Actions

Work Header

None So Blind

Chapter 11: An Inconvenient Conversation

Chapter Text

As Dwalin said, Bilbo’s friends were more than willing to fill his days with song. The Cavern of Echoes was every bit the wonder Fili promised. One voice turned into a thousand there, and a single harp became a symphony. A notable master of the instrument played a concert for their little group which brought Bilbo to tears. Kili’s elven friend Tauriel sang a song of springtime, and Bilbo thought that Luthien the Nightingale could not sound sweeter. Even the hobbit’s own poor singing became something almost good, and he resolutely did not wonder about what Thorin’s voice could do in a place like that.

He did wish he could see the place. When the dwarves described it, they tended to use words like travertine and mineral deposit, and a lot of fancy terms for rock formations that often slipped into Khuzdul. Still, it sounded beautiful enough.

Anyway, Bilbo knew exactly what the inside of a pub looked like. Many a happy hour was wasted in the Silver Shield as well. Bofur knew dozens of musicians, less refined than the master harpist, who were happy to learn a few Shire songs and teach Bilbo dwarven ones in turn.

All of them did great justice to the beer. Oin was remarkably sanguine about Bilbo indulging now that they were indulging together. The healer enjoyed a good pint as much as the next dwarf, and Gandor was happy to serve. Bilbo did not wonder if Thorin would like the beer, or if the king’s presence would discombobulate the publican as much as a dragonslayer’s did.

He didn’t care.

Instead, he danced and drank and enjoyed his fish and chips. For variety, Tauriel occasionally sang in the elvish style, long ballads that brought Bilbo to tears. Mostly this happened when the party moved back to Bilbo’s hearth. Kili joked about not subjecting all of Obsidian Alley to elven music, but Bilbo suspected Tauriel was a bit shy about performing. Either way, the Company was remarkably tolerant of the change whenever it took place. They were remarkably tolerant about a great many things. Like the fact that Bilbo would nod off for long naps in the middle of the merriment, but wake and beg everyone to stay the moment he heard the music stop.

Nominally, it was a house warming, celebrating the fact that Bilbo was up and about. In truth, after a long journey, a battle, and constant work to put the mountain in order, everyone needed the chance to relax. Bilbo gave them an excuse. Like Dain gave Thorin an excuse after the Battle of Five Armies. Bilbo did not wonder if Thorin would enjoy the music. If Thorin wanted to join in, he should have been Bilbo’s friend instead of his keeper.

It was three full days before their party ended. Part of Bilbo wanted it to last forever, but when he came out of his bedroom after one of his naps, his head felt like a thousand dwarven hammers were pounding on his skull. Too long without a drink, perhaps, or a few too many in quick succession. Suddenly, the pleasant music was far too loud, and his friends were an annoyance.

The moment he complained, Oin was at his side. At once, the healer shouted the rest of the Company out of Bilbo’s little home. Only Tauriel was allowed to remain. Her professional opinion was that Bilbo had overindulged, which was true, but her expression of it caused Oin to exile her as well. Then, Bilbo was obliged to drink a truly awful concoction—which included a raw egg—and sent back to bed.

All told, it was probably the best ending that such a party could have. When Bilbo woke again, he was alone in an empty smial. Wrapping the blankets more firmly around his shoulders, he snuggled down into his soft bedding, enjoying the quiet. To his left, just on the edge of hearing, a clock ticked away the minutes. To his right, a warm fire crackled in the grate. Exactly what one wanted on a winter morning.

After a time, Bilbo reached out a lazy hand, feeling around for the button at the base of the clock. When he found it, the low, brassy bell tolled eight times, then a higher, silvery bell chimed twice. Half past eight in the morning. Breakfast.

Rolling out of bed, Bilbo pulled on a dressing gown and toddled off to the kitchen to put the kettle on. The sink was full of dishes, so Bilbo made a start on the washing up while he was waiting. Usually dwarves were very good about cleaning up as they went, but given their abrupt departure, Bilbo was happy to do it. They’d all been picking up after him for months.

