Chapter Text
When Helen did at last pull from Fíli’s embrace, she knew that there was no time like the present, and if the recent misunderstanding between the two of them had taught her anything, it was that communication was vital if a relationship with Fíli was something she wished to pursue- which she did. There would be enough drama in that endeavor without adding to the mix. Besides, theirs was a special circumstance. He deserved to know fully what he may be getting involved with, and it was better now before either may be hurt later on.
It was with that in mind that Helen spoke, “Fíli, before we let this go any further, there are somethings that I learned recently- about myself- that I feel you should know.”
Fíli’s tender expression turned at once to one of concern. He took her hand and guided her to the chairs near the fireplace, “Is something wrong? You’re okay?” he asked as he glanced her over for sign of injury or illness.
She managed to give him the tiniest of smiles despite the butterflies in her belly. It seemed to ease his worry somewhat, though her stomach was still heavy with dread. She was worried that if he knew what she did he may not wish to be with her after all.
“When I realized how I felt for you,” she said at last, “There was so much I didn’t know about myself- things that I thought I should know before I even considered telling you how I felt. Since coming to this world, I’ve had so many questions. So many. I didn’t know if I would ever get any answers to any of them; it was driving me crazy, Fíli. I don’t like it when I don’t know how to fix something, and I didn’t even know where to begin. So I just pushed it all to the side. Over time, I just got so used to locking up all these unknowns about myself that I nearly forgot how much I truly didn’t know. And then you came along.”
She looked to her hands that were still being held by his much larger ones and she smiled down at them, “I knew so much about you before I met you. Not everything, but enough. I knew enough. Enough to like your character, because that is what you used to be to me. And then I met you and it was nerve-wracking because for nearly my whole life I had read about you and your bother and Thorin. And then to see you living and breathing and real.”
She looked up at him. Her eyes sweeping over his face, “And you were so much better than I ever could have imagined. You so far exceeded any expectations, and believe me, they were very, very high expectations. I was absolutely star struck when I first saw you. You were a beloved storybook hero come to life. It was amazing. I’m still a bit amazed by it. I think a part of me will always expect to wake up and find this all a dream, but I certainly hope it isn’t.” The corner of her mouth quirked as his cheeks slowly pinked along with her words. She sighed. “But then, you all didn’t like me or trust me. And I-“ She shushed him as he started to apologize, “No, no. I don’t blame you. I don’t blame any of you. I mean, I’m an elf and a stranger and I couldn’t communicate with you at all. I can’t even image what would have happened if Gandalf wasn’t there to translate for me.”
She ignored the dark look that fell over his face as he imagine just how that would have likely gone. There was no sense getting upset over what hadn’t happened however. Instead, she pressed on, “It served a purpose though. It snapped me out of my awe and made me stop looking at you all as characters come to life, and look at you all as living, breathing people. It made it all more real, I think. And aware. I was all too aware of the lot of you. After all, I had to make sure one of you wasn’t going to decide to off me or something. I spent most of those first few days torn between a mix of awe, disbelief, sadness, and overwhelming amounts of excitement. I was so damn happy to meet you all and I spent all of my time watching you all. Just taking it all in, really. It was how I started to notice things. Little things that weren’t really ever mentioned in any of the stories about you all. Silly things about each of you really, like how Bifur has this knack with children,” she grinned as Fíli chuckled.
“It is true. Kí and I always thought it was funny too,” he said through his chuckling.
She giggled, “It really is. He looks so scary. The scariest, most likely, though don’t tell Dwalin I said that. But kids just flock to him, don’t they? It’s incredibly sweet how he whittles little toys and hands them out to each child he sees.”
“I honestly have no idea where he keeps them all. His pack must be 90% toys and 10% supplies,” he laughed.
Helen giggled harder, “Right? It is impressive, truly.” Once their laughter had trickled off, her grin turn shier, “I noticed things about you as well.”
His eyes widened a bit and his breath caught at the way she was looking up at him through her lashes. Her bashfulness made his heart burst and his face heat all at once. He swallowed, “You, you did?”
She nodded.
“Like what?” he wondered.
She chewed her inner cheek, “Well, like how big of a heart you have.”
He flushed.
