Chapter Text
Thorin’s madness is growing and Fili watches his uncle with increasing unease. His obsession with the Arkenstone blinds him to the growing exhaustion of his companions, the passage of time and the world outside. His only reaction to the news of the Laketown survivors reaching Dale had been to order the treasury guarded at all times – and to fortify the gate.
Fili had hoped. Hoped with every fiber of his being this wouldn’t happen. Had hoped his uncle to be stronger than the curse.
But he cannot deny what he sees before him. He can sense the call of the gold in his own veins, hears the beckoning song emanating from that golden glow. But one look at his friends, one look at his brother and he remembers not to give in. And he does not understand why Thorin cannot resist.
Dwalin and Balin can no longer reach him. When they mention diverting attention, Thorin suspects a plot. When Kili spoke out to help the Lakemen, Thorin implied treason, and Fili will never forget that look of terrified betrayal and hurt on his brother’s face. He loves his uncle, but not this incarnation.
This, he thinks, is no longer his uncle. His uncle would not have treated Kili so harshly. Would not be doubting their loyalty. Would not allow himself to be consumed by madness.
“Fili,” somebody calls and he looks up to see Bilbo making his way toward him. The hobbit, too, has grown pale, and looks perhaps more haggard than anyone else of their little troupe.
“Thorin said we’re going outside,” Bilbo says and tension suffuses his voice, “Everybody should come.”
Fili nods and stands up. The armor’s heavy weight is unfamiliar. Even with it he feels naked – they are facing an army of hundreds, not the best dwarven-made armor will save him, he thinks. Nor his brother, his friends, or his uncle.
Or their burglar. He wonders what Thorin is thinking – except for the mithril shirt, now well-hidden under the worn blue coat – Bilbo sports no armor at all. Perhaps Thorin will not allow his burglar out of the mountain. It would not surprise Fili. At one point he may have had misgivings that Thorin would trust Bilbo when he made threats against Kili and him. But no longer. Thorin’s trust is both blessing and curse, he knows, and from Bilbo’s behavior in the last couple of days, he thinks a curse is more likely.
Thorin barely ever allows Bilbo out of sight. And yet does not listen to any counsel Bilbo attempts to provide, shutting him down by reminding him that “dwarves are different”, “dwarves are strong”. They may be, Fili thinks, but they are not invulnerable. He’d rather make decisions like a weak hobbit, if it meant saving their lives.
And Thorin forgets his own strength. There are bruises on Bilbo’s wrist from where he held on too tightly, and the hobbit’s body is stiff, he walks uneasy, as if pained. Fili does not want to know what lies underneath the clothes, but if he ever felt a grudge against Bilbo, it has long since vanished. Now all he feels is sorry. Bilbo is as unhappily involved in this as they all are, and it is likely he will die today, too.
Maybe if he hid in the mountain –
Grey daylight greets them and Fili banishes the thought. He takes a deep breath, steps outside and looks down from the rampart. Rank upon rank of spotlessly dressed elven soldiers cover the ground between Erebor and Dale. A small group of men with rusty weapons has joined them, and above them a stitched banner of Dale flutters in the morning breeze.
It is a cold wind, carrying a taste of snow and ice. The clouds are grey, heavy, and Fili thinks that this is likely the day they die.
***
“The stone is real,” Bilbo confesses, “I gave it to them.”
And everything shifts. Something in Fili jerks, he wants to desperately deny it, but it makes so much sense, and Bilbo looks terrible, frightened and determined simultaneously. It cannot be true –
But the stone Bard slips back into the folds of his coat glows with a light unique and unmistakable. Even Fili, who has never before seen the Arkenstone, knows that this must be it. How on earth did Bilbo then –
“You would steal from me?” Thorin hisses, his entire body shaking with rage.
Fili’s blood runs cold, he knows his uncle’s anger and this is not it. This is fiery, mindless fury, but Bilbo doesn’t realize.
“Steal, no,” Bilbo responds, voice rising, “It stands against my claim.”
It’s the wrong thing to say, Fili realizes, and so does everyone else. They’re all waiting, horrified, breath held, and somebody needs to warn Bilbo. Needs to get him away from here, even if they don’t understand how he traded it, how he got the stone, why –
“Your claim,” Thorin echoes, icy hatred swinging in his voice, “What claim do you think you have, you miserable rat?”
