Chapter Text
Thorin is giving him that look again. The look that speaks of appreciation for Bilbo’s openness, while also holding some kind of question.
He’s giving me an out, the hobbit realises.
Granted, the dwarf king should know by now that Bilbo isn’t one to back off once he’s set his mind on something; but still, it warms Bilbo to know that there is no pressure – not from Thorin.
There is also a distance between them again; just enough to allow Bilbo to form coherent thoughts, while still granting him the calming pleasantness of the dwarf’s proximity. (It is certainly not respectable in Hobbit standards, but Bilbo wouldn’t have it any other way. He’s long forgone the notion of holding on to these stuffy conventions anyway.)
“Well … contrary to what you might believe, the thing on this journey that was hardest to getting used to wasn’t the lack of my warm hearth or even my bed – nor were it my books or my garden.” Bilbo’s eyes flicker to the side, his throat working. “It was the company.”
With a frown tugging at his brows, Thorin keeps his eyes on the hobbit’s face – Bilbo can feel the all but piercing gaze on him, uncertain for a moment if that has been the wrong thing to start with. Surely there could have been a way to explain all of this without making it sound like the company was solely responsible for his misery.
“Bilbo, I know we aren’t the most civilised—”
He hurriedly looks back at the dwarf. “No, no Thorin, that’s not what I meant.” A strange expression flickers across Bilbo’s features; something of it could be read as amusement, but some part of it makes it look like he is in pain. “Of course, most of your folks’ traditions and character traits are frowned upon by Hobbits – but then again, Elves and Men aren’t held in high regard by my people either. Hobbits have their ways, and everything that’s different from those is usually not worth thinking about. However, that’s not the point I’m trying to make here.” Bilbo once again turns more to Thorin, and there’s a small, humorous tilt to his lips as he does so.
“Oddly enough, I wasn’t all too irritated by the blunt and rough behaviour of you all. I have developed a rather thick skin anyhow, as I’ve already listened to my fair share of insults that came from family members – although I must say that Hobbits are well versed when it comes to insults disguised in sweet talk, so you would probably think we’re all friendly with each other.” Bilbo waves his hand in a dismissive gesture. “But I’m going off track … again.” He pulls a face that looks somewhat apologetic. “What I meant to say is that it’s not that part of the company’s manners that I found difficult adjusting to – it was the touching.”
Thorin instantly sits up straight, brows tightly knitted together, and a flicker of anger flares up in his eyes. “Has anyone touched you inappropriately?!” The dwarf appears to be one second away from jumping up and letting out a bellow that would most definitely wake the entire company. “I swear on the life of my sister–”
“What?!” Bilbo looks at Thorin as if the dwarf had just confessed that he was friends with an Elf. “You’re asking me if anyone has–? Ohhh!” An involuntary snort makes its way out of Bilbo’s twisting lips.
Well done, Bilbo Baggins. You’re a real wordsmith, do you know that?
“Thorin, calm down! It’s nothing like that,” the hobbit says, biting back another chuckle at the almost seething dwarf. “It wasn’t that they touched me in any way I didn’t want or like – it was almost … the opposite?”
Towards the end of the sentence, Bilbo’s voice has gotten quieter, carrying a hint of shyness that finally summons Thorin’s undivided – and luckily non-murderous – attention.
“My dear Bilbo, I'm afraid I don't understand what you are trying to tell me. Are there any hobbit customs we have violated in some way?”
Against his will, another grin breaks out on Bilbo's lips – leave it up to Thorin Oakenshield, up until yesterday the most grumpiest dwarf Bilbo has ever known, to worry about that now.
Seems like it’s not only his sense of direction that’s a little off, the hobbit thinks amusedly. What he says instead, is, “Well, yes, that you have as well — multiple times if you want to know.” He gives a non-malicious snort. “But this is also irrelevant in that case. I meant to say that– I mean I was–" Bilbo clears his throat.
Get it out already, Baggins!
Thorin's searching gaze on him feels too heavy to meet. Bilbo takes another deep breath.
'“I was jealous.”
There, it's out now. Was that so hard?
