Chapter Text
“What?” Thorin’s voice flutters breathlessly, too quiet, too high, and yet too loud in the cold night. Overhead the stars are veiled. A busy murmur pulses through the torch-lit camp around them and in his chest his heart has stopped.
Gandalf, his face grieved and aged and burdened beyond words, turns his eyes downward and quietly shakes his head.
The world fades. Background noise fades into silence, the icy wind’s caress vanishes, and yet Thorin shivers as his world narrows into a darkening tunnel and time grinds to a stop.
Because of what Gandalf said. It cannot be true.
“No,” he protests. His voice rises. “No. Gandalf!”
The wizard gazed at him sadly and then turns toward the tent behind him. A warm light emanates from within; but Thorin has grown numb as he follows Gandalf inside.
It's quiet inside. Thick carpets keep the din outside, a fire crackles merrily in an oven in the corner, several oil lamps provide light. Thorin does not feel the warmth, does not notice the silence - his eyes are drawn to the still figure lying on a cot in the middle of the tent. Various bottles and medical instruments yet stand next to where a pale hand rests on faded blankets - the healers have already moved on.
Thorin’s breath hitches.
Under timeworn, once-luxurious covers Bilbo lies peacefully, his face relaxed as if asleep. However, his chest neither rises nor falls, and the bandages wrapped around his head are white despite the dried blood that taints strands of curly hair a darker hue.
And as Thorin’s heart breaks, Gandalf speaks.
“I'm so sorry, Thorin,” he says. “I wish I knew what happened.”
Pain bubbles up in Thorin’s chest. “He was safe,” he protests, as his fingers clench. “He was safe when I left him.”
Left him with you, Thorin does not say.
Gandalf’s expression twists with unspeakable sorrow. Thorin doesn't see it; his glassy eyes fixed on Bilbo, and he reverently steps closer to the cot.
“I know. I thought the same.” Gandalf bows his head. He knows what Thorin sees; he was here before and laid his own hands on Bilbo’s chest, disbelief cursing through his veins as he sought to understand.
“Why did you leave him?” Thorin's voice trembles. He recalls carrying Bilbo to the camp, recalls the warmth of Bilbo’s hands when they last touched him. Why did you leave him, he silently shouts at himself.
“I thought he was safe.”
A pained noise that isn't quite human escapes Thorin’s throat. He reaches out, hesitates - then crumbles to his knees next to the cot, one hand clenching the fabric next to Bilbo’s hand. It has grown pallid already, and probably cold.
But Thorin can’t yet make himself confirm it; cannot yet cross that slight gap and take Bilbo’s hand. Not when he still remembers those fingers weakly holding onto his own. His eyes burn and he squeezes them shut.
“We will find out what happened,” Gandalf vows, and there is something dark in his voice, something that echoes through time and space, and yet fails to touch Thorin. “We will.”
Thorin exhales quietly. Then he opens his eyes and turns his gaze to Bilbo’s face. Somebody kindly wiped away the blood and grime, but he is too pale, his cheekbones too sharp. When Thorin thinks of Bilbo he remembers sun-kissed cheeks, sparkling eyes, and a wide smile.
Now nothing of that remains.
“He should never have come,” Thorin whispers, though whether he blames Gandalf or himself he does not know.
“Perhaps,” Gandalf allows with a small sigh. “But I doubt he would agree.”
No, Thorin thinks, of course not. In spite of everything Bilbo had shown remarkable tenacity and a stubbornness that put many dwarves to shame. He’d also taken great joy in being contrary - if only to rile Thorin up.
Behind him a rustle of cloth betrays Gandalf moving. The wizard steps to the other side of the cot and reaches for a bundle sitting among the abandoned medical instruments. Thorin has paid it no attention, but now he realizes it does look surprisingly familiar.
Gandalf picks it up and begins to unwrap it. A strange heaviness accompanies his words, but When Thorin catches sight of a familiar glow his heart sinks.
“We were rather surprised to discover Bilbo had the Arkenstone on him.”
***
The first time Bilbo touches the Arkenstone he knows.
