Actions

Work Header

Growing Dwarves (And Kingdoms)

Chapter 3

Summary:

Bilbo is dragged into bath with the heirs of Durin, not that he actually minds. Much, anyway. Later, though, it turns out certain dwarves have been harboring rather mistaken assumptions about their little hobbit, which clearly means Bilbo must demand explanations of Thorin. Fíli, meanwhile, just wants to talk with Ori.

Honestly, though. How hard is it to tell the lads from the lasses?

Chapter Text

"So." Thorin set aside the last document he had been reading, looking up at Dwalin, who was patiently standing on the other side of his desk. "You caught up with Kíli by the morning after you set off."

"Aye, that's true." Dwalin gave a solemn nod. "There aren't that many roads to take, with there only being one river, and I don't think he expected anyone to follow him quite so soon, seeing as he wasn't exactly hiding."

"And at the time you sent word by raven, so we would know he was safe and would not worry."

"As I had promised to do, yes." Dwalin's expression still hadn't changed a bit.

"So, can you please explain to me why exactly you took a full week to bring him back?"

Now, Dwalin finally reacted, even if only by scratching the back of his head. "We had to return upstream?"

"For all your insults, Dwalin, I'm not actually stupid." Thorin shook his head. "Don't tell me you thought he had the right idea."

"Seemed good enough to me, and he was right in that an empty quiver would not make a very impressive gift. Besides, I was rather under the impression your main protest was about his sneaking off without taking anyone along. We figured that with me keeping watch, nobody would try anything funny, so that was all right."

"Right." Thorin sighed. "Did he at least find some scales, to make the whole mess worth the trouble?"

"Aye. Turns out the buggers are much easier to pry loose than they are to pierce, which is to say it's possible at all." Dwalin shrugged. "Still didn't come home with more than a couple of handfuls, seeing how they were all at the bottom of the lake, but it should be quite enough to fill her quiver."

"How did that even work? I can't imagine the waters of the lake would be anything less than murky and dark." Not that dwarves in general had a problem with low light, but not even they could work in total darkness.

"Well, surprising though it may be, your prince is not altogether stupid." Dwalin flashed him a brief smirk. "He'd taken along a couple of the crystals miners use to provide light. Don't think he'd have found anything otherwise, what with all that water and ruined houses getting in the way."

"I'm not sure if it makes matters better or worse that he had the foresight to take those along but didn't stop to think he perhaps shouldn't go at all."

"Well, one hopes he'll think for a moment before he does such a thing again." Dwalin shrugged. "I've had a lot of time to explain just how many ways this scheme of his could have gone wrong. If he doesn't get it now, he never will."

"Thank you for completely ruining any attempt I might have made at being hopeful." Even so, Thorin couldn't help but smile a bit as he stood up from his seat. "I shouldn't be too surprised, though. Remember Dís preparing her own courtship gift?"

"As though I could forget," Dwalin murmured. "The royal princess deciding she should take down a wolf all by herself for the pelt. I'm still not sure if I'm more annoyed that she sneaked off without warning or that she actually managed."

"It's not like it would have been any different if she'd let any of us come along. We'd have ended up holding her cloak while she skinned the beast." Thorin stretched himself, feeling aching muscles slotting into place. "I do hope Balin isn't about to come up with more work for me to do, because at the moment, I rather believe I'm done for the day."

"You make it sound like he's making up more work just to annoy you."

"I wouldn't put it past your brother. He's had stranger schemes before." Thorin walked out of his office, Dwalin close on his heels. "I suppose I should go check on the boys. Fíli wanted to present Bilbo with his new set of rooms today, and I'm not sure if Kíli is going to be excited about it or disappointed that he didn't get to be around for much of the preparations."

"We all make our choices. His was to spend the last week outdoors getting himself cold and wet every day instead of staying in the cosy mountain, so he has no right to complain." Dwalin groaned, pulling his head to the side with an audible crick. "Now, if you won't be needing me, I think I'll be going. I've had quite enough of princelings for a little while."

"Wish that I could make that choice." Thorin patted Dwalin on the shoulder. "You go on, my friend. I'll make sure they haven't literally smothered the poor halfling."

The new royal wing was not far from his office, thanks to careful consideration in choosing the placement for both. The old visitors' quarters they had taken over were in the better part of the mountain, yet behind too many hallways and small chambers for the worm to have made its way there. The old royal apartments were unusable now; while some of the rooms remained, particularly those Thorin and his siblings had occupied so long ago, the larger, more lavishly decorated ones had been torn out by claw and fire for their gold and gems. Thrór's rooms had been trashed entirely, to the point where their structural integrity would have to be examined before any actual attempt at cleaning or reoccupation were made, not that Thorin was in any particular hurry to do so. He was of a mind to make the new assignment of royal apartments permanent.

