Chapter Text
Bilbo does not realize it at first. One moment he is stuck in a too narrow passage with an odd, dangerous creature closing in, wielding a sharp rock as a weapon. Of course, Bilbo’s sword is stuck on the wrong side, and his buttons get in the way. The creature pounces with an unholy shriek –
And then he is on the other side, together with Gollum who looks around in confusion. Bilbo, shaken to the core, remains where he lies, while Gollum mutters to himself, and drops that glistening rock. “Thiefs! We will find you!” he exclaims, and bounds off again.
Bilbo forces himself to his feet – he does not know why Gollum failed to see him, but he will not question his luck. Everything feels too wrong to figure anything out – he needs a quiet moment to settle his thoughts, but there is no reprieve. Abruptly there are familiar voices shouting, the sound of running boots – and Bilbo rushes after the company.
Like Gollum, they do not see him at first. Only when Bilbo clears his throat and speaks up his presence is noticed – with some surprise and relief. Thorin remains skeptical, demanding to know how Bilbo escaped, and the hobbit can only shrug.
He does not quite understand it either. But perhaps his memory is faulty?
“What does it matter?” Gandalf comments in an attempt to placate the growing tension, though there is an odd expression on his face. Lucky for Bilbo, though, Thorin is mostly interested in his reasons – and Bilbo does not hesitate to state those.
“You do not have one. A home. But I will help you take it back if I can.”
And that is his promise. Come what may, he will see it done – and that softens the hollow feeling in his chest a little.
***
To his own astonishment, Bilbo walks out of the confrontation with Azog with nary a bruise and only two hardly-bleeding cuts. He is too surprised at his own daring to question why the rather deep cut on his arm does not bleed; and too thankful for the reprieve after to think much upon his confrontation with Gollum.
Thorin’s hug provides him with inner warmth that carries through the night. The next morning is the first that Bilbo wakes without feeling dead tired still – though he remains rather exhausted and hollowed-out.
Gandalf proclaims they will visit an acquaintance of his, and with the gentling landscape the general mood rises. Birds chirp, and the rocky path turns into green grass. The landscape is lush, and the nightmare of the Misty Mountains remains as the icy, beautiful backdrop against small woods and wide grasslands.
The animals turn enormous, and for the first time Bilbo thinks he may enjoy the wild. It certainly helps, that the overgrown insects keep their distance. Others are not so lucky, and by noon it is nearly a miracle none has been stung one of the oversized bees.
Once they arrive, Beorn stares down Gandalf. “I will not house any of Morgoth’s creation.”
His stance is oddly tense, almost as if he was afraid. Bilbo is surprised, because Beorn is twice the size of Gandalf, and even considering the wizard’s magic, he would be more than a fair opponent. However, Beorn took one look at Bilbo and immediately stiffened.
“I would not bring one of those to your doorstep,” Gandalf replies, “Though there may be some chasing us. Our company –“
“Your company? Do you mean you and your companion?”
“Indeed. Myself and Master Baggins, a hobbit from the Shire,” and in small increments Gandalf spins their tale. It is a nice one, Bilbo thinks, and one he might want to write down later. Somehow, at this thought, he grows dizzy.
“Are you alright?” Bofur asks quietly, but not quietly enough. Abruptly, all eyes turn to him and – surprisingly without blushing – Bilbo waves the concern aside. “It’s nothing a bit of food won’t fix.”
They do have a feast and the next couple of days are bliss.
***
On one of the early days, Beorn joins Bilbo as he meanders through the gardens. Around them, wildflowers bloom in dozens of colors, at least three times as large as Bilbo has ever seen. Some petals are as large as his hand.
Bees hum and birds chirp, but leave the visitors alone.
“It has been long since I have heard of the Shire,” Beorn comments.
Bilbo laughs. “Most people don’t ever hear of it. In fact, I don’t believe the dwarves were even conscious of the place before they passed through.”
“And you just joined them?” Beorn asks.
“Gandalf had a hand in it,” Bilbo admits, and then he softens, “But I’m glad I did. I didn’t understand it then, and I think I’m only beginning to understand it now – what a home actually means.”
Beorn looks at him contemplatively. It might be the light, but Bilbo also thinks he looks sad, though he has no idea why.
“So this is your resolution, then?” Beorn asks, “Will you see that quest through, even though it is not your own home?”
Bilbo smiles. It’s a bit lopsided, because he knows that his reasoning is not entirely straight, and most other hobbits would run screaming. But in his heart he feels that this is right.
“Quite so.”
