Chapter Text
Explanations and Rumours
Dís listened. She had no choice but to listen. As the she-elf, Galadriel, had begun her explanation, Dís had listened raptly. For the first half hour there was nothing that could have drawn her from the elf’s side, but then… she was told of the deaths of her sons and brother. Her first reaction was, of course, that Thorin failed to protect her sons and she intended to take it out of his hide. No sooner had she stood, than the elf had frowned and Dís was frozen, unable to move, to speak.
She continued to stand, frozen, in front of her chair, while the elf continued her tale. Hearing of the War of the Ring and the deaths of so many, brought the princess to tears, but still she was frozen in place.
Then Galadriel told of a meeting of the Valar in Aman, where the hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, was given a chance to right so many wrongs. A decision was made and as there had been 9 Walkers in the Fellowship of the Ring, so there would be nine souls Returned to Arda.
Bilbo took it upon himself to carry the Ring and Nienna, the Lady of Mercy, told him of a prayer of holding that could contain the Ring and render it harmless to those around it.
But who to help him? Who to Return? Erú Ilûvatar was consulted and it was he who would choose Bilbo’s Allies. All those with Children offered them. Erú thought long before revealing his choices.
Thorin Oakenshield’s heart was already tied to that of Bilbo Baggins so he would Return. Lady Yavanna feared for the heart of the dwarf-king with the deaths of his sister-sons and begged Erú to include them. Mahal willing gave of their souls, for in truth, Thorin, Fíli and Kíli never accepted their deaths and kept pleading for the hobbit to be allowed to join them after his death. Their cries and laments when the hobbit journeyed to the Undying Lands, were never ending. They mourned at all times.
And so Fíli and Kíli were to join their uncle. Mahal swore that he would release no more souls.
Nienna Returned Elladan and Elrohir, their healing abilities would surely be needed at some point and being the grandsons of Galadriel would give them influence with their elven-kin.
Tauriel was the heart bond for Kíli, even if the Bond had not been fulfilled, her heart was crafted to beat in cadence with his.
Bard of the Line of Girion was the only human to be Returned. It was the Doom of his Soul to draw his bow on the Dragon. It was Vairë that reminded the Valar gathered that the dragons were once the most trusted of the Dwarroven Allies, could this alliance not be rewoven? Must the dragon die? Could not the curse of Morgoth be revoked? Broken?
Manwë asked who would be the last of the 9 souls to walk again. Varda, his wife, was forced to remind her husband that Elladan and Elrohir were but one soul, they were truly halves of a whole. There were two more for Erú’s choosing.
Erú told then of his search, of reading the memories of those involved in the Reclamation of Erebor and the War of the Ring. He found three souls that knew the worst of Mordor, that stood against all that Melkor and Mairon could raise. Further he found that two of these tenacious souls were Bound together, that even though their peoples still distrusted, they had Bound themselves and Wed. Not just for the mortal life of one but for the eternal life of the elder. If one was to Return, so must the other, or apart they would Fade and Fall.
Legolas Greenleaf and Gimli Gloín-ul would be the last of the Returned.
Tulkas and Oromë pleaded with Mandos and Vairë that the Returned be allowed to keep their memories, that they had been chosen because of the strengths they had gained. To deprive them, would weaken them and allow discord within the group, stopping them from becoming all they could be.
If the 9 Returned failed, Arda would fall.
Then Ulmo raised the question of how they would be Returned. After all, not all of them were dead. Thorin, Fíli and Kíli were in the Halls of Mahal and Bard was in the Halls of Mandos, it was true, but Tauriel of Greenwood was held as but a strand by Vairë, waiting to be rewoven.
While Gimli and Legolas were still alive, Bilbo, Elladan, Elrohir were in the Undying Lands. How would they be Returned and would they be told why?
Erú listened to the voices of his Valar and finally he silenced them.
Bilbo would be Returned in September. He would know the most, he was the last to leave Arda and so would have the greatest idea of what and why. He would need time to prepare and would be Returned two full seasons before the Istari approached him.
For the rest, they would Return in order of their deaths or departures from Arda.
Elladan and Elrohir were second. There would be a single day between their Return and that of the hobbit.