“It’s true. Many people are kind. People do nice things because it is expected or polite habit even. But you genuinely care about people, don’t you?” she said, “It was small things I saw. You buying a pencil for Ori in Hobbiton when his snapped as he sketched, and then placing it into his bag without him knowing. Most people would make it a gesture. People tend to want acknowledgement when they do nice things, but you snuck it in and never said a word about it. And then there is the way you make adjustments for Bombur’s weight and size without drawing attention to it. When it is time to sit around the fire, you somehow corral the others into leaving the one spot where Bombur will be able to sit easily. And you do it without anyone being any wiser to it, without Bombur even noticing, I think. You just do it. And how you talk with Dori when he goes on a detailed lecture about how certain teas go best with certain moods or how purple shouldn’t be an autumn color because it brings to mind wine and parties and feelings of spring. You don’t just sit there blanking out as he speaks like most everyone else does. You actively engage in it. And you are genuine about it.”
She shook her head, “If things like that weren’t enough, one look at the way you are with Kíli would show it. You two are close. Of course you are, but it’s the way you are with him. You are protective, yes. And doting. But it’s more than that. He looks to you a lot. Before he does almost anything, he glances your way. Before saying something to Thorin or offering to do a task, he looks to you. You’re his support system, always giving him exactly the push or nudge or warning he needs.”
Fíli let out a small dry laugh of a sound, looking down, “I guess I do do that. Our father died when we were young. Well, no. I was young; Kí, Kí was just a little thing. Barely talking. All curls and grins too wide for his chubby cheeks and faster in his feet than anyone that small has any business being.” They chuckled at that. “Ma was devastated. She just-“ his voice cracked and he cleared his throat.
Helen squeezed his hand, “It’s ok. Fíli, you don’t have to talk about it.”
He grinned, “I know. But I want to tell you.” Giving her hand a return squeeze, he spoke, “Ma fell apart when Da died. They were so in love. I remember it so clearly still. Ma would light up a room when Da was around and he only had eyes for her. It was as though she hung the stars in the sky. When he was gone, Ma’s light went with him. Even still when she laughs, there is something in her missing. So, I grew up fast. I made her coffee in the mornings like Da used to. At 10 years old, I had coffee waiting for my mother when she came to the kitchen. And for Kí, I felt like I had to make up for all the time I got to have with Da that Kí never would. I never wanted him to feel the absence like I did. So, I did all the things my father used to do for me. I’d chase away the monsters under the bed. I’d teach him to braid his hair. I taught him about strangers and how to speak to elders. Ma was there. She was dimmed, less vibrant, but she is a good Ma, wonderful even, but there are somethings that a Da teaches his son and so I did them instead. When Thorin declared me his heir, my lessons became more intense. It was at my earnest that Kíli was made to attend as well. Everything I was taught as an heir, Kí would learn as well. How to fight. How to ride a pony. How to delegate. All of it. After a while, Thorin became more a father figure to us, but he is dimmed too. Like Ma. They’ve both suffered greatly. I never wanted Kí to lose his light.”
Helen took a shaky breath as he finished. “Fíli, you are remarkable. You take way too much on yourself though,” she grinned at his sheepish smirk and eye roll, “I’m serious; you carry the weight of the world on your shoulders, which is not healthy. But you are such a good person, Fíli. You’re a good son and a good brother and a good friend. You’re a good man.” She gave a shrug, “It’s no wonder I fell for you. I’d have to be a blind idiot not to.”
He chuckled, looking pinker than ever, “Well, I don’t know about all of that, but I’m glad you did.”
She scoffed, “It’s crazy that you honestly can’t see how amazing you are. You’re a damn unicorn.” At his confused look, she laughed, “It’s an expression from my world saying that you’re the equivalent of finding the rarest and most magical of mythical creatures.” They shared smiles and she sighed. “When I realized how I felt about you was starting to change, at first it didn’t matter. I couldn’t speak to you all still. I thought it was a crush and pushed it down most of the time, but then you nearly drowned. You stopped breathing and your heart wasn’t beating. It was a terrible way to realize that my feelings were not the usual crush. Not some silly fan crush on an idol. I cared for you deeply. Still, I never imagined anything would come of it and then the trolls happened and then Gandalf did his wizardy thing and then I could understand you all.”