“Jealous?” Thorin repeats it as if Bilbo has mumbled. Which he has certainly not, thank you very much!
There is also a tone in Thorin's voice that Bilbo can't fully decipher. There’s definitely confusion, a lot of it, and perhaps only a pinch of incredulity; but it doesn't sound like the dwarf would break into a fit of laughter any time soon – and that is already something.
“Yes, jealous. I feel mildly stupid for it – no, scratch ‘mildly’, and replace it with “utterly”, if you will.” He looks towards Thorin with the certainty that an embarrassed flush is high on his cheeks – again.
I seem to be doing that quite often today. He tries not to give this more thought than necessary.
“It's just that … before you lot came along, I have spent many years on my own. My father died a few years after my coming-of-age. His death crushed my mother’s spirits and for a long time she was but a shadow of herself, before she eventually followed him eight years later.”
His voice sounds too clinical even in his own ears, and Thorin has no doubt picked up on it as well because he reaches for Bilbo’s hands. Bilbo doesn’t have it in him to do more than send the dwarf a grateful smile, which, if he thinks about it, probably looks more like a grimace.
But, as they say, it’s the thought that counts, right?
“Uhh, I’m going to have to reach back in time a little bit for that tale…”
“It’s not like we can sleep, yet, anyway, hm? Might as well talk then.” Thorin smiles. “I’m listening.”
“Hm, right.” Bilbo sniffs; then he gives a curt nod and takes a deep breath.
“Up until my father’s death, I never really minded being a single child. My mother spent so much time showing me the world and its wonders, that the thought that I could have had more fun or could have gone on more adventures with a sibling never really occurred to me. Even my father – who scoffed at the mention of adventures and sent my mum halfhearted glares – joined in on smaller outings every now and then. It was all I could have wished for: I was granted the presence and the unconditional love of my parents for all of my childhood. And I was content, even as other Hobbits pitied me for the lack of siblings. I’ve had a few cousins who were curious and open-minded enough to play with me without going down the ‘he-is-an-only-child-and-an-odd-one-at-that’-lane, but back then I didn’t really care a great deal about sustaining or even deepening those connections. I thought that I didn’t need them for my happiness – not the same way I needed my parents, at least. But when my father died, I began to regret that particular slackness, if only because there could have been other people my mother cared about enough to … to maybe help me keep the flame of life inside her burning. Later on, I realised that it wouldn’t have made any difference in the end. There’s no one who could replace your true love, after all, hm?”
He tries for a smile, and manages to conjure forth a line of lips curled with deep-felt love and aching melancholy.
“When she was gone, too, I realised that what the others were always saying about siblings must be true; and suddenly, being a single child has never felt so lonely and wrong. The first times I left the Smial, which was now mine alone, I was sometimes nearly overrun by friends and distant relations expressing their condolences, and they gave me hugs and all that. They invited themselves over for tea, and even though I was irritated by it at first, I found myself grateful for it sometimes – it meant that the Smial, which felt ghostly quiet, was filled with voices again.
"But then the weeks rolled further into the lands, bringing the joys of spring with them, and the days between visits began to stretch, until my mother’s passing was but a distant memory, lingering in the presence of her favourite tea cup, and in the shadows of my parents’ empty bedroom.” Bilbo’s eyes stray to the side, zoning out into the shadows of the forest.
“Outside, the world continued on. The birds sang, the markets bustled with life and soon it came that every time I ventured out into town I saw couples and parents with their faunts everywhere. I couldn’t tear my eyes from them; couldn’t help watching with a clenching heart as children tugged their mothers or fathers along, and as siblings scuffled on the streets until either their mother reprimanded them or they tumbled into someone else, stopping them in their track. I saw how the more cheeky youngsters sneaked off together to do … well, what siblings are usually up to, I guess.”
Bilbo gives a helpless shrug.
“All of a sudden, I found myself wanting for exactly that kind of connection, for that kind of easy companionship with someone who is, from a biological point of view, much more likely to stay by your side until you’re both old and grey and weak. Someone who could be there and have the same memories of our childhood; who lived them with me, and could help me remember how my father’s sigh sounded when I came home from one of my adventures, and how his eyes flickered with unconcealed love when my mother couldn’t hide her smile as she treated my scratches.