The hobbit ruthlessly didn’t think about the extent to which the Company helped him clean.

The tea kettle whistled, interrupting the thoughts he wasn’t thinking, giving him an excuse to fry a few eggs instead. His new icebox was much larger and nicer than the one in Bag End, and the butter was so cold that it was practically a block of ice itself. Once it was in the pan, however, it sizzled a treat, and by the time Bilbo had a plate put together the butter was soft enough to spread evenly on his toast. A quiet breakfast was a small pleasure. Bilbo didn’t wonder if Thorin enjoyed the same.

Instead, he wandered his home, feeling about for cups and plates abandoned on end tables. Having twenty settings precisely was very helpful. He never would have found the beer mug half full and abandoned atop the pottery hutch in the dining room without being very certain that one was missing. Giving the tables a good wipe down after second breakfast only made sense. While he was at it, he decided to find the broom, sweep up, and dust the mantles. An orderly house made for an orderly mind, as his mother always said.

By elevenses, he was out of chores and decided it was long past time to get dressed.

In Bag End, the hobbit had whole rooms devoted entirely to clothes. Theoretically, he had the same in Erebor, but so far that only meant that he had a few mostly empty dressing rooms. Thanks to Dori, there was an admirable system for sorting clothes by type and then color in place, but there were not many clothes to be sorted in such a way. That was just as well. Bilbo was as open to the sartorial advice of a good tailor as the next hobbit, but he liked to make his own choices.

So he chose. Bilbo chose a fine silk shirt, a tweed waistcoat, and a warm wool jacket. Despite his trust in Dori’s system, he would have given a great deal to be able to look in a mirror. It was not the first time he’d dressed himself since the world went dark, but it was the first time he would be facing strangers without a friend to look him over first.

Confidence could make silk out of rags, his father used to say. Plucking a walking stick from the stand next to his front door, Bilbo Baggins went down to the market.

The walk was a rather long one. Following the stone roads of Erebor was easy enough, but in the darkness it required quite a lot of faith in his own memory. In the darkness, the path ahead seemed to stretch without end. Just when Bilbo began to suspect he was lost, the bustling sound of the marketplace ahead filled his ears. He was not relieved. To be relieved would be admitting that Thorin was right to worry in the first place.

He wasn’t. Obviously.

Upon reaching the Great Marketplace, Bilbo knew his way to the Silver Shield by rote. Unfortunately, the Silver Shield was not his destination. Instead of right, he turned left on Marbleslab, and made his way to the outermost edge of the market. When dwarven voices mixed with the voices of men, Bilbo knew he was in the right place.

Struck by a sudden suspicion, he stopped walking. “I can’t see you,” he announced, “but I know you’re there.”

For a moment, there was only the sound of the street: goats tripping past with their heavy carts, haggling, hawking, and grumbling voices. Then, Bilbo received his answer.

“How did you know?” Nori asked. “You said it was the scent of my hair oil before, so I changed to a different one.”

Rather than admitting to his lucky guess, Bilbo said, “Suffice it that I did know,” very shortly indeed. “Why are you following me? Did Thorin send you?”

“Nah.” Nori was dismissive enough that Bilbo actually believed him. “Just wanted to see if I could. One burglar to another, what gave me away?”

Sniffing, Bilbo resumed his walk.

“Alright then.” Bilbo could hear the shrug in his friend’s voice as the dwarf fell into step with him. “I won’t follow after, I’ll walk with you. Where are we going?”

“I am going to see about some fish for dinner,” the hobbit said. “I would prefer to do so alone.”

Nori hesitated. “The King really didn’t set me to following you.”

“But you told him you planned on it?” Fuming, Bilbo stopped walking to face his friend. How he wished he could glare! It was impossible to express himself without a proper glare.

“Told Dwalin,” Nori corrected. “He wants to have you guarded whenever you leave the Dugout. I figured you’d rather go walking with a friend.”

