Chapter Text
The lighting rig offered little light from a distance. The 40-watt bulbs shine like a beacon in close proximity but stationed at the door to the Grand Gallery the light is swallowed by darkness. Even so, it doesn’t deter Bilbo from returning to the throne twice more.
After he and Balin re-joined the others and spoke of their find the team were quick to take off towards the stairs, proper etiquette be damned in their pursuit of the truth. He had followed and found them lined before the throne eyeing the stalactite with happy relief. All but Gandalf, who eyed the hollowed space with a touch of sadness. He could sympathise, as he too longed to see the Arkenstone in all its glory, the pinnacle of the Durin’s success or perhaps the bane of it.
Since then, the team had come alive, rushing down the stairs to retrieve their equipment. He hadn’t realised how subdued the team had been until that moment. They had all salivated at the thought of Erebor, but even with the mounting evidence they could not bring themselves to fully believe because to believe was then to be able to fail. Haiti had taught him that. Bofur had been there, as well as Gandalf and though the others were spared the immediate shame, it had sent ripples throughout the archaeological world and everyone felt the brunt of their mistake. It had cowed them and made them hesitant, but now they had their proof. The throne of Erebor was depicted in a book found in Khazad-dûm, eliminating all doubt. They had found the lost Kingdom.
He had followed the others down the stairs back into the Gallery of the Kings before coming to a halt beside Bofur’s lighting rig. He had watched as Gandalf and Nori went off to retrieve the camera and later heard Gandalf giving commentary from the secret door, explaining their journey as he retraced their steps. Bofur had returned to his pack and eagerly rifled through his supplies finding his tools and rushing off with his chisel to take rock samples. While Balin and Ori returned once more to the balcony where Balin described the tapestries and Ori hastily wrote in his black leather-bound book.
He even watched as Dori and Freddy began to unpack their gear while Kenny took to sketching a brief outline of the kingdom making him feel like a spare part. Normally his role was historian but with Balin present his service was no longer required. He also acted as Gandalf’s second but the team worked as a cohesive unit rendering his position useless. He had felt useless, undermined and unwanted.
He had taken his leave from the group without word. Thoughtless, but the others were engrossed in their tasks and he wasn’t comfortable interrupting them because he wanted to see the throne once more. He couldn’t explain his desire to see it again, he only knew he had to and so he had returned to the throne and had remained there.
In his mind he tried to reconcile the past but he could not. The King’s actions made little sense. It was one thing to be selfish but his actions weren’t just of greed, they were destructive. Why annihilate his entire family? He could not take his gold with him, why deny his own kin their future and himself a legacy that will live on long after his death? Why besmirch his family name and his honour? What was his motivation?
He tried to put himself in the King’s position and paced before the throne with the eyes of Thorin’s forefather’s staring in judgement. He must have had the weight of the world on his shoulders, the pressure could cause anyone to snap but to murder his family? Something must have triggered his dangerous outburst but what?
Legend blames the Arkenstone. A diamond so magnificent Thrór named it the King’s Jewel and bestowed power upon it. Whomever should hold the Arkenstone would rule over the seven kingdoms. It was folly, of course, undermining his own rule, a costly mistake. Why bestow power upon a gem? His actions led many to believe that the diamond may not have been a diamond at all. Some suggested it was a meteorite and it was radiation from the stone that drove both Thrór and Thorin insane. There was speculation that it could be a dragon egg from the fantasists, and a dinosaur egg from the realists. Spiritualists suggested that with the range of colours the Arkenstone could have been used as a spirit trap and a malevolent spirit controlled the king’s actions.
It made him want to see it all the more. He had examined the throne to the best of his ability and even checked the floor to see if the Arkenstone had fallen though his search was in vain. However, his search wasn’t entirely useless as he eyed the now severed frame and found a secret button. It was a simple catch mechanism disguised as a part of the frame and now exposed from the damage. The king would have known about it so why then hack away at the throne? If it were rage why not destroy the entire thing instead of focusing solely on the stone and if it were the stone he was truly after why then not just release it?
