Chapter Text
He found himself in a nice, warm bed.
He’d slept through the night, Thorin realized. The sun once again shone through the window.
No Dr. Ch’tra this time. Instead, Thorin could hear the faint sound of humming.
Someone was humming somewhere in Bag End.
Thorin sat himself up, put a pillow to prop himself up, and sighed.
Now Thorin could hear singing. Despite himself, he smiled.
“Let’s go in the garden,” The voice sang.
“Hello?” Thorin called out.
“Oh, we’re awake!” the voice answered. “Fancy some breakfast?”
“Of course,” Thorin replied.
“Good!” And there he was, Bilbo Baggins, one-time burglar, and, according to Buffi K’gar, now a galactic bon vivant, With a bed tray filled with capers, sausages, and eggs, along with a carafe of juice.
“There’s, eh, coffee brewing, if you like,” Bilbo said, putting the tray in front of Thorin.
Thorin nodded.
“So!” Bilbo began. “You’re my houseguest, then?”
“I suppose,” Thorin replied. “You had me come here when they revived me.”
“I’ve visited your sister in the Ered Luin,” Bilbo said. “It’s a lovely place to stay, but a dreadful place to find oneself when coming back from the dead.” Bilbo looked over his shoulder, and glanced back at Thorin. “And a hobbit’s home is made for comfort.”
“Yes.” Thorin said.
“So there you go, then!” Bilbo said, smiling. However Thorin noticed that the smile didn’t entirely reach his eyes.
“Will…will Dr. Ch’tra be coming back to check on me?” Thorin asked.
“The good doctor will be along to check your vitals, as will your nephew,” Bilbo answered. “Probably as soon as your sister and her husband arrive.”
“She’s remarried?” Thorin asked.
“That’s for her to explain,” Bilbo said, waving the subject away. “But don’t worry. He’s a fine chap.”
Thorin ate the breakfast silently while Bilbo watched him. Now the smile was gone from Bilbo entirely.
“Your scar,” Bilbo said, absently touching the bridge of his own nose. “It’s the same injury.”
Thorin glanced at Bilbo. “It seems that we are very much alike, your Thorin and myself.”
“Yes, it would seem,”Bilbo agreed, nodding his head. “Little differences, here and there.” Bilbo circled the bed, while Thorin continued to eat. “It’s a bit dangerous, you know? Second-guessing your choices in life.”
Thorin looked up at Bilbo, but said nothing.
Bilbo continued puttering around the room, clucking his tongue at the books that Buffi had left out the night before and re-shelved them. “She never puts my books away, never mind that she has every single sentence I ever published,” Bilbo explained as he went.
“She was showing me,” Thorin said. “Showing me pictures of you.”
Bilbo chuckled. “Was it the cows? She can’t get enough of the dairy farm story.”
Thorin smiled warmly. The picture of Bilbo in the field of dairy cattle was endearing, to say the least. Then as soon as it started, the smile faded again.
Bilbo moved the armchair back over to the bed and grabbed his own breakfast plate and began to tuck in.
Thorin looked at Bilbo as he ate and mused, “I always wondered how you managed to put it all away.”
“Hobbit appetite, I suppose,” Bilbo said, wiping his mouth with a napkin. “Accelerated physiology and all that.” Bilbo paused for a moment. “I’ve seen you put a meal away quite heartily yourself, if I recall.”
Thorin shrugged. It wasn’t that way the last time Thorin recalled—not that he wanted to recall those last days.
Before he knew it, his hands were being held by Bilbo’s. “It’s going to be all right,” Bilbo told him. “We’re here, together, and we will get you better.”
“You are too kind, B—Master Baggins,” Thorin said. He stared at his glass of juice.
“I realize we—you and I—we don’t truly know the other,” Bilbo said. “This alternate universe business, quite frankly makes me go cross-eyed if I think about it too much. So can we forget about it? You can be my Thorin, and I could be your Bilbo, if you’d like.”
Thorin looked at Bilbo, with a look of near-horror, and took his hands away from Bilbo.
Bilbo looked stricken for a moment, but recovered quickly. “So tell me, Master Dwarf. How do you know me? Him. Me. Damn,” Bilbo cursed.
Thorin didn’t speak.
Bilbo continued on. “The last time I spoke to you, you tried to apologize to me,” Bilbo said quietly. “You weren’t yourself, you see. The dragon-sickness, and the Arkenstone business—It was intense. But then you fell at Ravenhill, and I was there…to see you off.” Bilbo wiped his eyes. “By the Lady, that was so long ago, and so much has happened. I don’t even feel like the same Bilbo myself.”
