Actions

Work Header

The horror at Erebor Island

Chapter 5: Into the depths of Narag Tharr caves

Summary:

After their morbid discovery, the Gardai suspect there might be another beast lurking on Erebor. Their reasoning leads them, Bofur, Bilbo and Thorin to the infamous Narag Tharr caves.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

Fíli had climbed down the roof as fast as he could. He had found Kíli collapsed on the ground, both hands pressed against his face.

 

“O’Shea! Are you all right?” No response. “Kíli? Kíli, please, let me take a look at your nose. It’s bleeding.”

 

The evocation of blood lit up something in the other guard’s mind. His blank glance met a pair of concerned blue eyes, and he came back to reality.

“It’s… It’s Elladan… It’s his... head!” Kíli stammered.

“Shhh, you’re in shock. Let me see your nose.”

“It’s his head! Elladan is dead!”

 

Fíli winced when Kíli grabbed his jacket with his bloody hands. Those stains would be hard to wash.

 

“Stop this now, officer!” Fíli firmly shook his colleague’s shoulders, ready to slap his face if necessary. Struck by the harsh order, Kíli stopped screaming and loosened his grip on Fíli’s jacket.

 

“Ok, look at me, calm down now. Focus on my eyes, O’Shea. That’s it. Now, breathe. Slowly. There. That’s good. Can I take a look at your nose, now?”

 

Fíli’s soothing words helped Kíli to calm down. He sat up and let his teammate examine him.

 

“You’re lucky; it doesn’t look broken. There, press this tissue against your nose until the bleeding stops.”

Kíli complied in silence, carefully avoiding to look at his friend’s head, lying on the ground and looking at him with void eyes.

 

“O’Shea? O’Shea?” Fíli’s voice seemed so far away; Kíli had to focus to hear it. “We need to bring this head to Dr. Gleeson. I’m going to the car and fetch a cloth, and I come back. Can you stay on your own?”

Kíli mumbled a “yes” and Fíli was off to their car. Still seated on the ground, he thought “I wasn’t even supposed to work today.”

 

*~*

 

Dr. Oin Gleeson had not been happy to be disturbed by the guards early on Sunday morning. He had just been about to go for a walk with Minty, when the two young dwarves practically hauled him back to his surgery, right next to his living room.

 

Kíli closed the curtains much to the doctor’s consternation and astonishment, while Fíli placed something wrapped in a blood-stained cloth on his desk.

Before he could protest again, Fíli unwrapped it, and Oín recoiled. Elladan’s head stared at him as if he accused him from beyond.

 

Kíli leant towards him, for once deadly serious.

“What killed him, Oín?”

“The fact that he’s just a head.” Oín pried his eyes away from the horror on his desk. “You bring me someone with a head cold or a headache, and I could do something. But you bring me just a head, and you’re taking the piss.”

“Doctor, we need to know.” Fíli fixed the doctor with a hard stare.

“He was mauled by some sort of animal.” When he saw that the two Gardai were not satisfied, he shrugged. “I don’t know. A Balrog?”

“A Balrog.” Kíli didn’t know if he should laugh or weep.

Fíli looked exasperated. “A Balrog. A creature from legend. We can’t put that in the report.”

 

But he looked surreptitiously at Kíli. That thing they saw earlier, that Akhlat, was certainly not a Balrog. But it had shaken some of Fíli’s certainty.

 

“I’m a country doctor, for Mahal’s sake,” Oín gruffly informed that young upstart from the city. “Where am I going to run across stuff like this?”

 

A sudden gust of air made them all start. The door was thrown open and revealed an excited hatted dwarf.

 

“Wait till you see it! By my beard, you’re not going to believe it!”

“Mahal!” Kíli was the first one to steady himself. “Bofur, was is it?”

 

*~*

 

It was only noon, and this Sunday was already too full of gruesome events to be taken lightly. Kíli and Fíli had decided to go back to the station to put on their uniforms for they couldn’t stay in their civilian clothes anymore. Whether they liked it or not, they were on duty for the day. Just putting on the uniform helped Fíli to feel back in control of the situation. He was a guard. He could handle whatever challenge was thrown at him.

