Chapter Text
Otho Baggins is wailing. A bleeding gash on his knee, a hole in his trousers and mud on his shins. His cousin Bilbo runs down the hill after him, eyes wide and heart pounding. He'd merely tried to push his cousin off - he hadn't wanted to hurt him.
"Otho!" he shouts, "Otho, I'm sorry!"
Otho continues crying, hiccupping and unable to form words. Blood runs down his leg, and that injury looks bad, terrible, and Bilbo's stomach turns.
"I'm sorry, Otho, really," he stammers as he drops into the grass next to his cousin. They're outside of Hobbiton, on that shortcut through the fields leading to a small lake. It's summer and the sky is cloudless - ideal weather for children to go and play in the shallow lakes around.
But now Bilbo does not feel so cheerful anymore. Otho can't stop crying, though he's gasping for air, and the wound isn’t closing, and there's dirt in it as well.
He swallows. "Otho, I didn't mean to, really. Please, Otho, I'm sorry."
His cousin doesn’t budge, so Bilbo reaches out to rest a hand on Otho's shoulder, wishing to somehow convey to his cousin that he did not mean to hurt him. He has never felt so helpless, and he doesn't understand why it happened - he didn't mean to cause harm, didn't mean for Otho to bleed.
The moment his hand touches Otho's arm, a spark runs through Bilbo's spine. He gasps, doesn't hear Otho doing the same. For a moment, the world blurs, and Bilbo has to blink for it to refocus -
His cousin has stopped crying. There is still blood on his trousers, but then that terrible wound is gone, has disappeared, and Bilbo can only stare in disbelief, just as Otho does.
"What....?" Otho mumbles in that tear-choked voice, though is not crying any longer.
Bilbo blinks. And then he realizes that his knee hurts.
"You're bleeding!" Otho exclaims. There is large red stain spreading over Bilbo's trousers, all around his knee.
***
That was, Bilbo later resumes, the moment when he first discovered his talent. And while he had been glad to stop Otho from crying, his parents had not been happy. "Promise me you'll be careful when you use it," his father had asked him to, while he had wrapped the bleeding knee, his hands firm yet gentle.
His mother had sighed and ruffled Bilbo’s hair. "It's a talent some of your ancestors had as well, Bilbo. It can help, but just don't expect too much of it."
He learns what she meant when a few years later his grandmother falls terribly ill. And no matter how much Bilbo concentrates, he can't make her better. So she grows weaker, frailer, and when he asks his mother why late one night, she sighs. "As far as I know, it's really only wounds that can be
helped like this. And you do know, Bilbo, those wounds are not being healed. You only take them onto yourself - so be careful."
And Bilbo is. As he grows up, he learns that he can reasonably take on some of the scrapes his younger cousins suffer when playing too wildly, but he will not take on broken bones. He will not allow any of them to depend on this ridiculous power, not when it fails saving his father and mother just the way he could not save his grandmother before.
A rare talent it may be. But it seems to be not worth very much after all.
***
Bilbo is not certain if Gandalf actually knows of his talent and this is why he was picked. He has a feeling it has more to do with his complete unsuitability to traverse the wild. Within the first days he is drenched, his legs and bottom are sore, and he's dead tired because he can hardly sleep on the ground, with rocks and twigs poking into his flesh.
The dwarves have no such complains and snore happily on. Thorin seems to detest Bilbo's existence in general, while Gandalf is always exceedingly amused. Except for that evening, when Thorin refuses to go to Rivendell.
And while Bilbo does not agree with Thorin decision, he is somewhat relieved that there are also people in existence that can rile up Gandalf. Tough he is not quite so happy when he realizes, he now is alone with thirteen dwarves, who until now have barely tolerated him.
But the evening progresses without incident, until Bofur sends Bilbo to take dinner to Fili and Kili. Who have lost the ponies. To trolls.
If the situation wasn't so dire, Bilbo might have laughed. Instead, he has to find a good reason for the trolls not to cook his companions, or at least to stall until Gandalf arrives. Even though he does so rather late, and Bilbo for once shares the dwarves' grumpiness.
"What is it?" he hears Fili ask, and turns to see Fili help Kili up. The younger dwarf looks pale, and stumbles.
"My leg," Kili hisses and sinks down on a rock. Fili calls for Oin, and dread fills Bilbo. Hopefully this is not serious - but Kili wouldn't grimace like this if it was merely a scratch.
"Kili?" Thorin asks, having come up to the two. Fili helplessly shrugs his shoulders as Oin makes his way over.
"What is it?" he asks, gruffly.
"His leg," Fili gestures, and they all look down - but through the rough fabric of Kili's trousers, no injury is visible.
"On the back," Kili hisses between clenched teeth, "It's on the back."
"Well, then turn over," Oin orders.
Kili is a bit hesitant, and Bilbo has to admit it is not very dignified, especially when Oin tells him to drop his trousers. But except Kili, nobody else comments.
Then Bilbo catches sight of the injury and has to suppress a gasp. Along the back of Kili's shin runs a long, bleeding cut. It's not very wide, but bleeds heavily, and Bilbo's stomach rolls at the sight.
Oin mumbles something under his breath, and Thorin asks, "Where did you get this?"
And Bilbo knows exactly when that happened, even before Kili answers.
"When ... I tried to catch Mr. Boggins... When the trolls had him..." Kili stutters, and then squeaks as Oin presses down on the wound.
Bilbo's heart clenches guiltily. He knows he isn't skilled, he never meant to get anybody hurt on his account.
"That'll need stitches," he announces, and Kili grows paler. Thorin turns to glare at Bilbo as Oin to shuffles off to retrieve his pack, and Bilbo feels cold. He avoids Thorin's gaze, looks at wound on Kili's leg.
He didn't mean for this to happen. He didn't ...
Bilbo purses his lips. The dwarves won't understand - they still think he almost made the trolls eat them. This will only rob him of whatever sympathies remain.
Unless he is foolish. The wound looks painful, and it'll probably hurt Bilbo more than Kili. Hobbits are not as hardy as dwarves, and Bilbo has fainted from cutting himself on a fish knife.
But Kili did get hurt for him.
Discarding his deliberations, Bilbo steps forward. As he stops right before Kili, he can sense Fili's bewilderment and Thorin's mistrust. When he reaches out, Thorin takes a step forward as if to stop him, exclaiming, "What are you doing?"
But he is a split second too late. Bilbo feels the spark run down his spine, just before Thorin catches his wrist and drags his hand away from Kili's calf. The young dwarf blinks, confused, while pain explodes in Bilbo's leg.
He bites down on his lip to stop the scream from escaping, but his knees buckle, and he lands on the ground with Thorin's hand still wrapped around his wrist.
"What happened?" he hears Fili wonder, and Kili shouts his name, but it's all distant, barely audible over the pounding of his heart and the searing pain in his leg. It burns, and he has to gasp for air because his lungs don't properly expand, and it's blinding - and somebody is shaking him.
