Chapter Text
Balin was the one who came to clean up the broken teacup. Bilbo was still seething in his bed, but he knew Balin by the tapping rhythm of his knock, the smooth cadence of his step, and the scent of pipeweed, velvet, and old papers. How had he not known Thorin? There was nothing more distinctive than Thorin’s laugh. Khaz, too, smelled like embers, incense, and steel. No dwarf but Thorin had such a smooth, measured stride. If Bilbo had been thinking at all, there was no way the dwarves could have deceived him so.
Friends did not willfully deceive each other. That was his only excuse. Bilbo had not been looking for lies. Yet lies were told, so it must be that Bilbo had no friends at all. Then it occurred to him that perhaps Thorin was the only one to lie, and somehow that was even worse.
“Isn’t this a bit below your dignity?” he snapped at Balin.
The dwarf sounded a little surprised to be addressed so rudely. As well he might, while doing Bilbo a favor, but the hobbit did not feel the slightest pang of guilt. “I’m always happy to help when you need me, Bilbo, you know that.”
“I mean,” Bilbo said, anger coloring his tone quite fiercely, “Why would Thorin get you out of bed in the middle of the night? Surely some other dwarf might be found for the job. I happen to know there are several scribes working through the night in the treasure chambers just outside that door. Thorin might have asked one of them to help.”
“Ah.” The mattress beneath Bilbo sank slightly as Balin took a seat at the foot of the bed. “Is that what you and Thorin fought about? He knows that he cannot keep you locked in here away from harm forever. You are not a prisoner, Bilbo. But while you are weak, he will trust your safety to no one but the Company.”
“And no one thought to mention that to me?”
Balin paused, “Surely you did not notice just now that the only visitors you have had beyond the Company were Thranduil and Dain, neither of whom Thorin left alone with you.”
Furious, Bilbo could not find words to speak of Thorin’s long deception. Instead, he said, “I should like to speak to Gandalf as soon as possible.”
A warm hand touched Bilbo’s arm. “Of course, but it may take a little time. He left the mountain on some business of his own, as you know, and tracking a wizard down is never easy. Is there anything that I can do for you in his stead.”
“I wish to go home,” Bilbo said firmly. “He promised to take me once I could walk unaided, and I can now.”
Balin’s gentle hand gripped Bilbo, then relaxed once more into a light touch. “I see. Well. If you do not care to wait for the wizard, my brother and I will see you back to the Shire at any time you choose. After all, that is the least we can do for a friend. Indeed, though I will not speak for the others, I suspect most of the Company will join us.”
An emotion other than rage entered Bilbo’s heart then, and the hobbit found he could not speak around the lump forming in his throat. Finally, he said, “But you have all only just made it home yourselves. Such a journey would be dreadfully inconvenient.”
Balin’s laugh was very light, but it shattered the remnants of Bilbo’s anger like a hammer. “Fear not. The Shire is hardly out of our way. After all, we must pass into the west to reach the Blue Mountains, and most of us have kinfolk there that must be escorted to Erebor. Though you may set the date of our departure, doubt not that we would be departing come spring in any case.”
“Oh,” Bilbo said, feeling very childish. “You are too kind. Thank you.”
“May I ask a favor in turn?”
“Naturally.” After being shown such courtesy by his friend, the hobbit rediscovered his own manners. In fact, he was quite ashamed of his earlier outburst. Angry as he was with Thorin, Bilbo had no reason to vent his spleen on the rest of his friends. “I am entirely at your service, Balin, as I hope you know.”
Although he could not see Balin’s smile, Bilbo heard it in the dwarf’s voice, and he remembered the way those bright eyes twinkled when he was pleased. “Promise me not to decide that date based on your feelings about Thorin. My king is an inspiring figure, and he inspires anger and awe in equal measure, as I well know. I do not think it would be wise for you to stay in Erebor only to bask in his pleasure, nor to leave when you are both in a temper.”
Duly chastened, Bilbo wanted to promise, but something about Balin’s words stopped him. “He is in a temper with me? The nerve! As though I have done anything except catch him in a lie!”
“Peace,” Balin said quickly. “I do not know whether his anger is directed at you or himself, only that he was displeased when he asked me to come to your aid this night.”
Feeling more juvenile than ever, Bilbo sniffed. Nevertheless, he couldn’t help being slightly mollified by this. “Very well,” he said. “I promise.”
“Now,” Balin said, “Since we are both awake, I wonder if you have any further thoughts on that trade agreement with Mirkwood that I mentioned earlier. Thranduil continues to insist that it must be written in Sindarin as well as Westron to be enacted as law, and the translation of the third clause is wholly unsatisfying.”
“Yes, of course,” Bilbo said. And so they were able to talk about verb forms and vegetables until the hobbit drifted off, leaving all thoughts of Thorin behind.
The following morning, Bilbo got out of bed, dressed himself, and informed Dori politely but firmly that he was going for a walk. Somewhat surprisingly, the protective dwarf didn’t try to stop him. Instead, Dori offered the hobbit a lightweight walking stick and his arm. To leave the sickroom and go anywhere of note, they would have to cross the sliding coins which were still piled high above the treasure room floor.
“May I be permitted to carry you?” Dori offered quietly as Bilbo tripped along, leaning heavily on his stick each time he almost fell.
“No thank you,” Bilbo said. Then, because that was too much of a sting for such a faithful friend, the hobbit asked where Dori consistently acquired such interesting teas. The topic saw them through the worst of the climb up a particularly steep stack of coins.
As they walked, the hobbit realized that his anger with Thorin caused only part of his discomfort. The rest was the gold. Walking on shifting, sliding gold coins was not like walking on sand, gravel, or any other surface, really. It was a sensation Bilbo only ever experienced once before. His heart told him that he would encounter a dragon at any moment. Just when the fear almost overcame him, Dori put a second hand on his arm. He was not alone. He would never again face a dragon alone.
Bilbo stopped walking for a moment so that he could prop his stick under one arm and pat Dori’s hands. “Tricking you lot into being my friends is the smartest thing I’ve ever done,” he said. “I’m really very proud of myself for thinking of it.”
Dori’s laugh was a dignified chuckled that suited him well, and the pair continued on. After a solid half hour of wading through the coins, they reached a flat stretch of hallway. Dori described it for Bilbo, and the hobbit found that he could sense the nature of the place easily.
