Chapter Text
Bilbo couldn’t tell you the exact moment he’d fallen sick, when weariness turned into something unspeakable, but he could tell you the exact moment he’d known. Like all well-bred hobbits, he was a mild hypochondriac who viewed every sneeze as ominous portent of, if not death, then inconvenience just when he needed it least. Despite this gloomy cultural inheritance, Bilbo had never viewed illness with terror or dread; he considered it rather like another distant relation who made periodic claims. It probably wouldn’t kill Bilbo, but that didn’t mean he wanted it hanging around.
So somewhere in Erebor, about five months before the unwaking that prompted abduction and abdication, there was a journal in Bilbo’s rooms with an entry that read, “Guild luncheon a success tho damnedable headache the whole time. Begged off dinner to take nap instead.” The luncheon of the ascendant craftsmen of the Clockwork Guild had been the first time that Bilbo’s health had pressed so direly against him (while also indeed being a success, and several dwarves complimented Bilbo on the event in the week after, not that this detail is particularly relevant to this narrative, but no reason not to emphasize it). Bilbo had spent half the luncheon propping his head up with his hand; his neck didn’t seem equal to the task. The craftsmen thankfully didn’t disparage the lack of manners. Bilbo doubted they noticed. At any given dwarf gathering, an elbow upon the table was hardly the most egregious breach of etiquette.
He mentioned his poor aching head to everyone that day, and sometimes mentioned in as many times as it took to solicit the proper amount of sympathy. Thorin had needed little prompting; he inquired after Bilbo’s health the moment he saw Bilbo come back from the luncheon and all but ordered Bilbo be confined to quarters for rest. This was perfectly sufficient sympathy, and Bilbo had kissed his husband on the nose with more good cheer than he had felt all day. Then he had taken a nap.
He hadn’t thought to go to a doctor. Neither had anyone else encouraged him to. Bilbo complained of various aches and maladies all the time, and if he didn’t have any at the moment, Bilbo could always remind a dwarf of his horrendous head-cold he’d gotten saving the party from Mirkwood, or of the constant cough he had his first months in Erebor when they were still clearing out the dragon char. Dwarves reminisced about battle wounds; hobbits, their various colds.
It was not until two weeks after the luncheon, at the planning committee meeting for the coronation anniversary coming up, that Bilbo began to be concerned in earnest. “You don’t look well,” said Freya as she sat down beside him at the table.
“I don’t feel well,” Bilbo said, gearing up for a good long complaint. But he paused. Freya never inquired after his health. Specifically because she didn’t want to hear his good long complaints. “Is it that apparent?” he asked instead.
Freya nodded, concern in her eyes as she studied with the careful eye of a master dwarven craftsman. “You look concerning,” she said bluntly and with such weight that for the first time Bilbo thought that maybe he ought to be concerned.
His mother had gotten sick often, though less so the older she got. She was always wondering away from home, leaving Bilbo and his father to their own devices. And then she would always wonder home, with new stories and gifts and a special light in her eyes that made her look like herself. But she was frequently under the weather when she returned—headaches, lack of appetite, paleness. It was nothing very extreme, nothing more than you’d get that if you’d slept poorly for a few nights. Bilbo’s father said that it was just Belladonna tiring herself out traipsing across the countryside, hither and thither and who knows where. Bilbo’s mother said it was the coming home that gave her the headaches, with such boys as she lived with. These explanations were often exchanged while Bungo and Belladonna sat in their chairs by the fire, their hands clasped and the merriness in their voice warming the room.
Belladonna stopped travelling when Bungo died, and Bilbo couldn’t tell you if it had haltered her illnesses because if it had, then grief had stepped up to replace them. But Bilbo could tell you he’d never suffered any such regular weakness of body as his mother had periodically in his youth, and Bilbo for his part had never gone hither and certainly not thither. And when he finally went on his journey to who knows where, the conditions of the expedition were so uniformly terrible that it never occurred to Bilbo to associate his aches and weariness to anything besides sleeping on the ground, trudging through the rain, and rather more sprinting from goblins than that comprehensive contract had advertised.
And he had been happy. Happier than he’d ever been in his entire, healthy life.
There were downsides to everything, Bilbo supposed, but he’d always considered the aches and stresses of the road well worth the rewards they offered. It was the same way Thorin’s beard might scratch, but Bilbo would never turn away from the press of his husband’s lips.
He’d been happy in Erebor as well. As miserable a place as the underside of a mountain can be, it was beautiful too, and cozy in its own way, raucous with a distinctive cheer Bilbo imagined you couldn’t hear anywhere else in the world. The dwarves roared their constant welcome home. They offered it to the dwarves returning; they offered it to the dwarves that had never before been. They even offered their welcome to Bilbo, who had no claim of blood or memory to the strange mountain on the other side of the world. But Bilbo, the dwarves told him in no uncertain terms, would be welcome in Erebor until the end of his days.
Sometimes when Bilbo thought that he might live in Erebor until he died, he wept at the thought, and then he dried his tears and continued to live in Erebor. With the dwarves. With Thorin.
At least in Erebor, he’d had Thorin.
"Thorin," Bilbo said for the third time, with the most careful enunciation of the name. When Beorn continued to look distressingly thoughtful (distressing, that is, to Bilbo; Beorn looked altogether too mild about the issue), Bilbo added, "Dwarf. On the tall side, for dwarves. Black hair. Beard. Beaky nose." Bilbo paused and tried to think of a description that wouldn't apply to half the dwarven race. "Very kind eyes?" he added hopelessly. "You've seen him, Beorn, I know you have. I was there when you met him."
"I remember thirteen odd dwarves in my home," Beorn said. "Can't place which one was yours."
"You fought at the battle that placed him on his throne."
Beorn shrugged one massive shoulder. With Beorn sitting down, Bilbo was eyelevel with his shoulder for the first time and he could attest that it was indecently massive. "All kings look the same. They are like dwarves in that regard."
“You didn’t like him very much?”
Beorn just gave Bilbo a look that conveyed how little that narrowed things down.
This conversation, by the way, was happening on either side of the dining room window. Tauriel and Dwalin had brought Beorn back on their invitation to Bag End, but the measurements had not worked out. The door to Bag End was about five feet tall. Beorn was about two-hundred. He’d stooped, grinned through the doorway, and said, “What kind of hospitality is this, little bunny? This is how you repay me for letting you into my home?”
When Bilbo followed this up by offering him a dish predicated on him forgetting that Beorn, in certain forms at least, did not eat meat, Drogo had full-on glared at Bilbo for the first time ever before he offered served Beorn a meal more in line with his diet. “This is no way for a Baggins to treat a guest,” Drogo had said to Bilbo.