***
Beorn is truly sad to see them go. If he hugs Bilbo longer than the others, well, nobody sees it fit to comment. Nor does the parting glare Beorn directs at Gandalf make much sense, but the company is well-rested and anxious to be on their way.
Their bellies are filled, though to his own surprise Bilbo has remained on the lean side. Still, it’s easy going until they reach Mirkwood, and when the dwarves begin to complain of hunger, Bilbo has to admit that the impenetrable darkness of the forest disturbs him more.
Also, that odd, hollow feeling returns in force. Bilbo’s gut informs him that something is wrong, terribly wrong, but he can’t put a finger on it. And he won’t bother the others, because the forest is already bad enough. Perhaps this and hunger are causing his own paranoia.
***
Realization comes late and dramatically.
One day when sneaking through Thranduil’s dungeons he slips. He is not fast enough, fails to duck away in time – and even if the elves can’t see him, their ears are sharp, and their blades strike true.
“I’ve got it!” one of the elvish guards exclaims, as a soft gasp falls from Bilbo’s lips. The dwarves roar from their prison, but all Bilbo can stare at is the blade piercing through his chest. He feels wrong, strange, uncomfortable – but thankfully, there is no pain.
The elf tugs at the blade, there’s a scream of “Bilbo!”, and the hobbit stumbles backwards. The blade slides smoothly from his chest, and he falls to his knees.
“Where is it?” the other elf asks, “It fell off!”
“Can’t have gotten far, though,” the guard comments, looking at the reddish liquid coating the blade.
Bilbo feels dizzy, pressing a hand to his chest where he knows the cut is. When elvish hands blindly reach out for him, he manages to scramble away on unsteady feet.
He keeps going until he finds the first quiet corner. With a sigh, Bilbo sinks down, thinking that this will be the end. This is where he will die – alone in a strange place with no friends at his side. With dread coiling in his stomach, he removes his hand from the injury.
And finds only very little blood coating it.
But the sword stabbed deeply. It went right through his body. So how…
And suddenly it all makes sense. How Gollum, the spiders and the elves could not see him. The strange looks Beorn gave him. The hollow feeling, how he did not gain weight, how his injuries don’t bleed and how his chest is cold and still.
Why Beorn asked him if restoring their home to the dwarves was his desire.
He must have known.
Bilbo does not know what he feels, but it is gut-wrenching. The stab wound will not kill him – because he is already dead. Has been for a while. Which is why the animals avoided him, why Beorn first saw him as a wraith – a dead body, moving and talking, and Bilbo never realized.
Even though he does know the legends.
***
Being dead does not make drowning any more comfortable. Bilbo coughs and sputters when the dwarves drag him to the shore, his lungs ache fiercely, and the trip to Laketown is a blur. He feels weak then, and is content to let the dwarves fuss over him.
The stay at Laketown also gives him a chance to gather his thoughts.
Dead things can’t linger forever, unless they are wraiths, tied to something with black magic. He is glad that he does not turn invisible to the dwarves, either. And the men of Laketown do not recognize him for what he is.
Oin, however, is rather concerned about an old head-injury he discovers underneath Bilbo’s curls. It does not bleed, but neither does it seem to be healing. And because he only sees the cut the blade left on Bilbo’s chest – and not also the exit wound on his back – he assumes that it was shallow.
Bilbo wonders if he should tell them.
Now, with the Lonely Mountain so close, he can feel himself fading. He does not dare turn invisible, for he may not be able to undo it any longer.
But his quest is not yet fulfilled, and he will see it done.
In the meantime, though, he pens letters to the Shire. He will not return to Bag End, and the thought causes his heart to ache. Along the oversized furniture of men, he misses his home more than ever.
When they leave, Bilbo stands for a long time, looking back. The lake glitters enticingly and even the borders of Mirkwood shine in rich shades of green. Beyond tower the snow-capped peaks of the Misty Mountains, and somewhere beyond them lie the Shire’s rolling hills.
“Don’t look so glum, Master Hobbit,” Gloin tells him cheerfully, “Perhaps the beast has perished, already.”
Bilbo musters a weak smile. The dragon does not particularly scare him, now.
“And then you’ll be home to your garden and armchair, sooner than you expect,” Gloin adds.
No, I won’t, Bilbo thinks.
“But of course you’re welcome to stay for a while,” Fili chirps in, and Kili adds, “Actually, we hope you’ll stay for a bit.”
It is hard to regret his decision to come when thirteen dwarves cheerfully invite him to stay. It may have cost him his life, but he feels warmer inside than he has for a long, long time.
***
Miscalculation has Bilbo staring up – petrified – into the glowing, golden eyes of Smaug. “What, then,” the dragon hisses, and the steam from his nostrils is hot, “are you?”