As a rule, hobbits do not delve so deeply within the earth as dwarves, but they do live underground and are well accustomed to tunnels and such. Bilbo knew that he was under the earth from the temperature and the cool scent of rock around him. He knew that the ceiling was high above—like the one at Great Smials or Brandy Hall, and not only a little way up like the one at Bag End—from the way the air moved. Smooth stone under his feet and the regular clack of his walking stick against the wall was enough to let him know that it was paved in an orderly dwarven style. Indeed, all he learned from Dori that he could not learn for himself was how far the tunnel stretched out before them, and that the ceiling vaulted in an arch indicative of the architecture of the early Third Age and the reign of Thrain I.
That was very interesting, and the hobbit would have been happy to continue along such a line of conversation, but Dori said, “Oh, it’s not my area. I only know as much because Ori will remark on it. If it’s history you want, you have the wrong brother.”
So they talked about tea, books, and small comforts. Even walking at a leisurely pace, all roads eventually lead somewhere, and Bilbo began to hear the bustling sound of many people further on.
“Shall we head back?” Dori offered.
“Are those Thorin’s orders?” Bilbo asked sharply.
Dori paused. “The king has given no orders about the length of walks you might take, Bilbo. Indeed, I would be far more inclined to trust Oin’s opinion, and he told us that you should be allowed as much exercise as you felt inclined to do. Only, by my watch it is a quarter to eleven o’clock, and you missed your second breakfast. At our current pace, it will be lunchtime before we make it back to your room.”
“Ah.” Such considerations were imminently sensible, yet Bilbo loathed the idea of turning back. He did not want to feel coins between his toes ever again. “What is up ahead?” he asked.
“Ah, well.” Dori hesitated. “We’re getting a bit close to the Great Marketplace, actually. Don’t let the name fool you. It’s rather rough and tumble at the moment, with hardly anything worth buying. A few merchants manage to make their way from the Iron Hills and elsewhere every so often, but mostly it’s just good solid camp gear. With a few sundries brought in by Stiffbeards who overcharge. Everyone wants Ereborian gold, of course, but it’s midwinter. There’s not the kind of choice you’ll find come summer when things really get going.”
“Of course,” Bilbo said. “I understand completely. Thorin wouldn’t like us to go. And there are those Stiffbeard merchants. He’s made it clear he does not trust them.”
Dori hesitated again.
“I’ll make it easy, shall I?” the hobbit added tersely. “I am going. You may come along if you like. Thorin can go hang.” Then he stomped forward, as best he could. Hobbits can barely manage a good stomp in the best of times, since their footfalls tend toward the absolutely silent. A blind hobbit, who needs to feel the way with his walking stick, simply cannot build up the reckless inertia that a proper stomp requires. But Bilbo tried.
Beneath his feet, the road changed slightly, from the big smooth blocks of the long hall to something more like cobblestones. That did not make stomping any easier. Nor did his walking stick swing, though it did ring a bit more, as though some of the cobblestones were metal, not the simple river rocks which paved the streets of Hobbiton.
Dori caught up with him after only a few steps. “No harm in a little outing, I always say.” The dwarf’s voice was confident, as though he didn’t really mind continuing on, but he leaned in to take Bilbo’s arm. “Do stick close to me, though, if you please.”
It was a pleasant enough way to walk, and as they approached the marketplace, Bilbo was willing to concede the necessity. The cacophony of dwarven voices filled his ears long before Dori began describing stalls and storefronts to him. He heard cartwheels, tramping boots on stone, the clip of goat hooves on the same, and the ringing of coins as well as hammers, but most of all he heard voices. Haggling was a favorite pastime for all dwarven merchants, and that was not nearly so loud as those shouting out to hawk their wares. One particularly booming voice promised, “Repairs while you wait! No more’n an hour! We can’t do it in an hour, the whole job’s free!”
“What are they repairing?” Bilbo asked curiously, interrupting Dori’s description of the broad avenue lined with shops and interspersed with stalls.
“Ah, who do you mean?” From the hand on his arm, Bilbo could feel Dori turning to look about, and he smiled.
“The fellow who promises to take no more than an hour.”
“Ah! That’s one of the armorers. We’ve had a few others trickle in from the Iron Hills, and soon enough our folk will come up from the Blue Mountains, but for the most part, all of the dwarves in Erebor were soldiers in the Battle of Five Armies. So for the most part, everyone has a bit of armor that could do with a few repairs. I’d say half the stalls here are armorers or blacksmiths, though it’s many a soldier who can do that sort of thing for themself if they have the tools.”
Bilbo chuckled. “Well, in that case, I am not surprised that you believed this place would be of little interest to me. I don’t suppose there’s a fruit shop?”
Dori patted his arm. “There is an inn just here. Hearty stews, crusty bread, and dwarven beer for the asking, if you’re hungry. Although it is probably not as nice as what Bombur has for you, if we turn back.”
Sniffing the air, Bilbo detected rather more grease and gristle than one would wish for in a stew and politely demurred. You never need to visit the first inn you happen across in a marketplace. In a marketplace, there are bound to be other options. Happily, the dwarf did not press. Leading him on, Dori began to tell Bilbo all about the rather limited selection of textiles available. It did seem to be a rather bleak situation, but Dori knew a good yarn merchant who didn’t overcharge too much despite the scarcity of his goods.
As the dwarf continued talking, his voice faded into the background and another scent captured Bilbo’s attention. This was not the smell of hundreds of hardworking dwarves walking past. Nor was it the scent of goats who bathed even less frequently and occasionally did what goats would do in the middle of a public avenue. No, this was a very pleasing aroma, which teased Bilbo’s nose like a comic drawing in a children’s book. Although he was unable to see, he imagined it like a visible trail, leading through the marketplace.
“This way,” he said firmly, tugging Dori’s arm gently.
Naturally, the cautious dwarf hesitated to follow a blind hobbit’s lead. “Ah, Bilbo, my friend, I am very sorry to say that this is not the way to my friend the yarn merchant.”
Bilbo patted his arm. “Do forgive me, Dori. May we not visit your friend’s shop in a short while? Only I rather think this brief detour will be quite rewarding. If it is not worth your time, I promise to go back to my sick room at once like a good little invalid.”
Dori shrugged. Bilbo could feel it in the way his arm moved.
