Actions

Work Header

Thief's Conundrum

Chapter 7

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Thorin gestured Bilbo to one of the chairs in the parlor while the servant quickly transferred the contents from the cart to the stone table. The sumptuous spread nearly covered the expanse of the table, its delectable aromas were dizzying and Bilbo’s mouth watered hungrily. He languidly slipped onto a sofa, eyes shifting from dish to dish but never straying out of the boundaries of the table. He mindlessly took the empty plate handed to him and proceeded to pile a bit of everything onto it with swift hobbit precision. He was only slightly bothered by the fact that all the dishes had some type of meat in them and the only vegetables present on the table were in the spicy chili he just scooped into his mouth; he’d have that chili recipe, even if he had to resort to bribery to get it.

Thorin watched silently, sipping weak ale from his cup as Bilbo slowly decimated the feast. He had seen many skirmishes, even one big battle in his one-hundred and some odd years, but he’d never witnessed such annihilation before.

“Is the food to your liking?” Thorin asked, hiding his smirk in his cup.

Bilbo didn’t respond right away, licking his fingers clean of the gooey chocolate monstrosity he just inhaled only a moment before; they were clean and sticky now. Only when he looked up to answer the King’s inquiry did Bilbo realize he not only destroyed a lunch likely meant for two, but he just licked his fingers clean in front of royalty.

“Oh-” Bilbo cleared his throat awkwardly. “It’s a very fine meal indeed. I-uh, my manners seemed to have left me, I didn’t even save you any,” he babbled.

“It was an offering, you do not need to worry about me,” Thorin said while valiantly suppressing his amusement.

“It was still terribly rude of me not to offer,” Bilbo stated matter of factly.

“Be thankful you have not witnessed my nephews or my brother eat; I assure you I’ve seen much worse,” Thorin chuckled as he slipped into the comfy armchair. He released a contented sigh, happy to finally relax after a stressful morning and afternoon; though the evening wasn’t looking to be much better.

Bilbo smiled tentatively, not quite sure what to do yet with the cordiality that the King was showing him.

“I’ve seen plenty of messy eaters myself, Your Majesty, however manners for a hobbit are paramount you see. Why, if my mother were here-” Bilbo frowned, letting that line of conversation trail off bitterly as he was reminded of the predicament his mother was in.

“That’s partly what I would like to speak to you about,” Thorin interjected calmly, capturing Bilbo’s subdued attention. “There is little that I can do from Erebor; our alliances in that part of the world are very weak as you have probably already figured out. We will be unable to send a message.”

Bilbo became tense and his brow furrowed in confusion; Thorin had just promised him a few hours ago that he would be allowed to send a message.  “What? But you said-”

“Be at ease, Master Baggins, and let me continue,” Thorin soothed.

The hobbit nodded hesitantly and relaxed again, allowing Thorin to continue.

“We cannot risk Álvur and his King finding out about the situation here in Erebor; sending a raven or even a dwarf would put more than just your mother in grave danger. Erebor has a long standing accord with elves,” Thorin explained, albeit a little tartly. “Balin has cleverly suggested we route a message through Rivendell, on to the settlement of men near your Shire and then to the leader of your people.”

It was a very clever plan, Bilbo thought. He was a little baffled that he hadn’t thought at all about the repercussions of a letter to the Shire being intercepted by an enemy. However- “A letter won’t be enough though,” Bilbo’s said glumly.

Thorin’s expression turned grim. “It will not be enough, no. Of what we’ve learned from the other thief, if you both have not returned to Eriador before winter begins then King Magni will not be kind to your Shire.”

“Why would he do this just for a stone?” Bilbo said roughly, his voice cracking with emotion.

“It’s not for the stone itself, but for what it represents - what it used to represent,” Thorin sighed tiredly. He had hoped that the Arkenstone farce would just die away completely, but it was a King’s folly and one that would be remembered for ages to come.

“But how can a shiny stone be anything more than just that? You dwarves in your colossal mountains have jewels aplenty, what need is there for that specific stone?” Bilbo fumed. After seeing with his own eyes the wealth of one dwarf kingdom he couldn’t fathom the reason for the deceit of Belegost’s King.

“The days leading up to the discovery of the Arkenstone King Thrór, my grandfather, was showing signs of an illness of the mind. Sometimes he would forget things, his behaviour toward people shifted, he was more quarrelsome and quick to anger; he had more good days than bad. When the Arkenstone was found the changes were more obvious; the shiny stone, as you called it, became a symbol for our kind. Thrór deemed the Arkenstone the King’s Jewel and convinced other dwarven kingdoms pledge their loyalty to it and by extension the stone’s master.”

“How in the world did he ever manage such a feat? Surely the other kingdoms thought better of it?” BIlbo asked, eager to learn as much as he could; the history lesson was quite intriguing.

“Thrór was a great King; he was very charismatic, cared very much for Erebor and its people. He is the reason Erebor is no longer a simple mountain city; Durin’s folk were experiencing their longest period of prosperity since Khazad-dûm,” Thorin explained. “He had the love of his people and no kingdom was willing to go to war with all the others if they stood alone in defiance - it was easy to convince all dwarves that such a precious find was a divine gift.”

Thorin was barely into his forties when it happened and he remembered it all. His heart ached watching his grandfather deteriorate; his father became increasingly strung out trying to covertly keep the kingdom together while simultaneously preventing war behind Thrór’s back.

