Chapter Text
Those first few days exploring Ered Luin, Frodo could hardly believe that any place shaped by mortal hands could be so impossibly vast. He’d assumed the foyer made up the bulk of the dwarvish settlement, so it was a shock to discover that it was only the gateway to a sprawling underground city. He hung onto Dís’s every word as she explained the meaning behind each statue and carving they passed, of which there were many. (Most involved long, bloody battles with dwarves always emerging triumphant.) She also regaled him with tales of lost Belegost and Nogrod, which had both fallen into the sea in the war against Morgoth. Much of what had been built since, she explained, had been modeled on tales of those legendary cities.
Frodo’s favorite places were the caves where the common dwarves had built their homes. They were so deep within the mountain that they existed in perpetual darkness, so giant crystals—like the ones he had seen in the lanterns, but a hundred times larger—had been installed in the rocky floor, bathing the caverns in a watery blue-green-violet light. The artificial twilight lent everything a magical air, Frodo thought, like something out of a fairy tale.
When Dís was busy with administrative tasks, Fíli took it upon himself to play the part of guide. Frodo was careful not mention his late brother again, but Fíli seemed unable to help himself from doing so. Ered Luin had been their home since childhood, so every landmark held a memory, usually of pranks played on unsuspecting nobles and family members. Frodo could very easily imagine the trouble that a young Fíli and Kíli (who in his mind behaved very much like Merry and Pippin) could have gotten into.
He could spend a lifetime exploring this place and barely scratch the surface of it. As happy as it made him to be shown such wondrous sights, things which most hobbits could barely dream of, he was increasingly—and uncomfortably—aware that the world outside the Shire must be incomprehensibly large, if this single mountain held so many secrets.
Bilbo did indeed take him to visit the elves that lived nearby. This was one of the only occasions when Thorin accompanied them anywhere, and he did so silently, with only the barest hint of civility toward their hosts. Bilbo mostly ignored the glowering, choosing instead to congratulate Frodo on how well he was coming along in his studies.
Frodo did not know what Thorin did with his time when he wasn’t with Bilbo. He suspected it had to do with the forges, as he carried the scent of molten metal with him everywhere he went. Dís and Fíli ruled jointly and appeared remarkably popular with their subjects. There didn’t seem to be a place here for a king without a crown.
The passage of time was difficult to gauge underground. It felt like they had been here for a fortnight, perhaps, but Bilbo assured him that Afteryule was nearly ended. Frodo did not know when they intended to leave, and in truth he was not eager to return for some time yet. Bilbo, he thought, must have shared his reluctance, for while they spoke late into the night about all the wonders of Ered Luin, they never mentioned the Shire, as though by avoiding saying its name they could delay the reality of having to go back to it.
Frodo suspected that their adventure was nearing an end, however, when for three nights in a row Bilbo did not return to their quarters. He was always there in the morning to wake Frodo and accompany him to breakfast, but he made no mention of what was keeping him away in the evenings.
----------------
Frodo had already climbed into bed, and Bilbo was sitting at the desk in front of the fire, scribbling away, when a heavy knock sounded at the door. Bilbo muttered to himself, pausing at Frodo’s bedside to check and see if the younger hobbit had awakened, before going to answer it. Frodo was not actually asleep, but he kept his eyes firmly shut anyway, and even added a sleepy little snuffle for good measure. He had a niggling instinct that something may happen this evening that would fill in some of the gaps Bilbo had left in his stories, but only if he remained absolutely quiet.
“Frodo is asleep,” Bilbo whispered to their visitor with some irritation. “So you should keep your voice down, if you can manage it.”
“I am sorry. I can return at some other time,” came Thorin’s unmistakable rumble.
“You’re already here, so you might as well come in.” The door closed, and there was a moment of strained silence before Bilbo spoke again.
“Did you have something you needed to say, or are you going to glare into the fireplace all night?”
Another long pause. “I wanted to apologize for my words earlier,” Thorin said haltingly. “I was frustrated, and I spoke in anger.”
“You are absurd,” Bilbo replied waspishly, in lieu of an acceptance. “I knew you didn’t mean it, or I would have tossed you off the terrace then and there.”
“Even if you knew, it does not excuse my behavior,” Thorin said. “I should apologize for my errors instead of assuming that those around me know the meaning behind what I say. That is what you always tell me, at least.”
“Oh, come here, you daft thing,” Bilbo sighed, all traces of anger fleeing as quickly as they had appeared. There was a rustle of fabric, and Frodo assumed Bilbo had pulled Thorin into a hug. For several moments, there was no sound but the crackle of flames and Frodo’s careful breathing.