 

Thinking Fíli wasn’t looking, Kíli had refilled his whisky flask from the liquor stash he kept in his locker for emergencies. After the shock caused by their latest discovery, the guard was still deeply shaken, and he needed the comfort of his flask more than ever.

 

One hour later, the two Gardai were standing in Bofur’s backyard, next to his bathtub. They all looked at the house in front of them.

The bathroom’s wall was completely demolished. As the excited fisherman was talking, Fíli was conscientiously taking notes, watching Kíli from time to time to make sure he could believe Bofur’s wild tale.

 

“How am I supposed to wash meself?” asked Bofur. Fíli raised a suspicious eyebrow. The ancient brownish crust coating the tub was speaking for itself.

 

“Use your sink,” the blond dwarf replied irritably, stashing his notebook. He looked at Kíli, who was stomping back to the car, shouting at Bofur to put the kettle on.

 

Ten minutes later they were all standing around the fisherman’s rickety kitchen table, tea in hand.  Bofur had poured a healthy dose of Poitin in Kíli’s and his; Fíli narrowly avoided the addition.

 

Kili had spread a map of Erebor on the table.

“Ok. Here’s where Elladan’s car was abandoned, here’s Dior and Nimloth’s house, here’s where the whales washed up, and we’re here. I was hoping it would show some sort of pattern.”

“It’s the letter. The letter zed,” Bofur supplied helpfully. While Kíli’s mind wandered to Zorro, Fíli thought of something more practical.

“Did you show that thing to anyone before we saw it?”

“Well, Dior got a look at it before I brought it down. It spat on him.”

When he saw the two young Gardai staring at him, he added: “Why?”

Fíli looked to Kíli in silent understanding.

“We think there might be another of those things. At least one, anyway.”

“Are you serious?”

When Kíli saw the glimmer in the other dwarf’s eye, he rolled his eyes. “The one you caught can’t have fertilized the eggs itself. There must be a male out there. Yes, he’d be worth a fuckton on eBay, Bofur.  But he’s big enough and strong enough to knock a hole in your bathroom wall. Let’s worry about that first.”

Bofur’s house was old, but like all homes on this windswept island, it had been built solid enough to last for several long-lived generations through harsh storms.

Fíli peered from the kitchen to the bathroom. A draft could be felt from there.

“The hobbit said it needs water, didn’t he?”

“He says a lot of things.” Kíli gritted his teeth. Snotty little bugger that scientist.

“Mostly bollocks,” Bofur added. Fíli felt that the other dwarves didn’t like the poor scientist much. He was about to defend Bilbo but focused.

“Whatever. But if it needs water to survive, how could it be moving about on dry land?”

Bofur shrugged. “It was raining.” And then, adding when the two dense Gardai didn’t follow him. “There’s no such thing as dry land when it’s pissing down.”

“There’s a storm coming.” Fíli felt himself freeze a little. “Tonight.”

 

Kíli rubbed his temples. “All right. All of this …” his fingers drew a vague circle around the area on the map, “must be its territory. Which means … it must be somewhere around there with access to water.”

Shrugging as if it had been obvious from the start, Bofur supplied:

“Narag Tharr caves. I caught the female around there.”

Fíli nearly smacked himself with his notebook. Of course, he had asked that question, routinely, and wrote it down. But as both Kíli and he had assumed that they wouldn’t be involved beyond handing in a report, they had failed to take that into consideration.

 

*~*



It had pained Kíli, but Fíli was right: they needed Bilbo and Thorin for their expedition to the caves. Determined to claim his precious catch as his and his only, Bofur had insisted on coming with them as well.

 

Equipped with powerful electric torches, the four dwarves, and the hobbit were cautiously walking among the rocks of the West Beach towards Narag Tharr caves, Fíli and Kíli closing the group a little behind the others.

They could hear Bofur ranting about global warming, vaguely approved by Bilbo.

As usual, Thorin was walking in silence, his hands behind his back and brooding over thoughts only known by himself. However, he paid attention to the fisherman’s rant when it came to the sudden disappearance of the Merrows. The mermaids had always been abundant in the Misty Sound, and some of them had taken up residence near the caves. Used to Erebor’s people, the creatures weren’t feral anymore. If only they could approach some, they could learn useful things.

