Chapter Text
From Episode 75 of Cypher: The Mysterious Disappearance of Agatha Christie That Probably Has Nothing to Do With Doppelgangers According to Spoilsport RM
RM: When confronted by the police, Christie claimed that she had driven around aimlessly until she came to the quarry. The car hit a bump and her head was slammed against the steering wheel. That’s the last thing that she remembered. Considering the recent passing of her mother and the discovery of her husband’s affair, it is theorized that she had some sort of mental break.
RJ: Yes, reasonable, logically, probably, sure. But consider doppelgangers.
RM: What?
RJ: Hear me out –
RM: No -
RJ: I will edit you right out of this podcast. So, doppelgangers. Have we considered that Agatha Christie was lured out to the chalk pit by her alternate dimension doppelganger, Theresa Neele? In this universe, Theresa Neele was the name of her husband’s mistress but in the double’s dimension, that was her name and Agatha Christie was the woman having the affair. The double then murdered the original Agatha Christie, hid the body, and then the doppelganger took over her privileged life. She immediately took herself to the Harrogate Spa to treat herself to some rest and relaxation before starting her new life with Christie’s cash.
RM: …
RJ: Have you considered aliens?
RM: … No, I did not consider aliens.
RJ: Makes more sense than any of your mildly depressing theories.
RM: The very reasonable and accepted theories that she entered into a fugue state or that she deliberately planned the entire stunt to punish her philandering husband?
RJ: Yeah, those. Also “philandering”. Love it when you break out the four-syllable words.
RM: It makes more sense that the most celebrated mystery author in England was taken from a salt pit by invisible alien creatures with enough intelligence to build vessels capable of interplanetary flight and then dropped her off in London for a good time?
RJ: I mean, they abducted her to the spa. If I were an alien, that’s exactly what I would do. Forget take me to you leader – take me to your leisure.
RM: …
RJ: I thought that was pretty good.
RM: I vehemently disagree with everything that you have said in the last five minutes. Let’s move on. For eleven days she went unnoticed despite a massive media campaign and front-page newspaper coverage. But this was a different time. In this age of cellphone tracking, tracing chip cards, and CCTV cameras in every corner, it’s impossible to just vanish into thin air like Christie did.
RJ (pause): It’s not impossible though.
RM: To do what? Fake your own death or disappear? I would say almost impossible.
RJ: But if someone wanted to fake their own death –
RM: Most of these cases of disappearance end up being kidnappings or a cover for murder. People don’t just disappear. There are 1.6 million CCTV cameras in Korea. They can monitor your emails, your texts, and your bank accounts.
RJ: … But people have disappeared.
RM: They were probably kidnapped or murdered. If you’ve been kidnapped, the likelihood of survival is slim. Why would they keep you alive?
RJ: They really like your company? You make a mean carbonara?
RM: 50% are released after the ransom is paid if it is a kidnapping for profit. But 50% are just killed immediately.
RJ: …But there is still the possibility that people could be found alive afterwards? There’s always hope.
RM: It’s unlikely.
RJ: Unlikely doesn’t mean impossible.
RM: No, it just means that the odds are slim.
RJ: But not zero.
RM: I suppose.
RJ: … More or less possible than aliens abducting Agatha Christie to replace her with an alternate dimension doppelganger whose long-term goal was for her to write “The Halloween Party” which would eventually inflict immeasurable global harm through Kenneth Branagh’s ridiculous Poirot mustache?
RM: …
*
The face of Kim Taehyung, the most famous missing person in Korea, stared up at Namjoon from Seokjin’s case folder placed innocuously on the restaurant table. The hustle of the waitstaff and the clink of metal dishes leant a pleasant white noise, but Namjoon heard none of it over the roaring in his ears.
Everyone knew that face. For a time, it had been everywhere: on the television; on the front of newspapers and magazines; and on posters blanketing Seoul. Kim Taehyung had been considered one of the most handsome bachelors in Korea. He had an easy, sleepy beauty with kind, expressive eyes, soft cheeks and moles in all the right places. He was objectively handsome by everyone’s standards.
He had grown up in the lap of luxury – his parents owned an unspecified chunk of Seoul. He’d insisted on earning his way into university even though there was little point – his destiny was assured as soon as he was born. His time at university had been his parents’ one indulgence of his whims and it had been their last mistake.
