Actions

Work Header

Getting it Right

Chapter 9: The Limits of a Hobbit

Summary:

Gandalf pushes Bilbo a bit too far and he pays for it. Ouch.
Fíli and Kíli spar with Elladan and Elrohir.
New weapons are planned.
There's news on the Smaug issue.

Chapter Text

The Limits of a Hobbit

 

“No.”

“Please-”

“No.”

“I need-”

“No.”

“Bilbo, why-”

“No.”

“When-”

“No.”

“Will you at least-”

“No.”

“I need to know-”

“No.”

“May the Valar save me from stubborn little Halflings!” The wizard raged.

Stubborn. Little. Halfling.

The hobbit stood and turned to leave the terrace.

“You will stay and answer me, Bilbo Baggins!” the wizard’s hand descended on his shoulder.

The hobbit snarled. He grabbed the wizard’s wrist, twisted, pulled, stepped back and yanked. And….

Gandalf somersaulted forward and crashed onto the paved terrace on his back, the breath slammed from his body. The hobbit reared from his slightly crouched position and kicked the wizard’s staff away from his reach, before looking at the wizard in disgust and storming away.

“Mithrandir.” Elrond sighed in exasperation. “You were warned. Pray that this is the end of it. Bilbo’s retributions tend have long lasting side effects.” With that Elrond left Gandalf to recover his dignity.

“I still need to know what will happen and when to expect it.” He muttered under his breath as he climbed to his feet.

“No, Mithrandir, you don’t.” Gandalf spun towards the lilting masculine voice.

“Ah, Elladan, Elrohir. Yes, I do need to know.”

“No, Mithrandir. It is better for you and for Bilbo if you do not know what is to happen.” Said one of the Twins.

“Have you not thought about the how it pains Bilbo to speak of the things you ask?” Continued the other.

“Have you not asked him to relive those hurts, without consideration?”

“Have you not pushed and cajoled?”

“Have you not been warned?”

“Bilbo’s pain is great, Mithrandir. Having Thorin Oakenshield with him now lessens this pain, yes, but the memories are still there, the heartache still echoes.”

“If the beings of Arda were judged by their heart and courage, he would be the greatest of us all.”

“But to love is to feel pain. He feels that pain so much more than others.”

“But-” Gandalf started.

“There are no ‘but’s Mithrandir.”

“You have tried to force him against his will, Mithrandir.”

“Oh, no. No. I would not hurt him-” Gandalf tried again.

“You already have.”

“By ignoring his decisions,-”

“-by trying to override his choices,-”

“-by pushing him so.”

“You are forcing-”

“-him into pain.”

“His retribution will be-”

“-his and his alone,-”

“-none will assist him.”

“But so will your forfeiture-”

“-be yours alone.”

“You have done what has not-”

“-been done since the settling of Imladris.”

“You have deliberately-”

“-caused hurt to an innocent.”

“Pray he does not present-”

“-a case to the White Council.”

“Your penance could permanent banishment from Imladris-”

“-or it could be that you must face the Valar themselves-”

“-in Valinor and as it is they that Returned Bilbo to Arda-”

“-they may not be generous in their judgement.”

With this the Twins shook their heads sadly at the wizard and faded back the way they had came, a final comment came from nowhere.

“You signed the covenant when the Dúnedain first came to Imladris, you are bound by those laws as much as Gilraen and her son.”

Gandalf sat, shocked at what had happened. What he had let happen. What he had done. He had not meant to hurt, but hurt he had. Learning of the betrayal of Saruman had deeply shaken him and he had sought to find balance in answers from Bilbo, but instead he had broken a sacred vow. As the Twins had said, he had hurt an innocent, he had disregarded the wishes of another. Deliberately.

He brought much shame to his name - names.

He first thought was to find Bilbo and ask forgiveness, but it would be pointless. He had proven to the hobbit that his word meant little. Better to wait and if Bilbo spoke to the Council, he would take whatever penance they deemed. If Bilbo did not, then he would ask for a chance to regain the hobbit’s trust.

He did not know where to retreat to. To go to the Gardens of the Valar was out of the question, he would not taint their peace with his presence. In the communal areas he may meet with one of his brother-wizards or the Lady Galadriel and he was not fit to join them. In the end the grey wizard went to neither, after much walking he found himself at the Tear of the Stars. The giant crystal Tear that sank into the protruding rock floor of the cave and out again many feet below, it’s flat surface forming a natural rostrum.

Watching the setting sun’s rays hit the waterfall that sheltered the Tear, causing rainbows to dance across the valley below, grounded the wizard, but the beauty of it reminded him of Bilbo’s innocence and his abuse of it. As the sun sank lower, the light of the moon brightened. Beams filtered down and the crystal began to glow.