Fíli would be next, at the last moon in October. The blonde may have died but minutes before his brother and Uncle, but he would have a week before he was joined. The energies needed to Return a soul to Arda were immensely draining. The Valar had learnt this when sending the split-soul of the twin elves so close after sending the hobbit. The Valar needed a full month of recovery after that monumental error. Their exhaustion nearly lost the twin’s soul in the void, something the Valar almost drained their Light to regain.
The first moon phase in November saw Kíli’s Return to the Blue Mountains and his brother.
Thorin Oakenshield woke to the next moon phase in that same month.
Tauriel saw the first snowfalls over the Woodland Realm in December.
The night before Yule was when Bard Return to Laketown and his children.
Legolas awoke the morning of the New Year in his Father’s Halls and was a very unhappy elf. Estë and Irmo were greatly alarmed at the anger and thoughts of retaliation that went through his mind, the Valar deemed it fortunate that Thranduil did not call for his son that day, or there would likely have been murder and mayhem in the Halls, for the young prince initially believed his father responsible.
Gimli’s age fought the Valar, physically his body and mind were not matured and none wanted to force a Return on the dwarf. Estë and Nienna tried for months to wake his mind but every attempt failed, leaving the dwarf with severe headaches. They were forced to turn to Tulkas and ask his intervention. Tulkas and Manwë believed that the dwarf had the strength his for soul to re-integrate with his body, without damage. That the moment they chose, was the moment the young dwarf saw the Mountain of his forefathers, was a poetic coincidence.
Irmo and Erú conspired and sent dreams to a select few on Arda. Among them, Gilraen, wife of Arathorn chief of the Dunedain, mother to Aragorn, the heir of Isildur , also to Elrond of Rivendell, father to Elladan and Elrohir. Glorfindel had been Returned to Arda for more than an Age past, his knowledge would be needed and were Glorfindel went, so too did Erestor. Galadriel of Lothlorien had the ability to speak mind-to-mind and she was shown the meeting of the Valar. The last to dream was the Istari, Alatar and Pallando, who were prompted to investigate whether to dragon must die.
The elf continued with the tale, telling of the plans the hobbit. Of letters to the Blue Mountains, Rivendell, Lothlorien and Mirkwood. The young princes arrival in Hobbiton and the plans the three made. Of hobbits to heal the land around the mountain. Of skilled artisans to come to the Mountain and teach those who would learn. Of a future in the Mountain for a hobbit and his dwarf.
Still frozen, Dís was forced to listen to the journey anew. A journey that kept to the same path and timeframe, but with minor differences. Most notably their stays in Rivendell and at Beorn’s. The additions of the elves to Thorin’s Company now made sense.
But what shocked Dís the most was Smaug. Even though she’d received and read the letters that Thorin had sent she was still uncertain of what Thorin intended the future to hold for the dragon and her (her!) hatchlings. First the gender of the beast and then the curse? What other surprises were in store for them?
Finally whatever Galadriel had done that froze the princess was gone and Dís fell back into her chair, tears ran down her face and she knew that her sons, were so much more than just hers. Now, they were the embodiment of Erebor’s future.
Thorin, Fíli and Kíli had died for Erebor and now they lived for Erebor. She had always believed her sons were destined for more than being smiths and fletchers in the Blue Mountains, but this was beyond anything she could have imagined. Her brother and sons were the face of the dwarrow nation, for many generations to come.
It would take some time for the dwarrowdam to adjust her thinking.
Nori was mad. No. He was more than mad. He dragged the unconscious dwarf by the leg, not at all concerned about the dwarf’s head bumping along the stone floors. Throwing open the door to Thorin’s private audience chamber, he continued to drag the dwarf until he reached the centre of the room, where he threw the dwarf’s leg away from himself and stomped to a chair.
It was a full table that met his eyes. The White Council, Lendarion, Thráin, Daín, Balin, Bard, Óin, Dís, Bilbo and Thorin.
“Nori!” Thorin had jumped in surprise when the door had been thrown open. “What? What’s wrong with Bofur? Óin? Would you-”
“Leave him.” Nori growled low and viciously.
“Nori?”
