Chapter Text
On the day after the marriage Dwalin and Thrain take their leave. Bilbo stands awkwardly in the background while Thorin embraces his friend and father, trying hard to fight down the tears. Seeing them clad in their journeying gear drives the knife deeper into his heart.
They will go home.
He cannot.
“Don’t lose hope,” Dwalin whispers as they knock their foreheads together one last time. “We’ll get you back.”
“I’ll do what I can,” Thrain promises, drawing his son in a tight embrace.
And Thorin wants desperately to believe them. But he would not have married this hobbit if the dwarves of Erebor had any power in this affair. Hopelessness spreads in his chest as he watches the familiar figures disappear down the winding path. It’s a bright and beautiful morning; green trees sway in a gentle breeze under a cloudless sky, but darkness fills Thorin’s heart. It’s unlikely he will see either his home or his family again.
Bilbo clears his throat. “I’m going in,” he tells Thorin.
Thorin hears his footsteps fade away. But he remains where is for a long time, staring east over rolling hills and colorful gardens, feeling utterly uprooted and lost. He’s never been so alone, and for all the determination in his chest, he is afraid that he won’t get out of this.
Bilbo looks outside after a while. “Do you want lunch?” he asks.
Thorin doesn’t reply.
Thorin only enters Bag End after the sun has set. Then he marches straight to his room, ignoring Bilbo, ignoring the smell of food wafting through the corridor. He glares at his luxurious surroundings; a mockery of a prison. The mithril candleholders and the ruby-framed fireplace turn Thorin’s stomach.
It’s a cage, he thinks to himself. A thrice-damned cage.
He refuses breakfast and lunch the next day as well.
At dinner Bilbo comes knocking, carrying a tray that smells delicious. Thorin’s traitorous stomach growls and Bilbo has the audacity to look concerned.
“You should eat, Thorin,” he says. “I understand this is upsetting, but -”
“You don’t understand anything!” Thorin shouts, crossing the room to tower over Bilbo, and it drives a spike of satisfaction through his chest to see Bilbo taking half a step back. “If you understood you wouldn’t have insisted on this! You’d not be locking me up here!”
Bilbo’s mouth settles into a firm line and his expression goes flat. “A situation that resulted purely from your inability to control your temper. In case you failed to notice you are not the only party inconvenienced, but as usual your self-centeredness blinds you.”
He sets the tray down on the ground with a final-sounding thud as Thorin fumes silently. Bilbo inconvenienced, pah.
The hobbit casts him a poisonous look. “You would think a prince would know not to think of himself first when there is a kingdom depending on him.”
“You-“
Bilbo doesn’t let him speak. His face twists into an ugly snarl, and his voice turns vicious. “Indeed, I have to wonder if you actually want your people to starve. Ever since you arrived here you have been nothing but dismissive, suspicious and downright hostile. I don't see how that is supposed to help your people.”
Rage boils up in Thorin’s blood. “But you don't need me to act nice,” he hisses back, just as cutting, “You just need to make sure I don't get away - lest you lose your valuable pawn.”
Bilbo snorts. “You are greatly overestimating your own value.”
“And the Shire is not a prison,” Bilbo continues. “You are free to leave. Look how you fare outside of it - or how long it'll take for the mercenaries to catch up with you.”
“Oh, that's the way it is,” Thorin crows. “You'd simply tell them somebody else offed me, terribly sorry your majesty, now back to the contract.”
“Yes,” Bilbo replies with bite. “That is what we will say because it will be the truth.”
Thorin slams the door.
The following day Thorin wakes unusually late. Last night’s fight lingers like a bad memory, while sunlight streams through the thick curtains and his stomach growls with discomfort. Wearily he turns his gaze to the ceiling as his thoughts begin to spiral into anger and despair.
However, his stomach is insistent. He hasn’t eaten since the wedding, he supposes. Which isn’t terrible – dwarves are hardy folk – but the lack of food makes him feel unsteady. Out of sorts. Much as he would prefer to hide away forever, the growling of his stomach denies him that option.
