Chapter Text
The others accepted Mahal’s cryptic answer, though Thorin couldn’t help but be curious at the way his maker seemed to not know himself what the hobbit creator had in plan. They were distracted by Fíli who was moving towards the rocks again in much haste, almost as if his life depended on it.
“My son,” Mahal called to him, catching his attention. This time, Fíli only appeared worried and everyone knew it was not for himself. Mahal gave him a kind look that seemed to ease his nephew’s worries just a little. Mahal rose a rocky brow at him.
“Now, you know full well that that could not happen,” Mahal said, looking almost amused. Fíli jerked a little in shock and Mahal just shrugged good-naturedly. “Part of being your creator, I guess. I know each dwarf’s thoughts, just as I know your thoughts right now.” Their maker then tilted his head towards him with a soft look.
“Do not fear for Leoláin. She is safe and on her way here. Trust me,” he said seriously when Fili looked ready to argue. “I would not let you stay here if she was in danger or in harm's way.” Fíli stared at him for a moment, eyes calculating Mahal before he finally nodded his head once, moving back to sit on his rock, though he looked anything but calm on the matter. In fact, he looked to be slowly spiraling further into a panic attack, and the only one who seemed to be able to do anything to help distract him was his brother. Kíli took to talking Fíli’s ear off, and, thankfully, he did it quietly.
Thorin noticed Yavanna shake her head fondly as she watched, glancing up at Mahal so they could share a fond look, even if it was brief. The two of them glanced down at Bilbo, and back up at each other with a small sigh.
“This is going to take a lot out of me,” Yavanna warned, smiling timidly at the shrug of Mahal’s broad shoulders.
“I’ll help you home,” Mahal offered with a soft smile, motioning towards the hole he came out of. “We can take the scenic route!” Yavanna’s startled laugh seemed to bring life around them and brought a sense of calm with it. With a nod to her husband, she walked up to Bilbo and Thorin, crouching down in front of them, and Thorin was startled when he felt grass suddenly sprout beneath his knees. At a quick glance, he realized that grass had grown all around them, guessing that it was from the Lady’s very presence.
“Oh, Bilbo Baggins,” Yavanna cooed, brushing away some of his curls as a mother would, a gentle smile on her face. “I'm so sorry, my child.” Thorin couldn’t help the burn in his eyes, blinking back the tears that filled his vision at the sight of it. After another moment of silence, she gazed up at Thorin.
“I am going to go back in his memories, and deem whether Bilbo's actions were indeed selfless or selfish. It will not change whether I bring him back or not," she promised, her amber eyes soothing Thorin and his obvious worries at her words.
"But if I find them to be indeed an act of selfishness, I will hereby remove fairy powers from all hobbits in the Shire that hold it,” Yavanna explained to Thorin who nodded somewhat hesitantly. Mahal made a delighted noise from behind her.
“Hehe! Good! You should probably just remove the Magic from them anyways,” he chimed in, peering over Yavanna’s shoulder. “I think it’s caused enough damage to our children and your hobbits.” She nodded slightly, appearing to be only half-listening. As she continued to gaze at Bilbo, her eyes grew uncertain, her green brows furrowing in deep thought.
“What’s wrong?” Thorin couldn’t help but ask after some time had passed, eyes bouncing between Bilbo and Yavanna. He wouldn’t deny that he was becoming an even bigger wreck, holding his breath while Yavanna inhaled slowly.
“I will be taking away the power from my children who have it and do not know they possess the magic in their blood,” Yavanna reaffirmed to them, waving her hand in the air as if that simple movement removed the magic.
“But,” she said slowly, glaring down at Bilbo in a way that made Thorin hold his breath in fear of her next words, “I feel deeply impressed to leave Bilbo with his magic powers,” she explained, her fingers gently touching the braid in Bilbo’s hair. She held the braid between her fingers for a moment longer, before giving a slight nod of her head. “With the first curse gone, Bilbo Baggins will be the first Hobbit to go back to the way of the fairies. He will have magic that he can use freely, without consequences from me.” Thorin had to admit he was a little shocked by the proclamation but grateful that his One would live and wouldn’t have to go through such a painful death ever again. Judging by the way Mahal jerked his head in shock, Thorin was not the only one surprised by her declaration.
“But, you must warn him of using magic in a too carefree manner,” she warned him, a grave look in her eyes. “For though I will not bestow the consequence, there are consequences to all of our actions.”