“Forgive me, cousin,” Bilbo had said, with a smile and shrug. “The illness has made me forget my manners.”
“You can’t keep blaming everything on your illness,” Drogo had replied, which again, was the sternest thing he had ever offered Bilbo. Bilbo had to laugh. Drogo looked so much in that moment like Bungo Baggins, affronted that his wife could somehow manage to forget that Missus Birches didn’t like to sit on the left side of the table or that Belladonna had put her elbows on the table again. Bilbo had been like his father for so long, had even served with his father’s emphasis on decorum as a representative of a government, and yet Bilbo was continually finding new ways to remember that he was his mother’s son.
Bilbo wasn’t laughing now, as Beorn sat outside and finished his lunch, seemingly without a care about the snowflakes drifting down into his soup. He looked back at the gathered guests of Bag End, sitting around the dining room table. Tauriel rested with her head on the table, Dwalin leaned back his eyes closed. And Dis sat with a strange placidity.
“So you haven't seen him then,” Dis asked. “Nor have you come here on his request.”
"I am not an errand boy for any dwarf," Beorn said. "I came here to suit my own purposes. This land is one I have not ventured to in some time, but I have been here before and owe some alliance to the land. There were whispers in the woods of wolves prowling through this land in search of an easy meal."
"Wolves?" Bilbo, Drogo, and Primula asked at the same time.
Beorn grinned with all his teeth. "Not anymore. Those that aren't dead won't return for a long while. You can rest easy this winter, and I can put to rest my debt to ranger who protects this land."
Primula and Drogo sighed. "Thank you," Bilbo said to Beorn, and truly meant it. "Then I suppose you were just finishing up when Tauriel and Dwalin met you."
Beorn nodded at the parties in question. “That lot? They insisted I come to you and tell you all I know."
"Which is nothing," Bilbo said.
Beorn shrugged and held out the now empty bowl. "Not about any dwarf king.”
"Thorin," Bilbo tried helplessly again as Drogo hopped up to refill Beorn’s dish. "About this tall? Would have been frowning? Er. Blue coat?"
“Also had a hobbit strapped to his back,” Dis added dryly.
Bilbo glanced back at her and she raised an eyebrow. “Right,” Bilbo said weakly. “That was perhaps what I should have lead with.”
"A hobbit?" Beorn said. He eyed Bilbo. “You?”
"Yes, I've been quite sick. I—"
"Too long and far from your home."
"Yes, yes," said Bilbo. "Did everyone know about that except me?"
"The Shire is a land unto itself, and its people have their own mysteries," said Beorn. "We do not protect it just for the hobbits who live here. It is a peerless land, with its own magic that must be protected."
"Yes, well, it's very inconvenient," Bilbo said. "And you didn't think to mention it when I met you?"
Beorn shrugged again. "You had your quest. I knew nothing of your ignorance."
Bilbo sighed, his head dropping into his hands. "I thought—I hoped," Bilbo said at last, "that you would have seen him."
"Too many dwarves have passed through the lands I protect for me to recognize yours," said Beorn. "Though most go towards your Lonely Mountain, many head away as well."
"Traders and messengers," Bilbo said glumly. "I worked with plenty from Erebor in my time. I would not think there were so many in just the last four or five months—"
"I do not memorize every dwarf that passes through."
Bilbo sighed again. "No, no, you wouldn't. And with Dis sending out her men to look for Thorin on top of everything." Bilbo sighed once more. He might keep sighing forever. "He has a very high pitched sneeze?" Bilbo tried one last time.
Beorn laughed, a laugh with a timber and depth never before heard in the Shire. You needed a minimum of two meters height to produce a sound like that. “The world is big. Your dwarf is small. What is his life to mine? I have not seen him, Bilbo Baggins. He did not bring me here.”
“But you’re the fourth,” Primula said. Everyone turned to look at her, and she flushed a little. “I mean, well, you know. It’s silly, I know. But you’re the fourth person to arrive, and it’s just, and I know this is silly and all, but fairy tales, it’s always the fourth thing that’s the important thing.” As everyone stared at her, she faltered.
“Right!” said Drogo, leaping to her defense. “Like, the first brother tries and then the next and the next and then it’s the fourth brother that does it.” He put the bowl of soup on the window ledge. “So she’s right, you’re the fourth.”
“Third,” Dwalin said.
“No, Dwalin, that’s not how counting works,” Dis said.
Dwalin threw a dinner roll at her. “I mean it’s always the third thing that’s the important one. It’s never the fourth.”
“It’s always the fourth,” Drogo said.
Primula nodded. “The third is too soon. You’ve got to try three things in fairy tales, and then with the fourth you get it right.”
“No, it’s not,” Dis said, and Primula shot her a look of pure betrayal. “Fairy tales always work in threes.”
“Dwarf ones do,” Bilbo said, whose role in his own household was increasingly becoming that of cross-cultural translator. “Hobbit ones work in fours.”
“Elf ones work in patterns of fives,” Tauriel said. “If anyone is interested.”
Drogo pointed at Tauriel. “So maybe we just need another person to arrive!”
“But I don’t think Beorn counts as our proper fourth,” Primula said. “Since he isn’t adding anything.”
Beorn knocked back his bowl. “Don’t know what’s happening,” he said. “But in my people’s fairy tales, someone usually ends up eating someone else.”
“Horrifying,” Bilbo said. “And not applicable to this situation.”
“At least we hope,” Dis said.
Primula muttered something to Drogo that sounded like Lobelia; Drogo snorted and shushed her.
Bilbo rolled into the kitchen for another cup of tea. Disappointment sat in his throat like a stone; he swallowed his drink around it. He wanted to be alone.
“It doesn’t matter which culture we’re drawing on,” said Dis, who now and then was capable of sneaking up on you when she remembered to take her boots off.
Bilbo scowled and wiped off the tea he’d sloshed on himself when he’d jumped at the sound of her voice. “No, I don’t imagine that this situation is governing itself by the rules of fairy tales.”
“Quite right,” said Dis, reaching over to pour herself her own cup. “It’s clearly a murder mystery.” When Bilbo glared at her, she added. “Minus the murder, obviously. Bilbo, I’m joking with you.”
“I’m not in a joking mood.”
“I gathered.”
“I wouldn’t think you’d be either.”
“I’m always game to joke about my brother. It’s the only way we’ve ever survived each other.” Dis sipped her tea. “I do wonder if he’s dead.” She said it casually, as if she were remarking on the weather.
