Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 64: The Bagginshield Fanfic Trend Timeline

Chapter Text

The Bagginshield Fanfic Timeline - An analysis by Avelera. This is just my opinion and no fics are named. I don’t pretend to have totally exhaustive knowledge of all Bagginshield fics, this is just my overall observations since having started shipping Bagginshield the day AUJ was released. No particular reason to share this now except it was on my mind. 

AUJ Era Bagginshield Fic: Free-for-all. Almost everything is either implication or extrapolated from The Hobbit book using movie appearances, there is no cohesive movie canon so fanfic writers are free to imagine the quest ending however they see fit. Bagginshield is a ship, but it’s simply one of many as every character is shipped with every other character (and even characters that haven’t shown up yet like Tauriel). Popular characterizations and tropes coalesce, such as dwarves using Khuzdul pet names, dwarvish hair braiding culture, Bilbo-the-Gardener, fem-Bilbo, secretly-female dwarves, and general fanon Dwarvish culture for everything from their view on gender to physiological differences from other races. Quest-retelling fic is rampant. Bilbo and Thorin when shipped together often correspond to standard yaoi tropes of Tall-Dark-Aggressive-and-Brooding and Blond-Flowerchild-Innocent-Submissive, though there are many exceptions. Since Thorin’s character is still fairly mysterious in the films, authors are often uncertain of how to voice his character by comparison and it’s not uncommon even in Bagginshield-centric fics for Thorin to spend most of the story in the background or not talking. Also, displays of affection and/or actual lengthy conversation between Thorin and Bilbo in many instances don’t occur until the climax or even the final chapter of the story. 

DOS Era Bagginshield Fic: The DoS theatrical release adds depressingly little to the Bagginshield ship compared to the AUJ Hug Scene and the various hopes and imaginings of fic writers as seen in DoS-predictive fics. Early DoS fic is less transformed and more sustained from AUJ era fics as no major disruption happens, fic writers simply continue to write in the established tradition and ongoing stories rather than change their plans dramatically. Fans look forward to BotFA which promises the book’s Mithril Shirt Scene and the Death Scene for more ship-y moments. This changes somewhat when the Extended Edition is released and we get the vouching scene from Bilbo and a few other Bagginshield moments. Tauriel is added to the mix of characters though and many Kili-centric fics change in tone as a result, as they now have to either explain why Kili isn’t with Tauriel in favor of another dwarf of choice, or the new “canonical” ship of Kili/Tauriel is added to the general mindscape. 

In the lead up to BotFA’s release, Thorin-hate reaches a fever pitch as fans extrapolating Richard’s performance and appearance onto the book canon of the Arkenstone Debacle scene have Thorin shaking Bilbo and threatening to kill him. Bagginshield shippers, based on fanon works that assume a darker characterization of Thorin, are often accused of enjoying an abusive ship despite the fact the series was not yet complete and how these book scenes would be depicted in the films was yet unknown. 

BotFA Era Bagginshield: Explosion. An influx of new Bagginshield authors sweep into the fandom, fanfic writers who previously could not “see” the ship jump enthusiastically on board. Even long-term Bagginshield writers are shocked (and immensely gratified) by the intimacy between the characters as seen in the Mithril Shirt Scene, the Death Scene and especially the entirely unanticipated Acorn Scene. Thorin’s characterization in fic dramatically softens, to the point where it’s clear if a fic was written pre- or post-BotFA just by the contrast of how aloof and forbidding Thorin is vs how emotional and soft. Thanks to the actual film depiction of the Arkenstone Debacle, where Thorin is shown as heartbroken rather than enraged by the revelation of Bilbo’s betrayal, much of the Dark Thorin characterization and abusive ship accusations lose their justifications as a completed character arc for Thorin becomes available. Quest-retelling fic becomes less common (or is simply exhausted) compared to Everyone Lives AU aftermath stories and other reimaginings. 

Addendum:

Lots of the wilder dwarvish culture aspects came from the AUJ era when fanfic writers really sunk their teeth into this rather new interpretation of dwarves we got in AUJ even vs. the LotR films. Keep in mind, none of the LotR era dwarves had tattoos or gave any indication that they were born before the age of 1,000

While there are hair and beard braids there, in general their design was a lot more simplistic and the only dwarf we had long-term exposure too was Gimli, who was turned into a bit of a joke compared to his book-counterpart. So anything you see regarding hair-braiding culture, Khuzdul-use, hidden gender or differing views on gender binary (which was somewhat owed to Gimli’s TTT line about dwarf women) are total fanon by AUJ-era fic writers.

Vestigial fic tropes from this era are mostly based around book canon but with movie appearances. Thorin and Bilbo having their final words to one another in a tent is from the books (I’m very guilty of that across multiple fics). Anything where Thorin is imprisoned alone and at length in Mirkwood is from the book and common from AUJ era fic’s anticipating DOS. There was an entire fic once where Bilbo couldn’t be around Thorin because being held over the ramparts had traumatized him, while in the movie not only did Thorin barely lift Bilbo as he was pressed against the wall (it was more of a shove than a near-murder), but the idea of Bilbo being traumatized at that height is rather laughable since the ramparts were barely a story tall and over water, Bilbo climbed down it later that night without even blinking.

But mostly I’d say Serious & Forbidding Thorin is the longest-term holdover from the first couple years of fic, also Thorin barely talking. I’d owe that latter point to the fact that Bilbo talks a lot and he has the LotR series and the Hobbit book for authors to build a voice off of, since he’s still pretty similar to his book counterpart in all ways except his view of Thorin. Whereas Thorin was so dramatically changed from the book that there wasn’t really much to go off of besides a dozen lines of dialogue. I know for my part it took at least 10,000 words of writing Bilbo’s POV before I dared attempt Thorin’s, though now I’m much more comfortable with it obviously.