Actions

Work Header

Episodes from Middle Earth

Chapter 51: This is not a victory

Summary:

Bilbo does not survive the battle.

Notes:

This was another tumblr ficlet based on the posts by buriedbilbo and the amazing art by french-unicorn.

Heads up for violence, pain, and character death.

Chapter Text

A gust of freezing wind blows over the frozen river. Thorin shudders, and finally tears his gaze from Azog’s dead body. Orcrist pins the pale form to the ground; Thorin forced the blade deep into the ice, and now finds he can’t quite pull it out.

He takes a deep breath and the icy air burns in his lungs. His body yet throbs with battle fever, though the heat in his blood begins to abate. The sounds of battle coming from below have faded, and the world up here has been returned to utter silence. The dead bodies of numerous orcs lie on the ice around them, their black blood staining the clear white.  Thorin looks down and finds himself leaving bright red footprints –

The cut to his leg still bleeds sluggishly, and he sways on his feet for a moment. Azog’s blade caught him across the thigh. It’s not a deep cut, certainly not fatal, though now it begins to sting as life reasserts itself to Thorin’s fatigued body.

He turns his back, wondering numbly what to do.

Azog is dead.

He’d hoped for this for so long, yet now it leaves Thorin staring blankly across the frozen expanse. Erebor is reclaimed – but what about his actions before, what about the fallen? Where are his nephews, where are his companions? What will happen now?

Swaying like a drunk man, Thorin makes his way back toward the crumbled tower. But the spot where he remembers Fili falling is empty. Rusty lined cracks run through the ice, and no, Azog stabbing Fili was no nightmare. A part of Thorin wants to believe it was, but that moment has burned itself onto the back of eyelids.

He will –

Azog’s dead.

Thorin forces himself to take another, burning breath.  If Fili’s body is gone, there is a chance his nephew survived. He doubts the orcs would have removed the body – more likely Kili and Dwalin and Bilbo carried him to safety.
And with some luck they remained in safety, too.

Too much blood already stains Thorin’s hands. Death would have been easier then dealing with the aftermath of what he did while under the dragon-sickness. And he’d not expected to walk from this alive, had only wanted to see Azog perish, and then would have been more than happy to close his own ice.
But here he is, the last one standing on this frozen scene of desolation.

The wind tears at his clothes and hair, both heavy with dried blood and filth, and he begins to move again. Boulders seem to be tied to his feet, and each step takes gargantuan effort. The other side of the river isn’t coming any closer.

And it feels as if it takes an eternity, but Thorin reaches the crumbled staircase leading down from Ravenhill. His head swim as he climbs down the first flight of stairs. The snow is stained by black blood; a layer of frost covers the dead orcs.

But there are droplets of red staining the snow, too, and Thorin’s heart clenches. Who was hurt here, he wonders? Dwalin, Fili, Kili, and Bilbo should have been gone. Who …

He staggers down another flight of stairs, surveys unmoving bodies sprawled across another ruined building. The color has been bleached from all of them, and perhaps that is what makes the red stand out so brightly.

Thorin blinks.

Red?

Another gust of wind blows past him, and that is dark blond curls moving with it. The face underneath has grown pale, as all around him, and for a moment Thorin flounders, his mind struggling to comprehend what he’s seeing.

Then the situation slams into him.

He stumbles over, disregarding the uneven ground, the patches of ice, the painful tug on his own wounds. But that unmoving figure is Bilbo, and he should have realized at once; he’s so much smaller than the orcs. He half-lies, half-leans against a crumbled wall; dried blood covering his forehead and matting his curls, while brighter red stains the snow underneath him. The worn blue coat is darker in some places then others, and Thorin’s stomach twists.

Bilbo doesn’t stir.

Thorin’s knees give out. He drops to the ground, breath stuttering. His hand hovers over Bilbo’s body, afraid to touch him (and find him cold and gone and his world is already crumbling. Bilbo looks too small lying here, so terribly far from his home. What was Gandalf thinking, what was Thorin thinking; they should have never let him come -)

Then he catches sight of a small cloud of fog rising from Bilbo’s lips and he realizes the hobbit still breathes. Thorin surges forward, feels for the pulse – and feels a slow, shallow beat under his fingers. Bilbo’s skin is frighteningly pale, almost ashen already, and Thorin anxiously studies him for injuries. And there are many, too many –

A big gash on his head, scrapes on his cheeks, cuts on his hands. A deep cut near his collarbone, just above the mithril – and a horrendous gash on his leg. It cuts deep, into the bone, and Thorin hisses. Bilbo’s trousers are stained black from blood; the foot has turned purple.