Thorin had no desire for gilded walls and gem-encrusted fireplaces. There were still nights he woke up gasping for air in the fleeting memory of a floor of pure gold coming up to swallow him.

As he reached the door leading to the common area of the royal wing, though, he could hear some commotion from within. Frowning, he paused, then pushed the door open.

"Uncle!" Fíli offered him a brilliant smile from where his arm was wrapped around one of Bilbo's, Kíli occupying the hobbit's other side. "All done for the day?"

"I am, unless I need to start a lecture on how princes are not supposed to assault esteemed guests." Thorin lifted his eyebrows, letting the door fall closed behind himself as he walked in. It was not quite the privacy of his own rooms yet, but he could still allow himself some measure of relaxation. "And Kíli. I wasn't entirely sure if I would find you here; I'd have thought you would take the opportunity to see your elf again."

"I would have, except she's out of the mountain. Seems like Óin convinced her to show him where to find the plants for her pain remedy around here." Kíli managed to give a carefree shrug while still maintaining his grip on Bilbo. "And we're not assaulting anyone. All we want to do is show Bilbo a good time."

"You'll forgive me if that sounds somewhat ominous to me." Thorin stepped closer. "Master Baggins? What is going on here?"

"You know, I'm not entirely sure myself." Bilbo made to affect a huff, but reminded Thorin mostly of an indulgent father playing along with his children's games even though he didn't understand their meaning. "I just mentioned that I might like a bath tonight when I saw the lovely little bath chamber attached to my rooms, and the next thing I know, these two are swinging me off my feet and off we go like a horde of orcs."

"We were more polite than that!" At Thorin's questioning look, Fíli relented. "Well. A bit more polite, at least."

"They've got the big forges going," Kíli hurried to inform him as a way of explanation. "And Fíli said he checked earlier and the plumbing works. There's no way we can let Bilbo wash in a teeny tiny tub if there's a chance the proper bath is working!"

"And it never occurred to you that he might actually prefer that tiny tub? Hobbits are rather different creatures from us dwarves." Thorin glanced at Bilbo, who was looking bewildered right now but quickly schooled his expression to something more sedate. "Master Baggins? Am I wrong to make the assumption that hobbits do not make a habit of public bathing?" It certainly seemed so from the way Bilbo had always refused to wash together with the rest on the road.

Bilbo's eyes widened a bit. "Not at all," he huffed. "That would be quite improper!"

"Nothing improper about baths, unless one's actions make it so." Thorin offered him a small smile. "I think my sister-sons are rather eager to show you the dwarven way of bathing. We only ever use solitary tubs if we are in a hurry, if only we can help it, but I can certainly have yours prepared for you if that's your preference. Don't let these two pester you into something you're not comfortable with."

"You have a public bath here?" Bilbo's eyes widened. "In the apartments?"

"Well, it used to be public, back when these were visitors' quarters," Fíli supplied helpfully. "But now that we've taken over, it's obviously a family bath. Completely different thing. We had a small one back in Ered Luin, but the open ones back there were pretty amazing, compared. I've heard the ones here in Erebor are something else entirely, once they get all the forges going to keep it all warm."

"Mother says all of Erebor could bathe at once and each have a place in the water," Kíli announced, a tone of wonder in his voice. "Can you imagine that? A mountainful of dwarves all in the same baths!"

Thorin chuckled. "It's not quite that impressive, I'm afraid, certainly not back when the mountain was full. But I do admit they were much roomier than what Ered Luin had to offer. And they will be again, once we get them running, but for now, we'll have to content ourselves with the family baths."

"I have to admit, I never would have expected dwarves to be quite so keen on the subject of baths." Bilbo blinked as he realised what he had said, then flushed a bit. "Ah, not to say you are dirty or anything! It's just, I'd have thought you'd be too, well, practical to waste much time and energy on something as seemingly frivolous as bathing."

Kíli chortled. "Oh, believe me, it's a practical matter all right," he announced with a leer. "Never mind the miners and all the dirt and dust they carry, you don't know the meaning of stink until you've met a dwarf who just spent a whole day at their forge. Uncle here smells so bad sometimes, an orc would faint at getting a whiff of him."

"So I stink, do I?" Thorin's lips twitched. "And this from the lad who started off his apprenticeship smelling of piss every day."

Fíli chuckled at his brother's glowering grimace, then smiled as Bilbo gave them a slightly horrified gaze. "Kíli's a leatherworker by craft," he explained. "His master thought he should be familiar with where his materials come from, so he had the poor thing work for a tanner for the better part of a year before he was allowed anywhere near the actual workshop."

"Worked a treat, too." Thorin couldn't help but notice the boys were once again nudging Bilbo in the direction of the room that housed the large bath shared by the apartments even as Kíli complained of his miserable experiences. "I know precisely how to prepare my own leather, as well as why I'd rather pay someone else to do it for me."

