Actions

Work Header

Episodes from Middle Earth

Chapter 25: A Long Fall

Summary:

Thorin drops Bilbo from the gate. The hobbit survives, badly injured, and then suddenly an army of goblin and orcs arrives on the scene.

Notes:

Warnings: Canonical Character Deaths, Blood and Violence

This combines movie and book canon, so Fili, Kili, Oin and Bofur are in Laketown.

Chapter Text

It is with a heart full of dread that Fili mounts his pony that bleak winter morning. The air tastes of ash, and the grey clouds promise snow and early darkness. His brother’s head is bowed, too, and even Bofur displays none of his characteristic cheer when they ride out of the smoldering ruin that a few nights ago was Laketown.

The screams of that night still echo in his ears.

And the accusing glares cast their way hurt – had not the dwarves promised wealth and glory? Had not Thorin stood before them and vowed to let them share in the riches of the mountain? Instead a dragon came, and Fili has heard Thorin refused to part with his wealth.

That is why Oin, Bofur, he and Kili accompany Bard, Gandalf and Thranduil today. They are hostages, even if Bard has been gracious enough not to treat them like this so far – they’ve been allowed to help as much as they can.

Perhaps they can help today, too, Fili thinks with a heavy heart. Perhaps he and Kili may succeed where Bard and Thranduil failed – perhaps their words will rouse their uncle from whatever madness he fell prey to.

But then they reach the mountain and Thorin steps forward, high above their heads and even from distance Fili realizes that his features are set in stone. The wind howls over a landscape as devastated as he feels.

“Are you threatening me?” Thorin thunders from the gate, shoulders squared. He has a new coat, one made from velvet and furs – it flutters in the wind, making his uncle look like a vengeful creature from the neither worlds – like something that isn’t his uncle. “Do you intend to force my hand? Do you ransom my kin like a common robber?”

Fili watches as the company behind Thorin shifts. Dwalin is gripping his axe, Balin’s frown betrays nothing, and Ori looks distinctly uncomfortable. Next to Fili, Bofur waves awkwardly at his brothers, and Bifur rolls his eyes in return, while Bombur shrugs – but the air is tense, and to Fili, the ten up on the gate look unwell, their faces pale and haggard.

Then again, he can still see the horror of the dragon’s attack written all over Kili’s face, so they probably do not look much better.

“We intend no such action, and I would thank you not to insult our honor further,” Bard returns, voice strong and even, “Your kin are well and shall be treated well – they are here today to demonstrate that we honor our promise and will take care of all that seek shelter with us. And we are asking you for naught but to do the same.”

“And so do we,” Thorin returns, “But we do not do so with two armies behind us while holding a sword to your kin’s throat. This is not the same – it is not I, but you, who is not honoring their promise!”

“Thorin, please!” Kili shouts abruptly, “People are starving! They need your help!”

Fili’s heart skips a beat, but whatever hope there might have been flickers out when he watches Thorin’s face. Their uncle looks at his youngest nephew and his expression grows colder still.

“Have you turned my nephews into your dogs?” he asks, and his eyes turn to Thranduil, “Doing your bidding, so that I may fold and leave my kingdom to your wishes?”

Thranduil urges his steed forward and the group parts for him. “We have done none of this sort, King under the Mountain,” he spits the title like an insult, “Your nephews, however, are sane, where you pretend to be blind and chose madness. But negotiating will be of no further use – we will buy our share, then.”

“There is nothing you could offer me that – “ Thorin begins.

But then a man in inconspicuous grey robes rides forward, a wooden chest held before him. On a nod from Thranduil he flips the lid open.

And Fili’s jaw drops as, for the first time in his life, he sees the Arkenstone. Nestled among blankets the stone emits a bright light, enchanting and bewitching. Only Thorin’s angered shout of “How came you by this?!” draws Fili from its spell. 

“Did you steal it? Who was the thief that – “ Thorin rages, while Thranduil, calmly, shakes his head. “We are no thieves. The Arkenstone was delivered to us in promise of a share.”

There is hint of a smug smile on Thranduil’s face, but worry on Bard’s. Fili’s heart is pounding in his ears – he did not know this, and neither did Kili, or Oin, or Bofur  - and who did it and when did that happen? Thorin will be furious, and this is terrible, though he understands that it will also make Thorin pay.

But –

“Then I am betrayed,” Thorin states in a deceptively calm voice, as he turns to his companions up on the gate with him, “Who was the one to give my greatest treasure to my enemy?”

Fili holds his breath – he prays no one will answer, because this cannot end well, and he cannot think of one who would have done this. Dared to do it, knowing Thorin’s wrath, knowing how this would end –

And Bilbo sighs, shoulders slumping. “I did.”

Fili’s heart stops, and it feels as if the ground had dropped out from underneath his feet. He can only stare in horror as Thorin whirls around and advances on the paling hobbit.