He grinned remembering back on it, “Your speech was impressive. Gandalf really has a knack for timing.”
She snorted and gave him a light shove earning chuckles, “Damn wizard meddling. He could have warned me first, but no. He decided you all needed to hear.”
Fíli’s grin turned to a smirk, “It could’ve been worse. You could’ve been ranting about how impossible we all were. You weren’t exactly treated all that well up until then.” He looked sorry for it now.
She brushed it off, “Don’t. I’ve already said I didn’t blame you all for how you treated me. Though I do wish you all would try to make Bilbo feel more welcome.” Fíli flinched at her disapproving look, feeling poorly for not trying more to ensure that Bilbo did not get the brunt of his Uncle’s poor temper. She pressed on, “It was then that I started thinking about ‘what if’s. What if I did want to be with you? What if you liked me as well? What if. What if. What if. All the things I had wondered about myself since coming to Middle Earth all surged forth and I just knew that I had to get answers before I could let myself really entertain, even the thought, of there ever being an us,” she gestured between them.
He nodded, rubbing his thumb over the back of her knuckles affectionately, “And you found them? The answers?”
She nodded. Her mouth opened and closed several times.
At her hesitation to continue, he brought one of her hands up placing a kiss upon it, “There is nothing you could say that would scare me away.”
She took a breath as she began, “I was most worried that there was a chance that I could, in the future, unexpectedly return to my world in much the same way that I came into this one.”
His grip on her hands tightened just slightly. The way his gentle smile he managed to give her didn’t quite reach his eyes betrayed his feigned calm as the implications settled in his mind. His voice remained even as he spoke, “And could you? I know you likely wish to go home. Is it possible?”
She was amazed that he was still trying to sound happy for her even when the tension radiating off him gave away his despair at the thought. She squeezed his hands in reassurance, as she spoke, “No. I likely won’t ever be able to go back. I’m no longer human, a child of man. I’m half what I was and half elven now. Elves do not exist in my world.”
His breath whooshed out of him. She saw a flash of relief in his eyes, but his words were only those of comfort. “I’m so sorry, Helen. Though I do not know what it feels like to lose your home, I’ve seen what that can do to someone. I promise you that I will do everything in my power to not let you get to that dark place. My Uncle and even my own Mother hold that sadness and loss in their eyes. I’d do anything to spare you that pain,” he said.
“Oh Fíli,” she let out a weak laugh of disbelief, “If you get any more perfect, I may not be able to handle it.”
He looked a bit embarrassed.
She chuckled, shaking her head, “I’m sorry. I’m not used to someone looking after me. I’m afraid you’ll have to bear with me as I stumble awkwardly until I get used to the idea. I’m used to doing the looking after.”
He smiled softly then, “You mean with Charlotte?” At her wince, he froze his smile slipping away as he closed his eyes, “I’m so sorry. I didn’t think-“
She shushed him, “It’s okay. I need to talk about it. Not going back to my world has only one real loss I can’t get over. Charlotte may not have been blood, but she was my sister in every meaning of the word since childhood. I miss her deeply. I just wish that I could know if she was alright. I worry for her illness.”
“Maybe you can,” he said.
“Huh,” she looked up confused.
His brows furrowed as he thought, “Who knows what the future may hold. After all, you were able to get answers to questions about yourself. Maybe there is a way to learn of her wellbeing.”
Helen smiled wistfully, “Perhaps. Though, I fear looking as well.” At his questioning expression, she explained, “I learned about another complication to my ability to return. Time moves differently in my world and this one. If I did look, she may be old and gray or even-“ Her voice hitched.
He reached up to brush a strand of hair from her cheek, “I’m sorry.”
She leaned into his palm, her eyes closing, “Thank you.” She took his hand from her cheek, tracing patterns into his palm. At last she spoke, “You may be right though. Perhaps there could be a way to find out how she is. It’s the not knowing that is worst I think. I can’t come to terms with it really, because I don’t know what I’m trying to come to terms with.” She sighed. “There is nothing more to be done now, however. I’m in this world. I am another race than from how I was born. My very biology has changed,” she shook her head, “It is hard to wrap my head around, honestly. Hearing it is one thing, but I can’t seem to come to terms with what I am now.”