 

Feeling his hands slightly shaking, Kíli took a quick swig from his flask when he thought Fíli wouldn’t notice. Unfortunately for him, nothing could escape the other guard, and when his eyes met Kíli’s he couldn’t refrain a half concerned half irritated look.

 

“What?”, asked Kíli, on the defensive. Fíli stiffened a bit.

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You gave me that look.”

“What look?”

“The ‘I-feel-sorry-for-you’ look.”

“No, I didn’t.”

“Yeah, you did.”

“No. I gave you the ‘I-feel-embarrassed-for-you’ look. Big difference.”

 

Though said very calmly, the guard’s harsh words pierced right through Kíli’s heart. He realised that Fíli’s opinion mattered to him, more than he would have thought, and he felt ashamed. Coming out of the blue, a vision of a flirting Bilbo appeared in his mind and a sudden whiff of jealousy seized him. He couldn’t let Fíli’s disdain unanswered, so he tried to defend himself.

 

“So that’s worse. Listen, I’m no dandy fop Ph.D. Boggins type.”  Fíli laughed drily to these words.

“What’s the hobbit got to do with your raging alcoholism?”

“I’m not a raging alcoho…” Kíli interrupted himself and huffed “You’re some character, you know that? A real character. I’m a social drinker.”

“Mm-hm, I’m sure you are.”

Willing to end this conversation, Fíli hurried to catch up with the others, leaving Kíli behind.

 

The small group gathered in front of a huge crevice formed in the rocky wall of a cliff. The infamous Narag Tharr caves. Kíli shivered as a tragic memory resurfaced. Many years ago, one of his classmates had drowned there, caught by the flood tide.

As if he had read through Kíli’s mind, Bofur waggled his walking stick toward the caves and warned the troop: “Now, look, the tide’s coming in, so another hour and this place will be under water, so be careful now!”

 

After a quick glance to Fíli, Kíli put his cap on and required everybody’s attention. This was police business, so he and Fíli would lead the exploration. The scientists nodded in agreement and checked their torches one last time.

 

Bofur didn’t need any persuasion when Kíli told him to wait for them on the beach. The fisherman watched the cave swallow the dwarves and the hobbit with a worried look on his face.

 

*~*

 

Obscurity surrounded them all as soon as they entered the narrow space of the cave, and they had to blink a few times to accommodate their vision to the ambient darkness. All they could hear was the wind gushing through the passage and the regular sound of the surf.

 

Walking in single file, the group moved forward slowly, the light of their torches illuminating the black rocky walls and casting dreadful shadows.

At length, the narrow way broadened so they all could stand side by side and catch sight of the way out, leading to another part of the beach.

Feeling nervous, Kíli started to whistle a tune but got rapidly shushed by Fíli, who was trying to focus on looking for significant clues.

Bilbo and Thorin had ventured on their own, the faint echoes of their footsteps and the light of their torch bouncing on the dark walls of the cave.

 

Fíli was starting to think the group shouldn’t be separated when the light of his torch caught something on the ground. The guard waved at Kíli before kneeling down to inspect his find. It was an orange weatherproof coat with an elvish marine blazon on it. One could read “Vingiló” but the end of the word had been ripped with a part of the coat.

 

“Are we missing some fishermen?” whispered Fíli. Kíli crouched down beside him and took a closer look.

“Mahal almighty… , “ he breathed with a dull voice “It’s Eärendil’s coat.”

Fíli cast him a questioning look.

“He, his ship and his crew were presumed lost at sea. Last time someone saw them alive was last Friday, just before you arrived.”

“Did you know them?” asked Fíli.

“Yes. For a long time. Eärendil’s sons, Elrond and Elros, were my friends back in the days when I was...” but he never finished his sentence.

“I’m sorry for your loss, Kíli.”

The guard couldn’t help but feel compassionate towards his colleague. He had lost so many people he loved. With a sympathetic smile, Fíli put a hand on Kíli’s shoulder and squeezed it briefly before getting up.

Seeing that Kíli was still lost in the contemplation of  Eärendil’s coat, he cleared his throat to get his attention.

“Get up. We should find the others.”

