Chapter Text
Fili couldn’t believe his rotten, stinking luck. His first trade mission, the one where he was finally going to prove himself to his uncle Dain and show himself as a responsible, capable adult, worthy of inheritance, and of course the ship had to be attacked by pirates. Of course.
He’d been in his cabin looking at his journals when he’d heard the commotion on deck, and he wasn’t stupid enough resist after he’d seen the apparent skills of the pirates – his poor crew hadn’t stood a chance. Now he sat tied at the foot of the ship’s mast alongside the other members of his company who’d been sensible enough to surrender, watching gloomily as the pirates slung a makeshift bridge of planks across the vessels and ransacked his ship.
And it had all started so well.
“Careful!” he was about to shout as he saw two of the bandits carrying a trunk between them stumble on the bridge, before stopping himself – it hardly mattered if it went overboard, it was all gone anyway.
“Watch it!” barked a voice, and Fili realized he hadn’t been the only one to notice, as a huge bearded pirate stomped in front of the two of them, sun glinting off the tattoos swirling over his bald scalp and his enormous arms threateningly. “Not a drop of it goes before the captain’s seen it, got it? Or he’ll have your hides for tablecloths tomorrow!”
Fili heard a soft whimper next to him – Bombur, the ship’s cook, looked petrified as he met Fili’s eyes, tugging on their bonds weakly.
“He didn’t mean it,” Fili whispered, trying to sound consoling. “I bet pirates say that kind of thing all the time.”
“It’s heavy,” one of the bandits whined, dropping his half, and taking off his hat to wipe at his sweaty forehead. He didn’t seem particularly perturbed by the burly pirate’s threat.
“Get it the hold before I have your balls for breakfast.” The smile on the pirate’s face was positively dangerous.
“Since you asked so nicely,” the bandit said cheerily, popping his hat back on his head and hoisting the trunk back into his arms. He and his redheaded friend, shaking his head slightly, disappeared into the frenzy of of activity as pirates swarmed over the annexed ship, hastening back with their arms full of booty.
There was a cry as suddenly one of the pirates, who had been halfway up the rigging lost his grip and fell.
The bald pirate rolled his eyes, as though dealing with pirates was no better than dealing with unruly children. “Get up!” he growled, stomping over to where the man writhed on the ground, moaning.
“I can’t - I can’t - my arm!”
“What’s wrong with it lad?”
“I think it’s - aargh - my shoulder!”
“Now listen here, if you don’t get up and stop crying, I’ll give you something real to cry about-”
“Just look at it, Dwalin!” the man with the hat piped up from the crowd who had gathered around the writing man on the ground. “That’s not right! He needs to see someone!”
“Dammit lad, pull yourself together,” Dwalin growled. “We haven’t got time for this.”
“His shoulder is dislocated!” Oin called as if he couldn't stay silent any longer. The bearded pirate turned his head slowly.
“I’m a doctor. The shoulder needs re-setting. If you let me out of these, I can help you.” Oin held up his hands, tied together with thick hairy rope.
Dwalin continued to look suspicious for a minute, before another groan from the sailor on the floor apparently made up his mind. He pulled a knife out of his belt as he stomped over to the mast where the prisoners were tied, severing Oin’s bonds in a single clean slice and gesturing towards the injured man with a low growl.
Oin got to his feet and hurried over to where the patient lay, face now a disconcerting shade of green.
“Alright, laddie, let me have a look. Does this hurt?”
A wail seemed to answer his question.
“No doubt about it, dislocated.” Oin gripped the man’s elbow with one arm, taking his wrist tenderly in his other hand. “You’re lucky you’re young, lad, or with a fall like that you’d have broken something badly. What’s your name?”
“Nain.”
“Sorry, didn’t catch that? I’m a little deaf you see.”
“It’s Nain - aah!”
“There we go,” Oin said sounding pleased with himself.
Fili recognised Oin’s tactic of asking questions to distract his patients from any potential discomfort they might feel, and felt a wave of admiration for the elderly doctor. He and the rest of the crowd watched, wide-eyed, as Oin helped Nain back to his feet.
“Now go lie down and get that arm in a sling. Don’t take it off for ten days and take it easy for a while after that,” Oin warned him.
“Thank you, sir. I – I swill.” The lad nodded, holding his arm carefully as he hurried below deck, hastily untying the bandana around his head with his good hand as he went.
“Well done,” Fili whispered as soon as Oin came within earshot, but the booming voice of the tattooed pirate cut across him as he stomped over.
