Chapter Text
“Who are you?” He asks again as the boys share a look of concern. “Where’s Balin? What have you done to him?”
“What?” The boys’ question in disbelief.
“Why are you doing this?” He demands, casting his gaze towards the rope ladder. They both stand closer to it than himself effectively blocking his only exit.
“Bilbo, are you okay?” Kenny asks sounding genuinely concerned that he could almost believe him. Almost.
“It was you two the whole time.” He gasps in realisation. Balin had suspected that it was them who had set the furnace ablaze and were the ones terrorizing Dori. When Dori had died, the boys had emerged from the shadows together and they were the last to arrive after Ori was pushed, giving them ample time to have pushed Ori, come down the stairs and join them. Then there was Bofur who left with the boys while Nori grieved in the tunnel alone with his baby brother. “How did you kill Bofur and Dori? Where is Balin?” He demands, voice growing louder with every accusation.
“Killed? We haven’t killed anyone. We were looking for an exit and we got distracted by a jewel-encrusted breastplate in the armoury. Then we couldn’t find Balin so we came back here to ask you if you knew where he was.”
“What have you done to him?” He repeats fearing the worst.
“What is that God awful smell?” Freddy asks, changing the subject.
“As if you don’t know.” The boys’ approach and he scurries away unscathed as their interest lies upon the broken statue.
“Is that a bone?” Kenny asks alarmed while he steadily moves away, back against the piled rubble.
“All this time I thought Thorin sought revenge but it wasn’t him, it was you two.” Sardonic laughter erupts behind him and the brick at his back gives way. He moves away until the backs of his thighs hit the sarcophagus and coughs as the stagnant air is filled with dust from the fallen rock.
There is a sudden breeze in the air, thick with the scent of tobacco, that soon clears the dust. He rubs at his eyes, making them water and clearing his vision when he hears footsteps and the tap of wood hitting the stone floor.
He looks at the brothers and finds them just as perplexed as he is and when he turns back he sees the silhouette of a large man standing in the uncovered entrance.
“Gandalf?” He says in disbelief as his old friend enters the tomb leaning heavily on his walking staff. He steps forward to welcome him but pauses after one step by the look in Gandalf’s eyes. Usually his eccentric friend would announce his name to the heavens and open his arms for a warm embrace but there is no welcome in his eyes and his arms remain by his sides.
“Gandalf?” He questions again, unsure and takes a step back. The hairs on the back of his neck stand on end and he looks at the boys out of the corner of his eye finding them just as lost.
He’d like to think it was with a heavy heart that Gandalf nodded his head, only once, sorrowful but determined. There’s scuffling and exerted breath before two figures enter the room. His heart plummets as he sees Balin battered and bloody held by a muscular forearm across his throat and the barrel of a gun pressed against his temple. He faintly recognizes the man holding Balin as the head monk Gandalf had spoken to before they had entered the mountain. He stands at an intimidating six foot five and his pale skin makes him appear ethereal.
Out of the corner of his eye he sees Kenny lunge forward to avenge Balin but Freddy holds him back. Even after all of these years, Freddy remains the sensible one. “What the fuck?” Kenny exclaims instead, sharing his sentiments.
“Gandalf what is going on?” He asks since Kenny’s question remained unanswered.
“Oh Bilbo, my dear boy, I did warn you about that overactive imagination, didn’t I?” He doesn’t answer, he can’t, as he waits in fear for Gandalf’s next words. “There are no monsters only men.” He shakes his head in denial and blinks back tears that sting his eyes.
“Please, let Balin go and we can talk.” Gandalf shakes his head in reply.
“I remember the day when I first saw you, I knew that you were special.” Gandalf says, apropos of nothing. “My grandmother was a psychic; did I ever say?” He had in one of the multiple versions of his childhood, one of many he hadn’t believed. “Unfortunately, her gift didn’t pass to me, not entirely. I saw enough to know it was there but not enough to know what it was. You were just a boy when I first saw you, but the energy around you was ancient. You did not belong there, you were out of place and out of time. It was a wonderous thing, truly, and I thought that if I were to take you under my wing you would lead me to my fortune.” He shakes his head in denial. Gandalf had shown no interest in treasure.