He had suspected it, of course. Hearing the dwarves’ name for it the connection had not been difficult to make. Still, among hobbits - they’d always spoken of it as a myth, a rumor.
Something curious, but irrelevant.
Bilbo purses his lips as he turns the stone over in his hands. Perhaps these old myths are not quite as irrelevant as he always thought.
“Would it help, do you think? Would it help Thorin if the stone was found?” he dares to ask Balin at one point and holds his breath in the suffocating stillness of Erebor these days.
But Balin shakes his head and speaks of madness. Below them, in the treasury, Thorin sinks deeper into the clutches of a different curse. One where the strange tingling Bilbo feels in his fingers whenever he touches the Arkenstone is of no consequence.
***
“The Arkenstone?” Thorin asks, taken aback. A part of him wants so shout at the wizard to discard the stone; wants nothing to do with the cursed gem. But underneath that fury lurk questions, and Thorin cannot help but recall.
His own fingers digging into the soft, warm skin of Bilbo’s shoulder. The scared but determined glint in the hobbit’s eye. And the shared smiles when they’d met on the battlefield and put all of that behind.
Now the warmth, the spark, and the smile are gone. Forever.
Thorin's gaze drifts back to Bilbo’s still body; the thought echoing in his mind like a thunderclap. Forever. He won't ever see Bilbo smile again.
Meanwhile Gandalf uncovers the stone and its glow brightens the interior of the tent. Thorin wearily glances over. He’d thought the gem’s part in the story over.
But apparently he’d been wrong.
“Indeed,” the wizard remarks while a contemplative frown pulls on his forehead. “I do not know when he took it; nor do I know why.”
***
When Bilbo recalls the rumors next, his throat aches from phantom fingers, and bruises form where his back pressed against uneven stone. But most of all, his heart aches - with loss, and grief and fear, and he sticks close to Gandalf as the wizard directs them back to Dale. Orc horns echo over the valley; elves and dwarves and men scramble into formation.
But black smoke already rises on the horizon and ever new tunnels open with thunderous clamor to the north. Fresh legions of orcs and goblins tumble into the fray; hungry for flesh and blood. Even the sky seems overcome with despair, and in his heart Bilbo hopes Erebor’s closed gate will protect his dwarves.
They might outlast the battle. Even if he, Bard, and so many others won't.
The orcs number far too many.
“Go, Master Baggins! To the hall!” Gandalf orders, pushing Bilbo up a cobblestoned street. Around them men and women rush back and forth; some planning to barricade themselves in the city hall; others picking up what weapons they find to fight. Bilbo stumbles, because he has Sting tied to his belt and a mithril vest under his coat.
“But - “
“You will be safe there,” Gandalf says shortly. “This …” his mouth twitches and he swallows whatever he intended to say. “Go!”
And then he whirls on his heel and rushes back toward the city walls, from where a frightening cacophony of screams, blades, and crumbling stone echoes. Even before he's out of sight Gandalf draws his blade - and Bilbo's own shoulder slump.
It’s unlikely he’ll see the next sunrise.
“Go inside boy!” somebody shouts his way, rushing past with a rusty pike in hand.
Bilbo’s head swims. He should go inside, hide. He’s no fighter; he should hand Sting to somebody who knows how to use it. Maybe it will help.
Maybe it will save just one life.
Behind him the mountains shudder as another earthworm bursts through. Bilbo can see the flying rocks in the distance, and his stomach sinks. So many, he thinks, what chance do we have? Even if he hides, what good will it do?
“Heaven help us,” somebody mutters, and Bilbo’s heart echoes the sentiment. His fingers tremble, and he finally turns toward the entrance to the hall with his feet feeling like lead. Overhead the sky grows darker, and the mountains rumble dangerously.
It’s as if the earth itself -
Oh, Bilbo thinks.
His feet stop on their own. Men and women keep running. Shouting. Screaming.
Dying.
Bilbo can still hear his grandmother’s voice as she narrated that tale. Now, between the screams and the rumbling, he can hear it once again. Words, almost forgotten, drift past him like a light breeze that breaks the oppressive gloom lingering over the crumbling city.
There is power in the earth.