"Leoláin!" Fíli suddenly shouted, startling the hobbit creator and everyone else, though Thorin could hear the happiness clear in his voice with just an underlying tone of worry. They all turned to watch as Fíli ran up to the girl who was struggling up to the rock base where they were, her arm seemed to hang limply by her side. Thorin was a little surprised when his nephew practically threw himself at Leoláin. The girl seemed slightly startled by the act as well but quickly accepted the hug with a small smile on her face.
“Oh, thank Mahal, you’re safe,” Fili cried, pulling back to smile brightly at Leoláin whose eyes twinkled with awkward amusement, her own smile growing.
“You’re very welcome, my son,” Mahal said cheerfully, smiling down at the couple. Fíli turned to his Maker, brow raised in amusement, and Thorin could feel the relief rolling off of his nephew in waves. Fíli bowed to him, respectfully and his smile was one of gratitude. Leoláin looked back and forth between the two, eyes widening as her brain began to catch up with Fíli and Mahal’s words.
“Is . . . is he - ?” Fíli nodded his head at the question and stumbled to help her back to his rock so they could sit down. Mahal waved his hand in what Thorin thought was greeting, but when he looked back at the girl, she was lifting her arm and moving it around and the small cut on her eye was gone, showing that she had been healed in very much the same way that they had. The bemused smile on Mahal’s face at her own shocked look was quite hilarious. Leoláin brushed Fíli off easily with her renewed strength, and walked over to Mahal, ignoring Fíli fabulously as he fell to the ground with a light yelp, tripping over his own feet as he tried to go after her. He was completely fine, if also completely caught off guard by her sudden haste to meet her Maker.
‘Meet her Maker.’ Ha!
“Ha! Good one, Thorin!” Mahal chuckled lowly, catching Thorin a little off guard at the way his Maker read his mind.
“Hail, Mahal, creator of the mighty race of dwarves,” she called out, kneeling in front of him and placing her right fist over her heart as she bowed before him. Mahal grinned down at the title, and after a moment, Leoláin glanced up timidly with a sheepish smile. “Um. . . I apologize, but I don’t know what I should do after this.” Mahal gave a little chuckle, before bowing his head low in greeting, an honor that had even Yavanna’s eyes widen in shock before looking at Leoláin as if she was staring into the girl's very soul. A look of recognition crossed her face and she smiled widely in Leoláin’s direction.
“There is nothing to forgive, child of mine. Go and help your One to his rock that he seems very fond of.” Leoláin’s strangled intake of breath and Fíli’s mumbles of how he was not fond over the rock were the only noises to be heard after the surprise announcement. When Thorin thought a little about it, it made some sense with the way that Fíli had been acting. The girl shook her head, eyes closed as if to shake the weird thought from her mind.
“Forgive me, but I - I beg your pardon?” Yavanna chuckled along with Mahal, turning to share a knowing look with her husband.
“Oh, my dear,” she said, her voice like the rustling of leaves on a warm day, catching Leoláin and Fíli’s attention. “Though you do not see it yet, we see it as clear as day, just as we see the ever-growing and strengthening bond between Thorin, son of Thraín, and Bilbo Baggins,” she said, eyeing Thorin with a warm smile that had him surprisingly smiling back, even though his heart still ached with the absence of his Bilbo. Yavanna turned towards Dale with a slight tilt of her head. “The love between Dwalin, son of Fundin, and Ori, son of Lori. The tenderness between Bofur son of Bokur, and Nori son of Lori.” Thorin glanced at that couple, smiling softly at the way the pair were grinning at each other. Yavanna continued to list off some couples, looking around at only a few of the couples there, her eyes catching sight of Thorin’s other nephew. “And the fondness between Kíli son of Víli, and Tauriel, Captain of the Gaurd of Mirkwood.” Kíli suddenly had a massive smile on his face, as he no doubt was thinking of his One. At the mention of elves, there was some grumbling from a particular dwarf in his company, and Mahal gave a small chuckle.
“As much as I am also unfond of elves, Glóin, my son,” he spoke, making the others glance at the dwarf who looked to be turning as red as his beard for being caught, “there are a few elves who are rather exceptional,” Mahal said with a small nod. He glanced at Kíli with a look of pride. “Those special enough, are the ones I chose for my children. Hopefully, that will bring you some comfort when the time comes in your life.” There was a strange look in Mahal's eyes as he smirked down at Glóin who was beginning to puff up in confusion.
“What does that mean?!” Mahal’s smile only grew.