“He’s not,” Bilbo said with a surety he didn’t feel. “I would know if he was.”
“How?”
“If he were dead, I wouldn’t be nearly so cross with him.”
Dis laughed. “You see?” she said. “Look who made a joke.”
Bilbo smiled despite himself. “Don’t let it fool you. I’m still devastated.”
“As am I, Master Hobbit. But what else is new?”
They finished their tea together in companionable silence, and when they were done, Bilbo let Dis push him back out to the dining room, where Beorn was reaching through the window to poke Drogo in the gut, proudly proclaiming him a far better chubby little bunny than the poor Bilbo Baggins, who barely had any meat on his bones these days. Drogo looked a little proud of this assessment and seemed to be watching Primula out of the corner of his eye to see if she was impressed as well. If Primula was, she was hiding it well under the cover of a very animated conversation about Tauriel regarding different versions of their fairy tales. Dwalin drank up Bilbo’s ale and appeared to be participating equally in both conversations, which meant ignoring them to the same amount.
“Mahal’s forge, has this place become crowded,” Dis said.
Dwarves now and then did excel at understatement.
That night, Bilbo lay awake in bed for reasons besides Beorn’s earth-shattering snores. The skin-changer was camped out in Bilbo’s garden at Drogo’s invitation; he would have offered him the last of the spare beds, but even if Beorn could have comfortable fit himself inside Bag End, he’d have shattered whatever he tried to lay on. But Beorn didn’t mind the snow, it seemed. In fact, the one time Bilbo hobbled himself to the dining room window to yell Beorn awake (he could stand and walk for a whole minute now, wasn’t that a remarkable achievement matched only by very young toddlers), he looked out into the black night and saw a great deal more fur that he’d been hoping for. Bilbo believed in letting sleeping bears lie.
So he lay in bed and look up at the ceiling and thought to himself, once upon a time. Once upon a time, there was a king who disappeared to save his love, and he encountered trials and tribulations along the way. He saved his love from the jaws of death, but there was a cost. And the cost was…
Bilbo couldn’t think of anything past that point. Maybe he just wouldn’t.
Dis was right anyway, Bilbo reasoned as he flopped over in bed trying to get himself comfortable. (His latest letter to Bofur was still half completed on his library desk, and Bilbo thought tomorrow he might add something like, insomnia continues to be an infuriating sign of improvement. Some nights I wouldn’t mind being sick again.) This wasn’t a fairy tale. This was a mystery, and all his guests red herrings, and soon there’d be the glorious parlor scene where the detective explained everything. You all were looking in the wrong place! Only I, the great detective of Bag Shot Row, could solve the mystery of the hobbit in the pumpkin patch and his missing dwarf. It all started when I was called to the garden of Pippa Bracegirdle, sister of the notorious—
Bilbo sat up so quickly he nearly blacked out. Beorn kept snoring outside while Bilbo thought. “The scene of the crime,” he whispered to himself with a hysterical little giggle, adrenaline beating his heart like an anvil, hope fluttering as hope kept doing.
When Primula, the earliest riser in the Bag End, came to the kitchen the next morning, she found Bilbo dressed and ready with a kettle ready on the fire. “We’re going out,” he told her.
Primula, unflappable to her core, just said, “Pour me a cup to wake me up and I’ll grab our coats.”
And an hour later with the sun barely over the horizon, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins with her baby on her hip opened her front door to see two of her least favorite hobbits in all of creation waiting to be invited in.
Lobelia served tea. It was a sign of how long he’d been in Erebor that this fact surprised Bilbo, but hobbit hospitality was inviolate. Two hobbits might stab each other over biscuits, but the host would make sure that they served the biscuits in the first place.
“What a delightful blend,” said Primula.
“Thank you,” Lobelia said stiffly.
Lotho on Lobelia’s lap tried to fit his entire fist into his mouth. He was making good progress. The lack of teeth probably helped.
“Is your husband well?” Primula asked.
“Yes,” said Lobelia.
“Good,” said Primula.
“Indeed,” replied Lobelia.
Silence reigned in the parlor. Bilbo blew on his tea and didn’t sip until Lobelia had. Every time he’d supped with her, he couldn’t shake the fear that she might have poisoned the dishes.
“When I returned to the Shire, you were the one that found me,” Bilbo said. Lobelia and Primula both looked shocked that he’d spoken. The average tea time featured at least ten minutes of forced small talk before anyone broached the business of what actually brought them there. Bilbo had lived in Erebor long enough to learn impatience as well.
“My sister found you,” Lobelia corrected. “You were lurking in her garden.”
“I was unconscious, I believe.”
“Don’t need to be awake to lurk.”
“Actually I think you do. Otherwise, it’s just called being unconscious in a garden.”
Lobelia sniffed like she didn’t think that sound any better.
On reflection, she wasn’t wrong.
“Fine,” Bilbo said. “But I was in her garden.”
“Yes.”
“Did you find anything in the garden?”
Lobelia looked at him like he was an idiot. “Obviously we did.”
“Anything in the garden besides Bilbo,” Primula said. “Did you or your sister find anything in the garden or maybe at the funeral?”
“At the funeral?” Lobelia asked. She drew herself up. “Are you asking if I looted my kinsman’s corpse?”
“Did you?” Primula asked.
Lobelia squawked with indignation. In her lap, Lotho gurgled a noise that was almost the same. “Well! To be insulted in my own home like this!”
“Primula,” Bilbo said quietly.
Primula narrowed her pale eyes. Bilbo sighed, and passed it off as blowing on his still scalding tea. Bilbo had spent his time in Erebor assiduously avoiding many of the traditional tasks of a king’s spouse—the endless receptions, the meetings, the event planning, the awards, the constant good cheer and careful diplomacy—but he hadn’t dodged them entirely. He’d served at Thorin’s side of enough years to learn some diplomacy; he’d also served enough time to learn about audiences. It was a tricky thing, having a third party in the room. It created an additional person for everyone to perform for. Easier, sometimes, to converse without.
(Bilbo would not confirm nor deny whether or not he had maybe perhaps used an object of some sort to be present in some meetings that he was not, in the strictest sense of the word, allowed to be in. But if Bilbo, hypothetically, had ever done that, it had taught him an interesting lesson on the difference between how people talked in front of you versus how they talked the rest of the time. Bilbo had spent his entire life in the Shire learning the theory of this principle, but it’s one thing to see how your mother and her sister talk about their mutual friend when she isn’t there and quite another thing to stand invisible in a room and listen to a dwarven council form their objections to your foreign presence at their high table. Hypothetically.)