“Betrayer!” Thorin roars, and Bilbo has just enough time to raise his hands, before Thorin grabs him by the throat. Balin shouts in protest, Ori flinches and a human archer near Fili notches an arrow to his bow, but Thorin takes no note of any but himself and Bilbo. With brutal strength he spins both of them around, and Bilbo loses his footing, and doesn’t find it, because Thorin has taken a step forward, and Fili doesn’t want to believe what he is seeing –

The uncle he knows is not capable of such cruelty. Cannot –

But Bilbo’s hanging in the air, hands clutching desperately at Thorin’s arms, and whatever he says is lost on the wind, but Thorin’s voice thunders with curses.

“Stop it!” Bard shouts up, “Stop it, Thorin! Stop this madness!”

“Thorin!” Kili screeches, and Fili’s heart clenches at the desperation in his brother’s voice.

“Thorin Oakenshield!” And the man bearing the Arkenstone throws back his hood, and Fili has never been so glad to see Gandalf – the wizard looks as grim and fierce as ever, and surely, he’ll make it alright now –

“Stop this at –“

And that is the moment Bilbo falls. There is a short scream – a split, heart-stopping moment when Fili stares and thinks this cannot be real, this must be a nightmare, this cannot happen – and then, with a dull thud, the burglar’s body hits the ground.

Up above, Thorin remains, frozen, hands outstretched. Pieces of worn fabric clutched in his fists and he is staring at the empty air, a hint of surprise on his features.

“Bilbo!”

Gandalf surges forward, and Fili remembers to urge his pony forward, while his mind remains caught in a loop. This cannot be how it ends, this cannot be real. How could Bilbo have fallen, how could the ground so suddenly have dropped away from underneath his feet?

Bard is on his knees and Gandalf drops down beside him, Thranduil lingers behind them. Fili, numbly, gets down from his pony, his brother's sharp gasps accompanying all the way forward. His knees feel weak, even though he only sees rock.

Rock and the backs of their allies? Captors? Will they now take their revenge on Fili and Kili?  He shakes the though off, though he strangely does not feel concerned for his own fate. Perhaps this is all an illusion...

Perhaps -

"No!" Kili shrieks and falls forward, "No, Bilbo!"

Fili catches sight of a limb hand lying on the ground, upturned, relaxed and its white skin mottled with blood. Everything else is hidden by Bard and Gandalf, and Fili’s stomach turns. He hears Kili gasping, sobbing, but it doesn’t make sense – this cannot be happening, this –

“Thranduil,” Gandalf shouts and turns to glance to the elven king, “This needs your help.”

Thranduil’s expression remains cold, unreadable. He casts a short, calculating glance up above – but when Fili looks, the dwarves have left the gate – before he turns to Gandalf. “Very well.”

And when Gandalf makes space for Thranduil, Fili sees the damage the fall has wrought on their burglar’s fragile body. A dwarf may have stood a chance, but Bilbo’s chest looks concave, and his leg is bent at an ankle that is not possible, and there is blood running from his nose and his mouth – and is that a bone - ?

Then Thranduil kneels down and Bilbo is, once more obscured from sight. Fili is left reeling.

***

Kili spends the night treading circles into the muddy ground before the healer’s tent. He’d seen Bilbo, silent and unmoving on the ground, and thought him dead had not Gandalf been convinced otherwise. For a terrible moment – one that had felt like an eternity – Thranduil and Gandalf had worked their magic; then the elven King had turned and declared Bilbo ready for transport.

Gandalf had risen, face grey, and Kili hadn’t been able not to ask – not with his heart in his throat and his world so off its axis that he felt dizzy. “How is he?” he had all but shouted at Gandalf, “How is he?”

Gandalf, exhausted and weary, had frowned, and it had been Thranduil who had answered. “He is alive. For now, and I do not know for how much longer.”

And with that they had been left. The main host of men and elves had turned back to their camp, paying no attention to their potential hostages. “Shall we go join the others?” Fili had asked, then. But Kili had been able to tell that his brother had been just as disturbed as him at that monster wearing their uncle’s face.

Bofur had shaken his head. “Still some repairs to finish,” he had muttered and turned his pony. And so they had followed the men back, until Bard had seen them and told them they were free to leave - they are not hostages, after all.

Hours later, Kili is certain he does not want to join his uncle now. Not, when the sight of his nephews with men and elves had unsettled him – but the sight of the Arkenstone at the same place had thrown him into a blind fury.

He is drawn from his bleak contemplations when Oin emerges from the tent, grey-faced. Kili stops himself from shouting at the last moment – the majority of the camp, including his brother, is finally asleep – and hurries over instead.

“How is Bilbo?” he asks, and can’t quite keep the hope from his voice. The blood on Oin’s clothes makes his stomach churn, and suddenly his heart is racing.