Gandalf’s visage darkens at the memory. “Many times you almost led me to my ruin, always accepting my charity and never returning the favour.” His jaw drops in response to the accusation. It was true, Gandalf regularly footed the bill and though he was always grateful as time wore on he may have not shown enough gratitude. It had become old hat and he had become expectant rather than hopeful of Gandalf’s generosity but he was never ungrateful.
“I would have given you anything.” He admits sadly, feeling crushed beneath Gandalf’s withering gaze.
“But you don’t have anything.” Gandalf counters and he cannot refute the truth. His parents died without insurance policies and what little they had in the bank went towards their funerals. They had owned their own home but the housing market had crashed. He had tried to wait it out until the agony of living where his parents had died became too much and he had to drastically lower the asking price just to be done with the place. “Except maybe this,” Gandalf continues holding his gold-plated chain with his ring attached. Balin must have pocketed it upon the ramparts after reading the runes.
“That’s mine.” He hisses nastily. His father had given him that ring. Thorin had given him that ring.
“I remember when this was first given to you. You flaunted it so proudly. I said I could value it for you and you balked at my suggestion. All the things I had to go without for your keep but you would not part from this ring. Do not claim you would give me anything when time and again you have proven that you would not.”
He does not reply, there are no words and his tongue feels dry from the absence of them. He holds his hand out for his ring to be returned only to have his silent request denied. He thought it would be. “It was soon after receiving this ring that you asked me about Erebor, you’d never mentioned it before but I paid no mind, everyone asks about the lost Kingdom at some point in their lives.” Gandalf goes on having a lot to say for himself, publicly airing thirty plus years of grievances. “Most people stop after a fashion but you would speak of nothing else and even wrote your thesis on the existence of Erebor. I thought my time and patience had finally paid off but all you did was talk of Erebor, talk and take, talk and take, getting me further into debt.”
A part of him wishes to run away and hide, stick his fingers into his ears and silence Gandalf’s vicious words but he stays. If his heart must be broken to know the truth then it must be.
“Imagine my surprise when Thranduil tells me of two promising young boys- brothers- that shared your obsession with Erebor.” A chill runs down his spine as Gandalf turns his attention towards the boys and his heart plummets. Freddy is still restraining Kenny but the fear on both their faces forces him to give up his position and stand in front of them, defensively.
“You leave them alone.”
“Make up your mind Bilbo,” Gandalf warns scathingly. “Choose your villain. Is it me or them or the pile of bones over there?” Without a word he eyes the sarcophagus feeling every bit the fool that he was. Gandalf was right, there were no monsters only men. “I thought nothing of it, until I received an interesting phone call. The Dalton’s had caused quite a stir with their map theory and there have been eyes on you for many years.” He opens his mouth to speak but Gandalf holds up a silencing hand. “Let me just start by saying I didn’t believe a word they were saying and I can honestly say I believed Erebor was a myth. I’m not your enemy here Bilbo, I’m just a man earning his due.”
“You sold me out. You pushed Ori!” He screams the accusation realising those familiar blue eyes he had seen were not Thorin’s but Gandalf’s. His mentor had never left, he had remained in the mountain the whole time.
“Sacrifices had to be made, yes.” Gandalf admits with a nonchalant shrug.
“You killed Dori…and…Bofur…” he says, voice breaking.
“Nori as well.” Gandalf adds as casually as mentioning the weather and throws Nori’s camera to the floor as unperturbed as Azog had been when casting Frerin’s head to the floor.
“You brought them here!” The team had always struck him as odd, and he knew Gandalf had his reasons for assembling them but he could have never foreseen his malicious intentions.