 

*~*

 

Tired of waiting on his own on the beach, Bofur became restless. He started pacing in front of the cave, trying to peer inside but he couldn’t see a thing beyond two feet.

 

This wait was excruciating! Bofur had to busy himself with something, or he would become mad. A good swig of his precious poitin was what he needed. Alas, he had forgotten the damned bottle in the car! Grabbing his walking stick, he left to retrieve his liquor.

 

He was halfway to the car when suddenly, something in the sand caught his eyes. Partially buried in the sand among the rocks and the algae, there were six eggs, just like the one they had seen earlier in Bilbo’s lab. If he hid them better, he could sell them for a good price… Oh, yes, he could.

 

Carefully, Bofur probed one of the small globes with his walking stick before crouching down to have a better look. Driven by curiosity, he unearthed one of the eggs.

He was about to hold it in his hands when he felt something moving inside the thick translucent shell.

He startled so hard he fell on his butt, screaming “Mighty Mahal!”. Still on the sand, the thing inside the egg squirmed and emitted a squelching sound.

This was too much for Bofur. Valuable or not, those things were threatening and dangerous. The dwarf hastily got back on his feet, grabbed his stick and went back to the cave, quite pale all of a sudden.

 

*~*

 

After a short moment, Kíli recomposed himself and tried to locate Bilbo and his uncle. Fíli and him swept the light of their torches over the rocks, but the scientists were out of sight.

“I knew we shouldn’t have split the group” grumbled Fíli.

“They can’t be that far, can they?” replied Kíli before shouting “Hello!”

Fíli jumped like a startled cat and hissed “Mahal! My heart! What are you doing??”

“I’m calling them. Well, do you know a better way? Hmm? Hello!”

Fíli winced.

 

Something splashed behind their back. Something big.

The two Gardai turned around slowly.

 

A quivering wall of dark flesh and tentacles was behind them. Rising slowly. They traced it with their torches. It filled the entire cave. Just tentacles. Tentacles and a monstrous mouth.

 

Fíli was the first to move.

“RUN!”

“Move! Quickly!”

They stumbled into each other as they turned around. Slipping on the algae. The sound of the tide coming in interweaved with the splashes of the tentacles.

 

The only thing saving them was the narrowness of the passage. The monster’s bulk slowed it down.

Then the path was barely wide enough for Fíli to press through. He could see the light through the narrow entryway. Beckoning him.

 

“Fíli! Hurry!” Kíli had run into him.”Hurry!”

“I’m trying.” Fíli’s shoulders chafed against the rough rock.

“Would you move your arse?”

He tried to push the other dwarf, reaching a bit too low.

“Let go of my arse!” Fíli retorted, distracted from the situation.

But with a hearty shove, Fíli stumbled out into the open, quickly followed by Kíli. His slender built was an advantage for once.

Behind them, they could hear the monster growling, its tentacles emitting suction sounds as they gripped on the cave’s walls.

 

“Go!” They both shouted at once, tripping over the sand before they found their bearings again, running away from the cave. Fíli stumbled, and Kíli took his hand without thinking, pulling him further along.

 

“You ok?”

They both stopped for a moment, looking back.

“The size of that thing!” Fíli was shaking.

“It’s okay; it can’t get through the gap.” Kíli let out a sigh of relief, seeing the monster stuck. Then he fell on his backside, struck by something on his head. The monster’s tongue had lashed out and taken off his hat.

“Mahal!”

 

“Leg it!”

It was Fíli now who took Kíli’s hand and dragged him along.

“Thorin!” Kíli remembered his uncle was still in that cave. “THORIN!!!!!!”

“Oh shit.” Fíli stopped as well, desperately scanning the area. Where were the scientists? Had they heard the noise and deduced what happened? How would they get out?

 

Bofur was running towards them, but Fíli made frantic signs for him to stop, while Kíli was still shouting for his uncle.

 

*~*

 

“Do you think it’s wise to get away from the others?” asked Bilbo.

 

Thorin remained silent, focused on his exploration of the cave. With a sigh, the hobbit followed his former professor and they got deeper into the darkness. After groping their way along, they found signs of life. A nest made out of algae and fish bones scattered around it could only tell one thing: merrows dwelled here. But where were they?