Grinding his teeth, Thorin sits up, stands – totters for a moment – and then marches over to the closet. His travel gear, mended and laundered, hangs there, mocking him. Next to it he finds a selection of shirts, vests, trousers and all other garments needed; obviously made from quality materials and tailored to his size.
Beautiful clothes. Thorin hates them.
Still. Soft cotton sits better against his skin in the Shire’s warmer weather than hardened leathers, however, he feels very naked when he leaves his room. For a moment Thorin glances down the corridor, pondering – he hasn’t truly paid attention to Bag End, doesn’t know what lies beyond all the doors.
Though he does know where the kitchen is.
Nothing stirs, and he rather quickly finds Bilbo has left; at least the note left in the kitchen says so. He won’t be back until late at night either, and Thorin sighs in relief.
Perhaps there was a grain of truth in last night’s confrontation. Thorin hasn’t been on his best behavior, but he also has had no choice at all. It is, he admits to himself in the silence of an empty kitchen, a difficult situation, and he finds that what he originally deemed wrong and right blurring. The kernel of anger filling his chest has not vanished, but shrinks.
The hole in his stomach meanwhile has grown considerably, as a particularly loud growl announces to the world.
Alright, Thorin tells himself, breakfast first. As the royal chef Bombur always used to tell him, any day that doesn’t start with breakfast doesn’t even stand a chance of being good.
Warm sunlight streams in from the outside as Thorin sets down an arbitrary selection of bread, bread spreads and cured meats. Perhaps he could go out, check the perimeter? Then he takes a bite and momentarily forgets about everything.
How.
How can food taste this good?
He’d thought he’d known fine food in Erebor, but this constitutes an entire new dimension. Thorin fumbles with the glass, turning it to decipher the hand-written label – but Bindbale Jam rings no bell, and Thorin is left chewing thoughtfully.
Maybe he shouldn’t have been surprised, he thinks. After all, the Shire’s current power rests on their produce. And the magic nobody speaks about.
However, now that he is in the Shire, Thorin realizes, he has the chance to investigate the foundations of the hobbits’ power. And once he has worked it out, he will write to Erebor and all other kingdoms so they can restore order to the world.
A smile spreads across his face, and once his stomach is filled, he turns from the kitchen to search for the library.
What he finds is a fairly large room housing several bookshelves, another ruby-studded fireplace, two velvet-covered armchairs, and a large desk covered in papers. His curiosity piqued, Thorin takes a glance – but sees only columns of numbers, names of people he does not know, and references to occurrence he has never heard of. Several addresses are located in Gondor, though no more can be gleaned, and Thorin is too honorable to snoop any further.
He didn’t come here to purview his husband’s correspondence – he intends to learn more about the hobbits’ rise to power. Erebor’s histories have ever been vague on that part. Five centuries ago hobbits first began to cultivate the fields down in Rohan, Thorin recalls, and their great success eventually made the men depend on them. From there, their power spread like a plague.
Thorin eyes the shelves. At least Bilbo seems to have arranged his books by topic; the only sensible decision according to Erebor’s librarians. Bilbo collection houses a fair number of books on elvish history and poetry, Thorin realizes with a grimace.
He moves on, finds three entire shelves dedicated to all sorts of collected tales and legends. A few times he recognizes the word magic – but it always, always turns out to be a tale. His mood sinks further when he passes another large section on elvish history.
The dwarven section he finds is only slightly smaller; and to his surprise Thorin spies copies of familiar tomes among them. All five volumes of the History of Erebor as edited by Fundin make Thorin’s lips twitch. His fingers ghost over their hard bindings, and find a small leather tome next to it. Dwarven lineages this one is titled – the author not known to Thorin, but they did their research well.
Nostalgia rises when Thorin discovers the Tales of Aule and his Children – his father used to tell him and his siblings those when they were young. Those rare moments when politics hadn’t claimed their family; when even Thror sometimes joined in to add a note or two to the tales.
But that was a long time ago, back when his mother had been alive, and the world had seemed simple.