“The captain will see you now,” he announced, taking out his knife again and slicing through Bomber and Fili’s bonds as if they were nothing more than embroidery thread. He put two hands on Fili’s shoulders and steered him forcefully below deck, a few more pirates joining their escort down to the captain’s chambers.
They were led down a set of wooden steps to a narrow hallway with wooden panels and burnt out candle brackets lining the walls. Fili’s heart beat faster with every step on the surprisingly plush carpet underfoot (no doubt stolen, just as the ship would have been), closer to the mahogany door with the brass sign reading ‘Captain’. Dwalin shoved the door open with a foot and pushed the three captives inside, the rest of the pirates somehow cramming their way into the small room too. The captain looked up from his seat at the desk, and with shock Fili saw a face he recognised, seen countless times as a child at parties and dinners, before his mysterious disappearance around ten years ago, about which no one knew anything and rumours were rife.
“You’re Thorin Oakenshield,” Fili blurted out.
Thorin raised his eyes, crystalline blue and more piercing than any other Fili had ever seen. “That would be Captain Oakenshield to you, I believe,” he said not unkindly. He rose to his feet slowly, looking to Dwalin for explanation.
“These are from the ship,” Dwalin said, gesturing. “Some of the rest of them jumped overboard, those who fought were killed. These and a few others came quietly.”
“I see. What are your names?”
They stated their names, one by one.
“This one calls himself a doctor,” Dwalin interjected, gesturing to Oin. “Just fixed Nain’s shoulder when he fell out of the rigging. And did it pretty painlessly too.”
Thorin regarded Oin carefully, who stood his ground unflinching. “It so happens our crew is in bad need of a medic. Would you consider joining our ranks?”
“If the pay’s fair and wages good,” Oin agreed brusquely.
“Your needs shall be met. What will you require?”
“My instruments and chests from the ship. And a room of my own to use as a clinic. I cannot abide performing delicate operations on the open deck like animals in a farmyard.”
Thorin laughed. “You drive a hard bargain - but that can be arranged. We shall clear one of the smaller store-rooms for your purposes, if that will suffice.”
“It shall indeed.”
“And you, Bombur? What was your position?”
“Ship’s cook.” Seemingly emboldened by Thorin’s easy negotiation with Oin, Bombur stopped trembling though he still babbled. “I would be happy to - if you would require my services, captain - I would be very happy to continue sailing with you.”
“A cook, at last. You’re very welcome.” Thorin’s lips twisted into a wry smile as Dwalin laughed out loud, apparently at a joke no one else could understand.
Thorin’s calm blue eyes landed on Fili. “And you. What can you offer us?”
Fili didn’t know what to say. He saw Oin and Bombur giving him sideways looks, as if somehow hoping to help him.
“I don’t know, sir,” Fili said finally.
To Fili's surprise, Thorin smiled. “At least you’re honest. And brave - I do not see you quivering in your boots fearing for your life.”
“No, sir.”
“What was your role on the ship?”
“I was representing the company. I was to oversee the delivery of our merchandise and negotiate a return trade from Bristol to Kingston.”
“I apologise for the little hiccup in your mission,” Thorin said dryly, and a few of the others in the room tittered. “How old are you, boy?”
“Seventeen.”
“A child, then. I bet your birthday was less than a week ago.”
Fili said nothing. He didn’t want to confirm Thorin’s thoughts, tell him that he had pleaded with Dain for months to let him lead his own voyage. Dain had grudgingly withheld until Fili’s seventeenth birthday, when he finally told Fili he could set sail on the upcoming voyage the very next day. That had been three days ago - and what a catastrophe it had become. He hadn’t even made it out of the Carribbean.
“Are you loyal?” Thorin asked suddenly. Fill opened his mouth but stopped himself. He knew this was a test. If he said yes, they might consider letting him stay on the ship. But by saying yes and using it to secure his acceptance into the pirate crew, he would be proving himself a liar and a turncloak.
“Yes,” Fili answered finally.
“To your master? To Dain?”
“Yes.”
“Very well. Loyalty is admirable in any character, not least in one so young and in a situation such as you find yourself in now.”
Fili swallowed, finding a lump in his throat nestled there like a ball of cold lead.
“You shall leave tomorrow. Can you swim?”
“Uh, yes sir,” Fili replied, surprised by the question.
“Good. You’ll forgive me if I won’t be able to drop you directly to the shore - must abandon the scene of the crime, you understand.”