“The power that the stone granted him began to blacken his heart, and the illness of his mind disrupted our government and unbalanced our economy. Before the Arkenstone, the bottom end of the lower classes had a solid  income; no one went hungry and everyone had a roof over their head. And afterward trade decreased; the men who tended the crops in the valley ceased when the King refused to pay them their promised wages and our closest allies - Dale and the Woodland realm - distanced themselves; all that was mined ended up in the treasury which I have no doubt that you saw with your own eyes. The lower and middle classes suffered the most; in the last years of his reign Thrór was rallying support to retake Khazad-dûm, and when the nobles began to feel the same suffering of the lower classes biting at their heels, the people rebelled.”

“I can’t imagine it ended well. What happened?”

“Erebor was out for blood and the other kingdoms were denouncing their fealty to the King’s Jewel. The masses wanted to see Thrór executed for his transgressions but it wasn’t right to blame him for all that he did while suffering from his illness; he was Erebor’s greatest king.”

“But he still had to answer for what he did, he betrayed many people and rebellions aren’t bloodless,” Bilbo pointed out smartly.

Thorin hummed in agreement. “A closed trial was held, he was deemed unfit to rule and stripped of his Kingship; Thráin-my father-was crowned King Under the Mountain. As his first proclamation, unwilling to be a kinslayer, he banished Thrór from the kingdom; he and Grandmother cleverly sought out the Elven King’s aid before the judgment was rendered.”

“And the stone?”

“The King couldn’t trust that someone wouldn’t try and misuse the stone so he had the vault and all of its security built solely for the purpose of housing the Arkenstone - he even carved the defense runes himself.”

“Wouldn’t it have been easier to crush the stone and get rid of the pieces? Seems like a lot of effort just for one shiny stone,” Bilbo mused. It obviously wasn’t a best kept secret if someone from another dwarf kingdom found out about it. More Importantly, if all of the kingdoms denounced the Arkenstone, how would someone else be able to misuse is?

“My father never told anyone why,” Thorin shrugged and downed the last of his ale.

“What happened to Thrór after he was banished?”

Thorin marvelled at Bilbo’s curiosity; outsiders didn’t care to learn about dwarven history which was freely shared knowledge.

“He lived out the rest of his days in the Greenwood; by the time he got the proper healing treatments, the illness of his mind progressed to a point where Thranduil could only see to his comfort during his extended stay.”

“That is a very sad story,” Bilbo sympathized, his eyes a little downcast.

“History is often unkind, but it is the duty of those living in the present to avoid repeating the mistakes of the past,” Thorin offered sagely. “Those defenses were thought to be impenetrable until very recently. There are still a few of Thrór’s old council who are alive yet and you have given them quite a shock. They want you properly punished.”

Oh. “You didn’t come here for the history lesson,” Bilbo stated meekly. He curled his hands nervously into the legs of his trousers. Thorin was wearing that unsettling expression again, and it made Bilbo’s stomach flip flop.

“I did not come for a history lesson, but I am not here to tell you that you’re to be executed either, so you can relax. Balin is certain he has all the information he needs, but since I can’t let you take the stone and you’re still considered a criminal you will need to punished.”

“How can you tell me to relax one moment and then say that I need to be punished in another?” Bilbo scoffed.

Thorin’s lips twitched amusedly which Bilbo didn’t appreciate one bit.

“This isn’t funny!” Bilbo squawked.

“Perhaps not,” Thorin smirked. “In a few days time a trial will be held to maintain appearances, but your punishment has already been decided; until this mess is cleared up you will be serving under the crown.”

“I’ll be your servant?” Bilbo said incredulously, giving the King a funny look.

“What? No, Balin will be giving you work for the duration of the sentence,” Thorin sputtered.

Of what he learned about Bilbo from the short time spent in the hobbit’s company, Thorin was certain that he wouldn’t take kindly to being someone else’s servant. He didn’t trust that Bilbo wouldn’t make his life a living nightmare either.

“And what about Nori, will he be given the same sentence?” Bilbo asked curiously.

Thorin was silent and Bilbo took that to mean that Nori didn’t get the same treatment; it made him angry.

“How could you not give him the same sentence?” Bilbo scowled, crossing his arms over his chest stubbornly. “He is in the same situation as I am and you’re ready to just throw him in a cell. What a benevolent king you are, Your Majesty,” he mocked sarcastically.

Thorin’s jaw hung loose, his mouth slightly agape as Bilbo scolded him; very few people dared to speak to him like that.

“Dwalin pointed out to me that Nori has been causing trouble for the guard, he can not be trusted with such a lenient punishment,” Thorin explained but Bilbo gave him a look that said his argument was hogwash. He felt a little guilty now that those words left his mouth; the power this fussy hobbit had over him was very bizarre.

“I will see that he is given the same sentence then,” Thorin finally amended.

Bilbo nodded agreeably and relaxed again.

“I would very much like to speak with him, if that isn’t a problem. That won’t be a problem for a King, will it?” the hobbit looked expectantly at Thorin.

Thorin’s lips pressed into a tight line. He wasn’t sure how it had happened, but he was thoroughly wrapped around Bilbo’s little finger.

“I’ll make the arrangements,” Thorin pouted.

“Excellent!” Bilbo grinned.

Notes:

I'm thinking there will probably be 2 more chapters after this one - 3 tops. Nori was suppose to show up in this one but someone wanted a history lesson instead (and they were also quite bossy).