"Ah. That is." Bilbo blinked, looking a bit bewildered. "I guess it's good to know they didn't let you off easier just because you're royalty?"

"Of course not." Thorin scoffed. "No true master would devalue their own craft so, no matter who their apprentice." Well. He supposed a hobbit wouldn't have known much about that. "All dwarves have a craft to call their own, for all that not all of us pursue it for a trade. I was already familiar with a smithing hammer before the worm ever came and forced me to labour to support my family. If anything, my master was only ever harder on me for my birth, because a prince ought to be excellent in everything."

"Which is why uncle is brilliant," Fíli said, ever loyal. "I know the basics of blacksmithing, mostly because men would always have work for a passable smith, but I'm nothing like him. He made most of my weapons, you know."

"He did?" Bilbo glanced at Thorin, who shrugged.

"I couldn't very well let him fight with substandard weapons, and I was the best weapon smith we could afford at the time." That was something he was never going to feel ashamed for. Some might have thought it beneath a king's station, but he would do whatever it took to keep his family fed and well.

"Yeah, well, I'm still going to keep using them." Fíli pushed open a door and guided Bilbo in, Kíli on his other side. "Maybe you could get uncle to make you a proper sword, too, instead of your little letter opener."

"Thank you, but I'm quite fond of mine." Bilbo glanced around. "And I see you have brought me to the bath after all."

"Well, we aren't going to force you into the water, but you should at least see how great it is." Kíli grinned. "Come on, it's going to be great."

"One would think you'd have gotten enough of water for a little while." Even so, Bilbo seemed to be looking around with some interest.

"Well, yes, but that was cold and dirty. Nothing like this." Kíli strode on ahead, already stripping off his topmost tunic. "Uncle? You going to join us?"

Thorin lifted his eyebrows as Fíli and Bilbo both turned to look at him. "You know, I do think I will. It has been a long day, even if I may not stink of sweat and smoke this time." He met Bilbo's gaze. "The offer still stands, Master Hobbit. Just say the word, and we'll have someone fill up your tub, privacy guaranteed."

A hint of flush appeared on Bilbo's cheeks, probably in embarrassment, but it was chased away quickly enough. "I, ah. I think I'll just join you three. I'd hate to cause more work to everyone, and, well, I suppose I should learn something of the dwarven customs."

"Great!" Now, Fíli stepped away from Bilbo at last, already hurrying after his brother. "Uncle, you tell him what to do, we're going ahead!"

Thorin snorted at the boys' hurry as they rushed through the small outer chamber into the actual bath area, littering clothes along the way. "Hopeless, both of them." If Bilbo noted the fondness in his voice, at least the hobbit didn't comment.

"So, ah. I'm assuming the principle is the same even in dwarven mountains, right?" Bilbo started fussing with the buttons on his waistcoat as Thorin made to remove his own belt and outer layers. "Clothes off and into the water?"

"That's the gist of it, yes." Thorin chuckled. "Not that the lads have always bothered with the first part. At least they've learnt to put clothes back on after. I rather lost count of the times we had to chase after nude little dwarflings straight out of the bath when they were small."

"You know, that really doesn't surprise me as much as it should." Bilbo glanced at the abandoned clothes marking a trail of the princes. "And I'm assuming leaving a track isn't actually part of the etiquette, either?"

"Not quite." Thorin made quick work of his clothing, folding it on the stone bench in the front chamber. At least there hadn't been a council meeting today, or he'd have had rather more to disrobe from. "Most of us prefer not to dirty our clothes any more than already happens."

"Right." Bilbo was doing his best not to look at Thorin, a pink tone already rising on his cheeks as he instead focused on getting his clothes off. Thorin decided to have mercy on him, heading out to the bath proper once he had taken off all his clothes.

It wasn't quite the royal bath he remembered from his youth, but it came close. Fíli and Kíli were already splashing about in the large pool like a pair of children, laughing and shouting as they tried to get water on each other, crying out in protest at every splash as though they hadn't already been standing waist deep in the water. Thorin shook his head at such childishness, stepping into the water with what he thought was rather more grace and maturity.

The feeling of sinking into the warm water was near divine. He hadn't been exaggerating; even without dealing with the council, he had had a long day indeed, and for all that there hadn't been much physical effort involved, he still managed to find aching, tense muscles that loosened in the warmth. Sitting on the low bench against the edge of the pool, he closed his eyes, listening to the boys squabble.

He didn't hear the approaching footsteps, the footfalls of a hobbit soft as ever. He did, however, hear the slightly hesitant voice going, "Ah. How do I get in?"