"Master Baggins!" Kili is shouting, and he is holding Bilbo upright by his shoulders, "Bilbo! Bilbo!"
He blinks, tries to focus. Kili is staring at him, intently, Fili just behind his shoulder, pale and confused. Thorin stands to the side, a frown on his face.
"Bilbo, what did you do?" Kili exclaims, and Bilbo thinks of course, the dwarves don't know, and there was a reason, but he's abruptly feeling quite exhausted. Black starts to creep into his vision, and the last thing he hears is Fili.
"Mahal, his leg - Oin! Hurry up, Oin!"
***
Kili feels the body in his arms growing slack, and fumbles to keep hold of their burglar. Bilbo's head lolls back, and Kili barely manages to avoid slamming it against a rock - he's terrified of doing further harm, doesn't understand how his injury now is Bilbo's, and the body in his arms frighteningly fragile.
"Here, set him down," Fili instructs, spreading his coat on the ground. Kili swallows, and allows his fingers to unclench - then Oin is there, forcing him aside.
"What's that?" their healer asks, hands reaching for the sluggishly bleeding wound, "Where did he get this?"
"It's mine," Kili stutters.
"Eh?" Oin glances up.
"On a rock," Fili shouts, "He fell over a rock."
Oin nods, and turns back to the ground. Kili stares at his brother - they both know that this is how Kili got the wound, not Bilbo. Thorin, too, frowns down on them.
"He'll need stitches," Oin announces before any of them can speak, "Get my kit, lad."
And Fili takes off before Kili can even climb to his feet. He turns his eyes back to Bilbo - the hobbit's face is slack and pale, and Kili thinks that this is not what he wanted, no matter how bad the pain was.
All he can do is stare helplessly as blood continues to run down Bilbo’s leg, staining the ground while the hobbit remains unconscious. Oin is turning a cord into a makeshift tourniquet, because Bilbo is so pale – there is so much blood, and how much more can their burglar lose?
Kili blinks. The question that falls from his lip is a soft “How…?” that is almost swallowed by the wind. By chance, though, Balin picks it up. He heaves a sigh. “I don’t know. But there are more things between the sky and the earth than we know or understand. We’ll have to ask him once he wakes.”
***
There is no time for asking questions. First Gandalf is demanding answers how his burglar got so badly injured, then a second wizard shows up with ill tidings, and then there are orcs and wargs. Oin slings the limp body of their burglar over his shoulder as they race for safety.
“One of your number is injured,” Elrond says as they reach Rivendell, “Come and rest. We can provide shelter and supplies, and our healers shall care for him.”
Oin tightens his grip. “He’s my patient.”
“Then they shall follow your instructions,” Elrond replies patiently. He inclines his head, and Oin might not like elves, but he is not going to turn down supplies. There is an ugly flush on Bilbo’s cheeks that he does not like.
Thorin frowns, while Gandalf leans forward. “There is something else I must speak to you about,” he says – Oin can tell from his expression that these are no good news. He only hopes they are not related to their quest – their luck has been bad enough.
Bilbo’s body twitches – it’s a slight movement, but Oin knows that he needs to set his patient down. All the running and jostling cannot have done him any good. So he ignores the hesitance displayed by Thorin, Dwalin and his own brother and steps forward.
“Please, lead the way.”
***
Bilbo wakes to sunlight on his face and fluttering, white curtains. The bed he rests on his soft and warm, yet his body feels stiff. As if he’d overexerted himself –
His memories come back abruptly, and he releases a sigh. Embarrassing that his last memory is collapsing in front of them company. He’d known that the pain would be bad, he’d just not expected his body to give out.
After all, he has healed his fair share of leg injuries before.
In response, his leg itches, and Bilbo tries to rub it against the sheets. Something tugs at the skin – not painful, but weird and stomach-turning – and when Bilbo carefully draws the covers aside he discovers stitches.
His stomach lurches.
He’s quick to hide the leg under the covers again, and gazes around looking for a distraction. The room is utterly unfamiliar, and only now he realizes he has no idea where he is. Have the dwarves brought him to a healer in some settlement and moved on? How much time has passed? Has he been left behind?
Before he can work himself into a frenzy or even try to get up, the door opens and an unfamiliar elf comes in, holding a bowl and a washcloth.
“Ah, Master Hobbit, you are awake!” he exclaims, “Your companions will be glad to hear it!”
***
Several hours later – the sun is setting outside – Bilbo finds himself surrounded by the entire company plus a wizard and Lord Elrond of Rivendell. His fingers keep toying with the blanket covering his legs, and he feels strange being at the center of attention.
“I hope you forgive our curiosity,” Lord Elrond says with a smile that does wonders to soothe Bilbo’s fraying nerves, “But it has been a long time since I heard of something similar.”
His chest clenches. For a moment he remembers his mother, warning him not to let the knowledge spread.
“Indeed, I have never heard of such a thing at all,” Oin harrumphs. Kili and Fili watch anxiously, while Thorin has his arms crossed before his chest.
“Only in ancient history texts…” Ori mumbles, “Or myths, rather, I think.”
“That is all very well,” Balin intercedes, “But why don’t we let Master Baggins tells us what happened.”
Bilbo purses his lips. Now, with the danger gone, he wonders why he betrayed his secret so carelessly. Kili would have lived, and dwarves are known to be hardy. Only Bilbo was weak to his own sense of guilt and the glares cast his way.
“It … well, it…” he stammers, looking down, “It’s … it’s supposed to be a secret.”
A murmur goes up, and Bilbo hunches his shoulders. Nori leans forward. “So can more of your kind do this?”
“No,” Bilbo shakes his head, “No, it’s … they…” He trails off.
Lord Elrond clears his throat. “Master Baggins, if you are uncomfortable talking about it, please do not feel forced.”
He casts an eloquent look at the dwarves. There have been, according to the rumors Bofur was happy to share with Bilbo during the afternoon, a number of them. Elves may have few dealings with hobbits, but are generally fond of them. On the other hand, the dislike between dwarves and elves is legendary. And so, the arrival of a company of dwarves with one injured hobbit caused some suspicions.
Bilbo has been flustered ever since.
“No, I… I’ll tell you,” Bilbo protests. He can trust these people. Gandalf and Elrond naturally, and he has to trust the dwarves.
He bites down on his lower lip and tells himself to stop stammering. It’s a very simple tale after all, and he does not need the rest of the world reading any more into it.
“It’s nothing but a particular talent,” he eventually manages, “Apparently it sometimes shows up in my mother’s family, though it’s rare.”
“And what is that talent exactly?” Gandalf inquires, a deep frown on his face.
“Well, I can heal injuries in a manner,” Bilbo replies.
