Chapter Text
For a king, Thorin was not always easy to find.
It was simple enough when he held a court day, or when he was scheduled to meet with his council. The rest of the time, though it sometimes took some guesswork. There were times when he was walking around Erebor, inspecting the mines or living quarters that were still being cleared for use, making decisions on where to extend the cleaning and repair efforts. Other times he was meeting with various important people, sometimes even venturing out into Dale, which to Bilbo didn't seem like a particularly large effort on his part, given the short distance between the two cities, but seemed to amaze the dwarves enough to have them murmuring about it whenever it happened. And sometimes, when there was paperwork that could not be avoided or he simply required a moment of peace, he would retire to his office.
Luckily for Bilbo, he had chosen the last option today, holed up behind closed doors after the court hours were over. Had he simply thought of something to discuss, he might have waited until later in the evening when Thorin's location was somewhat more predictable, but Bombur had asked him to deliver a quick meal to the king as Thorin had apparently neglected to eat his lunch. This, of course, was an utter crime, a fact that Bilbo and Bombur rather agreed on, yet they knew it to be all too ordinary; Thorin seemed to be of the obviously mistaken opinion that food was secondary to whatever dusty document he was poring over at any given time. Bombur was too busy in the kitchens, though, and despaired of the effectiveness of sending one of his already too few helpers along with a tray, knowing they would not get Thorin to eat if he decided it could wait. Even most of the Company would not have insisted, Bilbo suspected, with the possible exception of Fíli and Kíli, and they surely had better things to do than play babysitter for a grown dwarf. Not that Bilbo thought Thorin was a child, but he was somewhat reminded of toddlers protesting at the food offered.
Bilbo, however, had no such reservations, and had by now more than gotten over his hesitation of entering Thorin's office. There was no guard, and no lock at the door, and if Thorin had told him to take this as a sign it was all right to enter he could only blame himself if Bilbo did just that.
"Thorin?" Bilbo peeked in through the door, balancing the tray on one hand as he pushed the door open. "I brought some food for you."
Thorin blinked, looking up from some papers. "Food?"
"Yes. It's not quite yet dinner time, but you did not have lunch at all, and Bombur wanted me to make sure you actually eat something." Bilbo walked into the room. It was sparsely decorated, but Thorin insisted it had everything he needed, which Bilbo supposed was true enough. There was a nice, sturdy desk that Bilbo rather envied, along with a couple of chairs and a bookshelf that was still mostly empty. The desk, in comparison, was usually full of notes and documents. It shouldn't have surprised Bilbo, really, given the size of the contract they had presented him with, but somehow he had not imagined Thorin getting swamped in paperwork. However, from what he had seen so far, this was indeed the truth of a king's typical day when he could not escape to other duties.
"You make it sound like I'm not feeding myself."
"Yes, well, from what I have heard, you are less than consistent about that." Bilbo somehow managed to find clear enough a corner on the desk to set down the tray. "Please. It won't take up that much of your time, and you will have more energy to actually focus on your work."
"You're not going to give up either way, are you?" Thorin sighed. "Very well. I'll eat the meal."
"Good." Bilbo settled down in the free chair, making himself comfortable. "Because I plan to make sure you do so."
For a moment, Thorin simply stared at him, then sighed again, pulling the tray closer. "Somehow, I'm not surprised that you do."
"I'm a hobbit. We take our food quite seriously." Bilbo curled up in the chair as he watched Thorin starting to eat.
"So I have come to notice." Despite his wry words, Thorin actually turned to the food, which Bilbo took as a good sign.
As luck would have it, the project of feeding Thorin was interrupted as Ori arrived, looking somewhat rushed. "Ah… Your Majesty? I mean, Thorin?" He gave a little bow, rushing toward Thorin's desk. "We just received a raven from Ered Luin."
"Really?" Thorin frowned, pausing in his eating. "A letter, then? Since you did not bring the raven with you." Bilbo still wasn't entirely sure how the raven thing worked. He knew Thorin and some other dwarves of Durin's line could speak directly with the ravens of Erebor, yet sometimes they preferred to write letters for the birds to carry. According to Kíli, this was because the birds could not always be bothered to pass along all the details of a long message, but Bilbo wasn't sure if this was the truth or just Kíli's own theory.
"Precisely." Ori pulled a folded piece of paper from his sleeve. "It looks like Glóin's handwriting."
"Indeed." Thorin unfolded the paper on his desk, continuing to eat as he started to read. Soon, though, he paused, then looked at Bilbo. "Master Baggins. I believe this concerns you."
"Oh?" Bilbo frowned. "What is it?" From their last report, Glóin's small group had been well on their way, and had not expected to send another word before they reached their destination. He certainly could not imagine what word would come for him from the Blue Mountains.
"Apparently, Glóin stopped by Hobbiton to see if he might find some clothes and such to bring to you, for when you make your journey back." Thorin sighed. "It seems some of your relatives had announced you dead and taken over your house."
"What?" Bilbo could feel himself paling. "They took Bag End?"
"It's worse than just that, I'm afraid. From what they could get out of the hobbits, before they moved in, most of your belongings were auctioned off all around the place."
