Chapter Text
“So, it’s a forgery then.” He states sadly.
“No,” Balin contradicts. “I believe this is authentic, see the sigil here?” He says pointing to a circle of wax with an anvil and crossed hammers with seven stars above depicted in the centre. “Notice the size and shape? A ring, one of seven. A ring for each King of the seven kingdoms.” He gently turns the pages. “Each entry is marked by one, here, two rings, Gundabad, possibly the peace treaty.” He guesses while turning the page and then, once his point is finally made he closes the book. “If Frerin became king why was his death noted in the casualties of the Blood War?”
“Perhaps they were mistaken?”
“They made a point of describing his death, decapitation.” A shiver runs down his spine.
“Maybe the ring was stolen?” He tries again.
“The thought had crossed my mind, given Thorin is in his grave without the ring. But if they went through so much trouble to falsify records, why then seat a dead man upon the throne?” He pauses without an answer. “It appears that the other records were falsified.” He doesn’t speak, only arches a brow in query. “The Gundabad Chronicles, my life’s work.” Balin adds quietly and lowers his head.
The Gundabad Chronicles was Balin’s greatest work and had cemented his place as the foremost historian of Durin’s Folk. Now the very work that had made his career could very well end it. He doubts it would but his credibility would always be questioned and that was as good as.
“You reported what you had found at the time.” He says placatingly. “New things are being discovered all the time, contradicting what we once knew as the truth. Remember, you stand in the lost kingdom of Erebor, a place some scholars would swear was mythical. You are in a position to correct your own work.” He had thought his words were comforting but Balin had opened the book once more and was carefully turning the pages.
“A page is missing.” He says suddenly, running his fingertip down the centre of the book. “Just as it was in Gundabad.”
“A page, which page?”
“It would appear the last page. This is a book that documents royal announcements, I must study it further. If my suspicion is correct, Erebor is missing a dynasty.”
“You think it announced a birth?”
Balin nods. “An heir would usurp Fili. Who else would gain from the elimination of these records?”
“You think Fili murdered his cousin and uncle for a seat on a throne?”
“A seat that was promised to him, and good men have been killed for less. It could also explain why Thorin murdered his nephews.”
“Fili was too young to rule, a kingdom such as this would be set upon, Thorin would have had to assume leadership once more. He would have been judge, jury and executioner. He wasn’t mad, he was justified. Though that does not explain why he would murder his lover.”
“Are you even sure he did?” Balin asks.
“You said it yourself.”
“I don’t know what to believe anymore.” Balin says sadly, still distraught over their findings. Self-pity wasn’t a good look and his mood would only continue to sour while they remained in the library.
“Ori says he had found something in the Grand Gallery, worth a look?” He suggests, as Balin continues to stare at the book morosely. With a reluctant nod of his head, Balin closes the book once more and stands from the stool with a crack from his old bones.
“Did he say what he had found?” Balin asks, collecting his torch while he winds his own.
“No, he only said he saw something. I think it was a statue.” Beyond the tomb in the dark he had seen the silhouettes of statues highlighted by the rig so it was a safe assumption.
They leave the library and cross the Gallery of the Kings and enter the Grand gallery without incident. The tomb rig is off which is odd, and the rig in the corner remains disused. “Ori?” He calls out into the dark reluctant to step foot on uncharted territory. The ground could be a potential minefield given that a whole dynasty was potentially missing. “Ori?” He calls again, waving his torch but his light is swallowed by the darkness. “Well he was here, you don’t think he’s fallen, do you?”
“Who’s fallen?” Nori suddenly asks from behind them and he screeches, caught by surprise.
“Have you seen your brother?” Balin asks while he places a hand over his frantic heart as if he could physically slow it.
“No, I’ve just come to look for him.”
“I saw him earlier,” he offers, glad of the dark so he does not have to see the probable glare. “He said he saw something that he wanted to investigate.”
“And you just let him go off alone, did you?” Now it has been said, it was foolish on his part but he thought Ori wouldn’t go far. In truth, he hadn’t been thinking. He had gotten his translation and he hadn’t thought more than that. If Ori had fallen and hurt himself he’d be entirely to blame for his short-sightedness.
“Well…” he begins but he has nothing but lame excuses.
“Quiet,” Balin insists. “Do you hear that?” Ever since the pulley system started the silence was disturbed by falling rocks, which he hears now. He eyes Balin in confusion but the elder man only presses a finger against his lips and continues to look up. The ceiling is vaulted and beautifully carved but without the rig they hadn’t a hope of seeing it.
When he begins to lose his faith in Balin he hears it, though what it is remains a mystery. An echo of a noise emanating from the ceiling? He’d seen the ceiling for himself, there was no walkway. “The throne,” he whispers much to Balin’s annoyance until he contemplates his words.
“Now why would he be up there for?”
“Are you two going to tell me what you’re on about?” The cry becomes louder, a sob? A plea? The noise is distorted in the Grand Gallery. “Ori!” Nori yells immediately followed by Ori’s bone-chilling scream. It’s long, drawn out, becoming louder by the second and then they hear it. The impact of a body hitting the stone floor, the wet sound of blood and the crushing of bones. “Ori!” Nori screams, and goes to run to his brother but Balin holds him back.
“Best you not see that laddie.” He advises and Nori falls against him, defeated. “Bilbo?” He nods his head, it isn’t something he wants to see but the alternatives don’t bear thinking about. He winds his torch and walks towards the next hall with slow timid steps.
“Nori!” He hears Bofur call and turns, shining his light on the two lovers before carrying on. He passes through the arch into the next hall and turns right assuming Ori fell from the throne walkway.
“Ori?” He whispers in a broken voice knowing he will never be answered. He continues his approach constantly winding his torch to keep his hands from trembling. He’s reluctant to keep his eyes on the ground knowing what he is about to find and he pauses as he hears a splash from a puddle he stepped in.
He shines a light on his boot and vomit rises in his gorge as thick blood drips from the sole. He follows the trail of blood to the crumbled disfigured and deceased body of Ori Smith. He looks so small dressed in his brother’s oversized jumper. His hands are broken and his arms are shattered as if he was trying to save himself from the impact. His neck is broken as his head is twisted to a grotesque degree, and what more damage there is he cannot see.
He sets his torch down and removes his coat and covers Ori’s body. Ori had always been small but he was smaller now as his body had compacted by the impact. His ribs must be broken, lung and heart pierced, the internal damage doesn’t bear thinking about.
He picks up his torch and steps away. There was no way he would have survived the fall. He blames it on morbid curiosity that has him shine his light mapping Ori’s fall to the very ledge where for a moment familiar blue eyes are reflected in his torchlight before they disappear. He waves the torch, hoping the sapphires were reflected once more but there was nothing in the darkness.
A feeling of dread comes over him. All this time he had assumed Thorin sought redemption but what if he was wrong? What if it wasn’t redemption he wanted, but revenge?