“Come now, sit by me here,” Bilbo finally broke the silence. “I don’t want a crick in my neck from staring up at you all night.” A soft patter of feet on the warm stone floor, and then the overstuffed chaise by the fireplace creaked. Frodo cracked open his lids just a fraction; by looking in the full-length mirror that faced the bed, he could see his uncle and Thorin sitting side by side, their hands clasped on the seat between them.
“So what did you mean, if not what you said?” Bilbo coaxed, when it seemed unlikely that Thorin would resume their conversation without prompting.
“I was...concerned for your safety,” Thorin said. “When you said you wished to spend time with your Elvish friends alone, I recalled the skirmish that took Kíli away from us. I was afraid that a small group of elves would be no match for a pack of winter-starved orcs, should more of their kind be lurking near settlements not patrolled by us. My fear overrode my judgement.”
“Was that all that sparked your temper?” Bilbo asked.
“No,” Thorin replied, reluctantly. “Our time together is short. The thought of you spending two days away from me when you are already leaving so soon...it pained me. I would not lose one moment with you, while I am fortunate enough to have you here.”
“Absurd,” Bilbo repeated, with unmistakable affection.
There was another long pause, and Frodo wondered if this was the end of their discussion. He had never heard Thorin speak this much before; was he like this only with Bilbo? Or was he still so unsure around Frodo that he was too uncomfortable to speak freely?
“I am glad that you brought Frodo with you,” Thorin remarked suddenly, and Frodo had to fight not to jump at hearing his own name. “He is as bright and good-natured as you said in your letters.”
“I’m afraid I can take little credit for his best qualities,” was Bilbo’s rueful reply. “His parents were excellent role models, as adventurous as our kind can be without running after a troupe of dwarves and a mad wizard. And he spent a decade with his mother’s family before he came to live at Bag End. I’ve merely given him more learning than most hobbits bother with, and filled his head with wild tales. His merits are entirely his own.”
“I think you do not give yourself enough credit,” Thorin said. (Frodo agreed wholeheartedly!) “His resilience and eagerness to learn speak strongly of your influence.”
“Yes, well,” Bilbo sniffed, “I am proud of his accomplishments, wherever they come from. He is a good boy, and will be an excellent steward of Bag End when I am gone.”
“Why did you not bring him here sooner?” Thorin asked. “You know that he would have been welcome in our Halls.”
Frodo held his breath. He also wished to know the answer to this question.
“Perhaps I wanted to preserve my own place,” was the wry response. “You’ve seen how Dís has taken to him. I fear my position as her favorite Baggins has been usurped.”
Bilbo sighed, then carried on more seriously. “At first, I was afraid to tell him about you. You know how children can be. Before I knew his character better, I thought he might proclaim my business to all and sundry. I know differently now, of course. He is loyal and compassionate, and would never share anything told to him in confidence.” A pause. “I worried he might not understand what you are to me. Men being married to one another is not unheard of amongst hobbits, but it isn’t common. Perhaps the youth are less concerned about it than their elders. But...I had only just taken him in. He endured months of my fumbling without complaint. He is, as you say, incredibly bright. He’s brought me great joy in the short time we’ve been together. I could not face the idea that he might...” Bilbo trailed off, unable to speak his fear aloud.
The words may have been unspoken, but to Frodo they rang crystal-clear in the silence, much the way they had on the night Bilbo has proposed the journey to Ered Luin: That he might reject me, and leave me alone. Again.
Frodo shut his eyes tightly against the prickle of tears, but he didn’t do it fast enough to miss Thorin’s anguished expression reflected in the mirror, or the way Bilbo clutched the dwarf’s cloak when he was pulled into an embrace. He could barely hear Thorin’s murmured reassurances over the pounding of his heart. Hours after Thorin had departed and Bilbo had climbed into bed, Frodo lay awake, his thoughts tumbling over one another like a rockslide, until exhaustion pulled him into an uneasy rest.
----------------
The next morning, Frodo was not awakened by his uncle. He had no idea what time it was, or where Bilbo might be. He fumbled through his daily ablutions, until he emerged from their shared quarters feeling more or less awake, and ravenous. While he still felt lost in most of Ered Luin, he knew exactly where the dining hall was, and it was there that he decided to look first.
