Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

'Tis the Season

Summary:

Christmas brings many things - snow, present buying panic, and the return of Billy's old high school crush.

No matter what Heather says, this isn't going to end like a Hallmark movie.

 

Harringrove Winter Bingo prompt: Cheesy Winter Romcom

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

The snow arrives the same day that Steve Harrington does.

“What is it?” Heather asks, seeing his hands still around the wet cloth. When he still doesn’t answer, she stomps across the cafe to peer out of the window herself.

“Ah,” Heather says and he can’t help but flinch at her knowing tone.

“Shut up,” Billy mutters but doesn’t even try to take his eyes off the striking figure climbing out of the Mercedes. The snow had begun only a few minutes before, just enough to create a gentle flurry as the car inched along the street, stopping just outside Twilight Tea.

“Golden boy made good come home for the holidays,” Heather says quietly, leaning her elbows on the table. It probably stings a little - after all, she and Steve were of the same stock. Good families, money, opportunities…at least, until Heather had been caught with her hands down another girl’s top. The disowning was swift and brutal, made far worse by the scandal being captured by a rival paper to the one that Tom Holloway owned.

“I guess,” Billy says, reaching over to pick up the crockery he was meant to be clearing away. The cafe is always busy this time of year, heaving with people stopping in on their way to or from Christmas shopping. Billy watches the families that come in, sit by the window to watch the twinkling lights and feels a dull throb of pain. He doesn’t ever remember having a family moment like that.

“He was on some list of most eligible bachelors,” Heather says, watching Steve Harrington stroll across the street in a navy coat, flakes beginning to collect in his dark hair. “Net worth, hobbies, most recent girlfriend…it’s enough to make you sick.”

“Probably,” Billy says shortly, carting his load back to the kitchen. They’re not closed yet but they’re winding down for the night. The only person left in here is Alexei, nursing a mug of herbal tea over his textbooks.

“Wonder why he’s come back?” Heather muses, taking over Billy’s job of wiping down tables.

“Who’s back?” Robin asks, popping her head around from the kitchen. Heather just grins.

“Your favorite person,” she sings, gesturing to the rapidly disappearing figure of Steve Harrington. “The myth, the legend, the hair.” Robin makes a face but strains over the counter to see him anyway.

“Maybe it’s one of those Scrooge things,” she says, giving up and walking around to stand by her girlfriend. “He’ll be cranky and miserly to kids in the street, before ghosts appear to him in the night, while his bony knees shake under his nightgown…”

“I bet Billy would like to see that,” Heather says slyly, just loudly enough for even Alexei, with his dubious English, to look up.

“I hate you,” Billy says, without ire. For starters, he saw Steve in the showers during gym and he definitely doesn’t have bony knees.

What he did have was enough to fuel every single one of Billy’s teenage desires for years.

“Yeah, so he’s handsome and rich, but maybe he’s also a dick,” Robin says, hopefully. She spreads her hands across the space, as if to make a point by the sage green walls, the mismatched chairs, the fake stained glass partitions. “Look at what we have, huh? Our own business…”

“That will take us forever to pay off,” Heather says brutally, wiping her hands on her apron. They rent the space for cheap, and some of their equipment is getting old, hand me downs from Benny. By rights, three kids that come from nothing shouldn’t have even gotten this far but they had help. Heather had an aunt who liked her enough to leave her an inheritance, and Robin and Billy have been working and putting money away since they were old enough to. Combine that with Benny lending them a hand, and Hopper, and Joyce, and cranky old Murray…they’d all helped in some way, by investing, if they could, or finding cheap furniture or calling in favors…

It’s enough, because Billy finally feels like he belongs somewhere. This cosy little space, that they cleaned furiously and painted up, strung up with fairy-lights and photo-frames, made to feel like someone’s front room. Then there’s the apartment upstairs that they share, Heather and Robin in one room and Billy in the other. Sometimes it’s rough, living and working together, especially when two of you make up a couple. But it works more often than it doesn’t

“I was going to say ‘and we have each other’ but clearly this is not a festive mood,” Robin snarks, stomping back to the kitchen. Heather just shakes her head.

“I think the holidays are getting to her,” she confides quietly to Billy, as though she doesn’t wait for the one Christmas card her mother still sends her. They’d never admit it but all three of them fiercely cherish this little family that they’d made because the ones that gave birth to them don’t seem to give a fuck.

“Doesn’t it to us all,” Billy murmurs. He hasn’t heard from his dad in years, not since the divorce when Neil had hightailed it back…somewhere. Billy had been old enough to refuse, having finally - if reluctantly - put down roots in Hawkins. Susan and Max also stayed, moving out of the place on Old Cherry to the trailer park. They’re doing okay though. Max works when she’s not at school, even picking up a few hours here at the cafe when they can afford it. Billy stops by to see them pretty often because at the end of the day, after Robin and Heather, they’re kind of the only family he has.