“Lead the way, then,” the dwarf said. And so Bilbo did. Following his nose and making sure to test the ground in front of them, with his stick, the little hobbit strode confidently through the busy marketplace. The pair must have made quite a sight, with a blind fellow leading someone dressed in the sort of sartorial finery that Dori favored. In fact, it wasn’t long before Bilbo started to catch the gossipers at work.
“That’s Lord Dori, that is.”
“—must be the Dragonslayer.”
“Well, I don’t know. I’ve never seen a halfling before. My cousin says—”
“Blind as a bat, you know.”
“—be taller. Looks like a babe, all pink and hairless.”
“You should give it to him. I’m sure he’d be gracious—”
“The Stiffbeards say he’s some sort of spirit. Not of this world.”
“Bimbo. Didn’t you hear the king’s battle cry? No mistaking it. Definitely Bimbo.”
“Well, let’s follow, then. If they are going to the Hammer ‘n Tongs, we can spot him a pint. The Dragonslayer. D’you know—”
“I thought he’d be shorter. Practically of a height with Lord Dori.”
“—an embarrassment. Look at Lord Dori’s clothes. And that’s the best that they give the Dragonslayer? No gold at all. Ought to have a few earrings at least, I say, even if his hair is too short for—”
Smiling to himself, Bilbo let Dori lead him around a clothier’s street display before correcting the dwarf’s direction back toward the wonderful smell.
“Where are we going?” the polite fellow asked finally. Bilbo was impressed by his patience. Well bred or not, the Baggins would have demanded an explanation much sooner in the walk. Fortunately, the timing worked out perfectly.
“Here,” Bilbo declared, executing a perfect right turn and waving his walking stick to show Dori their final destination.
A long moment passed. Despite the noise of the street, everything seemed very quiet suddenly. Finally, Dori said, “Ah, Bilbo? This is a stone wall. There’s nothing here.”
“Oh.” Sheepishly, Bilbo turned them around to face the opposite direction. “Here?” he said hopefully. “If not, then somewhere very nearby.”
Dori laughed. “Here, indeed. I see your destination now, Bilbo, and smell it, though I am amazed that you could from so far away.” Stepping forward smartly, the dwarf placed their order. “Two, please.”
“You’re Lord Dori,” said an astonished voice. It sounded young, and, unless Bilbo was mistaken, feminine.
“Indeed I am, my good dwarf,” Dori said. “This is my friend, Master Baggins. Might I be privileged to know your name? And the name of your fine establishment, if it has one.”
“Master Dragonslayer, I think you mean!” Definitely young, and rather excitable. “Sorry, sir. I’m Zindi, daughter of Zani, at your service, sir. My cart doesn’t have a name. Begging your pardon, sir. It’s only a cart. But here you are. At my cart! Two, you said? Oh, no charge, sir. Not to the Dragonslayer.”
This prospect made Bilbo rather uncomfortable, but he couldn’t rightly insist since he was relying on Dori for the actual purchase. Although he was one of the fourteen wealthiest people in the mountain, presumably, Bilbo didn’t actually have a coin purse with him. So he could not press money on the vendor.
Fortunately, Dori held a similar sentiment when it came to taking advantage of young entrepreneurs just starting out in their business. “That is kind of you, thank you dearie. So that’s one free to Bilbo, and I’ll buy three for myself. I’m sure these are very filling, but we forgot to bring proper provisions along on this walk of ours. I need to build up my strength to keep up with the hero.”
Zindi laughed, and Bilbo lost Dori’s arm. A few coins clinked and the wonderful smell was suddenly appetizingly close. One free in a batch of four was still a very good deal, but at least there was likely some small profit for the lass in the bargain.
“There’s a little bench just here, Bilbo,” Dori said.
“Indeed there is, sirs. Original stonework from before the dragon, or so I’m told. That’s why I set up my cart here. You wouldn’t be my first customers to enjoy a bit of a sit and a place to put your shopping while you eat.”
Bilbo smiled at Zindi. It was a little tricky to feel his way over to the bench with his walking stick and his hand, but the hobbit was grateful that the dwarves let him do it without fussing. Though perhaps it was not mere deference to his feelings, for Dori obviously had his hands full, and Zindi suddenly had a rush of other customers.
“Apparently he smelled it all the way from the other side of the market.”
“They say hobbits are very knowledgeable about food.”
“Must be worth trying if—”
“—just as strange as the Stiffbeards say.”
“Well, if they’re good enough for the Dragonslayer, they’re good enough for me!”
“Six please! I’m headed back to my mates. Do you have anything I can carry them with?”
Once Bilbo was seated with his walking stick propped up against his leg, Dori handed him a warm pastry wrapped in a napkin. Sniffing it deeply, Bilbo sighed. His mouth watered. “Ah,” he said. “Nothing like a meat pie from a market stand. They are meat pies, aren’t they? Could be dumplings, I thought at first, but the crust smells—”
“Very fine meat pies indeed,” Dori said, after a quick swallow. “Hot, though, so do take care.”
Lifting the steaming pie to his lips, Bilbo took a slow bite. Buttery crust flaked away under his teeth, dissolving on his tongue. Steam tickled his nose and a hint of gravy teased him dreadfully, but he was not a fauntling. He waited, anticipating all of the delicious things he could smell: well cooked meat, cumin, fennel, onion, garlic, and a dozen other spices. Finally, he gave in to temptation. Piping hot, the pie filled his mouth with the familiar flavors of salt, grease, and so much good gravy.
Bilbo devoured it neatly in less than a minute and tapped Dori’s arm for another, which was instantly supplied.
A hobbit’s hunger was never wholly absent. Even after a proper all day feast, there were always a few corners that wanted filling in. There was always room for some tidbit, if it tasted nice or was a particular favorite. Still, the most urgent part of the demand could be met somewhat, and two pies just about did the trick. Bilbo lingered over the third happily.
“Nothing like a good meat pie,” he said cheerfully, taking a bite of the nicely cooled pastry. “I feel like I’ve been wanting a meat pie for two years together. You just can’t make them properly at home, you know. Not a real hand pie. It’s not the same. Has to come from a marketplace or a Free Fair after you’ve been walking around a bit. Why, it’s the third most important thing you can get at a market, now I come to think of it.”