There were always dwarves milling about in this shared space. The continuous mining shifts meant that when one group was just beginning their work, another was leaving it, and both needed to eat. Most paid him no mind after the first or second day, and anyone who still did usually spared him no more than a glance. After filling his plate from the communal board, he looked about for a place to sit, hoping that perhaps Bilbo might be waiting for him. Instead, he saw Thorin sitting by himself, with nothing in front of him but a steaming mug. He met Frodo’s eyes, and inclined his head in what the hobbit interpreted as a “come here” gesture. He wove his way through the noisy crowd of workmen and sat himself at the table across from Thorin, immediately tucking in to his meal.
“I asked Bilbo if he would mind my spending the morning with you,” Thorin said without preamble. “He is with Dís, making arrangements for your return journey. If you have other plans, however, we can make time to speak later.”
“No, I don't have other plans,” Frodo replied. He was surprised to hear that they would be leaving soon, since Bilbo had made no mention of it. But he supposed there were many things Bilbo elected to keep himself, especially when they pained him.
Thorin must have taken his answer as acquiescence, for he said no more, only took the occasional sip while he waited for Frodo to finish eating.
When he was done and their dishes were placed in the proper receptacles, Thorin strode purposefully out of the Great Hall and through the labyrinthian corridors that ended at the entrance to the Keep, with Frodo scampering behind him. Rather than heading outside, as he first assumed, Thorin turned down a corridor that Frodo had not seen before—not surprising, considering the size of the city—and led them through a passageway that did not seem to get much foot traffic. The further they walked, the less finished the walkways became. Unlike the main thoroughfares, which were carved at precise angles and inlaid with with intricate geometric patterns, the walls here were rough and unadorned save for crystal lanterns placed at intervals. The air felt cooler, more damp. And furthermore, they seemed to be climbing upward, if Frodo’s shortened breath was any indication.
Just as he was about to ask his silent companion where exactly they were going, the corridor lightened. A few more feet, one final turn, and Frodo was suddenly confronted by an unexpected sight: a wide opening had been hewn from the mountainside, ten feet across and a foot and a half or so above the ground, the perfect height for a dwarf to lean against without danger of falling. The view it afforded was magnificent: Eriador stretched before them in one endless vista, with nothing obstructing it. They must have been facing southeast, for Frodo could easily identify the curve of the River Lune where he and Bilbo had crossed on their way here. Further away, he glimpsed a grey smudge that could have been the North Moors. Far on the misty horizon, he even fancied he could see the tall trees of Bindbole Wood, just West of Hobbiton.
“This is...absolutely...beautiful!” Frodo panted, hands braced on his thighs. “Did you...carve it out….yourself?”
“I did not,” Thorin answered, without a hint of strain in his voice. “We excavated this area when we first arrived, but the stone is too porous to safely support more walkways. It can be used as a lookout post, but during times of peace it is mostly forgotten. I like to come here to think.”
And to look at the Shire, Frodo thought, though he didn’t share the observation aloud.
Once his lungs were back under control, Frodo felt confident enough to break the silence.
“What did you wish to speak to me about?” Thorin seemed taken aback, as if he had expected more polite chit-chat. However, Frodo had observed this dwarf enough to guess that the effort would be wasted. Also, his head was still full of emotions from the night before. He knew in which direction he wanted to steer their conversation; small talk would only expend unnecessary time and effort.
“You are very direct,” Thorin observed, not disapprovingly.
“I can be,” Frodo allowed. “It’s just that, as you say, we will be leaving soon. Yet this is the first time you’ve sought my company. You must have something to say that you don’t want Bilbo to overhear.”
“You are also quick-witted, for one so young.” Thorin’s voice was a little warmer this time. “It reminds me very much of your uncle.”
Frodo didn’t respond. He simply waited, his cheeks stinging from the cold wind.
The dwarf sighed. “You are not wrong. I am sorry that my reticence has seemed like avoidance. That was never my intention. But I am, as my sister and nephew never hesitate to remind me, not the most socially adept dwarf. I did not wish to presume familiarity where there was none.”
“Furthermore,” he continued, “Bilbo shared his intention to bring you with him in his letters, but made no mention of how we were to behave together. I erred on the side of caution, and decided not to flaunt our relationship, should it make you uncomfortable.”
“You being married to Bilbo doesn’t bother me,” Frodo said. “In truth, it’s a relief to know that he hasn’t been alone all these years, as most of the Shire thinks.”
Thorin’s mouth tightened unhappily, and Frodo wondered if he was, in fact, being too blunt.
“Perhaps he has been alone for longer than he should have, if that is the belief amongst his kin,” Thorin replied.
