Actions

Work Header

Episodes from Middle Earth

Chapter 15: All must die

Summary:

Half of the company dies in the Thunder Battle, and the other half must deal with it and continue.

Notes:

Written for the kinkmeme: http://hobbit-kink.livejournal.com/8973.html?thread=19167501

Warnings: Blood, gore, angst, character death (everybody is dead in the end).
AN: The response to this little one shots is amazing - thank you all so much! (And feel free to point out mistakes. I'm no native speaker, so mistakes are not always typos).

Chapter Text

“Take my hand, take my hand! FILIIII!” the scream escapes, even as Kili watches his brother being torn away. Thunder drowns out his voice, rain beats into his face and the wind whips soaked strands of his hair into his face while he stares with wide eyes at now empty air.

The giant has moved, and he can’t even see his brother anymore.

And this has to be a nightmare –

“Kili!” Thorin shouts, and belatedly he stumbles backwards, not even paying attention to the narrow path behind him.  A firm hand grabs hold of his arm and drags him backwards, just in time to escape a new avalanche raining down from above.

Somebody’s shouting, but all he hears is the desperate pounding of his heart. This can’t be happening, he thinks, he’ll wake up and Fili will right beside him, and then they will –

“Move!” Balin shouts and he is pulled along, barely managing to put one foot in front of the other.

An explosion of rock sounds from above and Kili twists around – and sees only the dark gargantuan shapes of the giants battling. It doesn’t feel as if it could be happening, and he can’t see his brother or any of the others, and there’s water in his eyes and his vision blurs.

It’s a miracle he doesn’t slip. Bifur drags him further, always forward over the ledge, and there are three giants and they’re missing half of their company, and Kili is practically deaf –

And then one of the giants begins to fall. It’s close, too close, and Thorin halts them, but not only because it’s close but also because Kili sees those six figures, desperately clinging onto the giant’s knee, yet helpless to stop gravity.

If he screams, the sound is lost in the roar around him.

***

The moment the ground stops shaking, Thorin pushes forward. Stone crumbles under his feet, the wind keeps howling and threatens to throw him off the mountain, but Thorin doesn’t even pay attention to the forces of nature raging around him.

His heart has practically stopped, and he does not dare to breathe before he knows.

Knows what has become of his company.

His friends.

His nephew.

He knows the dwarves behind him share his fears, but he can’t look back now. For a moment, he cannot be their leader – first, he must know. 

So he stumbles around the corner, shakes hair out of his face – and then stops abruptly.

The world falls silent.

Before him is a niche, really, and it would be a blessing otherwise. However, this niche is covered in loose stone, water, and the unmistakable shapes of still and silent bodies. Thorin does not hear anything over the roaring of his blood.

All he knows it that these are his dwarves. And they aren’t moving.

“What is…” somebody calls from the back, and someone else is shoved into Thorin. The others don’t know yet, he thinks for a split second, then he stumbles forward and the others follow.

A soft gasp from Balin’s lips. A curse from Oin, a shout from Gloin –

“ORI! NO!” Dori pushes past them all, not caring for his own safety. Nori follows on his heels, his face white and drawn, fists clenched in his pockets. For a moment they all are frozen as Dori sinks down on the other side of a rock pile, and frantically shoves aside pieces of dust and rubble.

The body Dori draws to his chest moments later is still and pale. Only the glistening red of fresh blood covering half of his face gives him a touch of color.

The conclusion is inevitable.

Thorin turns away as Dori clutches his little brother into a fierce embrace, and Nori stands by, pale and helpless. He doesn’t dare to think beyond the obvious. Not yet.

“Fili,” Kili shouts, right next to his ear, “Fili!”

And Thorin’s heart skips a beat. He looks over the niche, trying to find his nephew – Bombur is right up front, as he isn’t moving, and he won’t (and Thorin can’t look), but he sees no blond hair. His knees are trembling, and from the corner of his eye he sees Balin drop to his knees.

He is about to turn, a terrible premonition in his gut, when Kili abruptly screams his brother’s name and jumps forward. Before Thorin can even reach his side, he has pushed aside a large boulder. It tumbles from the mountain with an earth-shattering explosion, but all Thorin focuses on is Fili’s form, half buried under more rubble, and eerily still.