“Primula, what if you took Lotho off Lobelia’s hands for a bit?” Bilbo asked. “I’m sure Lobelia wouldn’t mind.”
Lobelia wrapped her arms around Lotho who promptly drooled on them. “I very much would.”
Primula, after a brief breath, tipped her head and said, “What a sweetie. I’ll be happy to take him, Lobelia. If you’d like.”
“You insult me and now you want to watch my child?” Lobelia sneered.
“I want to give you a few minutes alone to have a conversation in which you don’t need to worry about breastfeeding, diapers, or if Lotho is going to put something he shouldn’t into his mouth.
Lobelia opened her mouth. Then she shut it. She did have the look in her eye of a woman who hadn’t been more than ten feet from a baby in weeks. “Well, if you insist,” Lobelia said as she practically tossed the infant at Primula. Primula slung Lotho onto her hip and, cooing gently at him, slipped out of the parlor.
In the new emptiness of the parlor, Bilbo crossed his hands in his lap. “By the way, yes,” he said. “I am accusing you of grave-robbing, minus the grave. You’ve stolen so much from me while I’m alive, that I can’t imagine you passed up the opportunity when I was dead. In fact, I don’t know why the thought hadn’t occurred to me before.”
Lobelia spluttered. “I have never stolen a thing in my life, Bilbo Baggins! I ought to take you before the magistrate for slander!”
“Do! I’ll be happy to show him the place in my pantry where my mother’s silverware ought to be.”
“I haven’t the faintest idea what you mean.”
“You stole them at my father’s wake, if that jogs your memory.” Bilbo leaned back in his chair and reminded himself, diplomacy. But on the other hand, he had learned much of his diplomacy amongst dwarves and they solved a great many interpersonal conflicts via head-butt. “The point is,” Bilbo said while Lobelia kept up a muttered litany of how dare you and I never and the cheek of some people these days, “is that you are not one to let an opportunity go to waste.”
Lobelia interrupted her monologue of self-righteousness to ask, “And what does that mean?”
“It means did you find anything on me or around me that says where Thorin is?”
Lobelia said nothing.
Bilbo leaned forward. “I’ve been so thick,” he said. “I’ve been the biggest idiot. Thorin would not leave without a trace or abandon me without a message. It must be somewhere, Lobelia. Do you have it?”
Lobelia was quiet a moment. Her silences were always more sullen than thoughtful. Then she said, “I visited you, you know. That first week you were in Bag End.”
“After you tried to bury me alive.”
She shrugged, as if to say what are you going to do. “A lot of us were at that funeral, let’s not point fingers. I visited you, is the point.”
Bilbo didn’t remember that. He must have still been asleep at the time.
“Our cousin told me to piss off,” Lobelia said. “In no uncertain terms.”
Bilbo tried to imagine Drogo telling anyone to piss off in no uncertain terms. The best he could imagine was Drogo standing apologetically at the door. Sorry, Missus Sackville-Baggins, I really would, but Mister Baggins still needs his rest and I wouldn’t want you catching anything, if you can catch this from foreign parts being magic like that, since I know you’ve got a young one at home and you need to be fighting fit for the lad. How is Lotho, by the way? And your husband? And your cousins? And your sisters?
That, Bilbo could picture.
“Incomparable rudeness,” Lobelia said. “And the Brandybuck nurse—” Lobelia glanced at the door to the study suddenly, a spasm of tact overcoming her. “Well, you can just imagine.”
Bilbo very much could. It said much about Primula’s personality that she got on so well with Dis.
“I know when I’m not wanted,” Lobelia said, “and when that’s the case, I’ll take my presence elsewhere.”
“You’ve never removed yourself from my doorstep simply because I wished you gone,” Bilbo retorted.
“We’re family. Customs dictate you let me look in on you. You’re the sad bachelor of Bag End. We all thought that if someone didn’t knock on your door now and then, we’d find you years later moldered to rot in your bed.” Lobelia, reflecting on her good deeds towards her unworthy kin, puffed up so much Bilbo was tempted to give her one good jab with a needle just to see what happened. “So naturally when you came home, I wanted to see how you were doing, and I was bustled away by your goons just as sure as if I’d been a bandit in the night. Fine, I thought. Just as well, what are they to me, I’ll wait till Bilbo Baggins can receive me himself, if he can, and if he can’t, I’ll know why and have the two of them brought before the magistrate for murder of a helpless decrepit.
“And then I get word in the market that you’re feeling better. Up and about even, or at least up, and I thought, well, my dear cousin will be wanting some relief of company, and head I on up the road to your house pleasant as you like, grapes and wine and all that for your health. Then all of a sudden comes this…this…ogre creature, horrid, hairy, tall, stinking of Eru only knows and this creature, this beast stops me. Me! Minding my own business! And asks me for directions to Bag End!”
“And I take it you gave them,” Bilbo said.
“It was a matter of life and death,” Lobelia sniffed. “And don’t you judge me for it, Bilbo Baggins. You would have done the same in the face of brute with an ax and a beard, a beard, Bilbo. I have a child and a husband, don’t you know. You wouldn’t know what it’s like, having to keep yourself safe for the sake of your family. You get to run off into the wilderness whenever you feel like it and never mind if anyone’s going hungry at home or the laundry needs doing.” She shrugged. “And they said they knew you. I believed them, of course.”
“Of course,” Bilbo said dryly. “You weren’t wrong, I suppose, since I do think that’s King Dis you are referring to. Mind that you never let her know how you’ve described her.”
“You’ll tell her the moment you get home, no doubt.” Lobelia harrumphed and crossed her arms. “Don’t understand why half the ladies’ in the Shire are so eager to join her book club.”
“A strange charisma runs in her family,” Bilbo said. “Trust me.”
Lobelia harrumphed again, a noise of principled distrust towards anyone generally likeable. “You let her stay in Bag End, of course. You’re more hospitable to strangers than your own family.”
Bilbo considered saying something like, Dis is my family and she didn’t give me much choice, but he thought better of it at the last minute. No sense giving Lobelia ideas.
“Anyway, when it was clear that your brute—”
“Dwarf.”
“That’s what I said. Anyway, I thought to myself that I wouldn’t go visiting you until she was gone, but then she was never gone, and as the weeks went, I started thinking to myself about trying my way up the hill again when your dwarf was out and about in the village—stomping about like she owns the place, I ask you, that doesn’t seem very kinglike to me, I didn’t vote for her or all that—and so I take myself up the hill again, still with the grapes and the wine and all that.”