Chuckling politely, Dori took the bait. “And what are the other two important things for which a hobbit visits the market?”
“News and gossip,” Bilbo said at once. “Though it can be hard to tell the difference, of course. All in all, one is safest with the meat pie. Still, if that’s your brother Nori’s new cologne I smell, wave him over. We’ll see if we can’t get a bit of the others.”
There was a rustle of fabric just barely audible over the din of the marketplace, and Bilbo imagined Dori looking around quickly. Then the dwarf said, “And what are you doing lurking over there?”
Nori sauntered over with his light footed swagger, not nearly as noisy as the tramp of other dwarves. “Looking for you, brother,” he said smoothly. “It’s been hours since the pair of you went out for a walk, and I missed the dulcet tones of your constant nagging.”
Bilbo laughed. “How did you find us?”
“Just asked myself where I could find the best snack and headed for it,” Nori said easily. “To be honest, this is my third stop. Checked the royal kitchens first, then that tea shop over on Goldbrick Lane. I know Dori likes it.”
Considering the idea thoughtfully, Bilbo said, “Well, unless you would like a meat pie as well, perhaps we ought to adjourn to—”
“A proper pub?” Nori suggested quickly. “I want chips and a drink that a dwarf can actually taste.”
Dori sniffed. “You have no appreciation for the finer things, brother of mine. Anyway, I’m sure Bilbo was about to suggest returning to his rooms. It’s been a long walk, and I’m certain that our hobbit would like a rest.”
“Actually, a pub sounds lovely,” Bilbo said brightly. “Only mind you choose one with good beer, Nori. I haven’t had a proper half-pint since Laketown, and that has to be months ago now.”
“I know just the place,” Nori said, waiting patiently for Bilbo to rise on his own and gather his cane. The moment he was standing, however, the dwarf grabbed the hobbit’s arm and whisked him off down the path at a much less sedate pace than Dori’s.
“You’re heading for the Silver Shield?” Dori asked.
“Nah, I thought the Hammer and Tongs would be Bilbo’s kind of place.”
“Nori.” Bilbo didn’t need to look at Dori’s face to hear how annoyed he was, but he imagined that Nori—who could see the mighty little dwarf’s expression—got the picture.
“Course I’m taking him to the Silver Shield, Dori. It’s got the best beer under the mountain. Give me some credit for taste.”
“Very well then.” Dori’s voice was full of the usual easy politeness, and he seemed molified by the choice of pub. “I shall meet you there in an hour or so.”
“Oh!” Bilbo was so angry with Thorin, it hadn’t even occurred to him that deviating from his usual activities might inconvenience Dori. Of course the dwarf had other things to do with his time. After all, he would not have spent the whole of his morning in Bilbo’s sick room. Usually they would take tea and biscuits together for an hour or so before some other visitor came around.
Bilbo released Nori’s arm and turned in the direction of Dori’s voice. Tucking his walking stick in the crook of his left elbow, he offered his right hand to the air. It was immediately grasped in a firm dwarven handshake. “Thank you very much for coming along on my little adventure, Dori.”
Suddenly, there was a tug on his hand and a warm forehead pressed against his own. Then Dori stepped away, and the cool, cavernous air of the mountain filled the distance between them.
“Forgive the liberty,” the dwarf said, very politely, “but I would take it as a kindness to be included in all of your adventures, Master Baggins.”
Smiling very softly, Bilbo gave Dori a wave and a nod. “In that case, I’ll see you later my friend.” Then his arm was taken up once more by Nori, and they were off to the pub.
Walking with Nori was very different from walking with Dori. There was certainly no stream of polite chatter about the shops and their various wares. Nori bounced along with barely contained energy, and he was far more concerned with the streets and avenues themselves.
“Right here, on Shaleblock Road. Don’t know if you can feel the difference under your feet, but it’s a nice, wide boulevard, all shale. Very easy on the cart wheels, so of course it’s full of them. I’d recommend keeping to one side, though no one goes too fast. Still, you can’t count on some of these blighters to stop for anyone. That bastard with a mangy old billy near just ran a child over.”
“Oh dear! Should we see if they’re alright?”
“Nah. Little wastrel’s fine. Tugging at his mum’s vambraces and beggin’ for sweets already. Anyway, this is our turning. Left onto Quartzcobble Lane. Feel ‘em? They just finished repaving it. Blasted dragon tore the whole thing up, along with Goldbrick and any other street with a bit of shine to it. I mean, Goldbrick I can understand, but quartz isn’t worth anything. It was all clear stones before, when I was a kid. Used to shine like diamonds, so maybe that’s why. Almost like it better now, with a bit of rose quartz mixed in. Gives the place some personality.”
“Do you mean to say that there’s actually a street paved with gold somewhere in this marketplace?”
“Course! Don’t know how you hobbits ever find your way around in the Shire, where all the roads look the same and are paved with the same stuff. Goldbrick is mostly an alloy, of course, not what you’d call pure gold. It’d be all dinged up by the first cartwheel to drive down it, if it was pure gold. Even so, no one without a storefront is allowed to drive a cart along it. Very posh address. That’s why Dori takes his tea there. They barely let us walk down it in the old days. Now we could buy and sell the whole street if we had a mind. And Dori does. He’s landlord to half the block. Not my idea of a sound investment. Too much overhead. But he likes the respectability. Tied up more than half his share of the treasure right away, building it back up and finding tenants and everything. Another left here.”
“Onto Marbleslab Road?” Bilbo guessed, feeling the smooth, polished stone beneath his feet.
“Close!” Nori said. “Graniteblock Road. You’ve got the convention down, though. The big roads are blocks of something tough and smooth, not little bricks or cobbles. Best to keep to the side because of all the carts. Mostly we call them blocks, not slabs. Not sure why. Sounds better, I suppose. Good guess on the marble, too. Even a dwarf would have trouble telling the difference between polished granite and polished marble by touch, especially when the street sweepers buff it twice a month. Anyway, here we are! Corner of Graniteblock and Obsidian Alley.”
“Just Obsidian?” Bilbo was slightly surprised by that.
“Give it a step,” Nori said.
A certain smugness, hidden in the dwarf’s voice, advised the hobbit to be very careful indeed as he stepped forward onto the slickest surface he’d ever had occasion to walk on. Even with his stick, Bilbo almost fell. Quickly retreating to the sturdy granite blocks, he said, “It’s like walking on ice!”