He glanced up at her bashfully, “You are beautiful.”
Her cheeks flushed.
He seemed to gain nerve as he continued, “Inside and out, you are. I may not understand much about how it happened- how you came to our world- other than that the gods deemed it so, but I know that you are still you. Whether here or there, Man or Elf, you are still yourself. That hasn’t changed,” he grinned and reached to brush one of her pointed ears, “even if somethings have.”
She smiled, a few giggles escaping as his touch tickled her ear. She shook her head, “How am I ever going to be able to be mad at you if you keep saying such perfect things?”
He chuckled, “I guess you’ll just have to get used to letting me get away with everything.”
She scoffed, “Or perhaps instead of mad I’ll just get even.”
His shoulders shook as he chuckled, hiding his mirth behind a hand.
She watched him laughing as butterflies took off in her belly. His eyes twinkling and dimples in full play. She was amazed once more that someone so rugged and powerful looking- so very masculine could be so gentle and beautiful. She wanted to kiss him. Dear gods above, she desperately wanted to pull him over and kiss him until his giggling stopped, and then she wanted to kiss him more.
Instead she blurted, “I may not be able to give you children.”
His laughter sputtered. His eyes wide as he looked at her now bright red face, “W-what?” he choked.
She cursed herself, because honestly, she planned to get to this part delicately and with as little embarrassment as possible. Instead, the overwhelming urge to kiss him senseless had panicked her and she had blurted out the first thing that came to mind. She cringed, “I’m sorry. I just- um, well.” She cleared her throat noticing how very pink he had become as well. “I know it is not something that is exactly appropriate to talk about right now, or at all… my world is different. We are more, um open about these things, even if I personally would rather not talk about it in a non-medical or scientific way. But considering…” she trailed off.
He started to speak but she urged herself on.
“No, wait, let me get this out before I chicken out,” she said, “I wanted to know, because this, this world and the people in it, is all new to me. While I know a lot about many different things in this world, there are many more things I don’t. The biology of the races of this world and how they mesh together. With the origins of Dwarves being from a different maker than Men and Elves, I did not know if the races were genetically or even physically compatible enough to produce viable offspring or to even mate to begin with.”
Fíli was lost now. Lost, but he got enough to be thoroughly shy at what he thought she was talking about. As her rambling quickened and her hands began to squeeze his palm, he pushed his embarrassment aside. He took his hand back, and cupped her face, “Helen, you are talking rather fast and using words I’m unfamiliar with. Breathe, its okay. I’m not going anywhere. Just breathe.” She did as he asked and he nodded, “Good girl,” he near cooed as though calming a frightened fawn. His thumbs rubbed her cheeks as he breathed in deeply again, coaching her to copy him. He was good at spotting anxieties in others and good at talking people down. He had perfected it as he and Kíli grew, when others teased his younger brother for his smaller beard or preference of a bow over axes and swords.
Her panting eased and her pupils relaxed as her panic eased. She continued to breathe with him until finally his hands fell from her face. She smiled at him in thanks, “I’m sorry. I have been a bit nervous about this part of the talk and I’ve never been entirely good with talking about these sort of things, in regards to myself. I am a scientific mind at heart and I get a bit lost in it once I get started sometimes.” She explained, “My worries were to do with the way the races of this world were made, how they were assembled and if they could,” she flushed intertwining her hands to represent a blending, “mix well on a fundamental level.” She sighed as he nodded that he followed though his cheeks were back to pink. It was fine. Hers matched. “These kinds of things are known to you all. These are things that are learned as you grew up, but I was plopped here without knowing any of it. I had to know if what I am could interfere with my future,” she glanced up at him, “And if we were, well, a ‘we’, I needed to know how it could interfere with our future.”