Kili is at his side at once, drawing his brother into his arms without even clearing away the rubble.

There’s blood on his hair, Thorin realizes. And he is so very, very pale – too pale for one so young, one who’s barely begun living. This … this should not happen to his nephew, not to one who never had a chance to know the glory of their line, to fulfill his destiny.

This can’t …

And then he sees a momentary twitch. It’s weak, but Thorin has good eyes, and his heart abruptly stutters.

“Oin,” he calls, his voice hitching, and then stronger, “OIN! Get over here! He’s still alive!”

***

Bifur is good at blending out his surroundings. He rarely understands what others are saying, so he has learned to ignore all idle chatter.

Dori’s sobs and Kili’s screams are no idle chatter, but for now even those are silenced as he beholds the sight before him. Thorin and the others have skipped past his brothers – Dori and Nori, too, went for family of their own (poor Ori, Bifur thinks, he was so young…), and he can see Balin sit, quietly, next to a large, unmoving form.

And then his eyes are back on his own family, and Bifur has seen enough cruelty to know that what he sees is true, and that fate can be this horrendous. It is … not entirely unexpected, because there had never been much hope in their quest.

The quiet grief in his heart feels like an old friend.

Bifur sits down between Bombur and Bofur. Bombur is on his back, eyes open and staring unseeing into the dark night. A pool of blood is spreading underneath his head, sluggish, and Bifur reaches out to close his eyes. The skin is already cooling.

It must have been quick, he thinks, and it is a relief when Bifur has watched so many die in pain. He would rather it had been him – he is the one who is not quite there, who cannot communicate. But apparently, the fates have decided to spare him a little longer – whether it is to torture him, he does not know.

Bofur’s face is peaceful. Bifur, who remembers his cousin’s expressions when he was asleep, finds his lips twitch – trust Bofur to look peaceful only in death; in sleep he’d always been pulling disturbing grimaces.  Bifur can’t quite tell what killed him – there’s no pooling blood, nor is he missing parts of his body (and to Bifur that is good already) – but there is no denying that his last remaining family has passed on.

“Good for them,” Bifur thinks, and then gathers one hand of each cousin in his own.

There isn’t much he can do for them. But he will sit here and hold their hands until they have gone completely cold.

***

The world is cold and dark when Bilbo comes to. Wetness covers his face and his body is strangely numb. Icy water splatters against his face, so apparently it still is raining. He wonders how much time has passed – his memories are blurry, but the terror is still in his veins.

Underneath it all, he feels wrong. He doesn’t dare to move – for now he isn’t hurting, and that probably is a good thing. Over the howling of the wind he can hear voices and movement – it takes a moment to make sense, but then it clicks.

The dwarves – and they are calling for Oin and Fili. Bilbo wonders what happened to them, because there’s an edge of desperation to their voices. And anyhow, what happened to the others, and why are they still outside?

He tries to blink – but his eyes refuse to open.

It’s not surprising, though, considering how damaged he feels.

“…. His leg,” Oin yells over the storm. It appears to be raining less, now, though that might just be Bilbo’s impression.

“…ribs?” Thorin sounds strangely anxious.

“Might be broken,” Oin’s voice is strained, “I can’t tell like … though he may ….”

Something clatters to the ground, and Bilbo realizes that the faint, choked noise has been coming from elsewhere. It’s a voice, one he knows and…

Dori is crying. Why would he …

Bilbo’s blood runs cold. Ori was on the giant with him, clinging to Bofur and screaming for his life, like they all had. But Bilbo was alive, so Ori ought to be here too. Maybe they just hadn’t found him, maybe they’d just discovered them now …

But Dori is crying and Nori is silent and they aren’t searching for anybody.

“We need to get him out of the rain!” Oin shouts, interrupting Bilbo’s horrifying conclusion (he’s glad to abandon it. Mayhaps he’ll wake to find it all a hallucination and himself back in his armchair in the Shire).

“I’ll go and…” Kili. He sounds brittle, desperate.

“You’ll stay,” Thorin growls, his voice echoing the wind’s icy howling, “I…”

“No lads,” and that would be Balin. Who sounds terribly sad and grieved, and Bilbo feels fear spark in his chest (which is in pain and feels so, so wrong), “You stay with him. Gloin and I will go and we…”

For a moment, the rain drowns out what he says.