Nori laughed. “If you could see it, you might call it beautiful. The whole thing is a perfect stretch of obsidian. Shatters so easily, obsidian does, that they say it was the find of a lifetime, back when it was lain. Course, no one thought about what kind of a street it would make, and now it’s been here so long that no one wants to get rid of it. Survived Smaug. Practically a historical landmark. Doesn’t matter that you can’t take a cart down it without crashing the thing at the other end, or that half the pedestrians end up on their asses at some point.”
Bilbo laughed too. “Not the address I’d choose for a pub.”
“Ah, well. Had to take what he could get, didn’t he? Gendor, I mean, the owner. Wasn’t one of the soldiers who set up shop instead of leaving with Dain. They got first pick of locations, obviously. That’s how Dori was able to rebuild almost half a street alone.”
“Alone?”
Nori snickered. “Hiring help. Obviously. Dori’s strong, but even he can’t raise ten buildings in two months on his own. Come on. There’s two steps up to the door. Dwarf sized, not hobbit sized.”
Bilbo appreciated the warning, and didn’t bother to correct Nori. No reputable hobbit pub would have steps of any size. Even so, he was happy to negotiate the minor obstacle and leave the cool air of the street for the warm hearth of a common room, the familiar smell of hearty food, and the cozy hum of friendly conversations. As the door closed, the sounds of hawkers and smell of goats were shut outside. In fact, all sound stopped. The gentle chatter and the click of stoneware against stone tables included. For a moment, Bilbo wondered if he was losing his hearing as well as his sight.
“Ho there! Nori!” Bilbo suddenly had the impression of another person standing right in front of him. Perhaps it was the volume of the voice or the warmth that dwarves seemed to radiate at all times.
“Hullo Gendor,” Nori said jovially.
“Welcome! Welcome to the Silver Shield!”
“Thanks. I’ve been here before.” Once again, that slightly cruel sense of humor was in Nori’s voice. Bilbo wondered who was about to step on something slippery.
“Indeed you have! Indeed you have, Master Nori. Your usual table is open, if you’re expecting Company,” Gendor said. “First pint is always free, to members of the Company.”
“Kind of you,” Nori said, “but we can afford to pay.”
Bilbo bit his lip to hide a smile. So that was it, eh? Well, he didn’t mind. “Bilbo Baggins, at your service.” He managed the best bow he could offer with the walking stick in hand. “If we wait for Nori to introduce us, he’ll make us wait all day.”
“Gendor, son of Grandor, at the service of you and your family, Master Baggins. This way, this way! Master Nori enjoys a corner booth, but we’ve a lovely table in the window if you prefer.”
Although he suspected Gendor would very much prefer to have the Dragonslayer sitting in a window where any passersby could see, Bilbo said, “A booth would be lovely. Let’s leave the view for someone who will enjoy it. And I’d prefer a half-pint, if you have a suitable mug and it isn’t too much of an inconvenience.”
“Of course, Master Baggins. Of course! We pride ourselves on service here at the Silver Shield. Do you prefer ale, beer, or small beer?”
Off to the side, Bilbo heard a dwarf grumble, “Service? Never heard him string more than ten words together before today. I give him a nod; I get a beer.”
“Good beer, though,” someone else said.
“Aye. Best beer under the mountain. No question about that.”
The hobbit smiled. “Which do you recommend, Master Gendor?”
There was a slight pause, then Gendor said, “Well, at midday, most prefer my small beer. It’s refreshing and will warm you up for your afternoon work. But if you haven’t got any afternoon work to go to, I’d recommend the ale. It’s a good, strong winter warmer, and I’m rather proud of it, to tell the truth.”
“I would be pleased to try it,” Bilbo said, sliding into the booth. “Nori?”
“Fish and chips with extra chips, and a pint of the same,” the dwarf said amiably.
“As you say, just a moment,” Gendor said jovially. Indeed, it was less than a minute before he was back, placing a stoneware mug in front of Bilbo and a plate somewhere nearby. “Here we are then!”
Bilbo felt the dwarf’s hovering presence, even after he said thank you. Lifting the mug to his lips, the hobbit took a slow sip. The ale was cool in temperature but warm in effect. Just what one wanted on a winter’s day, and it had a full, rich flavor. “Delightful!” he proclaimed, and it was not mere politeness. “Indeed, the chorus of praise your brews receive is well warranted, and I find that I must join my voice to it at once, Master Gendor.”
“Thank you, Master Baggins. Thank you very kindly. Just give us a wave if you’re needing anything else.”
“We will,” Nori said, quite rudely. “Now shove off. In a minute, your other customers are going to stop staring at us and realize they’ve got orders waiting and food getting cold.”
From the snort Nori gave, Bilbo suspected that Gendor departed with a glare or an equally rude gesture, but the publican did depart. Taking another sip of his beer, Bilbo let his ears fill with the sound of recommencing conversations and his nose enjoy the familiar aroma of Nori’s chips.
“I say,” he began after a moment, but he got no further. Stoneware slid over the polished table with a gentle scrape.
“Help yourself,” Nori said, referring to the offered plate. “Got extra chips so we could share.”
“Thank you, Nori.” Bilbo did, indeed, help himself. The chips were just as nice as the beer: thick enough so that you could taste the potato, but thin enough to be fluffy and well cooked the whole way through. “And thank you for taking the time to tell me about the streets. I’m sure Dori would have, but I somehow got the impression that he doesn’t like the idea of me wandering about on my own anytime soon.”
Nori laughed. “Ach. Streets are important. I figured one of us owed it to you to tell you about them before—well. As Dori might say, it wouldn’t do for you to think Thorin came up with it all on his own.”
Beer turned to bile in Bilbo’s mouth. Choking down the liquid, he picked up his stick. “You knew?” he demanded. “You were part of that despicable deception?”
“What?” Nori’s voice was surprised. All innocence. But then, he was a criminal, wasn’t he? He was probably very well versed at feigning innocence.
“You’re as bad as he is! To come out walking with me, pretending everything is normal, when you were a party to that ignoble, hateful, loathsome lie the whole time! Did Dori know, too? Are all of you just pretending to be my friends?”
“Bilbo!” The hand on the hobbit’s arm was very light for a dwarf. “I am your friend, but I have no idea what you’re talking about.”