“I am riddle-winner, barrel-rider. I am the lucky number,” Bilbo says calmly, though his knees are weak, “I am the one you cannot kill for I am already dead.”
Smaug roars. “But I can destroy your body, foul creature. I can rip off your legs, I can tear apart your body, and I can burn you until nothing remains.”
“You can,” Bilbo replies, his voice even though he is terrified, “But you need to find me first.”
And with that he lets his body disappear from view.
The fading feels more complete than before, and Bilbo fears the moment he cannot undo this state. But he must endure – for now – and move as quickly and lightly as possible. Smaug strikes with his claws and his tails, spits fire and roars so that the mounds of gold shift and tumble.
He’s almost back to the passage when Smaug’s furor dies down.
“I do smell them, dead one,” the dragon states and sounds – all of a sudden- horrifyingly calm about it, “You have no smell, wraith that you are, but I smell the dwarves. On you, and, I think, from that corner, too. They must be waiting outside – for their very own wraith to return.”
Bilbo freezes.
“Tell me, dead one, did they recall you from your eternal sleep? Did they wake you so you could do their bidding?” Smaug continues, and his voice cuts straight through Bilbo’s being, “Because it is certainly lucky to have one among your company that is already dead.”
Bilbo knows better than to rise to the taunt. Yet he can’t help himself. “It is a far older magic that has brought me here, o Smaug the terrible,” he says, “A magic that, as you fail to understand it, works to your end.”
“Then we shall see, dead one,” Smaug hisses, “Whether your ancient magic will also bring back your dwarves.”
***
The dwarves survive. Most of Laketown’s inhabitants and a number of particularly unlucky elves do not.
Neither does Smaug, but as the fires of Laketown brighten the night sky Bilbo wonders at the price. In Erebor’s treasury, the dwarves rejoice – Bilbo feels distanced, unlike them. A part of it looks at the distant catastrophe of Laketown and thinks that this cannot be called victory.
Another part waits for the magic to fade out.
The mountain has been reclaimed. His contract fulfilled – he may not be happy, but the company is alive and home (even though it does not feel like it), and he waits for a sudden blow of pain, or oblivion to abruptly swallow him.
Nothing does happen. He continues to feel hollow and exhausted, but death does not come for him.
Instead, Bofur finds him. “’tis not a night to sit out here on your own and be glum,” Bofur tells him, “Come in, there are some old wine barrels that survived the dragon.”
***
Morning brings the revelation that the mountain is not truly won. Bard tries to reason, and Thranduil glares coldly. Thorin is deaf to both.
The glint of obsession lightening his eyes turns Bilbo’s stomach.
His part in this, he realizes with a heavy heart, is not yet over. And when, hours later, he finds the Arkenstone, he wonders at the designs fate has upon him.
All he wanted was to see his dwarves restored to their home, hale and happy. Their home he may have returned to them, but currently they are not hale. And neither will they be happy once he has played this final part.
Bilbo wishes he could at least be angry at Gandalf. For bringing him out on an adventure that first took his life and will now see him depart from this world cut off from everybody he ever called a friend. But he can’t – not when does not regret running out of his door, does not regret a moment spend among the company.
Not when this quest means enough for him to invoke that ancient hobbitish magic that now is straining to let him see the quest’s fulfillment.
***
The elves seem to sense something off about him. Bilbo feels the suspicious glances cast his way, senses their hostility. He won't blame them for thinking him a wraith for now, pale and thin and grieved, he must look the part.
Bard greets him like an old friend, which is a small blessing. Thranduil remains seated, though his hand closes around a dagger under his robe.
"Who is that?" he inquires and nods towards Bilbo.
Bard raises an eyebrow. "That is Master Baggins, a hobbit in the employ of Thorin Oakenshield's company."
"There was no hobbit when they passed through my lands," Thranduil replies sharply, and Bilbo makes certain not to move. Lest Thranduil try and stab him - who knows if not an ancient elvish blade may undo those last strands of magic that hold him together.
Bilbo clears his throat. "I was there, even though you did not see me."
Thranduil remains tense. "I have never heard hobbits could do that."
Bilbo swallows. "No, that is something only I can do."
Thranduil wants to ask something else, but the flap of their tent is drawn back and Gandalf enters.
"Bilbo," he exclaims, "Not that I am not glad to see you, but what are you doing here?"
And with a heavy heart the hobbit suggests the bargain.
Not that it needs much convincing. Bard sees reason quickly, and Thranduil follows soon. But when Bilbo rises up to return to the mountain, both leaders protest.
"You'll be safer here," Bard says, "Thorin will not like the deal. I would not see any harm come to you."