Thorin opened his eyes, looking up to the direction of the voice. Then, realising the effect of his sitting in the water and Bilbo standing at the edge, he looked up a bit further, finding a flushed face. Well, the best way to make this less awkward for his friend was probably to act as though it wasn't. "There's a bench running along the edge, under the water," he said. "It shouldn't be too far down for you to step in."

Bilbo nodded, wearing the kind of look of determination people often saved for dangerous battles and other such challenges. Despite his apparent reservations, though, he managed to make it down in the water well enough. He seemed to relax a bit as soon as the most critical areas were hidden by the water, taking a seat next to Thorin. "This really is quite nice."

"I do agree." Thorin leaned an arm back on the edge, gesturing with his other hand. "If we're actually dirty, we wash in the smaller basin first, so the bath proper doesn't get filthy. I know we were quite fine with roughing it up along the journey," he added, smiling a bit at Bilbo's badly hidden surprise, "but that was due to necessity, not desire. Just because people think of us as dirty little thieves doesn't mean we much care to live up to that unfortunate reputation."

"Ah. I didn't think that." Bilbo flushed again, though, perhaps recalling some harsh words he might have heard about dwarves in general. "And I'm sure things will change once you get the kingdom to flourish again."

"I can hope." He glanced over to the lads, who hadn't calmed down yet. "I want to leave Fíli with a better throne than the one I was given."

"Well, that will definitely happen, since that moment had better be far in the future." Bilbo gave him an admonishing gaze. "I didn't come all the way here just to see you die, you know."

"Indeed not." Thorin's lips twitched. "You came here to steal my treasure and give it over to elves." He could jest about that, now, and not feel that twinge of agonising pain mixed with desire anymore. It was a welcome change, though one he much feared might reverse itself one day.

"I didn't —!" Bilbo spluttered in annoyance. "I gave it to Bard! And I had very good reasons, besides. And it wasn't stealing when it was my share!"

"I know, I know. And I did hire you as a burglar; it is hardly your fault if you decide to follow that decree." Thorin smiled even as he sought out one of the braids in his hair, working out the bead at the end before starting to unravel the braid. "Truly, I should be proud. If there ever was a great burglar, it was the burglar of Thorin Oakenshield."

"Oh, now you are just trying to embarrass me." Bilbo's slight flush, though, made soon way for a curious expression. "Say, I've never seen you take off your braids before."

"That's not much of a surprise." Apparently the boys had squabbled enough for a moment, as they chose this point to join the conversation, wading closer through the water. "While some of us have great braids, others less so," at this, Fíli glanced at his brother with a grin, getting a scowl in return, "working on them isn't something just anyone may see. Some of us got a bit less prudish on the road, but you'd have a hard time finding a dwarf willing to braid his hair in front of anyone but family or their closest friends."

"I'll never understand you dwarves." Bilbo sighed, shaking his head, but there was a hint of a smile on his lips. "You'll run around with your privates hanging out without a thought, but braiding hair is too shocking for anyone to see."

"It's not quite the same." Thorin snorted, starting work on another braid. "And in any case, we don't go around naked much outside bath time. So, don't worry, your precious sensibilities are quite safe around here."

"I don't know. A proper hobbit would never go around without a shirt like your lot seem to do." Bilbo was amused for a moment, then blinked. "Wait. You don't mind doing that with me here, then?"

Thorin didn't need to look to know the boys were waiting eagerly for his response. He ignored them, focusing on a stubborn little tangle on the braid he was undoing. "If the lads think you ought to be living in the family apartments, I see no problem with my fixing my hair in front of you." His lips twitched into a small smirk. "Just don't ask me to braid your hair as well. We're not quite close enough for that just yet."

Bilbo seemed to understand enough of the implications to flush as Thorin glanced at him from the corner of his eye, with the lads tittering in the background. Thorin went on undoing his braids, enjoying the warmth and the relaxed atmosphere.

If his mind had some suggestions as to how very lovely Bilbo would look with a braid or two in his curly head, possibly woven there by an experienced hand, well, that was neither here nor there.

*

The thing about Fíli and Kíli, Bilbo had come to notice, was that he could always tell when they were coming along.

Of course, this was hardly a surprise. They had not exactly been the sneakiest members of the Company, chattering away as they often did, and dwarves in general were not built for stealth. However, sometimes it almost seemed as though they made a point of making noise now that they were back in their rightful place, stomping along the stone floors with even more enthusiasm than the older and bigger dwarves. Therefore, he heard their steps approaching down the corridor just in time to set down his pen and turn towards the door before it was opened without as much as a by-your-leave.

"Bilbo!" Kíli cried out in lieu of a greeting as he burst into the room. "Look what we found!" He skipped closer, showing off some kind of garments he had draped over his arms.

Bilbo blinked, somewhat confused. "Are those dresses?" Dresses or robes, he decided, though they were quite different from what the hobbit ladies back home would wear.