The healer takes a deep breath. “Alive for now, and that’s already more than any of us could have hoped for.”

“Will he – “ and Kili finds he can’t finish the question. Live? Die? Heal?

Oin shrugs wearily. “If he makes it through the night, he may just live. By the way, lad, would you mind sitting with him? The elvish healers are finishing up, but we’ll have to look after the other patients. And I think it’d be good if one of us stayed with our burglar – no matter how it ends.”

The responsibility is like a crushing weight on his chest, and Kili can only nod. He won’t let Bilbo alone. Not after the company has already failed him so horribly.

“Good lad,” Oin claps his shoulder, “Now, I have to go and see my other patients. If I see Gandalf I’ll tell him to come.”

Kili takes a deep breath, steels himself and wordlessly enters the tent. The elvish healers nod at him in passing – there is little animosity here among the dead and the dying, Kili has found. Too many of those that survived the wrath of the dragon succumb to their wounds day by day – a lot of them children.

Silently Kili draws back the curtain that is supposed to keep out the cold air. The fabric and the fact that he has a tent to himself speak for both, the severity of Bilbo’s condition, and the high regard Thranduil and Bard hold him in. There is even incense in a corner, but it cannot obscure the scent of blood and sickness.

On silent feet, Kili approaches the cot. It is large, it’s size designed for men or elves – it would make a dwarf look small, and Bilbo is practically swallowed up in its sheer size. A silken coverlet is wrapped rather firmly around the hobbit’s body – to keep him from moving. Yet, Kili knows that the lack of further blankets reveals just how afraid the healers were to put any sort of pressure on Bilbo’s chest.

There is another bandage wrapped around Bilbo’s eyes, barely darker than the hobbit’s pallor. Yet Bilbo is breathing, and with pursed lips, Kili drops onto one of the stools left standing at the cot’s side.

And then there is nothing to be done but wait.

***

Bofur keeps his hands busy. It’s what keeps his mind from wandering, and reluctantly lets the men and elves accept him into their midst. He has always been good with wood, and with the air growing colder each day, every pair of skilled hands is direly needed.

Oin does his share helping with the sick and wounded, while Fili and Kili wander the camp, looking like ghosts. Bofur understands it – he shares their horror, but perhaps is hide is thicker, and it was not his own blood that dropped a friend to his death.

For once, fate was kind – which makes Bofur wary, leaves him waiting for the other shoe to drop. Dwarves do not get lucky – history is proof of that. But Bilbo recovers, slowly, but certainly. Four days after his fall he regains consciousness, and beyond Gandalf’s wildest expectations was even coherent.

A fall like that ought to have scrambled anyone’s brains, Oin had commented, and “a little higher and we would have had to pick up several pieces of hobbit from all over the place.” But Bilbo keeps getting better, and at one point he starts to greet his visitors with a smile.

It’s a fake and brittle thing – hardship is written all across the hobbit’s face, now gaunt and haunted – yet he tries. There are nightmares, the healers say, and Bofur who has accompanied Bifur for decades thinks of course there are, and doubts they will ever leave. Bofur even hears rumors that Bilbo admitted to expecting Thorin’s reaction – and if that is true, how desperate must he have been to gamble with his life?

Bofur swallows, and turns to look at the darkening sky. It’s morning, but these days it seems the sun will not come up at all. His first appointment is with a group of men to head toward Laketown and demolish the majorly damaged buildings. Those that are stable they have opened for the children and the old – of the others they salvage what they can to build further shelters.

Some of the men nod at him, a few even call out greetings. The most eye him uncomfortably – he is a dwarf, and dwarves are the reason for this disaster. The help of one does little in this respect. He is glad once they begin their work and forget about the desolation surrounding them.

The spell lasts until midday. Then, a rider approaches in gallop from the camp.

“Gather the weapons!” he cries, and it is a man clad in ill-fitting armor, “Gather all the weapons you can find! An army of orcs and goblins approaches! They’ll be here by nightfall!”

***

This is what the end looks like.

Thorin stands atop the gate and gazes out across the scene of death and desolation. The air is black with smoke, and the air carries the scent of blood and burning flesh, and the screams of the dying.

Numbly he watches as the ground before Erebor is soaked with blood. This was not how he thought to reclaim his kingdom. This is not the glorious return they have dreamt of since the dragon came.

He swallows and the wind tears at his hair.

"Thorin?" Balin asks, quietly, and soft footsteps and ringing weapons betray the rest of the company.

This battle will not spare them. Already the field below is drenched in black - the orcs and goblins number too many, and the refugee camp of Laketown is on fire. Somewhere down there his nephews linger - he prays they live, while the evidence before his eyes is frightening.

He has felt numb for a long time. Ever since the halfling's slight body dropped from his fingers nothing has truly felt real - he has wandered the halls, staring blindly at the gold, its shine suddenly diminished. Wondered what he has done, Kili's and Fili's youthful laughter echoing in his ears. Bilbo's frightened eyes haunting his sleep.