It was a good thing he was already sitting, or he might have fallen down. "No."
Thorin gave him a grave look. "Glóin scared them out of the house and made sure they didn't carry away anything that he recognised as belonging to you, but at the end of it there was very little remaining in Bag End." Thorin shook his head. "They left one of their warriors to sit in your house for the moment to make sure none try to take it over again. Glóin told your family that when they return from Ered Luin he would be expecting either the return of all your belongings or the full sum they were sold for, but he doubts he will ever get all of it, and I have to agree. Any who would sell out hope of a kin for their own selfish greed will not be honourable in repaying their debts."
Thorin's words registered somewhere, but Bilbo couldn't focus on it much. The thought of having his things sold off made him feel faint. Not just his belongings, either, but everything his parents had left behind. The doilies and the china and the chairs and the table, and the silverware, Lobelia was sure to have taken the silverware his mother had so carefully polished time and time again. And the drawings his father had made while he was still just planning Bag End, and the few pieces of his mother's jewelry he'd had left, and all the books and the furniture and the paintings and —
"Bilbo?" He looked up, and found Thorin looking at him expectantly. "What do you want them to do about this?"
"You shouldn't bother —" Bilbo started, but never got any further.
"Don't you dare say we don't have to do anything," Thorin cut him off. "None of this would have happened if we had not dragged you off without a warning or time to prepare. Obviously we cannot give you back everything that was lost, but our honour binds us to do all that is in our power to lessen your grief."
"Even so. I wouldn't want to hinder them on their way home at last." Even if the price of that was the loss of his own.
"Nonsense. I'm sure my sister will take great pleasure in administering some righteous justice herself, and Glóin will do everything he can to help. As I'm sure you have noticed, we dwarves do not take well to thieves, certainly not such honourless ones."
"…Right." Bilbo took a deep breath, trying to gather his thoughts, scattered by the shock as they are. "Ah. If we sent word now, would it reach them before they pass Hobbiton again?"
"Certainly. The ravens fly fast, and will get there in plenty of time. Just say what word you want sent, and we will do it." Thorin glanced at Ori, who nodded in agreement, already reaching for writing supplies on the messy desk.
"Ah. Tell them that I will be staying in Erebor for the foreseeable future. Anything of mine that can be regained, including Bag End itself, is to be put in the care of my cousin Drogo," Bilbo said, speaking slowly as he sorted through his thoughts. Drogo was one of his favourite relatives, and a young hobbit could certainly use a comfortable start to life. "He's to use them as his own, money and objects alike, until I return." If he returned. Perhaps one day he would be brave enough to do that, but right now the mere idea of walking into Bag End and finding empty rooms and bare walls caused almost a physical ache.
"As you wish." Thorin nodded solemnly, while Ori was busy scratching down the angular runes. "Anything else?"
"Please have them ask Drogo to keep employing the Gamgees for the garden. They have been loyal to my family for many long years, and I'm sure they'll do the same for Drogo." Bilbo drew a deep breath. "Also, if — if they can salvage any of my writings, or my writing supplies, please ask them to bring them along." Though he doubted the Sackville-Bagginses would have hesitated for a moment before turning all his precious notes and drawings into glorified kindling. "And my parents' portraits, if they remain."
"We'll pass the word along." Thorin wore his most serious and kingly expression, as though this had been a matter of the state instead of the homely happiness of one little hobbit. "Of course, if there is anything you need us to get for you, just tell us. We owe you full compensation for the losses you have suffered because of us."
"I'm fairly sure that was not specified anywhere in our contract," Bilbo murmured. "And besides, my reward was long since chosen and spent."
"Don't be ridiculous, burglar. I've told you before not to mind the ire of my madness, and I tire of telling you so again." Thorin shook his head. "As long as you stand under the mountain, you will not need for anything, you have my word on that."
"I... thank you, really. But if they can't get back my parents' things, there's really not much I need beyond some clothes and writing things." Not that he had much need of those, either, as long as he didn't mind wearing dwarven designs. Perhaps once Dale was further along in its rebuilding he should ask Thorin for some coin to purchase fabric and hire a seamstress to make him something more suitable for a respectable hobbit. For now, though, he could well make do with Frerin's old clothes, and besides he didn't want to seem ungrateful by casting them aside so soon after receiving them.
"Nevertheless. If there is anything you need, just tell anyone in the Company to pass the word, or ask for coin to purchase it yourself where you wish. You are owed a fair share of the treasure, and I will see to it that you get it."
"I rather thought I was using my share to help the rebuilding of Dale."
"And I disagree. There is gold enough to rebuild both Dale and Erebor several times over, and yet enough left for each in the Company to live in comfort for the rest of their lives. Do you truly think us so cruel as to deny you your part?"
"I told you myself that the Arkenstone was my share."
"And you gave it away, so obviously you were not happy with it." Thorin sighed, a look of exasperation on his face. "Master Baggins, we dwarves are known to be stubborn creatures, but I think you might have a claim to challenge that. Even so, I plan to stand firm as long as I need to in order to convince you of your folly."