Thorin reluctantly ignores two rare books. There are only three surviving copies of The History of Khazad-dum left; one shouldn’t be hidden away in a private collection in the Shire. But what Thorin seeks are answers to the riddle of the hobbits’ power – not almost lost accounts of dwarven history.
Before long he realizes that Bilbo owns no books on magic. With a frown Thorin decides to look for hobbit authors, and discovers very few. A few collections of “popular tales”, “drinking songs”, “farming suggestions”, and about thirty cookbooks are all Bilbo owns.
Perhaps the cookbooks constitute a code? Thorin pulls one from the shelf, opens it. The content lists five different recipes for pumpkin soup, three types of pumpkin pie, roasted pig with pumpkin. With a frown Thorin puts it back, grabs another – which contains only recipes for sweet dessert cakes.
If there is a code hidden in these, he cannot see it – and perhaps there is no code at all. Maybe Bilbo keeps the books of importance elsewhere?
By the end of the day Thorin has investigated Bag End’s garden shed and cellar, discovered several spiders, a second pantry, and bottles of exquisite wine. But no trace of magic, no hint as to what gives the hobbits their power.
Frustrated, he retires before Bilbo returns.
Bilbo obviously has no desire to speak with Thorin either. He hasn’t even left a note for Thorin, but the house is empty. Thorin starts his day with a leisurely breakfast and then decides to complete his letters. His father and Dwalin will need weeks yet before they reach Erebor, but he owes his sister and brother news.
Writing to the King is more difficult – he has no concrete news to share; nor can he be certain his letters will reach Erebor unopened. But before long he has the lines down and seals the envelope.
Thorin takes a deep breath before leaving the house. Birds are singing and the weather is warm, bordering on hot. Fluffy white clouds fly over the sky, down below the small lake glitters in the sun. A few hobbits pass Thorin on the way to the market square – their conversations fall silent as he passes them – and he wonders.
What if hobbits only speak of their secrets? What if they have never written down the key to their power?
Thorin still ponders this as he reaches the post office. It’s a quaint building right behind the market square where two saddled ponies leisurely chew hay while their riders lounge in the shadow of a tree. As Thorin enters, he finds the postmaster waving after an elderly hobbit from a plump chair, calling “don’t worry, Master Worrywart”. Master Worrywart shakes his head and slowly inches past Thorin, his golden cane thudding on the floor, but he apparently doesn’t even see the dwarf.
Thorin hesitates for a moment, before stepping forward and handing over his letters. The postmaster eyes the addresses critically, then turns to Thorin.
“Courier?” he inquires, his eyebrows raised.
“Yes,” Thorin answers bluntly – the instructions on the letter ought to be clear. “Also,” and he forces himself to be polite, “is there a public library here?”
The hobbit blinks. “No, I’m afraid the next library is in Bree. But you should ask your husband – I understand he has a fairly sizeable collection and if not, the Thain’s collection is said to be the largest in the entire Shire.”
“The mayor office at Michael Delving keeps copies of all contracts, though,” an elderly lady adds as she enters.
The postmaster nods. “That he does. Now, those letters will take a while to reach their destination.”
Thorin nods in understanding and takes his leave. As he steps outside, he overhears the old lady saying “… a bit brusque, but I suppose it’s understandable. Must be homesick…”
Thorin purses his lips. What use is their sympathy when they are the ones forcing him to stay in this accursed place? Even the bright sunshine seems to be mocking him.
The day is growing hot and so Thorin resolves to return to Bag End for the time being. He passes the market which today has only few booths of local traders. Most hobbits wear light silken gowns and wide-brimmed hats to shield from the sun – which makes his hair grow uncomfortably hot.
“… in the south,” he hears somebody say in passing and thinks he recognizes the hobbit as one of the wedding guests.
His companion certainly looks concerned. “Then maybe we should call them back?”
“With the autumn harvest coming up and all the population increases, I don’t think we can. But the steward is aware, and so is everybody else.”
Gondor then, Thorin thinks, curious. He knows the south tends to be politically difficult. Gondor and Rohan are aligned, though don’t see eye to eye in all matters. Gondor and Mordor have unsolved territorial disputes, which include the legitimacy of Mordor as a country. Generally not many countries accept Mordor, however, Gondor’s claim to Mordor’s territory has lead certain fractions in Harad to actually side with Mordor.