For the first time in ages, Thorin looked at Bilbo with sheer excitement. The hobbit was glad that the partial dark hid the pink shade colouring his cheeks.

 

As far as he could remember, the hobbit had always been attracted to his professor.

It had been love at first sight, so to speak. Like in those cheap romance movies, he had run into Thorin on his first day at the University, thirteen years ago. The dwarf had been kind enough to lead him to his class.

Usually stern, Professor Oakenshield could become quite animated when the subject of his teaching was about the creatures populating the Irish Sea. Not the common dolphins and seals, but the more extraordinary races such as merrows.

The young hobbit student had spent years listening to his dwarf professor, in a state of perpetual awe. The dwarf was brilliant. Not good at social interactions, not much of a smiler, but brilliant.

Rapidly, Bilbo had become Thorin’s best student, and after his graduation, he had taken charge of Erebor’s Shore Sciences Laboratory. Bilbo had thought it could help him get closer to Thorin, but the dwarf had suddenly lost any interest in the hobbit. His problematic nephew was going through a rough time once again, and Thorin had focused on his family issues. After that, Thorin had less and less showed up, and Bilbo had even thought about quitting to go back to England.

But now that this exciting case had appeared, Thorin and Bilbo were working together again, and the hobbit had caught himself hoping for something to happen.

 

So here they were, almost alone in the dark, when they heard Kíli’s voice booming through the cave. The two scientists winced at the sudden noise. Thorin grumbled something unintelligible, and Bilbo sighed in disappointment. Why did Kíli always come in their way?

The hobbit was about to answer the Garda’s call when he saw Thorin’s eyes widen in front of him. Slowly, the dwarf switched off his torch and put a finger across his lips. Bilbo frowned at first, but Thorin seized his shoulders and made him crouch beside him.

The hobbit murmured “What’s going on?”.

“Shhhh… don’t make a sound, and stay close to me. If we’re lucky, it won’t notice us.”

 

Flustered by Thorin’s attitude, Bilbo complied. He was putting so much effort in hiding that he unconsciously stopped breathing for a while. His heart was pounding painfully in his ears, and suddenly, the Gardai’s panicked screams filled the dark space of the cave.

A cold sweat ran down Bilbo’s spine as he was repressing a desperate need to cry out his fear. Pressing his hands on his mouth, he let out a muffled whine.

 

Thorin had stayed tense and focused the whole time.

What was that gigantic beast? It had tentacles like the strange female specimen he had examined a few hours ago, but this one was immense! And it was after his nephew… Thorin inwardly pleaded Mahal to save Kíli’s life for he loved his nephew like the son he had never had.

 

After a short moment of total mayhem, the cave became silent again. That’s when Thorin eventually noticed the shivering hobbit crouched on the ground beside him.

“Bilbo? It’s all right. It’s gone.”

Still trembling, the hobbit stared at his former professor and asked with a shaky voice “What was that?”

 

Thorin was about to answer when he felt something cold and wet encircling him. The flood tide!

“We must get out of here! Quick!”

 

Thorin manhandled a still shocked Bilbo out of their rock shelter, leaving the torch behind them. Once out of the merrows’ nest, they heard a low and angry growl coming from the opposite side of the cave. The monster was busy elsewhere. It was now or never.

 

Thorin settled Bilbo across his shoulder and jumped in a growing pool of water. It was their only way out.

Fighting against the strength of the current, the dwarf forced their way out of the cave, to the other side of the beach, now covered with water.

 

Kíli! They had to find him!

Thorin hurried across the highest rocks and turned just in time to see Kíli and his colleague on the beach waving at Bofur, who was running towards them.

 

The dwarf’s shoulder was starting to ache, and he remembered he had been holding Bilbo the whole time. The hobbit was still in shock, his limbs as limp as those of a ragdoll.

Thorin transferred Bilbo in his arms and ran as fast as he could to join his nephew who was frantically screaming his name.

Notes:

Thanks to all of you for your kudos and comments!

For those who wonder where does Narag Tharr come from, it's the Neo-Khuzdul for "black" and "rock".
And merrows are the mermaids/men from the Irish folklore.