"He is right, you know," Ori piped up, though he became somewhat flustered as both Thorin and Bilbo turned to look at him. "Uh... I mean... what I meant to say is, nobody wants to see you go without. You helped us get the mountain back. It'd be a shame on all of Erebor if you didn't have everything you needed as long as you are our guest."
"Precisely," Thorin agreed. "And you are welcome to stay as long as you see fit. If you'd rather not accept all that as your due, I'm sure we can find something for you to do once you have fully recovered."
"I'm more than well enough to do my part already," Bilbo argued, somewhat relieved at this slight turn of events. "I don't even need the pain remedy now, unless I have a particularly bad day. I'm not strong enough for anything very physical, but then, I'm pretty sure there is no way I could accomplish dwarvish work anyway. But if there's some small way I could help, I would be happy to."
"Good thing, then, that I have just the appointment in mind. And one that won't be too taxing on you during your recovery, either." There was a somewhat worrying look in Thorin's eyes. Bilbo was not sure he liked it very much.
"Right. And what would that be?"
"Ori." Thorin glanced at the young dwarf again. "If you are done with the letter, would you take another note?"
"Yes, of course." Ori hurried to write off the last few runes, then set the letter aside to dry, reaching for another piece of paper. "What shall it concern?"
"An official appointment, as it happens. I'm sure you will know how to word it, seeing as you helped Balin create your own." Yes, definitely a worrying look. "Make it known that on this day, I appoint Bilbo Baggins of the Shire to sit in my royal council until further notice, with all the duties and rights thereof."
"Thorin!" Bilbo exclaimed. "You cannot do that!"
"I think you will find that, as the king of this mountain, I can do precisely that." Thorin gave him an innocent look. It was not very convincing. "Worry not, I will not expect many duties of you. All I want is someone who will actually take my side in the discussion with the elders."
"And what do you think they will say?" That, at least, had to be taken into consideration. "They're not going to accept me into the council, I'm sure."
"Then they will change their minds by the time I'm through with them." Thorin's expression turned firm. "You've done more for the mountain than any of them ever did, and I will make sure they know it if any of them even dream of protesting."
"And if they turn it against you?" Because that was something that worried him. Besides the whole awful business where he was supposed to play the part of a royal adviser. "Say that you are unfit for a king because you make such un-dwarvish appointments?"
"In that I expect you to take my side, Master Hobbit, whatever you may think of my decisions in private." Thorin gave him a smirk. "After all, someone has to stick close to me to make sure I get enough to eat."
Bilbo could hardly even believe he was almost regretting the act of bringing someone food, but he had to admit it was close to happening.
*
"So." Balin was smiling, just barely, as he eyed Bilbo from where he was standing by the door to the council room. "Are you ready, Master Baggins?"
"Honestly? Not one bit." Bilbo shook his head, straightening himself. "But I don't suppose I have much of a choice, now do I?"
"Not really, no." Balin chuckled. "Unfortunate though it may be, I find our king is rather hard to convince otherwise once he has his mind set on something."
"Careful, old friend. I might think you are being disrespectful." Thorin walked up to them, looking every bit the king he was in his formal robes and crown. Bilbo wasn't sure why he seemed to dress in more formal attire for the council meetings than he often did for the general court, but then he supposed these people were less likely to be impressed than the average dwarf coming to the king with his grievances. "Though I'm sure you mean no such thing, now do you?"
"Wouldn't dream of it, Your Majesty." Balin's smirk said otherwise, though Bilbo knew he would keep any lack of respect to private settings rather than airing such things before the council. "I must say, Master Baggins, for someone with little in the way of beard, you look rather well turned out for the council."
"I, ah, I try." He was wearing the best set of the dwarven clothes Dori had adjusted for him, and given that they had once belonged to a prince, he had been assured they would be more than adequate for the meeting. The trousers were a bit too long for his liking, and the coat a bit too heavy, but then the mountain was not quite as merciful in its climate as his hole in the Shire, even as more of the grand forges were lit up every few weeks to radiate their warmth into the rest of the mountain. "Are you sure this is part of formal wear, though?" He tapped his fingertips against the hilt of Sting, securely on his belt. Sure, Thorin was bearing Orcrist, but then Thorin at least looked like he was supposed to have such a thing. For Bilbo, all it would accomplish was surely to make him look ridiculous.
"Well, of course. How else do you suppose you would respond if someone were to challenge you to a duel?"
"What?" Bilbo very nearly choked on his own tongue. A duel? Wasn't this supposed to be a council meeting, not a battle?
"Aye, in the olden times, most disagreements would have been settled with blades, though these days we rather prefer words. Now don't look like that, burglar." Thorin's hand on his shoulder should not have felt as comforting as it did, not when he was speaking such nonsense. "The tradition is rarely observed, and even if it were to happen, you hereby have my permission to request me as a champion. No sensible dwarf will think any less of you for it; even among our people, some are more trained in battle than others."
"Yes, well, it's not exactly the sensible dwarves that I'm worried about." Sensible dwarves he could deal with, and even some of the less sensible ones, a number that most certainly included Thorin. It was the other ones, the dwarves who looked at him askance for merely daring to walk inside the mountain, who worried him.