“… hope things stay calm,” is what Thorin hears as he wanders away.
Thorin retreats to Bag End’s wide backyard to train, and when the heat grows unbearable goes inside. He retrieves food before Bilbo returns, and picks up The Tales of Aule for reading.
The next morning, he steps into the kitchen to find Bilbo sitting at the table. Thorin freezes in surprise, though Bilbo calmly sips on his tea.
“The postmaster asked me whether you really intended to send them by courier,” Bilbo says, pointing to the envelopes lying on the table. Thorin recognizes his letters. He cannot see whether or not they’ve been opened, but blood rushes to his face.
Bilbo watches his reaction carefully. “Courier to Erebor would take three months. Twice that time in winter,” he says.
Thorin crosses his arms over his chest. “So they were delivered directly to you instead?” he asks.
“The postmaster felt you were perhaps unaware of your options,” Bilbo returns patronizingly. “For long distance correspondences we send letters to the post office in Tookborough. They have raven and pigeon roosts – they will use whatever method is fastest. Letters to Erebor should take about a week.”
Thorin inhales deeply, forces his displeasure down, and nods. “Very well. How do I note this on the envelope?”
“Just keep the address and write via Tookborough office,” Bilbo replies and gets up. “Also I will be having guests over later.”
“I won’t disturb you,” Thorin promises.
Thorin heads down to the post office again, picks a few books from Bilbo’s library, and then takes Orcrist and heads to the backyard. The familiar exercises help him regain his equilibrium.
He does not mean to eavesdrop. But when he leaves the backyard intending to return to his own room, he hears voices from the library. He can’t quite see who is there, but the discussion sounds fierce.
“And what are they offering?” somebody asks, sounding exasperated. “More stones for grain?”
Thorin’s curiosity is piqued. He hears Bilbo sigh.
“Diamonds,” another person guesses. “Or some other form of rocks. Useless as usual. You know that we’re selling them at a loss, and the last ruby shipment from Erebor was of subpar quality.”
Thorin bristles. How dare those hobbits - they can’t tell quartz from diamond and they dare to call Erebor’s priced rubies worthless?
“Perhaps there was a mistake,” Bilbo offers weakly.
“Mistake or not, by now that’s almost the smaller problem,” voice number one says sharply. “The price drop to the south is no accident – Gondor’s markets have been flooded with rubies, and I doubt those were exported there from Khand.”
“I know, Rufus,” Bilbo replies slightly sharper. “And I have raised the issue with the King under the Mountain, and am waiting on the reply. But I also understand they are in a difficult position as they need to import grain from the south to feed their population.”
“Then why do they send us faulty stones and flood the market in Gondor with quality wares?” the one Bilbo named as Rufus asks.
And the still unnamed hobbit adds. “Even if this was truly but a mistake – you know the jewelers of Ered Luin and Rohan pay for their grain imports through the jewelry they can sell to the south. The price drop is hurting them badly.”
Thorin’s blood runs cold. Erebor’s trade with Gondor had always been hailed a sign of their independence by his grandfather. He’d never contemplated it affecting other countries.
“Neither Rohan nor Ered Luin are depending on jewelry trade though,” Bilbo returns. “Especially now that Rohan gets to sell their horses to the Haradrim and Khand they’re profiting nicely. And you know even Rhûn’s interested, Ludo.”
Rufus, however, seems not satisfied. “In short term, no, I don’t see this causing great harm either. Should the undercutting persist, however, I believe we need to investigate. Especially since it renders Erebor’s payments to us worth even less.”
“And there is the factor of growing unrest,” Ludo adds more quietly. “You must have heard about what is going on in Ithilien – it is not only the jewelry trade that is being affected. The young Miss Worrywart who’s overseeing farming there is worried they’ll have a riot on their hands.”
“Lobelia said she’d look into it,” Bilbo says.
“Lobelia’s idea of solving this would be to send a horde of orcs through in order to make everybody appreciate our agreement keeps them behind the Ash Mountains nowadays,” Rufus returns sharply.
