Actions

Work Header

Coming Home

Chapter 3: I Want To Know

Summary:

Commander Buffi K'gar coaxes Thorin out of the bedroom.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

And so, over the course of the afternoon, Bag End was visited by Bifur and Bombur, who had two carts of deep dish pizza beamed over from Erebor’s kitchens.  Bifur was too emotional to speak; he used the Khazad gestural language to convey his gratitude that Thorin was alive.  Fíli noticed that, along with Bifur’s hair having turned entirely white, even the scarring of his old injury had been healed by modern medicine.  Bombur told him that along with his own health-related treatments (The Dwarrow was down to 90 kilograms, praise Mahal) Bifur was getting a cortical treatment in the fall.  Though he had his moments of clarity, the damage to his language center had always seemed to come up time and again.

Bofur and Nori arrived together shortly after that.  While they were present when Thorin’s stasis chamber had been transferred from the other universe, they hadn’t seen him up and aware until now.  Kíli never thought he would see the day that Nori’s thievery would have given them such a boon.  

Bofur was still proud of the fact that he had negotiated a mining agreement with the nearby Bed-Lama system.  “In fact,” he told Kíli and Bombur and anyone else within earshot, “We have preliminary mining ships setting up platforms as we speak.  And I’m confident that we’ll find dilithium deposits by year’s end.”

Bombur grinned at that.  After all, he’d been the one to design the mining platforms.

 

Kíli wandered back to the sitting room where Fíli sat speaking with a returned Ori. The two were leaned in toward the coffee table in the center where a antique tea service was newly stocked.  He thought he could smell faint traces of chamomile.

 

“I see,” Fíli sighed.

“It was a surprise to us all at the time,” Ori replied, “But in hindsight…”

 

“How terrible.  Terrible!” a voice that Kíli immediately recognized as Dori exclaimed.  “What a tragic set of circumstances!  And to think, it could have happened in our own universe as well, if not for—“

Dori didn’t finish his thought, and instead wrapped his thick arms back around Ori, who squeaked at the strong embrace.  Ori didn’t seem to mind, though.

Kíli glanced at Fíli who nodded at him.  Confirming the engineer’s initial concerns about Thorin.  

“So what do we do?” Kíli asked.

Fíli stood up.  He looked at them.  “To honor the memory of our departed King, I will help this Dwarrow.  I will stand by him.  I have no illusions that he is entirely the same as my Uncle, but I will stand by him.”

Kíli smiled.  “As will I.”

“Ive seen many versions of ourselves in the Multiverse,” Ori told Fíli and Kíli.  “Versions that are virtually unrecognizable, where we are Terran, different species, different genders, different timelines…But this remains the same.  I knew this reality was well-chosen.  Thank you both so much.”

Ori broke the grasp of Dori and hugged them both at once.  He then took another piece of pizza and munched into it with gusto.  “Bombur and pizza, though—that’s new!”

“Not many alternate universes where Dwarrow-men and Turtle-lads interact, is there?” Kíli asked with a scoff.

“N-nope,” Ori replied, and took another, bigger bite.

 

Thorin dozed in the bedroom through it all, though Fíli and Dr. Ch’Tra popped in now and then to track his vitals.  

 

A few other visitors showed up as well.

 

However, the boisterous entrance of Glóin, his son Gimli, and his granddaughter Doeli roused Thorin up finally, as the moon came into view in the window and afternoon began to wane.  

“Alternate universes!  Medical Stasis!  These Terrans use their gobbldygook speech to ruin even the best of miracles!”  Gimli exclaimed.  Over the years, his aversion to technical speech had gotten more and more pronounced.  Kíli, who was fluent in Starfleet technobabble, rolled his eyes.

Adad, I was in the room when his box appeared, you know,” Doeli reminded her father.  “Popped into our reality—pop!—just like that.”