Bilbo thinks he may have passed out, for the voices seem more distant now, and the air feels cooler. He needs to move from here if he doesn’t want to catch his death, or at least a bad cold; needs to move now, no matter how lethargic he feels.

Yet, like his eyelids, his body refuses to obey.

***

Kili is shaking so badly he’s been banned from carrying his brother. The makeshift stretcher Oin pieced together from coats and weapons now is being held up by Gloin and Nori; Kili and Thorin walking beside it.

Fili remains still and deeply unconscious.

And Oin’s prognosis did not sound good.

Kili feels faint, disconnected. Everything around him seems to a dream, and he only wants to wake up. He hasn’t yet dared to look too close. But he has seen Dori break down, and Bifur sitting there with his back to all of them –

“Here’s a cave,” Balin, now in front, pronounces, and luckily, it is not far.

And yet it’s bitter to have been so close to safety when the unthinkable happened. Kili drops down next to his brother the moment the stretcher is set down, clutching his brother’s hand as if he could infuse some of his own energy through it.

Oin mutters next to him, peeling aside Fili’s soaked clothes and revealing a chest that is black and blue, and Thorin sucks in a sharp breath.

Kili’s heart stutters to a stop.

Is this …

And then Oin tells him and Thorin to step back and let him work. Kili, at first, fails to react, but Thorin forces him up and away, even while Kili’s eyes remain glued to his brother’s motionless body. There’s blood covering his hair and torso, and his face is too white and he doesn’t want this to be the last time, can’t dare to think –

***

The voices of his companions have disappeared.

Icy rain continues to assault his face, but he isn’t truly cold. Bilbo can tell, though, that ought to be freezing – the ground under his back is, and he thinks once night falls the rain will turn into snow. He might miss the calming patter –

His last company after the dwarves left him.

There is a deep ache in his chest that thrums with every breath he draws. The dwarves are gone, and all he has for company is cold rock and rain – and he does not think he will move from this spot ever again. His body is completely immobile – he did not even have a chance to call after the dwarves.

Strangely enough, though, he is not afraid.

He would like to know what happened to his companions. They may not have cared about him, but he remembers clinging to Bofur, Dwalin’s hand on his shoulder – and he hopes they survived and left with the others.

(Though there is a strange note in the dwarves’ voices that lets him know that not all survived. And that some came to great harm).

And perhaps they have not abandoned him – perhaps they just didn’t see him. But, Bilbo thinks with a spark of self-depreciating humor, this is not a time to start lying to himself. To Thorin Oakenshield he has ever been little more than a burden – he can understand why the dwarf chose to move on without him.

Especially since he can’t move under his own power.

So even if they left him for dead, Bilbo does not feel upset or angry. He is strangely numb, but it is no bad feeling. And rain and rocks are no bad company for his last hours – maybe preferable to a group of dwarves he never truly belonged with. 

***

“We should burn the dead,” Balin says, softly, “We cannot take their bodies, and I would not leave them here.”

He does not add anything about wild animals and plunderers, but they all know what happens to those left for dead in the wild. They have been travelling for too long, Nori thinks, and with a sharp pang realizes that his little brother now will never have a chance of living a safe, settled life.

It leaves a bitter taste in the back of his throat, and he almost wants to exclaim that he and Dori will certainly carry Ori’s body all the way to Erebor – but Nori has always been pragmatic, and Balin’s suggestion is sensible.

Dori only hugs the body closer. They’ve wiped away the blood and the dirt, and now Ori truly looks as if he was sleeping. Nori knows this, because he likes to visit at night, and he enjoys seeing Ori sleep the carefree sleep of the innocent – it makes doing what he does easier.

But that is now gone.

Forever.

Nori is familiar with death, but he has to squeeze his eyes shut to stop the tears from falling.

***

His baby brother is rather heavy, Balin admits with a huff. Or perhaps he just is not strong enough – it does not matter. In the time span Bifur has carried both his cousins to their cave, he has barely managed to take Dwalin half the way.