The questions weighed heavy upon him because he couldn’t make sense of them. Discovering the past was supposed to answer questions not ask more of them. So far, they had learnt that the Arkenstone existed, that the seven kingdoms were not imaginary and Erebor had a line of king’s, the memory of them etched in stone. So where was Thorin Oakenshield, the last known king of Erebor? Legend suggests they will come across his body in a stash of gold with skeletal hands clutching the Arkenstone, his back bent from curling possessively around the stone as his empire crumbled to dust.
The thought of finding the once great king like that turned his stomach and hurt him in ways he could not explain. He did not know why the king’s demised troubled him, or why he felt the need to justify the king’s callous actions. He had never felt the need to question the past before but he needed to make sense of the senseless. Thorin Oakenshield imploded, his attack was targeted upon himself, as if he meant to eradicate himself from history. What grave error could he have made to deal such punishment upon himself?
Punishment.
He eyes the backrest of the throne once more and sees only the result of rage. A terrifying rage. He reaches for the camera around his neck and instead his fingers twist around the gold chain and his ring in the camera’s absence. He would like a picture to immortalise the throne but the light is too dim and he cannot see past the throne to see if there are any photo-sensitive artefacts behind it. He is also unaware of what creatures had taken refuge in the halls and the last thing he needed was to create a swarm of bats.
He had to wait and simply ignore the churning feeling in his gut. The throne unsettled him in ways he could not decipher, he only knew or rather felt, that something was wrong.
A piercing scream jolts him from his reverie followed by the panicked shouts of the team. He immediately takes off running along the walkway and down the stairs. The hubbub is emitting from the King’s Gallery and he rushes towards the light at the entrance and emits a scream of his own as he’s suddenly grabbed as soon as he crosses the threshold.
“Bilbo Baggins have you taken leave of your senses?” The arms that hold him tightly release him and he turns finding Gandalf glowering at him. He shrinks into himself having never been on the receiving end of one of Gandalf’s infamous glares before.
“I…err…I…” he splutters unhelpfully.
“It is dangerous to wander alone, should anything happen to you I could not forgive myself.” His heart is warmed by the confession but then Gandalf’s eyes narrow and his anger overthrows his hurt. “Stick to the path!” He nods vigorously knowing as much.
“What happened?” He asks, eventually finding his voice and waves in the direction of the top left corner in the King’s Gallery where the others are huddled.
“Come and see,” Gandalf offers without enthusiasm. He follows along aware of the distance grown between them and can only blame himself for his stupidity. Gandalf’s anger is born from a concern for his well-being which he had flagrantly ignored.
As they approach he can see one of the ancient carvings of a king had crumbled, identifiable only by the round stone head wearing a helm with hollowed circular eyes open wide as if in horror over its own demise. There is nothing remarkable about it, but Nori is recording and Bofur is taking digital pictures of the fallen stone.
He follows Nori’s journey with his eyes and sees that a path has been cleared and revealed a hidden alcove not unlike the stairs in the Grand Gallery. He takes his leave of Gandalf and follows Nori into the nook and stifles his cry of amazement with his hand as he looks around. Bookshelves, several of them, poorly made but the majority are filled with parchment and a few more adorned with books.
He feels a presence behind him and finds Gandalf in the doorway appearing vexed and he could only blame himself for Gandalf’s temper. He turns back and sees Ori and Balin beside an oak table perusing an open scroll, while Balin appears serious Ori is giddy with excitement and he realises then that it was Ori’s scream of delight that he had heard.
He walks over to the pair, noticing one of the lighting rigs has been set up in the corner and looks over the scroll. He can’t read Khuzdul and has no idea what has been written, and can only see it had not been finished. Balin looks vaguely troubled but then without a smile he always appears that way as does Gandalf so he puts it down to a nuance of age. Ori is avidly reading and does not share his expression and his nerves are calmed. He had feared those were the dying words of a scribe speaking against the Mad King. It is silly really, as there are no signs of trouble, no spilled ink or overturned furniture, everything is simply covered in dust and cobwebs, abandoned.
He peruses the many bookshelves, always trailing behind Nori so he is not filmed. It always makes him cringe when he sees himself on film or when his picture is taken for a local paper or posted on a website. Even his Twitter icon is the Yorkshire dales while his FaceBook icon is a detailed drawing of a dragon. Freud would have a field day categorizing his neuroses. It wasn’t fame he sought, or even riches, he liked to wander as he had no roots after his parents died and he always had a Gypsy heart.