“Oh, you’ll see,” he giggled almost madly, “and you are not going to like it, haha! But, you’ll get over it. He is really special, even if his father's annoying,” he smiled, and Yavanna nodded, turning back to Leoláin.
“We also see the bonds of those who may not have their other half with them now.” Thorin couldn’t help but think of his dear cousin, Balin, and his now dear friend, Dori. The eldest Ri was smiling softly at the creator even with the pain in his eyes. Yavanna smiled soothingly at his friend, before turning back to Leoláin.
“Do not fight the feeling of love, for it is a magic that is beyond the strength and power of even Morgoth himself.” Mahal nodded, gazing down at Leoláin who was staring at Fíli in shock. Fíli gave a little smirk and leaned in to steal a hug. Either to be flirtatious or funny, Thorin did not know and reminded himself to tell his nephew that he was neither flirtatious nor funny and he should stop trying to be right away; but, it seemed Leoláin was going to do that for him. The poor girl seemed to go into a small panic attack of her own, grabbing his jacket in one hand and chucking him back in horror. Unfortunately for Fíli, he was not the most graceful dwarf, and it showed now as he fell on his rear with a small yelp.
“Don’t be daft,” she hissed at him, though Thorin still saw the look of concern in her eyes and the way her hands reached out as if to help him, though she restrained herself. “You may be funny, brave, a little smart, and kind of attractive,” she rambled nervously, gesturing at Fili.
“‘A littl- Kind of’ ?” Fili squawked from the ground, but Leoláin paid him no mind as she continued.
“But! That does not mean I will just do something stupid! Or just jump into hugs with you like that !” she declared with a snap of her fingers. “No matter the fact that I, crazy enough, wouldn’t mind, and no matter what they say! No offense,” she rushed holding her hands up to Mahal and Yavanna. The creators seemed to not really care, looking at the pair with amusement. “It’s - it’s just that . . .” Leoláin tried to explain, glancing all around her as if asking for help. When no one said anything, the girl looked down at Fíli who was lying at her feet smiling pleasantly up at her. “We just met!” Fíli laughed quietly, holding out his hand which Leoláin took instantly, helping him up to his feet. When he stood, he gently grasped her arm with his other hand in an almost embrace. He smiled fondly at her, making the young maiden blush even through her tan skin.
“Don’t worry, Princess,” he said, earning himself a scowl at the title. “We can talk about it later. Whenever you're ready.” Fíli winked at her, startling a laugh from the girl which brought a laugh to his own lips. The two nodded at each other in understanding, and walked, surprisingly hand-in-hand, back over to Fíli’s rock. Thorin watched them with a tender look on his face, lips lifting ever so slightly when Fíli made enough room for both Leoláin and Kíli to sit on either side of him. He was glad his nephew had found the same love he himself had found with Bilbo. That both his nephews had found it. Found their Ones.
May it never be taken from them, please, Thorin prayed, and he felt a large hand rest on his shoulder, startling him. He glanced up as Mahal gazed down at him intently, a comforting look in his eyes.
“It won’t,” he promised, his voice no louder than a whisper, and Thorin realized with a sudden jolt that Mahal had heard him, and was answering his silent prayer right now. Thorin bowed his head in thanks, and Mahal left him to go back and kneel just behind Yavanna. She was smiling sweetly up at Mahal, before turning and moving her attention back to Bilbo.
She gently placed her hands on either side of his head, and at first, Thorin felt relieved when he saw the smile that graced her face. The air around them, which had been pleasant enough, suddenly grew heavy with an eeriness about it, the wind picking up above the gentle breeze that it had been. Thorin glanced at Yavanna, watching as her head began to twitch to the side, her face contorting into an expression of unease. Thorin was not the only one growing worried when her breathing began to grow shorter, louder, and came in quick succession, the wind vigorously whipping around them.
“Anna?” Mahal called out over the howling wind, watching as pain swept over her, her face pinching in fear. It was a terrible sight watching her spasm, and it seemed Mahal couldn’t stand it anymore. “Yavanna!” The hobbit creator’s eye snapped open, and she fell away from Bilbo into Mahal’s waiting arms. The wind stopped immediately. Mahal held her, as she clutched her hands to her chest as if they had been burned. Mahal helped her sit up, continuingly asking about her wellbeing. Thorin glanced down at his hobbit, then back up to Yavanna who was shivering and looking at Bilbo in agony.