“You’re the Bilbo who went to the Terran Homeworld,” Thorin said. “To Vulcan. Tell me, did you manage to get to Qo’NoS?”
Bilbo sighed and chuckled. “No, not quite. There was that nasty business with the Civil War a couple years ago. Some of the youngsters brought a souvenir back, however.”
Thorin’s eyes widened as Bilbo gestured toward the hallway. It was much smaller than one made for a grown Klingon, but all the same, a miniature bat’leth hung on Bilbo’s wall in the hall.
He got up, brushed the crumbs off of his lap, and walked back to the doorway. “I’ve got to get this place in living condition for the Gamgees—they’re the ones that live here now—the next time they get back home. You’re welcome to get up and help me, if you’d like.
Thorin shrugged and got himself out of bed. He found that he was much less stiff than he was yesterday. The Thunderan doctor had told him that it would be so. Even so, he made slow deliberate movements and began to pad around the room.
“It may not do for me to continue to move about in pajamas,” Thorin said, glancing at Bilbo.
“Fíli left you something to wear,” Bilbo said, from the hallway. “Something contemporary, but I’m sure it’s to your taste.”
Bilbo continued to the kitchen. Despite the replicator technology he’d brought back with him six years ago, he’d left the kitchen otherwise untouched, albeit with a more efficient oven and stovetop, and, of course a powered cooler. Within he’d found all the uneaten pizza from the night before. He chuckled and shook his head as he took a square for himself.
“There’s, erm, some leftovers from last night,” Bilbo called back. “They say that cold pizza makes a fine breakfast, but I’ll, erm, let you decide for yourself, eh?”
Thorin entered the kitchen wearing a royal blue tunic, with twin vertical braids down the front. The trousers were black and the boots he wore made solid reports on the hardwood floor.
“It looks right, but feels strange,” Thorin said, as Bilbo handed him a plate. “The sleeves are—thank you—tight at the wrist, and the un—“
“Yes?” Bilbo said, bemusement in his voice as he grabbed his towel. He began to wipe down the countertops.
Color began to creep up Thorin’s neck. “At any rate, what can I do?”
“Grab the broom, and start sweeping up the crumbs,” Bilbo told him.
Thorin did so, and as they began to wordlessly clean the kitchen, Bilbo resumed humming to himself, and sang a few lines once again. “Let’s go in the garden, you’ll find something waiting…” he sang.
“Ah, I’ve missed those quaint hobbit songs,” Thorin said, still sweeping. He glanced at Bilbo and grinned. “A song for every occasion.”
“It’s, erm, actually a Terran song,” Bilbo amended. “Captain Reid taught it to me.”
“Terrans,” Thorin said, shaking his head. “It’s hard to believe they can be trusted here.”
“Not where you’re from?” Bilbo asked.
“No.” Thorin shook his head again. “They built a empire, subjugating hundreds of peoples in the quadrant, and only when they’d begun their reforms to become more benevolent, they were conquered by the Alliance. Our world—barely—stayed neutral, even when the ships rose.”
“The Numenorean ships? When did they arise on your world?” Bilbo asked. “For us, it was only a decade ago.”
“The ships arose from the oceans not soon after—after the Battle,” Thorin said, leaning the broom against the wall. “We found the signs of Numenor within, and the Dunedain—what little remained of them—were called to decipher them. What they taught in so little time, also protected us against the Alliance when they sought to take what was not theirs. The Alliance—and the Army of the Eye.”
“Well, here, the Men of the Terran Homeworld managed to stave off extinction—just barely—by allying themselves with the Vulcans and the Andorians, and the Tellarites, and after they banded together to fight the Romulans, they formed a Federation,” Bilbo explained. “They eventually formed a philosophy of peace and to leave alone those worlds that were on their own paths. That is why the Numenorean ships weren’t raised until recently.”
“Eighty years of innocence,” Thorin said.
“For some,” Bilbo admitted. “Not for all of us.”
“Did you have knowledge of life beyond Arda?” Thorin asked. “Balin had told me about the Empire, and their conquests of the stars—you?”
“Balin did indeed,” Bilbo admitted. “He gave me books, literature, history…all the things I wasn’t supposed to know about in Middle-earth. But then again, I’d been changed by my experiences, and learning about life on other worlds seemed par for the course. It was then that I’d decided that I’d tell my story and send it out there…and so I did.”
Thorin smiled warmly at Bilbo, and took a step toward him. “It’s so amazing,” He said. “What you accomplished.”
“I’m only telling the good parts,” Bilbo admitted. “Those many years of feeling…wrong, because of that accursed device, of being devoured from within without even knowing.”