He could drag him by his feet – Balin recalls actually doing this an eternity ago when they both were still dwarflings and Dwalin had been annoying him – and he is certain Dwalin would be willing to forgive the indignity – but he forces himself to gather his remaining strength.

And in a way this is good. The exhaustion is a distraction – one that does not allow him to think too deeply about loss and bygone times. That after so many close calls, death has finally claimed his brother.

As much as he knows he must keep his composure, he cannot deny the sting in his eyes.

“Let me help you,” a familiar voice says behind him, and Balin is so surprised he almost drops his brother’s body. When he turns, he finds Thorin looking at him – and their king’s eyes are deeply grieved, and Balin recalls Fili’s limp body and Kili crying.

“Shouldn’t you be with your nephew?” Balin asks, softly.

Thorin purses his lips. “Oin and Kili are with him,” he sighs, “And Dwalin was my brother, too.”

Balin closes his eyes, fighting tears and memories. Both, Thorin and he, do recall those simpler times, when they played with toy swords, swore to become heroes and nobody even dreamt of dragons. Now, all those childhood dreams have further crumbled.

One more of their companions is gone, and Balin eventually nods.

Together, Thorin and he carry Dwalin’s body inside.

***

They have arranged the bodies at the far wall. Once Oin has finished working on Fili, and they all have said their goodbyes, Thorin will set fire to the cloaks that cover their dead. It is not as grand as a dwarven funeral should be, and burning is only a paltry replacement for a stone tomb, but they cannot do any better.

Should they retake Erebor Thorin vows he will erect a memorial for every dwarf that died on the quest.

And then, suddenly, there’s a commotion behind him.

He turns, just in time to see Bifur, soaked and clutching a bundle to his chest, stumble into their cave. From behind him, Balin exclaims “Bilbo!” and a sudden, hot spike of guilt races through Thorin. Until now he had completely forgotten about their burglar.

***

Oin barely looks up from his work when behind him the company breaks out into exclamations. Fili’s breath is shallow, and time is slipping away from them. His options are limited, but Oin is relatively certain that there is a rib puncturing the young prince’s lung.

Most of his ribs are broken, so it is a miracle he yet lives. Oin thinks his legs may be broken, too, but he hasn’t truly looked at them beyond making sure there were no heavily bleeding injuries. The dwarf’s chest is where this battle will be fought.

And Oin, with a frown, knows that it will be close. He needs to remove that piece of rib, preferably without disturbing the other fragments too…

“He’s alive!” Gloin shouts and Oin glances over his shoulder. Kili, too, looks up as hasty footsteps draw near, and Bifur sinks to his knees, careful not to disturb his precious bundle too much.

The hobbit’s face is ashen, his lips tinted blue. He’s been out in the cold for too long, Oin thinks – Bilbo is not even trembling anymore. Bifur mutters something in Khuzdul that is too low for Oin to catch, but his expression is unmistakable.

With a sigh, Oin looks – not long, though, for behind him Fili’s life is slowly slipping away.

Not that their burglar is any better. Even without seeing the damage, Oin can tell that he must have broken several ribs, and his left foot is so badly crushed it will need to be amputated. 

Oin swallows. “I can only treat one of them,” he tells the group, “And I can’t save either. We will need to go back to Rivendell.”

Thorin immediately inclines his head. “We will.”

Nobody says a word, but Oin can feel the tension rise. Thorin does not look at him, his gaze once again drawn to his nephew. Kili is clutching Fili’s hand tightly, his face anxious.

Balin is the one who sighs. “Treat Fili,” he says, “We will make Master Baggins comfortable.”

Thorin does not protest.

Why would he, Oin thinks to himself as he turns back to Fili on whose chest black and blue bruises blossom, why would he when he has to choose between his nephew and a stranger. When none of them would have expected a different outcome, even if the injured party had been one other dwarf.

It’s understandable, and yet it leaves a bitter taste in his mouth.

***

Without a word, Bifur tugs his own worn coat tighter around Bilbo and rises. He walks over to where Gloin has gotten a fire started and sits down, gently arranging the hobbit in his lap. In his arms he appears fragile and childlike – and Bifur thinks he should never have come.

Balin sinks down next to him.

“What a terrible night,” he mutters in Khuzdul, and when Bifur glances over, Balin seems to have aged a century.