“What happened?” Thorin demanded, looking between the two creators and Bilbo. “What happened?!” Mahal scowled at him.
“Now you just sit there, and wait till she gets some air,” he scolded, eyes hard and final. Thorin complied, and moments went on with Mahal calmly holding her, whispering sweet soothing words to calm her down. Finally, Yavanna leaned into her husband and mumbled something in his ear which had him gasp and look at Bilbo in shock. He glanced back at her, startled.
“You’re sure?” At the little tilt of her head, Mahal cursed under his breath and began mumbling about something that Thorin strained to hear yet couldn’t, though if he were to go by the scowl on his face, whatever Mahal was saying wasn’t good.
“What is it?” Thorin asked, begging to know now as his anxiousness continued to grow.
“He has it,” Yavanna finally answered him, her voice firmer than he had expected though she physically shook with whatever it was that was troubling her.
“Has what?!” Thorin couldn’t help but demand, getting rather furious now that everyone was being so vague and it all had to do with his One. He was about to go off and yell a little more and may Mahal help those who got in his way.
"Oh stop that," Mahal scolded, glancing at Thorin with a tiny scowl. “The only one who is going to get in your way is me so that doesn’t make sense for me to stop myself.” He glanced back down at Yavanna who was still clinging to him with her eyes squeezed shut. Shaking his head, he turned back to Thorin and Bilbo in concern. Thorin felt like he was going to explode in anxiety, especially when Mahal leaned forward as if to speak, only to turn away to the far side of the rock area. That’s when Thorin heard it. The sound of galloping animals that was becoming increasingly louder. When Thorin finally turned, he was greeted with the sight of his missing company members.
Balin and Bifur rode up the walkway, Dwalin and Ori coming up behind them on their shared ram. Thorin felt some relief at the sight of his friends, and that was when he noticed the grey pointy hat coming up the way. Galloping on a beautiful white horse was Gandalf, who held the same all-knowing yet slightly confused face. He managed to maneuver his way over, passing the dwarves and sliding off his horse in a graceful way.
“Thank you, Shadowfax,” the wizard whispered, leaving a gentle touch on the horse's nose and Thorin swore he saw the horse nod almost as if in response. Gandalf swiftly walked up to them, eyes only on the hobbit. He crouched before them both, his hand moving just above the hobbit, mumbling incoherent things under his breath. With a sigh, he withdrew his hand, glancing down at Bilbo with a sad look in his eyes.
“My dear boy, I’m so sorry.” Now Thorin was really starting to lose his patience. Had it not been the extra sounds of two other horses that caught Thorin’s attention, Thorin knew he would have really been flipping out; but as he glanced behind Gandalf to see two beings who had not been invited up to this terrible gathering, he was starting to flip out anyways.
“Why did you bring them here, Gandalf,” Thorin couldn’t help but sneer, shifting his hobbit closer as Bard and Thranduil dismounted and walked up to them. Gandalf didn’t even acknowledge him, turning instead to the two creators to his left. Thorin glanced back at the two uninvited guests, taking in Bard’s horrified look. Even Thranduil looked stunned, his big mouth hanging open in shock. Thorin couldn’t look at them any longer, turning to the wizard.
"My good lady," the wizard said with a smile, turning to Mahal with a strained smile. "Aüle," Gandalf said, not sparing Mahal another look. Mahal shockingly growled at the wizard, surprising Thorin at the aggressiveness towards the wizard. Yavanna shook her head in exasperation, turning to Gandalf with a smile.
“My friend,” she welcomed warmly, looking at him expectantly. “Did you bring what I asked for?” Thorin watched as Gandalf’s eyes looked over to Bard, his suspicion growing at the way the man glanced down sheepishly. The wizard shifted his gaze over to Thranduil who was appearing even more statuesque than usual. With a soft sigh, Gandalf finally answered her.
“I was, unfortunately, not given the stone, my lady,” he revealed, startling most of the group. “As the people who hold onto it, refuse to give it to me.” There was a second of silence, then every one of the dwarves was in an uproar, cursing the bowman and Elvenking loudly.
As Thorin sat there in shock with the shouts of his kin sounding faint in his own ears, all he could think about was how close he was. He had managed to drag two creators right in front of him, get them to agree to help save his Bilbo all for the cost of that blasted stone, just to now be told that he couldn’t have it back? Thorin wasn’t going to have any of it.