Three years into his degree, the chaebol heir had been studying at one of the smaller university libraries late in the evening when he had simply stood up, walk away from his table, and vanished. His bag, laptop, wallet, and phone had been discovered still on his table upon closing. The librarian had searched the entire building and had found no one. He had placed Kim Taehyung’s belongings in the lost and found, and thought nothing of it.
It had been a Friday night - the heir’s bodyguard had the weekend off. There was nothing unusual about Kim Taehyung spending the evening at the library. He had been, by all reports, a diligent student – a hard worker but not naturally gifted. SNU was considered safe – cameras covered most of the campus and it had its own security force. But it wasn’t until Monday when the alarm was sounded that no one had seen or heard from Kim Taehyung for an entire weekend.
His apartment was searched and nothing incriminating was found. Eventually, his phone was traced to the library and the story started to unroll.
Search parties scoured the campus and surrounding areas. All of his usual haunts were flipped and shaken to see if anything came out. His chaebol friends all did carefully scripted interviews about how concerned they were for their friend. The university held a vigil to hope for his safe return.
It seemed impossible that someone like Taehyung had simply vanished into thin air.
There had been no news until a week later when a ransom for 7 billion won was texted to Kim Taehyung’s father. It included the secret phrase between the two of them that was used to confirm proof of life. There was no picture, nothing traceable.
Despite the protests of the Seoul Metropolitan Police, the Kim family paid the ransom electronically and siphoned some of their spare change to the kidnappers for the safe return of their heir.
There was no answer.
The young man was simply never seen again.
No body was ever found. There was no trace of him or sightings that panned out to be anything but wishful thinking. The posters eventually became sun faded and were torn down or plastered over. The university reopened the library and cancelled the extra campus security.
It remained the shame of the Seoul Police Department that they had been unable to find a single clue. The money had simply vanished into a web of untraceable online banking due to the stubbornness of the Kim family in following the kidnapper’s demands.
Three years ago, Kim Taehyung simply stood up on Friday night and vanished.
Namjoon had followed the case obsessively when it’d happened – Taehyung was only a few years younger than him. The facts of the case seemed like something from a detective novel – a young, beautiful man who simply disappears never to be found again. But why did Seokjin care about it or think that they had a chance of solving it when organizations with more money and expertise had failed?
“Why this case?” Namjoon opened the file folder. It was meticulously organized – newspaper articles were clipped together and there were other groupings of police reports, shots from security cameras, floorplans of the library, and a stack of photos. He recognized a few of the security camera photos from the true crime websites he followed and documentaries, but there were some pictures he had never seen.
One caught his eye.
He had never seen a photo of Kim Taehyung where he wasn’t serious, demure, and wearing a suit. He was always poised and put-together in a way that Namjoon could only dream of – and then shake his head because it was never going to happen.
The missing man was in a messy art studio – a beret was perched rakishly on top of his messy curls, and he was holding a paintbrush dripping with red paint. He was standing in front of a painting with a distinct cubist face with a bloody nose. What was shocking to Namjoon, was that he was grinning.
In all of the pictures Namjoon had seen, the man had looked serious and shy. But he looked so genuinely happy, Namjoon’s own lips curled up in response.
It was a candid photo.
Seokjin drummed his fingers on the table.
He never telegraphed his emotions – other than shyness. Namjoon had seen him at work in some very tense situations and he hadn’t been able to tell whether Seokjin was affected at all. Later, when they were at a bar together, Seokjin would rant and complain until he was red in the face about how furious he had been.
But Namjoon was careful and meticulous. He always saved a little brain space to add notes to his file on Kim Seokjin. Seokjin rolling his eyes could mean one of seven things. He had six, very distinct blinks. He had five laughs – one of them very real, one indulgent, one polite, one a little cruel, and one fake.
Seokjin was craning his neck around and humming - which meant that he was feeling anxious and indecisive.
“I…” Seokjin’s fingers stilled. He looked at Namjoon, really looked as if he was studying an abstract painting in a gallery. He wasn’t just looking, he was interpreting. Seokjin wasn’t an analyst in the same way that Namjoon was. He looked at the world like it could be solved – that with the right input and output, everything would balance. Seokjin was attracted to true crime because he thought there were answers to be found – he was not a fan of ambiguity.
