Chapter Text
Billy wakes, fully encapsulated by warmth. There’s several layers of blankets and several limbs draped across him, and he’s reminded how good lazy mornings with Steve are. He lays there, the sun barely peeking through the living room blinds. After a few minutes of running his hand over Steve’s back, and breathing in the still lingering scent of floral shampoo, he carefully squeezes out from captivity. Steve rolls over, bringing the bundle of blankets with him into a ball.
Cold air nips at his exposed legs, so he throws on a pair of sweats discarded near the futon. After he pulls them over his hips, he notices the large mound of comforters that has formed on the recliner. Red hair sticks out in a couple places. He walks over to the thermostat and turns it up a couple notches higher than usual.
It’s Christmas, he rationalizes.
He turns to switch the tree lights on, when he notices the ratty little box Max has had glued to her hip sitting there. He rolls his eyes, turns the lights on, and heads into the kitchen.
The faucet strains when he flicks it on. After a couple seconds, water starts to dribble out, eventually reaching a steady stream. He fills the coffee carafe and pour the water into the top of the machine. He pulls one of the last filters out of the bag, and fills it with store brand grounds before placing it in the coffee maker, and turns it on.
As the smell of coffee slowly fills the room, Billy’s thoughts drift to last night. To Robin’s words. His eyes roam over to the paper bag sitting on their dining room table. He walks over to it, pulling out the gift from El and Hopper. The sweater is just as soft as it was last night. It’s simple. Heather grey. A small surfer with a red board. Him.
He cuts the tag from the side before pulling it over his head. It fits nicely enough, hugging his chest ever so slightly. It’s a little loose on the arms, but it’s warm. Could give Steve a run for his money.
When he looks up, Max is standing draped in blankets, a smile pulling at her lips.
“Morning.”
“The sweater looks nice.”
“Whatever.”
She walks over to one of the cabinets and retrieves three mugs that look suspiciously like ones from the nearby diner, even sporting the same logo. Pure coincidence. She fills two of them up, and hands one to Billy. She leaves the third cup next to the sugar and powdered creamer. They sit together in silence for a while, Max occasionally peeking out from her cocoon to take a sip. Eventually, after they’ve each had one cup and are nursing their second, she looks at him expectantly.
“Presents?”
A pit in his stomach forms, but he needs to get this over with eventually.
“Yeah, sure.” He stands, and leads them out to the living room.
Steve is still sound asleep on the futon, hair splayed over his forehead, making him look years younger. Billy reaches down to nudge him awake, but Max grabs for his arm.
“Just us?”
He pauses to look at her. Her eyes say “please” even though her mouth won’t.
“He’s gonna be mad.”
“He’ll live.”
Billy shrugs and sits on the ground next to the tree.
“Me first.” She plops down across from him, and reaches for that small, shitty little box wrapped in plain white paper. “Here.”
“That's for me? You carried it around all day yesterday, could’ve given it to me when we were at the Byers' place.”
“I was going to, but I saw how weird you got with that sweater, so I just held on to it.”
“I was not weird, the fuck?”
“Whatever, take it.” She shoves the box into his hands. It’s light. He gives it a shake, but stops when Max shoots him a frown. He pulls back the sheet of paper, and reveals a small cardstock box. He gives Max a look but she just nudges him with her foot. There’s tape sealing it shut, which he easily rips off.
In the box, is a wad of tissue paper. He plucks it out and tosses the container aside. He peels it back, layer after layer, and inside is a necklace. His fingers trace over it, feeling some familiar ridges, and some new ones.
“Max… How did you…”
“I went back in, a couple days after... I know how much that meant to you. Couldn’t let him take anything more from us than he already did…”
“How stupid could you be… Trespassing in a burned down mall…” Wet spots appear on the tissue paper in his lap.
“I’ve got a crappy role model, I guess.”
A broken chuckle leaves his mouth as he stares down to the Saint Christopher charm in his hands. A weld mark travels through the center of it. His fingers tremble as he works the clasp.
“Here, I got it.” Max sits up and reaches over, unhooking the chain.
“Can you..?”
“Yeah.”
She holds the two ends of the metal chain in her hand. He turns, pulling his hair away from his neck. “I couldn’t find the chain, so I had to get a new one. Lucas and his dad helped me weld it back together.” Max reaches around and secures it, turning the chain to move the clasp behind him.