The wizard sent up a prayer.

“Lady of Mercy, I beg of you. Have mercy on Bilbo. I have wronged him. Ease his pain, Lady Nienna. My zealousness was wrong and I freely admit it, but my words mean little, now. I do not ask your forgiveness, Lady, for it is Bilbo that I have wronged and I am not worthy of his forgiveness. Instead I ask, ease his pain, give him peace. He deserves peace, Lady of Mercy.” Gandalf had one hand on the Tear as he whispered.

He did not expect a reply. But a reply he got.

“Olórin. You have caused much hurt to my Wife’s child.” The deep echoing voice was not that of the delicate Elf-like Lady Nienna, but was that of Aulë, whom the dwarrow knew as Mahal.

“Lord Aulë. I am sorry, but I beg not forgiveness. I am not worthy of it.”

“It is not your place, Olórin, to decide who is worthy and who is not. Your next few days will be most uncomfortable for your dignity, but if you abide by the actions of my son’s Chosen One, then the matter will be considered complete. It may take time for you to regain his confidence, but he will hold no animosity for today’s actions.”

“Thank you, my Lord. As long as he is no longer in pain, I will take whatever chastisement he wishes.”

“Good. But be warned, we will not be lenient a second time. If he falls before his tasks are complete, so to will all Middle Earth fall. He is the Balance.”

“I will not let that happen, Lord.” Bilbo? The Balance?!

“Good. He knows what is in front of him. Listen when he speaks, but do not try to restrict him. It is not your task to protect him, but rather to guide and support him. He is as volatile as my children and sees no sense in withholding his ire. He is creative in releasing his emotions… As you will soon see.” The amused voice of the Valar faded until Gandalf was uncertain if he had heard the last sentence correctly.

“I will give all that I am to see Bilbo completes his tasks and is free to life his life in peace and love.” The wizard said as he touched his fingers to his lips and then to the crystal Tear. A flair of brightness from the crystal filled the cave. The pulse of light told the wizard that the Valar had taken his comment as a vow. If he failed in the task he set for himself, then he would give his all, his power, his very life would be forfeit.

No pressure, then.

 

The next morning as the wizard made his way to find breakfast, he passed many elves, all of them looked at him, either startled or amused. What was it about his appearance that would startle an elf? When he reached the dining area, he joined many members of Thorin’s Company and a few elves. Elrond, Elladan, Elrohir and Lindir among them.

Bofur and Kíli took one look at the wizard and started to laugh, followed very quickly by the Twins.

Elrond smiled and shook his head. Even Oín and Gloín grinned.

“What is so amusing, may I ask?” The wizard grumbled.

“Have you checked a mirror, this morning, Gandalf?” Ask Balin.

“No…”

“Perhaps you should. It may answer your question.” Balin was also beginning to grin, too.

Elrond waved to an elf that was bringing a platter of sweet pastries to the table, he spoke to her quietly and within moments she returned with a tray. Elrond lifted a hand mirror from the tray and passed it to Gandalf. The wizard looked at his reflection and in doing so nearly dropped the mirror.

His eyebrows were green. The bright green of new grass in spring. But that wasn’t all. His hair was streaked, but instead of the salt-n-pepper grey that he normally saw, this morning his hair was coloured. It was different shades of blue, from baby’s breath to a rich azure, and pinks of soft blush to vibrant fuchsia, where the colours met they blended into purples, from pale lilac through to deep violet. Only his beard remained unchanged.

“Oh, my.”

“Indeed.”

“How? How did he do it?”

“Bilbo?”

“Of course. I would normally have thought it the Twins, but their reaction say otherwise. Bilbo is the only other person who has cause to be… irritated with me.”

“Ah. Well… We don’t know.” Elrond replied.

“Elladan? Elrohir? Any ideas?”

“Sorry, Mithrandir.” Said one.

“We tried for years, to work it out-” said the other Twin.

“-but we’ve never caught him and-”

“-he never showed us.”

Fíli looked at the Twins curiously.

“Do you have to do that? I mean is it instinctual or did you?, just one day decide to speak like that?”

“We don’t remember-”

“-not talking like this.” They answered with a puzzled frown.

“Adar? Did we ever-”

“-talk alone?” They also turned as one, to face their father.

“No. Even their first words were consecutive. As has been everything since. The only time they were separated they struggled to communicate at all. They truly are halves of a whole.”

“Here comes Tithin-Adar. We can ask if you like, Mithrandir?”

“What does Tithin-Adar, mean?” Asked Kíli.

Bilbo stepped up to the table and pulled out a seat as he reached for a plate.

“Tithin-Adar means little father. Much as I claimed Kíli as kin, I claimed the Twins.” He grinned suddenly. “I hope you like having more nephews, Thorin.”