Eventually, Seokjin spoke. “I… I knew Taehyung.”
Namjoon, on the other hand, could not hide an emotion if his life depended on it. He knew that surprise was written all over his face. How could Seokjin not have mentioned this before? What did it mean?
Seokjin took a drink of water; his fingerprints were clear in the condensation on the silver cup. “We were at university at the same time, for a year. We had friends in common.”
University Seokjin. What was he like? Was he a partier? Or a serious student? Namjoon tried to image what younger Seokjin would have been like. Instead, what he said was: “You had friends?”
Seokjin rolled his eyes – this one meant he was amused at something Namjoon had said. “Yes, I had friends. You’ve met one of them – Hoseok?”
Hoseok with the wide smile and the boundless energy. He had insisted on taking them to dinner on the 50th recording of their podcast despite their identities apparently being secret (“I can’t keep secrets from Hoseok – just look at that face!”). He admitted that he didn’t listen to the podcast (“Too scary, sorry!”) but he was endlessly supportive. Namjoon liked Hoseok.
“One of them, Min Yoongi - knew Taehyung from Daegu. A good guy.”
Hun. Seokjin had a lot more friends than he had ever let on. He never talked about other people or weekend plans beyond gaming until his thumbs fell off.
“I had already graduated when he… he disappeared.” Seokjin blinked several times while his face was a perfect blank. “When he… went missing, I went back to talk to them, but everything was so chaotic, and campus was locked down. His parents made everything much worse.”
Namjoon could not imagine what his parents would do if he went missing. They called him every weekend and his mother sent him regular daily reminders to drink water and eat lunch. His father insisted on transferring him 50,000 won every month for snacks. “They must have been devastated.”
“They were upset because they thought their golden goose had slipped out of their hands,” Seokjin said in a bitter tone. His eyebrows furrowed. “They always had eyes on him – his grandmother left him a pile of money and bypassed the rest of the family. They couldn’t wait until he turned 25 and could get their grubby little hands on his fortune. I was surprised that anyone managed to find the chance to…”
He didn’t finish this thought. Instead, he spun the file around and flipped through it in a way that told Namjoon he had done it many times before and took out a picture.
It was five men, boys even, sitting on a couch in a dorm smiling at the camera. He recognized Seokjin, immediately. His haircut was atrocious, but he was still the most handsome person that Namjoon had even seen. Beside him was Hoseok, a young man with a heart-shaped smile who had his arm flung around a cat-eyed man who was mugging to the camera.
And there, on the floor, was Kim Taehyung, the Kim Taehyung, with his arm flung around a blonde-haired man with a smile so unrestrained and bright that his eyes were practically closed.
“This was us. Me, obviously, the only ten. Hoseok was in the dance department. That’s Min Yoongi, a librarian. I always thought he’d end up as an anarchist.”
Namjoon raised his eyebrow. His brain was pinging loudly. “Librarian?”
“Yeah,” Seokjin said. He kept his finger on the young Min Yoongi’s chest. “He was working at the library that night. He was the one who found Taehyung’s stuff that he’d left behind. That’s why he didn’t think anything was wrong, at first. Taehyung could always be a bit absent-minded, so he figured he’d just left the stuff there for Yoongi to take care of.”
“Do you think he-“
“He would never hurt Taehyung.” Seokjin’s eyes flashed dangerously. “He loved Taehyung. We all did.”
Noted.
“That’s Park Jimin, sitting beside him. He was a double-major in dance and computer science. A ridiculous combination. They were all younger than me, so I ended up paying for all their food. Every time. They sure could eat.”
Seokjin’s voice was so soft and low as he spoke about them. They all looked so young, and Seokjin didn’t look as sharp as he did now. University Seokjin was padded against all the horrible barbs of the world. His face was now leaner and harsher in its beauty from what he had lived through.
“I graduated and then that fall… Taehyung… was gone. Everyone was… a little broken. Jimin moved back to Busan to be closer to his parents. Yoongi moved there too, for a job last year. Hoseok’s still in Seoul but he works abroad a lot.” Seokjin’s voice was quiet. “Everyone drifted apart after Taehyung… disappeared.”
Namjoon hummed.