"Well, if they refuse to be sensible, that just makes it all the easier for me to decide where to start when I want a few seats opened." Thorin shook his head. "No one will harm you here, Master Hobbit, save if you let their words wound you. And knowing you as I do, I rather think you would be the victor of any such battle."
"I, ah, I hope so." It was all he could do, in any case. "So, shouldn't we go in?"
"Certainly, if you are ready." And, before Bilbo had any time to take back his earlier words, Thorin opened the door and marched in, leaving Bilbo and Balin trailing behind him.
Most of the council was already gathered, though he supposed that was just to be expected. After all, Thorin's arrival heralded the beginning of the meeting, so all had to be prepared. Bilbo quickly followed Balin to a couple of empty seats as the rest of the council rose up to bow to Thorin. Somehow they still had the time to give sideways glances to Bilbo, and few looked approving.
Well. Disapproval at social gatherings was nothing he hadn't faced before. He'd just have to pretend they were particularly unpleasant relatives, and he would be fine.
He did have a few friendly faces to fall back on, in any case, even aside from Balin's calming presence at his side and Thorin's majestic figure at the head of the table. Fíli was seated next to Thorin, giving him a quick grin, and though neither Dwalin standing to the side on guard duty nor Ori seated next to him with his scribe's equipment got quite that familiar, Bilbo found their presence rather soothing nevertheless.
Honestly, it would have all been fine if one of the dwarves hadn't apparently decided that Bilbo's presence ought to be the main topic of the day.
"Now, we have heard the formal assignment, and I would not dream of questioning the decisions of the King," though it sounded an awful lot like that was precisely what he was trying to do, "but I must ask, is this… hobbit… truly the best choice for the council?" Somehow, the dwarf managed to say "hobbit" in much the same tones most dwarves seemed to reserve for "orc". Or possibly "elf". It was hard to say how much of the distaste in his voice was due to his race and how much was just personal dislike, after all, so it wasn't all that easy to judge.
"It is my belief that Master Baggins will be most accomplished indeed in his task." Thorin was perfectly calm and collected, the perfect king as always, and by his side Fíli was smiling the bland smile that Bilbo knew by now to be his way of masking an angry frown. "Would you like to offer some reason as to why this should not be?"
"Well, for one thing, he is quite obviously not a dwarf." Another member, now, looking as though he had just smelled something particularly foul. "I know you have introduced some… changes… to the customs of the mountain, but surely the council room ought to be a place reserved for our own people alone, if nothing else?"
"Master Baggins is one of the Company, and as such, has as much if not more claim to this mountain as anyone else gathered here today." A deliberate jab toward all the people who had failed to answer his call for help, and one that did not go unnoticed, if the uncomfortable expressions around the table were anything to go by. "He has stood by me through all the hardships of our journey, and provided me with invaluable counsel. I believe I would be foolish indeed to abandon his words now that we have won back our rightful place." Of course, Thorin had failed to listen to most of his advice, but pointing that out here would have been quite counterproductive.
"Even so!" And yet another one protested, now. "How important could he have been during your quest, anyway? It's not like he could even fight by your side with that little knife of his!"
Now, Thorin frowned. "I'll thank you to refrain from passing judgement on matters on which you have no knowledge."
Clearly, this was the point where Bilbo was to step in, as evidenced by the several voiced raised at once. He cleared his throat, first politely, then louder, until at least most of them had settled down, letting him speak without needing to shout.
"No, no. It's all true, isn't it? My little knife is woefully small and not very threatening at all. Nothing like the great big axes these grand warriors are bearing, which I'm sure have inspired many a grand tale of battle and honour." He gestured towards the loudest protester, who immediately started preening at the praise for his indeed rather impressive axe. Dangerously stupid or dangerously proud, then, and either possibility surely required a bit of a letdown.
"Your knife is not exactly without tales, though." Perhaps Thorin had caught on; perhaps he was simply being polite. Either way, it served Bilbo's goals quite well.
"Oh, you must be joking, my dear friend. After all, there is so very little I have done with it." He gave the council his best innocent smile, that of a hobbit who was simply looking around at all these wonderful, polite people he was having the pleasure of meeting today. "I have only killed some Mirkwood spiders with it, and born it into battle against the Defiler in defence of my king and come through on the other side. The Battle of the Five Armies is certainly its greatest triumph so far, and even there I hardly did anything any proper dwarf would not have done, had they been granted the chance to aid their king against that dreadful pale orc." Bilbo sniffed. "It hardly even did me any good against the dragon. I am certain any of the grand warriors here can claim much more impressive triumphs with their own blades."
"Oh, I am certain that is true." Fíli's grin took on a rather gleeful edge. "I must say, much to my regret, I know very little of the esteemed warriors gathered here today. Surely there are many tales of valour they could offer up for my education, ones more magnificent than Bilbo's accomplishments, as you have now heard them?"
"Ah. Right." One of the earlier protesters cleared his throat. "Perhaps we ought to turn to more urgent matters?"
"I do quite agree." Thorin's lips twitched almost imperceptibly, which for him was a rather obvious sign of amusement. "Shall we proceed to the actual issues, then?"