And then he steps forward and reaches for the sword strapped to his side.
They need to act, Fili thinks desperately, now. But everyone’s frozen stiff, wide-eyed and panicked and Bilbo pales, but still doesn’t understand, still believes he can make Thorin see reason, still doesn’t understand the madness that has taken over his uncle.
“Thorin,” Bilbo calls, voice hitches, “Thorin, what are you – “
The King swings. Bilbo barely dodges the blade, but it leaves a deep scrape in the stone behind the hobbit. With a thud, Bilbo hits the ground, presses himself back into a corner and it’s the worst thing he can do.
“Thorin!”
Somebody shouts for Bilbo from below, but Fili pays them no attention. Not even Dwalin moves a muscle. And of course, he thinks, of course, they are dwarves and Thorin is their King, and it’s treason even if he’s mad. Even if they all know Thorin will never forgive himself, even if they know this is not who Thorin is, but a pale parody of him, and they’ll let Bilbo die for that, and –
No, Fili resolves. No.
Somebody has to stop this madness.
Maybe it is because he has not grown up as he should. Maybe he’s been too influenced by foreign cultures, maybe he’s just simply not enough of a dwarf. But he’s not going to let his little brother and all his friends perish for the sake of maintaining a meaningless tradition, he’s not even going to let a single hobbit die at the hands of a mad dwarf King.
“Stop it, uncle!” Fili shouts, unsheathing his own sword and stepping forward. Balin twitches, Gloin grimaces – by all rights, he shouldn’t be doing this, should stand frozen. But that’s not him.
Bilbo’s eyes widen comically, but Thorin doesn’t take note, does not even turn, but instead raises his sword like an executioner –
Fili lunges forward.
Somewhere in the back of his mind he remembers not to aim for the fatal spots, but all his life he’s been trained to kill. The blade slides between Thorin’s ribs before Fili’s quite comprehended what he’s doing.
Bilbo’s eyes widen. Somebody gasps. Thorin’s sword clatters to the ground, Fili stumbles backward. Thorin sways, takes a step to the side. Then his knee gives out and he collapses to the ground.
Fili stares in disbelief. He did this, he knows. That is his blade sticking through Thorin’s upper torso. He feels numb, distanced.
Dwalin rushes past him, followed by Balin and Oin. Somebody is shouting, but Fili doesn’t hear it. Instead, Kili catches him by the arm, eyes wide and face pale. His lips move, though no sound reaches Fili’s ears. He allows his brother to tug him back, away from where his uncle collapses and he still cannot believe he did this.
This changes everything, a cold voice in the back of his mind tells him. Everything. The world will not be the same.
He’s just stabbed his uncle. His uncle who’s not the same, who went mad and a part of him just wants to wake up. Wants for this to stop. Close his eyes, and be back in the Blue Mountains once he opens them again.
***
Even for an event as momentous as Fili’s deed, the world does not stop.
He feels the passage of time keenly, sitting in a dark corner in Erebor. Whether he wishes for time to stop of hasten, he does not know. His companions have left him alone, though he wonders for how long. Wonders when they will be back.
Will Dwalin demand his head for his deed?
Would Oin come to pronounce Thorin’s death?
Will Balin cite the old laws and with red-rimmed eyes declare Fili’s banishment?
His heart is heavy, though he does not cry. Does not deserve to, because he stuck his uncle knowingly. Aware of the consequences; not blinded by any sort of spell or madness. And for all he wishes his uncle would live – for all he already misses the dwarf that used to ruffle his hair and teach him how to care for his weapons – the mad specter he could not allow to proceed.
Could not allow to get them all killed.
Fili’s sigh echoes among the stone. Kili left him here, he does not know how long ago, beseeching him to stay put. Muttering about how it all will turn out alright, do not worry – but his brother has a good heart and high hopes. Fili knows this will not turn out alright.
But he will face the consequences, regardless of how dire they turn out to be. As long as the others live, he can accept them.
Quiet footsteps draw him from his contemplations. Nori emerges from the corridor, his expression utterly unchanged. Fili cannot read what he thinks of Fili’s actions, as Nori stops and beckons at him to follow.