Robin’s folks seem…fine. They’re not out waving pride flags or anything but they’ve invited Heather and Billy to Thanksgiving a couple of times. Robin always looks faintly pained by her mother’s comments but, unlike Neil, they don’t seem to come from a place of malice. Which, out of the three of them, means that Robin wins ‘least suckiest parents.’

Billy continues to clean up, even pouring Alexei another cup of coffee. He’s in no rush to kick the guy out. After all, Alexei comes in here a lot and, unlike certain customers, never makes a nuisance of himself.

The bell jingles just as Billy’s moving chairs back in and his heart sinks. They hadn’t flipped the sign yet but who wants coffee at ten to six five days before Christmas?

“We’re nearly closed,” he says shortly, and tries to remember that his lack of festive spirit isn’t anyone else’s problem. “We can get you something to go but…” His words are cut off, effectively drying up in his throat as he turns and meets Steve Harrington’s deep brown eyes.

“That’s okay,” Steve says easily, looking around the cafe curiously. Billy’s heart - that had skipped a beat, and then jittered into a frenzied beat - slowly grows cold as he sees the cafe through Steve’s eyes. Full of hand-me-downs, shabby around the edges, only just held together by enough quaint charm that they can get away with it. “I just wanted to see…Tammy said you guys had opened up a cafe.”

Tammy Thompson, who works at the jewelers down the road, and has the dubious honor of being Robin’s first love. Sadly, she’d only had eyes for Steve, something that clearly hasn’t changed.

“Yeah,” Billy says, aware that the chattering in the kitchen has stopped. “Nearly a year now.”

“Good business?” Steve asks, and Billy can hardly take the soft tone, as though Steve genuinely wants to know.

“Yeah,” Billy says again, wondering where the fuck his words have gone. “It was slow to start…but Robin makes all of our cakes, and Heather did a stint in a proper coffee shop, so she knows all the tricks and I…” His words trail off, unsure why Steve is looking at him like that. Maybe he’s babbling.

“And you?” Steve prods, as though he’s not wearing a coat that costs more than Billy makes in a month, two months, as though Steve hasn’t grown from being a young doe-eyed sort of attractive into a heartthrob that would make women swoon, as though he actually cares what Billy does in his day to day.

It hurts, because there’s no way that he does.

“I worked at Benny’s a lot during high school,” Billy says, regretting it the moment the words come out. Yeah, he’d spent a lot of time in school alone, because he’d needed to work, because having friends was a risk and most of the time he’d smelt like the diner anyway, full of grease and fat and sweat. But he hadn’t cared because Benny had looked after him like no one else ever had. “So I do most of the cooking.”

“Cool,” Steve says, sweeping slightly damp hair away from his face. It’s still trying to blizzard outside, the white flakes getting thicker and faster with every minute. “Will you be open tomorrow? I should stop in for breakfast.”

“We’re open until Christmas Eve,” Billy says, because as much as it sucks, they stand to rake in a lot of cash from the last minute shopping crowd. They did really well during the summer, but then it had settled down as the winter had started to draw in and they need that buffer to last them until spring. They’re only closed for three days, opening up again on the twenty-eighth. It’s not much but they’re a new business and there’s only three of them. Aside from Max, or Jane, who come in for a few hours when needed, they can’t afford to hire anyone else yet.

“Great,” Steve says, meeting Billy’s eyes with a warm smile. It’s the exact same smile from high school, something that starts out slow and lazy, and then spreads across Steve’s face until it’s as blinding as staring into the sun. “I’ll have to stop by.”

“Isn’t it your morning off tomorrow?”

“No,” Billy says through gritted teeth, without turning around. Robin and Heather have finally slunk out of the kitchen, just to watch Billy’s humiliation. You’d think they’d have something better to do, but apparently when you’re a happy lesbian couple, a popular pastime is torturing your single friends.

They got lucky. They fell in love senior year and never had to struggle through Hawkins’ limited gay scene.

“I thought it was,” Heather adds, folding her arms across her chest. Robin rests her head against Heather’s shoulder, her cheek against baby-blue cotton. “Hi, Steve.”

“Hi, Heather,” Steve says, nodding towards her and Robin. “And…Robin? Hey.”

Robin looks vaguely startled that Steve even remembers her name. But Steve had never been one of those guys, even though he’d been the undisputed king. And he could have so easily been a dick, but he never was.

More’s the pity to Billy’s poor, fragile heart.

“I’m sure it’s Heather’s?” Billy retorts, wondering if the lure of an unexpected morning off will get her to shut up. He’d forgotten that tomorrow was his glorious free morning of the week, where he doesn’t have to get up at six for opening, and can lie in listening to the sounds of chatter and the coffee maker below him. “I’m definitely working tomorrow morning.”

Heather gives him a slow, sly smile, and he realises that this was probably her plan all along.

“You’re right,” she says, with a shrug. “My mistake. Hey, you should make Steve your eggs Benedict. You’ll love it, Steve. People swear up and down they want to marry Billy after they’ve had the eggs benedict.”