There has only ever been one traitor, and that was himself.

But it is of no matter. The enemies’ numbers are too great - tonight, death awaits them all. But if the gods are gracious, they will let his nephews survive - let them escape and go back to the Blue Mountains and live their lives happy and in peace.

Thorin turns around, and the company looks at him, their faces grim and their weapons sharp in the flickering light.

"No matter what happens tonight," Thorin states, "It was an honor to share this with you. I will fight, for this is my duty, but if any of you longs to eschew this, may Mahal bless your path. If the gods have mercy, tell those in the Blue Mountains that the gold is cursed. Tell Master Baggins I am sorry. Tell my nephews I am sorry."

"We'll stand beside you, we always have," Balin replies, lightly and Dwalin grunts an affirmative. This is not the first time they have walked toward certain death - and it almost feels like an old friend beckoning. "If this is where it ends then we will face it together."

Thorin closes his eyes. "Thank you. I could wish for nor finer companions in this dark hour - and I hope one day you will find it in you to forgive my madness."

Nori snorts. "We were no less enthralled than you.”

“We’ve been on this road together and come this far,” Ori adds, an odd note of confidence under his normally so hesitant voice, “Let’s walk the last part together as well.”

Thorin nods, and has to shut his eyes for a moment. There are no better dwarves he could wish for to share this with him – and he wishes there was a way to save their lives. But may their maker forgive him, may his friends forgive him – he will see this through.

He lifts his sword. “For Erebor!” he shouts, and adds, to himself, “For my people.”

***

With a loud clatter, an elf warrior stumbles into Bilbo's tent, the usual grace of his kin absent from his step. He is bleeding from a gash to his forehead, his face pale and grim and Bilbo pushes himself up, with trembling arms. Ever since the last healer left the tent with a grim face and a sword strapped to his belt, he's been nervous.

Scared, even, listening to the shouting outside.

"What is -?" he begins, but the elf interrupts.

"They'll be here soon," he announces, "Where is your sword?"

"What!" Bilbo exclaims and his heart drops, "Over there, but what is happening? Is the battle going ill?"

The elf stomps over, casts a critical eye on Sting and then tosses it into Bilbo's lap. "The enemy's numbers are too large. There is no chance to win and the King said to try and save your life - if luck is with us, we'll make it to the forest."

And yet Bilbo knows that Mirkwood's border is far, on the other end of the Lake. Abruptly he smells smoke in the air, and can't help the quiver of his lips. "But the dwarves - there was an army from the Iron Hills. Aren't they -?"

"Oh, they are all here and we are all fighting back to back now, but that will not save either of us," the elf proclaims and casts around for a large cloak, while Bilbo's hands tighten around Sting.

He should fight - his friends are out there, dying. And if they die, shouldn't he die with them? His heart hurts too much to consider going home, but -

What help will he be in battle? He never was a fighter, and now, with more broken than hale bones in his body and a leg that will not carry his weight, what can he do?

"Wear this," the elf wraps a large cloak around his shoulders and then, gently, picks Bilbo up on one arm, "Keep your head down."

Bilbo stomach rolls in protest at the movement, and his world blurs - and then a gust of cold air hits his face, and he smells blood and burning flesh, and the world around him is one fire. Blades glitter in the flickering red light, and the howling of wargs fills the air.

A growl nearby, and Bilbo barely sees an orc's twisted features over the fabric, and then the elf moves so quickly and the air is spinning, and he hears metal pierce flesh. The stench of Orc hits his nose, just as a choked noise tells him the elf's blade found his mark.

Then the elf turns, and Bilbo sees the carcass on the ground. The elf tightens the arm around him, and Bilbo's face is pressed into the fabric of his coat. It leaves him blind to the battle, but not deaf, and he hears an arrow whizz by, and then the elves are shouting in their own language, and his head hurts too much to puzzle out more than fragments.

"... Take his horse!" he hears and suddenly the elf starts running and Bilbo wants to tell him to stop, because his ribs are on fire and he can't breathe. All that escapes from his lips are choked gasps, not audible over the din of battle.

And then he's tossed, and for a moment he feels like falling.

Then he is caught, and the impact makes the world go black.

The blackness does not linger, a deep burning in his chest and leg pulls him back, and he's being bounced relentlessly. His mind is fuzzy, and somebody is holding him upright, though it makes him feel sick, and he hurts.

Suddenly they veer sideways, but it’s not enough. The first arrow flies by close enough for Bilbo to feel it, but the second hits the rider with a dull thud that even Bilbo feels. There is a choked noise, and the arm holding him grows lax –

And then they are falling.