Bilbo wasn't sure what he had imagined a council meeting to be like. Long and tedious, perhaps, judging by the way Thorin and Fíli often spoke of it. He wasn't even too surprised to find arguments cropping up, given what he knew of the nature of dwarves; putting a bunch of such stubborn people together and expecting them to reach an agreement without any conflict was a doomed wish from the start. What he hadn't been quite as prepared for, though, was the volume at which these arguments took place. It seemed everyone was determined to get their own viewpoint out, and planned to do so by being the loudest one to offer one, or by being louder than the person they disagreed with. He supposed it was more civilised than actual armed duels, but only just barely. What was more, while Thorin could silence everyone with one well-timed shout, he seemed to prefer not to do that too often, letting the arguments go on for a while before he interfered. Bilbo supposed it was sensible, as at that point they were more likely to agree to whatever Thorin said simply because it was not what that insufferable orc-dropping sitting opposite to them had suggested, but it did get rather taxing on his ears.
At the moment the discussion about the new mine shafts was growing louder, long since past what Bilbo would have considered to be polite tones. Far as he could tell, the council was somewhat unclear on what kind of information was at hand and how reliable it was, which obviously meant everyone presumed their own knowledge to be the only correct kind. Thorin was leaning back in his seat, looking utterly uninterested in anything being said, while Fíli had actually taken out a knife and was cleaning his nails with it. Bilbo would have frowned at him for doing so, knowing better than to openly scold the crown prince in front of the council, but frankly he couldn't blame the lad. The dwarf seated next to him had a bad habit of waving his arms as he talked, and had very nearly hit Fíli in the face at a heated point of the previous argument. Now, the knife seemed to make him keep his distance at least.
Ori was saying something in the background, though Bilbo could not make out the words over the general din. The poor boy had set aside his equipment some time ago; it would have been quite useless for him to try to take any notes when even Bilbo, seated at the table as he was, could not make out more than a word here or there. After another attempt or two at making himself heard, Ori stood up and stepped to Dwalin, speaking to him instead.
Dwalin said something in return, but Bilbo's attempts at reading his lips were distracted by a particularly loud argument right next to him as an elderly dwarf with numerous scars on every visible part of his body declared that plans were for cowards. Before Bilbo or anyone else could even begin to address the flaws of such an approach to mining of all things, though, a loud, sharp crack cut through all the noise, leaving everyone silent for once.
Thorin had half risen from his seat, everyone else looking around for the cause of this disturbance. With a tiny flush, doubtless of embarrassment, Ori lifted one of Dwalin's hammers from where it had just neatly broken the large stone table in half, lifting it over his shoulder with one hand as Bilbo might have done with a nice, light walking stick. "Ah. I do apologise for the interruption, but if I might say something?"
Bilbo rather suspected many of the dwarves around the table would have rather protested at a mere scribe speaking up, but at least none of them were quite so foolish or rash as to say that when said scribe apparently had no more trouble with handling a big war hammer than he would have with a quill. Thorin, though, showed no surprise whatsoever, merely nodding at Ori. "Speak."
"I have been working with Master Bofur to prepare a thorough map of the mines; it's going rather slow, though, for reasons we can't help. The miners are charting everything as they inspect the tunnels and shafts for structural damage, but their numbers are yet few, and most of them are needed to actually work in the secure areas. Furthermore, they are not exactly educated in such tasks, so what notes they take are rather without use for anyone else." The poor lad seemed quite flustered, now, clutching the handle of the hammer as though for comfort. Nobody was interrupting him, though. "We are comparing everything with the old maps, but a lot of the old documents have been destroyed or at least require restoration, and, well, the only trained scribes in the mountain right now are Master Balin and myself, and I'm only a journeyman, still. And, ah, we are rather busy with a lot of other things. So the miners do know what's in the tunnels they are working in, but it's going to take a while to put all that together in a form that would be understandable for anyone who isn't familiar with the miners' script."
"I would be happy to help you with that task," Bilbo said as everyone else still seemed a bit too shocked to respond. "I may not be a Master scribe," had no formal education in the art, in fact, but there was no reason to say that aloud now was there, "but I do think I could be of some help."
"An excellent suggestion, I'm sure." Thorin nodded, as calm as though this had been a perfectly normal, civil discussion that had at no point involved yelling or cracking tables. "This is precisely why I have chosen to leave the decision of primary targets to the discretion of the miners' guild. They are best informed at present, and until we have more of both miners and smiths in the mountain it is of no great urgency to direct them toward some particular vein or another."
"At least you might have taken greater care when assigning the master of the guild," grumbled someone. "I'm sure this Bofur character is a fine dwarf at his craft, but his other qualifications are rather lacking." Bofur was a guildmaster? Since when? Obviously Bilbo would have to scold him for not giving Bilbo the chance to congratulate him on such a matter.
"And what qualifications would he be lacking?" Thorin's eyes rose up high. "I am informed he was a perfectly qualified member of the guild back in Ered Luin, and has showed great proficiency in directing our yet small number of workers so far."