Thorin frowned. “What?”
Bilbo shook his head. “You had your dragon-sickness, Thorin. I had that Ring.”
Thorin’s eyes widened. “Your invisibility ring?”
“It was indeed a Ring of Power,” Bilbo said. “It turned out to be the Big One. The one that started everything.”
Thorin looked lost. “The War of the Ring, they’d called it. Your ring.”
Bilbo shook his head. “Not mine. Not in the end. Do you want to know?”
And so, while they brought the cold tea service trays from the parlor to the kitchen, Bilbo explained how he’d taken in his cousins Drogo and Primula’s son Frodo when they’d died unexpectedly and raised him from a young lad. How he’d left the Shire on his eleventy-first birthday, and how he’d slowly gotten away from the Ring. From there, it was Frodo’s tale to tell.
Thorin’s brow knit together. “I’m so sorry. I wish—“
“Yes?” Bilbo looked at him. He was now working on the cushions in the sitting room.
Thorin spoke slowly, as if choosing his words very carefully. “If there are other worlds where things happened differently for us, as they have, then I hope—for our counterparts’ sake—that there was at least one world where neither one or the other of us didn’t depart from the other.” With that, Thorin stood up straight and nodded.
Touched, Bilbo put his cushion down and walked up to Thorin and put a hand on his cheek. “That’s an amazing thing to say.” He withdrew his hand and looked at Thorin for a moment, then a moment longer. “Thorin Oakenshield,” he began, and then stammered for a moment, until he finally blurted it out.
“Were we in love, you and I?”
Thorin deflated when he said it, and sadly looked at Bilbo. “Were we?” he answered back.
“Because, you see, we’d gotten closer and closer on our journey, my Thorin, and despite the one bit of unpleasantness, he seemed to come to like me. And, of course there was those seemingly near misses, where we almost…and then we were interrupted.”
Thorin smiled, his eyes not quite meeting Bilbo’s. “We had those moments as well. I came to be quite fond of him—my Bilbo.”
“Do you think—if things had gone differently—“ Bilbo waved off the passive question and asked the real one. “Did you love me?”
Thorin continued to stare at the floor. “It’s the only thing that makes sense. Why else would I have—why else would I feel that way? Why else would I have hated myself so much?”
“Hated yourself?” Bilbo patiently said.
“Did you come to love him?” Thorin asked.
“Don’t change the subj—“
“Did you?!” Thorin said, raising his voice for the first time.
Bilbo Baggins plainly looked at Thorin and simply said, “Yes.”
Thorin blinked tears away from his eyes.
“I loved him enough to risk our friendship to save his life and sanity,” Bilbo continued. “I loved him enough to be sent back to the Shire.”
“Loved him enough to risk your own life?” Thorin asked. “You were a little foolish sometimes.”
“I was younger then,” Bilbo admitted. “All those life lessons ahead. The ones you helped to teach me.”
The two of them were still almost nose-to-nose, their foreheads touching. “Go on then,” Bilbo goaded the Dwarf, smirking. “Give an old hobbit a kiss.”
It was Thorin that broke away. “We should finish this before my sister arrives,” he weakly said.
“Very well,” Bilbo sighed. From the sitting room to the Parlor, they moved to straighten things up, including the umbrella holder that Thorin glanced at. Bilbo continued to hum his tune. “Right there where you left it, lying upside-down,” He sang. Thorin wandered to another bookshelf, with volumes removed. He picked one up, and flipped through it, revealing drawings within.
“These are unusual,” He murmured. “The front is on the wrong side.”
“Oh!” Bilbo exclaimed. “That’s my manga translations. I work with a publisher on Arda to translate the stories from Japanese to Westron. Which one have you got there?”
Thorin squinted at the print under the foreign characters on the front cover. “Lupin the Third,” he said.
“Oh, that’s a good one!” Bilbo said. He looked at the books littered atop the coffee table and sighed. “Looks like the Company agreed as well. I’ll have to inventory to see if anyone has ‘borrowed’ a volume.”
“What’s it about?” Thorin asked, flipping through the pages. “And how do I read this?”
“The panels go right to left,” Bilbo explained. “It’s about…” And then Bilbo laughed heartily. “It’s about a burglar!”
Thorin cocked an eyebrow as he glanced at Bilbo and continued. “Is he a good one?” he asked.
“Good enough to have the international police after him,” Bilbo explained as he gathered the books in his arm. “And he’s as good with the women as he is with stealing things. He doesn’t travel alone, mind. He’s got his right hand man, Jigen, and a warrior, named Goemon, who work with him. Not to mention the beautiful Fujiko!”