He hits the ground rolling. Pain explodes in his leg, and his vision goes white. Something hard and sharp collides with his chest, there is dirt under his fingers and a wet spot on his clothes. The taste of copper on his lips, and he coughs, fumbling blindly for Sting. Around him, madness reigns.

Arrows soar overhead, he can’t tell if the scream around him stem from friend or enemy, and wargs and horses both threaten to trample him. But the fatal blow does not comes, and Bilbo blinks the dust from his eyes to see blood-sprinkled ground before him, and an arm clutching an axe not too far away. It’s been torn off – the jagged edges betray this.

His stomach twists, but there is nothing in it to bring up. Instead, with cold-sweat covering his forehead, he looks up, only to grow dizzy. His heart is pounding too fast, the rhythm echoing in his head –

A growl makes him look up, though the abrupt movement makes his vision blur. There is an Orc staring down at him, its dull blade stained red, and it’s features twisted in unholy glee.

Bilbo’s heart stops. Blindly, he fumbles for Sting, pulls it from its sheath and brings it before him. The Orc only grunts in amusement, takes a step forward and Bilbo scrambles to get away. But he can’t get up, and every movement sets of white fire in his leg.

He bites on his lip, and his vision clears – in time to see the Orc raise its blade overhead –

And with roar Thorin Oakenshield throws himself before Bilbo and servers the orcs head with a might swing of his sword. The king whirls around to dispatch two more orcs with smooth, powerful movements – Orcrist cutting through flesh and bone as if it was paper, and Bilbo gasps.

Finally, Thorin turns.

And when their eyes meet, Bilbo realizes that the madness has left Thorin.

“Master Baggins,” the King under the Mountain says and kneels down before him, “Are you hurt?”

For a moment, Bilbo is unable to comprehend. The madness is gone, and that is incredible, and that makes him happy – and the smell of death lingers in the air, and what is Thorin saying?

Then a hand reaches for him, grasps his shoulders, and Bilbo, belatedly, flinches. For a moment he remembers the same hand dangling him in the empty air, an icy breeze tearing at his clothes –

“Forgive me,” Thorin utters, and loosens his grip but does not retract his hand, “Bilbo. Why are you here? Why aren’t you far away? This battle is no place for you! Why didn’t Gandalf see to it?”

Bilbo trembles and can’t seem to stop it. But he blinks, and nods over to the fallen rider. “They… They tried,” he stutters, and his throat burns. He doubles over coughing, wet and warm liquid on his lips again, and then it’s only Thorin holding him upright.

Thorin curses under his breath. “You can’t stay here,” the King announces, and Bilbo wants to laugh – he can’t stand, how ever should he escape?

There is a contemplative frown on Thorin face as he gazes over the field. Between fire and smoke little is visible, but it is clear that no safe haven is to be found.

“Erebor,” Thorin says, and Bilbo finds himself lifted into the air again. But this time the hands are gentle, and the hold is protective, and he hears Thorin shouting for Dwalin and Gloin, and to clear a path, and there is a hand on his shoulder, and he thinks somebody is calling his name –

But the world fades out.

***

Dwalin first thinks Thorin is holding a child. Wrapped in a green cloak, the body Thorin clutches against his chest is small, and Dwalin turns and beheads two goblins sneaking their way.

Gloin has Thorin’s back covered, so he’ll be opening the road. As he turns, Thorin nods toward the mountain. Erebor, then, to save the one –

A gust of wind pulls the cloak down enough to reveal blond curls, and Dwalin swears. “He’s alive?!”

Thorin gives a nod. “Badly hurt, though.”

And that is not difficult to imagine, not when Dwalin stood there to watch their hobbit fall. It had happened so fast, there hadn’t even been a chance for him to move, and then it had already been too late. He’d seen the elves and men gather, see Gandalf set to work – and then Thorin had turned on his heel, strode away, his face ashen.

He hadn’t meant to let Bilbo fall, then, and that – among many other reasons – makes Dwalin glad their burglar is alive. Truly, he had expected the slight thing to die at that fall, but he is happy he was wrong.

And with a turn Dwalin dispatches an orc, and then three more, with a grim smile on his features. This time, there will be no accidents. Not while his axes are sharp and in his hand and his companions need defending.

***

It’s a miracle they make it to the mountain, and Thorin’s leg is throbbing from a cut. There is cold sweat on his back, gasping for breath and clutching Bilbo to his chest. The hobbit has not stirred, not even when one orc managed to slip past their guard and only Thorin ducking away saved them from worse.

Dwalin’s axes drip with black blood, and blood runs from his face from where a stray blade caught his ear. He turns to look back down, where the battle still rages under a veil of smoke and darkness.

“Go,” Thorin tells him and Gloin, and when they hesitate, he repeats it, “Go! Your brothers are down there!”

Gloin draws in a sharp breath and turns on his heel. Dwalin hesitates for a short moment. “I have a brother here, too,” he says sotto voce, “Maybe even two. Will you be alright?”