The scrolls appear to be in good condition but he doesn’t touch. This was Balin’s area of expertise and he wouldn’t deny him his prize. He will, of course, offer his assistance now that his wandering had earned him Gandalf’s wrath.
He waits for the library to clear before he approaches the table and finds Balin still reading the scroll, back bent as he does not trust the integrity of the stool.
“Could I be of assistance?” He offers quietly and he fears too quietly as Balin continues to read.
He casts his gaze upon Ori who offers him a tight smile. “No thank you, Bilbo.” Ori finally answers in Balin’s stead as the silence had become uncomfortable. He’s glad of the reply even if it was dismissive. He liked to think he knew when he was not wanted and now was certainly that time. He nodded in acquiescence and left the library and gazed forlornly at the entrance to the Grand Gallery. He wanted to see the throne again, just once, to put the niggling thoughts in the back of his mind to rest but Gandalf shakes his head as if reading his mind and he stays.
The boys are seated on the golden floor talking amongst themselves as he sits beside Kenny. They offer him nods in acknowledgement before falling back into conversation and he takes it. He’s there but he’s not, he tended to play a secondary character in the story of his own life. He doesn’t mind, it is better than the alternative.
The boys are discussing their share of the find and he doesn’t have the heart to tell them of the Heritage Act. The finders fee would still be substantial but far less than the frankly stupid money the boys bandied about. He plays with the ring around his neck as he turns his gaze towards the Grand Gallery once again. Something calls to him without a voice, like a siren to his soul.
“Bilbo…Bilbo… Oi Bilbo.” He snaps out of his reverie and finds five pairs of eyes on him as Nori, Dori and Bofur had joined them.
“Hmm?”
“What would you do with your share?” He reasons they were still discussing their spoils and shrugs noncommittedly.
“Pay a few bills?” He offers. “Treasure doesn’t really interest me.” He ignores Nori’s scoff and instead stares into the boys’ surprised faces.
“Oh yeah?” Bofur challenges. “Then why do you wear that ring around your neck? You never take it off.” He doesn’t miss Nori’s glare towards Bofur but pretends that he does. Instead he looks down at his fingers clutching the ring.
“It’s a family heirloom,” he answers dishonestly. It isn’t entirely a lie; his father had given it to him claiming it had been passed down from father to son for generations and he believed it. Only, later he would learn that was possibly correct, it just wasn’t his family. Both of his parents had been adopted at birth and knew nothing of their biological parents. His father had witnessed his love of history and ancestry and had gone into the local antique shop and bought the ring claiming it to be a family heirloom.
Not much later he had found the receipt and a month after that his homework was to discover his family tree and he found it was no more than a stick. He pretended to be oblivious as his father looked upon him with sad brown eyes that spoke of betrayal. He didn’t see it that way, and still didn’t. His father said it was an heirloom and so it was an heirloom, an heirloom had to start somewhere after all.
He knew the ring had value, his father had paid one thousand pounds for it; no small fee but later he would realise it was greatly under-priced. He refused to have it valued in his respect for his father. He didn’t want the truth to mar the loving act and knowing its true value might make him want to sell. He doubts he would, even living in his box London flat but the ring had been betrayed before and Lord knew he owed Gandalf a great debt.
The conversation moves on to schooling and he listens politely but not too keenly as Nori explains how his heart lay in cinematography. He had been studying film and media at Nottingham University when a position on Ori’s archaeology team opened up and he could not refuse his baby brother anything. Dori was the same, with several passable GCSEs he had foregone further education to raise both Nori and especially Ori after their mother was diagnosed with cancer. When she passed, Dori’s attention zeroed in on Ori as a coping mechanism and though he had no interest in archaeology he came as a package deal with Ori.
He already knows Bofur’s past and he doesn’t want to stir Nori’s ire so he nods occasionally with his eyes averted. The boys are entertained by his story and make up for his lack of response with laughter and probing questions.
Gandalf joins them soon after and regales them with fanciful tales of a childhood he never had. He hides his smirk from the others and wonders if they buy Gandalf’s cock and bull story, he knows he did when he had first heard it. It’s a strange thing to lie about but Gandalf tended to be wishy-washy with details so he put it down to being another one of his eccentricities.