"Yes!" Fíli grinned, showing off a couple of them hanging off his arms. "We found them right in the royal apartments, so don't worry, we're not robbing some poor lady."

"We think they belonged to our mother, back before the worm came," Kíli said, clearly enthusiastic. "It's hard to believe she used to be this small, but then she was pretty young when they had to leave."

"She definitely won't fit in these when she returns."

"I wouldn't imagine so, no." Bilbo frowned. "Not that they aren't pretty, but why exactly are you showing them off to me?"

"Isn't it obvious?" Kíli's grin got even wider. "We thought that since you're also pretty small, they would fit you just right!"

"Uh." Bilbo resisted the urge to squirm. "I do not think it would be quite appropriate."

"Oh, come on," Fíli tried to encourage him. "It's not like our mom's going to wear these anymore. And you do need more clothes, so why don't you at least try them on?"

"It's not really something I'm used to wearing." At first he'd thought this was some kind of a strange joke, but the boys seemed to be quite serious about their offer.

Kíli blinked. "Do hobbit ladies not wear dresses?"

"Yes, they do," Bilbo sighed, doing his best to keep the shrillness of indignation out of his voice. The poor lads seemed honestly confused, not malicious. "However, gentlehobbits do not."

"And?" Fíli frowned. "Are these the wrong style for hobbits or something? We know they're pretty old, but they'll have to be adjusted anyway, so…"

"Boys, I know you mean well, but I don't wear dresses. I'm sure they're very fine dresses, but I don't wear them. Because I'm not a lady." Could he possibly make this any clearer without getting crude?

For a moment, Fíli's frown deepened. Then his expression cleared into an understanding smile, and Bilbo let out a sigh of relief. Of course, his momentary respite was immediately crushed by the prince's next words. "Oh, don't worry about it, Bilbo! You don't have to pretend anymore."

"Right," Kíli agreed, catching on to whatever conclusion they had erroneously reached. "I know this isn't home like your hole is home, but you're safe here, promise. You don't need to keep pretending around here."

"I'm not pretending." Bilbo rubbed the bridge of his nose. Oh, he was going to have such a headache before this was over. "I'm not sure where you got this idea, but I am not a lady, not even in secret. I'm a male hobbit, always have been, always will be. There is no pretending or secrecy going on."

"Wait." Kíli stared at him as though he had just announced he was an orc. "You mean you're actually male?"

"Well, obviously," Bilbo sniffed. "I'm Mister Baggins, mind you. How could you possibly not know this?"

"We figured you were just using the male words while on the road." Fíli frowned. His arms with the dresses had sagged, and Bilbo almost felt guilty for disappointing him. "I mean, female dwarves often do that when they're travelling outside the mountains, so we just thought it was the same for hobbits."

"Oh, no. Hobbits just do not generally travel at all, regardless of gender. But if we did, you would have a hard time finding even one grown hobbit lady who would be so improper as to wear male clothes." He shook his head. "I simply do not know how you could have come up with such an idea."

"Well, dwarves don't make much of a difference either way," Kíli said, looking a bit uncomfortable now. "And you're the only hobbit we've ever seen. But we've seen men, of course, and in their places men grow beards and women don't."

"You don't have a beard, and you're fussy about things like kerchiefs, and you cook," Fíli added. "We just figured that meant you were a lady hobbit, and you were just really bad at pretending to be male."

"We didn't say anything, though." Kíli shifted his weight from one foot to another. "None of us did. We figured that if you were doing it for safety, we could keep you safe between the thirteen of us either way, and if it was some weird propriety thing you might not want to draw attention to it."

"Wait. You said none of you," Bilbo realised. "Exactly how many of you thought I'm female?"

"What do you mean, how many?" Fíli's frown was back. "Pretty much everyone in the Company, I guess. Though Óin didn't really talk about it, and Bombur always shook his head, and Uncle Thorin and Glóin just told us we were being stupid. We just thought they didn't want to gossip like that."

"Oh. Oh, my goodness." It was a good thing he was already seated, or he might have needed to sit down. The entire Company thought he was female? How was that even possible?

"Um. We're sorry?" Kíli did look guilty, shifting again. "I mean, we just assumed, but we shouldn't have. We just didn't want to offend you by asking about something like that."

"It's quite all right." Bilbo sighed again. "I… I think I need to talk with your uncle."

"Oh?" Fíli blinked. "I think he's talking with Balin in his office right now."

"Thank you." Bilbo got up from his desk. The boys still looked uneasy, he noticed, and he sighed. "I'm not mad at you," he said. "I mean, I'm fairly sure I've seen dwarf ladies by now but couldn't even tell. It's not like you could have known."

"If you're sure." Kíli still shifted, though. "Uh, hey, Bilbo? Since you don't want these, what do you think we should do with them?"