“But–”, he gulps, swallowing around the ball of emotion that is stuck in his throat as he back at Thorin with an almost pleading expression, “what I wished most for was someone who’d put their arms around me; someone to hold me until my tears dried, and longer. Physical contact has always been what calmed me down the quickest – and suddenly I was stripped of that. Six years I’ve spent holed up in my Smial, quietly longing for someone to touch the same way my parents did.
“The few times I did go outside, the other hobbits always tried to coax me into taking a wife and settling down. ‘Fill Bag End with life again’, they said. ‘You can’t be a bachelor forever.’ But I felt that there would never be anyone in Hobbiton or even the Shire who could give me what I wanted; what I needed. ”
There is something akin to wonder in Bilbo’s eyes as his gaze travels down to where his hands are still embraced by Thorin’s.
“And, you know, at some point I’ve begun giving up – hoping, I mean. Because I knew that I wouldn’t leave Bag End on my own accord – be it that I was suddenly too cowardish to face the wild, or the fact that I knew that if I went out there, I would have to deal with all the things I tried to keep locked up behind a door I hadn’t dared to open in years, behind which a wonderfully hand-crafted bed and a writing desk were gathering more and more dust.”
Eyes flickering back up to Thorin, Bilbo huffs mildly, lips curling into a thoughtful line. “Perhaps there was also a part of me that didn’t want me to find someone else to share my life with, because it would have meant for me to go on and let go of the past. And I don’t think I was ready to let go of the one thing that was still left of my parents.”
The hobbit heaves a great sigh and coughs, suddenly taking notice of how much he’s been talking. Needless to say that Thorin, dear considerate Thorin, knows exactly what the issue is.
The only impertinence is that the dwarf has to pull away his hands – gently so – and leave his place to get what he needs, but it doesn’t take more than a few seconds before the dwarf is back at his side, even closer than before as he softly presses a waterskin into Bilbo’s hands.
The relief of the cool liquid running down his sore throat is certainly an adequate compensation for the time he was robbed of Thorin’s body warmth.
He mumbles a quiet ‘Thanks’ as he hands back the waterskin.
When he meets Thorin’s gaze again, drawn in by the dwarf’s affectionately glinting eyes, the shadows beneath them suddenly leap out at him, and the guilt comes crashing down on him like a waterfall.
“Thorin, I am so sorry! You’re tired and I am rambling–”
A hand on his own stops him dead, and he clicks his mouth shut when Thorin gives a small, but firm shake of his head.
“Please, don’t apologise, Bilbo – not for sharing what bothers you – which isn’t what I’d call ‘rambling’, by the way.” He raises one eyebrow in a kind of gently-reprimanding way, and strokes his fingers over the back of Bilbo’s hand. The hobbit unconsciously leans closer, chasing after the dwarf’s hand as it pulls away. “Besides, I’m not any wiser about what exactly you’re jealous about – and even though you might not believe it, I'm a curious dwarf. And I’m afraid I’ll find it difficult to find sleep if you decide to put me on the rack.” The latter sentences are accompanied by a grin so innocent that it borders on looking ridiculous, considering the otherwise so regal face it’s situated on.
However, Bilbo has to admit that its intended effect isn’t mitigated in any way, and so he bumps his shoulder into Thorin’s. The dwarf doesn’t so much as move a toe[1] to the side. “Alright, where was I?”
“You said that you didn’t feel ready to leave Bag End – and with it, the memory of your parents – behind,” Thorin supplies, his voice so soft Bilbo could hug him for hours at end.
“Ah, yes.” Bilbo flashes Thorin a small smile, which surely doesn’t convey his emotions to their full extent. “Well, all of that led to a pretty – as you can probably imagine – lonely period of my life; a period I’d stopped to believe it would ever end. But then you all barged into Bag End, all boisterous, and uncivilized, and rude, putting me of my stride for a good long while. It was all too much, having that many people – and dwarves, at that – in my home, after years of isolation. And I thought that my annoyance about your behaviour played a big role in that, but the next morning, it … it all came crashing down on me when I woke up and I realised you were all gone, the tune of your song a distant echo that has etched itself into the walls. Appearance-wise, the Smial was just like it was before – if not a bit cleaner, with the tricky dish washing of the company and all,” Bilbo pulls a face as if he still doesn’t know what he should think about that, “and yet it was not. Not for me, anyway.”