“I’ll see our hobbit settled as safe as can be,” Thorin replies, “Then I’ll rejoin you. My fate is with my kin, no matter how dark the hour.”

Dwalin manages a quirk of his lips, inclines his head and says “Aye”. They both know how this will end.

And with that Dwalin, too, goes to rejoin the madness.

Thorin takes a deep breath. If they do not meet again, he hopes to rejoin his companions in the Halls of Mandos. It is a matter of hours, now. But before, he has another duty to fulfill.

He directs his steps to the small guard room they had set up camp in before. It’s warm, and there are spare cloaks and blankets. The air is biting, and if Bilbo is to last the night, he will have to be kept warm.

Bilbo weighs close to nothing, and his unresponsiveness is scaring Thorin. He is so used to the hobbit fussing, protesting – being lively, and perhaps that has blinded him. But he had his wake-up call the moment that body fell from his fingers.

Gently, Thorin settles him down and covers him in their remaining blankets. He can tell from the bandages he spies under Bilbo’s clothes that the injuries from the fall were extensive. And he can only pray the interlude on the battlefield has not worsened his condition.

But there is blood on Bilbo’s lips, and Thorin knows that the fates are often cruel.

He rests a hand against Bilbo’s cheek, a small sound falls from the hobbit’s lips, and he turns into the warmth. It’s such a trusting gesture in spite of all Thorin has done to him, that his heart breaks.

“Bilbo,” he whispers, though he has no right to use his name.

The hobbit mumbles something, but makes no attempt to turn from Thorin’s hand. The King exhales quietly – this moment he will take for himself. He will pay for his crimes later.

“It’s quite alright,” he tells the hobbit, and if his voice catches – well, who is there to hear it?

“…longer…” Bilbo mumbles, and then his eyes open a little.

Thorin holds his breath, disbelieving. But Bilbo does not flinch, only blinks sleepily. “Hmm?” ,he hums, “Must we leave?”

“No, Bilbo,” Thorin replies, “You can sleep a little longer. It’s quite alright.”

“I thought there was a fight,” the hobbit says, his words slurred. His eyes keep falling shut, and Thorin bites down on his lip. His fingers tremble, but Bilbo doesn’t notice.

“You … don’t worry about it,” Thorin tells him, and he feels as if he is choking on his words, “Just rest.”

Bilbo closes his eyes and relaxes. Thorin closes his eyes. “And may whatever is good in this world spare you. I have wronged you greatly, Bilbo Baggins, and would that I could make it right. But that is a chance I neither deserve nor will be granted.”

He flinches, when unexpectedly, a small hand settles atop his large one. When he looks down he finds Bilbo’s brow cinched.

“… Thorin…” he hears, but Bilbo’s voice is barely above a whisper, “… don’t fret… sleep.”

“I will, Master Baggins. … Bilbo. Soon.” And with that he squeezes that small hand in return. It’s scratched up and the skin bears calluses. A lot of the soft flesh is gone, and bones and lean muscles remain.

Another change he has caused – and for what? For throwing Bilbo off of the gate? For almost killing the one who tried to save him? What had Gandalf been thinking when he had asked the hobbit to come along? What had he been thinking to allow it? He’d seen how untouched Bilbo had been by the darkness of their world, and he’d derided him for it – instead of realizing that the peaceful ways of the Shire were what he had wanted for his own people all along.

The hand in his relaxes, and Bilbo’s breathing evens out.

“Sleep well,” Thorin whispers and carefully lays Bilbo’s hand back down, “Sleep well.”

He wants to say that once morning comes things will be alright. But he knows better – knows the devastation that awaits outside. Whatever morning may bring – he prays it will come fast.

With a deep breath he draws his sword.

It is time to face his fate.

***

Victory is granted, though Thorin does not live to see it. Dwalin saw him slay Azog, but was not quick enough to stop the blow that pierced Thorin’s stomach. And so, while the battle raged around them, he sat with his King. His friend.

Listened to him breathe apologies, plead his forgiveness and pray for his nephews survival. Nephews whose bodies Balin now is covering with a sheet, their faces wiped clean of dust and dirt. They were too young –

But this realization comes too late. Dwalin sighs and turns to look at the other survivors. They are a sad group, their faces stained with grime and blood. Gandalf sits, bowed over, while Thranduil and his folk are retrieving their own dead.

And if they aid man or dwarf to unbury their fallen kin – or accept a helping hand on their way – nobody comments. Death is the ultimate equalizer, turning old grudges into insubstantial fairytales.

“Bilbo!” somebody exclaims, and Dwalin glances up to see Bofur run to where Gloin returns from the mountain, a body held in his arms. Ori limbs after Bofur, leaning heavily on Nori all the way.