“Oh.” Bilbo sat back down, sheepishly. His face was rather hot from all the shouting. He took a sip of his beer. He ate another chip.
After quite a while, Nori said, “So. You and Thorin had a row, then?”
“Yes.” Bilbo’s mug was empty, but he wasn’t entirely sure that a second would be a good idea. One made him lightheaded. Two would probably make walking back to his miserable sick room over all that gold impossible. He signaled the publican.
When they had their second round and a few more chips, Nori asked, “Do you want to talk about it?”
“No.”
For a moment, Bilbo worried that the silence was too awkward to break. Unlike his brothers, Nori didn’t have very much in common with a bookish homebody, and he wasn’t really one for small talk. Fortunately, they were saved by the slamming open of a door, the tramp of feet, and happily chorused cries of, “Bilbo!”
Fili and Kili bounced into the booth, Kili pressing against Bilbo’s side to make room for others. Listening carefully to the cadence of footfalls, smelling oiled leather, ink, and tea, Bilbo thought he identified everyone.
“Hello Fili, Kili, Dwalin, Ori, Dori, Bofur, and Bifur! Am I missing anyone? Seems we’ve half the company here now. I didn’t realize the booth was that big.”
“It’s not,” Bofur said. Someone laughed.
“How did you know us?” Kili demanded. “Do you and Nori have secret signals? You should teach them to us. I’m great at Iglishmêk.”
“You sign like a squirrel with a broken hand,” Fili said. “But you should teach us anyway, Bilbo. We all want to help you.”
“I’m as surprised as you lot,” Nori said. “I didn’t give him a hint.”
Dwalin snorted in disbelief. “And we’ll all take your word for that, right enough,” he said sarcastically.
“I know you because you’re my friends,” Bilbo said. And because they were his friends, he did not add, ‘Blind I may be, but no one is going to trick me again.’
“More importantly,” Bofur said, “Why didn’t you tell us you were coming out to the pub? Letting Nori buy your first round. I question the very foundation of our friendship.”
Whatever the foundation of their friendship might be, it seemed able to bear the weight of a round for everyone, and a very merry gathering commenced. Instruments were found, and other musicians joined the Company in lively songs. Fili and Kili insisted that Bilbo leave the booth to learn a little jig. Although it took him some time to get the hang of it, eventually the hobbit was whirling down a line of partners laughing as he went.
Two dances was, perhaps, two too many for a recovering body. Bilbo slumped back to the booth with a pint of the small beer and his own plate of fish and chips, but he was very happy to do so. Certainly, he did not lack for company. Ori regaled him with tales of the slow reclamation of Erebor’s library, promising to transcribe any books that sounded interesting into the runic language which could be read by touch. Dwalin grunted a few words about the remodeled training yards for the army, which he seemed very proud of, and mentioned that Bilbo might enjoy a visit now that he was up and about.
“Don’t be daft,” Kili said, flopping down next to Bilbo, smelling of sweat and far more ale than the hobbit had consumed. “Bilbo would be bored to tears by the training yard. It’s not as though he was ever interested in practicing swordplay. We should go to the Cavern of Echoes. Fili and I have been saying for days. It’s incredible, Bilbo. You’ll love it.”
“Oh!” Fili’s voice was bright and eager. “Are we going to the caverns now? We ought to get Uncle. He’s got the voice to make the place sing properly.”
“I’m afraid that I’m rather tired,” Bilbo said quickly, without thinking.
He had cause to regret it at once. No sooner did he speak, but Dori answered. “Of course you are. And so am I. It has been a long day, after all. Do allow me to see you back to your room, Bilbo, and we’ll leave this lot to their little riot.”
“Er, no thank you.” The party that filled the pub was still going strong. Music and the rhythmic dancing of dwarven boots filled his ears, but Bilbo was very aware that all the dwarves in his immediate vicinity had gone quiet.
“No fear, Bilbo,” Fili said bracingly. “Now that you’re up and about, we can come down to the pub every day, if you like.”
“You can’t, Crown Prince,” Dwalin said sternly. But his voice was much kinder when he added, “Though if Bilbo wants to spend his days in song, there will be many to join him.”
“Indeed,” Dori agreed. “However, I think it’s time to call it a day. What do you think, Bilbo?”
Denying how tired he was would be futile. The hobbit did want to turn in, but he couldn’t face the prospect of heading back. Walking across all of that gold again would be awful. Going back to the sickroom—full of the smell of ointments and a dozen reminders of Thorin’s lies—was inconceivable.
“Is this place an inn?” he asked, “Or just a pub? Only, perhaps they have beds for rent somewhere, and I can have a little kip here. No need to go all the way back to my own room.”
“Sorry!” Kili’s voice was rather too cheerful to suit Bilbo’s mood, suddenly. It wasn’t the lad’s fault, of course, but Bilbo shouldn’t have to pretend to be pleased about facing that awful place again. “I think Gendor has ideas about adding rooms one day, but everyone is still getting up and running. All he really has is a kitchen and the common room.”
“Not that he wouldn’t give you his own bed if you asked,” Nori put in, “but I happen to know for a fact that he sleeps next to the fire here in the common room. He’s got a little fur rug, but it’s not nearly as comfortable as your room.”
“Right.” Bilbo knew that the kingdom under the mountain was still being rebuilt. Thorin came to him daily with concerns about feeding, housing, and ensuring the safety of the slowly growing populace. Even so, he wasn’t the sort to give up without a fight. “I don’t suppose any of you live nearby? I hate to impose, but I would do very well in an armchair. I don’t need a bed.”
“Course you don’t,” Bofur said. “You’d be happy to sleep in the street, I’m sure, and it’s nothing to do with the length of the walk back to your room. Apropo of nothing, why don’t we flag down a cart? It could take us as far as the treasure room without anyone needing to be carried.”
Deep within Bilbo’s heart, the flame of hope died. He smiled. “That would be lovely. Thank you, Bofur.”
“It wouldn’t!” Kili’s voice was full of the sort of outrage which usually accompanied accusations of murder. “He’s doing the thing! Where he says no the first time you offer him tea, even though he really does want it, because who knows why. I know this one. Bilbo: I was going to put the kettle on anyway.”
Someone laughed.
“How drunk are you?” Fili asked.
“Well, I’m not sober,” Kili admitted slowly. “But I’m not wrong, either. Am I, Bilbo?”
