Actions

Work Header

Under Siege: Hobbits versus Dwarrows

Chapter 5: Thorin’s Surprisingly Softer Side. Or: Fun with spoons.

Summary:

More fun in the Shire.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The comfortable routine that had settled in with the hobbit-dwarven cohabitation came to an abrupt end on day four.

The day had started similar to all the previous mornings: The sun hung brightly in the cloudless sky as the residents lingered over their last few bites of breakfast and their last few sips of tea or cocoa in the kitchen.

The younger ones had slipped out of their seats already and stood at the sink, jostling over who got to rinse out their empty plate and mug first. The post-breakfast routine put in place by Bilbo involved rinsing and then piling each used dishware into a few neat stacks on the counter, ready for a proper wash by those who were assigned to dish cleaning duty on that day.

The other morning task left was to make the beds as Bilbo had made it clear that under no circumstances would anyone be allowed to exit the smial until their their own sheet and pillow had been shaken out, folded and placed neatly on the bed. This initially left the young princes at a complete loss since they never had to learn how to make a bed but Frodo had with great pride demonstrated how to complete the task. Now it had become a fierce competition between the three lads to see who could do it the fastest with the least wrinkles.

As the sound of bare feet pattered across the wooden floor and into the direction of the bedrooms, Bilbo turned to the two adult visitors. “Do you have any plans for today?”

Thorin shook his head. “Nothing concrete so far. Dwalin and I had talked about going to speak with the Shire blacksmith and to find out more about the types of weapons that he makes.”

“That’s actually something that I can answer: None.” Bilbo answered.

“None?” Dwalin was flummoxed.

“Well, a hobbit blacksmith can produce over a couple types of knives and sometimes a even spearhead or two for our patrolling bounders but other than that he is more practiced to make common household items and farm implements.” When the dwarrows continued to stare at him blankly, he added, “You know, frying pans, door hinges, fire pokers, wheels. Those sorts of things.”

“Ah, of course.” Thorin gave his captain a serious look. “Perhaps we should wander over to your grandfather’s house and speak with him about your defense methods in the Shire.”

“Really don't think that is necessary.” Bilbo answered with a sigh.

Before anything else could be said on the topic there was a knock.

“Now who could it this early in the day?” the hobbit got up to answer the door.

The dwarrows in the kitchen could not see the visitor but heard their host's grumbled greeting.

“Bilbo Baggins! Is this how you greet your cousin?” The female hobbit stepped into the smial, removed her large floppy hat and shook her head to loosen her curls, then unceremoniously pushed her hat into Bilbo's hands.

"Oh hello ... Lobelia.” A small sigh escaped him which earned him a frown. “What brings you here?”

“Not much, not much. I just wanted to ask if I could borrow your ... why, who do we have here?” Lobelia said with a trilling laughter and a fake surprise smile, unapologizingly gaping at the two guests as she walked towards into kitchen.

“Um... I’ve got visitors from the kingdom of Erebor. Lobelia, meet Mister Thorin Oakenshield and Mister Dwalin.”

“Dwalin? I've never heard of such a family name.” Lobelia asked.

“I'm just Dwalin.” came the grunted response.

“Err, yes, it is not rather commonplace among dwarrows to only go by their first names. And,” here Bilbo gestured sardonically to his brightly dressed cousin, “may I introduce you to my cousin Lobelia Bracegirdle. Our great aunts are cousins thrice removed  - at least so they claim.” the hobbit stated.

“Oh, who cares about the details of family relations, all that matters is that we are family that live close and are very close, isn’t that right, dear Bilbo?” Lobelia chirped as she removed her gloves and placed them on the kitchen counter.

Bilbo nodded through gritted teeth. “Of course.”

Lobelia walked to the cupboards where she helped herself to a cup and saucer and then opened the cutlery drawer. “Now where is my favourite spoon?” she mumbled, rummaging around until Bilbo who had followed her reached over her shoulder and with an exasperated huff removed one of his family’s silver teaspoons from the drawer and handed it to her.

“Thank you very much, cousin!” she accepted before she pulled up a chair to sit at the table and pour herself a cup of tea that she topped it off with two heaping spoonfuls of sugar.

“So,” she started without any preamble as she took her first sip and cast a calculated glance at the silent dwarrows, “What brings you here to the Shire? Can’t imagine it being our lush greens and peaceful pastures, what with your kind preferring dark rocks and dank caves. Working on a better trade agreement with the Thain I suppose?” she pried without reservations while Bilbo came to stand behind her, rolling his eyes and mouthing a silent apology to his visitors.