“The Arkenstone does not belong to you two!” Thorin bellowed, quieting most of the group even though they all shouted in agreement with him. Thorin stood up for the first time in an hour. His legs were completely asleep, but his mind and sheer will power stayed him from swaying. Also, the fact that he refused to look weak in front of the tree shagging elf king, also helped.
“It belongs to me, and my people,” he declared, trying to allow his legs time to remember how to move, but he was ready to charge at them with the anger he felt. He pointed to the Green Lady. “And we are giving it to Yavanna. Now, give me the stone.” Everyone stilled at the deep, muffled laughs that eerily filled the air. They all glanced at Thranduil who was now looking more as if he didn’t have a care in the world.
“Do you really think we would believe you wanted the Arkenstone, just to give it away to someone else?” Thranduil asked in exasperation, still chuckling like he had heard the funniest thing ever. The King waved his hand in Bilbo’s direction. “You nearly killed your friend because he took it, and now you want to give it away?” The king roared in laughter when Thorin did a small flinch at his words. Thorin turned away from Thranduil, for he knew if he continued to look at him he was going to kill him, and instead glanced at the bowman in hope.
“In exchange for the Arkenstone, I will give your people more than what was bargained for in Laketown,” he pleaded, catching the bowman off guard. “The mountain is open to you and all your people till you have enough strength and men to rebuild Dale and Laketown, which I promise to provide added help when you begin rebuilding.” Bard’s eyes grew wider with every declaration made by Thorin till he stood gawking at him, stunned. “You have my word.”
“Like that means anything,” Thranduil sneered. Thorin couldn’t deny the harsh statement made, remembering in a blur how Bard had pleaded for him just to keep his word back at Erebor. Bard seemed to recall this moment as well if the glare shot at him had anything to do with it.
“I know my previous actions can never be forgiven, or overlooked,” Thorin accepted, lowering his head in defeat. “If our places were reversed, I doubt I would believe or trust you.” Thorin felt a hand on his shoulder and glanced up to give a thin smile at his youngest nephew.
“My mind has been cleared of the gold sickness, and it has never been more clear till this moment. I need that stone,” Thorin begged, praying to Mahal for his help. “And I will do whatever it takes to get it back.” Bard looked hesitant, half of him appearing as if he wanted to give him the stone, and the other half not willing to. Thranduil seemed to notice the bowman’s inner struggles, and walked over to him, standing in front of Thorin and blocking him from Bard's view.
“Your words mean nothing to us,” he dismissed Thorin, a small yelp turning into a growl at the stone that was thrown at his head. The Elvenking whirled around at Mahal, assuming him to be the culprit, but the creator was smirking at the group of young ones in Thorin's company.
Though it was Ori who was the one to throw the stone, his aim still perfect even with the way they seemed to shake, Kíli was the one who stormed up to the two kings, his fists trembling at his side in his anger.
“The Arkenstone belongs to the King of Erebor, my uncle. You will not dismiss him as if he were anything lesser than you,” Kíli raged at the elf who glared down at his nephew, but the cold eyes of the elf did nothing to deter the boy. “We deserve the Arkenstone, and we demand that you give it to us!...please,” the dwarf corrected on second thought. Thranduil’s lip curled back as if the elf was about to snap something at Kili when a hand grabbed at his shoulder gently.
The dwarves stood watching as Thranduil slowly turned back to the bowman, beginning to have whispered conversations. Thorin watched, his eyes narrowing when Thranduil shook his head at Bard. Bard was still looking at him with an unchanging face, but the man almost looked displeased with the elf when Thranduil shook his head again, opening his mouth to speak again but was promptly cut off.
“Why do you need the stone?” Bard called out, much kinder than the Elvenking. Thranduil rolled his eyes, turning away from them all in annoyance. Thorin felt his hopes rise at the look on Bard’s face, hoping to gain his favor. Yavanna spoke up from the side where she rested against Mahal.
“In exchange for the Arkenstone, I will bring back Bilbo Baggins.” Bard stared at the creator who nodded her head, confirming whether or not she planned to do that, before glancing back down at Thorin in confusion.
“I don’t understand,” he said, glaring at Thorin. “As Thranduil said, you nearly killed him not mere hours ago, and banished him before all of us, labeling him a traitor.” Thorin looked down at the hobbit, shame eating away at him. “And now you are willing to give up the Arkenstone to save him?” At Thorin’s quick nod, Bard narrowed his eyes at the dwarf. “Why?”