"Well, if you're certain your mother won't have any use for them, why don't you go out and see if there are any young dwarf ladies among the Iron Hill dwarves who might?" Bilbo gave them a small smile. "After all, it would be a pity to see such fine things go to waste. If they are still intact after all these years, they must be of pretty sturdy make."

"Right!" Fíli nodded. "And if you'd like, we could then go look for Uncle Frerin's room. From what mother told us he was just barely grown in Azanulbizar, so some of his clothes might fit you if we find any left here."

"If you think it would be appropriate." He had not, Bilbo noted, ever heard of an Uncle Frerin before. But then, he supposed he could guess why, if the boys had only heard of him from their mother.

If he had been at Azanulbizar.

Bilbo tried not to think too hard on it as he headed toward Thorin's office, the young princes slowly returning to their usual carefree chatter in his wake.

*

Thorin had barely called out his invitation to enter as the door was opened, hasty steps approaching. Balin might have expected such hurry to herald one of the two princes, not their burglar, but apparently even Bilbo could sometimes be called to hasty action. He certainly seemed a bit out of sorts, eyes dancing wildly around the room before settling on Thorin.

"Master Baggins." Balin smiled. "It's good to see you are up and well." Of course he had been to see Bilbo briefly since he had started taking Tauriel's pain remedy, but he was indeed glad to see it was still working.

Bilbo, quite unlike his jovial self, only gave Balin a curt nod before storming further into the room, stepping only a few feet from Thorin, staring up at him with what Balin believed to be annoyance. "You." It was rare indeed that anyone would address the King Under the Mountain in such a tone. "Fíli and Kíli were just in my rooms."

"I'm not too surprised by that." Thorin didn't react either to the sharp tone or the thunderous expression. "I'm taking it something about their conduct upset you?"

"Why exactly do they think that I'm female?"

Now, Balin was forced to blink in surprise. "You're not?"

"Obviously not!" Well, it certainly wasn't obvious to him. "Goodness, you all really thought that, didn't you? It wasn't just the boys being silly?"

"Not all of us." Thorin appeared perfectly calm despite the rather unusual subject matter. "I know at least Óin, Glóin, Bombur and myself were somewhat more informed, but we figured that correcting them would only lead to more unnecessary fuss. Mahal knows you would have been unbearable if we had brought up something that embarrassing about you, and the best way to keep the discussion from your ears was not to correct their assumptions, since they were so adamant on not telling you about your poor disguise."

"You could have told at least some of us, you know." Balin couldn't help the slightly scolding tone in his voice, though whether it was at the secretiveness over the journey or the way Thorin apparently failed to notice how his words only aggravated the hobbit further, he left that for the king to decide. "I'll agree the lads probably would have made a fuss, but surely you should have trusted most of us to keep things under wraps."

"And why was it our place to correct you? Clearly it wouldn't have made any difference to the situation, so as long as the hobbit was not bothered, it was hardly that serious."

"But how is that even possible?" Bilbo was waving his hands as though not able to entirely contain his frustration about the situation. "I mean, how did they come to that conclusion in the first place? I don't even look like a lady hobbit!"

"And how were we to know that?" Balin scoffed. "We hardly know how hobbits usually dress themselves, and even so dwarves don't always make a difference in dress between sexes. You were the first hobbit most of us had ever seen! We knew that the women of menfolk lack beards, and that seemed good enough a clue for us."

"That, and you were a very proper little creature all along the way," Thorin added. "If they couldn't read any clues in your clothes, and never saw you without, how were they to know better?"

"But I don't even have a bosom!" Bilbo had to be rather upset to be able to exclaim that without either faltering or flustering. "Surely that at least is in common in all the female folk I've ever seen, and that can certainly be visible even with clothes on!"

"There is such a thing as chest wraps; they're certainly common enough among female dwarves on the road." Thorin shrugged. "Besides, not meaning to offend, but it seems even a male hobbit is somewhat soft and round compared with a dwarf."

This seemed to annoy Bilbo even further, judging by the flush that rose to his cheeks. At least Balin was going to assume it was annoyance; he wasn't quite willing to consider otherwise. "Just because we're not all carved from bloody rock and stone doesn't mean we're all female! And besides, the boys still seemed to be in their mistaken belief even though we have shared a bath!"

Now, that was new information to Balin, who glanced at Thorin. The king chose to ignore him, instead regarding Bilbo with a calm air. "They've never seen a female form naked, though, so it's not like they're going to know the difference. The public baths in Ered Luin were separated by the sex, and their mother hasn't bathed with them since the day their father and I could be trusted not to drop them; they always were rather lively in bath, and Dís was of the opinion she was at least entitled to a peaceful bath if nothing else."

"So they know nothing at all?" Bilbo's tone was starting to get somewhat shrill. "They know nothing of how to tell apart male and female?"