Thorin sat down, his cleaning work forgotten, as he was absorbed into the story. Bilbo continued to work around him. “If you like Lupin, you might like some of the Tezuka graphic novels I’ve translated. The Phoenix series is particularly interesting.”
“How did you come to this?” Thorin asked.
“The father of the turtle-lads is Japanese,” Bilbo explained. “When we met, I told him of my passion for learning languages and translating volumes, and he suggested I learn his native language of Japanese. From there, I found these centuries-old stories—think of them as akin to illuminated pages or tapestries, but bound in paper, with a forward narrative. The lads called them ‘comic books’ but that hardly does the art justice, does it?”
Thorin looked at the illustrations. Though it was a static image in each panel, Thorin could see that Lupin was a character that was constantly in motion, his arms flailing, his face contorted in some expression or another. He was in stark contrast to Jigen, who was cool and still.
“So,” he said at last. “Would you say that you are like Lupin, while I am more like Jigen?”
Bilbo screwed up his face in thought. “Well,” he replied. “I don’t think I’m quite as lusty as Lupin is. And you’re not quite as low-key as Jigen.”
Still, Thorin thought. It might be fun to attempt that chinstrap of a beard Jigen was wearing.
“Well, let’s see,” Bilbo scanned his manga bookshelf. “Akira…Maison Ikkoku…Lone Wolf and Cub…Uzumaki…ohh, don’t read that after dark…Oh! Chobits, that was a charming one.”
Bilbo looked over to Thorin who continued to devour the Lupin books. “I’ve also translated some other Terran literature to Westron, if you please. “David Gerrold? Diane Duane? Nicholas Sparks?”
“I was a very shy Dwarrow-lad,” Thorin said. “I’d spend as much time as I could reading. I had to be pried off of my seat to learn my numbers or how to fight.”
“I know,” Bilbo said. “Your sister told me.”
“I’d have read stories like this like mad,” Thorin said. “Sneak a candle in my bed chamber and risk setting my bed on fire to read. Frerin nearly pulled my braids off my head when I almost did!” And with that, Thorin threw back his head and laughed freely, for the first time since he’d awakened. Bilbo joined him in laughter and clapped his back.
And like that, Thorin stopped. As if, Bilbo thought, he remembered he wasn’t supposed to be happy.
“We…we should continue,” Thorin finally said.
“Oh, Thorin,” Bilbo sighed. “Won’t you tell me what happened to you? I know you’re not from this world, but…” Bilbo put a hand to his mouth as he struggled to find the right words. “Your entire being is filled with sorrow, and despite all this effort to lighten your spirit, it cannot depart you.” Now Bilbo was sniffling. “I wish with all my heart I could take it from you. I wish I could have been there with you to—”
“But you weren’t.” Thorin said, flatly.
“Why wasn’t I?” Bilbo demanded. “What happened to that Bilbo that he didn’t help you when you needed him the most?
“I—!” Thorin cried
“Yes?” Bilbo exclaimed, once again, in front of Thorin. The Thorin he knew would never allow anyone to confront him so directly.
“I—!” Thorin stammered again.
“What happened to me?”
“I KILLED YOU!” Thorin wailed.
After Thorn’s voice rang out, The silence in Bag End covered them like a shroud.
Bilbo didn’t look shocked. He nodded and sat Thorin down. “That would have done it, yes.”
“Y-you don’t understand,” Thorin said. “I…wanted to throw you down that wall to the rocks below. I was going to do it!”
Bilbo nodded. “You weren’t well. You were under some kind of psychic attack. It wasn’t you.”
“But…it was. I could have picked you up with my bare hands and hurled you off that rampart, but as it was, the Company rebelled. They rushed me, to get you to safety, to clap me in irons, to stop their mad King. But my hand slipped…”. Thorin took a hand away from his face and thrust it toward Bilbo. “I was snapped awake, I saw clearly what was happening, but it was too late! Too late. You dropped onto the top of the wall, but you went the wrong way. You fell down to the rocks below. We flew to the base of the Rampart. They told me that, no, you were all right, you were wearing that shirt I’d given you. You wouldn’t have suffered more than a final indignity.”
Bilbo maintained his calm gaze at Thorin.
“We came upon where you'd come to rest, and I knew immediately. Your head was wrong. Your neck…you’d snapped your neck. And that was that. There was no time to mourn, because there was a battle to fight. And after…”
Thorin collapsed on the sofa, resting his head in Bilbo’s lap. He was shuddering as he spoke, as if getting the words out were a physical effort. Bilbo supposed that it was.