“So why did you get injured, then?” Kili exclaims, pushing forward, “You got hurt when you healed me! Why did that happen?”
Bilbo flinches, and Fili pulls Kili back. “It’s, well, maybe healing is the wrong word?” Bilbo suggests faintly, “I mean, I do heal people, so …”
“But you take on their injury in turn,” Dwalin growls from where he is standing next to the door, “That’s not healing, laddie, that’s just exchanging your health for another’s.”
“Yeah, err, well, perhaps it is?” Bilbo replies, “Honestly, I’ve never put much thought into it. It really isn’t all that much, if you …”
“And yet you said it was secret,” Thorin interrupts.
Bilbo shrinks further into his blanket and pillows. “Well, they … there were rumors that it could be abused.”
“And those certainly were not wrong,” Gandalf thunders and glares in Thorin’s direction, “Perhaps you should have taken those warnings a bit more seriously – as Kili has said, what you do is not healing, but just taking on somebody else’s injuries. That’s not –“
Bilbo lifts a hand. “I know, Gandalf,” he says, “I know.”
“Then why did you do it?” Fili asks.
And that is the question Bilbo cannot answer. Not without revealing his heart, and he trusts the dwarves with his secrets, but not with this.
So he glances outside where night is slowly falling and shrugs his shoulders. “Seemed like a good idea back then.”
***
As they leave Rivendell the dwarves remain distanced, but the atmosphere feels friendlier. Bilbo chats with Bofur, and sometimes with Ori and Fili. Kili is either awkward or too close – he is the first to set aside food for Bilbo or help him up a steep slope. But when Bilbo tries to talk to him, the young dwarf turns his head aside and stammers.
“He’s feeling guilty,” Bofur tells him one cloudy afternoon as they are making their way down another mountain, “Especially after finding out you basically traded your health for his. It’s not right for us.”
Bilbo shrugs. “He got hurt because of me in first place.”
“Hm, well, but you did not hurt him yourself, did you?” Bofur asks lightly, “You see, that is quite important to us. He got hurt trying to help you, and we think we’ve got to be responsible for our own actions, you know. So him getting hurt is the consequence of his own doing – no matter why or what for.”
Bilbo huffs, stopping for breath, before directing a rare toothy smile at Bofur. “And healing him was my own action, too.”
Bofur blinks, and Bilbo chuckles. “Don’t worry, I’m aware or what I’m doing. I’m being careful.”
It’s just that everybody else is skilled in battle and Bilbo isn’t. So, logic suggests, he might very well shoulder those injuries in order to keep everybody else in their best condition.
***
Bilbo never gets to talk to Kili. Instead he encounters stone giants, goblins, strange creatures and Azog the Defiler. Madness and fear war in his veins as he draws his own blade – and how should a letter opener ever fare well against the blood-encrusted mace the defiler wields? – and throws himself into the fray.
***
Thorin comes to abruptly, heart in his throat. Last he saw was Azog bearing down on him, and an insane hobbit jumping between them, but there's only darkness after that. His body feels sore, though he remembers the mace catching him in the chest -
"Mahal, what did you do?" Somebody is shouting, and Thorin blinks. A weight is resting across his chest, and suddenly he hears Kili muttering "Thank you, thank you, thank you so much," and his nephew is crying?
"Kili, did you ..." Balin gasps, catching his breath, and Thorin finally, finally manages to push himself upright on his elbow, dislodging the dead weight - of a hobbit sprawled across his chest.
The pieces fall into place immediately.
Carefully Thorin sits up, making sure to keep a gentle hold on their burglar, but Bilbo does not even stir, and Thorin wishes Oin would be a bit faster, or Gandalf was here - but the company is scattered, with many still in the air, while a giant eagle deposits Bofur on the far end of the hill.
Had circumstances been different, Thorin would have marveled at this wondrous rescue. But there is a still hobbit in his arms, and Kili has tears streaming down his face, while Fili stares in frozen shock.
"Uncle, you... " Fili mutters, but his voice hitches and he hides his face. Kili sobs, presses the heel of his hand against his eyes, and shakes his head.
"He healed you, did he?" Balin asks, as he reaches Thorin, Dwalin not far behind, helping Oin upward.
Thorin swallows and nods. The body in his arms is unmoving and too light and still - and this isn't how he ever wished for his life to be saved. Not at such a terrible cost. Not when Bilbo already cast himself between Thorin and Azog.
"Bilbo, is he...?" Fili whispers, and Thorin wants to hug his nephew - Fili should not look so pale. Should not be out here, if Thorin is honest. The boys are too young, too inexperienced for cruelties such as Azog's. Knowing the tales is different from meeting the foe.
"Turn him over," Oin orders with a huff, "Quickly now, he might not have all day."
Thorin swallows and tugs the hobbit to lie on his back across Thorin's lap. The movement reminds him of his restored health - and the price that it took. Bilbo is chalky white, with a deep cut on his cheek and another under his hairline. Fresh red stains those golden curls, making them stick to too pale skin. But the hobbit sucks in a shuddering breath, and Thorin cannot deny the relief flooding his heart.
Oin leans in, fingers dancing across the hobbit's chest, a frown on his face. Thorin follows, but there are no visible bloodstains on the vest, and he was wearing armor when the mace caught him, but he remembers not being able to breathe right, so -
Bilbo coughs abruptly, a small, rasping sound that has Oin yell at him to turn Bilbo's head and make sure he doesn't suffocate, and Thorin's heart clenches. The body in his arms shudders, as it struggles to suck in air, the coughs growing successively wetter - until a thin stream of blood dribbles from Bilbo's lips.
Thorin's blood freezes. He hears Oin curse, sees Fili pale further and Kili shout the hobbit's name, but cannot stop the mad spiraling of his thoughts. The moment the mace had connected, he had known. Of course, he had known. The armor might have prevented his chest from being smashed in immediately, but that blow had caused serious harm.
Harm that now Bilbo suffers.
"Thorin!" a new voice shouts, and Gandalf is running up to them, "Thorin, are you - Bilbo! What happened to him?"
"He took on Thorin's injuries," Balin says, quickly, before anybody else can speak up, "Can you do something?"
Oin doesn't look up from where he is palpitating Bilbo's chest, trying to find the damage, "Something's wrong with his lungs - I don't think it's anything I can heal here."
Kili gasps and Thorin presses his lips together. Should Gandalf be unable to help...
The wizard does not even reply, instead he drops down, casts one hand over Bilbo's face and another over the hobbit's chest. Closes his eyes in concentration and begins to mutter in a strange language - and Thorin does not dare to breathe.
The air feels terribly still, and Gandalf keeps chanting.
And then he gives a small gasp, sits back and breathes out, just as Bilbo's eyelids flutter.
"Bilbo!" Kili exclaims, while Fili turns to Gandalf, "Is, is he alright?"