Bilbo smiles weakly. "I doubt I will come to harm," he replies - Thorin cannot kill one who is already dead.
Thranduil purses his lips. "Perhaps not in body, but in mind. I, too, would counsel you to remain here."
Both Bard and Gandalf look curious. Bilbo shrugs uneasily. "I would rather see this through."
Understanding dawns in Thranduil's eyes. "This is your purpose, then?"
Bilbo nods. And abruptly, Gandalf's eyes widen and he steps forward, grasping Bilbo by the shoulders. "Bilbo!"
The wizard's eyes search his, pleading for that dark suspicion to be untrue. Bilbo shakes his head in response and brushes aside the hair.
Underneath the wound remains raw, open and bloodless.
Gandalf sucks in a shape breath. "When?"
"The caverns under the Misty Mountains," Bilbo replies, "Though I did not realize it until we were deep into Mirkwood."
Nobody needs to know that it took an elvish blade stuck through his chest for him to realize.
Gandalf holds him tighter. "I'm so sorry," the wizard whispers, voice choked, "I'm sorry."
"Excuse me," Bard interrupts, "But I don't understand what is going on here."
Thranduil straightens, while Gandalf makes no move to let Bilbo go. "A long time ago I heard a rumor. Or rather a myth, perhaps," Thranduil tells, "Of a people from the distant west that may linger after death to see a duty fulfilled, a wish realized or their affairs settled. It was no dark magic allowing it, no evil power raising wraiths - but a favor granted to those that lived ever in peace and died with a kindness in their hearts."
Bard blinks. The picture is clearly coming together in his mind - but he does not seem to believe it yet.
"I thought it just a myth until today," Thranduil finishes, "But apparently it is not."
Bilbo clears his throat. "It is awfully rare, though."
"Are you saying, Master Baggins, that you are...." Bard pales.
"I am dead, Master Bowman," Bilbo replies evenly. He has gotten used to the idea, has made his peace, while his companions struggle.
"Then how...?"
"As King Thranduil has said, a bit of ancient magic allows some of us to linger until we have completed our business. At least, as long as the body remains hale," Bilbo explains. He recalls Smaug’s threats all too clearly.
"And your ... Wish was to reclaim Erebor?" Bard inquires.
There is an unspoken "why then do you still linger now that the dragon is dead" in the air. Bilbo purses his lips. "My wish was to help the dwarves reclaim their home. While I have to admit I do not understand this magic, I believe my wish will only be fulfilled once Thorin is legitimately crowned king under the mountain."
"Then if he is not?" Bard asks.
"Then at some point the magic would fade," Bilbo answers, "In fact it already is."
Bard looks pained, and Gandalf's fingers tighten around Bilbo's shoulders. The bowman turns to Thranduil. "Is there any way to undo this? Would perhaps one of your kin from Lothlorien or Rivendell know? I would send our fastest rider..."
Thranduil shakes his head. And Bilbo reaches out - if he was taller he would have given Bard a pat on the shoulder - as it is, he barely reaches upper arm.
"There is no undoing this," Bilbo gently tells him, "I am already dead, and all I wish is to use this chance as I am supposed to - by seeing Erebor reclaimed."
"Then I will help you in whichever way I can," Bard vows.
***
When Thorin's hands close around Bilbo's throat, his heart is what hurts the fiercest. Thorin shakes him, dangling his body over the wall, roaring in rage.
"Then do so," Bilbo wants to tell him, "Throw me down."
Perhaps it will break his body so that it mirrors his shattered heart.
Gandalf's intervention saves him. The wizard looks worried, and if Bilbo did not know better, he would have thought to have seen an instance of panic on his face. Yet once his feet touch the ground, Gandalf is collected as he enfolds the hobbit in his arms and spirits him away.
"Will you be alright?" Gandalf asks, quietly so that Bard who rides nearby won't overhear.
"I think so," Bilbo replies, "It's not been fulfilled yet."
The dwarves may sit in their home, but it is not yet completely theirs. Bilbo does not know why, though the magic holds. He does not know if he should be grateful for it - because had the magic faded earlier, he would not have experienced this.
Then again, if not for that desperate trade Thorin and his company might now be slaughtered by the joined forces of Laketown and the Greenwood.
***
Bilbo is sitting with Thranduil, Bard and Gandalf – all oddly concerned for his well-being –, when the messenger arrives. An army of orcs and goblins, he announces, they will be there by nightfall. Thranduil nods, coolly, and gives orders to prepare. Bard seems not as calm – how shall they deal with this new foe? – but he imitates the elves. Gandalf purses his lips and speaks about sending a messenger to Dain. Regardless of the sorry state of their negotiations, the King of the Iron Hills needs to know of the approaching danger.