“Then why have you lived away from him?” Frodo asked, sensing that the challenge that might lead where he was aiming.
“Why did you pretend to be asleep when I came to your chambers last night?” Thorin countered. There was no heat in his voice, but Frodo was shocked into silence nonetheless.
“How did you know?” he finally managed through the embarrassment.
“I helped raise my nephews for many years after the death of their father,” Thorin responded easily. “I know when someone is feigning sleep in order to overhear a conversation they are not meant to be privy to. You need not worry,” he assured the hobbit. “There was nothing said that I did not wish you to hear, and I believe Bilbo truly did think you asleep.”
“But why…?”
“It is sometimes easier to share the truth with someone other than the person who most needs to hear it,” Thorin stated. “Which is one of the reasons I wished to speak with you."
Thorin's voice became hesitant, less smooth. "I have been....troubled...recently, regarding Bilbo. I begin to wonder now if our years apart might have done more harm than I realized. As the person closest to him, I hoped you might help me discern the truth.”
“I can't help anyone when I still don’t understand why!” Frodo snapped, politeness forgotten. Even he was taken aback by the forcefulness of his own reply, but now that the words were spoken aloud, he would not apologize for them. “Why did you ever decide to separate in the first place?”
This was the crux of the problem, the great mystery that needed an answer before anything else could be resolved.
For a moment, it seemed Thorin might not answer him at all. He gazed out across the Westmarch, and the early morning light made the furrows of his face appear even deeper. He was so still that could have been part of the mountain itself.
“It is difficult to explain, but I will try,” he began. “Things that seemed very important back then are less pressing now. Much has changed...we have changed. And yet we never revisited our decision. We simply fell into our own routines, and never altered them. I suppose to one as young as yourself, it must seem baffling. Once you become older, though, you begin to find more limitations. You seek smaller spaces to occupy. You do what’s easier, because you are too weary to do anything else.”
Thorin was not wrong about it being baffling, but Frodo held his tongue with great effort. This dwarf used words in the same way one might use the tips of one’s toes to test the steadiness of a rope bridge: careful, deliberate, ready to pull back to safety in a second. He was clearly still finding his footing.
“After the quest was over, and another sat on the throne that I had sacrificed so much to attain—even though it was the right decision, the one that was best for my people—I was lost. My body healed, but my spirit remained untethered. I left my kin and followed Bilbo because he was the one who seemed to have a clear direction, and I needed that. I did not share his love of wandering, having had more than my fill of it after the fall of Erebor, but our travels together were the best years of my life. For the first time since faunthood, I ruled no one except myself. I learned what kind of dwarf I was free from the weight of a crown. Bilbo was there with me every step of the way, in good times and ill, the dearest companion I could have asked for.”
Now that Thorin had begun, the words seemed to flow more easily. Frodo was surprised, but not enough to interrupt. It seemed that his curiosity was about to be satisfied at last!
“We had grown...close...on the quest, though neither of us assumed we would survive long enough to fulfill any oaths that were made. When it was only the two of us, miraculously alive, we made good on those promises. He accepted my proposal. Somehow we never discussed where we might settle in the future. We knew that we cared for one another, and that seemed enough at the time.”
Thorin exhaled heavily before continuing.
“But couldn’t live on the road forever. We grew older and slower. There were too many close calls, too many instances where a second’s hesitation could have ended in injury, or worse. We did not seek danger, but there are many things in this world, both seen and unseen…” He stopped. “We decided that we needed a place to hang our traveling cloaks for good.”
“Bilbo suggested the Shire, naturally. He had Bag End...filled with all his comfortable things, a life that he could slip back into easily. I suggested Ered Luin, for much the same reason. We could not come to an agreement. I can admit now that my pride would not bear the idea of being beholden to anyone, even him. After all the years spent begging and scraping for every morsel, to be offered a home so easily—the very thing I had fought so hard for!—it felt too much like charity. I wanted no part of it.”
“It wasn’t, you know,” Frodo interrupted. This topic was too near his own heart to let it lie. “It wasn't charity. He would never offer such a thing out of pity.”
“I know that now,” Thorin agreed. “But I chose not see it at the time. And just as importantly, at least to me, I had already done much to damage Bilbo’s reputation. I did not wish to bring him further shame.”
He continued. “Then, in the midst of our personal strife, Dís sent word that Kíli had died at the hands of a rogue band of orcs here in Ered Luin. It was a miracle our entire company survived my foolhardy expedition. That my sister-sons had lived to return home was perhaps my only real triumph. To lose one of them so senselessly such a short time later—in a place I believed safe, no less—was agony almost beyond bearing.”