Abruptly he swivels to the right. Thranduil’s tent was next to the hall; he remembers. Bilbo pushes through the crowd, ignores the shouts of protest, turns the corner - and breathes a sigh of relief when the tent still sits there. One lone elf remains on guard, but this time Bilbo doesn’t hesitate to slip on his ring.
The world shifts into blurred grey; the noises dim into a distant roar of screams and ringing weapons. Only the lone elven sentry glows bright, and that makes it easy for Bilbo to avoid him despite his heart thundering in his chest. He slips into the tent, a cold gust of wind following him.
The interior looks unchanged from the night before. Bilbo’s gaze wanders and for a moment panic rises in his mind: what if the Arkenstone is not here? What if it was taken away already? But then he spies the elegant wooden box sitting in the corner, and he knows the stone is within.
He sighs in relief.
Now that he looks for it, he can sense the stone humming with power. Its promise sings to Bilbo’s ears; joined by its unearthly glow as Bilbo opens the box and draws out the stone. His fingers tingle, yet the sweat drying on his back feels cold.
Outside, the mountains rumble.
Is it possible, Bilbo wonders.
The Arkenstone pulses in his hand.
Power in the earth. And a long time ago our ancestors knew how to wield it.
A gust of cold wind blows open the tent flap. Torches and fires light the plain; ruins have turned to black shadow as the sky has started to fade to starless black. But still Erebor’s towering silhouette remains visible and beckons to Bilbo.
Another orc horn blows. The wind carries faint screams and the smell of charred flesh.
Bilbo looks to Erebor. The wind is stronger now, he thinks. It’s picking up. Changing.
A shudder that is not only due to the cold runs down his spine. He knows what he must do.
***
“At first I thought he may have taken it to return it to you,” Gandalf says quietly.
Thorin straightens where he kneels. “He didn't …” He never even mentioned it.
“Yes,” Gandalf replies, interrupting the weak protest. “He didn't give it to you.” The wizard falls silent, but Thorin can guess at the question himself.
Why, then, did Bilbo have the Arkenstone in his possession?
***
Bilbo reaches Ravenhill with his lungs afire and his legs trembling. He does not know how many blades he dodged on sheer luck alone, and how many dead and dying he passed. But blood now clings to his skin and clothes, and does trickle from a shallow cut over his ear where he did not duck fast enough.
An icy gust of wind cools the sweat on his forehead and Bilbo feels the earth stir underneath his feet. The Arkenstone throbs in his hand.
He draws a shuddering breath. Walks forward until the place feels right. Snow-dusted ruins surround him; black silhouettes in the night, while fires flicker like tiny lights on the battlefield below. Perhaps it would be better to do this in the mountain itself; at the place where the stone was once found.
But Erebor’s gate remains shut - and Bilbo is grateful, because like this he knows his dwarves are safe and hale and not dying down like so many others - and the stone in his hand glows brightly. Brighter than before.
Ravenhill is good enough.
There is power in the earth. Power older than magic. Men and elves, they long have forgotten. Dwarves once knew it through their gems and jewels, but in the end that blinded them.
Bilbo takes a deep breath, flexes his fingers. Sets the stone before him, sits back.
And even our kind barely recalls what it is. We can feel what ground is fertile, and what ground has spoiled, but we, too, have lost the skills to wield its power.
How, Bilbo had asked of his grandmother, young and naive, can you wield it?
Bilbo’s fingers tingle, even though his fingers aren’t touching the stone. And there is something in the air. Churning, shifting - Bilbo can sense it. He may not be a wizard, may just be one little hobbit, but he can sense the earth stir.
It’s the earth. You cannot yield it. Nobody can.
Bilbo purses his lips. Concentrates.
Because of the price.
Bilbo puts his hands down on the Arkenstone.
***
“Its glow appears diminished,” Gandalf murmurs, drawing Thorin from his grief. He has not risen from his knees; does not know if he will ever have the strength too. His hands have found Bilbo’s; gently enfolding it between his own.
Now he casts a bleary glance toward the wizard who hovers, his staff drawn, over the Arkenstone.
“I … wouldn’t know,” Thorin replies wearily. Perhaps the stone’s light has lessened, but to him the stone has ceased to matter.