“We came here to pay our respects to the Thain and yes, to discuss new mutually beneficial treaties.” Thorin admitted with reluctance.

“What is your interest in this?” demanded Dwalin and in true royal guarding style, sized her up like any petitioner approaching the throne during a public audience.

“Just the same level of interest any responsible Shire resident should have to keep their homes safe.” Lobelia returned in a haughty tone, tilting her chin up so she could look down her nose at him.

“M’lady,” the tattooed warrior spat out, “do you accuse my king of ill intent toward hobbits?”

“How should I know his intent?” Bilbo’s cousin retorted, her nostrils flaring. “You dwarrows always keep your presence ever so secret. You hide in your camps out in the fields and ignore every hobbit in town. Why, I wouldn’t put it past you folks if you ... ”

“Lobelia!” Bilbo interjected, his face hot with embarrassment. “Thorin and Dwalin are my guests, and I will not allow you to disrespect them under my roof. In fact, if you do not leave right this moment, I will make sure to send a strongly worded letter to grandfather Took about your rude comments to the dwarven dignitaries.”

“You wouldn’t dare!” spat his cousin.

“Oh, I mean it Lobelia. Get out. Now, please.” Bilbo marched back to the front door and pointedly opened it.

“Fine!” Lobelia set her cup of tea back down on the saucer with a heavy clink. “Don’t expect me to come running next time you need help, cousin.”

“As if you ever did.” Bilbo shook his head as he closed the door behind her with a firm thud. “Lives closest to Bag End, yet always shows up last when something needs to be done.  Unless it’s a party, then she is unfailingly early.”

Dwalin who had risen from the bench when the hostile words started, sat back down next to Thorin who continued to calmly drink his tea. “What an irritating woman.”

“She certainly is.” The king agreed. They both looked at Bilbo who shrugged his shoulders and sighed.

---

It was only later in the evening that Bilbo noticed that something was amiss or rather, that somethine was missing: Two of his mother’s favourite tea spoons.

With the young ones already asleep in bed and Dwalin smoking his pipe outside near the shed, Thorin grew bored as he sat alone in the living room. When he padded into the kitchen to see what might take his host so long to prepare their tea, he found Bilbo going through his drawers and tearing apart their contents in agitation. The counter was piled high with a various assortment of cutlery and cooking knick knacks. The dwarrow picked up a funny looking colourful stick that looked like a tiny backscratcher and observed his host’s frantic activity.

“Master Baggins, what are you looking for?”

“My... my spoons! I cannot find them!”

“Spoons?” echoed Thorin with confusion as he watched Bilbo attack the cupboards next.

“My silver spoons! My family spoons, the ones ...” The hobbit stopped for a second to take a deep breath and look at the dwarrow, who just continued to look at him in a questioning manner, “the ones my mother loved so much. My father gave them to her for as their wedding gift. They... they are quite special to me.” Bilbo finished while he resumed his search.

“Hm.” Thorin contemplated the scene in front of him, uncertain how to ‘defrenzy’ a hobbit without drawing his ire. So instead he picked up the cups and the tea and quietly tiptoed back to the living room where he sat down and waited - he was unsure for what.

“Aren’t you going to help me find them?” Bilbo’s voice streamed in from the kitchen, and Thorin jumped up and made his way back to the kitchen.

Unfortunately, Thorin’s additional assistance did not yield any more success, and Bilbo had to concede to going to bed without locating the two missing family heirlooms.

It was not a surprise when the hobbit was still upset the next morning. Over breakfast he blurted out: “I’m sure it was her!”

“Hmm?” Dwalin looked up while he made short work of the stack of pancakes on his plate.

“My cousin! The one from yesterday, remember? She’s always envied me for Bag End, and do you recall how she fawned over ‘ her favourite spoon ’ yesterday? That... that thief! How dare she burgle from me?”

“What happened, Uncle Bilbo?” Frodo inquired, his curiousity piqued.

“Ah, never you mind, Frodo. Just don't trust that ... “

“Master Baggins,” Thorin spoke up, hoping to stem the angry tide. “Hurling accusations without any proof is not wise. We can investigate this matter as thoroughly as possible right after we finish breakfast. It's nothing to concern the little ones with.”