There is a slight pause, a moment of silence as the skin between the hobbit’s brows wrinkles, his eyes flicking around as he searches for the right words.
“Thorin … my Smial hasn't felt that alive for a decade.” Bilbo shakes his head, huffing out a mostly humourless laugh that says as much as ‘I can’t believe I’m saying that’. Fingers fiddling with the fluffy fur of Thorin’s coat, the hobbit thinks back to the moment where he had stood in his living room in Bag End, trying to figure out why he’d felt so at loss at the dwarves’ disappearance.
“All of a sudden, there had been voices again to drown out the stifling silence without that being the intention, and there was the presence of thirteen dwarves to fill the emptiness of a home that has stopped feeling like one many years ago. It awoke a strange feeling of companionship inside of me, despite the fact that you were all strangers to me. And back then, when I was – against my better judgement – listening out for any of you, I realised that this was it: I would never get another chance like this, a chance to leave Bag End behind – if only for a while or for good, I didn’t know. But in a fit of courage, I took the chance. And, foolish as I was, I had hoped for this fuzzy feeling from the day before to continue on the road.”
Taking a deep breath, Bilbo thinks, Here it comes.
“And that’s where, well, the jealousy-thing that I mentioned earlier comes into play. In Bag End I’ve already noticed that you’re a rather touchy bunch, but on the first day already of riding with you all, I came to realise just how much you have all been touching each other. Even though we were seated on ponies, everyone found a way to create some physical contact – be it a clap on another’s shoulder or thigh, a bumping of fists or even a quick headbutt – howsoever you managed to pull that off.”
Bilbo snorts at Thorin’s slightly smug grin, before he continues his tale – if he kept the pauses in between longer, he doesn’t know if he were able to get to the end. And something in him uncoils at the thought of finally letting it all out.
"Whenever we stopped to make camp, there would always be someone braiding the beard or hair of another dwarf, and as soon as night fell, everyone would cuddle up closely. Except for me.” The urge to hide from Thorin’s attentive gaze is almost to great to ignore, but there is something that makes him push through. “You all offer your touch so openly, so freely, and yet I always found myself sitting at the sidelines; watching in silence how you all treated another like close family would do; and I couldn’t help but feel that I was a member of the company only by contract.”
The expression on Thorin’s face has been minutely growing sadder, his brows pinched together and the lines in his skin deepening, as if he’s already – and once again – blaming himself for the hobbit’s hardships. Bilbo can’t stand it.
“It’s not like I blame you! Yavanna knows I’m not. After all, I was a stranger to you. And you were strangers to me. There were no reasons, whatsoever, for you to treat me like you treat one another; you are all kin. But I just couldn’t help myself feeling like the Valar wanted to mock me; putting what I so desperately wished for directly in front of my nose but not granting me to be part of it.”
He doesn’t say that he has cried himself to sleep a few times in the first weeks.
It feels like Thorin knows anyway.
“This is what I was jealous of. I wanted all of that too. I wanted the small touches in between, the earnest smiles, the warm glances that whispered ‘Are you okay?’ and lit up with relief when it was the case. I wanted to experience what it means to have a family again.”
Bilbo’s eyes drift towards the – still sleeping – company. (It’s really a testament to the exhaustion of them all that not a single one of the dwarves had awoken yet, with all the talking Bilbo and Thorin had done.) His face softens as he takes in the sight; most of the dwarrow haven’t moved much since he’d sneaked across the camp to join Thorin on this rock, which means that they’re still clustered together in snoring heaps. Figuring out which limbs belong to whom would even be difficult if it were day.