“The hobbit is my One,” Thorin explained, trying to make things speed up so he could get Bilbo back. Every second without him was agony. To Thorin’s surprise, Bard’s face split into a large smile while Thranduil let out a small displeased grunt. Thorin turned back to watch as Thranduil looked rather put out, and felt rather confused by the whole ordeal. Only able to construct the idea that these two had made a bet about him and Bilbo, which was weird and rather strange, but Thorin had to ignore it for the moment, definitely planning to come back to it later.
“Uh,” Thorin said, gathering their attention again. “What I did to him, is more disgraceful than I can possibly tell.” Thorin had to look away at the pitting look that came across Bard’s face, glancing instead at his One. “I have a chance though, to bring him back, and-”
“And what?” Thranduil demanded, right in front of Thorin’s face in less than a second. “Have a happy ending with your One?” the elf hissed. Thorin glared at him. “Why do you deserve to live a nice and happy life with your love, while others must suffer the loneliness?” Thorin opened his mouth to shout at him, ready to argue with the tree shagger, but slowly found himself closing it. He thought about his last hour without the hobbit, and couldn’t picture living any longer without him.
But what if you had to? his thoughts wandered. What if that had been the end? What makes you get to live a happy life with your One, while others like Balin, Dori, Dis, Bard, and even Thranduil have to live on without theirs? What makes you better than them?
Thranduil made a small noise, straightening to his normal height. “That’s what I thought.” And with that, Thranduil turned to walk away. Thorin felt his blood boil at the sheer audacity and stubbornness of the elf, and suddenly, Thorin had a lot to say to him.
“You would let him die because of your own pain?” Thorin bellowed at the retreating form. Thranduil didn’t stop though as he continued to walk to his elk, and Thorin suddenly felt a rush of terror at the idea that they would leave, the Arkenstone and his One with them. “You would let him die because of your hatred towards me?!” Thranduil glanced back over his shoulder at Thorin, and his expression was blank.
“You already let him die.” Thorin's mouth dropped, and he felt absolutely gutted, his heart had stopped.
He can’t mean it. He can’t. . . he can’t. . . .
“How dare you,” Yavanna growled at Thranduil so fiercely that everyone whipped around to stare at her, even Thranduil. She was absolutely seething, and with a wave of her hand, she was lifted up from her spot and was carried over to stop in front of Thranduil by massive vines with large thorns that stuck out at odd ends, only making Thorin further add to the idea that Yavanna was very mad.
“You’re really acting like Fearnor right now,” she said, and at first, Thorin had no idea what she was talking about, but whatever it was, was taken as an insult by the looks of it. Thranduil’s eyes widened in anger, and he opened his mouth to no doubt yell when Yavanna shook her head vigorously.
“Keep quiet,” she hissed, making him shut his mouth with a snap. The green lady pointed at Bilbo, her harsh look falling. “You would let him die because of your selfishness?” Thranduil quickly glanced at Bilbo, but when his eyes went back up to met her, any bit of remorse he had on his face for him fell and he was back to glaring.
“People die in battle all the time,” he spat through gritted teeth. “It is a small price I am willing to pay.” The group was in chaos at the proclamation, even Bard didn’t seem to like his words. Everyone was yelling, all but one. Thorin stood there with feet planted as firmly as they could for he feared falling over in his grief, his heart breaking even more at the way Thranduil seemed to be able to throw away Bilbo’s life like that.
“Why?” he pleaded, trying to make sense of Thranduil’s reasoning. His question silenced those around him. The Elvenking met Thorin's unrestrained look of confusion with a cold glare. “What has Bilbo done to you that would make you so unwilling to help? Why won’t you help him?”
“What makes you and your One so important, that you get a second chance?” Thranduil demanded, jabbing his finger in his chest. “I lost my beloved wife Ages ago, and do you know why?” Thorin blinked in shock at the hurt in the Elvenking’s eyes, and it seemed that had been the breaking point for Thranduil who was now talking freely, his voice full of anger and untold sorrow.
“My father had a necklace of precious white gems made by the dwarves, the one that resides in your mountain,” he growled out. “My father said I could have it, but I would have to go and get it myself. So, I went to the meeting with the King Under the Mountain, thinking I could gift my lovely wife with the necklace when I returned. I arrived just as they found that wretched stone.” Thranduil’s pained voice rang through the field. “I brought the agreed payment, as my visit was supposed to be quick. Pay, get the necklace, and then leave.” The elf shook his head in disgust.