The boys speak next, sharing the same past they speak over each other and finish each other’s sentences. It’s quite the double act and he listens enthralled and is surprised to learn that the boys are not wealthy. Their parents had the foresight to save for university but there was not much left for anything else and the boys truly were burning through their student loans as young lads tended to do.
He also learns that it was no coincidence that it was the boys who had discovered Erebor as accidental as it had been.
“It started as a theory,” Freddy explains and pulls out an A4 sheet of paper with a hand-drawing of the Durin coat of arms while Kenny produces a map of the southern alps from his backpack. “The seven stars of Durin represents the kingdoms but also his rebirth. His seventh reign would be his final, as it is destined, mapped out, written in the stars.”
“So, it got us thinking,” Kenny continues pulling out a piece of tracing paper. “if it’s mapped in the stars maybe it’s mapped on the earth.” He says tracing the seven stars onto the tracing paper. He places the tracing paper over the map and the gathered look surprised as the second star covers Gundabad and the fifth is slightly away from Khazad-dûm. “We came here to find the exact sigil as we believe it is the only correct map.” He looks down again and sees that the third star is slightly off Erebor giving the statement some validation.
“The only problem is when we got here the sigil got mixed up in Māori artefacts and is now touring New York.” Freddy adds.
“So, we got this idea to climb Mount Gundabad and see if we could see a pattern and where to look to next.”
“But then Kenny decides that we should climb Mount Cook seeing as there was less people this time of year.”
“Because it’s dangerous.” He adds and is met with two false astonished expressions.
“Yes mum. Anyway, we thought we had worked out where Orcarni was and then there was the rock slide and the tunnel and you know the rest. Mister Greenleaf will be kicking himself, he said we were mad thinking we had found Orcarni and then we discover Erebor.”
“Greenleaf? Thranduil Greenleaf?”
“Yeah, he was our teacher in Oxford.”
“Small world,” Gandalf says around a cloud of smoke.
“We were in that class.” Kenny whispers, leaning forward.
“What class?” Dori asks oblivious.
“Haldir was our classmate.” Freddy informs him but Dori remains oblivious. “You don’t know the story?” Dori shakes his head, no. “It was a huge scandal, Thranduil ran off with him. He was married with four children, a biological son from a previous marriage and three adopted kids and his husband was hot, I mean supermodel hot, I would.”
“So would I,” Kenny nods in agreement.
“Bilbo did.” Nori adds spitefully and the venom in his tone reduces the gathered to silence. “Thranduil was your mentor for years, how long were you lusting over his husband?” He scoffs at the accusation and shakes his head but offers no reply. It wasn’t like that, this was just a mindless accusation made by an insecure boyfriend and he wouldn’t validate his lies with a response. “With friends like you who needs enemies?” Nori continues, clearly having a lot to say for himself.
He shakes his head and stands up. The atmosphere is overbearing and he will not sit and be vilified for things he hadn’t even done. Not today and certainly not here. “Truth hurts?” Nori carries on despite Bofur elbowing him in the ribs.
He won’t respond, confrontations were not his forte and his head was beginning to hurt. “You’re a fucking snake in the grass. All butter wouldn’t melt but I can see right through you.”
“Okay that’s quite enough,” Gandalf intervenes.
“It’ll be enough when that little prick leaves, what does he even do, apart from servicing you?” Gandalf stands outraged and Dori begins to chastise his brother and this is what he wanted to avoid. The blow-up and choosing sides, the causalities of war have always outweighed the original dispute and he can’t have that on his conscience. It is a minor issues and sides are already being taken and he can’t bear it. He’ll wait for tempers to simmer and leave tomorrow but for now he needed some space.
He walks off towards the Grand Gallery and hears Gandalf calling after him, telling him not to go, that it is dangerous. He knows as much but he needed to be alone in the dark with his thoughts; he wants to disappear if only for a moment. He looks towards the stairs considering returning to the throne but decides against it. He can’t face the throne knowing the unrest he had caused, it would be wrong of him to find solitude when he has brought nothing but trouble to the team.
He ventures right and walks faster as voices are raised in the King’s Gallery. A simple spark had turned into a wildfire and he can’t be responsible for that. He takes off running into the dark too lost in his own emotions to concern himself with common dangers and in the bleak darkness where the light does not shine, the floor gives way beneath his feet and he screams as he falls into the hidden chasm.