Bilbo shivers. So this is the result of his desperate actions? Should it all mean nothing in the end? His heartache, the pain and this chance granted to him? Will it all fall apart before an army of dark creatures? His heart, once again, fiercely aches for his home. The safety, the simplicity – all the things he will never regain. And he hangs his head, feeling utterly defeated.
Bard shrugs off his coat and wraps it around Bilbo’s shoulders. “Do not worry so, Master Hobbit. If not for you, many of us would lie dead already.”
Bilbo forces a bleak imitation of a smile on his face. “But there are so many…”
Thranduil shakes his head. “They may be many, but that does not make them skilled warriors.”
“And there is a far better chance of victory when fighting united,” Gandalf adds.
Their cheerful words do not lighten Bilbo’s mood. Instead his gaze falls to his own blade – he heard the news, he knows how many orcs there are. They will need every blade to win.
Bard’s hands tighten on his shoulders. “You need not fight in this battle,” he tells Bilbo, “You have already done more than enough.”
He means it, too, Bilbo can tell. Not one of those present in this tent will begrudge him should he choose to turn and flee. And yet he is the only one present who needs not fear death. So he nods at Bard, casts a baleful smile at Thranduil and Gandalf and rises to his feet. The magic holding him here is weakening, he has felt it since Smaug died. But while he still is here, he will do what he can.
***
Being dead does not make a battle any less frightening. Nor does it make the cuts he receives sting any less.
He does not whether it is due to the fading magic or his small size that he passes unseen through orcs and goblins alike. Even men rarely take notice of him, and elves always seem surprised. He does not recall when he last saw a friendly face – he’d been with Thranduil and Gandalf – and then a dark cloud of bats with razor-sharp claws had descended, and the world around had dissolved in blood, dust, screams and flashing blades.
Time has lost its meaning – all Bilbo knows that there are steadily more corpses littering the ground. Blood has turned charred earth into mud, and even he cannot avoid stepping onto torn off limbs and shattered bones. His vision is blurred, and he is glad that he is invisible, because it becomes hard to tell friend from foe.
Blood-caked, and with their faces twisted in rage and despair, the differences between men, elves, dwarves and orcs dwindle. Bilbo stumbles, dodges and twists, and feels utterly caught in a nightmare. He cannot stop long enough to gather his thoughts, and yet he seems barely there.
For a moment he wonders if this is the magic giving out.
Then he hears Azog roar in triumph, and his dead heart gives a sudden throb. He sees the mace high in the air, recognizes the form prone on the ground in front of the pale orc – and forgets having ever felt hollow or exhausted.
Determination soars and Bilbo throws himself forward, pushing his body harder than he ever has before. He grips his blade in both hands – he is too small to deliver a killing blow, and that is an honor that ought to be Thorin’s – but he can cut into the back of the orc’s knees.
And Sting sinks in deeply, cutting through veins and tendons, and Azog’s roar of triumph becomes one of pain instead. His mace falls from his hands, and around them the fighting slows down. Confusion washes over many faces –
Not Thorin’s, as he uses the moment to return to his feet, grasp Orcrist and level the blade at Azog’s throat.
When the defiler’s head hits the ground, the battle has turned. Bilbo feels elated, smiles, as he remains unseen – until he feels the cold bite of steel in his side.
The goblin looks just as confused. He tugs at the blade that is stuck deep in Bilbo’s side, and it makes an unpleasant, wet sound. Bilbo feels queasy, and stumbles. Suddenly he can’t seem to bring his own sword up, and the monster of crusted metal is sticking out of his side.
Then there’s a roar, and Dwalin smashes the goblin’s skull in.
“Burglar!” the dwarf shouts, staring in search at the empty air, “Bilbo!”
Around them the battle is fought with renewed vigor; now that victory seems close at hand. Bilbo stumbles, tries to focus, and the world blurs. Has the magic already …
Then there are hands on his shoulders, and when Bilbo looks up, Dwalin is looking at him. Not through him, but at him – the dwarf can see him, and Bilbo’s heart lurches with relief. Dwalin’s hands are strangely gentle as he guides Bilbo to lean against him; concern and terror in his eyes – and it takes a moment until Bilbo realizes that it is directed at him.
“Stay with me,” Dwalin says, his eyes studying the blade that is still stuck through Bilbo’s side with unveiled worry, “I will get you to the healers. Just try to …”
Bilbo can’t help the warmth he feels at Dwalin’s concern. Or the soft smile that spreads on his face. He rests a hand on Dwalin’s arm.