“Of course, sir.”
“Good.” Thorin turned to one of his men, and by that Fili guessed he was dismissed. “Has the merchant ship been emptied yet?”
“Aye, captain,” the pirate said gleefully. “And a fat lot of booty too! The goodies in her stores, it was a wonder she could sail at all!”
“Torch it. We must be on the move within an hour.”
“Aye-aye.” The pirate left and Thorin turned his attention once again to Fili, Bombur and Oin. “It must be getting along for dinner time. If you would indulge us, Bombur, perhaps you could show us your talents.”
Bombur nodded rigorously as Dwalin chuckled, folding his arms across his stomach. “Oh, I can’t wait to watch this one.”
—————
Dwalin’s mirth was explained later as Fili sat on his bed, pondering what to do. He had been given the only spare cabin on board to spend the night while Oin and Bombur were sent to the belly of the ship to set up hammocks with the rest of the crew, though Fili didn’t particularly think of his as a place of honour - though the door wasn’t locked, he didn’t get the impression he was welcome to roam the ship freely, and had a strong suspicion that giving him the cabin was more a way to keep an eye on him and keep him in one place than to make him feel like an esteemed guest.
He was staring out of the small porthole at the glimpse of darkening sea, speckled with reflected gold from the setting sun when he suddenly heard an sharp crash and yelling coming from what sounded like the galley. Unable to resist his curiosity, he pulled the door open a crack and peeked outside to better hear the sudden roaring.
“A ship’s cook? Are you replacing me?”
“Dis, please -“
“Oh, I see how it is! The first fatty who comes along claiming he can boil an egg and you’re done with me! Well, that’s gratitude isn’t it?!”
Fili cringed at Bombur’s apparently unfriendly welcome. He recognised Thorin’s pained, pleading voice but he could have sworn whoever he was talking to had a distinctly female (if extremely loud) voice - and hadn’t Thorin just called her ‘Dis’? But wasn’t it supposedly unlucky to have a woman on board a ship? And weren’t pirates superstitious folk?
Much closer, he heard a giggle. Fili saw a boy a few years his junior, dark hair falling loose around his shoulders, also peering round the edge of a doorway opposite and stifling a smile. He caught Fili’s eye and grinned.
“Please, Dis, there’s no need to shout -“
“Why, isn’t my cooking good enough for you?”
There was a pause. Fili wondered if Thorin was floundering.
“I see!” the voice bellowed. There was an almighty clang and a yelp of pain. “I suppose if it’s not fit to be eaten it’s not a waste if it’s all over you instead!” roared the voice, growing louder along with stomping footsteps. Fili whipped his head back around the doorway, catching a glimpse of a slight figure storming down the hall towards them.
“Is everything okay, mama?” Fili heard a young voice say, in a way that suggested he was trying to sound tentative while clearly repressing his own giggles.
“Your uncle Thorin is a complete and utter arse!” Dis replied loudly just before she slammed the door behind them.
Fili heard more two more approaching footsteps and pulled the door to hastily, leaving it open just a crack. He caught a whiff of something that smelled of stew and heard Dwailin’s chortling. “I told you so.”
—————
When Thorin had granted Fili his freedom, Fili hadn’t realised it would be under such uncivilized circumstances.
“Walk the plank!” someone had cried gleefully, rousing a positive chorus of “Walk the plank! Walk the plank!”
And Thorin, by his nerve, said not a word as five pirates appeared bearing a six foot long plank; a group had surrounded Fili, chivvying and pushing him towards it until somehow he had ended up here, precariously balanced on a long piece of wood haphazardly slammed into place on the tallest deck of the ship, surrounded the entire crew, giggling and practically wetting themselves in anticipation of the spectacle.
“My apologies,” Thorin called over the tittering and cackling pirates. “But I did ask if you could swim. Circumstances dictate, you know…”
Fili could have sworn. He looked down at the sea, glittering in the morning sun, fifty feet below him.
“Is there no dignity to be had around here?” he muttered through gritted teeth.
“Well, since you’re leaving it behind anyway, I wouldn’t mind those shoes you’ve got!” one of the pirates called, rousing gales of laughter around his friends.
Fili glowered murderously at the speaker, then took off his shoes and threw them at him one by one. The pirate caught them, albeit narrowly, and gave Fili a shit-eating grin, sending up another round of guffaws.