“I would rather do for myself,” Bilbo said firmly. “But do please come to tea this afternoon.”

“Bilbo.” Nori’s voice had a wheedling tone, and the hobbit imagined him raising his hands in a placating gesture. “You’re not just a little fellow any longer. There are more Men, Stiffbeards, and strangers in the mountain than folk we know and trust. If someone were to kidnap you, or strike at you to get to Thorin—”

“I don’t care! You tell Thorin Oakenshield that I’ve been walking through markets on my own for over forty years. If I’m not free to do so in his mountain, then I’ll go straight back to the Shire where I can do as I like.”

“Okay! Okay! Stop shouting,” Nori begged.

Around them, the street was quieter than it had been. Bilbo suspected people were staring. He didn’t care. He continued his attempt to glare at Nori, doubting its efficacy.

“I’ll go,” Nori said. “Enjoy your shopping.”

Taking a deep breath, Bilbo forced himself to ask, “Will you come to tea?” They were good friends, after all.

Nori didn’t answer. His footfalls were lighter than other dwarves. Without the strong scent of his hair oil, Bilbo couldn’t identify him by anything other than his voice. The thief might have been two inches in from Bilbo’s nose. Or he might be gone. In the darkness, the hobbit had no way of knowing.

Turning, Bilbo continued down the street until he heard a fishmonger calling out. The fishmonger was a man from Dale, and he promised that all of his fish came directly from the Long Lake. After a little conversation, a few choice fillets were exchange for a few coins, and Bilbo proceeded with a parcel in one hand and his walking stick in the other.

There was plenty of food in his hobbit hole—Bombur took the task of stocking a pantry very seriously—but that was not the point of going to market. Bilbo picked up a few slightly wrinkled lemons, a bottle of Dorwinion wine, and a new wooden spoon because he liked the way it felt in his hand. Because he could, the hobbit stopped by Zindi’s pie stand for a quick bite before returning home.

Once again, the lass tried to give Bilbo his pie for free. “It’s worth more than a royal endorsement, you coming back to my little stand. Everyone knows hobbits are particular about food.”

“No, no, no,” Bilbo insisted, reaching into his pocket for his coin purse. “You are trying to build a business, Zindi. Besides, they’re the best pies in Erebor. I’d hate to see you go under because you gave them away for free.”

Then he stopped. In his pocket, his fingers closed on nothing at all. “Excuse me for a moment, I just have to—”

Bilbo tapped his way over to the stone bench next to Zindi’s stall and set down his bag of groceries. Checking his other pocket was futile. It was just as empty. Searching his groceries was a waste of time. Bilbo was positive that he would not put his coin purse in the bag with his purchases. Nevertheless, he took out each and every item in the bag, feeling for his purse, listening for the absent jingle of coins.

It was gone.

“Ah,” Bilbo said, quite embarrassed. “I’m afraid I shall have bring my shopping home before I can treat myself. Never fear, I’ll be back in an hour or so.”

“Please have a pie, Master Baggins,” Zindi said softly. “It would be terrible for my business if you walked away without one.”

Bilbo took a deep breath, and then thanked her for the kindness.

As before, once Bilbo was settled with his pie, Zindi experienced a rush in sales. All of the customers seemed to want to greet Bilbo on the bench, which was a bit awkward. They said “Hullo Lord Dragonslayer” or “At your service, Dragonslayer” so loudly, Bilbo wondered if they thought he was deaf. Manners demanded that he nod if his mouth was full or say hello back if he could manage it politely, but it was tiresome to have so many demands on his courtesy directly after the humiliation of losing his purse.

“Well, Master Baggins,” Zindi said, “I’m halfway to proving my father wrong and no mistake.”

“Oh?” Bilbo was intrigued. That sounded like the start of a story, not just another pleasantry.