“Same grapes from last time?” Bilbo asked.
Lobelia glared. “Everyone knows grapes keep fine. And so I’m bringing them to you up the hill when lo and behold, what do I see?”
She waited with such an indigent silence that Bilbo sighed and said, “Another dwarf?”
“Another dwarf!” Lobelia flung her hands up in the air as if this were the most ludicrous thing anyone had ever heard. And, to be fair, Bilbo realized after a moment that it was indeed, by Shire standards, very ludicrous. If it had been Bilbo six years ago recounting this story, he would sound very much the same as Lobelia. How very large, he marveled, his world had grown.
On her couch, Lobelia was shaking her head without words, apparently too shocked to form them. She persevered nonetheless, and wrung a few out. “And then a few days later, what pops up around town but that unfortunately tall one, the elf or what have you, could look quite pretty if she wasn’t such a freak, and after your first two guests, we’re all thinking, well, at least this one’s quiet, at least this one’s beardless, at least this one doesn’t always look at you like she’s sizing you up for dinner. We could have lived with the tall one. The tall was as decently acceptable, except by now Bag End is overflowing with outsiders, brutes and thugs and all that, and it’s to the point that I wouldn’t like my Otho even go near that side of Hobbiton, a just concern that any good wife would share with her husband. And then, and now, with your bear man—”
“He’s not my bear man,” Bilbo said, though he was momentarily impressed how quickly that news had spread through the Shire. “He’s just a bear man in the area who decided to say hello. Nothing to do with me.”
“He’s napping in your garden!”
Bilbo couldn’t dispute that.
Lobelia shook her head once more, her hat bobbing with disappointment. “We had a quiet respectable village, and you went and decided that if you couldn’t go to the mountain, the mountain would come to you.”
“Lobelia!” Bilbo snapped, and what patience he had snapped with him. “Did you find anything? Were you going to bring me something?”
“Why’s it matter so much to you?” Lobelia said. “If some prick left me for dead in a pumpkin patch, I’d never waste another moment thinking about him again.”
“Because that prick is my husband!” Bilbo said. “And he would not leave me for dead!”
Lobelia’s jaw dropped like the trapdoor of a gallows.
Oh, Bilbo thought. Perhaps Drogo hadn’t spread that bit of gossip the way that Bilbo had assumed he would.
“Husband?” Lobelia asked.
“Yes.”
“Married?” Lobelia asked, a full octave higher.
“Yes, married! And glad of it, Lobelia,” Bilbo added, “so if you’ve anything to say about it, you can keep it to yourself.”
She gaped at him some more, her mouth opening and closing as she stared. Then she snorted. “You’d know something about keeping things to yourself, wouldn’t you!” Lobelia said. “Married! And you didn’t even send us a wedding present!”
Bilbo actually laughed. “No, Lobelia, I did not. Astonishing. I’m amazed it wasn’t you we found in Erebor, squatting on all that gold. Of all the greedy—”
“It’s not greed.” Lobelia’s voice cracked like a whip. “It’s how it’s done. Did you go off to, to, to your Erebor and start demanding to be given gifts on your birthday? Wouldn’t be surprised if you did, and if you asked for nothing but—but socks! And fine dwarven boots! Your feet got cold so far from home, I imagine.” Lobelia was a picture of affront, a kind of personal offense so convincing that even Bilbo almost believed it. “No wonder you married a dwarf. You’re no hobbit.”
“Believe me, Lobelia, I was never more a hobbit than when I was in Erebor,” Bilbo said. “And it would seem I’m never more of a dwarf when I’m here. Maybe you should have gone on the quest, you’re always perfectly horrible in any and all circumstances.”
Lobelia sniffed. Her hat almost toppled off in disgust. “Married,” she said again. “Typical Bilbo Baggins, isn’t it? Nothing homegrown good enough, you had to import. And look where it got you! On death’s door, it did. Everyone knows you aren’t supposed to leave the Shire, but you thought you were too good for that.”
“Silly me, thinking that was just yet one more superstition from hobbits so small-minded that the only time they look beyond their front porch is to sneer at the neighbor’s.”
“Maybe lots of us want to look beyond our front porch,” Lobelia said hotly, “only we haven’t the money to live alone, and we’ve mouths to feed, and a hearth to clean ourselves with our poor own hands. Your wicked mother settled right down when you were born, didn’t she? That’s what it means to grow up, the way a hobbit ought to. You don’t get to be selfish till you die. We’re not supposed to leave.”
“So you’ve been trying to bully and evict me from my home for more than a decade because of your deep selfless compassion.”
Lobelia stamped her foot. Her hairpins gave up, and her hat tumbled. “Oh, why should you get everything! Why should you get the mountain and the adventure and the hearth and the home! Now you’ve got the life of a bachelor and the life of a husband all in one. Married! Why do you get to live here and there when the rest of us put down roots and hope something grows? You get the nicest home in the Shire, then you get the kingdom in the mountain? What have you done that makes you get and get and get? And!” Lobelia shouted this last word so harshly that Bilbo jumped. She jabbed a finger in his face. “And! You get and! And the rest of make do with our or.”
“I don’t have and,” Bilbo snapped. “How do you not get that? I made my choices, and my choices were made for me, so don’t act like a martyr when only one of us has got a live-in nurse because their choices nearly killed them. I’m here, not there. I’m a husband, not a bachelor, and I want to know if I’m a widower!”
Lobelia snorted. “You won’t stay. You think I’m greedy? You’ll get tired of the Shire when it’s not enough for you, and you’ll remember Erebor before you got tired of that—”
“Because I got ill!”
“An illness that made you tired of Erebor!” Lobelia presented this fact like a trump card with such confident surety that Bilbo just gaped at her a moment.
“Well,” he said at last while Lobelia smirked, “I can’t leave the Shire. So you are, alas, stuck with me, and I should make clear that I fully intend to die in that house before I let you get so much as one silver spoon.”
The promise barely landed on her before she brushed it away. “You left before and you were fine for a while. You’ll leave again.”
“I won’t.”
“You will.”
“I won’t.”
“Just wait.”
“I won’t,” Bilbo said slowly, “because among other reasons besides it killing me, since that reason apparently hardly matters to you, this is the only place in the world my husband knows I am. So even if I was inclined to leave, I couldn’t.”
Lobelia said nothing to that. In place of words, she offered an eloquent glare. And then, her nostrils flaring, she said, “So maybe I did find something.”
Bilbo sat very still. “What?” he asked.