“Not quite like that,” Kíli reminded her.  “We had to do quite a bit of running around in Limbo to get back here.”

“Hullo Chief!” Doeli greeted Kíli, before spying Ori.  “Oh…Master Ori.  No hard feelings?”  Doeli was the one that knocked the wind out of Ori on Bed-Lama when he orchestrated a bit of mayhem to try to get away from Limbo.

“Oh, no.  None.  That’s quite the weapon you had,” He told her, and took her hands into his own.  

 

From his bedroom, Thorin sat himself up.

“Glóin has a granddaughter,” Thorin sighed.  “And she’s in Starfleet.”

 

“Yes,” Thranduil said.  His transition from sitting perfectly still in the armchair to suddenly speaking was jarring.  “Many of our kind have begun the pilgrimage to Terra to study.”

“Why are you here?” Thorin asked.  

“I am not entirely sure,” The King of Greenwood said.  “Rivendell has received a similar guest, who arrived in a similar manner from Romulus.  Romulans,” Thranduil said with barely contained contempt.  

“Aye,”  Thorin agreed.

“Why do you not join their revels?” Thranduil asked.  “This is all for your benefit.”

Thorin scoffed.  “No.  This is for the benefit of a dead Dwarrow.  Their dead Dwarrow.  I am but a…”

“A cuckoo,” Thranduil suggested.

Thorin turned to look at the High Elf, a quizzical look on his quickly scowling face.

“They often place their eggs in other birds’ nests, and their young is raised by the host nest,” Thranduil explained.  “But regardless, you are here.”

“You are uncannily more affable than the Elven King from my own reality,” Thorin observed.  

“Indeed,” Thranduil said.  “We are only met tonight; any quarrels I had with this reality’s Thorin Oakenshield died with him eighty-odd years ago.  We are free of course,” Thranduil said pointedly, “To begin new quarrels.”

“Perhaps some other time,” Thorin suggested.

 

He was interrupted by the sound of someone clearing their throat.

 

Thorin looked at the door entrance and saw another Cainian in a Starfleet uniform.  She wore her hair back and it was honey blonde.  Like Ensign K’gar she had a hound-like snout, and her muzzle had long whiskers.  

 

“You’re not supposed to be in here without escort,” She addressed Thranduil.  “Technically, you’re supposed to be in Rivendell, but we can let that slide.”

The King of Greenwood stood up to his full height, but the Cainian woman stepped right up to him.  “Out,” she told him.  “Or I’m staying put to make sure you play nice.”

Thorin was amazed to see anyone stand toe-to-toe with Thranduil.  

“Madam Diablador,” He said at last.  “Your mother will hear of this.”  With that he stalked out.

“Bye,” she said after him, before turning back to Thorin.  “The maturity of the High Elves,” She scoffed.  “Comes down to tattling on me to my mommy.”

“You are Bruffi’s sister,” Thorin surmised.  

“I am,” Buffi K’gar confirmed.  “I’m also the First Officer of the Medi.  I just finished my shift and came down to pay my respects.”

She sat down upon the side of the bed.  “Speaking of my mother, she’s authorized me to invite you to her hospitality at the Cainian Consulate on Earth,” She told Thorin.  “She does so at the behest of the Lady Dís.”

“My…sister?” Thorin asked.

“Yes.  Apparently, the two of them are friends,” Buffi said.  She put a hand upon Thorin’s arm.  “I’d like the two of us to be friends as well.”

Thorin looked at her suspiciously.  “And why is that, Madam?”

Buffi smiled warmly, and replied,  “Because we share at least one friend in common.”

Thorin said nothing.  He stared at his hands in his lap.

“He’s a well-read author these days,” Buffi said.  “Mostly travelogues to places that most of us take for granted, but he always seems to look at the quadrant with entirely new eyes.  He made Ohio feel interesting, believe it or not.”

“Oh…hai…O?” Thorin sounded the word out.