Thorin shudders.
In the library, Bilbo chuckles. “Indeed,” he agrees. “But it is also poisoned land that is difficult to work with anyway. I’m not surprised the malice in the ground is affecting people there.”
“It wasn’t the brightest idea to have great numbers of people settle there, no,” Ludo agrees. “But I’m afraid the malice there isn’t our main enemy.”
“You think somebody is plotting against us?” Bilbo asks. The tone of his voice sends a cold shiver down Thorin’s spine. He’s last heard this steel when he faced Bilbo on the other side of a negotiation table.
Ludo – whoever he may be – apparently is similarly intimidated. “I don’t know,” he hastens to reply. “I just … from what we hear…”
“It wouldn’t be the first time,” Rufus adds quietly, and Thorin recalls a plump cheerful hobbit with an intelligent gleam to his eye. His words make his appearance a lie, and Thorin near breathlessly continues to listen.
“Riots have happened and will happen again – they are bound to when the markets lose their balance or some demagogue manages to plant the right rumors in folks’ ears. The steward of Gondor won’t tolerate Ithilien rebelling, and if he can’t control them, Mordor will gladly reclaim those lands.”
Birds sing cheerfully in the tree above Bag End. Leaves rustle in a warm summer breeze. But the sweat on Thorin’s back has turned to ice, and his heart has frozen. He has grown up learning about the power plays of the Kings of old, of how they used their citizens as pawns. Yet no historian has seen the hobbits move entire kingdoms as their pawns.
“But perhaps the best thing would be if no riots happened, wouldn’t you agree, Rufus?” Bilbo challenges. “After all, I do not believe the steward of Gondor would rejoice in slaughtering his own citizens to quell a rebellion. And letting Mordor reclaim Ithilien posits a de facto loss of arable land.”
Thorin decides he has heard enough. Perhaps he should linger and learn more, a voice in the back of his head suggests – but what he overheard has shaken him. His thoughts spin as he walks to his room. He needs to inform Erebor, but of what?
That the hobbits misjudge the value of Erebor’s jewel deliveries is known. That Erebor’s trade with Gondor hurts the value further might be news – yet as Thorin starts to pen down the words, he realizes that he cannot turn them into a suggestion. Erebor cannot afford to trade less to Gondor as it would cut off one of its most important grain suppliers.
The matter of Ithilien only underlines the ruthless power politics Erebor already knows hobbits are capable of. But the interior politics of Gondor are not considered important by the crown – or at least Thorin cannot recall having heard them discussed.
So all he can do in the end is set a half-written letter aside, and bury his face in his hands.
He tries to find out more about the hobbits’ rise to power over the following weeks. Not that he has much else to do – but neither is his research fruitful. Even the elvish histories only mention contract after contract; not a word of magic. A writer from Gondor remarks on farming methods, and Thorin reluctantly attempts to make sense of one of the few hobbit books on farming. But he doesn’t understand much of soil and seeds, and it doesn’t read like magic either.
Time passes, and summer grows hot. The hobbits Thorin spies passing by Bag End’s entrance hall windows wear short-sleeved silk shirts with gold trimmings. Even their straw hats are decorated with bands of rare fabrics or glittering jewels that imitate the shape of flowers.
What frivolous waste of so precious gems, he thinks and misses Bilbo himself turning up. The hobbit, once again dressed, exquisitely in light silks, walks into the kitchen, letters in his hand.
“Good morning, Thorin,” he greets, and lifts three envelopes tied together with a string. “Those arrived today – feel free to check the letter box yourself every now and then.”
The moment Thorin recognizes the familiar blue seal on parchment his heart jumps in joy. He nearly rips the letters from Bilbo’s hand, and can’t quite stop his lips from twitching as he assures that “I will do so”.
His sister’s handwriting jumps at him from the cover of the topmost envelope, and Thorin’s heart aches. He missed them so much, and it’s difficult not to run directly back to his own room to read them.