“Maybe I went back out to my sister’s garden and found something there that the idiot constables jostled out of our pocket as they moved you. And maybe I tried to bring it to you, only to be horribly turned away. Like a beggar at the door. Or worse. And then maybe I forgot about what I found for a while until this very moment.” Lobelia sniffed again. “You might have said you were married. I might have remembered sooner if I’d know you were married.”
“What did you find, Lobelia? Give it to me now.”
“Promise that you won’t send any of your brutish guests to my house.”
“Lobelia!”
Lobelia put her hands up. Bilbo’s clenched each other so fiercely his hands turned white. Lobelia stood and went over to a small desk in the corner of the room. She rolled up the cover. She pulled out a book. “Slipped my mind, didn’t it,” Lobelia said as she opened the book. She pulled out a piece of paper that had once been white before it had gotten trampled in the dirt a few times. “Really, if the constables weren’t so useless, they’d have found it themselves.”
Bilbo pushed himself out of his chair. “What a crock!” Lobelia exclaimed as Bilbo hobbled over to her. “You don’t even need that thing, you’ve just too lazy to walk and want some sympathy, I see, I see.”
“Lobelia,” Bilbo said, his heart pounding from far, far more than the exertion of walking, “shut up.”
Lobelia rolled her eyes. “Or what?”
At which point Primula, who had put Lotho down for a nap before sneaking into the dining room on the other side of the parlor to eavesdrop, burst through the open door and cold clocked Lobelia with such force that she simultaneously broke Lobelia’s nose and her own thumb.
“Thumb outside the fist!” Dis yelled at her patient, as was the norm in dwarven medical care. “Honestly, Prim, you’d think you’ve never thrown a punch before.”
“I never have thrown a punch before.”
“No wonder the Shire is in the state that it is then! Respectable young hobbits not even learning how to fight!”
“Oh we do fight,” Primula replied. “It’s just mostly hair pulling and biting.”
“She’s teasing,” Drogo said. Bilbo doubted very much that she had been. “Hobbits don’t solve our problem with violence. Er. Usually.” Drogo was the reason that Dis was the one bandaging Primula’s hand, instead of Primula just taking care of it himself. He wouldn’t let Primula’s unharmed hand go. Primula didn’t seem to mind.
“I do hope she’s alright,” Primula said.
“I don’t,” Dis replied in a voice that implied warfare. “I very much hope the opposite.”
“Don’t do anything to make your hope so,” Primula said sternly. “It was a nasty thing to do, keeping that letter to herself, but you can’t blame her too much for being the way she is. She can’t help it. My mother’s always told me that Lobelia could have been a great woman ‘cept that she was cursed to humble circumstances. She ought to have been born as one of those bloodthirsty royals who kill all their relatives to get their own children on the throne. No offense, of course, your majesty.”
“None taken until you implied I ought to,” Dis replied.
All this was the conversation at the lunch table, and the words carried through Bag End’s hallways with the unfailing clarity of that voices always attain when all you want is a bit of quiet. Then all of a sudden, the voices dropped, as best as hobbits and dwarves in the full swing of conversation can manage. “Is that really all it said?” Bilbo heard Drogo whisper, and Primula responded in a murmur so low that Bilbo couldn’t make out the words. He heard Dis’ sigh perfectly. It was almost more annoying when they were trying to be considerate towards him. Bilbo rolled over to the door of his library, and pressed it gently shut. After a moment, he turned the lock. Then he went back to the place his favorite armchair used to sit before a caravan of dwarves had carried it across the world and reread the letter by sunlight.
It was short. It was scrawled. And it went as followed:
My dearest burglar, I am bringing you home as promised. The king of all birds has replied at last to my missives and will ferry you to the Shire. I have promised him my service in return. When my obligation is fulfilled, I will meet you healthy and hale in the Shire where you may scold me for all my actions in person. Awaken. Heal. Do not worry about me, amrâlimê. I will see you soon.
Yours, Thorin.
And then underneath, somehow even more hurriedly scrawled to the point of near illegibility, and if you could write to Dwalin, tell him I’m sorry about our parting, he’ll know what I mean, longer apology to both of you to follow, have to go, eagles flying now
“No wonder Lobelia didn’t know we were married,” Bilbo muttered to himself, running his fingers over the letters. “It’s about as romantic as a shopping list.”
Fili and Kili got a much better note. If Thorin was going to make such a habit of rushing out, he ought to start carrying drafts in his pocket with blanks he could just fill when the time came. Dear [Name], so sorry to leave you, but something has come up. I feel [emotion] about it, but because of [reasons] this must be done. I assure you, I am emotionally tormented by this, but no one in the world should have to shoulder the burden of [stupid noble thing] besides me. Lots of love, see you around. Thorin.
Bilbo had read the note a hundred times so far, from the first time as Primula sprinted him out of Lobelia’s house in his wheelchair, staring at the words as they bounded over the dirt road, Primula saying, “Sorry, sorry, so sorry, I just lost temper,” as they fled.
“Quite alright, quite alright,” Bilbo had murmured mindlessly back, as he read the letter a second time, a third, a fourth. It was short and scrawled and lacked his nephew’s flair for romantic language, and it was Thorin. It was Thorin’s hand, it was Thorin’s promise, it was Thorin’s stupid, stupid plan.
“To be fair, it worked,” Primula had pointed out on the bench where, having sprinting a mile from Lobelia’s house, they deemed it safe to rest a moment and catch their breath.
“Thorin got himself indentured to the King of All Birds,” Bilbo had replied. “Bloody stupid plan, everyone knows the Eagles are temperamental at best.”
“But I read your book, they helped you before.”
“They inconvenienced our enemies. It’s not the same. You should have sat in on the meetings we had with them. They spent half the time poaching Dale’s herds and the other half complaining that the Men were shooting at them as they tried to do it.”
Bilbo remembered distinctly one meeting where King Bard had looked conspicuously innocent as an emissary of the Eagles protested their treatment. “We are so very sorry that our archers have been trying to shoot you down,” he said with such wide-eyed earnestness that Bilbo almost forgot that he’d spied Bard on the parapets himself this morning, taking aim with that big black bow. “The people of Dale are perhaps still a little oversensitive towards winged beasts who steal our things.”
Thorin’s ring was still in Bilbo’s pocket. He kept it where his own ring had gone, not his wedding ring but that gleaming one still hidden deep in Erebor. Bilbo found he didn’t miss that either ring nearly so much now that he had Thorin’s. And Thorin had offered it to the Eagles as payment, perhaps, or proof of commitment that he’d pay them even more. When it was rejected, then his mother’s wedding bead. And perhaps that had done the trick.
