Bilbo’s advice. “A barn is different?” the king guessed.
“Sometimes, yes. If one is destroyed by a storm, or a roof caves in, it can be dreadfully urgent to put a new one up at once. In a case like that, the farmer throws a party. All of the neighbors come around to help him build in exchange for a good meal and a merry time. ‘Many hands make light work,’ is another saying in the Shire. I have wielded a hammer on such occasions myself, though I have never so much as put up shelves on my own in Bag End. You might be surprised by how much use unskilled helpers can be on a big job, when there are experienced folk about to offer guidance.”
“And which barn would you have us build?” Thorin asked. “The coal mine to fuel the rest of our work?”
“The plumbing,” Bilbo said firmly. “I mean, the aqueducts, or whatever you called them. Clean water, good food, and then warmth are what your people need first and foremost, Thorin. Otherwise you will have sickness, weak workers, and death.” Then he coughed. “Though I am sure you know best, of course, and I would not presume to lecture a king.”
Thorin smiled, and pressed Bilbo’s hand gently between both of his own, since the hobbit could not see his face. “I am grateful for your wisdom, my clever burglar. It shall be as you say.”
And, indeed, once every dwarf in the mountain was put to repairing the damaged aqueducts, the whole system was up and running within a few short days. Thorin wanted to extend the benefit to Bilbo’s sick room, that the hobbit might no longer need to use the chamber pot and bedpan which he clearly loathed. It would be a luxury for the little fellow as well, to be able to turn a tap in his golden tub and have a hot bath whenever he wanted one. Unfortunately, it would be far too impractical to run piping all the way through the treasure chambers—still damaged from Smaug’s residence and demise—for a short term benefit. Soon, Bilbo would be well enough to go to a better part of the mountain, full of every luxury imaginable. In the interim, his meager sick room would remain as it was.
The greatest luxury was time, and there was little enough of that to go around. Winter was not as hard on mountain dwelling dwarves as the Men of Dale and Laketown. The inside of a mountain was never warm, but it was also never cold enough to freeze water. Even so, the season presented many challenges. Just keeping everyone fed was an issue, for Laketown did not have nearly enough of a surplus to support Erebor, unless everyone wanted to eat nothing but fish. Soon, Thorin learned from Bard that the Master was starving his own people to sell their goods for dwarven gold. Upon the advice of Bilbo and Balin, the king ceased all trade in that quarter and relied on the merchants who came from further afield. But those merchants dared snowy roads indeed, and charged high prices as a result.
It was easy to talk to Bilbo about the challenges Erebor faced. The hobbit’s clever mind always had some valuable advice to offer, even if he occasionally fell asleep in the middle of a conversation. Yet talking to him was sometimes the greatest difficulty of all for Thorin.
“Bilbo Baggins, I would have words with you,” the king said abruptly.
The hobbit paused. “We, er, are having words, Thorin. Specifically, I am recommending that you do not buy fish from anywhere save the Long Lake. There’s an old adage in the Shire that fish from faraway brings only sickness. If it were up to me, I’d buy all the potatoes this Stiffbeard caravan can sell, but I’d leave the fish for fertilizer. I would never accuse them of ill intent, but I think these Stiffbeard merchants may be more interested in your gold than maintaining their own reputation for valuable goods. I can’t think of any other reason why they’d bring fish all the way up from the East. Instead of, say, salt pork.”
“I owe you an apology,” Thorin said stiffly. “It is long overdue.”
“Oh!” Bilbo flushed and sat up a little straighter. These days he only needed a few pillows for support, and could sit up on his own for minutes at a time. “Well, that is quite alright. You must know that I forgive you. After all, I shall not be bedridden forever, and you have been keeping your promise to tell me about all of the problems the mountain faces.”
“No, not for failing to mention Azog,” Thorin said. “As you say, my vow to tell you of every danger Erebor faces reconciles us upon that score. Nay, I am sorry for sending you to meet Smaug alone. I should have been by your side. Letting you face such danger on your own was not a fitting act for a friend or a king.”
Bilbo frowned and moved his hand in the seeking, grasping motion that meant he would like to touch the person he was speaking with. Thorin took the hand in both of his. The hobbit’s palm was soft and uncalloused. A scholar’s hand, not a fighter’s.
“Thorin, I am glad you were not with me. I was tremendously lucky. In fact, I cannot imagine any series of events that would have let me survive other than exactly what happened. If I had not found myself sitting on that magic shield, sailing through the air like one of Gandalf’s rockets, I would have melted away with everything else caught in that explosion. I doubt there were two such shields in all the treasure. No matter what you dwarves like to think, I did not fell Smaug in heroic battle. I don’t believe that monster could have been killed by all fourteen of us working together, even if Gandalf deigned to help. Everything that happened is for the best, and if it cost me my sight, at least it did not cost any of us our lives.”
This was a reasonable point. Thorin could not argue with any part of it. Nor did he wish to argue with Bilbo. To do so would be entirely foolish. So he said nothing.
The hobbit smiled. “Alright, Thorin. I forgive you.”
Thorin’s hands tightened on Bilbo’s reflexively. “You said there was nothing to forgive.”
“That doesn’t mean you’re wrong either,” Bilbo said. “It does not matter that I would have been blind and useless in your fight with Azog or that you would not have survived my flight from Smaug. The truth is, we ought to face danger together. That's what friends are for. So I shall forgive you, and beg your pardon in turn.”
“Thank you,” Thorin said, unable to contain his smile. “I forgive you as well, if you truly desire such a thing.”
“Then that is that.” Bilbo leaned back against his pillows with a sigh. “We’ll both do better in the future.”
“Indeed.” Thorin looked down at their clasped hands. Minutes passed in comfortable silence.
After a time, the dwarf even dared to stroke the back of the hobbit’s soft hand.
Finally, he spoke. “To that end, Bilbo, I have for some time hoped that you might be willing to share more of my future than the perils alone. Rebuilding Erebor is a monumental task, but with your help the work is halved. The joy of rediscovering my homeland is great, but with you by my side it would be unending. Would you do me the great honor of joining your life to mine, work and reward in equal measure, and making your home here with me?”
The only answer to this was a gentle snore. Bilbo was, of course, fast asleep.