“No, it has,” Gandalf mutters mostly to himself. “I wonder…”
***
Victory was impossible when night fell. But at some point the wind changes. A supply tunnel collapses. An earthworm turns against the orcs.
Within Erebor Thorin Oakenshield awakens from the curse. A more primal, older power surges through him, casts off the gold’s thrall. And he recognizes Erebor for what she is and knows his duty.
Then Erebor’s horn echoes over the plains and ruins, and fortunes change. The dwarves of Erebor throw themselves into the battle, easily cutting into rows of confused orcs. Revived, Dain and his dwarves follow. The elves regroup, only to round up stragglers and before long the flow of the battle has irrevocably shifted.
Bolg’s army never makes it. An avalanche kills half of them and destroys their passage through the mountains. The altered winds trouble the bats. And then the eagles descend; their powerful wings built for whirling and stirring air, and long before morning dawns men and dwarves and elves know that they will win this battle.
Up on Ravenhill, Bilbo lets go of the Arkenstone with an exhausted sigh. His eyelids flutter and he can feel the cold creeping into his veins.
There is a price.
One he pays, gladly, he thinks as he closes his eyes.
***
Footsteps interrupt Thorin’s dark thoughts again. Instead of passing somebody pulls aside the tent flap - a curse lies on Thorin’s lips already; he wants no interruption. But when he looks up and catches sight of Bofur’s face those words turn to ash.
The miner looks worn; his clothes splattered with blood and his face has only hastily been wiped clean. He should be resting somewhere, Thorin thinks, but then he knows where Bofur is looking, and can see realization set in.
“Master Bofur,” Gandalf begins, politely clearing his throat, and Thorin wonders if the wizard is about to usher him out. However, of the three of them, Bofur probably was the best friend to Bilbo. If any of them has a right to be here, it is him.
“So it’s true then,” Bofur murmurs softly, and Thorin swallows hard. “I had hoped the rumor wasn’t true.” The expression with which he looks at Bilbo is both sad and gentle, but he makes no move to approach.
Thorin feels like he should move. Bofur is Bilbo’s friend, not the mad king that tried to kill him. He ought to have this place, he ought to -
“Oh, the stone is here?” Bofur instead turns toward Gandalf with mild interest. “Did Bilbo have it?”
Gandalf’s brow furrows; Thorin wishes he could just destroy the stone once and for all. It only brought them grief and to Bilbo, ultimately, death. It’s -
“Its light has dimmed, too, I think,” Bofur remarks, crouching low to look at the stone closely. “It’s still dimming, isn’t it, Gandalf?”
His tone remains mildly curious. But there’s something in his voice that makes Thorin turn to watch over his shoulder and Gandalf purse his lips.
“I believe so, yes,” the wizard confirms, strangely hesitant. “But your stone sense is far better than mine, so you probably know.”
Suspicion colors Gandalf’s voice. He’s right, Thorin knows Bofur’s stone sense is unparalleled in their generation, but he can’t follow the implications. Not when Bilbo’s hand is still growing colder with each passing moment.
“You didn’t feel it, then?” Bofur inquires.
Now both Thorin and Gandalf stiffen. “Feel what?” the wizard demands, tone bristling with power.
Bofur gazes back to Bilbo and his lips twist into a small, sad smile. “I think I know what happened.”
***
Amid the ruins and frozen landscapes of Ravenhill, Thorin Oakenshield slays Azog the Defiler. Breathing hard, he stares at the head of his enemy, his mind still awash in disbelief while his body continues to hum with battle-fever. But the icy air cools him down, and the black blood seeping into the ice tells him that Azog is truly dead.
After so long, the orc has finally been slain, and Thorin scarcely can believe it.
Eventually he turns away and relief smooths some of the creases in his brow. Overhead the sky has begun to lighten, and the sounds of battle are dying down below. He can see where the elves have gathered to sweep the mountains for stragglers, and where the men of Dale proceed through the town to chase any remaining orc out of its hiding place.
He needs to go down there and help.