As Max lets go, the small charm hits Billy in the chest with the weight of a thousand suns. His fingers trace over it, as if holding it in his hands moments ago wasn’t proof enough it was real. He pulls it along the metal links.
“Thank you, Max… Damn it.”
He rubs his eyes before carefully tucking the necklace into his sweater. He reaches towards the back of their small little Christmas Tree, and retrieves the small envelope that sits there. He tosses it to her, and leans back against the Futon.
“My present is shit compared to yours, just a warning.”
“I won’t hold it against you, I’m a great gift giver.”
She peels the envelope open, and Billy buries his eyes in his lap.
“Right.”
He hears the shuffling of paper, and a pause.
“A shopping list?”
“Flip it.”
“Weirdo…”
There’s a beat of silence, then-
“What?”
He looks up.
“What do you mean, ‘what’?”
“What does that mean?”
“Max. Read it. What else could it mean?”
“I don’t know, this isn’t a word. I thought you knew how to spell.”
He drags his hands over his face and huffs.
“The letters. Read the letters.”
He watches as she mouths out the three vowels written on the back of an old grocery list.
“Oh.”
He looks up to see her. Her brows furrow, and she frowns before turning to him.
“No.”
“Yes.”
“You don’t.”
“I do, Max.”
“Nope.” He watches as she rips the receipt in half. “Absolutely not.”
“The fuck do you—”
“You don’t owe me shit, okay? You get me to school. You make sure I can eat. You drive me to the arcade. It’s enough. More than enough.”
“It’s Christmas.” He says, half defeated.
“Yeah, so? I don’t care, I know you don’t care.” She looks over his shoulder. “Steve is the only one here who cares.”
“Max, come on, I mean, I… I don’t not care.”
“I know. I’m just saying, I don’t expect you to do anything more than what you are. You didn’t ask for, well. Me. So. You’re doing enough right now. Spending the morning with my brother and his dumb boyfriend is a good enough present.”
“...Yeah?”
“Yeah.”
“Want a hug?”
“Gross, no.”
As they both laugh, a shuffling sounds from behind Billy’s head.
“...loud. So loud.”
Billy turns and is greeted by his wild-haired boyfriend.
“Morning, Sleeping Beauty.” He leans over to kiss Steve on the lips, and chuckles as he hears fake retching behind him.
“Hey…” Steve pouts. “Did you guys open presents without me?”
“Told you he’d be mad.”
“Whatever, sorry Steve.”
“It’s fine. Guess you two don’t get to open when I got you.”
Billy cocks his head.
“You already got us shit.”
“Hey, woah. I’ll take more Steve presents!” Max cuts in.
“Don’t be such a greedy shit.” Billy stands and walks into the kitchen. Shortly he’s followed in by Steve and Max, the ladder of which is still pestering the former.
“Pleaaase please please!”
“No! Also, I think I heard you calling me dumb. So I am absolutely returning yours.”
“It was Billy!”
“Was not! Leave me out of this.” He turns to the coffee maker. He grabs the last mug and pours the bitter liquid in. He carefully scoops two spoons of sugar, one of powdered creamer, and hands the cup to Steve.
“Here.”
Steve takes a drink, and his shoulders visibly lower, and he leans against the table.
“Okay fine. Get that bag over by the door, Max.”
“Yes!”
Billy shakes his head as she sprints over. She grabs the black duffel bag where it sits and props it next to Steve. He puts his coffee down and unzips the top, and scrounges around for a second before pulling out three boxes. He hands one to Billy, one to Max, and holds the third.
“What, got something for yourself, too?”
“Yeah, something like that. You two first.”
Max eagerly rips into the box. Billy, despite feigning indifference, already has his open. He pulls back the tissue paper, and audibly groans.
“What? What is i- Oh. No. Billy, show me yours.” She pulls the box from his hands, and her eyes widen. They both turn to Steve, and in their horror, he’s already holding his third of a matching pair of Christmas pajamas.
“What! They’re cute!”
“No way, not wearing these.”
“Same.”
“Guys come on! New holiday tradition! Plus, they’re soft. Please?” The two look at Steve. He’s standing there, brown doe eyes in full on puppy mode. They’re weak.
“Ugh, fine. I’ll be back.” Max quickly exits the kitchen to her room.
“Yes!” Steve ushers Billy into the living room.