Seokjin kept himself to himself. He rarely mentioned other people to Namjoon – he mentioned games that he played, and merch drops for those games. He’d introduced Namjoon to his mother and to Hoseok, but he’d never mentioned anyone from his time before working at the company. Seokjin lived in the present; he rarely looked back into the past – probably because he didn’t like what he saw.
Some people were drawn to true crime because their brains needed to know what was hiding in the dark. Their brand of anxiety was soothed by understanding the worst. Other people had the darkness thrust on them and needed to understand where it had come from.
“What do you think happened?” Namjoon asked finally.
The accepted theory, the theory that Namjoon had always thought was the most likely, was that Kim Taehyung had been kidnapped and kept alive until the ransom was delivered. He had probably been killed as soon as the kidnappers received the money. It was most logical explanation.
To stay hidden for three years in a country where even the back alleys were covered in CCTV cameras was next to impossible. He would have shown up somewhere at sometime. The fact that he hadn’t meant that he was probably gone.
Seokjin put the photo of their group back in the folder. He drummed his crooked fingers on Taehyung’s young, unguarded face in the art studio. “I think that Kim Taehyung is still alive.”
This is why Namjoon preferred to focus on cold cases from other countries or the distant past. Everyone involved was long since passed or the emotions had dulled. Talking about a contemporary, local case made him nervous. A cousin or brother or friend with ties to the victim or the perpetrator could be listening, and it could stir up horrible memories for them.
Emotions were tricky. Emotions were hard to predict and harder to control.
Namjoon kept his attention on Seokjin’s face. He couldn’t tell how Seokjin was feeling. He could tell if he was sad and wanted comfort or angry and wanted an argument. What Seokjin was saying was statistically unlikely but who was he to take away his friend’s hope? So, he answered: “Why?”
“Delicately put, as always.” Seokjin rolled his eyes - laughing a little at Namjoon but not in a mean way. “It’s not just wistful thinking. I am saying this because I think there are unanswered questions about the investigation.
“I’ve never said anything to the police because, frankly, it sounds insane.” Seokjin laughed at himself nervously. “And I’ve never said anything to another human being… but I think… I think that we need to talk to Jimin.”
Jimin. Namjoon looked down at the picture of all of them in the dorm room. Taehyung and Jimin were wrapped around each other, like happy little magnets. Their faces wore mirrored grins.
“You think that he was working with the kidnappers?”
Seokjin scratched the back of his neck. “No. Yes. I don’t know. I mean, according to every Webtoon I’ve read, every twink is a secret mafia boss. But after the disappearance, Jimin left for Busan and never came back. He barely talks to any of us anymore.”
Namjoon could see why he didn’t go to the police. “He went to live with his parents. That’s not suspicious.”
“That’s doesn’t make sense to me.”
“He lost a friend.”
Seokjin narrowed his gaze. Namjoon shivered. “Taehyung was much more than a friend to Jimin. And if you’d ever met Jimin, you would know that he would never walk away from his friends – especially if they were in pain or needed him.”
Namjoon wondered what his life might have been like if he’d had a best friend. He knew people, he’d had friends. But he’d never had anyone that he shared everything with. Really, Seokjin was the closest thing that he had to a best friend. And even now, he could tell that Seokjin was still holding his cards close to his chest.
“Jimin's behaviour afterwards was… out of character. And he was studying in the same library the night of the kidnapping. He’s on camera the entire time in the library. I just think that it would be worth talking to him. The police didn’t question him at all.”
“At all?” Why would the police ignore a potential witness with ties to the victim?
“They took the angle that it must have been organized crime. The Kim family had some shady business deals and had crossed a lot of people. Some people thought this might have been their revenge.”
To kidnap such a high-profile person was a huge risk. If he had been kidnaped, he was dead, and they might never find the body.
“Look. On the surface, this is an open and shut case. The kidnappers were organized crime and they just snatched him from the library. They could have probably figured out the camera angles and avoided being seen. He was a chaebol – they knew that his family would pay the ransom. They took him, and when they got what they wanted, they… got rid of him somewhere that he wouldn’t be found.”
As he articulated the accepted facts of his friend’s disappearance, Seokjin’s face was as cold and remote as the Dyatlov Pass. These were the facts.