Killing Azog exhausted him, but for a few cuts and bruises he is unhurt. He knows he owes the men down there an apology, even if the words have to wait. Letting them see him defend their homes will help mend the rift.
But more than anything he wishes to apologize to Bilbo, even though words cannot take back his actions. Cannot undo the hurt he caused.
Thorin sighs quietly to himself and sheathes Orcrist. As long as Bilbo is safe, he will be satisfied. What he can do for the hobbit’s happiness he will do.
But whether or not Bilbo will even want to look at him or be his friend after what happened…
Thorin morosely shakes his head and turns away. He brought this one upon himself; he needs to step up to his responsibilities. The sun crests the horizon and the air begins to feel warmer.
Lost in thought, he almost misses the spot of blue among the grey and white of ice-covered rocks. Patches of a familiar coat.
His heart sinks. It can't be -
Thorin leaves the staircase and crosses the distance. Nestled between the crumbling ruins of Ravenhill’s watchtower lies a small body.
No, Thorin breathes to himself. No.
His feet pick up speed, his mind starts whirling. Not Bilbo, he shouldn't be here. He was with Gandalf - the wizard ought to have kept him safe. He shouldn't be here -
The figure lies face-down, slumped over. But the matted curls that flutter in the wind leave no doubt to his identity.
With his heart in his throat Thorin drops to his knees. His fingers tremble when he reaches out, and he doesn't dare to breathe -
The skin under his fingers feels clammy, but he can feel a pulse. It's weaker than he likes, but Bilbo steady. Relief slams into Thorin so hard he bends over.
He's alive.
And, as far as Thorin can see, not hurt. He swallows he dread that still renders his knees weak and reaches out to turn Bilbo over.
The hobbit flops limply first, and Thorin again breathes out when he finds no injuries on Bilbo’s front either. Then a frown crosses Bilbo’s face and before Thorin can decide on what to do the hobbit’s eyes open.
Thorin freezes. Bilbo …
He has every right to not want to see Thorin’s face ever again.
But Bilbo mainly looks confused. “Thorin?” he asks, voice hoarse and slurred.
“Yes,” Thorin confirms and when Bilbo’s hand seems to reach for him he catches it gently.
He has no right.
Once Bilbo’s mind clears…
The hobbit blinks. “The battle?” he wonders. “What happened?”
“We won,” Thorin says and look toward the brightening sky. Below they will nearly be done finishing off the stragglers. “The eagles came.”
Bilbo smiles. “I'm glad…” he murmurs. “Azog?”
“Dead,” Thorin confirms. “I slew him not far from here.”
“Good,” Bilbo returns with conviction. He makes an effort to sit up, but visibly lacks the strength. There is a pallor to his face Thorin doesn’t like.
“Stay still,” Thorin cautions while he props Bilbo against himself. Worry rises in his chest again. “Are you hurt?”
Bilbo frowns. “I don't think so,” he replies a heartbeat too slow, and an icy fear rises in Thorin’s chest. Even though, aside from superficial cuts he cannot see any injury on Bilbo.
“How did you come to be here anyway?” Thorin wonders aloud to brush aside the rising panic. “I thought you were with Gandalf. Did you get split up during the fight?”
Bilbo grimaces, his eyes not quite meeting Thorin’s face..
“Something like that,” Bilbo murmurs, then blinks when Thorin begins to shuffle. “What are you doing?”
“We should get down,” Thorin says quietly. Concern throbs in his chest. He doesn’t like how the sluggishness clings to Bilbo, how he visibly struggles to even focus on Thorin. “I'm certain you are being missed in the camp. Also I find the ground somewhat cold to sit on.”
The shadow hovering over Bilbo’s face lifts for a moment, and his lips quirk. “... now that you say it.”
“See,” Thorin replies and carefully navigates one arm underneath Bilbo’s knees. “And I believe I know a number of dwarves who are rather concerned for you as well.”
Bilbo makes a noise of protest when Thorin stands. “Put me down, I can walk,” he insists and tugs at the sleeves of Thorin’s coat. “Thorin, you're hurt!”
“Nothing more than a scratch,” Thorin insists. “But you're not looking good.”