“Little ones!” Fíli exclaimed in horror. “We are not babies! Frodo may still be considered a little one but - ouch!” He rubbed his shin as Frodo glared at him and continued, “but Kíli and I are big enough to help with whatever it is that is upsetting Master Bilbo.”

“Enough.” Bilbo’s bristling tone quieted the conversation. “I will deal with this as I see fit. I will not let my guests be bothered by this dreadful situation.”

“If you wish.” Thorin nodded, using his eyes to warn his boys to stay out of it.

“Yes. I wish so.” Before anyone could stop him, Bilbo had stormed out of the kitchen and out of the smial, running down his path out and the front gate. Thorin cursed soundly as Frodo looked at him wide-eyed, then took off after his host, leaving the front door open. Dwalin continued to chew on his breakfast, gesturing at the fledglings to remain seated and to finish their morning meal.

---

“Master Baggins. Bilbo!” Thorin felt extremely self-conscious as he ran down the path. A few of the residents on The Hill had stopped their morning pursuits and turned toward him with a suspicious look; others still stared at the disappearing back of their neighbour. Instead of trying to explain the odd behaviour he focused on putting one foot in front of the other, worried that one misstep or fall would just magnify the gossip that was sure to develop.

Indeed Lobelia lived not too far from Bag End, or Thorin would have gotten himself lost among the rolling grassy hills. He actually lost sight of the hobbit towards the end of the pursuit but by then he could hear Bilbo’s raised voice tumbling out of the open entrance of a smial that had an ivy covered door frame and laced outdoor curtains that barely distracted from the deep fuchsia coloured round door.

An older lady hobbit sat in front of the smial in a grand wicker armchair and knitted calmly but it was obvious that she was preoccupied with following the heated conversation inside. Thorin bowed to her and entered the home, his hand resting on the hilt of his sheathed dagger.

“Just admit it, Lobelia!” Bilbo bellowed.

“Admit what? For heaven’s sake...”

“Don’t pretend you don’t know! If you had any decency you would confess this instant.”

“What on earth are you talking about, Bilbo? And stop yelling at me! ”

“What did you do with my spoons? You know, the ones my father gave to my mother!”

“Bilbo, have you lost your mind? Are you accusing me of taking them?”

“I don’t see anyone else in here who was at my home yesterday salivating over them, and there is no one in the Shire who covets them as much as you do!”

“You cannot possibly be serious! Why, I would have never believed that you could be even ruder than yesterday! What gives you the right to march over here and throw these nasty accusations at me in my OWN HOME?”

Thorin would have preferred a moment to catch his breath but he thought it too big a risk to take. So he inhaled deeply before he stepped between the two hobbits and raised his arms placatingly. “Excuse me.”

“WHAT??” Two agitated hobbits shouting at him at the exact same time was more menacing than he had anticipated. The royal dwarrow felt a shiver run down his spine but braced himself and crossed his arms with determination before he continued.

“I’d like to make a suggestion. If I may?” To which the glaring hobbits gave terse nods.

“Master Baggins here is deeply distressed because items in question are very dear to him. You can surely understand why he is so upset. He does not mean to accuse anyone of theft, however, I am thinking, perhaps you could help him narrow down the possible locations of those spoons. To make sure that they were not accidentally misplaced , you see, we could, well, let him take a look in your kitchen drawers. Just to alleviate his anguish, you know?”

“I have to do nothing to alleviate his inane and irrational anguish.” Lobelia huffed out but her anger had diminished to the point where Thorin almost thought that he saw something resembling pity on her face.

“To help your poor distressed irrational cousin?” Thorin entreated.

“Wait, what? Now you see here, you ... you ... confounded ... ridiculous...” Bilbo stuttered, his eyes blazing anew.

“You see?” Thorin quickly added, pushing himself in front of his hobbit host. “The sooner you will allow him to check that there is nothing here, the quicker he will calm down and return to Bag End with me.”

“Oh, FINE! Anything to stop him from acting crazy like this!” Lobelia snapped. “But hurry, I have little patience for any more of my cousin’s shenanigans. And he better not put any of my cutleries or dishes in any sort of disarray!”

Thorin nodded and grabbed Bilbo’s elbow to deftly steer him towards the cupboards and drawers. He whispered into the hobbit’s ear. “Stop arguing and look for your spoons quickly, for Mahal’s sake. You have no proof so this is the best chance you’ll get here.”