Thorin cannot look away, as Bilbo stirs in his arms. Those are small invisible movements, but with his hands clutching Bilbo's shoulders like a lifeline, he can feel every one of them. Color is returning to those pale cheeks as well, even though the gashes linger - a stark reminder that their burglar is not made for brutal encounters.
"He will be," Gandalf announces, "With some rest and care, I believe he should recover fully."
Thank Mahal, Thorin thinks, and sees Kili slump from the corner of his eye. Fili sinks back, leaning heavily against his brother, and Balin sighs loudly. The entire company lets go of a breath and relief, for the first time since the ground caved beneath them, truly spreads.
It is a miracle they survived the madness. Goblins, wargs and Azog himself - and Thorin himself now owes his life to their smallest member.
As he glances down, he finds Bilbo blinking, his eyes barely open, but awake. "Bilbo," he breathes, and the hobbit weakly tilts his head. His lips open, as if to speak, but Thorin shakes his head. "We're save, Master Baggins," he tells their burglar, "You can rest."
Bilbo blinks, and for a moment he seems to be gauging something. Then he closes his eyes, and Thorin feels the body in his arms growing slack once more.
A gust of wind races across the mountain top, and Thorin realizes, that midday has almost passed. They will have to find a way down, safe as the mountain may be, it is exposed to the elements.
As if he had read his thoughts, Gandalf pushes himself up. "There is a house not far from here," he announces, "We might find shelter there."
And while Thorin would have asked for the details any other time, now he merely wraps Bilbo in his own coat, all too aware of how much can still go wrong, and agrees to go there.
***
Beorn grumpily allows them to stay. The skinchanger denies to be acquainted with Gandalf, and does not like dwarves either. But their story evokes his understanding and Bilbo’s still form, wrapped in Thorin’s oversized fur coat, wins his sympathy.
Thorin settles Bilbo on a soft mat next to the fire, and with Gandalf’s reassurance in his mind, turns away. He needs to speak to Balin and to regain his bearings – he does not even know how far off path they have come.
Before he finds Balin, Gloin finds him.
He pats Thorin’s shoulder. “Alright?” he asks, and when Thorin replies positively, Gloin shakes his head, “Aye, but don’t do that again. Almost gave me a heart attack – and I really understand why Balin’s gone white so early and Dwalin hasn’t got any hair left to speak of. Really, have you always been so impulsive?”
Though he can tell Gloin means well, Thorin cannot deny the words sting. Looking back he understands that he endangered them all with his poorly thought-out actions, but seeing Azog had just caused a knee-jerk reaction.
“Just don’t rush into it next time,” Gloin tells him, “And you should talk to the lads. They, well, might do with a word of advice?”
“I will,” Thorin says – he remembers the terror on his nephews’ faces all too clearly. And while he is the leader, he needs to be their uncle, too.
Gloin doesn’t retreat. Instead, he frowns. “Well, it’s not my place to say, and it probably did not amount to anything… But you were not conscious, and they were next to you and Bilbo came running up to them. I don’t really know what went on, I just heard Kili telling Bilbo to save you …”
And knowing what they know about their hobbit’s peculiar talent that might have equaled Kili asking Bilbo to die in Thorin’s place. He gives Gloin a short nod, signaling he has understood the problem there.
***
It takes two days until Bilbo stays awake for more than two hours at a time. He still looks terrible and Oin has strictly forbidden any attempts at getting up - and the company is glad to see the order obeyed. For Thorin especially the memory of holding that helplessly twitching body in his arms is much too clear.
"Will we be staying here much longer?" Bilbo asks on the evening of their fourth night at Beorn's. He's still too pale and looking like a strong wind could blow him over, but his cheeks at least have regained some color.
"Perhaps a fortnight," Thorin replies, "We need to recover and to restock before we go through Mirkwood."
"Still, aren't we running out of time?" The hobbit inquires.
Thorin sighs and wonders how he could ever have called their burglar a burden. He is rather all too willing to sacrifice himself. "We'll take time for everybody to heal," he tells Bilbo, "This might the last respite we get before reaching Erebor."
Bilbo straightens. "Who else got hurt?"
His fingers twitch and Thorin thinks if he could, the hobbit would go and heal them. It's not healthy, this habit, and with the severity of injuries it might just kill him one day. Dwarves are made from stone - they can bear harm and broken bones. He does not know about hobbits, but they do not appear as hardy.
"Only cuts and scratches and some sprains," Thorin tells Bilbo. He does not mention that Ori also got concussed and both Bifur and Nori needed stitches for their cuts. And Dwalin is going to have to wield his axes in one hand until his left shoulder is completely healed.
Bilbo hums and falls silent.
"I talked to Kili, too," Thorin says as the silence drags on, "He understands- neither him nor anybody else will ask you to heal injuries from now on."
Bilbo glances up. "That... well, thank you, but that was not necessary."
"You were about to heal me anyway?" Thorin asks, suppressing his frown for the moment.
Bilbo twists the blanket between his fingers. "Yes," he replies, "I mean, I can, so why shouldn't I?"
Thorin takes a deep breath to calm himself. Watches the flames flicker merely, and reminds himself that all is well. "You could have died," he tells their burglar, "Those were serious injuries. Had Gandalf not been there, we might not have been able to help you."
Even thinking about it makes a shudder run down his spine. Yet Bilbo studies him quietly, his face still so unmarked by the world's cruelty in spite of the healing cut on his cheek.
"Well, it was my decision," Bilbo says, "And I did know Gandalf would follow soon. So I knew what I was doing. And please, before you scold the boys - they did not talk me into healing you. I decided that and I knew what I was doing."
Thorin frowns. "You almost died!"
"I knew what I was doing," Bilbo insists, shaking his head, "I know what I am capable of, you have to trust me on this."
And Thorin wants nothing more than to shake some sense into their burglar, but he cannot do that, not when Bilbo is still visibly recovering.
Instead, he sighs deeply. "You should not be so quick to risk your life, then. Especially with your talent - once you are dead, you cannot heal anybody."
Bilbo nods gently. "I know, Thorin. I know."
***
The dungeons of Mirkwood drain Bilbo’s strength worse than healing ever has done. The constant darkness, the whispers in the back of his mind, the lack of food all drive him toward the brink of total exhaustion. His hands tremble constantly now, and even though Bofur and Bifur are saving food for him, it is not nearly enough.
He haunts the dungeons, dodges elves, discovers Thorin, listens to foreboding conversations and is slowly but certainly losing hope. There is no escape, and even if – there is nothing but a bewitched forest awaiting them. He does not know if he would last another fortnight among those glowing eyes and giant spiders.
Dori is holding his hand, preventing Bilbo from disappearing as he does when he wants to escape the questions. It’s strange how on one hand he is starved for company, but feels too drained to hold a conversation.
“Say, Master Baggins, I was wondering,” Dori whispers, “Can you also heal yourself?”