“I perhaps made the phone calls but their own fates were sealed long ago. I’ve told you before that I am not the villain, I’m merely a pawn. If you are looking for someone to blame look no further than the sad sack over there.” He looks over his shoulder but sees no one. “The idiot king.” Gandalf says with disgust and approaches the sarcophagus. “Couldn’t die quietly, could you?” He addresses the body before looking back at him. “With his dying breath he swore vengeance and his threat held some weight, so much so the Brotherhood of Azog was formed. They took an oath to protect the secret of the tomb and the existence of Erebor. In fact, my good friend Bolg over there is a direct descendant of Azog the Great.”
“Alexander was Great, Azog was a cold-blooded murderer!”
“Still your tongue.” Bolg warns, tightening his grip making Balin whimper. He does have a similar appearance to the Defiler though he is not as tall nor muscular he is very close. He shares the same complexion and has a bald head but he is without scars. His eyes are spaced far apart like Azog’s were but the blue is dimmed by cataracts in both eyes. His ears are small and flat unlike Azog’s protruding bat-like ones but their mouths are the same. Thin, almost lipless and downturned as if they had never smiled a day in their life.
He tightens his mouth in response wanting to argue but not wishing to endanger Balin. “Why bring us here?” He asks, turning towards Gandalf. The older man is still by the tomb and as he watches him, Gandalf reaches inside.
“He won’t need this anymore.” He says and then there is a crunch as he pulls the ring and chain from Thorin’s neck, severing his spine and pockets the ring. His hands clench into fists at his side. Gandalf knew how much he resented Howard Carter for what he did to Tutankhamun’s body and so he can only assume it was deliberate. It was also worrying that Gandalf would damage something of historical importance. He wouldn’t unless the find was to never see the light of day. Gandalf’s actions were a message, a foreshadowing of what is to come.
“You don’t have to do this.” He pleads thinking if he kept Gandalf talking he might find a chink in his armour and get through to the man he knew.
For a moment there is a touch of sadness expressed on Gandalf’s face, but as soon as it appears it is gone. “My conscience did get the better of me when you fell and found the tomb. I suggested we all leave, if you remember? It won’t happen again, we are too far down the rabbit hole and my conscience has been paid.”
“Your thirty pieces of silver!” Kenny spits.
“Oh no my dear boy, do not sell yourself short. For my part they gave me this.” He reaches into his robes-grey- like the Brotherhood of Azog wore- he should have known, and produces the most magnificent gem he had ever seen.
“The Arkenstone.” Balin whispers transfixed by the swirling colours resembling a galaxy trapped within glass.
“Of course, I cannot say where I found it, Erebor must remain a secret.”
“How do you suppose to do that now we all know the secret?” Kenny asks, and he admires his naivety and frankly given the current events he was envious of it.
“The team is expendable, I made sure of that.” He had feared he might say something like that. “My directions were simple, allow the boys to find the sigil and locate Erebor and then I was to bring you and Balin but there could be no witnesses, no one who would ask too many questions. As Ori was Balin’s second, he would know what became of his mentor so he had to meet the same fate. Dori comes with Ori, so Nori would know but Nori was seeing Bofur so they all had to disappear. Unfortunately, Thranduil got wind of my plan and had a friend mix up the sigil with the Maori exhibition travelling New York. In return, I called the headmaster at the university and told of his sordid affair with his pupil and advised that he should leave. I meant leave with Bard, I never thought he would take the toy boy.” Gandalf laughs. “This cover-up goes further than you could imagine Bilbo. Erebor was never lost it was hidden and it will remain that way. Ask Balin.” His jaw drops.
“Balin?” He asks in disbelief but the older man stares at him in confusion.
“Balin knows better than anyone the lengths they will go to cover up the past.”
“What is he talking about?” Freddy asks as he and Kenny have been rendered speechless.
“The Gundabad Chronicles.” Balin finally answers. “There were not thirteen chapters, there were fourteen. As I explored the mountain I came upon the banquet hall and that’s where I found the bodies, hundreds of them, some still wearing their finery. It was a massacre.”