Now that the sun has risen Thorin can see the terrible pallor of Bilbo’s face clearly. He looks deeply exhausted, and even if Thorin can't see the cause, the idea that Bilbo has lain unconscious for so long makes his insides clench.
Bilbo doesn't reply and that worries Thorin even more. He turns back to the crumbling stairs leading down. Hopefully he'll find the wizard quickly - Gandalf will know how to help.
“Thorin,” Bilbo says thoughtfully after a moment. “I’m sorry.”
Thorin’s heart shudders. He hopes the stutter in his step isn't too conspicuous.
“Bilbo…”
“I am, really. I know what I did wasn't right, and if there had been any other way -”
“It's alright, Bilbo,” Thorin hushes. He can't stand the heartbreak in Bilbo’s voice; not when the guilt lies heavily on his own shoulders too.
“No, Thorin, it's not,” Bilbo protests and Thorin is glad to see a spark in his eye again. “You trusted me. I betrayed that trust.”
“I didn't leave you a choice,” Thorin returns. “And honestly, I ought to thank you for taking that cursed stone away.”
Bilbo chuckles weakly. Thorin tightens his grip and hurries his steps. He dares not to run, because ice and debris on the crumbling stairs challenge his footing.
Thorin swallows. “I also must make an apology of my own. Nothing I can do or say will make up for what I did, but if I could I would take back my words and deeds.” Thorin clears his throat against the invisible obstacle closing it. “Bilbo, I’m sorry. You went above and beyond the requirements of that contract, and I will forever be indepted to you. All of Erebor will.”
Bilbo smiles. Exhausted, but warm. “Well, then I’m glad,” he announces with a small sigh that Thorin can feel going through the body in his arms. “But you needn’t be so grateful; I merely did what I could.”
Thorin allows his own shoulders to relax a little. He doesn’t like how boneless Bilbo feels in his arms - it’s unlike him. But the battle has worn them all down, and Thorin is glad when his ears pick up noises from the camp below.
Elves, dwarves, and men have pitched tents and now work together, running between the tents, carrying water, medicine and food. Smoke rises on the distant field; orc corpses piled high and set aflame. Beyond all, the Long Lake glitters under a cold sun.
“It’s beautiful,” Bilbo murmurs.
Thorin inclines his head in agreement. “It is.”
A cold gust of wind brushes Thorin’s hair from his face. In his arms, Bilbo shudders and Thorin picks up his pace again. Even with the sun shining down on the ground the air remains cold; and the body in his arms does not feel warm enough either.
“How is everyone?” Bilbo asks quietly as the sounds around them grow louder. “Did they all…”
“When I last saw them all were alive and well,” Thorin responds and suppresses his own grimace. He left the others behind hours ago - and while the battle was won, he knows it came at a price. “I’m sure they are fine. I know quite a few wanted to find you.”
Bilbo smiles slightly at that. His gaze, Thorin realizes, has been drawn toward Erebor. Her snow-covered slopes glow under the morning sun, appearing almost magical.
“They want to make their own apologies,” Thorin adds and his heart grows heavier again.
“That’s not necessary,” Bilbo returns with a snort. “I’m just glad it all turned out alright.”
Thorin’s brow creases. “Still…” he protests, trying to find the right words. Nobody had foreseen the battle. Though he wonders whether he would have given the order to join if not for Bilbo’s mad barter.
“I do wish I had never put you in a position where you had to make that decision.” Thorin tightens his grip a little as another shiver runs through Bilbo.
Bilbo closes his eyes for a moment. “I never wanted to hurt you either,” he says. “But if all is well in the end, I suppose I can’t regret my own actions too much.” He blinks and directs a more mirthful smile at Thorin.
“You should do the same, Thorin.”
Honestly, he is not too sure he can. But Thorin will agree that everything - miraculously - turned out alright in the end. And while a part of him is waiting for the other shoe to drop - fate has never been kind to his kin, to him - maybe it will allow him this happiness.
“Your majesty!”
“Thorin!”
And then they have reached the camp. Several men and dwarves recognize Thorin, while the elven healers take note of the limp figure in his arms.