Bilbo blinks, startled.
“Because when you heal people you essentially exchange your condition for theirs. So perhaps the reverse is also possible?” Dori’s grip on Bilbo’s wrist tightens slightly. “If so, I believe all of us would be more than willing to help you out.”
For a moment Bilbo is speechless.
“Please, let us know if there is way for us to help you,” Dori continues, “I know it sits ill with me to be sitting here while trying to arrange for our escape is so visibly taxing you.”
“I…” Bilbo stammers, “Well, thank you. Truly, thank you. But no, I’m afraid the reverse does not work.”
Dori frowns. “Please be honest.”
“It doesn’t,” Bilbo returns and hopes his voice conveys that he wishes it would. What he wouldn’t do just to feel well-rested again for once.
“Did you try?” Dori asks, unhappily.
Bilbo casts his memory back. Somehow, the knowledge is intrinsic – but he might have attempted it. Back when he had first found out about his ability. In a fit of pique he’d gone, kicked his own foot against a tree and then tried to transfer it to his cousin Fortinbras.
It hadn’t worked and had only made Fortinbras look at him strangely for the rest of the week.
The memory is enough to make Bilbo relax for a short moment. Enough so he can turn to Dori and confess with a half-smile that “Yes, I did try. And no, it doesn’t work.”
***
"Are you alright?" Bilbo shouts as he struggles out of the water. His entire body is aching, and he can't breathe right, but the dwarves collapsed on the shore are groaning and retching and he's terrified his escape plan will end in a catastrophe. "Fili - Balin, is everybody alright? Was anybody hurt?"
His heart is racing, as he sees Ori stagger toward his brothers. At least Dori seems alright, wringing water from his beard, but Nori is sitting down and not moving. Did he break something?
"Calm down," Kili laughs, eyes still sparkling with laughter, "They're quite all right."
Balin nods. "Though I have to admit that for my old bones that was a little too much excitement."
Bilbo stumbles forward, now almost out of the water. The world keeps spinning, and he isn't certain if he should believe them. His head hurts.
"And Fili's only sick because his barrel smelled like apples," Kili adds, and Fili's face turns green before he retches once more. Kili is more amused than worried.
"If anything, you look like the one in most need of healing," somebody growls right next to Bilbo, and before he knows what has happened, he is picked up and lifted out of the water. With three long steps Dwalin has him on the shore and puts him down on a rock.
"You can't heal yourself?" he asks. Bilbo blinks and just manages to shake his head when Dwalin already turns to call for Oin.
As the dwarf shuffles over and makes Bilbo unbutton his vest and shirt, while Thorin joins them. Even wet and bedraggled he still cuts an impressive figure - compare to how pathetic Bilbo thinks he must look.
Thorin just stands there with his arms crossed over his chest, watching as the company members struggle to regain their equilibrium.
"We should head to Laketown," Balin tells Thorin, "We need supplies and a rest, too. There is still enough time until Durin's day.
Thorin frowns, but before he can speak up, a hiss from Oin interrupts him. "Why didn't you come to me sooner?" their healer shouts at Bilbo, "You should have at least told us you were starving!"
The outline of his ribcage is clearly visible underneath too pale skin, and Bilbo averts his face. Even under the clear sky, the darkness of Mirkwood's dungeon still presses on his heart. Oin tuts, and turns to Thorin and tells him they will need food. And something warm to wear for their burglar.
Thorin nods and his eyes find Bilbo's. The look in them is warm, caring and Bilbo's heart is still aflutter when Thorin addresses the company: "We head to Laketown."
***
Bilbo spends the first days in Laketown abed, drifting in and out of consciousness. When he is awake, his dwarves assure him that all is well and he need not worry - there is time. Outside, though the days grow shorter and the first snowflakes drift by.
Eventually he does recover and they have to plan for the journey onward. The last leg, and it feels strange that is should truly be happening. All through their trip Erebor had always appeared a distant goal, sometimes barely more than a dream. That they should have come so far -
A shudder runs down Bilbo's spine.
"And no healing anybody before we leave, Master Baggins," Dori reprimands that last evening, "You need to be healthy."
Bilbo nods and swallows. Not long now until he may face a dragon. His talent will be of little use then.
"Maybe somebody else should go in," Kili suggests, "If they got injured, Bilbo might be able to heal them."
Bilbo’s heart hitches. He knows this can’t work – he knows the reasons. And yet a small part of his heart wishes for nothing more than having somebody else face Smaug.
"Doesn’t work that way, laddie," Balin says gently, "Smaug will recognize a dwarf's scent within moments."
Bilbo, too, musters a weak smile from where is packing what is a necessity to take to the mountain. "You dwarves are terrible at sneaking. He'd hear you coming, before you'd see him."
And, what nobody dares to speak, but they all know - should Smaug catch an intruder, there is little hope that those injuries could ever be healed. Instant incineration is more likely, and Thorin looks at Bilbo and hopes that will not come to pass.
***
The sky is clear when they reach the mountain. It's a chilly day, but as they hike uphill, a sweat breaks out on Bilbo's skin. Under the bright light, the land around them is barren and dead. Only the ruins of Dale provide a dash of ash-covered color, and a shudder runs down Bilbo's spine.
His little talent, he thinks, is quite worthless in face of such desolation. What can he do but heal scrapes and cuts, what does that matter in a world where dragons may lay waste to kingdoms in mere hours?
He turns with a sigh and continues. But this is but a taste of what is still to come - and Bilbo learns how it is to feel truly small and powerless. Smaug toys with him, first, and then they cannot do anything but watch as the dragon descends upon Laketown.
Smaug is slain. However, Bilbo thinks as his stomach twists and turns, at what price? What price did their victory come at?
At the border of the Lake, visible from the gates of Erebor by its red shine, Laketown burns. And then the gold sickness claims Thorin's mind.
Bilbo cannot say he understands his friends any longer. Gold is all they look at nowadays, gems and riches, and all thoughts of food and friends have vanished. But Bilbo does not understand his own actions either. Not when he smuggles the Arkenstone out of the mountain and into the camp of Bard and Thranduil, knowing fully well that this is betrayal.
That Thorin will never forgive him.
And it breaks his heart to destroy these friendships, yet he sees no other way. There are bags underneath his eyes, and a pain in his chest that no talent can heal. That does not change when hands close around his throat, and he is dangled out over the wall. The wind roars in his ears, his lungs burn and Thorin screams from madness and fury, and Bilbo thinks that this is a sort of pain he cannot heal.
His own heart breaks, because he didn't want to hurt anybody. He knows the gold has driven Thorin insane - but this betrayal is all too real.
"Get him away from me!" Thorin orders as he flings Bilbo to the ground. The hobbit lands with a thud, his shoulder burning, and his head spinning. He coughs, struggling to sit up, desperate to do something.