Reaching out, Bilbo patted the young prince’s arm. “You’re a very good boy, Kili, and I’m glad to know you.” Finding his stick, he levered himself up from the bench. “Now, how exactly do we go about hiring a cart?”
“Wouldn’t be kettles,” Bofur muttered. Then he said, “Bilbo, as it happens, Bombur and I do have a little sofa at our place. Won’t be half as comfortable as your bed, you’d have to put up with Bombur’s snoring, and it’s nowhere close by. But we’d be happy to have you. You know my brother does a good breakfast, too, first thing in the morning.”
The hobbit was well and truly trapped. Worse, he knew it. Accepting the offer would be the same as admitting he had no pride at all. Every Baggins bone in his body rebelled against the mere thought. At the very least, he ought to wait until Bofur insisted a bit. But Bofur was a dwarf. He wouldn’t insist. And even Bilbo’s Tookish spirit was not brave enough to walk across those gold coins again, remembering dragons. He took the bait.
“Thank you, Bofur. That sounds delightful.”
Once again, the party continuing elsewhere in the public house seemed to grow very loud as all the dwarves near Bilbo were suspiciously quiet.
“Right,” Dori said suddenly. “That’s enough of that. Bilbo is tired. Let’s see him to someplace more comfortable than his sickroom where he can have a lie down.”
“Sure,” Fili said. “Kili and I will just—”
“Naturally,” Bofur said. “And I’ll duck outside to flag down a cart. Won’t be a moment.”
The trouble was, Bilbo really did feel exhausted. He heard Dwalin tromping off, Fili and Kili bouncing away, and he knew the others were up to something. Well. It wasn’t his job to sort everyone out. The dwarves could look after themselves in their own mountain. If they happened to work out that Bilbo was less than satisfied with his accommodations—locked away in Thorin’s treasure room like just another fancy cup whose feelings didn’t matter at all—that wasn’t his fault. He’d been polite about it. For nearly two months. Even the best manners had their limits.
Bilbo chose to ignore the fact that he’d been happy enough with the little room while recuperating. Bilbo chose to ignore a number of facts, because a hobbit could only deal with so much when he was very tired. Leaning a bit on Dori’s arm, he said, “I’m sure Bofur and I will be just fine on our own.”
“Yes, yes,” Dori said, “But you’re taking a cart and going my way. You don’t mind a little company, do you?”
“Never,” Bilbo swore. When it came to the dwarves of the Company, he even meant it. They were rude, ill mannered, and smelled like a barn full of goats, but he would rather be with them in the wilderness than alone in Bag End with a seven course meal on the table.
That said, it was still their turn to look after things. Bilbo let Dori hand him up to Bofur in the cart like a child. The cart was a sturdy wooden construction, clearly designed for carrying goods, not people. While the sides were smooth and lacquered, there were no seats. Bilbo found a corner and sat on the floor. As the goat trotted, the cart didn’t seem to bounce much, even over cobblestones. Bilbo only felt the movement when his head fell to the side, and his temple rested against the wall. Even then, the cart just rattled a little in a soothing vibration, rather like the cheerful lull of dwarven voices filling the street around.
Hands on his jacket woke Bilbo with a start. Kicking out hard, he rolled to the side and away. Everything was dark. Mirkwood. Couldn’t see an inch in front of your face in Mirkwood, but at least an attacker had the same disadvantage. Crying out to wake the others, Bilbo felt around in the darkness for Sting. The sword wasn’t on his belt—he couldn’t seem to find his bedroll—but he came up with a walking stick.
“Bilbo! Bilbo! It’s us!” Bofur’s voice was urgent.
“Spiders again?” the hobbit asked muzzily as memory returned to him. Then he blinked. He still couldn’t see, but he knew it was not the darkness of Mirkwood that filled his eyes.
“No,” Balin said kindly. “There are no spiders here. We’re under the mountain, remember? We made it. We won.”
“Balin?” Bilbo shook his head. “You weren’t in the pub with us?”
“The pub,” Oin grumbled somewhere off to the side. “The pub. Two months thankless work bringing him back to life after dragonfire that would have killed a normal person. Thought I had a reasonable patient at last. Steady recuperation, light exercise, and healthy food. That was my recommendation. Does he listen? I thought he did. I thought he was an intelligent one. Find out he’s been dancing and drinking and tying one on, and was I even invited?”
“No, I wasn’t,” Balin said. His voice was warm and calm, just as it always was, answering Bilbo’s question. “But I wanted to be here for this. We all wanted to be here for this.”
Bilbo could hear the occasional snort of the goat at the front of the cart, but he couldn’t hear any other dwarves. That wasn’t because they weren’t there. Dwarves could be remarkably still sometimes. The second they moved, they made enough noise to rival an oliphant, but when they were still, they were statues. Bilbo could smell Nori’s cologne and Ori’s inks, Fili’s leather and the scent of flowers that always seemed to follow Kili these days. Sudden suspicion entered his mind and he asked, “Is the entire company here?”
Balin hesitated. “Not the entire company.”
“I have no idea why.” Fili sounded angry. Far more so than Oin. “Uncle and Balin were together, but Thorin refused to come away. He said he was too busy. For this.”
“Ah.” Bilbo felt his face flush, but hoped that the dwarves would attribute that to the effects of his nap. “Who did I kick just now, then? I’m terribly sorry.” It was an inelegant change of subject, but it worked.
“That would be me,” Dori said. “And it was my fault entirely. You looked so peaceful sleeping in the cart there, I thought I would just carry you off to bed. But you’ve made your feelings on being carried very clear, now that it’s not a matter of fleeing from goblins and escaping death. I shouldn’t have tried it.”
Straightening up, Bilbo said, “Thank you, Dori, for respecting my pride, but I’m still sorry.”
“Then I accept your apology, and we’ll say no more about it.”
“Now.” Balin stepped forward, taking Bilbo’s arm gently. In part, the gesture was simple, expedient guidance. On a deeper level, however, Bilbo appreciated knowing exactly where at least one person was. It gave him a connection that the sound of footsteps, smell of dwarf, and all his other little tricks simply couldn’t. He missed seeing faces. “Let’s see you settled for the evening, Master Baggins. This is the High Hall, also called the First Tunnel and, more colloquially, Durin’s Dugout. There are two guards on duty at all times, and it’s their job to open the door for you. They’ll also greet you respectfully when you approach.”