“But… Something about this doesn’t add up. I can’t pinpoint exactly what it is – it’s like an error in a spreadsheet that I can’t find. The formula should work but it doesn’t, and I can’t figure out why without going through and finding the mistake. I can’t… I can’t find the mistake, but I know that it has to do with Jimin. I know that something about this is off, but I can’t pinpoint what or why. But I think you can.”
Seokjin’s fingers stretched out towards Namjoon’s hand. For a crazy moment, Namjoon thought that Seokjin was going to hold his hand in the middle of the restaurant, and he slowly unfurled his fist to capture Seokjin's hand. But then Seokjin shook his head and withdrew his hands to hide them underneath the table.
“I think that we should talk to people – Jimin and Yoongi. That’s all. Ask some questions, see what they remember.”
What they would remember is the pain of loosing their friend. What they would remember is having a little part of their heart wrenched from them and stolen. What they would remember is how their whole world shattered.
It would bring up bad memories for Seokjin. It would bring up a lot of bad memories for people that had spent three years living with uncertainty. Namjoon wasn’t sure if he wanted to stir all of that up.
But there was something there.
Something in that file was making Namjoon’s brain buzz. He could feel that whirl in his brain – the click of the gears warming up and the cogs clicking into place. There was something in that file that intrigued him. Something in it was not right.
“Take the file with you.” Seokjin smiled up as the waitress brought his food, arranged it on the table and surrounded it with side dishes. “Consider it. If you think it’s a bad idea, no hard feelings. I won’t be insulted. As I said, it’s a suggestion. We could always do the 100th episode about DB Cooper. I know that people have been asking for it.”
“He died jumping out of a plane,” Namjoon said dully. “It is the least interesting case of all time.”
“That’s not what the polls say,” Seokjin teased. His devoted himself to his food and teasing Namjoon about parachute physics.
After the meal, Namjoon did take the file home. It was meticulous – Seokjin was an accountant and good at details. He had presented a solid case. The police investigation had started with a foregone conclusion and hadn’t bothered to investigate anything else. They had shaken down some local gangs and investigated people with a grudge against the Kim family (which were numerous). But they hadn’t gone beyond that. There were no reports of talking to any of his friends from university beyond simply establishing alibis.
It seemed from the case file notes (Namjoon wasn’t sure that he should have access to them as he flipped through the typed reports with Seoul Police letterhead), they weren’t even aware that Taehyung had friends outside of his approved circle of other chaebols in the business department.
What was also strange is that Taehyung had been failing most of his business classes that semester. A few professors had mentioned that for most of the fall, session, Taehyung had been conspicuously absent from most of his lectures.
Namjoon texted Seokjin.
NJ: Did you know that Taehyung was failing most of his classes? How was he acting before the disappearance?
Seokjin called him immediately. “I know that you’re thinking Namjoon, and you’re wrong.”
Namjoon said nothing.
“Honestly, the few months before he disappeared were the happiest that I’ve ever seen him. Sure, he was failing his classes, but he’d never been happier. He kept talking about all his plans for next year. He wasn’t depressed.”
Namjoon knew how easy it was to mask feelings from other people. It was easy, he did it all the time. But he also knew that Seokjin was canny. He always knew when Namjoon was feeling overwhelmed – sometimes even before Namjoon realized it himself. When Namjoon needed a peopling break, Seokjin would take out his switch without a word and silently play beside him. Seokjin always exited them from meetings or company socials with charming excuses that left everyone laughing.
So, he trusted Seokjin’s opinion. Namjoon dropped that line of inquiry.
For the next week, Namjoon went to work, did his silly little job, ate lunch with his coworkers working on their quarterly project, researched the next case for the podcast (The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum heist), and went home. But in every idle moment, the smiling face of Kim Taehyung haunted him. There was something there. Something that was picking away at his brain.
As he sat in his bed compiling his notes about the art pieces stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner museum with a Rembrandt biography propped on his knees, he shook his head to focus on the task at hand. He really didn’t have any illusions of actually solving a case. He preferred to analyze them – to learn from them. He enjoyed doing the podcast with Seokjin. They got to talk about aspects beyond the case – the history, the sites, the politics or the art –
The art.
That was what was bugging Namjoon.
He sat up in bed, the book falling to his bedroom floor, and went over the folder on his desk. He had flipped through it so many times that he’d memorized how many flips he needed to get what he wanted.
He flipped past the schematics of the library.