"Thorin -" he gasps, "I..."
"Get him away or I will not be responsible for my actions!" Thorin thunders and reaches for his sword. Gandalf shouts for him to desist, but there is fire in Thorin's eyes and they are fixed on Bilbo.
"I..." Bilbo stammers, with his throat closing up, and then Dwalin steps forward. "Be that as it may," he grunts, "He could still be useful."
And Bilbo's heart sinks.
"No," Thorin declares, "I will die before I ask a traitor to heal me."
***
Bilbo has known grief. Has watched his father die and his mother follow. Had to bury one cousin far too young. But as he sits in Thranduil's tent, a blanket wrapped around his shoulders, it feels as if his heart is being torn into two.
The mug in his hands has long gone cold and he only looks up when somebody clears their throat directly in front of him.
“Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf says, and now he is wearing his customary robe and hat again, “What has happened to you?”
Concern mars his features and Bilbo glances aside. He is aware he must look a mess – Thorin’s hands have left purpling bruises on his throat and his cheek is cut up from where he hit the ground – but all those hurts are irrelevant when his soul has been shredded.
He cannot even muster any anger at Gandalf – who, in the end, is the reason Bilbo is here.
“Bilbo,” Gandalf calls again, and nudges Bilbo’s face toward him with a gentle hand, “I know this is hard, and I’m sorry you got dragged into this, but you do understand that this is a curse? Thorin is not quite himself, though that does not excuse his actions.”
Bilbo blinks. He has held the Arkenstone in his own hands – felt its thrall and power. But knowing this does not soften the grip of phantom hands around his throat in the slightest.
“Thorin was wrong to treat you as he did, and I believe he will realize it in time,” Gandalf tells him and pulls the blanket around Bilbo’s shoulders up, “Just don’t despair in the meantime.”
The wizard smiles, then, and for once the expression is free of schemes. This is merely Gandalf, the friend of his mother’s, who’d always had a soft spot for young, adventurous hobbits. And who is worried what his good intentions have caused.
Bilbo sighs. Darkness claws at his heart, but he cannot leave Gandalf without an answer. “Gandalf, I – “
“Mithrandir!” an elf exclaims, stumbling into the tent. He’s breathing hard, and his hair is askew, “Mithrandir!”
“What is it?” Gandalf barks and Bilbo holds his breath.
“Orcs,” the elven messenger gasps, “An army of orcs. Twenty hundred at least – they’ll be here by nightfall.”
***
There is no time to get away. With the orcs closing in, all save paths have been shut, and elves, men and dwarves abruptly find themselves back to back. By midday Dain has come himself with an envoy and has sent a runner up to Erebor.
While the gates stay closed, Gandalf worries about Bilbo.
“You could hide in Laketown,” Bard suggests, “We’ll be shutting down the lights, ready boats and destroy the bridge connecting the town to the land – it’s not a terribly effective defense, but it’ll save lives and orcs don’t swim that well. Those out on the water will be safest.”
Bilbo shifts uncomfortably on the cushioned seat. He doesn’t know why he was asked here – he leads no army, and he is the only one of his kind present. What he thinks should not have that much consequence.
“That seems wise,” Thranduil agrees, “This place will be a battlefield by nightfall. If you leave soon, you will make it to the lake before sundown.”
“Are there even enough boats left for your people?” Bilbo asks instead, “I thought Smaug burned the majority.”
Bard grimaces and rubs at his shoulder – there is a burn hidden under his clothes there, Bilbo knows, and guilt wells up in his chest. “Well, you’re not taking up much space, this should be alright.”
Bilbo closes his eyes. “Even so, I’d rather a child have my place.”
“Bilbo!” Gandalf protests, and half rises from his seat. Even Dain frowns and Bard growls, though Thranduil leans back and crosses his arms. “And what will you do if you stay? We cannot spare any men to protect you, and the battle will find you.”
“Without meaning to offend, Master Hobbit,” Dain adds, “It appears you might end up being underfoot and thereby causing harm inadvertently. I do not doubt you do not wish for this, but as you have admitted to never having been in battle, I believe staying away from tonight’s would be the wiser choice.”
Gandalf casts a curious glance at Dain – the King of the Iron Hills must know what Bilbo has done, and formed his own judgment – but Bilbo shakes his head. “I do not mean to cause trouble, and I am aware I will be of little help in a fight.”
“However,” Bilbo says and looks straight at the four others present, “I can heal.”
Gandalf’s mien darkens, Bard splutters and Thranduil raises one eyebrow. “What do you mean?” Dain exclaims, “Are you saying, you – “
Bilbo stands up. “You have a burn on your shoulder, Bard,” Bilbo says and walks toward him, “Let us see it, please.”
Bard stiffens in his seat. There is one loud sigh from Gandalf and Thranduil leans forward. “Please do,” he encourages Bard, “I have a feeling nothing bad will come of this.”
“On your head be it,” Bard hisses, while Bilbo tilts his head. “I promise this will be alright.”
As Bard peels away the layers, Bilbo takes a deep breath. “Some of my ancestors had a peculiar ability,” he tells the room at large, “They could heal injuries with just a touch of their hand. Some called it magic, and others grew afraid. Thought to kill them for having that talent or sought to enslave them to use the talent for themselves. Needless to say, the secret has been kept ever since.”
“I have heard of this,” Thranduil acknowledges, and Dain, too, inclines his head, “Though it always appeared more of a myth.”
“Nowadays it is,” Bilbo says, “I’m the first in five generations to have that talent.”
And when Bard has removed the last piece of clothing, they all can see the raw wound. The flesh is dark, charred and blistered, though it does not bleed any longer.
But it is painful, Bilbo realizes, when he concentrates and the wound reappears on his shoulder. It is terribly painful and hot, and much larger on a small hobbit body. He can’t suppress the gasp that falls from his lips, and then suddenly Gandalf is holding him by the shoulders and Bard asks what happened and how he did this.
Bilbo is directed back to his chair, and when his vision clears he is sitting down and Gandalf has pulled back his coat to peer at the burn now on Bilbo’s shoulder. Bard is directly behind him, his brow ceased.
“That might be useful, then,” he mutters.
Bilbo blinks and manages a bleak smile. “I could support the healers.”
“Could, certainly,” Thranduil interrupts, “But it would be foolish. Your talent, Bilbo Baggins, is not one of healing. Whomever you decide to save you will be saving at the price at your own life.”
And with that he sweeps from the tent. Dain, too, clears his throat and rises. “Much as dwarves disagree with elves,” he says, “He is right. And I believe none of us want to see you come to harm, so we would all feel safer if you chose to evacuate to Laketown.”
***
Bilbo never goes to Laketown. Dain and Thranduil may have spoken their recommendations, but they do not know Bilbo. And the uproar in his heart renders him deaf to Gandalf’s supplications, until, in the end, he is allowed to run messages between healers and supplies.