Alone in his library, Bilbo pulled out Thorin’s ring and slipped it onto his thumb. I will see you soon, Thorin had written. Bilbo sighed to the empty air. “Would it have killed you to be a little more specific?”
Outside his door, the waxing and waning clamor at the lunch table cut off suddenly, a silence that grabbed Bilbo’s attention. He looked up and listened. There were footsteps, and then the front door opened. He heard Drogo’s voice. He didn’t hear a response. But Drogo spoke again, and his tone was polite as ever as the front door swung shut, and then there was more murmuring in the hallway that Bilbo couldn’t catch.
“Horrid little man,” Dis said. That came through loud and clear.
Bilbo arched his neck out the library window, and saw Otho Sackville-Baggins hurrying back down the road.
Drogo knocked on the library door. “Bilbo? I’ve got something for you. Lobelia sent her husband with it. He said she, er, that it happened somehow to be in her possession and she just remembered she had it as well. So I guess that means she nicked this as well.”
Bilbo opened the door.
Drogo gave him Thorin’s wedding bead. Thorin’s mother’s wedding bead. The one Bilbo had braided into Thorin’s beard himself.
It was likely the closest that Lobelia would ever get to an apology. Bilbo wasn’t going to accept it. The apology, that is. The hand that wasn’t holding Thorin’s letter closed around the bead, and Drogo knelt down to embrace him as Bilbo started to cry.
Dis should have been the next one to see the note. That was what Dis argued, at least. But when Tauriel and Dwalin came back to Bag End that evening, it was Dwalin Bilbo sent Drogo to fetch. Dwalin read the words over once, and handed the letter back. “That’s that then,” Dwalin said.
Bilbo blinked at the paper outstretched to him. “Is that all?”
Dwalin shrugged. “What else is there to say?”
“Many things,” Bilbo said, finally taking the letter. “About emotions. And how you feel. About all this.”
“Thorin got you here safe. Nothing else to say.”
“Nothing else,” Bilbo repeated incredulously. “Nothing else? Nothing about relief perhaps? Or exasperation? Or something about how we should have known it was the bloody Eagles all along? Or any worries at all about where he is now?”
“With the Eagles.”
“Maybe! If they haven’t eaten him alive or dropped him off a cliff or heavens knows what!”
Dwalin thought for a moment. “Nah,” he said. “Thorin’s fine.” He scratched his beard. “Thorin knew what he was doing all along. Stupid to think he didn’t.”
“Dwalin…” Bilbo said.
Dwalin gave him a look that said the end of that sentence didn’t need to be said. Bilbo sighed and surrendered. “Very well. I imagine I’m not the hobbit you’d want to talk to this about anyway. Drogo’s a good listener, if you ever decide to admit that you do in fact have emotions.”
“It’s ain’t—” Dwalin snorted and half turned away. He rested his arm on the fireplace, and the flames from beneath made Dwalin’s beard look like shadow. “I don’t blame you. Anymore, I mean. For him leaving. Shouldn’t have ever in the first place. That was Thorin’s choice. It always was.” Dwalin looked at Bilbo sidelong, his knuckles getting knocking on the mantle. “We’re fine, you and me. Have been. Thought you knew that.”
Bilbo was silent a moment. “Yes, I did,” Bilbo said at last. “I know—I know we’re good friends.” It was a strangely intimate thing to say, into a room where the words echoed and you thought for a moment that they might be rejected. It felt just a little like flinging yourself off a cliff. Dwalin just nodded a little. That felt a little like a net, just before you hit the bottom. “But I wouldn’t blame you if you were still… I know I derailed what you thought your life was going to look like.”
Dwalin chuckled. Bilbo hadn’t been expecting that. “The dragon did worse.”
That startled a laugh out of Bilbo. “I suppose you’re right.”
They stood together a moment by the light of the fire, the moonlight streaming in from the window outside.
“Give it back,” Dwalin said, tugging at his beard. “I’ll show it to Dis.”
“Are you sure?”
Dwalin shrugged. “Someone has to.”
“Are you…” Bilbo tried to figure out the politest way to end this sentence. “On speaking terms yet?”
Dwalin looked at him in surprise. “Course we are.”
“But you two never actually seem to speak to each other.”
“Not everyone prattles like hobbits.”
Fair enough. Bilbo held out the letter and Dwalin took it without looking at it. “She might have questions about your mention in the postmark,” Bilbo said cautiously.
“I’ll answer them,” Dwalin said. He kept tugging his beard in thought. “I’m happy, I suppose,” he said, almost to himself. “Happier than I’ve been in a long while.” Dwalin glance sideways at Bilbo. “That enough feeling talk for you?”
“That ought to do it,” Bilbo said.
Dwalin nodded and left. Bilbo rolled his chair over to the doorway to listen. He heard Dwalin’s steps go down, heard the knock on Dis’ door. Heard the door open. He did not hear voices. Dwarves really were very good at silence when it suited them. It was all that work around the deafening forge. You learned to say the things you needed to say without saying any words.
It made eavesdropping very inconvenient, Bilbo could tell you that.
Dis’ door closed again, and Bilbo waited for the sound of Dwalin’s footsteps walking away. They didn’t come. It took Bilbo a long moment to realize that he must be in Dis’ bedroom now. Bilbo did his best to stop listening. Whatever was said or not said in the bedroom was the business of those in the bedroom alone. Bilbo knew that very well. He was a married man, after all, despite everything. You learn a few secrets about people in the process. Bilbo touched his pocket, the outline of Thorin’s ring underneath the fabric. The outline of his wedding bead now too. Then he went over to the window and spent a good long while that night looking up at the sky.
Bilbo couldn’t tell you the exact moment he’d fallen in love with Thorin, when affection turned into something ineffable, but he could tell you the exact moment he’d known: his hands pressing down on Thorin’s stomach wound as Thorin smiled at Bilbo with the softness like the sunrise in his dark eyes, the rising of something that would blot out what was there before. It took death crouching on Thorin’s chest to make Bilbo see the truth.
That much, Bilbo is sure. He’s just not sure when the truth that he discovered in Thorin’s dying smile first became true.
In his more romantic moments, he thought it might have been love at first sight. There was something to that theory, no matter what Dwalin had to say on the matter. Thorin did cut a splendid figure in the doorway to Bag End, a woodcutting of a king come to life. And he looked as nothing ever looking in Bag End, not even his fellow dwarves: he looked as if he didn’t belong. He was too grand for the domestic. Bilbo could see that at a glance. And there was something about the foreign nature of Thorin, the sheer strangeness, that Bilbo could very easily love.