Thorin’s voice was husky with pain, and Frodo wished that he had the words to comfort him, but experience had taught him that there were no platitudes that truly lessened such sorrow. Some things simply had to be endured. Instead he stared straight ahead and pretended not to notice the way Thorin turned his face away to hide his grief. He found his heart softening towards this dwarf despite himself. If there was anything Frodo understood well, it was loss.
“I returned home to be with my sister and Fíli. Bilbo stayed with me, holding me together until I could function again. He encouraged me to keep busy while protecting me from the worst of my self-destructive urges. So I buried my grief in labor, took on every task that needed doing, and by the end of that year I was supervising restoration for Ered Luin’s infrastructure. I had woven myself deeply into the fabric of life here once more. We agreed that, for the time being, Bilbo should return to the Shire to keep his relations from presuming him missing yet again, and I should remain here. We arranged to meet in several month’s time to discuss what we should do next. But when that time came, we were simply too happy to be together again, and I had my work to return to, so we put off the discussion until the next time. And so it went, on and on, until without even realizing it, years had passed and we still lived apart.”
Frodo’s chest began to throb. He had been so confident in his belief that Bilbo had been wronged, so ready to leap to his uncle’s defense, that he hadn’t actually considered the idea that Bilbo may have been equally culpable in his own misery. But his certainty was being steadily chipped away by Thorin’s careful, honest words. And yet, the idea that their shared unhappiness was merely the result of them being too stubborn to admit that they needed one another was dreadful. It was somehow more painful for its absolute pointlessness.
Thorin pressed on.
“I told myself that it was for the best. It was easier for me to imagine him as the master of his own domain once again. He had earned that, after so many years of dedicating himself to a broken dwarf. I willed myself to forget what his home was like when I and my kin invaded it and abused his hospitality so shamefully: a mausoleum, filled with knick-knacks that he couldn’t bear to part with, because what else did he have? There was no family awaiting his return.”
“You’re wrong,” Frodo disagreed, not able to bear any more. He stared hard at the floor to hide his watering eyes. “He had me. Every time he left, I ran after him, begged him to stay. Even before he took me in, he was my hero.”
Thorin clasped the hobbit’s shoulder heavily. “He is mine, as well.”
Frodo needed a moment to regain his equilibrium. He had blindly, arrogantly entered this conversation with unearned confidence, in the hopes of bringing about a specific resolution. Now the waters were muddied with decades of history that he could barely comprehend. He felt very young and very insignificant. His uncle—the eccentric, whimsical, sharp-tongued hobbit he had admired since faunthood—had lived an entirely separate life as the closest companion to this tragic, legendary dwarf. His stories had been true, and there were clearly countless others he’d never shared. Somehow it felt like he did not know Bilbo at all, and yet everything Thorin had told him only reinforced everything he had ever believed.
Subdued but unable to remain silent under the heavy weight of Thorin’s stare, he ventured, “You said before that there were other reasons you wished to speak to me?” Thorin drew his hand away, but he didn’t step back. He scrutinized Frodo in a way that made the hobbit feel, if possible, even smaller.
“I wanted to thank you, Frodo Baggins.”
Frodo’s eyes flew to Thorin’s face, startled.
“Thank me for what?”
“For taking care of him when I failed to do so. In my pride and ignorance, I left him alone for too long, allowed doubt and fear to gnaw away at his heart. I dreaded the day when he would grow too tired, too old, or too heartsick to come to me anymore, yet I did nothing to stop it. But you, Frodo, have become the joy of his life in the Shire. He has blossomed anew with you by his side. I fear that without you he may have faded into a shadow of the hobbit he was, and for that I will be forever grateful. As Bilbo’s heir, all that I have is already yours. But if there is anything I can ever do for you, anything at all...it would be my privilege, though it cannot begin to repay the debt I owe you.”
Emotion swelled inside of Frodo, spreading in a shuddering, aching wave to every inch of his body, lifting away a weight he hadn't realized was burdening his heart. It was a little like how he had felt the first time he crossed the Brandywine after the death of his parents: proud, frightened, a little overwhelmed. He had always hoped that in some small way he provided comfort to Bilbo, who had done so much for him throughout his life, yet always seemed to carry an albatross around his own heart. To be told that he had saved him in some indefinable way, well...he would scarcely have believed it if it didn't come from the mouth of this particular dwarf, who perhaps knew Bilbo better than anyone else. He would need more time to sort out his thougts on the matter. This discussion, such as it was, had spun him in every possible direction.