“Did I ever tell you he forbade me to leave the Iron Hills? Didn’t want me to be a baker either, if it comes to that. He’s a miner, you know. My whole family’s been mining in the Iron Hills since there’ve been dwarves there. Good, steady work, prospecting for iron. A dwarf with skill in a mine always has a place in the world, my father says.”

“That life didn’t appeal to you?” Bilbo asked.

Zindi laughed. “Not even a little. Spend my whole life in a tunnel moving forward at the pace of a pickax instead of my own feet? No thanks! I wanted to see a bit of the world. Meet new people. New kinds of people. Erebor’s incredible. I’ve met so many Men, dwarves of other clans, and even, if you’ll believe it, a hobbit.”

It was Bilbo’s turn to laugh. He also noticed that while he was conversing with Zindi, the many greetings stopped. He could hear the transfer of coin and the metallic click of her warm little oven opening and closing. Business was still steady, but it seemed to be conducted in a way that would not interrupt their little chat. Dwarves could be courteous. In their own way.

“A hobbit, you say?” Bilbo took a bite of his pie and chewed thoughtfully. “That must have been further west. Hobbits almost never cross the Misty Mountains.”

“What is it like? The land to the west?” Zindi asked.

“Gentle,” Bilbo said. “There are no mountains in the Shire, just rolling green hills, little rivers, and wide fields.” He told the lass about hobbit holes, Bag End, Hobbiton, and his neighbors. It all seemed very far away, but when he spoke, he could almost see the emerald grass stretching out to fill the horizon.

In fact, Bilbo enjoyed their conversation so much, that it was almost teatime when he made it back to his little hole in the First Tunnel. Balin was waiting for him on his doorstep.

The wise old fellow was perfectly happy to wait while Bilbo put the kettle on, stowed his groceries, and got a little tea together. Such tasks took Bilbo more time than they once might have, but Balin only offered to help once. When Bilbo declined the assistance, his friend sat patiently and waited. Bilbo served a very respectable tea with cress sandwiches, currant scones, clotted cream, and warm jam. Although he had not baked the bread or the scones himself, he would not have been ashamed to serve the same in Bag End.

Balin complimented the tea, and they settled in comfortably.

“Did Fili and Kili come by to help you clean up after the party?” Balin asked.

“No,” Bilbo said, “I managed very well on my own. Although I admit, the carpets may be a bit of a problem. I tried to pick one up to give it a good shake out in that snow covered patio which is meant to be my garden, but I couldn’t get it off the floor. I’m not sure that sweeping it with a broom did the trick.”

“Ah.” There was a pause. In the darkness, Bilbo heard Balin take a delicate sip of his tea. “Thorin thought rugs would be unnecessarily hazardous. Too easy for the lads to move about if they wanted to play tricks on you.”

Bilbo did not start or snarl at the mention of Thorin, though Balin undoubtedly wanted him to. A gentlehobbit did not flinch at the name of an acquaintance.

The dwarf continued, “All of the carpeting is properly fixed to the floor, and won’t be coming up without a great deal of redecorating. You’ll need to use a carpet sweeper to get it clean. There should be one in the broom cupboard. Dori or I can show you how it works whenever you like.”

“Thank you. Another scone?” Bilbo had no idea whether or not Balin was finished with his first, but as he was helping himself to seconds, the hobbit decided to offer.

“Yes please.” Balin’s plate nudged the back of Bilbo’s hand just above the breadbasket, and Bilbo placed a scone onto it with a feeling of triumph.

“There we are.” Bilbo grinned, and poured a little more hot tea into both teacups. “I had a lovely trip to the market this afternoon.”

At Balin’s polite noise, Bilbo told him all about the woodworker, Zindi’s pies, and the fishmongers from Dale. Balin was an interested audience, asking for the direction of the woodworker and expressing an interest in visiting Zindi at some point with Bilbo. After all, good pies were hard to find.

“By the way,” Balin said, when Bilbo concluded the tale of his trip. “His majesty has asked me to mention a threat Erebor faces.”

“Did he.” Bilbo had no desire to discuss Thorin. Or think about Thorin. Or hear Thorin’s name spoken aloud.