The police suspected that the kidnappers had stolen a staff pass earlier in the week in preparation to take their victim out through one of the staff exits that wasn’t covered by the cameras. The student librarians were always misplacing them or lending them to friends to use the staff break room. There were van deliveries that came in and out during the evening. It was likely that they had used the cover of the delivery van to smuggle him out.
But this wasn’t what he was looking for. He flipped past the police reports and the printouts of the faces of the students coming in and out the library that evening. He saw the form of Park Jimin slouched over a desk. Kim Taehyung studying and then the empty table with his things. He saw Park Jimin going into the staff room. Min Yoongi at the Reference Desk.
He was searching, searching, searching for something.
There.
He stopped at the candid pictures, the snapshots of their group that Seokjin had taken, that their friends had taken together.
There it was.
A picture of Taehyung, holding a paintbrush, in front of a large canvas. There was a strange angular face painting on the canvas with a nosebleed.
There.
That is what had been bothering him.
He held the picture closer. Then he grabbed his glasses from the nightstand and looked again.
Outside of true crime, the other thing that he used to calm his brain was art. He liked wandering through art galleries and finding pieces that spoke to him. And he remembered that there had been a piece in an exhibit – something like this in one of the Leeum Gallery a few months ago. The face – the same face. It could be a coincidence, or it could be something else.
He took a picture of the painting and sent it to Seokjin.
NJ: Did Kim Taehyung paint this?
It took a while for Seokjin to respond. Namjoon’s eyes flicked up to the corner of his screen. It was three in morning.
SK: He did. He was always hanging around the art studio and messing around. He always painted that weird face. Why?
Namjoon was flipped through the albums in his phone. He kept detailed pictures of pieces that he liked in carefully arranged folders. And there was the painting that he remembered. It was bright and colourful – maybe inspired by Basquiat. And it had the same face – down to the bleeding nose. It was a connection – maybe it was. Maybe it was nothing.
Namjoon sent Seokjin the picture that he’d taken from the gallery last year.
Seokjin immediately called him. His voice was deep and husky from sleep. “What are you thinking?”
Namjoon hummed. He was busy looking up the artist. They was anonymous, and it was exhibited under a pseudonym: Vante. They had exhibited a few pieces in Busan. The work at the Leeum Gallery had been on loan from a small gallery in Busan named Golden.
“I think that maybe… I think… I think that we should call the police.”
Seokjin groaned. Namjoon could hear him sitting himself up in his bed. Namjoon wondering whether he was wearing pajamas or…
“Namjoon… if Taehyung is still alive, maybe he doesn’t want to be found for a reason. And if we report on something and it turns out to be nothing, we’d be laughed at. Maybe persecuted. His family has so many lawyers.”
Namjoon considered. It was maybe nothing. They only had Seokjin’s memory of the painting to go on. Maybe someone had seen it at the university and copied the style in tribute to the missing student. Maybe it was a motif from another artist that Taehyung had copied. It wasn’t anything concrete. It was just a painting. Just a face.
“You said that this Vante first exhibited in Busan? Why don’t we go down there and investigate? We could talk to the gallery owner at Golden, maybe show Yoongi the picture? Maybe he remembers something. I can contact Jimin to see if he’ll have dinner with us and we can ask some questions to see if anything pops up. Your quarterly project is done, my report is finished. Why don’t we just take a two-week vacation to Busan?”
A vacation. Together.
Namjoon had never taken a vacation with a friend since he was in high school. His university friends had gone abroad but never invited him. They knew that he liked his things his way. Usually, a disruption to his routine made him anxious. A disastrous trip to Jeju had proved to them that bringing Namjoon along was a guaranteed bad time. But he thought that he might like it with Seokjin.
Seokjin could sense his hesitation. “I can make all the arrangements and send you a schedule. I’m the best at planning a vacation.” Seokjin laughed nervously. Namjoon could tell that his lack of response was making him nervous.
“Okay,” Namjoon said finally. This was important to Seokjin and Seokjin trusted him with this. Seokjin believed in him. He had to at least try. “Let’s investigate. Let’s go to Busan and talk to your friends.”
“Yeah,” Seokjin breathed out. “Yeah, okay, Namjoon. We’re doing this!”
Whatever they were doing, they were doing it. Together.