Thorin curses.

Bilbo needs help now.

He reaches out to gather Bilbo in his arms, when the hobbit stirs. Bilbo makes a soft sound, somewhere between a pained whine and a groan; his eyelashes flutter. Thorin hurries to draw Bilbo against him, shelter him from the cold at least, but the eyes that open are dazed and stare toward the sky. The body in his arms shudders weakly and then just lies there, lax.

“Bilbo?” Thorin asks; anxiety building up in his chest.

The hobbit remains unresponsive and another gust of wind blows past, reminding Thorin painfully of the time he’s losing. Bilbo’s eyelids flutter once again, and Thorin leans forward until he’s practically curled around Bilbo.

“Bilbo? Bilbo, please.”

“… Thorin?” It’s barely even a whisper. Or maybe just his imagination. But Bilbo’s glazed eyes move slowly, and he struggles to focus.

“Bilbo?” Thorin pleads. “Bilbo, are you with me?”

Bilbo makes another soft sound and stirs a little. Thorin’s grip tightens automatically. “Bilbo?”

“… you,” Bilbo mumbles, “I thought…”  A harsh cough cuts him off abruptly. It jerks his body violently, and fear sinks deep into Thorin’s veins. Blood splatters from Bilbo’s lips, dark and hot, and despair assails Thorin.

This –

The dark, terrible realization lurks just outside of his conscious thought. But he knows, he already knows. Knew the moment he saw the wound.

“Thorin,” Bilbo murmurs again, moving weakly. His eyes, dull and filled with pain that should have never been there, search for Thorin. “Thorin, I … I never wanted … I’m sorry… I…”

“Hush, Bilbo, hush,” Thorin forces out. Hot liquid wells up in his eyes; his heart is being torn apart. Bilbo should not be here, should have never been forced so far from home, and its all his fault. He pushes to his feet, staggering momentarily before setting off.

“Just hold on,” he tells the hobbit in his arms. “I’ll bring you to safety. Oin will take care of you. Everything will be alright, you’ll see.”

Just please hold on. Even if it hurts, even if the darkness beckons, please.

“… ‘m sorry,” Bilbo echoes, confusion flickering over his face.

“No, Bilbo,” Thorin interrupts as he forces his stiff body forward. “No, you don’t have to apologize for a thing. I was blind, utterly blind, and you were right. I’m sorry for how I treated you, and if I could take back my words and actions I would do so in a heartbeat.”

Bilbo blinks again, slowly. His brow ceases as he tries to process the words, and all Thorin wants to do is take the hurt away. Smooth out those lines, wipe away the dirt and heal the wounds. He quickens his steps.

“…glad I …” Bilbo murmurs against Thorin’s chest.

“Bilbo, no,” Thorin returns, not caring that his voice hitches and trembles. “It is us who are grateful for your help and company, and we have treated you poorly for it. Bilbo, if I – if there was anything –“

Anything I could do, I would.

Without hesitation, without doubt. But there are no enemies to slay, and the one remaining battle they are slowly but certainly losing. Bright blood keeps dripping to the snow despite the tourniquet, but even so, Bilbo’s pallor has grown bloodless. Deadly.

“… you have your home back,” Bilbo murmurs quietly. A shadow of a smile ghosts across his face.

Thorin blinks back tears. “Yes, yes. We reclaimed it thanks to you, Bilbo.”

A frown crosses Bilbo’s face once more. Another bout of coughs wrecks his body. Thorin presses his lips together, looks ahead. The tents before Erebor are still so very, very far away.

And even then –

“… Laketown?” Bilbo murmurs. His eyes are drooping again, and fear stabs Thorin into the stomach. No, he wants to scream, no. Please once, may the fates be kind.

“We’ll make amends,” Thorin promises. “I’ll see to it that Bard and everyone else get their share of the treasure. They’ll get all the help we can offer.”

If he’d not allowed the sickness to take hold. If he’d been on guard. If he’d – then perhaps they wouldn’t be here, and he wouldn’t be carrying Bilbo’s body from a battle he should have never been part of.

Bilbo smiles; a quiet expression on his colorless face. “Ahh, Thorin, you… you have always… been so good. Your heart… is … rather beautiful, I think. … and had I time I might have … liked to stay.” His eyes crinkle, and Thorin’s heart cries out in pain.

“You will, Bilbo, you will,” he promises, words rushing forward. “Stay as long as you want. Erebor will always be open to you; will offer you a home.”