“He’s drunk or was until I knocked him out. Dori, Ori, Bifur, Bombur and Gloín are trying to contain the situations. This… binjabl lulkhel!He was telling tales, tales of the Twice-Born, of Thorin, Fíli, Kíli, Gimli, Bilbo, Bard and our elves. It was one of Bombur’s little ones that told him, she wanted to hear the rest of the tale!” The thief-turned spymaster continued to mutter and swear in Khuzdul for some minutes, while those gathered around the table tried to make sense of what he’d just told them.
Thorin shuddered. He knew Bofur liked to drink, he’d boasted that one reason he’d joined the Company was for the free ale. But this? Thorin was stunned. He would never have expected this of the miner. If his own brother and cousin took action against him, then there could be no doubt of his actions. Bofur had not been pleased when the Company voted not to tell the mixed population now residing inside the Mountain, of the Twice-Born and their tasks, but agreed to hold his tongue. It appears he changed his mind. Why? Why now?
“The listeners?” Thorin asked.
“Like I said. Dori and the others are trying to contain it, but… I don’t think they’re going to succeed. I’m sorry, ê-Uzbad, there are so many of them and most of them weren’t that drunk, I don’t think there’s much chance of them not remembering Bofur’s words. I don’t think we can keep it secret much longer. It effects too many people. And, arthâkh, while I agree that it’s your call, for a spy or informant, that type of secret is like a seam of Mithril. Besides, we can use it to our advantage.” The spy spoke to Thorin, ignoring the others.
“How? What’s ticking around in your head, Nori Ri?” the King asked.
“Dís wasn’t a elf supporter. She wasn’t a Man supporter. She wasn’t even a hobbit supporter, not really anyway. Not until Galadriel got hold of her. If we have the elf tell some, not all, of the tale 9 Returned, it would cut the chocks(*) out from above them. with that one tale, we could ensure that you never face opposition or rebellion, nor Fíli or Kíli, either.”
“We have the ability to prove it. The Urzamu-u-Mahal came with Dís and there’s Tolban and Daín’s son Stonehelm, they’re both truth-seekers. And let’s not forget Tharkûn, either. No offence, Lady Galadriel, but not many dwarrow are likely to believe an elf without some sort of verification. Even if what you’re telling them is what they want to hear.” Óin assured her.
“There’s others, too.” Said Daín. “Others that can tell when someone lies. We have some of the best body readers in my army. If they can read which way someone’s going to move from a person’s eyes, surely they can read a lie.”
“And how, exactly will that help?” Thráin questioned.
“I thought better of you, prince Thráin. If someone’s not lying, then they must be telling the truth. Right?” the spymaster tutted.
“Ah… didn’t think about it in those terms, but… yes, I see your point.”
Thorin thought for a minute, letting the others talk around him, finally he made a choice.
“Nori?”
“Arthâkh?”
“If we can’t contain a rumour, then we’d best use it.”
“I Ijbilabî. What’s the plan?”
“Simple, my Master of Spies. We’re having a feast tonight to celebrate, firstly reclamation of the Mountain, secondly the Freedom and Alliance of Smaug, thirdly the destruction of the Orc army and lastly the arrival of our families.”
“Ah, yeah? And your idea is…?”
“Well, there’s always speeches at feasts, right? So we simply have the speeches made as if the Twice-Born were common knowledge.”
“Arthâkh? I’m not sure how you mean.”
“Alright.” Thorin sighed. “I have to make the first speech, so I’ll thank Galadriel and Elrond for assisting Bilbo, thank the wizards for having their information ready for us. Thanking Elrond for allowing his sons to join us on our Return. Then Galadriel can respond. Something along the lines of, her mirror showing her what we would need and when. That our changed goal of not just reclaiming the Mountain but of also freeing the dragon, gave her the cause to Call the White Council to Rivendell to create the Arrows that Bard would use to break her curse. Then Bard could put in a comment about being glad he didn’t have to use a Windlance this time.” He picked up his goblet and sipped at the clear sweet juice it held. “Finally Daín can talk about how quests and battles and loss taught me the value of second chances, even if saving dragons was a mad idea. Something like that. Well, Nori? Think you and Balin can work with that? Write speeches for Daín and I. You’ll need to give Galadriel and Elrond a dwarf’s point of view on theirs, too.”
“Nori and I can write them, not a worry, laddie… Sorry, Thorin.” Balin corrected himself.