“Time’s a-wastin’!” Dwalin shouted suddenly. “If ye want to keep even a spare smidge of your ‘dignity’, lad, I’d jump myself before this lot pushes you in!”
Fili looked down again, taking a deep breath. He was a strong swimmer, and the shore was within eyeshot - Thorin had at least had the decency to bring the ship as close to shore as he dared without the risk of being recognised.
Fili took a deep breath and counted down - three, two, one - and dived. He soared for a split second before his fingertips touched water and suddenly he was soaked. He scrambled upwards, breaking the surface of the water with a gasp, the ship towering high above him. The water was colder than he thought, and he shivered before turning to where he knew the beach was and began to swim. A wave rose behind him and he felt it’s pull before he was engulfed, leaving him floundering and spluttering in its wake. He kicked his legs, pushing on with all his strength - he had thought he was a strong swimmer, but the rivers and streams of his hometown were nothing compared to the cruel might of the sea in all her majesty. Another wave took him down before he’d managed to take a breath, and he felt salt water burn his lungs as he inhaled in shock. He forced his way upwards again, choking and coughing as his head reached the surface and fought to keep it there. All he could see were waves, more waves, wave up on wave, metres high, how had he ever imagined he could do this. He would die, with the pirates watching, having barely made it any distance at all, the shore was so far and the current was buffeting him, away, away. He suddenly wondered how deep it was as he tread water desperately to keep himself upright, there could be anything below him, whales, sharks, he only hoped he was long drowned and dead before any sank their teeth into him.
“Fili! Fili!” it must have been an illusion, over the roaring water he thought he could hear someone calling his name. He took a huge shuddering breath and forced himself underwater, kicking frantically - it would be easier to swim under the water, where the buffeting waves couldn't knock him off course, at least then he’d be able to swim straight. In no time at all his lungs felt like they would burst and he clawed his way to the surface to take a deep hiccupping gulp of air.
“FILI!” He definitely hadn’t imagined it this time. Something hard knocked him on the side of the head and he went under again, scrabbling with his hands above his head until he felt something rough and knobbly - a knotted rope.
“You fools! You think knocking him unconscious will make this any easier?!” The words vaguely reached Fili’s ears over the roar and slop of the sea as he grasped at the rope desperately. The rope began to move and Fili closed his eyes, holding on for dear life for fear it would flee him as he was dragged through the coursing waves, dragged somewhere, anywhere, at this point he didn’t care as long as he lived. His stomach roiled with salt water and terror and he hoped he wouldn’t faint.
Fili felt his body bump against something wooden - the side of a boat. “Wrap your arms around the rope, boy!” someone called. “And your legs, hold on with your knees!”
Fili did as he was told, at this point too frozen with cold and fear to do more than obey. His clothes felt like lead weighing him down but he gripped with all his might. His bare feet scraped along the glossy wooden sides of the ship as he clung like a limpet to his lifeline, his hands had rope burn but he didn’t care.
Hands grabbing at him, burying themselves into his wet clothes as they hoisted him up over the rail and he landed with a crash on the deck, spluttering and wheezing. A blanket was wrapped around him, a bucket held beneath his chin. Fili wondered why it was there for a moment before he retched, salty bile hitting the bucket with a sickening splatter.
Warm hands landed his clammy wet cheeks, tilting his face upwards. “Are you alright, Fili?” someone asked and Fili blinked, eyes stinging from salt, seeing a blurry face framed with long black hair in front of him. “Fili?”
Fili coughed and blinked, eyes adjusting to the sunlight as its light warmed his face. “I’m fine.”
The moustached pirate who Fili had yet to see without his hat roared with laughter. “You hear that? Spoken like a true comrade.”
“I tried - I couldn’t do it.”
“Not through lack of trying, that’s for sure,” the moustached pirate chortled.
“Time’s still a-wastin’!” Dwalin barked. “Time to get going! Farin, Nori, sort out the sails! Bofur, give them a hand!”
“Welcome to the crew lad,” the pirate who must have been Bofur smiled, He clapped Fili so hard on the back it made Fili cough and darted off to follow his redheaded friend.
“Wh- what?” Fili spluttered, astounded. “Welcome to the-“
“Yes indeed. Welcome,” said a quiet voice behind him and Fili turned to see Thorin’s face, wearing a small smile.
“Let’s get you inside and warmed up!” Dis fumed, wrapping an arm around him and bearing him towards below deck. Staring over his shoulder at Thorin’s face, Fili had the strangest sensation that he had known and planned this all along.