He swallowed as he processed her meaning. While ‘children’ had startled him, he understood what she was saying. It was not a usual courtship- He flushed as he looked at her and wondered if it was a courtship. After all, he hadn’t asked her yet. He looked over her face, her light brown hair, her gray-blue eyes. His heart skipped as she met his gaze. She was embarrassed but trying to be brave. Her small shoulders squared and chin lifted just a tad, as though daring him to tease her, and he adored her all the more for it. He breathed in. He knew that this was what he wanted, she was what he wanted. No matter what else came with it. They’d figure it out. Together. He lifted her hand and kissed the back, feeling her shiver as he did.
She watched him kiss her hand. The look in his eyes tender and supportive, though his cheeks were still the slightest bit pink as he nodded for her to go on. She was glad she hadn’t offended him. She forgot sometimes that this world was different from hers in many ways more than just magical creatures and fairytales. “I had never heard of dwarves and elves being, um, together,” she cleared her throat, “I didn’t even know if I was truly an elf. As it turns out, I am only half. No one seems to recall if it is possible for a dwarf and elf to…” she flushed, “but for dwarves and men, it has before. It is not really an answer, but it is all I have.”
He pictured a blonde child with gray eyes and found a pang of longing spread through his chest, “So, it could be possible, but it may not be. Though no one knows for sure, is that right?” He asked.
She nodded weakly, “Yes.”
“Well,” he said with a shrug, “then it is not very much different from the usual.”
She stammered, “What?”
He grinned softly, “Dwarves are rare for a reason. Not only because dwarven women are so rare and our stubbornness to not move on if our chosen does not return our feelings- especially so with dwarven women, but also because sometimes unions don’t produce children.”
She blinked, “Really?’
He nodded, “Truly, some lines have more luck than others, but it is still true for all of my race.”
She sat back at that, “Oh, I had no idea.”
He chuckled, “Nor would most. Us dwarves are a secretive lot. Such matters are known among dwarven folk, so they are not often discussed.”
“Cultural knowledge,” she nodded, “I just assumed, because you and your brother, and then your mother being one of three,” she said.
He grinned, chest puffing out a bit in pride, “Yes, my line is one of the unusually lucky.”
She thought for a moment, “But, if that is the case, then what if- What if we do get to that point? What if I’m not able to give you an heir? Fíli, you are Thorin’s heir. Surely this is a big deal. Should you not try to find a dwarven woman? One more likely to give you such a child? Do you not want children? I mean, I have never really wanted kids of my own, so-”
His brows furrowed, “You don’t want children?”
She stopped, “Well, it was never really that I didn’t want children. I just never had an urge to have any of my own. I always planned to adopt.” She studied him a moment, “Fíli, if children is something you are passionate about, you might need to look elsewhere. I never had a longing to carry a child of my own and the odds of it happening anyway seem slim to none. You are the heir, after all. I’m sure this is a pretty important issue. Perhaps we shouldn’t get any more involved than we already are.”
He pursed his lips. The image of the blonde child with gray eyes flashing though his mind once more. He tried to picture his child with a different mother, a truly dwarven child, with different features and even a full dwarven beard, but it did nothing. He felt no pang of longing. It felt as though seeing another’s child, not his, not hers, not theirs. He realized then that he was already too far in his feelings for Helen. His heart already belonged to hers. He had found fallen for her already. He had found his One. If not with her, he would never wish for children, let alone have them.
“Helen, it doesn’t matter to me that you are not a dwarven lass,” he said at last, “I don’t care that you are half-elf nor that you come from another world. Even if we never are graced with a child of our own, whether because it won’t happen or because you don’t ever wish it, I would still want to be with you. I would chose you a thousand times over. And if it was something you wanted and did happen, there is no other I could ever want that with. Heir or no. Children or no. I chose you. I chose us. This,” he said gesturing between them, “This and you and us.”
A tear spilled over and ran down her cheek. He wiped without a thought and she smiled. “Okay.”
“Okay?” he asked.
“Okay,” she nodded.
“Okay, what?” he prodded cautiously, “Okay, the child thing is settled or…”
“This. Us,” she smiled, “If you truly aren’t scared off after all of that.”
“I’m not,” he assured her.
She smiled, “Then okay.”
His dimples appeared as he returned her smile, bring her hands up between them to kiss her palms, “Okay,” he smirked as her breath hitched at the feel of his lips to her palms.