Bifur simply nods and strokes a hand through Bilbo’s curls. They are soft, like the hobbit’s skin, and Bifur is rather reminded of another time, when he also tried his best to comfort those dying. And yet, there is a difference between seeing a warrior succumb to his wounds and seeing an innocent bystander felled by something they had no hand in.

His cousins, while not warriors, set out on this quest prepared. There was little for them to lose, and Bifur will grieve them in time. Their hobbit, though, joined them for reasons they never cared to learn, kept smiling politely even when faced with Thorin’s temper and has given up a comfortable home – only to now die among a group of dwarves that barely know him.

Dies while their healer fights to save the life of another.

Bifur presses his lips together and wonders if it wasn’t kinder if Bilbo did not wake.

However, at that moment he sees Bilbo’s lashes flutter. He doesn’t hear what Balin says – it all fades into the background din Bifur is used to ignore – and his sole focus is Bilbo’s white face, and the soft groan that comes from the hobbit’s lips.

With baited breath he waits, until, eventually, Bilbo’s eyes are open. They are not glazed – and Bifur’s heart twists. Not only will their burglar die – he will die knowing what is happening, die without a familiar face nearby.

He holds him tighter, but that is a paltry replacement for family and loved ones.

“Ba-“ Bilbo begins, eyes fixed on Balin (who is hunched over with grief), but he can’t call out before he has to cough, chest heaving in response and his entire body trembles in Bifur’s arms. It’s not a coughing fit – two soft, wet sounds – and yet it ends with a thin trickle of blood running from Bilbo’s lips.

Bifur sees Balin close his eyes as if in pain.  “Thorin!” the advisor calls out, “Thorin, come here, just for a moment!”

Bifur runs a hand through Bilbo’s curls and whispers calming words in Khuzdul into the hobbit’s ear. He hopes their tone will tell their meaning – tell Bilbo that he will not pass alone, that he is not without friends, that these dwarves appreciate him, no matter how bad they have been at showing it.

And perhaps it works, because the tremors lessen, and Bilbo glances up to catch Bifur’s eyes. The amount of trust and gratefulness is almost too much.

“I’m sorry,” Bifur mutters in Khuzdul, “It shouldn’t be you. You shouldn’t be … dying out here. We shouldn’t have brought you into this … you should be back in your home, not here. Sorry.”

Bilbo smiles in response, though he couldn’t have understood a word.

“I would apologize as well,” a new voice cuts through, and both Bilbo and Bifur glance over to see Thorin. The King under the Mountain looks pale, haggard, and there is a lot of blood over his clothes that is not his own.

“Though there is no apology for what has occurred. For what it is worth, I regret bringing you into this, Master Baggins.”

Thorin swallows, and for a moment Bifur wonders if that is all he has to say. (He could understand, since a few paces behind them Oin and Kili are fighting desperately to keep Fili alive; but he thinks Bilbo deserves more than just this apology).

Then Bilbo’s lips are moving. “… quite an adventure,” is all that is audible, and a new stream of red runs down his chin. It almost looks as if Bilbo is trying to smile (as if he was telling Thorin that all is well and forgiven, and that damning kindness is far too typical of their burglar and Bifur wants to smash something).

With a shuddering breath Thorin sinks down next to Balin, and takes hold of Bilbo’s hand. It looks like a child’s hand in comparison, small and pale, and from the way Thorin carefully rubs it, Bifur guesses that it is cold.

He himself can feel Bilbo’s heart slowing down.

“Also, I am grateful that you joined my company,” Thorin tells their small burglar, “We would not have made it past the trolls without you, and I hope you know that you … that you are beloved by all of us.”

 

That brings a true smile, shaky and bloody, to Bilbo’s lips.

Yet his eyelids are drooping, and Bifur feels the small body slump against his chest. Thorin senses it, too. He musters a gentle smile and says, “Rest now.”

And the body in his arms stills.

For a moment, they all remain frozen where they are. The body in Bifur’s arms is warm, even though now Bilbo’s eyes are closed and his chest is not rising anymore. Thorin bows his head, and Balin, eventually, sighs.

“He is gone,” he says, and with a nod Thorin carefully lets go of Bilbo’s hand. It’s a caring gesture – the kind they hadn’t bestowed upon their burglar before it was too late.