“In Gundabad?” He asks knowing the same fate befell the Erebor inhabitants. Balin nods.
“I could not make sense of it but I recorded my findings and took pictures but my publishers refused to print that chapter. They took my dictaphone and memory cards and all of my research and swore me to silence. I should have never signed that waiver but I was selfish in that regard and I thought to make amends here. I asked for everything to be documented, written, photographed and recorded so the same fate would not befall me again.” The reason for Ori’s leather-bound book becomes clear, as it always struck him as odd that Balin chose to write instead of record.
“A nice try,” Gandalf says insincerely and produces the book from his robe. It had last been in Ori’s possession proving without doubt that he had been the one to push the youngster to his death. He tosses the book onto the floor beside Nori’s broken camera.
“Did you take my batteries?” He asks, as only Gandalf knew where he kept his spares.
“Don’t ask questions you already know the answers to, it’s exhausting and so is this conversation.” It happens so suddenly he has no time to react as Gandalf approaches Balin and clutches a fistful of white hair streaked with blood and as Bolg removes his forearm he runs a hunting knife across his throat, slashing him open from ear to ear before moving away covered in the historian’s blood.
Someone screams like a wounded animal behind him, it could be Kenny, he can’t be sure. He holds his arms out, blocking the boys should they decide to act impulsively while he watches Balin’s body drop to the ground lifeless.
He can’t find the words. He knew what Gandalf had done but he hadn’t quite believed it. Now seeing this his innocence is lost and he no longer sees a friend but the monster Gandalf truly is.
“How did you kill Bofur and Dori?” He finally asks, punishing himself for not recognizing the monster sooner.
“Air embolism.” Quick and painless, a small mercy. “I’ve done my part now,” Gandalf says to Bolg, looking shaken now there was physically blood on his hands. Bolg nods once, with his gun still directed at him and the brothers, giving Gandalf silent permission to leave.
“Coward!” He spits as Gandalf makes his way towards the exit.
“I respect you too much to watch you die like a dog. I never wanted this for you Bilbo but it is out of my hands. For what it’s worth I am sorry and I hope by answering your questions I’ve given you some closure.”
“Closure! You condemned me, them, all of us for a fucking stone!” Gandalf’s mouth tightens.
“You have never known hunger thanks to me, and now you never will.” His jaw drops as Gandalf takes the high road and leaves them to their fate.
“Azog wasn’t great.” He turns his ire upon Bolg. “He was a murderer known as the Defiler.”
“A name the Oathbreaker gave him.”
“He was known that long before the Blood Wars and what oath did he break?” He hadn’t broken his oath, he had simply made a mistake not seeing Azog’s obsession for what it was.
“Azog was to marry Thorin but the night before their marriage, Thorin murdered his siblings and nephews and poisoned the wine and blamed it on Azog. The Mad King had to be stopped and Azog put an end to him but his evil knew no bounds. Azog had to chisel off the prayer ritual to contain his evil but even then, it was foretold that should his tomb see the light of day the Mad King would return to seek revenge.”
“That’s bullshit! His only crime was to love the wrong person. Azog didn’t deserve his heart, couldn’t earn his love so he took his life. This brotherhood you have is a cult of liars. By sealing this tomb you are perpetuating lies.”
“I will not listen to the agent of the Mad King.” His jaw drops in response. Bolg genuinely believed he was a demon and his actions towards such evil were noble.
“You won’t get away with this.” Kenny shouts, and he truly wished he believed that as much as Kenny did.
“We have protected this mountain for a thousand years and we will protect it for a thousand more, in the name of Azog the Great.” He balls his hands into fists and they shake by his side. Arguing won’t solve anything, Bolg is too far gone mentally.
“There stands prince Fili and Kili reincarnated. The true heirs of Erebor, this mountain is their birth right, how could you deny them that? If they were Thorin’s victims why would they come back as his agents? And if you believe they were his victims why will you rob them of life a second time?” He tries to reason, ignoring the boys’ questioning looks.