"They know it's lasses who bear children and lads who father them." Thorin frowned. "Surely that is quite enough for now. Rather, I'm quite pleased to hear this. At least it means Kíli hasn't gotten up to anything too inappropriate with his lady elf."

"That's just all the more reason why he should be informed!" Bilbo's arms were flailing again. "If female dwarves bear children, then I'm assuming it all works for you the same way it does for men, right?"

"Far as I'm aware, yes." Thorin gave a shrug. "Not to say I've ever been privy to the information, but I've seen their women heavy with children, and they seem similar enough to female dwarves in the same state; I'd assume the beginning of it works the same as well."

"So perhaps Kíli should be informed as to the potential consequences, should he and Tauriel choose not to follow the propriety rules until their wedding?" Bilbo sighed now, rubbing the bridge of his nose as though dealing with something that was giving him a headache. Seeing how he was facing Thorin, Balin couldn't exactly blame him. "We may not do everything the same way back in the Shire, but at least I'm aware that two young people in love can be quite talented in figuring out what goes where unless they're given a good reason not to."

Now, Thorin's frown deepened. "Do you think so?"

"Well, obviously it's not absolutely certain, if Tauriel has the presence of mind to avoid such trouble, but I'd really feel better if they were at least somewhat informed. At least they should know the difference between lads and lasses at their age!"

"I'll think about it." Though even if Thorin did decide in favour of it, Balin rather suspected the actual talking would be done by someone unfortunate enough to be ordered into it by the king. Hopefully Óin. Balin wasn't any more eager for such talks than Thorin was. "But truly, their ignorance of your sex cannot be blamed on them, any more than the rest of the company. They see a soft form and a beardless face, so of course they will think you are female. It shouldn't matter, either way. My folk don't make much difference in how we treat the two sexes."

Bilbo paused, then made a rather displeased face. "Do you mean that other dwarves will think I'm female, too? Here in the mountain?"

"Unless you correct them? It's not unlikely." Balin stroked his beard. "I'd like to think I'm not a stupid dwarf, but I can only judge such things based on what I know, and I know little indeed about hobbits."

"Oh, by the Green Lady." Bilbo ran a hand over his face before fixing another sharp gaze at Thorin. "How did you know better than the rest, then?"

"Well, we had a rather different position from the rest of the Company. Óin is rather accomplished at midwifery, Glóin and Bombur both have wives, and I have lived with a sister for the better part of my life. Of course we would be more informed than those with only incidental acquaintance with the differences, if even that."

"No, I mean, how did you know it? Far as I know you didn't see me without clothes any more than the rest did." The slight hint of a flush was back, and this time Balin doubted there was much annoyance involved. How very interesting.

"We didn't, but it was a long time on the road. For all that you kept yourself quite private, we figured that if you had been dealing with your cycles, we would have noticed some evidence of it at least." Thorin's lips twitched a bit. "That, and to our combined reckoning it would have been rather unusual for a female to relieve herself standing up."

This time the flush and spluttering was surely embarrassment and nothing else, but even so, Balin decided to make a point of remembering the details of this particular interaction.

It was rare enough to see that particular smile on Thorin's lips.

*

"Ori?" Fíli paused in the doorway, looking out into the dusty reaches of the grand library of Erebor. Everything seemed quiet and empty, though a couple of candles had been lit, barely giving enough light to chase away the worst of the shadows. "Ori, are you here?"

"Over here!" The familiar voice was coming from deeper in the cavern, prompting Fíli to leave the safety of the doorway. The heavy door fell shut behind him, closing away what light might have otherwise travelled from the corridor. It was a good thing indeed that his eyes did not need much light, or he wouldn't have made it three steps in the semi-darkness without tripping over something.

"Why are you hiding in the darkness like this?" Fíli navigated his way through the empty library. The floor had been dusted for the most part, for what little good it could do in the wake of so long a time without use, but most of the shelves seemed untouched for centuries. He couldn't help but wonder if some of them had been the same even before the worm came; a lot of what was stored on them seemed rather dull.

"I'm not hiding." Indeed, as Fíli got around another shelf, he found one corner of the library better lit with several candles scattered about. Ori was sitting in the middle of it all, sorting scrolls that to Fíli seemed to lack any distinguishing features, yet Ori was finding it easy enough to divide them into different piles. "It's just wasteful to light the entire place when I'm only using a small part of it."

"What are you doing here, then?" It didn't seem much different from any of the other corners Fíli had just passed by. The one shelf he could see was somewhat askew, drag marks on the floor where the heavy weight had been shifted, but aside from that he saw no difference from any of the other spots Ori could have chosen. It seemed the shelf had been mostly emptied out, its contents doubtless now surrounding Ori on the floor.