“After, we took stock. A third of the Company, dead. Fíli and Kíli, alive, but maimed. The Ur brothers, killed protecting me. And all those arrangements…”
“Funeral costs were covered in the contract,” Bilbo recalled.
“And if nothing else, I would be true to my written word,” Thorin replied. “So your body was sent back to the Shire, quietly. What funeral arrangements Pallando made for you with whatever family received you, I never found out. And time passed on in the Mountain. But on that throne…it stretched. You know?”
Bilbo nodded. “It was the same for me, with the Ring.”
“And It just…I couldn’t do anything. I lay in chambers, while Balin and Dwalin quietly ruled as my proxies. And before long, talk about producing an heir…”. Thorin shuddered again.
“And it just kept going on and on…I could not stand feeling in that way. It had to stop. And so I worked in secret, arranging in writing for my cousin to become Crown Regent, while Fíli continued to recover. You know, Dain?”
“I remember him,” Bilbo said, as he stroked Thorin’s hair.
“Made all the arrangements. I would not have the Kingdom I had rebuilt fall because of my…It would stand.
“So finally, I sent for an item from the Ered Luin, possibly because I thought I was being clever or poetic…I called for a poisoned Orcish blade. And on the fifth anniversary…”
Thorin didn’t burst into tears. He did not engage in ugly sobbing. He lay there, head in Bilbo’s lap, keening his sorrow in low tones. Bilbo recalled doing the same, when their roles were reversed.
“It’s all right,” Bilbo said. “It’s all right.”
They stayed like that, for what seemed like an hour.
“You have said nothing,” Thorin said at last. “What must you think of this wretch who was once a King.”
“I think you are a Dwarf who was ill,” Bilbo replied. “And that doesn’t make you weak, and it doesn’t make you a failure. And, thanks to modern technology, it means you are a survivor.”
Thorin looked up at Bilbo.
“You didn’t kill me,” Bilbo told Thorin, “And killing the other me was ultimately a terrible accident.” Bilbo put his hand on Thorin’s cheek. “And for what it’s worth…I forgive you.”
“Do you think he would have forgiven me?”
Bilbo leaned down, and kissed Thorin’s cheek, wet with his tears. “There is more in you of good than you know, Thorin Oakenshield,” He told him. “Oh!”
Bilbo produced a piece of paper from his pocket. “Found this cleaning. It seems that you made quite the impression on our Commander K’gar last night.”
“That’s an understatement,” Thorin sighed, lifting his head back up.
“Do you want to read it, or shall I?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin nodded.
“‘ The hardest thing in this world is to live in it.
I learned that a lifetime ago from a woman whose memory inspires me daily.
Live, Thorin.
Buffi Mar’i K’gar.’”
“Now that’s a woman you want on your side in a fight,” Bilbo remarked, and began to hum again.
“Fíli wants me to come with him to Earth,” Thorin said. “I’d much rather stay here with you.”
“Well, that’s a problem,” Bilbo replied. “I don’t actually live here anymore!”
“Dr. Ch’tra said you were—“
“I am a benefactor of Bag End. I share ownership of it with the Gamgee family, the son of my former gardener. I put forth efforts to install modern comforts into the place, and they have a home for their ever-growing family. The way it was meant to be. Samwise serves on the USS Mediterranean as its chief engineer—“
“A hobbit?! An engineer?!” Thorin interjected.
“It’s a strange old world. And we all come to call this place home, the Bagginses and the Gamgees. And when you’ve gotten well, you may as well.”
“Do you think I should go with Fíli to San…San…”
“San Francisco is a fine Terran city,” Bilbo answered. “Fíli is a fine doctor, and he will work tirelessly to get you to your fighting strength.”
“Will you visit me?”
“Believe or not, I do have a residence on Earth!” Bilbo exclaimed. “I have a hobbit hole residence not far from where Captain Reid grew up, in a place called Petros Park. We can have tea daily, if you wish.”
“Can we visit the cows?” Thorin asked, a dry smile now creeping along his face.
Bilbo leaned onto Thorin, his head resting on his shoulder, chuckling. “Until the cows come home!” and with that they both laughed.
“Finish that song,” Thorin asked.
And Bilbo did.
“Let’s go in the garden
You’ll find something waiting
Right there where you left it
Lying upside-down.
When you finally find it
You’ll see how it’s faded
The underside is lighter
When you turn it around.
Everything Stays
Right where you left it
Everything Stays
But it still changes
Ever so slightly
Daily and nightly
In little ways,
When Everything Stays.”