Balin paused briefly and two voices Bilbo didn’t recognize chorused, “Good Evening Master Baggins,” as though they had been tutored.
Bilbo smiled and returned the greeting.
Together with the entire company, the hobbit passed between the guards and proceeded up a sloping corridor. It was not as wide as the roads in the marketplace, but four could walk abreast very comfortably. After only a few paces, Dwalin spoke up.
“This is my home here, on the left, with the knocker shaped like a triangle.”
“Oh!” Rather surprised, Bilbo asked, “Am I to stay with you this evening, then?”
“No,” Dwalin said. “But you should know the place if you ever need me.”
Nothing would do then but to stop the entire procession so that Bilbo could find Dwalin’s arm, give it a pat, and thank him for the kind gesture.
A little way on, Gloin said, “And this is my home here on the right, with Oin’s directly across the hall on the left.” Apparently Gloin’s door knocker was set with square cut sapphires. Bilbo had a hard enough time telling two jewels apart when he could see, but the little squares were easy enough to feel under his hand. By contrast, Oin’s door had a sort of bell pull that apparently flashed lights around his home somehow in deference to his difficulty hearing.
Just beyond Gloin and Oin was Balin’s home, with a knocker shaped like the head of a dwarf, his long beard on a hinge that swung up and down to do the actual knocking. Bilbo hid his smile at the novelty, privately thinking it was a rather silly place to put a likeness, but he did enjoy it. Napping in the cart had been rather revitalizing, and he was in a proper mood to go visiting.
Across the corridor from Balin was another door. Unlike the others, it was made of wood, and circular instead of square. There was no knocker. One didn’t need a knocker on a wooden door. Instead, there was a brass knob right in the center.
“It’s green, too,” Bofur said from somewhere far away. “We didn’t know if it mattered or not, about the green, but His Majesty thought it might be lucky.”
Turning the knob, Bilbo stepped through. He didn’t bother knocking. It was his house. There was a stiff, welcoming mat in front of the door, and some sort of boot scrape beside it which all of the dwarves used faithfully. Then the floor was comfortable hardwood. Bilbo ran his hand along the wall, and found a coat rack with fourteen pegs, an end table for his post, and a neat little umbrella stand for walking sticks and suchlike. As he stepped beyond the entryway, his toes sank into a deep, lush carpet.
“There’s carpet around all of the furniture, so you don’t bump into anything,” Balin said, with a gentle haste that caused Bilbo to put his hand out, feeling the back of an armchair.
Exploring further, the hobbit found armchairs, a sofa, a plush little ottoman, and smooth tables exactly where he wanted them. Just space enough for about half of the company to take tea comfortably. Then he was on hardwood again, and he noticed that the grain of the boards ran parallel to the walls, so he turned and found the rough stone that outlined a fireplace. There was already a warm blaze in the grate. Reaching down, he felt a woodpile, kindling, and a sturdy poker just where they ought to be. Rising, Bilbo continued his exploration to the next room.
Leaving one room and entering another, the hobbit noticed the floor change beneath his feet to hexagonal tiles and held out a hand. The inference was correct. His hand connected with something wooden and smooth. Instead of asking the dwarves shadowing him, he felt his way around the structure, step by step. It was a dinner table. Much larger than his table in Bag End, although there were only ten chairs.
“Not fourteen?” Bilbo tried to temper his grin as the dwarves stumbled over themselves to explain about the extendable nature of the table. Then he stumbled a bit as Kili tugged him hurriedly toward the wall to take note of the extra chairs around the outer edges of the room.
“It actually seats twenty very easily, and don’t you worry a bit about it,” the prince insisted. “Fili and I will put the added leaves in any time you like.”
The outer walls of the room also had china cabinets and linen cupboards, Bilbo was pleased to note. “It’s very clever to have this hexagonal tile all around the cabinets, too,” he said. “I certainly won’t bump into anything, and it will be very easy to keep clean.”
“That was Thorin’s idea,” Balin said gently. “He designed the entire floor-plan himself, though he was not able to build as much as he would have liked personally. I am very sure that he would like to be here, if—”
“I will not see him!”
Bilbo’s voice was sharp enough to cut steel. There was a collective gasp from the dwarves trailing him through his new home. Balin made a soft noise of dismay.
Slowly, the hobbit took a deep breath. That was twice in one day he’d taken his temper out on Balin when he really wanted to yell at someone else. “Sorry, Balin, more sorry than I can say. I know it is not your fault, but I would like to be clear about this. Given my preference, I would not see Thorin Oakenshield again, even if it meant I could see all the rest of the world as well.”
Everyone around Bilbo was absolutely silent. Still, in that way that folk made of stone could sometimes be. With a little huff, the hobbit strode away from Balin and continued his explorations. When the tile beneath his feet changed to a broad, square pattern, Bilbo discovered a new room, leaving the dwarves behind.
Blind though he was, Bilbo had no difficulty discerning the nature of this room. It was a kitchen. It was his kitchen, only slightly rearranged. To his left there was a sink, to his right there was a little stove. Beyond that was a lovely oven. The counters and cabinets were all smooth wood, and when Bilbo stretched out a hand, he found the kettle exactly where one ought to hang it. Fetching it down, he filled it and put it on the stovetop.
Tea was in a little cupboard just above the sink. No one had to tell Bilbo where to find it. However, for the first time he paused. There were six different jars with six different varieties. Each one had runes around the outside, likely describing the tea within. The word “tea” was easy enough to make out. Beneath that the “black” and “green” jars were equally obvious. The others he had to open and sniff.
“I think I’ll have the chamomile,” the hobbit announced. “Would anyone else care for a cup? Shall I make a pot?”
Finally, someone else spoke. “A spot of chamomile tea sounds lovely to me,” Dori said.
“And me,” Balin agreed. “Please do make a pot.”
“It’s another beer for me!” Kili’s joviality was forced, but Bilbo appreciated the effort.
“Beer’s about all we have to offer,” Bombur grumbled. “I haven’t had a chance to stock the larders. Not really. Wasn’t expecting move in day just yet. There’s only beer, barley, flour, and other things as don’t go bad.”
“We’ve made do with less,” Fili said, and the party recommenced.