"These are all old maps of Erebor." Ori waved his arm at the scrolls he had gathered. "Sure, we need to check everything for structural damage before they can be taken into use, but it would help prioritise the different areas if we had more accurate documents of where everything was. Right now we're going by the memories of those who lived here before the worm, and it's not always entirely reliable, especially when we're trying to figure out where to find a particular space behind a collapsed wall or the like."

"Okay, that does sound sensible at least." Fíli paused. Whatever people might have said, he wasn't entirely without manners or consideration. Well, not as much so as Kíli was, anyway. "Should I leave you to it?"

"Ah. I don't mind if you're here, really. I just can't promise to be very good company." Ori ducked his head for a moment, tugging at one of his braids in what Fíli supposed was embarrassment.

"I just need someone to listen, if that's not distracting you or anything." Fíli waited for Ori to nod before he went on. "So did you know Bilbo's actually male?"

Ori looked up at him, surprised. "He is?"

"Yeah. Kíli and me went to offer some dresses we found in our mother's old room, and he told us he wouldn't wear them because he's not a lady hobbit. Then we thought he was still pretending, but apparently he's actually, really male. So there we were, arms full of pretty dresses and having been mistaken about our hobbit."

"Ouch." Ori made a face, eyes falling back to his work. "That's, ah. Kind of embarrassing."

"You're telling me." Fíli sighed, rubbing the back of his neck. "Bilbo suggested taking the dresses to some young dwarf lasses arriving to the mountain, so I took them all to Dori. I mean, he's a dressmaker so he'll hear about anyone in need of clothes, and I figure he can decide who need them the most."

"Dori is good at those things, yes." Ori smiled at the thought of his brother. "Kíli didn't help you?"

"Nah, I think he went off to find Tauriel. Or maybe work on his gift and sulk. Wouldn't blame him, really; he's dealt a lot with people mistaking his sex because the ones with weaker beards are usually lasses." He noticed Ori now stroking in a hesitant manner his own wispy beard, and hurried to add, "You don't look like a lass at all! And look at your brothers; you'll probably have a magnificent beard in no time at all. Poor Kíli only has me to look at, and mine's really not very long for my age." Though his moustache was really coming in nicely.

"I don't think there's anything wrong with your beard." Ori's cheeks were still slightly flushed, so Fíli must have embarrassed him. A change of subject might be in order.

"Oh, damn. I wonder how hobbits are about same-sex couples." And now that he thought about it, that was a worrying idea. "I mean, most Men are really opposed to that sort of thing, right? What if hobbits are the same? That'd mean Uncle Thorin has no chance at all if Bilbo's actually male."

"Do you think so?" Ori frowned, though his eyes remained on the scrolls he was going through, sometimes setting them in one pile or another without even opening them for a look. "I'm sure I've sometimes seen him watching Thorin with interest."

"But what if he thinks Thorin is female? I mean, his beard isn't very long, and Bilbo said himself he's not sure he could tell dwarf lads from the lasses." No, that couldn't be. It would be so unfair for Thorin to get his heart broken over something so trivial. "Is there any way we can find out what Bilbo thinks of that without making it too obvious?"

"Well, we could just wait and see how he reacts to a couple he knows to be same-sex, but if he can't tell the difference with dwarves, he wouldn't really know unless it's someone he knows personally." Ori paused, his hand hovering over one scroll. "Wait. I think I have an idea."

"You do?" Fíli perked up. "What is it?"

"I'll tell you if it works. Maybe. It… kind of involves other stuff I'm not supposed to spread around." Ori's cheeks flushed again, and he scooped up one of the smaller piles of scrolls. "Ah. I think I'll take these to Bofur now, and then try and find Bilbo."

"He said he wanted to speak with Uncle, but I don't know how that would take. Probably not so long, if he just wanted to tell him how very rude we were." Fíli sighed. Wasn't that going to be a fun conversation. "You need help with gathering those up?" He gestured toward the rest of the piles.

"Oh, no, I'll get back to them later. Nobody's going to come here, anyway." Ori went around, blowing out most of the candles, leaving only one in a candlestick that he grabbed and handed to Fíli. "Hold this for a second, will you?"

Fíli did as requested, bemused. One arm still holding the scrolls close, Ori set his now free hand on the edge of the shelf Fíli had noticed before as being somewhat askew. In one push, Ori shifted the large stone shelving back to its proper position, then took the candle back from Fíli as though he hadn't just done something Fíli wasn't sure he could have managed even if he'd had his brother to help.

"Coming?"

Fíli hurried after Ori as he carried the light out of the library, pausing only once to test his hand against a similar, mostly empty shelf. As he had expected, he got it to budge with some effort, though just barely. Well. Clearly Dori's famous strength was something that ran in the family.

And here he had thought he had been watching the little scribe very closely.