“Get a healer! And then find Oin! And then the wizard!” Thorin barks at the nearest dwarf, who nods and takes off. Somebody directs him toward a tent - and then he’s turned around and told to go to another, because the King ought to have a better tent. If not for the hobbit in his arms Thorin would have protested - he needs no tent when his own mountain towers above them.
But Bilbo has grown strangely silent; his face hidden by his hair.
Eventually though, Thorin ducks into the right tent and leaves his growing tross of dignitaries and soldiers behind. The air within has thankfully been warmed - a small stove at the side sees to it. And the tent tarp has been strengthened by carpets and blankets. Even the wide cot set to the back looks more than decent - the blankets may be faded, but they still feel soft and warm.
Thorin gently sets Bilbo onto the cot. The hobbit blinks sluggishly, his eyes not really focusing. One hand lifts slightly, searching - and Thorin takes it, enfolds it within his own.
“Thorin?” Bilbo murmurs. His hand feels far too cold.
“It’s alright,” Thorin replies softly in that tone he used to soothe his nephews when nightmares kept them awake so many years ago. “I have to go and look after things. You rest for a bit, and I’ll be back before you know it.”
Bilbo relaxes at that, and Thorin smiles gently. Hopefully some rest will help Bilbo recover - he should not have been in the battle, not have lain alone in the cold for so long. So many things that shouldn’t have happened to him, and yet they did.
Thorin brushes his free hand over Bilbo’s curls. “You’ll be safe here,” he says. “Sleep well.”
***
Bofur’s words echo like thunder. Thorin’s blood has frozen, while Gandalf’s fingers are clenched around his staff. Bofur seems unmoved by either. Instead he leaves the Arkenstone behind and crosses the space to settle down on Bilbo’s other side.
Grief shines bright in his eyes.
“What happened,” Gandalf demands, nearly furious. “Master Bofur, what are you talking about?”
Thorin, too, looks to the other dwarf.
Bofur sighs. “During the battle I felt a … sort of current run through the ground,” he says quietly and reaches over with one bandaged hand to smooth a few stray curls from Bilbo’s face. “Twice.”
Thorin felt nothing. Nothing at all.
That Gandalf apparently hasn’t noticed either offers no consolation.
“The first time it was just before we left Erebor,” Bofur says, and the pit in Thorin’s chest deepens. Just before …
Did it coincide with his madness abating? Thorin had wondered at how suddenly his mind cleared, but brushed it aside in face of more urgent issues.
“Apparently the tide of the battle had already begun to shift then,” Bofur carries on. “There were some avalanches; some collapses.”
“Those did help a lot,” Gandalf adds, his forehead wrinkled. “I thought it was sheer luck, then.”
Bofur smiles grimly. “It needs a little more than luck to collapse a stable tunnel.”
Something cold runs down Thorin’s spine. A picture begins to form in his mind - but it is impossible. Utterly, totally impossible.
“Then what…” Gandalf mutters, his eyes widening as well.
“The second pulse I felt just around dawn,” Bofur continues, undaunted. “It didn’t make sense at first. But now … that was probably about the time when you found Bilbo, Thorin.”
Gandalf swivels to Thorin.
The King under the Mountain has no idea what they are implying.
“How was he when you found him?” Bofur asks, and Thorin understands that there is a hidden significance to his words, but he doesn’t understand it. Doesn’t know how to answer.
“He was unconscious,” he manages, his lips feeling unwieldy and stiff. “Cold from lying on the stone so long. Weak, too, but I couldn’t see any injury.” A terrible suspicion rises in the back of his mind: what if he killed Bilbo by moving him? What if he ought to have called help to him instead?
“I don’t think there was one,” Bofur replies, his tone gentler now. “But at that time Bilbo already ought to have been dead.”
***
Thus Erebor’s new era dawns with a funeral. It is perhaps fitting, Thorin thinks as he draws the black cloak over his shoulders and casts a look at his reflection, for many died to reclaim the mountain.
But Bilbo should not have.
He grimaces at himself. The grief is written across his features, obvious in the shadows under his eyes and the curve of his shoulders.