“It would make my life a good deal simpler if you would let him speak to you on his own behalf.”

“You needn’t carry tales for him. I certainly don’t care what he has to say.”

Balin sighed. “He is my king, Bilbo, and he feels compelled to keep his word to you. It is no grand army, only a minor oddity. There is a rash of petty theft in the Grand Marketplace. Cutpurses, shoplifters and the like are making a nuisance.”

“Cutpurses?” Bilbo sat up straight. “Then I was robbed!”

“What?” Balin’s voice was low and dangerous, but Bilbo paid it no mind.

“I lost my purse. I thought I must have set it down and forgotten it at one of the shops I visited, but perhaps someone took it out of my pocket! I was robbed! Well, isn’t that a wonder. After all, anyone might be robbed.”

“You were robbed. You.”

“Yes! Isn’t it silly? The simplest explanation is usually best, as my father used to say. Oh! I am relieved.”

“You did not mention losing your purse earlier.”

At last, Balin’s hard tone registered with Bilbo. “Oh.” The hobbit hesitated. “Ah, well. It hardly matters. After all, I’ve got that great chest of coin in my bedroom and Gloin’s made it clear that he’ll refill it anytime I like from the treasury. You know he has those account books and everything.”

“Yet I can’t help noticing that you are now relieved, in your own words. Relieved that some criminal dared to rob you. Forgive me Bilbo, but that does imply that you were concerned before.”

“Balin.” Bilbo fiddled with the tea things, straightening the tray by touch. The clink of porcelain soothed his nerves a little. “Please. Don’t.”

Balin was quiet for a long moment. In the darkness, Bilbo felt strangely alone. His friend was only across the table, but he wasn’t moving or making noise. For all Bilbo knew, the dwarf might have vanished away. Then, Balin’s armchair creaked, just a little. The dwarf must have shifted his weight. Leaning forward? Bilbo didn’t know.

Suddenly, there was a knock at the door.

Springing to his feet, Bilbo murmured a polite “excuse me” and dashed off gratefully to answer it.

“Bilbo!” Fili’s voice was a jovial trumpet, cutting through the unhappy darkness. The hobbit found himself wrapped in a quick, warm hug. When the prince backed away, his hands remained on Bilbo’s shoulders. “It is I, Fili, and Bofur is here also. Did Kili come to see you? He has disappeared with Tauriel. If he gets up to some mischief, I shall be blamed, so I would like to be a party to it when it happens.”

Bilbo laughed. “If you are going to suffer the consequences, you might as well enjoy the crime, is that it?”

“Precisely!”

“I am sorry to say he is not here. Balin and I were having tea. As far as I know, no one else is in my smial.”

Fili’s hands tightened briefly on Bilbo’s shoulders, before releasing him. “Then no one else is in your home, Bilbo. Dwarves do not sneak about. We announce ourselves proudly at the door.”

“Is that a fact?” Bilbo felt his smile grow stiff and unpleasant, but Fili didn’t deserve his vitriol. “Well,” he said quickly, before Fili could answer, “that will never do. You are my friends, and so you must come inside for tea.”

“I must bid you farewell,” Balin said. His voice was practically in Bilbo’s ear, and the little hobbit jumped to realize the dwarf was so close.

Dwarven hands caught Bilbo’s arm to steady him. Bilbo thought they were Balin’s, but he couldn’t be sure. All of the dwarves were still and quiet in that solemn, stoney manner that took them sometimes. The hobbit patted the hand with one of his own. “Thank you, I am quite well,” he said. “Only usually I hear you lot tramping around with your great boots. I must have been distracted.”

“The carpet muffles them a little,” Balin said. Of course it did, but not that much. With constant focus, BIlbo could use his keen hearing and sharp sense of smell to piece together the world around him, but after a long day, he simply wasn’t attentive enough to manage it.

“You said you were going?” This was tremendously rude, of course, but Bilbo was suddenly exhausted.