Fíli and Helen spoke through until dinner, where he escorted her upon his arm. If seeing the two in the same room wasn’t a shock enough, seeing the way Helen beamed at Fíli or how he looked to her like she hung the stars certainly served to do the trick.
The dwarves made a good ruckus at the sight, wolf-whistles and smirks abound. Kíli wore the biggest grin and coins were tossed as bets were cashed in. Gandalf’s eye were exceptionally twinkly as he chuckled merrily at the sight of the oblivious love birds who were so wrapped up in each other that they missed the wave their entrance had made. Thorin eyed the pair studiously before turning back to his meal. He glanced at the wizard with a lifted brow, “You seemed pleased.”
“Oh, indeed,” the wizard chuckled, “I take great joy in the happiness of others, my friend. And I dare say, I could not have wished it on two more deserving. The pair have been circling each other since near on the moment they met.”
Thorin’s brows furrowed as he thought back, “Did not my nephew pull a knife on her when first they met?”
Glorfindel’s eyes flashed, though a hand on his arm from Lord Elrond kept him in his seat.
Gandalf chuckled, “Indeed, the passion was already there. Or the seeds for it at least.”
Thorin seemed at a loss, “I dare say, if threats are romance to wizards, it is no wonder you don’t hear of them marrying.”
Elrond seemed to come down with a sudden cough, which he hid behind a napkin.
Gandalf harrumphed as he patted the Elven Lord’s back lightly, “You cannot argue the results,” he said looking to the couple as they neared.
Thorin watched as Fíli delivered Helen into her seat, bowing over her hand before moving to his own chair. Thorin shook his head, even as a tiny grin twitched at his mouth, “No, indeed you can’t.”
That dinner, Fíli and Helen remained in the clouds. Both wore silly grins and were prone to stealing glances. Luckily, their absorption into their own little worlds made them miss much of the teasing remarks of their friends. At last, it seemed that the lack of reaction from the pair made it lose its fun and the jeering stopped.
Kíli turned to his brother and saw his eyes glued to Helen’s figure near the head of the table. He chuckled and nudged his brother’s side, “She looks lovely tonight.”
A sigh and agreeing comment was the absentminded reply.
Kíli snorted, “I take it you two finally spoke. I told you she wasn’t engaged.”
That did catch Fíli’s attention, who at last looked from the vision of twinkling gems in Helen’s hair to his smug younger brother. Fíli rolled his eyes once he pieced together what had been said, “Yes, we talked. You were right,” he nudged Kíli, “Don’t look so smug about it. I admit I should’ve listened to you.”
“I’m sorry,” Kíli stuck his pinkie in his ear giving it a good shake, “I must’ve had something in my ear. What did you say?”
Fíli scoffed, but obliged, “You were right.”
“And?”
Eyes rolled, “I should’ve listened to you.”
“And?”
“You’re an insufferable ass,” Fíli flicked some potato at Kíli.
Kíli merely beamed with the white blob on his cheek, “I’m an ass, but I’m an ass who was right.”
Fíli groaned, “I’m never going to hear the end of this, am I?”
“Nope.”
“I hate you.”
“Love you too, older brother.”
“Love you too, brat.”
“Hey!”
Fíli chuckled as he went back to eating.
At the head of the table, the sound of Fíli’s laughter drew Helen’s gaze. Her heart clenched and then surged ahead at the sight of his eye-crinkled, dimpled smile.
Elladan and Elrohir snickered.
Her eyes moved to the twins and she flushed at having been caught staring.
Elrond sent the pair a look, silencing their teasing. He turned to Helen with a gentle smile, “I am glad you are back to your old self once more.”
She smiled shyly, “Thank you.”
“Things were all worked out then?” he inquired politely.
She nodded glancing down the table once more, “Yes, everything is perfect.”
She missed the dreamy quality of her voice, but Glorfindel did not. Nor did he miss the glances the fairest heir of Durin sent her way. Nor did he miss what Thorin had said about the dwarf pulling out a knife upon meeting her.
Glorfindel decided then that he would have to make sure the dwarf had only the best intentions with Helen. He’d have to gather information. It would take stealth. He eyed the twins in thought. Perhaps the pair could provide some assistance, after all, they were renowned for their tracking skills and patrols to the North.