In passing he does recognize the Durin seal in black wax on one of Bilbo’s on letters, and finds his curiosity piqued. What would his grandfather write to Bilbo about? Thorin? Trading contracts? The odd business in the south?
“There will also be dwarves from Ered Luin on the market tomorrow,” Bilbo calls after him, and Thorin merely nods while leaving.
The paper under his fingers feels like fire, so he hurries back to his rooms, slams the door and drops down in the nearest armchair. Shaking fingers rip through the string and the envelopes tumble on his desk. Not only has his sister written, but so have his brother, his grandfather, Balin, and even Gloin.
His heart warms and he can feel the beginnings of a smile on his face.
All is well, Dis writes in steady letters. Or as well as it can be. Frerin is not very happy with his unexpected promotion in the line of succession, and Thorin wonders why Dis has been skipped. She does not address it, but notes down Frerin’s complains about having had to attend a state dinner in Dale together with the elves.
That old antipathy won’t be resolved anytime soon. Even if Thranduil – immortal that he is – should one day chose to abdicate, his son makes just as apt a prat, Dis reports. Thorin chuckles at her words, yet can’t quite stop his mind from turning. If Erebor’s relations with the Greenwood were better, they could trade with them for food, which would have lessened their dependence on the Shire and Gondor.
Her sons also miss their uncle, Dis writes toward the end of her letter, and she does miss him too. Perhaps he can come and visit? It may not be the best of circumstances, but she hopes he is doing well in the Shire.
With a small snort Thorin sets the letter aside. His brother is more direct, wondering if it’s true that the Shire already compels children to learn dark magic. And how about that old tale where hobbits demand a human sacrifice when their terms of trade aren’t met? Hordes of slaves toiling in the fields?
Thorin grimaces. It pains him that he still cannot answer just what made the hobbits become so powerful. And while the horror stories they heard in Erebor aren’t true, he still shudders to remember the conversation he overheard.
The King’s missive is short. Thror wants to know all about the Shire’s magic, and compels Thorin to learn what he can. For they all must do their utmost to restore Erebor to its rightful glory.
The time is ripe, Thror adds in unusual elaborate style. Middle Earth is ready to throw off the hobbits’ yoke – Erebor may have realized this before the others, but things have begun to move again. After four hundred years, things will change.
Thorin purses his lips. He is, he has to admit, not entirely convinced. Back in Erebor, he only had a very abstract idea of the Shire – now that he is here and has glimpsed its politics, he doubts the change his grandfather desires will occur so easily.
Yet if it can be done –
Thorin begins to write his replies.
On the next morning, Thorin finds himself wandering the winding path down toward the market early. The sun isn’t high yet, but already the air feels warm. A few hobbits nod toward him in greeting before hurrying on, their colorful summer clothes glittering in the sun.
It has been some time since he last left Bag End, he has to admit to himself. Yet he has little business elsewhere in Hobbiton, and does feel quite out of place among the hobbits on the market. After dropping his letters off at the post office, he browses the stalls though produce and seeds hold little interest for him, and it galls him to see how some vendors use diamonds as a decoration to present their fishes and carrots.
The dwarven stall is set slightly to the back of the market and when Thorin approaches two dwarves straighten immediately, while the third is busy wrapping up a purchase with a hobbit. The clanging noises emerging from behind a screen hint to the presence of more dwarves, but for now Thorin feels self-conscious as he approaches. What picture does he make, clad in a white silk shirt and a fine blue and silver waistcoat? Though the geometric patterns decorating it are dwarven, the cut is undeniably hobbitish.
“Your highness,” the first dwarf, an elderly fellow with a long, white beard braided into a long, elaborate braid. “It is a pleasure to meet you.” He inclines his head and his comrades follow.
Thorin nods in return. “I am afraid I do not know your names.”
The dwarf introduces himself as Hemar, son of Lemi originally from Ered Luin. Due to the growing population in those mountains he and his little troupe, however, have taken to travelling for most of the year, only returning home for the celebrations of Durin’s Day and the worst months of winter. Twice a year they pass by Hobbiton, where they sell mostly iron wares like cooking pots or gardening tools, but also silver cutlery, and a few fine pieces of jewelry.