Bilbo yanked his elbow out of the dwarrow’s grip but did not say anything further and systematically started to look through the kitchen.

True to his word, they left Lobelia and her mother’s smial a few moments later. Bilbo was still fuming from having to admit to his ‘baseless accusations’ while Thorin used all his regal charms to apologize profusely to the two female hobbits before he followed Bilbo back to Bag End.

---

“Ah, there you are. Finally.” Dwalin emerged from the kitchen and wiped his mouth on his sleeve as Thorin and Bilbo returned. The burly dwarrow radiated the kind of quiet satisfaction only achieved by a delicious meal and the knowledge of being spared from drama. “You two ran off so quickly that I had no chance to say anything. Miss Lobelia did not take those spoons. I know that because I saw her put them in the sink before you kicked her out of the house yesterday.”

“I couldn’t find them at her place.” mumbled Bilbo unhappily. “No worries though, I’ll find them. I’ll prove to you that she took it.”

“Believe me, she did not take them because I found the culprits who did.” Dwalin stuck his head back into the kitchen and barked an order: Out shuffled Kíli, Fíli and Frodo, looking mightily guilty. The young dwarrows each held out a teaspoon to the hobbit, their faces filled with contrition.

Dwalin gave each of the princes a heavy pat on their shoulders and waggled his finger at the fauntling, then grabbed his axes. “Well, I’m going to the back to work off that breakfast. Would do me no good if I returned to Erebor with a belly.” He patted his full stomach and looked expectantly at Thorin who sighed and followed him out the back door with his sword.

Bilbo took the spoons and hustled the kids back into the kitchen. He placed the missing spoons on the table in front of them, stepped back and looked at them with consternation, trying to gather the words that he wanted to say to them.

“What is the meaning of this, boys?”

“We ... we borrowed them, Mister Bilbo.”

“Borrowed, you say? Then why did not not tell me that you had them when I was looking for them all over the smial?”

“We were going to ask you, we swear. But we forgot, and when we remembered again you were so mad already...,”

“We thought it would be best to try and sneak them back into the drawer but then Kíli dropped and stepped on one of them, and he bent it...”

“And I told them that you would never forgive us because they were your mum’s spoons, and they got even more scared and wanted to go get it fixed...”

“Frodo Baggins! I am very disappointed that you decided to withhold the truth and on top of it, talked your friends into it keeping it from me. There will be no desserts for you today, and I’ll have to think about an appropriate punishment for you in the morning.”

“What about Fíli and Kíli?”

“They will be dealt with by their uncle. When he gets back.”

“But that’s not fair!” Frodo stomped with both his feet, his eyes burning bright. “They shouldn’t get any dessert either.”

“They are our guests, and it is your responsibility to keep them safe and trouble free in the Shire. And I will not have you speak back to me. Please go to your room.”

“ Menu shirumund ,” mumbled the little hobbit.

“What did you just say to me?” Bilbo’s eyes narrowed but Frodo had already rushed by him and slammed the door to his room. When the older hobbit looked at the two young dwarven guests, their eyes were round as saucers and their lips pressed together forcefully. They looked as if they were about to explode.

Bilbo sighed. “I suggest that you two also go to your room and stay there until your uncle and Dwalin are done with their practice.”

“Yes, Bilbo.” - ”At once.”

And off the two princes went, rushing into their room and closing the door with the gentlest thud.

---

An hour later, when Dwalin and Thorin walked back into the smial, Bilbo was not having it.

“Please wipe that satisfied smirkikng off your face, Your Majesty .”

“Wha- I am not smirking?”

“You most certainly look like Dwalin after he found the last batch of cookies. If this is not one of the smuggest smiles I have seen on you, then I shall no longer call myself a hobbit.”

There was a barely suppressed grunt of amusement: Dwalin focused hard on the floor between his feet while he carefully shuffled sideways to pass behind Thorin until he had a clear path to the kitchen. “I.. um, need to do something. In the kitchen. Alright then.” And off he went.

“So how do you intend to deal with your nephews, oh wise leader?”

“Why is it of your concern, Master Hobbit?”

“Why? They need to be punished for lying. I have already taken care of my nephew.”

“What was Frodo’s punishment?” Thorin inquired.

“No desserts today, with more punishment to be determined the next morning.”