“I am,” Balin said. “Someone must tell Thorin what happened today.”

Bilbo sniffed. “Better you than me.”

Balin sighed. “Good evening, Bilbo.”

Returning the pleasantry, Bilbo ushered Fili and Bofur in, listening to Balin’s receding footsteps. “Just let me clear the tea things, and I’ll put on a little dinner,” the hobbit promised. “I’ve some lovely fish from the Long Lake, and I managed to find a few lemons, so you’re in for a treat.”

“Here,” Fili said, “let me.”

Unlike Balin, the prince refused to take no for an answer, and practically bowled Bilbo over clearing away the tea things.

“Place looks nice,” he added. “Are you sure Kili hasn’t been by? We were going to help you clean up after the party, but Dwalin was a beast this morning. I suppose you weren’t the only one who overindulged a bit, and he said three days was too long for a break from training.”

“I am perfectly capable of cleaning my own home,” Bilbo said snippily. Moving pointedly around Fili at the sink, he got out flour, eggs, and crumbs to start breading the fish to fry.

“Of course you are,” Bofur said. The toymaker’s voice was strangely quiet.

Fili sighed. The water in the sink stopped running, and there came the gentle clink of a final dish being set to dry.

“Well.” Bilbo forced a little cheerfulness into his voice. “I begin to suspect that you did not come looking for Kili after all! If you don’t intend to stay for dinner either, you might say so outright. Or I am doing all this work for nothing.”

“We are honored to share in your meal, Bilbo,” Fili said firmly, “but it is true that Bofur asked me to come here on a different errand.”

“Not to do my dishes, surely.” Bilbo wanted to gag Fili, or at least shove an apple in his mouth so that he could say nothing further. The hobbit knew full well what the prince wanted to talk about, and it wasn’t a subject he cared to visit.

“Bilbo.” Bofur was so hesitant. The crude toymaker was never hesitant. Bilbo wished his friends would not be so careful with him, even as he wished they would consider his feelings and leave the topic alone.

“We must speak of your anger,” Fili said firmly.

“If you would like me to be angry with you, by all means.” Bilbo got out a heavy cast iron frying pan and set it to heating with a clang.

“Bilbo,” Bofur repeated, “I know. Or I think I know. Your Khaz was the king, wasn’t he? Is that. Does that have something to do with why you are so angry with him?”

“Yes,” Bilbo said, pouring oil into the pan. “Thorin lied to me. Again. He told me his name was Khaz, and he lied. But he never will again, because I will never speak to him again. And that is the whole story.”

Fili drew in a sharp breath. “It is true?” He sounded very young. Hurt. The way Kili sounded when the orc arrow caught him in the leg and he came over all feverish. Bilbo sometimes forgot that Fili and Kili were in the dwarven equivalent of their late tweens.

Frowning, the hobbit tested the pan with a few drops of water, listening to the oil sizzle and pop. “Leave it there,” he said. “Let’s talk about something else.”

“I cannot.” Fili’s voice was hoarse. Bilbo began to wonder if he was actually sick. A three day party had to depress even the strongest the constitution, and the last month of winter was always the most dangerous. Perhaps the prince was coming down with a cold.

Dropping his carefully breaded fillets into the pan, Bilbo groped in the dwarf’s general direction until he found his shoulder. Intending to place a hand on the lad’s forehead to feel for a fever, the hobbit found both of his hands grasped firmly in a dwarven grip.

“It is unforgivable. More, he knows it.” As he spoke, Fili’s voice grew more certain. “I am a prince of the House of Durin, Bilbo. If there is to be justice in Erebor, even the king must bow before the law. Thorin will pay for his crime. I swear it. Tell me: would you have his head?”

“What?” Squawking like an undignified chicken, Bilbo might have tripped over his feet and fallen without Fili’s support. “No!”