“But do you know what your ancestors did?" Thranduil whispered, his face full of anguish. "Thrain pushed our meeting off for weeks. I waited patiently, as I had no reason to start a quarrel with our allies. Then, when I finally got my meeting with the King, bringing our payment, do you know what your ancestor did?” Thranduil asked coldly, and Thorin was glad he didn’t have to respond to that question and disappointed that he didn’t actually know the answer to it anyways. Thranduil snarled, the rage and anger coming back to his features. “Thrain laughed in my face. He told me he would only trade with my King and turned me away. I had no choice but to return home, only to find out that the day before my return, my home had been attacked, and my wife, my wife !” Thranduil cried. Thorin flinched at the harshness in his tone, and he was not alone as even Gandalf and Mahal's heads moved back in a flinch. “Had been taken hostage by orcs and filth that stormed the capital of my father's lands. She was dragged and beaten all the way to Gundabad!” The Elvenking bellowed, his exterior shaking with his memories.
“I took my army to find her, but it was already too late, and I had to sit and watch as she died in my arms!” A small sob escaped the Elvenking’s mouth, and Thranduil shut it with a snap to hold back anymore sounds that threatened to escape. Thranduil turned away from them all, walking over to the ledge of the rock, and glancing down at the ice below him, his head hung in misery.
Everyone was silent, not a sound to be heard. Yavanna had gone back to stand next to Mahal through Thranduil’s speech, and Thorin saw a few of her tears running down her cheeks, falling to the earth, little flowers growing where her tears landed. The Company didn’t know how to respond. Even Mahal was looking sheepish about his earlier roughness towards the elf, who was obviously still grieving over the loss of his wife. Thorin didn’t blame him, knowing full well that he wouldn’t live one hour without grieving the loss of Bilbo if Bilbo was really lost to him.
Thorin so lost in his own thoughts, missed Balin walk up to the Elvenking who was beside himself in his grief.
“King Thranduil,” Balin called out gently, catching his attention. Thorin was surprised not to see a glare on the King’s face, but rather a broken look of despair as he met Balin's eyes. “Now, I know you probably don’t want to listen to an old dwarf’s story,” he began. Thranduil snorted at his remark.
“I do believe, Master Dwarf, I am a few Ages older than you,” Thranduil quipped, much to Thorin’s surprise and Balin’s if the little chuckle had anything to say. Balin’s laughter brought a pleasantly small smile to the elf’s face.
“That’s true, laddie.” There was a silent moment between the two, and Thorin saw, to his amazement, how Thranduil seemed to relax only a little. “There was a battle, at Moria, are you familiar with it?” To Thorin’s shock, Thranduil nodded. “I was there, fighting alongside my brother and kin,” Balin explained, taking a deep breath. “And my One.” Thranduil’s eyes held a knowing sadness as he peered away from Balin.
“She was a fierce one, my One was. Tougher than mithril. She demanded to fight with us, and once she set her mind to something, no one, not even Mahal himself could have stopped her,” Balin described in awe, his voice reverent as he talked of his One. Mahal nodded in agreement at the dwarf’s statement, which only made Balin smile in pride. His smile quickly faded away, and Thranduil glanced back at him.
“I had fallen from a hit to the back of my head and didn’t notice the orc that was advancing from behind. My One did, and she charged the beast. I only had time to watch as her hand slipped, and…” Balin trailed off, unable to finish. No one blamed him.
“I didn’t even realize what had happened, only able to go back and avenge her.” The Elvenking was silent, looking at what Thorin realized was a ring on his finger, a tradition mainly used by men and hobbits.
“My wife loved the symbolism of rings in the world of men,” Thranduil explained to Balin, who had just complimented on it when he noticed the King fidgeting with it as well. “I got them for us after our first hundred years together.” Balin made a small understanding noise, grabbing one of his braids.
“My wife made me this bead. There isn’t a day that goes by that I don’t wish her to be by my side.” Balin sighed, tucking the braid back under his beard where he kept it safe. “And there isn’t anything I wouldn’t give to get her back.” Thranduil studied the dwarf in front of him, nodding in agreement.
“Now, I don’t know about you,” Balin continued, glancing back at Thorin and Bilbo. “But I wouldn’t wish the pain I have felt without my One on anyone. I would help them with the best of my abilities if they had a chance to remain with their One.” Thranduil’s demeanor changed at Balin’s confession, going as straight as a pole and glaring at Thorin and the others, though he looked a little less sure now, yet he still spoke harshly.