“We’re no jewelers, though,” Hemar explains as he and Thorin walk leisurely alongside the gurgling little river that runs through Hobbiton. “Urdu has quite some talent, but she prefers to forge swords. They always sell very well down south.”
He chuckles, and shrugs.
“And here?” Thorin asks as they pass a hobbit dozing next to his silver fishing rod. “What do the hobbits buy from you?”
Hemar smiles. “Oh, this and that as you saw. Mostly when we stay here we do home visits and repair locks and such things.” He picks up on the darkening of Thorin’s face and adds: “I know it’s no noble trade or anything, but it pays very well and keeps us and our families fed and clothed. And to the hobbits’ it is a rather important job, so I won’t complain.”
Thorin has a different opinion, but that he’ll keep to himself. “What about Ered Luin? What do they trade to the Shire?” Last time he heard Ered Luin was not rich in gems or even gold. A few good strains of silver, some diamonds and a lot of iron. Nowhere near the riches of Erebor.
“Oh, quite a number of different things,” Hemar replies a little amused at Thorin’s suspicion. “The iron from there is popular in the south. It’s not quite the quality of that coming from the Iron Hills, but as the roads are shorter and better, it’s a lot more affordable. Nearly the entirety of Rohan’s riders has been equipped with Ered Luin iron.”
Thorin did not know that, so he merely nods.
“Quite a lot of mining then, I suppose,” he comments after a moment.
“Quite,” Hemar laughs. “Still, the population has been growing quite quickly in those recent decades. It’s a bit tricky finding work for everybody - so a few of us have taken to travelling or setting up shops in the surroundings. There is a bit of work for jewelers; even down south they don’t have enough jewelers to work all the stones sent down from Erebor. That is one blessed mountain indeed.”
“Indeed,” Thorin echoes faintly, his mind racing. He recalls the mentioned price drop in the south and its impact. “Would you think it would help the situation if Erebor exported less stones to the south?”
Hemar stiffens, abruptly recalling just whom he is talking to. “Your highness, I’m afraid I understand little of the wider politics involved,” he hedges. “Personally, I appreciate that there is always work to be found, but I know that those in Ithilien cannot often afford it. And in recent years we have been getting paid less for our work.”
Because a greater supply of gems resulted in their value decreasing, Thorin realizes. Which in turn may or may not be related to Erebor’s increased demand for grain from the south in order to gain independence from the Shire.
It truly is a pity they never managed to establish decent relations with the Greenwood, Thorin thinks bitterly.
Summer goes on; Thorin writes letters and receives replies. But his grandfather tells him not to worry. All shall be resolved. His father assures Thorin that they hope to be able to renegotiate with the hobbits in time - perhaps the marriage can be annulled.
So time passes.
Until one morning when the days have already begun to grow shorter, Thorin comes into the kitchen to find Bilbo seated at the table, sipping his tea. A missive from Erebor lies next to his plate.
“We received Erebor’s payment for the winter harvest yesterday,” Bilbo says frostily. “And I was surprised to see it consisted of rubies again. I believe your father already returned to the mountain with the changed contract.”
Thorin freezes. His sister’s last letter mentioned Thrain had returned – and relayed his apology for not writing since he’d apparently barely had had time to breathe.
“I was wondering if you would be able to explain it,” Bilbo continues.
Thorin's blood heats. “How would I know? I’m not in Erebor, am I?”
“But you have been writing letters,” Bilbo replies.
As if Bilbo hadn’t. The truth is, Thorin has no explanation, but he barely gets to reply before a sharp knock to the front door interrupts him.
“Mister Baggins!” somebody calls in a near panic. Thorin looks in askance to Bilbo who appears equally surprised, and swiftly rises to his feet.
“Yes, what is it?” he calls out as he makes his way toward the door.
Somebody opens the door and a young lad stumbles into Bag End’s hallway, panting and pale-faced. Thorin lingers in the kitchen doorway, uncertain.
“Mister Baggins, word came from Gondor,” the lad gasps. “There was a riot in Ithilien. Miss Worrywart and her family there are all dead.”