“Balin, it’s alright, just occasionally you should remember that I’m 17 years older than you. And your King. Just occasionally, that would be nice.” Thorin teased, causing the others to laugh. “I don’t want anyone to say anything obvious about us being Twice-Born. If someone had been listening to Bofur, then we would be confirming what was said, without a formal decree.”
“Hmmm… If we do it right, then most people will think that the only reason we haven’t spoken out about being Twice-Born is because we had other things to deal with and being Twice-Born wasn’t as important as an army or Orcs, our injured and incoming caravans. Nothing hidden, but not important in the face of everything else.” Balin added.
“Nori, perhaps you should take Bofur somewhere else, he stinks. Let him wake up… will he remember that it was you that knocked him out?” Daín asked.
Nori’s smile was quite vindictive.
“Oh, yes. According to Bombur, Bofur remembers everything that happens when he drinks. Bifur says, Bofur can’t always figure out why he did something, but he always remembers that he did it.”
“Right, well, toss him in some out of the way spot and let him fret about what’s going to happen next.” Daín chortled.
Nori sighed in relief, listening to the small gathering discuss the speeches. Most of these dwarrow were from the Iron Hills with a smattering from the Blue Mountains and Nori was pleased to see Daín’s lad Thorin Stonehelm and a pair of dwarrow that Daín swore should have been truth-seekers, among them. All but those three of the gathered dwarrow were among those that had been there when Nori had knocked Bofur out.
Thank Mahal, that Gloín had the forethought to have Nori and Ori knock Bofur out as though it were an accident and the thief volunteering to take him to the infirmary while the scribe offering to fetch their healer Óin, helped. That all four of them were part of Thorin’s Company, cemented the fiction.
The conversation he heard gave him a feeling of satisfaction, Thorin was right, these dwarrow had listened to Bofur, but doubted his story. The truth-seekers listened to the speeches and heard no lies, so they believed. That the two groups met and talked, that the speeches supported what Bofur said, that Thorin and the lads acted like it was of no importance, this was the reaction they had hoped for (and Nori was not going to admit it, but he’d even prayed for it).
Within days, everywhere that Nori went, he heard the tale of the Twice-Born, the King and the Princes who died for Erebor and the dragon. Whispers of thanks to Mahal were uttered by many dwarrow, of thanks to Yavanna by the hobbits, Men gave their thanks to Mandos and the elves to Nienna, lady of mercy.
All his spies reported that confidence in the King and his Heirs was at an unexpected high, the only ones not delighted with their King, were Thrór’s advisors. Five of seven dwarrow were still of the opinion that it should be they that Thorin heeded, but with the population favouring Thorin, they had few options. The remaining two, they were a different seam to hew. One had already, very quietly approached Braga, the Laketown Chief and asked to be allowed to practise as a healer in the floating town. The other, asked Thorin and Gloín if they would recommend him to Bard as ugbash or dwarrow ambassador, he would swear fealty to Thorin, but he feared the Mountain and the Dragon, he had only just escaped with his life when she attacked all those years ago. Thorin knew of the dwarf’s reputation for being scrupulously honest and had no qualms suggesting him to Bard.
The dissenting five had made clear their intention to leave the Mountain come spring. If Thorin would not heed them, they would not stay. They sought dwarrow to join in their trek to the White Mountains to the west of Gondor. Daín and Thorin gave leave to any dwarf that wished to go south.
Erebor would have only dwarrow that wanted to be there. Thorin and his family were determined to made the Mountain a home and see it flourish.
Nori set off to find the soon-to-be-crowned King, to pass along what his ears and spies had heard. Then he planned to spend the evening with his beautiful little Zeri.
Sindarin = (S) Quenya = (Q) Khuzdul = (K)
binjabl = brainless (K)
lulkhel = fool of fools, idiot of idiots (K)
ê-Uzbad = my King (K)
arthâkh = boss (slang version lit. trans = direct!) (K)
Chocks(*) = a mining term for a temporary roof support (K)
Urzamu-u-Mahal = Believer of Mahal (K)
Ijbilabî = agree! (K)
Ugbash = treasurer (K)
Note: A truth-seeker is exactly what is sounds like. Tolban has taken being a Truth-Seeker, as a Craft similar to being a lawyer, but no defence or prosecution, only truth.