But there is no time for recriminations.

“Thorin,” Oin calls through the cave, “I need you here.”

***

Kili understands, somewhere in the back of his mind, that their burglar is gone. And he knows he should cry, will cry and mourn when there is time – but for now his eyes are fixed on his brother’s trembling form, and all he can think of is that Fili is they only one of that small group that still lives.

And somehow this scares him more than anything.

Oin is calm and methodical, washing his and Kili’s hands in alcohol, cleaning the blood and grime of Fili’s chest – which is bruises and uneven, and Oin will only say that he can’t be certain of anything right now.

“Hold his head,” Oin tells Kili, and then shouts for Thorin.

With shaking fingers Kili brushes wet strands of hair from Fili’s face. There are cuts on his cheek and forehead, and a large open wound over his ear, blood dripping from both his nose and his mouth, and his expression is twisted, his breath hitching, and Kili wishes he wasn’t in pain.

“Sit on his legs,” Oin tells Thorin, “You two need to make sure he doesn’t move. Not at all.”

The selection of sharp knifes of all sizes lying on the floor next to Oin emphasizes his words. Kili only nods and his fingers dig deeper into Fili’s shoulders. He hopes his brother will forgive finger-shaped bruises (prays he will be alive to be angry at them).

Kili does not dare to look at Oin, because their healer is pale, grim and determined. But it is not the relaxed expression with which Oin sets broken bones or treats colds – this speaks of risks Kili does not want to think about.

Instead he focuses on Fili’s face, even when from the corner of his eye he sees Oin level one of his knifes with a swollen bruise on Fili’s ribcage. The healer’s hands are steady, and Kili prays that all will be well, that all will –

The moment Oin cuts into Fili’s chest, a spray of blood explodes outward, and Fili twitches violently. Kili barely manages to stop him from moving, and he hears Oin curse, and suddenly his palms are sweaty and slippery, and he just wants this to not be happening.

Oin’s movements speed up, and he makes another cut. This one, too, bleeds heavily, but there’s no spray to drench them. Kili does not want to think about what Oin’s actions mean, wishes he wasn’t seeing it from the corner of his eye.

He wishes even more so, when Oin pulls back and inclines his head.

“Oin?” Thorin asks, voice atypically soft.

Their healer sighs. “I’m sorry,” he says, and Kili’s heart stops.

“I thought only one side of his lung was damaged,” Oin says, “But it’s the other side that’s damaged; this side is destroyed. Among a number of major blood vessels…. I’m sorry.”

In disbelief, Kili stares down at his brother’s face. Fili’s expression is – tense, as if in discomfort, and much, much too pale. The blood running from his nose is dark – and Kili recalls hearing that this was no good sign.

When he glances up – perhaps the world will tell him he is having a waking nightmare – it is to see Oin cover the long, now only sluggishly bleeding cut on Fili’s chest with one of their remaining blankets.

“What are you doing?” escapes his mouth, and if his voice is squeaky and panicked, he does not care.

“I can’t do anymore,” Oin replies, “I’m sorry.”

***

The night grows silent. Kili and Thorin take up vigil at Fili’s side, wiping his brow and speaking to him, kind words in gentle voices. Slowly, Fili’s expression relaxes, grows calm and peaceful, until eventually he, too, stops breathing.

Kili is too exhausted to cry out loud, so he huddles into a corner, sobbing silently. Thorin rests a hand on his remaining nephew’s shoulder – the pain, he knows, has not yet set in. The true grief Is yet to come – and then stands and solemnly carries Fili’s body over to the others.

The rest of the company rises.

They are all exhausted, bruised and shell-shocked. Thorin sees tearstains on many faces, and then turns to gaze at the six still bodies laid out against the wall. This is not how he envisioned his quest to go – it is a risk he was aware of, but he had not expected the tides to turn so fast.

Wasn’t it just mere hours ago that they were all grumbling on that steep path up the mountainside? That Ori had commented on the weather, and Dwalin told them that shelter would be difficult to find.

Now Ori lies in the center, wrapped in his brothers’ cloaks. He looks even younger in death, and Thorin wonders if he had not made a mistake allowing him to come.