From the corner of his eye, Dwalin sees Gandalf straighten and Balin wearily climb to his feet. Even some dwarves that have come from the Iron Hills turn.

“Is he…?” Dori asks, in a flat tone. They have all seen so much death during the last night – Bilbo would be but one more name to add to that devastating list of lives they should never even have risked.

“Alive,” Gloin tells them with a frown, “Not good, but alive.”

“Oh, thank goodness,” Gandalf mutters and climbs to his feet, “I had thought …” He trails off, and hurries over.

Dwalin is content to sit there. His legs throb, and he can’t find it within himself to stand. He is glad that Bilbo lives – Thorin would have been glad for it, too. It was only but a few hours ago that he covered Thorin’s back as the king clutched the burglar to his chest like his most precious treasure –

And Dwalin does not ruminate on the could-have-beens. He has seen too many lives lost to be able to grieve for all that has not come to pass. For all the opportunities lost – but he would have wished for Thorin to be happy.

When Oin pokes his head out of a tent nearby, Dwalin nods into the direction of the group. “Our burglar survives.”

***

It takes Bilbo days to wake up.

Sometimes he is in a dim state of consciousness, hearing people talk, but he does not know who is talking or where he is. Sometimes he hears the voices of people long gone – at other times he thinks he is back in his home, and it is his father shaking him awake.

Then he dreams of fire and death. Of trolls and caves. Mountains and rivers, eagles and bears. It is all disjointed, and sometimes he feels fire licking his skin, hands on his throat. Hears wind howling in his ears, and then he is falling, falling –

It’s too hot, and he remembers a dragon, but there are no dragons in the Shire. If there are any left in Middle Earth, they would never come there, so why would he remember a dragon? Its heat, its claws, its menacing voice?

Somebody pours a foul smelling brew down his throat, and weren’t they at Laketown? Have they lingered there for so long? Durin’s day must have passed by now – Thorin is going to be –

Angry.

And Bilbo’s head clears.

Yes, Thorin had been angry. Beyond furious – he swallows, and weakly reaches to rub at his throat. He remembers being shaken, clinging to Thorin’s arm, the unforgiving grip of the King on his coat and scarf –

“Bilbo?” a voice to his left asks, and Bilbo flinches. Pain explodes in his ribs at the abrupt movement, and a hand settles on his shoulder.

“Laddie, are you awake?”

He blinks, fighting back the blackness threatening to swallow his vision. The hand is broad, sturdy, but too small for a human and too callused for a hobbit. To his surprise he finds Dwalin watching him with a frown.

“I’ll fetch Gandalf and Oin, then,” Dwalin rumbles, “They’ll be glad to see you awake.”

Bilbo manages to catch his sleeve and tugs at it. “Wait…” he rasps, finding his throat dry and uncooperative.

Dwalin is quick to hand him a water skin, and even drinking leaves Bilbo so exhausted he could just pass out again. But his throat feels better, and he is too confused to wait for answers. “What happened?”

He has blurry memories of another tent – but was that real or a dream? And a battle, but with all the fever dreams he has seen, he cannot tell what was true and what not.

Dwalin sighs. “After you fell – there was a large battle. A host of orcs and goblin came down from the mountains, led by Azog.”

He turns to look at Bilbo, sees the anxiety written across his too-pale face and at last his expression softens. “It was good you forced Thorin’s hand – otherwise none of us would have survived. It was a close thing, anyhow.”

Bilbo blinks. Then perhaps his memories are real? “Then…?” the hobbit mutters, and Dwalin does not know what he is asking. But he knows what Thorin would have wanted him to know.

“Thorin realized what you were doing. He … apologized. Or tried to, anyway. You weren’t conscious, or at least not fully there.”

“He … he did?” Bilbo asks, disbelief creeping up his spine.

“Aye,” Dwalin replies, “And for what it is worth, I don’t think he intended to drop you from the gate, either.”

For a long moment, Bilbo is silent, turning something over in his head. Then tilts his head. “I don’t think he did, either – when I fell, there was a moment when I think he just looked surprised.”

“We all were,” Dwalin snorts.

“How is he?” Bilbo asks, “And the others? Did anybody get hurt? Did you manage to settle things with Bard and Thranduil? I asked Gandalf to safeguard the Arkenstone in case somebody tried to use it in an dishonest trick or anything, but – “

Seeing Dwalin’s expression, Bilbo trails off. “Are they…?” he whispers.

Dwalin shakes his head.

“They aren’t…” Bilbo gasps, “Tell me they aren’t dead?!”

His voice jumps, and Dwalin closes his eyes. “Thorin, Fili and Kili fell in battle. The rest of the company survives.”

Bilbo feels the ground drop away. How can those three – why them? Why at this point? Is there no justice in this world? Thorin had just reclaimed Erebor, and Fili and Kili been so young. Barely adults – what force would see young lives wasted so cruelly?