“Stay… see Erebor prosper,” Bilbo mumbles. “See you rule… and all be well…”

“Bilbo, you will –“

One last exhale, and then the body in his arms grows entirely still.

Thorin’s steps falter.

“No,” he murmurs, “No, please, Bilbo –“

The body in his arms doesn’t stir. Even the subtle tremors, the shallow rise and fall of his chest – all has ceased. Instead, Bilbo’s face now looks relaxed, at peace, though the pain has left visible lines. The blood, the injuries, the sunken cheeks, the shadows underneath his eyes – those things ought not to have come to pass, ought to have never happened.

“Bilbo.” His voice trembles.

“Bilbo, please.”

“Bilbo, don’t -. Please, don’t, don’t do this. Bilbo, we’re there soon. Were down and then they’ll take care of you. Oin will fix you. Or Gandalf – he’ll be glad to help. But, please- please don’t –“

In the cold gust of wind, Bilbo’s hair is the only thing that stirs. 

Thorin sways on his feet. The camp is not far now, but the body in his arms is still. Too still. Without breath or heartbeat or any sign of life, and that cannot be it. Bilbo had just been speaking. He’d been badly hurt but alive.

He cannot be dead!

“Please Bilbo, wake up,” Thorin pleads as the strength drains from his legs and he sinks to his knees. “Please don’t be dead.” His vision swims and it doesn’t matter. There is no need for urgency any longer. He’s late, too late, and he can never make up for this. Bilbo will not look at him another time and tell him all’s forgiven.

Bilbo will never look at him again.

“Please, one last miracle. One last time, for me. Please, Bilbo. I will do anything, but please, please, open your eyes. Just one last time. Please.”

Thorin squeezes his eyes shut, buries his face in Bilbo’s blood-matted curls. Underneath the dried blood some warmth remains, and a part of Thorin desperately wishes for Bilbo to open his eyes, to flinch, to scream –

Anything. If it only brought him back to life.

“Thorin,” a new voice breaks through the haze, and only now Thorin hears the footsteps hurrying up the stairs, “Thorin, are you alright?”

He pulls Bilbo’s body closer against his own, blinks away the tears and sees a tall figure clad in grey hurry toward him. The wizard looks haggard; his cloak has been torn and stained, and he’s out of breath.

“Thorin –“

And then Gandalf sees the small body Thorin holds protectively.

“Bilbo!”

Anger and hope war in Thorin’s chest, because Gandalf should have been there. Gandalf should have looked after Bilbo, should have protected him. Should have never brought him along.

“Save him,” Thorin mutters, his voice coming out choked and far to silent, and Gandalf staggers. “Save him!” he roars again.

“What happened?” Gandalf asks and hurriedly crouches before Thorin. “Where is he –“ His hand halts just over Bilbo’s shoulder. “Thorin, is he –“

“Save him!” Thorin shouts. He barely even feels the tears on his face or the wounds on his own body. “There must be something you can do!”

Gandalf’s face falls in grief and his hand sinks down on Bilbo’s shoulder. “Thorin, I can’t-“

“There must be some spell! Some sort of magic!” Despair tears apart Thorin’s soul, and he can’t, he can’t allow Bilbo’s story to end here. This cannot be the end. “Please! He came here for you! You must save him!”

“Thorin,” Gandalf interrupts gently, though his face now has gained deep lines, “I’m sorry. There is nothing I can do.”

“No!” Thorin shouts and draws Bilbo back; out of the wizard’s reach. “You brought him here! You should have protected him! He was with you when the battle started! Why did you not look out for him?”

“I tried to,” Gandalf replies and his shoulders bow under guilt and grief, “Yet I had others to see after, and he snuck away.”

“You should have looked after him better than that!” Thorin accuses. “He deserved better!” Not just from Gandalf, but from Thorin, too. From all of them – for his courage, his bravery, and his steadfast loyalty even in the darkest hour.

“He should not die here,” Thorin mutters. The last bit of hope in his heart flickers and dies, and he can only look down at Bilbo’s peaceful face, for the world has ceased to matter.

“No,” Gandalf agrees wearily, “He should not have.”

The wizard sighs. “If there was any magic that could bring him back, I would not hesitate to use it. But Bilbo is beyond our reach now. I’m sorry.”

Sorry is not enough, Thorin thinks. Not when Bilbo can’t even hear their words. Not when he will never be able to tell Bilbo what he meant to Thorin either. So Thorin tightens his hold on the cooling body while Gandalf sits silently next to him.

Erebor is won.

But to Thorin, the battle was lost.