Bifur, too, has covered his brother’s bodies with their own cloaks and cleaned their faces. It also hides the worst injuries – like this, Thorin thinks, they might be asleep. Only, he knows that Bombur snored loudly and Bofur was prone to sudden movements.

Thorin also notes that their hair ornaments are gone. It is a practical decision; he has to admit, one that he is more familiar with than he wants to be. Nobility is supposed to be buried with treasures, but in the wild, treasure only attracts thieves that care little for the honor of the dead.

Or, as Oin had put it when he had pressed Fili’s hair beads into Thorin’s hand, “Something to remember the lad by. Give them to his brother when the time comes.”

And that is no comfort, not when his nephew should have been buried in a stone tomb with all the comforts owed to one of Durin’s blood. But Thorin cannot grant this, as much as he cannot give any other of these dwarves the funeral they deserve.

Or give comfort to the living.

He knows he will have to watch Kili, knows that he cannot allow himself to grieve as long as his nephew looks ready to fall apart. At least Dori and Nori have each other, but his old friend Balin is left all alone (and he has lost all his family in such tragic ways, Thorin wonders how he is still standing. And Thorin cannot yet think about what he lost with Dwalin).

Bifur stands alone, too, even more so than before. Now it is not only the language that sets him apart, but there is no family to help him out either. And somebody ought to mourn their burglar – who looks very fragile in death, a lone hobbit among dwarves.

None of them deserved to die here.

But there is nothing Thorin can do.

***

Burning the dead is only an emergency option. And yet Balin has seen more funeral pyres than he has seen entombments. It is the curse of their people, he thinks, but he finds that he does not mind it that much anymore.

At least ash cannot be desecrated the way orcs sometimes do with the bodies of the fallen.

And there is a small notion of peace when Gloin starts to hum one of their old songs – one of grief and glory, one that has been chanted at the funeral of many a fallen warrior or king. The words do not mean much tonight, but the melody carries over the flickering flames.

It ties them into a broader scope, includes those that fell tonight into the long years of struggle they have gone through. Gives meaning to those sudden, abrupt deaths, and will even encompass one small hobbit into the history of Durin’s people.

Or perhaps, Balin thinks, that is what he wants to believe. But even if he is deluding himself, he knows that this is the kind of delusion they will all need in order to go on.

***

Oin sinks down next to Thorin. The sun is beginning to peak over the horizon, the sky clear after last night’s storm. Few have slept this night, and if, only due to exhaustion.

Thorin has not – he has kept watch over the fire, even long after the pyre has burned out, and smoldering ashes were all that remained. He thinks of his nephews – one sleeping restlessly, and the other gone forever – of old friends now lost or further burdened, and young lives snuffed out too early.

Of those he barely knew, and strangers willing to lend a hand. And a decision he is not certain was correct.

“I couldn’t have saved them,” Oin says without prompting, “It was unlikely, really, to save either of them, but we did try our best.”

“And yet I had to make a choice,” Thorin mutters, head bowed.

Oin sighs. “You did, we all did. There wasn’t much anybody could have done – even if we’d made another decision, we’d still have lost them both.”

And that is what Oin knows with growing certainty. “Rivendell is too far. We would have never made it in time,” Oin continues, “Master Baggins … you saw his leg. I would have had to amputate before, and I don’t think he’d have survived that.”

Thorin falls silent, while Oin remembers the ashen face of their hobbit as Bifur held him tightly. Back then he had already lost too much blood, Oin thinks now; treating his ribs would have killed him as certainly as taking off that leg would have. And that was not even considering the pneumonia Bilbo would have suffered after.

Even the healers at Rivendell, Oin thinks, would have been hard pressed to save the hobbit.

“It was the right choice,” Oin tells Thorin who still looks so haunted, “Master Baggins was comfortable. There was a better chance of saving Fili…”

Or at least, it had seemed so. Oin can’t help grimace when he recalls what he found upon opening the young dwarf’s chest. There had been no chance of saving him; not with his ribcage pulverized, his right lung gone and blood filling up the other.

Thorin clenches his fists. Oin is more than familiar with that terrible sensation of grief and helplessness, and knows that he has said what he could. Words can only do so much – he hopes, they will at least assuage whatever guilt Thorin feels (even if they can never assuage the guilt they all share for not having been better friends to their smallest companion).