“That’s good for you, Master Dwarf,” Thranduil said, turning away and back to the crumbling towers ahead of him. Thorin was furious at the stubbornness of the elf and was about to go up and give him the beating of a lifetime to get the Arkenstone when Bard walked over to the two Makers.
The bowman’s face was shattered, and Yavanna looked pressed to give him a hug with the obvious heartache the man was feeling. Bard reached inside his jacket and pulled out the Arkenstone. The stone had many of the Company gasping in awe at the glittering, shiny, “heart” of the mountain. Thorin looked at the stone and almost smiled at his own thoughts. The Arkenstone did not sway him, it did not call to him. Thorin saw the Arkenstone the way Bilbo must have seen it and almost laughed at how stupid he had been behaving over it. It was nothing but a shiny, pretty rock.
Bard looked at the Arkenstone, gently kneeling down in a bow to hand it to Yavanna who took the stone with a proud smile.
“Bard!” Thranduil scolded, glaring at the exchange in anger. Bard shook his head, his face serious.
“No,” Bard said, his words final. “If the roles were reversed,” he explained, glancing at Thorin. “I would do anything to bring my wife back.” Thranduil scoffed at the man, but to everyone’s relief, he did not further argue. “Plus, I owe the hobbit.” His words made a few of them share confused glances with one another.
“What do you mean?” Bofur couldn’t help but ask, staring at the bowman in bewilderment. Bard looked down at Bilbo with respect shining from his eyes.
“My children were cornered by a troll in Dale,” he explained. Thorin tensed at his words, worrying over the nice children he had come to know over his stay at Laketown. He heard the soft gasps of his companions and knew they shared his worry. Bard’s eyes held the same fear Thorin had felt when Azog had held Fíli over the edge of the building.
“I had no way to get to them, and I feared the worst. Just as the beast raised his arm, he was plucked from the very ground on which he stood. All of the orcs and creatures were being lifted, and I watched as they swarmed over our heads, right where we stand now and saw how they were thrown to another place far away.” Bard gave a small, reverent smile to Thorin as he finished recalling the battle.
“My children are still alive because of Bilbo Baggins, savior to all those still alive out there today. I owe him more than all the gold in your mountain for that.” Thorin bowed his head at the man, grateful for him more than ever.
“I am forever in your debt,” Thorin said.
“Just keep your word this time,” Bard jested, walking over to stand next to Gandalf who gave him an approving nod of his head.
“How dare you,” Thranduil said, turning on the bowman now. “Who do you think you are?”
“He’s Bard, the Dragon Slayer,” Fíli declared, smirking at the glare Thranduil sent his way. “And the new Lord of Dale.” Bard shook his head in denial, but no one could deny their birthright. Bard was now the Lord of Dale, just like Fíli had said.
Thranduil scowled, opening his mouth to say something else when he was forcibly cut off by a soft rumbling in the ground. Four stone walls appeared, bursting from the ground around the elf. A large stone slab flew from somewhere among the hill and was suddenly dropped over Thranduil, creating a small rock room for the elf and thoroughly trapping him inside. The small cracks and holes, that allowed him to breathe, released the shouts and outraged cries of the King, but they were muffled greatly and were more like a very loud humming.
The group slowly turned to Mahal who was smiling pleasantly at his “cage” that he just made. The Maker didn’t let his smile drop till he did a double-take at his wife.
Yavanna had her arms folded across her chest, her eyes narrowed into dangerous slits, and her foot was tapping against the ground that reminded Thorin of when Bilbo would get overly annoyed about something. Mahal lifted his giant rock shoulders in defense, his hands outstretched.
“What?” he asked, looking genuinely confused at being at the receiving end of Yavanna’s glare. The hobbit creator continued to tap her foot against the ground in a slow, staccato rhythm, making Mahal give her an exasperated look.
“Oh, come on!" the Maker grunted, flapping his arms her way. "You wanted to do it too, and don’t you deny it! Yours would’ve been made of grass, that’s all.” Yavanna remained glaring at the Maker but didn’t deny the accusation. Mahal, seeming to be uncomfortable by the way she continued to glare at him, gave her a look. "We have already lingered too long in the mortal realm, and I don't know about you, but I have things to do back in my halls." Yavanna gave an unimpressed hum, turning away from him. She slid the Arkenstone into her dress pocket and waved her hands around.
“Come on, everyone, we have some business to discuss,” she said definitively before she turned and glared at Mahal. “I wouldn't have made it out of grass .”