“I’m fine, master dwarf,” he answers, “Do not worry so. I’m …”
“Stay still,” Dwalin hisses, trying to keep Bilbo still without hurting him further.
“No, truly, listen,” Bilbo protests. And because there is no other way, he grasps Dwalin’s hand and moves it to his throat. Where he knows the dwarf will not feel a pulse.
“What…?” Dwalin stutters, horrified.
Bilbo closes his eyes. Sweet as Dwalin’s concern is – especially after their last parting – the truth about his condition makes this bitter.
“I am already dead, master dwarf,” Bilbo says, “I was … killed in the mountains. It is a lucky bit of magic that has allowed me to carry on – I meant to tell you, but at first I did not understand myself, and then the time was never right.”
He sighs, as Dwalin remains frozen.
“For what it is worth, I am sorry,” Bilbo says – he may be rambling, but he needs to get this off his chest, “I did not intend to deceive you. But you needn’t worry about me – this is a bit of a discomfort, but I will not suffer from it.”
So that Dwalin may return and fight for those that still live, Bilbo wants to say. Instead, he shuts his mouth and waits for the dwarf to react. See, if he fears that dead creature he is cradling in his arms.
The fingers around his shoulders first tremble minutely, then tighten. Dwalin’s eyes are large, incredulous.
Bilbo grows too nervous, so he looks away, and, absentmindedly, pulls the blade from his side. The sound makes his stomach turn again, but there is barely any blood on it, and the cut is white instead of red.
The magic is truly wearing thin.
Abruptly, thick arms wrap around him and he is crushed against Dwalin’s chest. For a moment, Bilbo is completely frozen – and then he melts into the embrace. It’s the relief he has sought for so long, the absolution he has wished for from his dwarves.
To know that they care for him. That they…
“How long?” Dwalin rasps, his face buried in Bilbo’s hair, “How long do you have?”
The hobbit swallows. “Not very long, I think,” he mumbles, “I don’t know. Until your home has successfully been reclaimed…but the magic is fading.”
The embrace tightens and under other circumstances Bilbo would have protested that his bones might break. Now, he welcomes it.
“Then stay safe,” Dwalin tells him, “Stay safe and stay here and wait until I come back!”
***
As morning dawns – pale and clear – and victory is sounded, Bilbo wonders why he still lingers. He is tired and worn, and even death cannot stop him from feeling pain. Around him, men and elves and dwarves wander the battlefield, looking for survivors.
He probably should go. Gandalf will be worried. Bard was also so concerned for him. And Dwalin…
“Bilbo!”
Dwalin has returned for him. With a faint smile Bilbo lets himself grow visible once again, and he sways on his feet from the exertion.
“You are still here, thank Mahal,” the dwarf exclaims, “Now, come with me. The others are in the mountain.”
He scoops up Bilbo when it becomes obvious that the hobbit is unsteady. Bilbo blinks, and wraps and arm around Dwalin’s neck. It is not uncomfortable, to be carried thusly. Once he might have protested being treated like a child – but now he welcomes the tender attention.
“Do the others know?” he asks when Erebor’s entrance comes closer.
Dwalin shakes his head.
“Then,” Bilbo’s heart drops, “… I am banished, still.”
“Thorin wasn’t in his right mind, and you know that,” Dwalin returns sharply, “None of us were. And I know there’s more than one dwarf in there that would like nothing better than to apologize to you.”
***
Indeed, Bilbo’s return to the mountain is better received than he would have ever dreamt it to be. Fili, with a large cut running down the side of his face, is the first to see them, and his shout of joy attracts the rest of the company. Kili lifts Bilbo out of Dwalin’s arms, twirls him around, singing “We did it! Thanks to you we won!”
Dori steps up and fusses over Bilbo’s appearance, “…and some good food,” and Bilbo can’t help but smile. Bifur musses up his hair, and Bofur draws him into another hug. Soon Bilbo aches from all the friendly pats and embraces, but his heart feels as if it could burst from happiness.
And then Thorin steps forward and sinks onto his knees. “Without your clear head and quick thinking we would never have won this. For now and forever Erebor is indebted to you, Bilbo Baggins. And if you will have my apology, it is yours.”
To Bilbo, it feels like all of his pain and heartaches are finally being rewarded. His suffering recognizes. So he can throw his arms around Thorin with a bright smile and proclaim that “I forgave you a long time ago, stubborn dwarf.”
When Thorin’s arms wrap around Bilbo’s back and hold him close, he does not think he has ever been happier. The magic, for all it put him through, was truly the greatest gift he has ever received.