"Oh, surely he is more than proficient. However, there are other qualities one looks for in a leader," someone else pointed out. "He may be an excellent miner from Ered Luin, but that is yet all he is. He has no claim to a high lineage."
"This is true. Knowing his work is not enough; he has to be able to lead others, and a common dwarf would surely be far more comfortable in a position more suited to his low birth."
Bilbo bristled to hear such talk, especially as it seemed to be echoed around the table. Thorin, however, seemed to take it all in his stride.
"Ah, yes. This is a most sensible point, I agree." Then, before anyone could get too busy patting themselves on the back, Thorin turned toward one of the dwarves. "Master Karhu? I'm sure you'll be happy to step down from your position as Guildmaster."
"What?" The dwarf, a huge thing with arms as big around as Bilbo's entire body and then some, stared at Thorin in confusion. "Why would I do that?"
"Well, it seems our council agrees that the best qualification for a Guildmaster is their high birth, and no other factors ought to be considered. I am a Master blacksmith, as are you; surely you do not claim to have a more noble lineage than mine?"
"No, but —"
"And I recall we were talking of re-establishing the goldsmiths' guild soon enough. With this point brought to my attention, I'm sure we can all agree that prince Fíli is the best choice for the Guildmaster. And for the leatherworkers, there is prince Kíli, and Glóin son of Gróin for the merchants, and quite a few others I could name. Certainly, I would have thought we would all be quite too busy with other duties to bother with such things, but since you all seem to think noble blood is required for the position, it would be utterly irresponsible for me to do otherwise."
"But —" someone started, still, only to be silenced as Thorin brought his fist down on the table.
"Silence! Yes, I have appointed Master Bofur the head of his guild as a reward for his services, and also because I know he is more than capable of performing well in such a position. I reward loyalty and honour and courage, and if you all failed to answer my call, you only have yourselves to blame. Be thankful I consider other things as well, or none of you could hope to attain any such positions in my mountain, for I will not be served by any who are not loyal and none have proved their loyalty more than my Company. Bofur is not capable of performing his duties because he is not a noble? I will see to it that he is appointed Lord before the day is over, and if any of you complains it will be their title that he takes. And if anyone dares to question my appointments for no reason other than lineage being more important than honour and skill and accomplishment, I swear to Mahal, I will name Tauriel of Dale my Head of Guilds, for surely a future princess of Erebor is of far more importance than anyone you could name outside my own household."
This utterly outrageous threat seemed to silence everyone, so much so that the rest of the meeting passed by in relative peace, with Ori looking quite relieved to be back in his corner taking notes. Bilbo, for his part, had very little to say, until the meeting ended and he rushed to catch up with Fíli while Thorin and Balin stayed behind to discuss some further matters with a couple of the least bothersome dwarves.
"Is it always like this?" he hissed to Fíli as he fell into step beside the prince, hurrying his steps to match his long strides.
"This chaotic? Not quite, though it does often get loud. I think they were more confrontational than usual because they were annoyed about your appointment." Fíli chuckled. "They might actually be relatively calm the next meeting or two. They usually are after Uncle bursts out like this, until they forget again."
"That, um. That thing Ori did, with the hammer. Is that a normal occurrence?" Because if so, he honestly wasn't sure his heart could take too many of these meetings.
"Oh, the bit where he cracked the table?" Fíli's face broke out into a grin. "No, that was very irregular indeed. Don't think I've seen anything like that before, and definitely not from Ori. Dori's going to be so proud when he hears about this."
"Right." Dwarves. He was never going to understand them. "And that, ah, threat Thorin made?"
"About appointing Tauriel Head of Guilds?" Fíli shrugged. "I doubt it'll come to be, not any time soon, anyway; he's made his point, and they wouldn't dare question it. If anyone was stupid enough to do so, though, I think he'd go through with it. Thorin doesn't make idle threats, and believe me, he'd sooner see Tauriel leading the guilds of Erebor than some Iron Hills puppet."
"I see." No, he did not, but he could at least imagine. "So Bofur is a Guildmaster, now? Has he given such appointments to many members of the Company?"
"Most of them, I think, either now or as promises of when we have more people." Another shrug. "Bombur's in charge of the kitchens, and that makes him happy enough, and I think Bifur wanted to work with Bofur rather than have some grand position of his own, but pretty much all the rest of us have some title or another. Óin will surely be the Guildmaster of healers, just as Balin will be of the scribes' guild, once we have enough of either to gather an actual guild, and Glóin's set to be royal treasurer as soon as he gets back. Dori's going to lead the dressmakers, and though nobody will admit it I'm pretty sure Nori's the spymaster. Dwalin's the captain of the guards, of course, and as for Ori, well, he's not yet finished his masterpiece and he's already the head scribe to the king. I don't think any of those please the Iron Hills idiots, except perhaps Ori because some of them don't understand just how important a scribe is, but all the others are at least distantly related to us so it's not so easy to make an argument against them. Of course, I think Thorin was actually serious about giving Bofur a noble title of some sort, if only to annoy everyone who would be against it."