“Is that so?” Steve says, looking delighted. He appears to have missed Heather’s pointed tone. “That sounds great.”

“But I still have to work,” Robin protests weakly as Heather slinks back to the kitchen. It’s now past six, time they should be locking up the doors and turning off the lights. With a jolt, Billy remembers that Alexei is still here, watching the proceedings with bright, interested eyes.

“Shit,” Steve says, pulling up his sleeve to check his watch. “You guys probably need to close. I just…wanted to say hi. I came back to see my parents for the holidays.”

“You’re staying here for Christmas?” Billy asks, unable to stop himself. But the hesitation on Steve’s face crushes whatever small hope he’d had pretty quickly.

“No, I was just here for a few days,” Steve says, shrugging sheepishly. “Thought I’d stop by, exchange presents with the folks before I need to get back…back home.”

“I see,” Billy says stiffly. God, he’s an idiot. The snow, the appearance of his old crush on his doorstep, smiling at him and saying how much he was looking forward to breakfast. Jesus, this isn’t some stupid Hallmark film. Steve clearly has a partner at home, in New York, in Chicago, in LA, wherever he lives now with a fancy, modern apartment, where the plumbing always works and the neighbors don’t fuck and fight with equal fervour.

Shit, is it too late to take back his morning off?

“But I’ll definitely come by tomorrow,” Steve says, shifting his weight back and forth. “I’d like to see you guys when it’s open. Didn’t this used to be…”

“The old pawn shop, yeah,” Billy says. The large windows, the huge open space at the front had been ideal for a cafe. Sorting out the back to make a decent kitchen to work out of had been harder, and where most of their money had gone. But because of the state of it, rent had been dirt cheap, and it seemed worth it to scrub down black floors for three days straight. Hadn’t always at the time, particularly when Robin had found the dead mice in the office, but they’d never have afforded it otherwise. “Closed down a few years ago and sat empty. All of the other units in the street were too expensive…anyway, it worked out well for us.”

“Tomorrow you’re going to have to tell me how you three went into business together,” Steve says with a small, soft smile. And Billy knows at that moment that he’s going to drag himself out of bed before it’s even light, if there’s even a glimmer of a chance of seeing that smile again.

“Sure,” Billy says, aware of Robin behind him, helping Alexei pack up his textbooks. “Over breakfast.”

His heartbeat doesn’t slow down even as the door swings closed behind Steve once more, and Billy hides behind the bookcase to watch his progress across the street back to his car.

“He’s not wearing the right shoes,” Heather grumbles, joining Billy at the window. She’s not alone, however, Robin and Alexei right behind her. “Fuck’s sake, he grew up here, he should know better.”

“Maybe he wasn’t expecting it to snow?” Robin suggests, as Steve climbs into the driver’s seat. Heather snorts.

“It’s Hawkins,” she says bluntly. “Of course it’s going to snow. Besides, it wouldn’t be Billy’s perfect little rom-com without a white Christmas, would it?”

“I fucking hate you,” Billy snaps, much to the surprise of Alexei. “No, not…go home, Alexei.”

The door jingles once more and Heather deftly does up the bolts. She still looks unrepentant, not even the least bit guilty. “I wanted to see how far you’d take it. God, you’re gone on the guy still, aren’t you?”

“It doesn’t mean anything,” Billy says, wanting nothing more than to climb into bed with a pot noodle and watch shitty TV. It’s so fucking pointless than he has to keep stomping down on any flicker of hope that dares flare into life. Steve’s so far beyond his level, it’s not even funny. All Billy’s ever known is scraping by, counting every penny, working his ass off for the life he has now. All Steve’s even known is everything on a golden platter, where life is warm and fun and easy. “Besides, he's straight. You do remember him screwing every available girl in high school, right?”

“We were there, we remember,” Robin says wryly, dropping down the blinds.

“And he’s not sticking around anyway,” Billy says, because by the time Christmas rolls around, Steve Harrington will leave this backwater town in his dust.

“Maybe the Christmas spirit will move him into staying a little bit longer?” Heather suggests, wiggling her eyebrows. “I wasn’t kidding before. Feed the man and he might be tempted into sticking around.”

Those aren’t words Billy’s used to. People don’t just stick around.

“Shit like that doesn’t happen in real life,” Billy says wearily, starting to pull up the chairs onto the tables. “He’s not about to change his plans.”

“Why not?” Heather asks and for a second he forgot that this is the shit she was raised on. While Billy watched action films to impress his dad and Robin watched artsy French films, Heather grew up on a diet of romance and glitter, the fairy tale ending where everyone hooks up by prom and people kiss in the snow in front of Christmas trees. “Tis the season. You never know what might happen.”

No, this is not some cheesy romcom.

Oh, but if it was.

Notes:

Except in the version in my head, yeah, it's totally a happy ending romcom.

I usually finish my bingo prompts in a panic about a week before deadline so yay me! I've finished two, and half completed two more. Maybe this is a sign of a good 2026.