Thorin was still patiently waiting for a response, however, so he gathered his scattered wits as much as he was able.
“I don’t know about this ‘debt’ nonsense,” he replied slowly. “I don’t believe you can be indebted to family.”
Even as the idea was still forming, Frodo knew what he needed to ask. His stomach squirmed with nerves, and he felt equal parts giddy and terrified at the import of what he was about to say.
“There is something you can do.” He breathed deeply, and looked Thorin square in the face. Here in the bright daylight, standing mere feet away, Frodo noticed that the dwarf’s eyes were piercingly blue, like a frozen lake. Dís had the same eyes, the same proud face, the same regal bearing. With her image in his mind, he could clearly envision what Thorin must have looked like fifty years ago, standing tall and proud in the doorway of Bag End, promising an adventure. Had Bilbo ever stood a chance?
“Come live with us. In Bag End. It doesn’t have to be right away. It doesn’t even have to be all the time. But please. I want you to live with us,” he said.
When Thorin didn’t respond, the fluttering feeling in his stomach turned to a hard knot of fear. Perhaps he had misinterpreted Thorin’s offer?
But then…
“Tharkûn was right...as he always is, the charlatan. No matter how long you know a Baggins, whether it be a month or a lifetime, they always manage to surprise you.” Thorin smiled, a full and true smile. It transformed him utterly, removing years from his bearing. “Are you certain of this, Frodo? Will you be comfortable sharing Bilbo’s attention? I would never wish to intrude on your relationship, or overstep my boundaries.”
“We’ll muddle through. You are as much as part of Bilbo’s life as I am. We will make it work. For him.”
“You are impossibly wise, for one so young. And equally kind. Truly, Bilbo could not have chosen a better heir,” Thorin praised warmly.
“Does that mean you’ll come?” Frodo pressed, wanting to be certain.
“I will come," he confirmed. "I have already discussed the idea with Dís and Fíli. They agree with my decision. It is time for me to leave this self-imposed exile...there is no need for it any longer. I have affairs to settle here, but rest assured, I will follow you before Astron, by the reckoning of your people.”
Frodo beamed. “Then I have one further request,” he added, happiness giving way to mischief. “Let us keep this between us. I want Bilbo to be surprised when you arrive.”
“As you command, Master Baggins,” Thorin laughed. “Bilbo has spent a lifetime defying all my expectations. It will be a refreshing change of pace to return the favor.”
----------------
Five days later, they all stood on the steps of the Keep in the early morning: Dís, Fíli, Thorin, Bilbo and Frodo. Unlike their arrival, the timing of which had been too imprecise to send an escort, they were to be accompanied to the edge of the Shire by Fíli on their return, to ensure their safety.
Frodo had been showered with so many gifts by Dís that they had to borrow a mule for the journey. Fíli laughed uproariously when he discovered this, but his mother was unrepentant.
“You will write to me, will you not?” she asked him now, as she straightened imaginary wrinkles out of the new fur-lined cloak around his shoulders. Of all the dwarves (and elves) whose acquaintance he had made on this journey, Frodo knew he would miss Dís more than any of them. She was the kindest, most generous, most learned and amazing person he had ever met in his entire life, of any race; motherly but not overbearing, regal but without conceit. His admiration was so great that would walk back to Ered Luin on his own if need be, to see her again.
The Baggins weakness for the line of Durin seemed to be hereditary.
“Of course I will,” he assured her. “And I hope that you will permit me to visit your halls again next Yule.”
“It would be my greatest honor,” she replied, and he knew the words were absolutely sincere. “The gates of Ered Luin are always open to you.” They embraced once more before she transferred her attentions to Bilbo. Thorin took her place, grasping Frodo’s forearm and touching their foreheads together in the traditional manner of dwarves.
“Farewell, Frodo Baggins of the Shire,” he said quietly. “May your journey be swift, and may Mahal bless you in all your endeavours. I hope that Fate will allow us to meet again soon.”
“I hope so as well, Uncle Thorin,” Frodo replied simply, before shouldering his pack and joining Fíli.
Thorin and Bilbo had already spoken most of their goodbyes privately, so as they stood before the gates of Ered Luin, they contented themselves with a gentle embrace and some final whispered words. Moments later, two hobbits, a dwarf and a mule were traveling through the shadowed pass, back into the world outside the mountains.
Frodo turned to look behind him one last time, and even though Thorin couldn’t see it from this distance, he mouthed one word...a promise and a plea:
Soon.