“Will you step out with me?” Thorin asks, “Stand as my equal in this reclaimed kingdom?”
“Whatever you ask of me,” Bilbo replies.
***
Outside, the sun is shining, and the battlefield does not look so bleak. Tents have been erected, banners glitter. And all heads turn, as Erebor’s ancient horn resounds over the plain for the first time in many decades.
"All hail Thorin, King under the Mountain!" Dain exclaims from his place under the gate, and the wind carries his voice.
Bilbo feels something give in his chest. The magic is unraveling. His task is fulfilled. It is a warm, brilliant feeling - the burdens are gone, as are the grievances, and he can't help the quiet, surprised "oh" that falls from his lips.
"Bilbo?" Fili asks, as his knees give away. The cheer is taken up by the other dwarves soldiers, though Thorin dives forward to catch Bilbo as he falls.
The sky overhead is wide and blue and beautiful.
"No! Bilbo!" Gandalf shouts and pushes through. More soldiers take up the chant – “King under Mountain! King under the Mountain!” – it signals victory, it signals the restoration of the kingdom. The voices of men join in.
"Bilbo, what is wrong?" Thorin asks, frantic and worried, and Bilbo wants to tell him that everything is fine, but he can't find his voice. So he smiles instead. At Thorin, Fili and Kili, Dwalin and Balin and Bofur and Gandalf and hopes his smile tells them how happy he is and has been to share this adventure with them.
How grateful he is to have seen it come to a successful conclusion. How warm it has made his heart to have gained their friendship – to be here with them, today, after all they have been through together. How glad he is that they are with him right now.
And then he lets himself sink into that beckoning, peaceful oblivion.
***
Thorin stares at the unmoving body in shock. In front of the wall, the crowds are cheering on him, while he holds the cold hand of his burglar. The small body is not moving, not even breathing, and -
"What's wrong with him?" Kili shouts, looking from Gandalf to Oin. He does not want to believe, while his older brother is already pale. Oin opens his mouth to speak, but Gandalf shakes his head.
"I will explain later," he tells them, "The people are waiting for you, King Thorin."
And like in a dream Thorin rises, his head straight and faces the cheering troops. It is a beautiful day, with the air crisp and fresh and full of promises. Even the clear blue sky speaks of new beginnings and good fortune.
***
When Thorin stumbles inside - the cheers still ringing in his ears, and followed by his just as distraught nephews - he finds his company solemn around a stone slab. On top of it, bedded on bedrolls and coats, is their burglar. Even from the distance, Thorin recognizes the pallor and the lack of motion for what it is.
"Bilbo!" Kili exclaims, "What happened to him?"
He stumbles forward, followed more sedately by Fili. Oin shakes his head, as does Gandalf.
"Why? How..." Kili trembles, "He was just with us, out there, and not..."
Gandalf straightens up. "It is a longer story, so please let us sit."
Thorin gestures for his nephews to follow, but he will stand vigil over the still body. No matter how often he meets with death, the experience is always surreal. Only moments ago he had talked to Bilbo, and though the hobbit had been pale and exhausted, there had been no clue...
"Hobbits," Gandalf begins, "are remarkable in many aspects. They do not deal in magic, but a kind of it is granted some from time to time. If granted then it allows the hobbit in question to linger on after death and see his affairs settled or a wish fulfilled."
There is a moment of utter silence.
Then the group starts to shout. "Are you saying he was...?" Gloin roars, while Fili sputters in disbelief. Bofur pulls his hat down, and Bifur mutters in angry Khuzdul. "No, but that would mean..." Ori whispers, while Oin says "he was always so cold and pale..."
And Thorin has to accept the unthinkable. Sometime on his quest Bilbo Baggins died, and none of them noticed.
"When, Gandalf?" Balin asks, his voice choked, "When did he..."
The wizard brushes the copper locks aside and reveals a familiar wound. It is as raw and gaping as it was when Thorin first saw it in Laketown.
"The elves?" Gloin explodes.
"No. It happened in the tunnels under the Misty Mountains, or so Bilbo told me," Gandalf explains, "Though he never said how it happened."
"I wish we had known earlier," Fili mutters, “I wish we had … could have…”
His voice cracks, and he buries his face in his hands instead of completing the sentence. The many what-ifs, all the unfulfilled hopes and wishes now hang heavily over their heads. Promises to show Bilbo the beauty of the mountain, hopes to make him feel at home here – now they will never come true.
Gandalf sighs heavily, as he looks over the company. Most faces display shock – there are tears streaming down Ori’s face already, and Kili’s eyes are red-rimmed as he worries his lower lip. Thorin is white, his face a mask of disbelief. Behind him, Balin shakes his head sadly. Dwalin stands silently, and looks a bit contemplative.