“Your uncle is asking for you,” Nori tells him, and Fili’s heart clenches, “Go to him.”
***
They pass the company. All have gathered in the antechamber of another room; their faces grave and solemn. The hairs on the back of Fili’s neck stand; his stomach twists. Do they all hate him? They should, he knows, but he finds only pain on those familiar faces.
Kili, Dwalin, Balin, Oin and Bilbo are not here.
“In there,” Nori says, and squeezes Fili’s shoulder lightly. The young dwarf nods, swallows. Fear coils in his chest, so thick and devouring he cannot breathe as he steps through the door.
The smell of blood hits Fili the moment he enters the small chamber. Buckets with dirty water and stained bandages litter the ground, half-heartedly pushed aside. Traces of frantic activity that has now died down.
At the center of the room sits a large bed. The sheets and blankets are clean but for a few spots of blood that whoever changed them must have missed. They cover Thorin up to his chest – Fili’s heart shudders. Laid up here, his uncle looks small, vulnerable, and he balls his fingers into fists until his nails dig painfully into the flesh of his palms.
If only –
“Fili”, Thorin’s familiar voice calls, gentle and hoarse, “Come here.”
His eyes begin to burn as he lifts his head. Thorin is looking at him; his eyes again clear and calm, and there is not a trace of anger or blame to be found.
Dimly Fili is aware of the others in the room. But his eyes are fixed on his uncle, his words stuck in his throat. Apologies, please for forgiveness, for understand – but he sinks down next to the bed in silence, his breath hitching in his throat.
“Fili,” Thorin rasps again and reaches out. Up close Fili spies the bandages under the covers, the terrible pallor of his uncle’s skin and wishes they could exchange places-
Thorin’s hand cups his cheek, pulls him close. The gesture lacks strength, but Fili follows willingly, allows himself to bask in this warmth that he knows he no longer deserves. That he –
“Don’t cry, my sister-son,” Thorin rumbles, a thumb brushing the wetness from Fili’s cheek, “Do not cry, please.”
“Uncle, I…” Fili manages before his voice breaks. He reaches up, draws Thorin’s hand between his own, pulls it to his chest.
Thorin looks at him fondly. “I wish I had more time to spend with you, and your brother. I wish these last week had been different,” he says quietly, “I failed as a leader and as your uncle. When I should have looked for your wellbeing, I looked for gold – do not be sad, Fili, you know this.”
Thorin’s breath stutters for a moment and somebody in the background moves. Fili does not look up, keeps his eyes fixed on his uncle.
“I am proud to call you my nephews. My heirs,” Thorin continues, softer now, “You did not fall for the gold’s spell – you stood up and protected my kin and company when I failed at my task. I cannot thank you enough for stopping me, Fili, know this.”
The hand Fili is holding wraps clumsy fingers around his own and squeezes.
“I shall pass glad to know my kingdom and loved ones in such capable hands,” Thorin whispers. Then, with great effort, he turns his head.
“Balin, make sure the histories tell the truth,” he rasps, “Make sure all know who the heroes of today truly are.”
Balin – who Fili now sees hovering at the head of the bed, eyes sad and grave – gives a short nod. “Aye, Thorin, I will see it done.”
Thorin chuckles. “And, old friend, do not downplay your own part in this quest. Dwalin, make sure your brother does not.” He smiles at the brothers, eyes shining with a gladness that breaks Fili’s heart, “And I’d ask you to look after my kin in my stead. If you would do me this last favor, as a friend.”
Dwalin’s eyes glint wetly in the dim light. He grits his tears. “I will, Thorin, I will.”
Thorin shifts a little more to look at Bilbo. The hobbit sits on the other side of the bed, mirroring Fili’s position. A white bandage wrapped hastily around his head does not hide the bruises blossoming beneath, nor the tear tracks on his face.
“Master burglar… Bilbo,” Thorin begins, softly, “I wish we had more time for I would have loved to share with you and experience all these things you have told me of. I should have –“
“No, Thorin,” Bilbo interrupts, his voice thin and squeaky, “Do not regret what happened, because I would not have had it any other way.”
Fresh tears trail down his face, before Bilbo bows his head and hair covers it from view. Not Thorin’s though, and Fili watches his uncle’s expression soften further.