"Right." And he hadn't known about any of this. Well, he had known about Ori, and Bombur, and had known everyone else was busy working on their craft in one manner or another, but he hadn't realised just how grand and important they had become. "I suppose it's just as well that I don't have an actual craft; goodness knows what they'd say if Thorin tried to give some such position to me." It was obviously scandalous enough that he was part of the council.
Now, Fíli halted, turning to look at him. As Bilbo looked back, confused, Fíli shook his head, smiling. "You actually don't know, do you?"
"Know what?" Yes, definitely confused.
"When you came in, there were two seats left beside Thorin's. And you took the seat that Balin didn't, right? The one next to him, one further from Thorin?"
"Well, obviously." What, should he perhaps have remained standing?
"The seat to the right of Thorin is mine, as his foremost heir. If Kíli were there, he'd be the next one from me, but after that the seats on the right have no particular significance. Balin sits to his left, as his head adviser; if both Thorin and I were away, and Kíli couldn't fill in for whatever reason, Balin would be the one to lead the meeting." He waited a moment, perhaps for Bilbo to digest this information. "The thing is, on the left hand side, it's not only the first seat that bears meaning."
Bilbo's eyes widened. "You don't mean…"
"Thorin didn't just give you any seat on his council, Master Hobbit, nor was he just placating the idiots when he said he values your advice. You are now second of his advisers, which is no trifling matter, and Thorin is as aware of that as any dwarf present today." Fíli patted him on the shoulder, smiling at his shock. "At least now you can rightfully join Balin in his complaints that Thorin never listens to sense, hmm?"
Well. Clearly Thorin was lacking in sense for doing such a thing in the first place.
Bilbo, meanwhile, needed a big cup of hot tea and a long while of silence, until either his ears stopped ringing or things started making sense.
Dwarves. What could a poor little hobbit do with them?
*
It was around the third time that Kíli lost hold of one of the strands that Balin sighed, shook his head, and got up from his desk.
"Honestly, laddie, by your age you should know how to do a simple braid."
"It's not my fault my hair's really bad for this." Kíli sighed, dropping his hands as Balin took over, starting by unravelling what little progress he had made. "And I can braid! I put my braids in Tauriel's hair! It's just doing it backwards that's difficult."
"Your hair's not that different from Thorin's or Fíli's, and they manage well enough." Balin shook his head. "And doing it for yourself is just a matter of practice. If you hadn't fought against it for so long, you'd have no trouble now."
"Easy for you to say." Kíli resisted the urge to huff like a child, but he did cross his arms over his chest. "You never wear any braids."
"That is true." Well, at least he had no trouble admitting his hypocrisy. "However, if I were to take to courting someone, or indeed to appearing in public in a more formal role than I do now, I'd make sure to put in the proper braids, in my beard if my hair could not handle them."
"Yeah, well, I've managed well enough until now." Balin himself would have smacked him upside the head a long time ago if it had been all that necessary.
"Your position was quite different before." Balin tsked, tugging at his hair just a bit too hard. "Before, you were the prince to an exiled king, and not a fully grown one at that. Now, you are a grown dwarf expected to represent his kingdom and his line, and it won't do for you to run around as you please."
"Let me guess. I should also try really hard to grow a proper beard?" That certainly seemed to draw more attention than his lack of braids, or at least more comments.
"Don't be ridiculous. There's nothing you can do to help that matter one way or another, whatever some foolish ones might say. Your braids, though, are a matter of will rather than nature, so there you have no excuse."
"It's not like people are going to forget who I am just because I don't have the right braid or whatever." Kíli sighed. "Isn't it enough that I wear the courtship braids?" At least for those nobody was going to make fun of him if Tauriel was the one to weave them in his hair instead of his own hand. Well, except to titter at how sappy he was being, but that was an accusation he did not mind in the slightest.
"When you are out and about? Aye, I suppose so. However, for formal court, you ought to be making more of an effort. And, Maker have mercy, your uncle seems to have decided it's up to me to make you learn." Balin gave another sharp tug, one that Kíli was sure would be blamed on tightening the braid. "Why he thinks it a good use of my time, I'll never understand."
"Uh, because you've been the one to teach us about court etiquette in general?" Which Kíli was doing his best to learn, really he was. Sure, it was sometimes troublesome to remember all the rules and customs and whatnot, but he did try his best to behave as he ought to in formal situations.
He was causing enough conflict as it was by his choice of a partner. He didn't want to cause either Thorin or Fíli any more grief if he could help it.
"Aye, I suppose there is that." Balin chuckled, a faint sound but nevertheless there. "I've got to say, I'm quite pleased with your progress these last few months. Truly, I might have done better to not bother with any instruction before we came to Erebor, seeing how you now seem determined to make up for all the learning you have neglected before."
"Now you just make it sound like I never learnt a thing until we came to the mountain." Which just wasn't true, at all. He'd learnt a lot of things, even some regarding his position as a prince. It just wasn't until recently that he'd found much meaning in following those instructions.
"Ah, but I can only comment on what I see. And if you were acting like a brat before, then I see no reason to lie about that fact."