He slips his sweats off and slides on the red bottoms. They’re covered in gingerbread men and holly, but yes, unfortunately, they’re soft. He pulls the tag off the shirt, trying his best not to look at the price, before undoing the buttons.
“Hey, what’s that?”
“Hm?” He turns to Steve, where he sees his boyfriend pointing to his own neck. “Oh, uh. Max.” Steve steps forwards, running his fingers along the chain that sits against his collar bone, before picking up the charm.
“No way! How’d she find it?”
“Snuck into Starcourt.”
Steve lets out an exacerbated breath. “Of course she did. Why did I even ask?” He focuses on the metal in his fingers. “It’s like…” He turns it over in his fingers. Billy’s gaze doesn’t leave Steve’s eyes. The way his brows scrunch, the way he bites the inside of his cheek when he thinks. Billy commits it to memory. “Kind of like a puzzle piece that was missing? I don’t know. All I know is how hot it always looked on you. I’m glad you got it back, Billy.” He turns back to finish dressing.
“Yeah, me too…” Billy’s voice is faint, and he can feel the back of his neck burning. He slides the sleeves over his arm, and buttons the shirt up. He watches Steve finish buttoning his own. His pajamas are covered in candy canes. Fitting. Cool and sweet. Refreshing, even. Steve turns back around.
“Steve, I—”
“Oh, no. That won’t do.” He frowns.
Billy bites his tongue.
“What won’t?”
“That.” Steve motions to his chest, worrying his lip. Steve walks over, and his hands rise against Billy’s chest. He leans forward, kissing along Billy’s neck as he undoes buttons.
One. Then a kiss.
The second. A nip.
The third. He presses his lips against his chest.
Over the necklace. Over his scar.
The fourth. Steve leans back, his arms rest against Billy’s side. The words just fall out.
“I love yo-“
“Merry Christmas Bi-”
They both freeze.
Steve’s eyes go wide, and Billy’s slam shut.
Was what he thought Steve said last night not real? Did he just imagine it? Does Steve not..? His heartbeat starts to race in his head, and his mouth moves, making a feeble attempt at trying to claw back time.
“Shit, Steve, I didn’t—“
“Hey, hey.” Steve cups Billy’s cheeks. “B, c’mon. Look at me.” He opens his eyes, but he can’t meet Steve’s gaze. “I love you, too. I love you so damn much.”
“You’re just saying that because I did.”
“No, I’m not. I mean it. I love you, Billy.”
He looks up. Hopeful.
“Wouldn’t have said it if it wasn’t true. You know that.” Steve punches Billy’s arm, and it gets him to let go of the breath he didn’t know he was holding.
“Thank fuck, I don’t think I had it in me for any more dramatics this morning.”
“Wait, what do you mean?”
“Doesn’t matter, c’mere.”
He grabs Steve by the hips and pulls him close. Billy runs his hands through brown locks as their mouths meet. He’s not sure if the necklace, Steve’s love, or the whimper that leaves his mouth when Billy bites at his lip is his favorite present, but he’ll gladly take them all.
Steve pulls Billy, now, guiding him to the futon. He eases himself down onto Steve, straddling his hips as they both sink into the cushion. Steve mumbles “I love you’s” between Billy licking into his mouth. Billy’s hands move down and start unbuttoning Steve’s pajama shirt. Thick hair peeks out that Billy can’t help running his fingers throu-
“Oh my god, get a room!”
Steve yelps and shoves Billy off of him, sending him crashing into pillows.
“This IS my room, Max!”
“You’re gonna pay for my therapy bills.”
“Sorry Max! We just, uh, you know. The holiday spirit got the better of us!”
“I’ll say. God.”
Billy smirks at Steve’s beat red face. They almost match the pajamas.
“Pancakes? To make up for it?”
“With chocolate chips?”
“Whatever you want, my treat!”
“Deal.” Max heads into the kitchen, and the sounds of bowls and pans getting pulled from packed cabinets ring through the living room. Steve turns to him with a sheepish grin.
“Sorry, B. Maybe later we can, uh, go back to my house and, well. You know.”
“Don't know if I can, might be busy.” Billy pulls Steve onto him and gives him a kiss. “Make me a pancake, and I’ll see if I can move some things around.”
“You’re such an ass.” Steve mumbles against his lips.
“Yeah, an ass you love.”
“That I do.” Steve gives him one more kiss before propping himself up. “Merry Christmas, Billy.”
“Merry Christmas, Steve.”