“I knew,” Dwalin says, breaking the suffocating silence.
Even Gandalf stares at him in surprise.
“I found out during battle,” he tells the company, and if the grief is plain in his voice, it is of no consequence, “After he injured Azog I saw a blade pierce thin air and recalled our hobbit’s odd skill. Went after him and had an awful fright then. But he told me it didn’t matter, that it was only some ancient magic that made him linger.”
“Until the quest has been fulfilled or failed, or the body is destroyed,” Gandalf adds.
“Why didn’t you tell us?” Dori asks, sharply.
Dwalin sighs. “There was no time.”
“That is why you were so frantic to find him once the battle was over,” Ori concludes, and wipes at his eyes, “Because the magic…”
“Aye,” Dwalin says and closes his eyes, “Should the magic fade I did not want him to be alone.”
His words summon the bleak scenario of the magic giving out earlier. To have Bilbo die on the battlefield; alone, friendless and so far from home. With Thorin’s stark accusations echoing in the air.
“I am glad you brought him to me,” Thorin says after a moment, and swallows thickly, “Thank you – I dare not imagine not having had an opportunity to take back my words and apologize for my deeds.”
The guilt would have devoured him. Regained kingdom or not, none of them would have known happiness knowing the price one of their own paid for it. Even now it is a bitter fate to accept. To know Bilbo died for their home; suffered and died for a group that barely welcomed him at first and was quick to cast him out at the end.
With a choked noise Kili stumbles out of his seat. For a moment he seems to collapse on Bilbo’s chest – then he enfolds the hobbit’s small body in his arms and slides to the floor, Bilbo clutched tightly to his own chest.
“Is… isn’t there any kind of magic….?” He stammers, gazing up at Gandalf.
The wizard stares at the scene with a heavy heart. He cannot deny his responsibility in this – had he not deemed Bilbo the right one for this, the hobbit would still be alive and happy in Bag End, and not cold and dead in a dwarf’s arms.
“There is none,” he replies, even as he internally continues to apologize to Bilbo and Belladonna, “No magic can bring back the dead.”
Kili sobs and curls tighter around Bilbo’s body.
“I really wish we had had more time with him,” Balin says, quietly, “Especially after those last days – those cannot have been easy on him.”
“They have not,” Gandalf confirms, recalling Bilbo’s pale face as even Thranduil looked on with concern, “But I think in the end, he was happy.”
He may not have been present for the reconciliation, but he had seen the smile on Bilbo’s face when he had stepped outside next to Thorin. Small, yet utterly content – and so painfully resembling the expressions Gandalf recalled from a young hobbit’s face that he had already understood what was bound to occur.
“He saw his wish fulfilled,” Gandalf adds, softly, “Your homeland reclaimed, the battle won and everybody reconciled.”
***
Bilbo’s funeral is a solemn, yet strangely grand occasion. In an attempt to imitate hobbit customs – customs that nobody truly knows – they attempt to replace gems with flowers and stone with soil. And where no real greenery will bloom, emeralds are shaped into imitations.
It is also the first occasion Bard, Thranduil and Thorin stand united.
Bilbo would have liked it, Gandalf thinks, and then sees about getting Thorin’s letter delivered to the Shire.
***
It takes month, but eventually a reply arrives. With shaking hands, Thorin unfolds the parchment, throat dry, and then reads the reply the Thain has sent.
I will not lie to you: it grieves me terribly to hear my grandson has died so far from here, and I do not deny a desire to rage at you for not taking better care. Yet I do also understand that the wilderness is a dangerous place and that accidents do happen. Therefore I shall take comfort in your words that you do grief his loss as I do.
Also I have to admit to a certain curiosity. It is perhaps a fault of us hobbits, but as we have little dealings with the outside world, your tale at times seems strange to me. Time permitting, might I receive an account – so I can learn what my grandson did die for.
I have to admit the honors he has been bestowed upon do sound strange to us – statues and portraits to commemorate the dead are unfamiliar to us hobbits, though I have heard of this practices from men. It does give me pleasure to know you treasured Bilbo so, and knowing him, I believe he may have felt rather smug about having an actual library to his name.
That said, while I appreciate your offer to restoring Bilbo to his homeland, I would decline. It is a long distance and we hobbits are rather practical with our funeral rites. We do care for the deceased to be buried close to those he cherishes and that cherish him. And while Bilbo was certainly cherished in the Shire, I do believe he holds that same place in your hearts. In the end to us hobbits home usually is the place where our loved ones are.
Fin