The gun shakes in Bolg’s hand as he removes the safety. His words have gotten to him but his brainwashing was too much. He aims at Freddy and he lunges at him without thought and tries to wrestle the gun from his hand.
A single shot is fired during the melee and the fight stops as Bolg stares at him. He glares back, securing the gun in his own hand before he staggers back and falls to the ground. The boys shout then and as Bolg turns towards them, he fires two shots, catching him in the neck and the second shot in the shoulder. He presses a finger against his lips silencing the boys as Bolg clutches his neck trying but failing to stem the bleeding.
He looks like a fish out of water as he drops to the ground, with his grey skin and gasping mouth. It was an end Azog should have met with, but he realises that Thorin’s curse had come true and they had put an end to Azog’s bloodline.
“Bilbo,” Freddy whispers and approaches him. He drops the gun to take Kenny’s hand while Freddy holds him up against his knees holding him in a loose hug.
“It’s not so bad,” he laughs breathlessly and looks down. His jacket had been left when Ori fell and so he only had a light burgundy coat that was now saturated with blood. It is bad, he knows, he can feel it. “I fired two shots so Gandalf will think you are dead.” He admits and thinks Thorin would be proud of him protecting his nephews as he so desperately tried to do. “The Arkenstone is yours. You know it, in your hearts, remember who you are. Don’t let that monster take the treasure of your house.”
“Bilbo,” Kenny cries desperately with tears streaming down his face.
“It’s okay…it’s okay.” He tries to calm them both, patting their hands. You either die a hero or live long enough to become the villain, at least now he was finally the hero of his own story.
“Please don’t go.” Freddy whispers pressing kisses against his temple. He wished he had had a son.
He clutches Freddy closer in panic as he hears footsteps approaching the tunnel. “He’s coming back!” He gasps petrified for them.
“It’s okay Bilbo,” Kenny eases, rubbing his back.
His teeth chatter as he feels cold. “Can’t you hear him?” He asks panicked and catches the look of concern they both share. “This is your mountain, don’t let them take it from you.” He looks towards the entrance as the footsteps approach without the tell-tale sign of wood tapping against rock. He tries to sit up but his health is rapidly declining and the boys huddle around him trying to calm him. The footsteps draw nearer and there is something familiar in the crease of leather and the soft chime of chainmail and the tap of a sword against a muscular thigh.
“Bilbo? Bilbo please,” Kenny begs patting his cheek. He’s so cold and numb he can barely feel the touch. The boys hold him closer as if they could heal him with their love but he looks beyond Kenny’s shoulder to the entrance of the cave where Thorin stands.
“My moon,” he whispers with a smile and holds out his hand before darkness falls. There he floats in the inky black nothingness until a warm hand closes over his own and pulls him from the murky depths and into a loving embrace.
He feels as if he has awoken from a deep sleep, disorientated but rejuvenated. Everything is the same but much has changed. His presses his head against the chest of his beloved and hears the steady beat of his heart while his nose is filled with the scent of leather, fire and something uniquely Thorin.
“At last, my stars.” Arms that he was wrest from hold him tighter and in return he tightens his hold.
Heart-wrenching sobs capture his attention and he turns seeing the two princes’ different but very much the same bowed over the deceased body that had contained his spirit but not his soul. It is a sorry sight but he does not regret his actions. He leaves Thorin’s embrace unsure how to console them and watches Thorin look over his nephews like the proud uncle he was.
“We’ll be reunited soon.” He nods. The boys had a second chance at life and he did not begrudge them. Thorin had always been his life, his quest, his saviour and without him he hadn’t been living only existing, waiting for the day his king would return.
“What now?” He asks.
“Eternity awaits,” Thorin whispers and holds up his hand. He approaches him then and lifts his right hand and palm to palm they circle one another, each captivated by the others eyes. As they turn his heart is full and he feels himself float until there is nothing else only Thorin and a lifetime of love that was denied to them.