The hands on Bilbo’s tightened, and the dwarf’s breath came in a quick, relieved puff. “Are you certain? It is true that the typical sentence for such a crime is not death, but the Dragonslayer must be equivalent to royalty. The sentence for assaulting a member of the royal family is beheading.”

“I—what?” Bilbo repeated. “Assault? Thorin didn’t assault me, Fili.”

Now, Fili’s voice was gentle, like he was trying to sooth a startled pony. “Keeping the matter confidential may seem like a kindness, Bilbo, but you do not owe us that. Nor should the dwarves of Erebor put their faith in a king who would abuse his power thusly. The great wrong which Thorin did you will be redressed. Publicly.”

“Why?” Bilbo was honestly bewildered. “Why would you think—?”

“Bilbo, listen to your heart,” Bofur said. “Whether or not you were amenable to the attentions of your Khaz, believing him to be a dwarf named Khaz, you did not want Thorin. That he got what he wanted through trickery and lies while you were injured does not make it any less of a crime than if he used force while you were well.”

“I don’t—Bofur!” Bilbo did not know what to say. “It wasn’t. Thorin didn’t do anything like that! I mean, he did tell me his name was Khaz, but why in the world would that lead you to conclude—?”

“Khaz—a Khazad—is a dwarf,” Fili said slowly. “Surely you have heard enough of our language by now to know that much.”

“Yes.” Bilbo’s face flushed as red heat suffused his cheeks. “I did work that much out, after the fact.” It was yet another reason he should have known. Another example of how foolish he’d been.

“It is a name we give to outsiders, when we do not wish to give our own,” Fili continued. Then he hesitated.

Off to the side, Bofur scoffed. Bilbo heard his heavy boots pacing back and forth near the stove. “It is the name we give our lovers,” the dwarf said, “when our hearts are uncertain and we hesitate to tell our friends.”

Releasing Fili’s hands, Bilbo stepped back very quickly. “That’s not. I’m afraid I’ve given you the wrong impression.”

“Bilbo.” Bofur sounded so strange. But desperately wishing to see his face changed nothing. “You told me yourself. That you preferred bathing with your Khaz.”

“Oh.” Bilbo sat down heavily at the kitchen counter. “Oh, fine,” he said dully. “I shan’t forgive you for making me say this, though. Don’t you know how much easier it is to be angry than to be—” The hobbit stopped. Admitting his embarrassment, his fear, his devastation, was impossible.

“You needn’t speak of it,” Fili said quickly. “You needn’t concern yourself with this at all. I will face my uncle alone.”

“No.” Bilbo’s head was too heavy to lift. Having no way of looking at Fili’s face was almost a relief. “No, I won’t let it come to that. So. The great crime of Thorin Oakenshield. Well. That would be cleaning up my piss.” The crude word came out in a rush. Bilbo almost couldn’t say it, but he had to be absolutely clear. Using a euphemism would only mean repeating himself a dozen times until the dwarves understood.

“What?” Bofur and Fili were a little off. They needed to practice more to speak in tandem the way Fili and Kili often did. Bilbo laughed, but it was a flat, joyless sound.

“I was recovering,” the hobbit said, blank and empty as a sheet of white paper. “It was the middle of the night. I thought I could use the chamber pot on my own. I couldn’t. I fell. It spilled. A mess was made. Thorin must have known that I’d rather be found by orcs than by him in that state, so he put on an accent and gave me a fake name.”

Neither Bofur nor Fili said a word.

“He didn’t have to keep on.” Bilbo’s breath came fast and hard. The pounding of his heart in his chest was almost painful. “For over a week. If he hadn’t. But he came back. And I thought he was someone whose opinion didn’t matter. Someone who didn’t care. He was just looking after me. Because I can’t. I can’t look after myself anymore. And the fish is burning.” Bilbo could smell it.

Cursing, Bofur leapt to the stove, clanging the hot frying pan about and scraping it noisily with a spatula. “I’m sorry, Bilbo,” the toymaker said. “I don’t think it’s salvageable.”

“Nothing ever is,” said the hobbit.