“You have a kindly heart, my burglar,” Thorin murmurs, “And I wish the world will appreciate it wherever you chose to go.”
A choked noise escapes from Bilbo and the hobbit curls further into himself. Balin takes a step forward, resting a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder, while Thorin once more turns toward Fili.
“Fili, Kili, my beloved nephews,” Thorin says, looking at them with that old fondness, the spark Fili had watched flicker and vanish during the quest, “No uncle could wish for finer nephews, no father for better sons. Tell your mother I apologize for all the perils I lead you into, and ask her to forgive an old man his faults. “
For a moment Thorin seems about to add something. Then his lips slowly form a smile, soft and relieved, and he closes his eyes. One last exhale leaves his lips – then his chest stays still.
Kili brushes past Fili with a loud sob, falls down on the bed next to Thorin. Fili’s ears ring, barely hearing the commotion. Does not see Oin step forward, reach for Thorin’s wrist.
Only when a hand firmly grasps his shoulder and gently pulls him away, Fili glances up. Dwalin looks down at him, red-rimmed eyes free of recrimination.
“Come away, lad,” he says, “He’s gone.”
And the world falls apart.
***
Fili does not know how time passes after this. Everything is blurred, astray. There are negotiations he does not participate in; not daring to show his face. Elves and men, they know what he has done. And once Dain arrives, only to find battle no longer imminent, the knowledge spreads.
Kinslayer, they whisper. Dwalin growls and Ori spins tales, but it doesn’t help. Because it doesn’t change the truth, Fili thinks. The truth that it was his sword that claimed Thorin’s life. He murdered his uncle. He is a kinslayer, there is no point in denying it.
And there is no point in staying in Erebor, either.
He cannot in good conscience expect anybody to accept him as King, not with the blood that stains his hands. There is no desire in his chest for the crown either – Erebor has cost him so much already, and he wonders if it was worth it.
So he tells Kili he will leave. Of course, his brother wants to come. “Where you go, I go,” Kili insists, but Fili shakes his head.
Erebor needs a Durin on the throne, and Erebor needs a young and healthy ruler. Kili is the best fit, and he deserves the crown. Fili stays for his coronation, but leaves the celebrations early to pack. He isn’t quite certain where he will go – perhaps west, perhaps south. Perhaps visit his mother, though he wonders what she thinks of him now.
News must have spread all over Middle Earth. He should stay away from dwarven settlements.
A short knock on the door interrupts him, and it is Bilbo who enters. The hobbit looks changed under the layers of fur and gold-trimmed clothes. His eyes look older, but they have lost none of their gentleness when they rest on Fili – and Fili isn’t certain if he should. Because when he killed Thorin he both saved Bilbo’s life and murdered his beloved, so he’d understand if Bilbo hated him. Or at least avoided him.
Instead, the hobbit takes a look at his packed up belongings and sighs. “Kili said you were preparing to leave,” he says, “Have you put any thought into where you’re going to go?”
Fili shrugs. “Wander, I suppose.”
Bilbo frowns. “If that is what you want, I’m not going to stop you. But how about you come to the Shire with me? There is space enough in Bag End.”
Fili blinks, turns back to Bilbo. “You … aren’t staying?” he asks, uncertain. Somehow he thought Bilbo would stay – the hobbit has been deeply embroiled in negotiations and everybody likes him. To the point that he’s treated with the same respect as Kili is; considered Thorin’s consort though no official statement has ever been made and Bilbo refused the title when it had been offered.
Bilbo shakes his head. “The mountain … it will be a beautiful place, no doubt. But I’m a hobbit. My place is in the Shire.”
No, Fili thinks, studying Bilbo, this hobbit probably no longer truly has a place in the Shire. But this is a mountain filled with memories, and he can understand the wish to escape them. Perhaps his uncles wish will come true and Bilbo will find happiness – but it is unlikely he will find it with Erebor.
Just like Fili, Bilbo does not fit into this Erebor that will prosper and grow. He may not have struck the killing blow, but he traded the Arkenstone and Fili knows that some remember this, too. This mountain will never truly be home to either of them.
Nor will they ever fit into the Shire.
Bilbo shrugs. “Consider it, Fili,” he says, “You know Bag End has spare rooms.”
Maybe it would be a little less lonely.