Bilbo should have never been in that battle. And while Thorin’s heart is selfish enough to be glad Bilbo followed them (and he knows they would have never made it without him), his heart wishes beyond everything that Bilbo was alive.
But there is no magic that can achieve this and under Thorin’s hand the Arkenstone remained cold, no matter what he tried. He’d have shed his own blood if Dwalin hadn’t stopped him.
With a sigh Thorin straightens. He leaves his chambers and heads toward the tombs under the mountain. Today, the air in Erebor has shifted. Grief shows, not only in the subdued murmurs and sad melodies echoing through its halls, but also in the dimmed lights now tinting the halls a dimmer, yet warmer hue.
Below, the grand funeral chamber has already grown crowded. Dain, Bard, Gandalf, even Thranduil - they all have come, and in their faces Thorin can see the same question that plagues him: if they are not all at fault. If they should not have let Bilbo stay in his comfortable, warm home so far, far away.
He’d be happy there now. Maybe raking in the last leaves in his garden.
Instead he lies here, dressed in foreign riches, but cold and unmoving. Even the Arkenstone’s glow from where it sits on his chest cannot hide the deathly pallor of his skin.
A fresh lance of pain pierces his heart as Thorin turns to take his seat. No, he thinks, they should never have plucked Bilbo away from his armchairs and his garden. They would not have reached Erebor; Mirkwood would have fallen, and before long the Iron Hills, too, would have been overrun by the enemy. But even so -
Bilbo’s life, Thorin now realizes, was the one price he wasn’t willing to pay.
But that realization comes too late.
***
“What?!” Gandalf explodes. Thorin freezes.
Ought to have already been dead?
“What do you mean?” he asks, his voice scarcely louder than a whisper. Bilbo had been weak, but alive.
Bofur grimaces. “I’m not entirely certain. For all I know he should have been dead then, but…” he shrugs and casts another wistful glance toward Bilbo’s face. “Using the power of the earth itself always kills the wielder. There are no exceptions. It’s why the practice has been mostly forgotten.”
Thorin blinks. He’d never even heard of it. But then, judging by his expression, Gandalf is equally dumbfounded.
“When we crossed the Shire I was surprised to find that it’s still in use. Well, in a seriously tuned down form - but Bilbo’s been quite good about sensing magic and stuff. He probably figured out what the Arkenstone was quickly.” Bofur chuckles tiredly. “I had no idea - and we call that rock the Heart of the Mountain.”
He shakes his head. In Thorin’s mind more pieces fall into place; and his veins crawl with icy realization.
“I never sensed any magic on it,” Gandalf protests weakly.
Bofur snorts. “That’s because it’s not exactly magic. The power of the earth is just that; power. And in some cases you get shortcuts to yielding it through objects like the Arkenstone.”
“Bilbo used it,” Thorin says in horror. Looks down to the still form - how could someone so small have wielded such power? Have known such a thing?
“He must have,” Bofur confirms. “I don’t know how he knew or how he did it. That knowledge was supposed to have been lost, but maybe hobbits retained it somehow.” He glances toward Gandalf, though the wizard shakes his head.
“I have never heard of such a thing,” he says in consternation.
“You said there were two pulses,” Thorin recalls. Did you use it twice, he wonders, as he glances at Bilbo’s peaceful face.
Bofur’s lips twitch. “That’s where things stop making sense,” he says. “All sources agree that even using it once will kill you. There’s no way anybody could have used it twice. And Bilbo … shouldn’t have been alive when you found him.”
“Somebody else used it?” Gandalf wonders aloud. “But the stone was with Bilbo the entire time.”
“It’s unprecedented,” Bofur agrees. “But I have a theory.”
“I think Bilbo was probably already dead when you found him,” he says bluntly, ignoring the stake those words drive through Thorin’s heart. “But either because you are King under the Mountain and in some way can affect Erebor or for some other reason - Erebor chose to expand some of her own power to Bilbo.”
“The second pulse you felt,” Gandalf mutters. Bofur confirms the guess with a nod.
“But the price had been paid; that could never be undone. Not even with the Arkenstone,” he continues, his voice softening with grief. “But perhaps the rules could be bent enough to allow a little more time.”
Fin