"Let's be honest, now. I still act like a brat sometimes, I just try not to do it when I'm forced to stand in court for whatever reason." Kíli gave a deep sigh. "I don't envy poor Fíli one bit. I'd go crazy if I had to do his job." It was bad enough handling all his own duties without having to act like a proper prince all that time.
"Perhaps it's for the best that he is the crown prince, then." Balin clicked his tongue. "Your brother is a fine prince, and will make a fine king some day, though I hope that is yet a long time in coming. Though you aren't as bad as I might have feared, seeing you grow up."
"Careful, I might try to twist that into a compliment of some sort."
"It might be one, though a backhanded one, I'll admit that much." Balin's deft fingers finished up the braid, offering it up to him. "Here. I trust you can at least secure it by yourself."
"Are you sure you should be doing that? Surely praising me will just cause me to get a big head." Okay. Securing a braid. He could do this, really he could. Though since apparently leather strips were not suitable for court attire, he'd have to do it with a bead, and doing that neatly was still something he needed to practice — which was undoubtedly why Balin had left it for him to do.
"Perhaps, perhaps not. I'll just have to trust your lady to keep you down to the ground. And in any case, I don't have to worry about ever fitting your head into a crown." Balin stepped away, watching his struggle with the bead with idle interest. "You weren't a week old when I first met you, you know. An awfully small thing, you were, for all that your mother would have skewered me for saying that where she could hear. And I must say, you've grown up a rather fine lad, and if I've had any hand in how you turned out, then I'll take pride in that little part. For all that you still have a lot to learn yet, it's all things that anyone can commit to memory, if only they have the right books or instructors. Etiquette and neat braids and all that is fine enough, and make no mistake, I won't count myself accomplished until you have it all down without flaw, but what you and your brother do have is a thousand times more precious to see in a dwarf."
"Let me guess." Kíli offered a faint smile even as he tried his best to slide the bead onto the braid without leaving any stray strands sticking out every which way. "Loyalty, honour, and a willing heart?"
"Who, indeed, could ask more than that?" Balin shook his head, a gentle look in his eyes as Kíli glanced up at him. "I serve Thorin not because of his line or for any shining gem, but because I find him a king worth following. And if, through some strange whim of time or nature, I would still stand in these halls when your brother takes his throne with you by his side, it would be naught but an honour to serve his heirs instead."
"Now that would be weird to see." Kíli shook his head. "I mean, I know that technically I outrank you and all, but it's kind of hard to get my head around that after a lifetime of getting scolded by you or Dwalin for whatever I've done wrong."
"Perhaps it's time you get used to it. In these halls there are but two who stand above you, and any who forget that ought to be put to rights." Balin's lips twitched. "Though perhaps it's best you forget that every now and then, if only so we have some hope of keeping you in line."
"Didn't you just say I'm not a brat anymore? I'd say I'm being utterly sensible nowadays."
"Aye, of course you are. Running off on your own to dive for scales for your elf, now how could I ever think you were anything but wise?" The smile lingered, though, marking the words as nothing but tease.
"At least I know my heart, and can admit as much, and to the flames of the forge with what anyone else says. Can't say the same for certain others, even ones older than I am."
Balin's eyebrows rose high at that. "And are we talking of someone in specific?"
"I could name more than one, and I believe so could you." As though everyone didn't see it. Well, everyone close enough to see, in any case. "Honestly, both Thorin and Fíli are running out of excuses, and yet they both pretend to be blind and deaf. I'm rather tempted to start kicking them both around until they get their crowned little heads out of their hairy arses. Maybe that's just me thinking courtship is wonderful because I find I rather enjoy it, but it's getting to be tiring to watch."
"Perhaps they are simply considering things beyond their own desires."
"Oh, so that's it, now? About to lecture me on how I should have considered my position before entering such a scandalous relationship?" He was getting irrationally irritated now, and he knew it. Balin had personally defended his choice before the council, and he knew as much, but these were arguments he heard whispered around him all too often.
"I didn't say their reasons were good, just that they might have them." Balin shook his head. "Though I do agree, it is beginning to get quite tiresome. I was certain Thorin would give in once he saw our Master Hobbit was in no hurry to return to the west, anymore, yet he seems determined to ignore the matter."
"Guess it's useless to hope for Thorin to see sense." Kíli sighed, then gave a small cry of triumph as he finally got the bead put in properly, nice and neat and secure. "I'd talk to him myself, but I know he'll just deny it all. And I can't even get Fíli to agree with me, because he'll get on the defensive himself."
"Indeed." Balin sighed, though it was with the same slightly indulgent smile he often wore when they engaged in some of their more harmless antics. Kíli might have wondered if he had looked like that when Thorin was silly as a young dwarf, except it was hard to imagine Thorin being silly. Well, not in the way he and Fíli excelled at, in any case. Thorin certainly had his very own brand of ridiculousness that he stuck to with surprising vigour. "Perhaps there is something I could do to speed things along."
"Unlikely, especially since I doubt Bilbo would appreciate getting locked up in a small room until they've sorted things out, and I doubt anything less would do." Kíli let the braid fall from his hands. "So. How many more do I need to wear before I'm presentable?"
Sometimes, just sometimes, it would have been so much easier not to be a prince at all.