“Very well. Kíli and Fíli shall not get any desserts either.”

“Thorin!”

“What? You just told me that I have to punish them!”

“Yes... but you have to come up with your own punishment!”

“But it’s a very good punishment! I shall go right now and tell them.”

“Thorin!!”

“What now? You are truly a confounding creature!”

“What is the rest of the punishment?”

“Tell me how you want to punish Frodo, and I will penalize my nephews in the same manner.”

“You can’t just mimic me, Thorin! At the least we should come up with a punishment together.”

“Is this really necessary, Master Baggins? I have never had to make up a way to punish them - my sister always came up with them.” The king exhaled and blinked at the hobbit innocuously, hoping that the other would laugh and offer to take the lead.

“Yes, alright. No wait, it’s not right.” Bilbo objected. “Why don’t you take the day and come up with an appropriate way to teach the kids a lesson, and I shall inform Frodo that the same punishment will apply to him. That suits me quite fine actually since I am tired and would like to go take a nap. See you later, Thorin .”

“Alright.” mumbled the dwarrow. He had a feeling that any further conversation with the hobbit might result in a rather lengthy lecture on his capabilities as a responsible uncle so he wisely kept his mouth shut.

---

The next morning Bilbo took no time to announce that he and Thorin had come to an agreement on what was an appropriate penance for the theft of the silver spoons.

“Thorin?”

“Mmh, yes.” Thorin scratched his beard. “Before I do that, I would like to know why you took the spoons in the first place. What instigated this?”

Fíli, Kíli and Frodo looked at each other. Fíli responded, “Well, Frodo told us about about the tree amber in the Shire and how it could be turned into the most beautiful jewelry.”

“And... and we thought that it would be a great if we could harvest some and make a necklace for mom.” Kíli added.

Frodo completed the story. “I told them that we needed something thin and long to scoop it out of the trees. Uncle Bilbo’s spoons were the best shape for it so I thought we could borrow a couple for a short while and put them back afterwards.”

Thorin hummed as he thought about their explanation. “Did it work?”

“Thorin!” Bilbo protested.

Thorin ignored the hobbit and repeated the question. “Well, Frodo?”

“We have not had a chance to try it out yet, Master Thorin.” Frodo said dutifully. “Uncle Bilbo found out that they were missing before we had a chance to go.”

“Hmm. I may have a better tool for you. Wait here.” The dwarrow marched into his guestroom with a flabbergasted Bilbo staring after him.

Thorin returned but a minute later, handing a long metal tongue with curved ends to his oldest nephew. “Here, use this to collect the amber. I think it will be more than suitable for this task.”

“Thorin. The punishment?” Bilbo tapped his foot.

“Hmm? Yes, of course, the punishment. You’ll bring enough amber back to make something for Master Baggins, and you will present it to him when it’s ready along with a sincere and well thought out apology.”

“Yes, uncle.”

“Yes, Your Majesty.”

“You may call me Uncle Thorin if you like, Frodo.”

The little hobbit beamed. “Yes, Uncle Thorin.”

“May we be excused?” Kili was eager to go

“Yes, unless your uncle has something else to say?” Thorin looked at Bilbo for assurance.

The hobbit rolled his eyes, then waved them off. “Just go. Don’t cause any more trouble, do you hear me?”

“Yes. We are sorry but we’ll make it up to you, promise! Bye!” The sound of their feet pattering against the floor and the closing of the front door caused Bilbo to shake his head with an indulgent smile.

Thorin watched him, his expression curious.

“What?” the hobbit raised his eyebrows.

“I don’t know how you do it.”

“What do you mean?”

“How you are so open with your love and care for them. How easy it is for you let them off the hook and yet in return, they give you the utmost respect and courtesy.”

Bilbo blushed at the tone of admiration that tinged the dwarrow’s words. “It... it’s nothing, really.”

“Oh, I disagree. I have never seen my nephews so considerate and well-mannered. You brought out a side in them that I never thought they possessed.”

“Oh.” Bilbo pondered for a moment. “I merely expect them to figure out what kind of person they want to be.”

“Well, you are remarkable.” It was Thorin’s turn to blush: Handing out personal compliments were not in his normal nature but Bilbo somehow managed to draw out words from his mouth before his brain had a chance to intervene.

Luckily the hobbit accepted it with a simple shrug and humble smile.

Notes:

Menu shirumund (Khuzdul) - You are beardless.