“I’m sorry,” Oin says, and then he rises and leaves.

A few moments later, Balin approaches. The morning light does little to hide his ill pallor, and for a moment Thorin fears that the grief will tear even more companions from his side.

However, Balin has seen as much death as Thorin has, and even now does not falter. “We need to get going,” he says, “This place --- is not safe.”

***

There is a short discussion on whether or not they ought to return to Rivendell, but nobody liked the elves there beyond the safety they offered, and the notion of sharing their grief with them is too much. They will all rather brave the unknown – as far as their feet will carry them.

Not a few, Thorin knows, would not mind a premature end to their own lives, now.

Then they need to redistribute their packs. Dori takes the food Bombur was carrying, while Nori picks up Ori’s book and a bundle of other possession that, Thorin is certain, belonged to the youngest brother, too.

Kili has Fili’s swords – Thorin knows because he saw him take those before he turned away. Going through the things of the departed to choose what to keep and what to discard had been another terrible hour last night. He has Fili’s hair beads and a small dagger – he hopes Dis will be willing to share more mementos should they ever be reunited (and she willing to ever forgive him, unlikely as it seems).

Bifur looks to be weighted down, carrying not only his own pack, but also three bundles of mementos. Gloin and Oin step in quickly, and even though Bifur is unwilling to let go, he lets Gloin take the cloth bag that belonged to Bombur and Oin the bundle that was Bilbo’s possessions.

And so, with a heavy heart, Thorin leads on.

***

Ironically, the next two days they have beautiful weather and ideal conditions. The path is dry and they do not encounter anything hostile – no orcs, no goblins, and no stone giants.

It’s as if fate was laughing at their pain.

On the third evening Gandalf catches up with them. The wizard looks to be in good cheer, though a bit miffed.

“Thorin Oakenshield,” he thunders, “Did I not tell you to wait …”

And that is when Gandalf catches on. The dwarves have all been watching him with strangely bland expression, and while Thorin might glare, there is no fire in his eyes. Kili has not moved at all, sitting lifelessly against a tree, and Gandalf realizes he cannot see Fili anywhere.

Nor does he see Dwalin, whose bulky form ought to be hard to miss.

Half the company is gone.

“What happened?” Gandalf asks, “What…”

“Stone giants,” Balin says from behind Thorin’s shoulder, “On the mountain pass. There were three giants, fighting and ... we were separated. The other group --- did not survive it.”

Gandalf blinks, now pale. “The other group …”

“It is only us left,” Balin confirms, “The others are dead. Fili, Ori, my brother…”

“Also Bilbo?” Gandalf asks.

“The hobbit, too,” Balin confirms, “As well as Bofur and Bombur.”

Gandalf says nothing in response. He swallows and turns away, but not before Thorin catches the expression on the wizard’s face. It is the soul-eating guilt he, too, experiences. Guilt for leading his company into disaster. Guilt for surviving, where others died.

And Gandalf must feel it too, for he was the one who pressured the hobbit into leaving – leaving on an adventure that turned out to be his death.

That was certainly not what the wizard had planned, Thorin thinks.

But then, he himself had not planned on losing his nephew either.

***

In the end, the quest succeeds. Not without grievous losses, but Kili – the first King under the Mountain after Smaug’s death, does not feel very attached to Erebor’s riches and is more than willing to compensate Bard and Thranduil.

He is a good ruler, but constantly sad. Historians explain it by pointing to the heavy losses during the quest and in the final battle before Erebor. Of the fourteen that set out, only five lived to see the mountain reclaimed. Six died on the way, three – Thorin, Dori and Bifur – on the battlefield.

And it is only a few years further down the road that Balin and Oin set out on their ill-fated excursion to Moria.

Kili has just passed when Mordor’s servants come knocking and Elrond calls for a council. Gloin leaves with his son to the south (and only Gimli returns, with an elf for a friend), while Nori organizes the intelligence (eventually at the price of his own life as he is found with a dagger from the south in his back). It is his network that reports that the battle fought before the Black Gates is won, that Sauron has fallen. And yet the spies also report that, as long as the one ring is not found, Sauron may rise again.

Fin