She waved her free hand.  “It’s an area of Earth that Captain Reid’s from.  The point is…” Buffi continued.  “He’s never in the same place twice.  He’s always traveling and always writing.”

“This doesn’t sound entirely like the same individual I knew,” Thorin said.  “He was determined to remain a homebody with his books and his…armchair over there.”

Buffi got up and plucked a book from the shelf Thorin pointed at.  She placed it by him and sat back down.  Thorin looked at the gilded letters on the leather-bound book.  

 

Here, There, Everywhere

 

A Halfling’s guide to the Alpha Quadrant.

 

“Oh, and look, there’s photographs in these sections,” Buffi pointed out.  

 

And there he was, grinning like mad, in Wayne County, Ohio, in a field full of dairy cows.

In the Mississippi Delta, trying to reel in a gigantic catfish.

In Vulcan’s Forge, with a towel wrapped around his head, giving two thumbs-up.

Wrapped up in a parka on Andor, snow blowing everywhere.

 

Thorin put the book down.  “Just one adventure after another,” He said.

 

Outside, Thorin and Buffi could hear someone begin to pick at what sounded like a guitar.  

“I think this is the musical section of the party,” Buffi said, grinning.  Thorin noticed that while her large canines were displayed, it was still friendly.  

“Who is playing?” He asked.  “It sounds like a lute.”

“It’s a guitar, so I suppose it’s Kíli,” Buffi replied.  “Fíli still plays the violin.”

Thorin nodded his approval.  

 

“Are you gonna keep picking and grinning are you gonna play something?” a voice that Thorin had not yet recognized called out.

“Well?” Buffi asked.  “You gonna join the party?  There’s pizza out there waiting for you.”

“I want to hear Kíli play,” Thorin said.  

Buffi opened the door and Thorin slowly padded over on his stocking feet.  There, he could see them almost all of them: Dori, Nori, and his Ori;  Bifur and Bofur and Bombur holding some strange round dish of food;  Gloin and his son Gimli, whose beard had grown almost as spectacularly as his father’s. and the young Dwarrowdam with dark hair and a short goatee that Thorin supposed was Doeli.  They were all gathered around where Fíli and Kíli were.  Fíli had a device that he was playing like a harpsichord, while Kíli was playing a device that barely looked like an instrument.  

Then there was the elf.

Tall, fiery red hair, and her expression was equal parts love, happiness, and profound sadness.

Kíli began to sing.

 

You're alone in the rain

Been thinking of you

You can't stop your tears

When you stayed with me just before

I want to know

Do you love me?

 

How long you had to wait for me

You can't think of yesterday

I got in a fight

When you saw me

But I couldn't talk and sprawled out on the floor

So it's too late

 

Thorin knew why the Elf-lass was sad.  Tears came to his own eyes as her hand rested on Kíli’s shoulder.

 

Oh Girl, How can I speak with you

If you could hear my secret

Now I really want to talk

It's a shame

Oh, Did you know

A way that you can find what you seek

You'll be stronger for real

 

“Oh, lad, that’s too sad a song to be a love song,” Gimli protested, wiping his eyes.  

“But you need sadness in a love story,” the voice of the man Thorin didn’t recognize protested.  He was stout and had short-cropped blond hair, and a lantern jaw. He was dressed in the same uniform as Reid and Buffi K’gar.  “You need it just before the happy ending.”

“And there was a happy ending,” Kíli said.  “But with all good things we had to earn it, didn’t we, love?”

“We searched across a continent on a foreign world for it,” the Elf—was her name Tauriel?—replied.

Kíli adjusted his instrument, and lifted his head up.  “All right, lads, I’m going to need a good hum out of you.”

One by one, the Company gave forth a guttural hum that resonated in the hall of Bag End.  Buffi closed her eyes and her whiskers flickered.  Thorin did the same.