Dwalin, Gloín, Bifur and Nori laughed at the look on Thorin’s face as he realised what Bilbo basically adopted the Twins meant for him.

“Cousins!” Yelled Kíli.

“Yay!” cried Fíli.

“May Mahal protect us all.” Groaned Dori. Everyone else at the table laughed at him, expect Bilbo, who was single-mindedly feeding his ravenous belly.

When he finished, he sat back with a sigh and nursed his mug of tea. He looked at Gandalf and raised an eyebrow. The wizard was a sight in green, pink and blue.

Gandalf raised one back, Bilbo smiled, nodded and nothing more was said on the matter.

The morning was spent in checking their supplies and making lists of things that needed replacement, repair or restocking. After a light lunch, the twins invited Bilbo, Fíli and Kíli to spar with them, for the first time the dwarrow would see Bilbo fight.

He moved similar to an elf, but there were marked differences. While they seemed to glide in straight lines, Bilbo flowed around them, almost in circles, but not quite so structured. The watching dwarrow at first thought it amusing, until Dwalin challenged Bilbo. Dwalin would grab and Bilbo just seemed to slip away from him, when they picked up their weapons, it became clear that one-on-one, Bilbo was very dangerous indeed. Yes, he would need more instruction on standard sword-work, the moves and counter-moves, but he was not the vulnerability they first thought.

Next up were Fíli and Kíli. Kíli was not particularly happy that he was unable to use his bow, but the Twins with permission from Elrond, offered to teach both lads how to use a double-ended short-sword as well as their weapon of choice, the long handled elven staff-sword. When the two dwarrow adapted relatively easily to the staff, the Twins and the two lads sat down and designed a weapon using the same principle, but of a more suitable size and style for a dwarf. After much discussion and many sketches, they came to a final design.

They ended up a weapon with an overall length of just below their shoulder-height, where the blade was slightly over half the total length. After an inordinate amount of time working out the design, they found way of increasing the length of the staff so it could be used as a walking pole. An extension pushed up into the base of the staff and a simple spring-loaded catch held pole of the staff and the extension together. Thorin suggested that the extension itself have another blade, this time more of a flat stiletto, that could be used as a dagger if needed.

The Twins offered to take Fíli and Kíli go with them the next day to meet with the master sword-smiths and recommend that they wait until that point to finalise all the aspects of the design, who knew what the smiths could add. Messages were sent and Telovar and his sister Teldriel invited the two young dwarrow to join them the next day, to go over the design and perhaps some preparation for forging.

As Thorin knew that they had at least one more meeting with the White Council, after lunch the next day and he agreed that the lads could spend the day at the smithy and with the consent of the smith’s, he and Dwalin would accompany them for the morning.

During the course of the afternoon, Elrond had spent a fair amount of his time talking to Bifur and Bofur. That evening Bofur stood at the dinner table and thanked Lord Elrond for the offer and that Bifur would like to talk to him more about it. They and Thorin were invited to Elrond's study for the evening and when they re-joined the Company, Bofur told them that Elrond felt that he and his healers would be able to remove the axe from Bifur’s forehead. They were uncertain at this point how this would relate to his speech centres, but that the very least he would be axe-free. It would however mean a three day delay for the Company. They would be able to do the actual removal soon after first light the next morning, the three days were to ensure that chances of infection were limited. Elrond stated that once the actual removal was complete Bifur would know within a few hours which speech centres would recover and he would be able to travel at the end of the requested three days. Elrohir and Elladan with Oín’s assistance would be more than capable of caring for Bifur as they travelled and helping Bifur with any speech therapies needed.

Late in the evening as various matters were being discussed with Elrond, Lindir, Elrond’s steward, appeared at their suite and after briefly conferring with Elrond, he spoke to Bilbo.

“Master Bilbo. Alatar and Pallando send word, they have found what they were looking for. They now know that the dragon can dealt with without it being killed.” He said. Bilbo called Thorin and Balin over to hear what the Blue wizards had discovered. “They will require the assistance of Mithrandir, Radagast, Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel. They plan to revert Smaug to what the dragons were before Morgoth corrupted them. They ask me bid you and Master Thorin think hard on the matter, as someone must be responsible for the dragon after the change.” Lindir then went on to explain what Alatar and Pallando said would happen to the dragon and why it would no longer be a threat to Erebor and it’s people.

Once Lindir finished, Balin asked Lindir if he would pass a question on to the two wizards and the elf agreed to do so. He listened to Balin’s question, bowed and departed quietly.

Between Bifur’s axe removal, the wizards construction the Company and the possibility of having elven weapons forged, Thorin and Elrond decided that the Company would stay in Rivendell for an extra five nights.