There is no time to sit down and think. Bilbo is still figuring out the different organization systems in place when the sun goes down and the world falls silent. For a moment it is as if time had stopped – no wind, no bird – and the air so terribly still.
The sky is a light blue with the first stars twinkling on the western horizon. No ripple disturbs the lake’s surface, no clouds shroud Erebor’s peak.
And then a howl tears through the air.
This is it, Bilbo thinks, and a shudder runs down his spine. He’s stumbling across the dark plain, two bags of bandages under his arms as the night irrevocably changes around him. The air hisses as arrows are fired, strings hum and sing, and then there are thuds and choked gasps.
The screaming starts. A tent goes up in flames. Weapons sing their cold, clear song of death and blood. Smoke fills the air and Bilbo is
coughing, wiping at his eyes. He can’t save them, he can’t, he tells himself as he sees elves dragging their companions from a burning tent and runs on.
A breeze picks up, cooling the sweat on Bilbo’s forehead, as the head healer – a man from Laketown – intercepts him, grabs the bandages and shouts “We need more! Get more!”
And he is running again, his heart in his throat, as the night is tinted in shades of red and orange. Bilbo gasps for air, stumbles over something – and is that a body over there? A high-pitched scream nearby, and he falters, fishes for his ring –
But somebody grabs his shoulders and drags him away and Bilbo thinks he can’t leave, can’t flee – the healers are counting on him, he has a task to fulfill –
The screaming is so loud he does not hear what is said. But they can’t be abandoning their posts already, hasn’t the battle only begun? Are they already abandoning their hurt and injured and if so, who will survive the night? Is there any hope at all left?
Are they –
With a roar that overshadows all other noise the gates of Erebor burst open. Weapons and armor glitter in the night, polished weapons forged from rare gems and mithril twinkle with starlight. And the first of them, tall and handsome, points his sword to the sky, and Bilbo’s heart catches.
Thorin, he thinks. Thorin and the company have come to fight. Will this be –
Something hits his head and never gets to finish the though.
***
When Bilbo wakes, the noises have faded. His head hurts brutally, his vision is splotchy, and his entire body hurts. He can’t move, and doesn’t understand why it matters, or where he is –
“Bilbo!” somebody exclaims, and Bilbo blinks until he recognizes Gloin on the cot next to him.
“What?” he slurs, and finds his limbs reluctant to move. His memories are unclear, but there a bandage wrapped around Gloin’s head, and there was a battle and –
“Did we win?” he murmurs.
“If not, we would not be here,” Gloin replies, and massages a bandaged shoulder, “But what are you still doing here? Why did you not leave before? We were so sure you had – “
“What of the others?” Bilbo stammers, and pushes himself upright. The tent is in an uproar, with elves and dwarves and men running all over the place. His head pounds. “Are they all alright?”
Gloin blinks and looks at Bilbo strangely. “Well, mostly. The sickness is gone, if that is what you mean.”
“But the battle?” Bilbo repeats, “Did they make it through the battle unharmed?”
Gloin’s silence tells Bilbo all he needs to know. His chest grows tight and he manages to push himself up, though the world spins madly. “Gloin,” he calls out, “Please! Who was hurt?”
The dwarf wets his lips. “It’s bad – very bad. You won’t be able to heal them.”
Bilbo shudders. “Who?” he asks, again, more sharply than intended.
“Thorin and the princes. But Bilbo, you cannot – Bilbo, no!”
But Bilbo does not listen.
***
Bilbo’s heart quivers. He sucks in a short breath, feels his knees weakening. He knew, he knew what to expect all along. Gloin’s words warned him, he shouldn’t be so shocked. But the air in the royal tent is heavy with the smell of blood and decay.
Death, he realizes, this is what approaching death feels like.
Bilbo stumbles, his ankle throbbing nastily. His head still smarts, and he has to blink away the white spots appearing in his vision.
They’re still breathing. All three of them are still breathing, but for how long – the candles cast the room in a soft light, but that orange glow is all the color that remains in Thorin’s face. Kili lies to his left, limbs folded carefully over his chest, a sheer hiding the injuries done to his torso. A black shaft sticks from Fili’s shoulder. But before the poison can claim him, the maimed leg will.
Is this what he fought for? Is this the price they have to pay for giving in to the gold sickness? Is this where their journey ends?
And something in Bilbo’s chest seizes violently. It’s as if he’s back on the wall and Thorin is shouting with fury and hatred, and his heart is being torn apart. Only this is worse – this is the end, there will be no time after this. No reconsiderations, no apologies, no discussions. Death is all that remains, and though Bilbo’s throat is still bruised, this is not the end he has wished for.
He came here to help those dwarves reclaim their mountain. He did not come to see them die.
Bilbo swallows and steps over to Fili’s cot. Blood has stained his beard and lips red – the only splashes of color on a too-pale face. His expression is so relaxed, he could be sleeping, but his breathing is growing swallow and Bilbo knows time is running out.
None of his dwarves will awaken before the end. It is probably a blessing, but to Bilbo this is wrong. This is not what he wanted.
And he can change it.
He may have promised not to give his life – and he knows, if he attempts to save even one of them, it will cost his life – but perhaps that is the better exchange. His talent has never been too useful in the grand scheme of things. But now it could change the future.
Now he can finally do something good.
Bilbo takes a deep breath. His ankle twinges with each step, and he leans heavily on Kili’s cot as he gets there. Sweat beads on his forehead – his own body is in poor condition, but that will not matter much longer.
It is a strangely liberating decision, Bilbo thinks as he stretches out his hand and reaches for Kili’s uncovered arm. Knowing that it will all end soon puts things in perspective – he is not sad, for example. Rather, he is satisfied. With Durins alive, this story will receive a fitting ending.
The moment his hand touches Kili’s skin, his body seizes. Kili is like ice, already so far in death’s clutches that Bilbo barely even feels any life left within him. But there’s the wound to his leg, a cut on his side –
“Bilbo!” somebody screams, “What are you doing?!”
Pain explodes in his leg and Bilbo is violently torn away, his hand losing contact with Kili, and people are shouting, and the world blurs –
And then he is on the ground, with somebody propping him up, while somebody else touches his leg and it burns – He shrieks, and there are hands in his air, on his cheeks and somebody tells him to be calm, to take heart, that all we be well –
Wetness covers his cheeks, and Bilbo realizes he is crying.
“Oin! Get Oin here! Now!” Dwalin roars, and it is Bofur clutching Bilbo’s body while Nori is wrapping cords around his leg. Blood spreads over the ground, and Bofur hugs Bilbo close, muttering “What have you done, Bilbo what have you done?”
His leg throbs relentlessly and his vision keeps blurring, but Bilbo recalls that he has to go on. He has to heal Thorin and Fili too, and he should check on Kili. Bofur ought to know that it’s all alright, that this is how it is supposed to be.