He doesn’t even feel the burn in his eyes or the wetness on his cheeks. Doesn’t hear Dwalin mumble something about getting Gandalf and leave the tent. His head is in uproar – so many things were left unsaid between them, how could Thorin just be gone?

How could –

There is a faint memory tugging on his mind. Something – warm. Strong hands holding him. Blue eyes fixed on him in concern, lifting him; a deep voice telling him it’s all right.

But that cannot have happened.

***

Yet, as Bilbo heals, he begins to piece the picture together. And it leaves him breathless from the pain in his heart.

After he fell, Gandalf tells him, it took the combined efforts of Thranduil, Gandalf, Oin and an assortment of healers to save his life. Kili, Fili and Bofur stayed by his side through those fevered days. Saying that, Bofur turns to glance outside, a wistful expression on his face.

“They were worried for you,” he says, “We all were. And in battle, we were all so afraid when we saw your tent go up in flames – we’d have run over, but there were too many, and we couldn’t just leave the others.”

From him and Ori Bilbo learns that the company reunited on the battlefield.

“We were crying,” Ori admits with a self-conscious shrug, “Not that any will admit that, now. But I think even Dwalin was wiping his eyes when Thorin hugged Fili and Kili and apologized.”

So they were reunited before the end, Bilbo thinks, and relief spreads through his chest. They had a moment to speak to each other without madness clouding their minds – a moment, no matter how short.

“Next we know everyone’s somewhere else, and it’s chaos,” Nori tells him, later, “Even the elves lost sight of their strategy. You had to be glad if there was anybody friendly behind your back. Kili and Fili did team up with those two elves – it’s a pity only the blond one survived. They made for a fierce team.”

And that is how Bilbo learns just how close Thranduil came to losing his only son. It makes him watch the King with concern, and a newfound understanding for the deep lines now visible on his face.

“She was but a child,” he hears him mutter, once, when they are seeing the red-haired captain to her last rest. It is an odd day, cold but clear, and for once all three races stand united.

“She shouldn’t have been there,” Thranduil adds, “None of them should have.”

Where Thranduil presides over the funerals of his own, Balin conducts the one for the line of Durin on another sunny winter day. Dain stands aside, still not wearing the crown many are all but pushing onto him.

“He’s waiting for a reply from Thorin’s sister,” Gloin tells Bilbo during that night, when they are all well into their cups, watery as the brew may be, “He’d rather she take up the crown, but nobody thinks she will even come here.”

“What about Balin and Dwalin? Aren’t they… cousins or something?” Bilbo asks.

“Yeah,” Gloin replies, “But Dwalin doesn’t want anything to do with ruling, and I think Balin doesn’t really want a crown either. Also, I think, Dain would be glad to have your approval as well.”

“Mine?!” Bilbo coughs as some liquid goes down wrong.

Gloin claps his back rather carefully – everybody lately has all but treated Bilbo as if he would break at the slightest contact. He doesn’t like admitting it, but it’s helpful when even Gloin’s clap leaves his ribcage aching.

“Yours, yes. You were a member of the company, and quite dear to Thorin, so your opinion is of importance,” Gloin tells him.

“But I…” Bilbo stutters.

“Well, you had a good motive and ended up more or less saving our lives, didn’t you? And Thorin did try to make up for it when he found you on the battlefield.”

That is news to Bilbo, so he sits up a little straighter. “He did what?”

“Ah, you were pretty out of it at that time,” Gloin replies, “The orcs had overrun the Laketown camp, and some elf had tried to get you out. Hadn’t gotten far, the poor sod, but then Thorin got there and he carried you back up to Erebor.”

Bilbo recalls those blurry memories of screams, warmth and a deep voice telling him to sleep a little longer. Maybe those weren’t fever-induced hallucinations? Maybe Thorin did –

“He was rather determined to make sure you live through the night,” Gloin adds with a small hiccup, “Would’ve been happy to know it worked, too.”

“Yes, well,” Bilbo stutters, dumbfounded, “I didn’t know that. Thank you for telling me.”

And he is glad it worked. But couldn’t Thorin have put some thought into his own survival as well?

The road back home, eventually, is long and lonely. For days Bilbo looks back at his memories, wondering at the emptiness in his heart. Is victory supposed to feel like this? Their quest was successful, and yet Bilbo cannot smile without pain. The price paid for victory was too high – and yet Bilbo knows that in the long run, that, when thinking of homes and people and the future of Middle Earth, it was worth it.

Like the memories of a bright blue sky on days of parting, his ribs continue to ache and he retains a slight limp. It does not bother him, but his neighbors notice. And when Bilbo even alludes to having seen battle, he can see in their faces that they do not understand.

They will never.

And when he calls Frodo for dinner and the boy comes bouncing – his smile wide despite the tragedy he has known – he thinks that this, perhaps, is not quite so bad a thing.

Fin