 

And Kíli began a more upbeat song about calling a place called America and everyone’s spirits were much more higher with handclaps all around.  Buffi left Thorin’s side and came back with a plate of what Thorin supposed was pizza.  It was a piece of soft bread with sauce, cheese, mushrooms and green peppers on top.  Thorin took a bite.  Then he took an even bigger bite.  

“This is even better than the sandwiches!” he exclaimed.  

“Welcome back to the world,”  Buffi said.  

“Your captain,” Thorin said, between bites, “Confided that though he’s wandered through much of Middle-earth, he felt himself to be a child learning his lessons.  What of you?”

 

Buffi looked far away for a moment, and for a time, Thorin thought he could hear more of that piano music in a gentle wave of arpeggios.  

“Do you remember,” Buffi said softly.  “Do you remember the first time you visited the Shire?”

Thorin did, and he nodded.  The lush green of the hills, the folks content to work the land and to visit amongst themselves.  He envied their simple lives and their simple desires to enjoy life.

“I spent most of my life in cities,” Buffi explained.  “My mother worked at the Consulate on Manhattan Island, while my father was off on his expeditions.  We didn’t actually live in the House of K’gar.”  

Thorin didn’t ask her to clarify what that meant, though he believed he understood the context.  “I see.”

“And while my first taste of Middle-earth was being led by the Steward of Gondor through Minas Tirith and looking out at all they had built, I will always—always—remember those green hills, and those little people so happy with their work.  That and the acorns.”  Buffi added.

“Hmm?” Thorin jerked his head away from the pizza.

Buffi dismissed her thoughts with a wave.  “That’s a silly little story, neither here nor there.”

They stood there quietly for a little while longer, before Thorin asked Buffi, “You don’t have to stand guard over me.  Please enjoy this gathering.”

“It’s fine,” Buffi said.  “I want to.  You’re not what I expected.”

“No?” Thorin asked.  “No, I suppose not.  I do have a bit of a reputation.”

“Ehh.  So do I,” Buffi replied.  “People change.  The people in our lives change us.”

“Who were you, then, Ms. K’gar?” Thorin asked.  “And who changed you?”

 

Buffi looked at Thorin and grimaced.  “I was a hurt and angry young woman who took that hurt out on the world.  I turned my pain into self-righteousness and built a tower around myself that no one could climb or enter.  Not even Galadriel herself could see my heart, I’d protected it that well.”

Thorin took Buffi’s hand into his and patted the top of it with his other hand.  “I know that tower well.”

“I let a man love me and he was taken away.  I let myself love another man and he betrayed and abused me and my trust.  And so I built that tower.  And while I worked with the Reids, I let the tower come down slowly.  I let people in—mostly people with the last name of Baggins—and I found a mission.”

“Those Bagginses,” Thorin murmured.  

“And one day…my man came back,” Buffi continued.  “And, you know, it wasn’t happily ever after, but…we got there.”

“Happily ever after until the end of your days,” Thorin replied, “Is the rarest of endings.”

“Someone once told me,” Buffi retorted, “That there are no such things as happy endings, because nothing really ends.”

“Some things do,” Thorin replied.  “Some things have to end.”

“Come on,” Buffi said, extending her hand back to Thorin.  “They’d all like you to join them.”

There was a time that Thorin Oakenshield would just as soon hack the hand off of someone who looked like Buffi K’gar as take it in friendship.  But the kindness that she and the other strangers had shown him along with these same-but-different kin and friends were keeping him afloat in unfamiliar seas.  Even as he took Buffi’s hand and let himself be led, he didn’t feel like his feet were quite reaching the floor, that a wave was about to crash into him, leaving him lost forever.  

Notes:

Song List:

"I want to know" --Benjamin Anderson (Kill la Kill soundtrack)
"Calling America"--Electric Light Orchestra
"Eternity ~Memories of Lightwaves~ Noriko Matsueda and Takahito Eguchi (Final Fantasy X-2 Soundtrack)