“And after the first few weeks, it did begin to feel like I was growing to be a part of you all. It started with Bofur, and Ori, and then Fíli and Kíli – albeit I have to give those two rascals the credit they deserved and admit that they had included me right from the start if one counts the little pranks they pulled on me, as well. Don’t tell them I said that, though.” He shoots Thorin a lopsided grin, which makes the dwarf answer with a halfhearted grimace of despair.
“Of course there still were some … hurdles, but I’ve grown fond of you all. And at some point I thought to myself that, perhaps, what I had is enough. That I don’t need the touching and all. But then–” Bilbo’s face takes on an expression of wonder, “then you hugged me on the Carrock, and the others where all cheering – and suddenly I felt almost whole again. It was like my entire body lit up; as if the sun itself was embracing me and lifting all this weight, which I’ve been carrying, from my shoulders. It felt like I have finally found something like a family again.”
The pleasant feeling that memory awakens in Bilbo is plain to see on his face, like he is experiencing it all over again, and Thorin can’t help but feel the same. But then the hobbit’s face twists painfully, and a look takes hold of his expression that is far too familiar for Thorin’s liking. He is sure Bilbo doesn’t even notice that he’s shifting his weight from side to side, his fingers almost clawing themselves into the fabric of Thorin’s coat now. And when the hobbit opens his mouth once more, the dwarf has an inkling that what he is going to hear now, will be exactly what has been weighing on Bilbo’s mind so heavily.
“Tonight, when I tried to fall asleep”, Bilbo says, “I suddenly realised how close I was to losing it all over again, before I even had the chance to properly enjoy it.” He presses his eyes shut, trying to force back the tears that have begun to well up in them. “I don’t think I can take this pain, Thorin.” His voice breaks, cracking apart like a shield that has taken one too many hits. “Not a second time.”
The words slowly fade out into the night; dissolving like mist into thin air, but echoing still as if they were instead spoken in a great hall of sheer rock.
They even reverberate in Bilbo’s own ears, or maybe that’s also the blood rushing through them, as he is pressing his eyes together with so much force that it hurts, unable to bring himself to open them and face Thorin – some part of his mind even welcomes the stinging pain, as if it could somehow save him from the even more gruesome fate of having his soul ripped out once and for all.
It shouldn’t really surprise him that it is a touch on his cheek – featherlight and yet so startling – that makes his eyes snap open. He had known what he would see, or rather, he had made an assumption that was thoroughly based on the previous reactions Thorin had shown him over the course of this night.
And yet, it hits harder than he expected.
Thorin is smiling at him with a far greater softness than the situation warrants, really. In that first moment, Bilbo doesn’t really understand it, and he still can’t help but wonder how Thorin is able to not only listen to such a tiresome monologue without batting an eye, but to also look at Bilbo as if the hobbit himself had hung the stars, and put gems into stone, and made the sun set and rise day to day.
Back in the Shire, such excessive self-centric talks were seldom looked upon with good-will, and that had been one of the reasons he’d stopped sharing his thoughts with anyone who wasn’t really, really close family – which mostly consisted of his aunts and uncles from his mother’s side. And although those of them who were still alive were more than sympathetic in regards to Bilbo’s grief, they couldn’t truly understand what stopped him from starting a family of his own.
Briefly speaking, Bilbo Baggins hadn’t shared his thoughts to such an extent with anyone ever before. And now he has dumped all this on one Thorin Oakenshield, the exiled King of Erebor – which is truly mind-boggling in and of itself, considering … well, considering everything.
So he takes in the dwarf – who looks so tired and and who is surely beyond exhausted from what they’ve all been through – and wonders why he’s still sitting here, listening to Bilbo pouring his heart out like water that has finally broken through its dam.
And it does things to Bilbo’s heart as he watches the dwarf’s emotions travel across his face – wonder, affection, grief, sympathy, joy … it’s all there, so plain for Bilbo to see that every word that could have been uttered would fall well short of conveying the true meaning behind them.
Oddly enough, as Thorin looks at Bilbo, and Bilbo looks back at him, it feels as if he is staring right into a mirror.
The realisation ascends upon him like a bucket of cold water.
And well, before he can even get a grasp of that himself, the words he’s unconsciously been dancing around for the last hours are already tumbling out of his mouth.
“I think I love you.”