“Get Oin! Gandalf! Anybody!” Dwalin shouts again, and Bilbo knows he should hurry.
He struggles to dislodge Bofur’s arm, but there is no strength in his movements and Bofur only holds him closer. “Be calm, Bilbo. We’ll … we’ll save you, I promise. You’ll be alright. Just, please, calm down.”
There are tears in Bofur’s eyes and Bilbo thinks he never meant to make his friend cry, but he can’t quite form the words. He also thinks that Bofur is lying and he should not – he cannot feel his leg any longer, but all he can see is red and chunks of flesh and bone and he doesn’t think hobbits are built to survive this.
“Dwalin, do you know anything?” Bofur shouts out as Dwalin stomps back inside. “Cut it – “
Nori hisses, “Anything except cutting it off!”
Dwalin growls under his breath.
“He’ll not survive it,” Nori continues and tugs the cord so tight Bilbo still feels it, and he needs to move, to do something –
“Let me go!” he gasps out, “Bofur, let go!”
“Bilbo, no!” Nori shouts, but Bilbo wriggles and kicks, “You’re only hurting yourself! Stop it! Bilbo!”
“Let me go!” the hobbit screams, “I need – I need to save them! Let me go!”
“Bilbo, Bilbo! Calm down, please! Please, just calm down!” Bofur shouts, clamping his arms tighter, and Dwalin has to help him, because there is desperation in Bilbo’s movements.
“Please!” Bilbo begs, “Please, just let me – “
“What is going on?”
It is barely more than a mumble. By all rights, they should never have heard it over the entire ruckus. But Bilbo falls silent, frozen in shock. Bofur’s eyes widen, Dwalin turns –
“Thorin!” he exclaims, “You’re awake!”
Bilbo blinks. Remembers phantom hands, remembers a broken heart. But so much warmth, friendship and affection. And Thorin – he wants Thorin to live, but the dwarf looks terribly pale and there is dark blood in the corner of his mouth.
“Thorin…” Bilbo whispers, and his vision blurs.
“Bilbo, stop it!” Bofur admonishes, but Bilbo does not hear him. Instead he stretches his hand out toward Thorin, not knowing if he seeks absolution or intends to heal him – there are so many shattered emotions in his chest, he barely knows what he feels.
“Bilbo?” Thorin replies and it visibly strains him to lift his head, “What are you – “
“Please….” Bilbo mutters and reaches.
“No!” Nori shouts and whisks Bilbo’s hand away.
“Let me –“ Bilbo gasps, but he doesn’t have the strength to fight. He can barely hold up his arm, and his vision is fading in and out. He is growing cold, too, and a strange hum has begun in his ears.
“Thorin, you need to stay down!” Dwalin orders sharply, and Bilbo sees that Thorin is reaching for him, too, and that there is fresh blood running from his mouth. And he remembers that Thorin’s chest was concave, that he needs to be healed –
“Bilbo,” Thorin gasps, “Bilbo, I …”
“You need to rest! Thorin, please, rest!” And Dwalin is begging, and Bilbo thinks that wouldn’t be necessary if they’d only let him up. He can heal Thorin – he can, but Bofur is not letting him go and he cannot move himself.
“I’m sorry,” Thorin chokes out, together with even more blood, “I … I was mad. I’m sorry. I never meant to – to treat you. I …”
He coughs and it brings forward black-tinted blood. Thorin’s chest rattles, and Bilbo wants to cry, because he can still save him, or at least try to –
“Please, forgive – “
“Thorin, stop talking!” Dwalin shouts, and his grip on Thorin’s arm is white-knuckled, and Nori is biting his lip.
“Please, let me help him!” Bilbo pleads, “Please, I can still – “
“Bilbo, no, don’t …” Bofur sobs, tightening his grip which is the only thing even holding Bilbo upright, “Don’t make me watch you die as well.”
“Please I…”
“Don’t,” Thorin gasps out, his chest heaving, “Don’t waste yourself on me, my burglar. I … I don’t…”
“Thorin!” Bilbo shrieks, “I… Let me help him!”
Nori is the one to close his eyes. Blood has soaked through his trousers and coat. The cord cannot be tied and tighter around Bilbo’s leg, and his fingers are stained red. “Let him,” he tells Bofur, “Just…”
Bofur makes a choked noise, and Dwalin’s eyes widen as he turns to glance down. Bilbo’s vision is blurry, but he knows his leg is in terrible condition. He knows he is dying and the dwarves are wasting time –
“Let him!” Nori shouts, and Bofur releases his grip. Bilbo falls forward, and Nori catches him, lifts him and settles him next to Thorin. It is warm, and Bilbo feels a strange sensation of peace trickle at him.
He takes a shuddering breath, and meets Thorin’s eyes.
“Bilbo, please,” Thorin whispers hoarsely, “Don’t do this for me. Don’t ---“
“I love you,” Bilbo tells him and takes Thorin’s hand.
***
Later, when the bodies are buried and the histories written, the story goes to say that Bilbo saved Kili, but afterward succumbed to his injuries and died in Thorin’s arms. Thorin, too, passed on before the sun rose on the following day, and Fili could not be saved either. For historians, it is a clear story, but those that were there remember despair, shattered dreams and broken hearts.
Dwalin remembers the soft glow of the air, the sensation of warmth creeping down his back – until it failed abruptly, and Bilbo had slumped forward. To their surprise, Thorin had caught him. Caught him and drawn that small body close to his chest, a shaky hand carding through dust-covered curls.
There had been no more words.
Three shaky breaths later Bilbo’s heart had stopped. And Thorin had looked up at them with blood running from both his nose and mouth and Dwalin had known that he, too, was dying. Bofur had wailed, then, and Nori had looked on with dead eyes and Dwalin had wondered why he was still alive –
And then they had finally realized that Kili was stirring. Bilbo may not have gotten a chance to even reach Fili, but he’d gone to Kili first and healed that injury and the young prince had lived. What followed had been chaos – healers running in and out of the tent. Dain was there, and then Gandalf and Bard and even Thranduil had come.
A mountain needed to be rebuilt, a treasure to be shared. Repayments made to men, a share for Dain and his people, too. Funerals to arrange and a coronation to celebrate. By that time the first caravans begun to arrive, and there was hardly ever a quiet moment.
But sometimes, Dwalin knows, he and all others of the company like to come here. It is not the actual tomb – but a smaller marker put up on the outside of the mountain. Because the last time they had been all together and whole was before they had stepped inside, and the marker is a reminder. A reminder for themselves of the truths that they do not want the share. And the world does not want to know them either.
The histories provide a simpler story of a courageous quest and a better ending. King Kili of Durin’s line crowned King of Erebor, Fili died a hero of a vicious battle and Thorin and Bilbo dead yet reconciled at the very end.
Fin