Hobbits would ascribe that inclination to Bilbo’s Tookish side, but Bilbo placed the blame elsewhere in his family tree. His mother was a wild and strange one, yes, but it was his father that had loved her. Respectability ran deep in the Baggins’ blood, respectability that meant a shudder of horror at the unrespectable; it was a shudder Bilbo felt when he first looked at Thorin. But shudders could mean anything. Revulsion and fascination were sometimes impossible to tell apart.
Oh dear. This isn’t the most romantic start, is it? To be fair, ultimately neither was Thorin and Bilbo’s first meeting. It might have been the start to everything, the journey and love initiated in one fell swoop. But then Thorin had to go and open his mouth. Even Bilbo’s romantic side had to admit that Thorin’s words did not make nearly such a good impression as his looks. Call Bilbo a sentimentalist, but he prefers his potential romantic partners not to openly regard him with such disappointment. Even if Bilbo as he was certainly encouraged that disappointment.
So maybe Bilbo fell in love on the journey, in those first weeks. It was hard to see where, though. For the first leg, Bilbo spoke to few in the company besides Bofur and his relatives, for Bofur had an easy and gentle kindness so easy and gentle that you might never notice it was there except that it warmed you as well as any fire. Bofur was hobbitish, in the best meaning of the word, and without much fuss he accepted Bilbo into his circle with an ease that never suggested that he was doing Bilbo any great favor in doing so. By all rights, it should have been Bofur that Bilbo married, if Bilbo had been looking to marry, for Bilbo had enjoyed the same relationship with Bofur that a great many hobbits enjoyed with their spouse: a gentle companionship, an easy friendship. But if Bilbo had wanted to marry a hobbit, he would have married a hobbit. (And presumably Bofur had his own opinions on the matter.)
Thorin Oakenshield was as distinctly not-hobbitish as beings came. Sentimental revisions of personal history aside (love’s pull was powerful enough that it had an insidious tendency to rewrite the past in cheerier colors, to add weight to looks and silences that had been nothing but looks and silence), Bilbo felt little towards Thorin in those first months beyond fascination. Who wouldn’t be fascinated by him? Who couldn’t stand beside Thorin Oakenshield and not feel the tug of destiny? (Many people, Bilbo would learn, and though he suspected this was love speaking as well, he couldn’t understand why: even when they’d been strangers to each other, Bilbo had seen Thorin wear his greatness like a halo.) To stand before Thorin was to stand before the tale’s hero; it was to see yourself as the supporting character in someone else’s quest. All this Bilbo felt and respected as any proper reader would.
But Bilbo certainly did not love Thorin for it.
Rivendell then? The city was as good a starting point as any, back on the subject of love. Standing at Thorin’s side as Elrond declared the madness of Thorin’s line, the first stirrings of pity for Thorin the person rose in Bilbo’s chest. “They say we have madness in my family as well,” Bilbo could have offered, but he’d known that Thorin would take no comfort and much insult in the Durins being compared to Bilbo’s mother who was wild enough by hobbit standards but perfectly mild by dwarven once. The Bilbo in Rivendell had been sure that he knew how Thorin would react, just as sure as the Bilbo back in Bag End after the fact was sure that his past self had been wrong. Thorin would have liked nothing more than to be offered anything other than the silence of pity. Perhaps there’s a world where Bilbo was a little braver; where he didn’t pass off cowardly silence as tact; where Bilbo that night spoke; and where Thorin after a moment of surprise responded. Perhaps there’s a world where Bilbo and Thorin fell in love that very night, and perhaps Bilbo would even have recognized the falling at the time. It would have saved them some time.
So no, it was no Rivendell, and it was not the road from it, and it was not the night of the Stone Giants and Bilbo’s faltering heart. It was not the moment of terror that came with separation. It was not Bilbo’s first kill in the dark. Bilbo had not been rushing towards the dwarves—any of the dwarves—so much as he’d been rushing away from everything else. He fell in love with his ring faster than Thorin. (Somedays, he even missed it just as much, which was the closest Bilbo ever got to truly understanding gold sickness.)
Bilbo did not fall in love with Thorin the moment that Thorin fell in love with Bilbo.
When the confessions were made—the hospital tent outside Erebor, the words making explicit what they’d both known in the blood-soaked snow—Bilbo and Thorin had played that favorite game of new lovers, where every moment of the relationship, already well-worn through excessive interrogation, is taken back out for shared reexamination, to cross-study the assumptions each of you made, to answer the questions that you’d been trying to ask without asking. To laugh and say, “You thought I was angry at you that evening? I never would have sought you out for dinner if I hated you.” Or, “I thought you were the most insufferable prick the first time we met.” Or, “I was never happier when you put your sleeping mat near mine.”
“Did you really think that I’d gone back to Rivendell?” Bilbo asked, his head on the pillow beside Thorin’s.
“I hoped you had,” said Thorin. “Or else you were dead in the mountain. If we barely survived, I didn’t imagine that you could. Though I worried about you on the way to Rivendell as well. I thought you would die in the wilderness on the way there if the elves did not find you.”
“You worried about me?”
“All the time. You are so small. I didn’t know what you were capable of.” Thorin smiled, such a sweet and mystified smile that it was not love that caused it, it was certainly the dwarven painkillers that Oin had administered. “Little did I know.”
“Little did anyone know,” said Bilbo. “Most of all myself. I didn’t know you cared for me then.”
“I cared for you as a member of my company. If you died, it would have been on my head.” Thorin pressed his forehead against Bilbo’s. When Thorin breathed in, Bilbo thought, he inhaled what Bilbo exhaled. And vice versa. The thought was so intimate that Bilbo had to squeeze his eyes shut. He wasn’t sure if he wanted to cry or giggle.
“I did not love you,” said Thorin, “until you returned.”
“And then?” asked Bilbo.
“Then I loved you, and will never cease to.”
“Because I told you I would help you reclaim Erebor?”
“No,” said Thorin. “Before that. When you returned.”
“Not after I jumped in front of that warg for you?”
“By then, I loved you so firmly that I could not remember a time when I hadn’t.”
Bilbo curled tighter against Thorin’s side. He didn’t know what to say. How could you say anything to that? Where would you start? “Then I might not have jumped in front of that warg then,” Bilbo said. “Could have saved myself a bit of trouble if I’d know you already liked me.”
Thorin laughed and winced, and Oin stuck his head back in the tent and shouted once more about not reopening stitches, which accomplished nothing except making Bilbo and Thorin laugh some more. Bilbo laughed and buried his face in Thorin’s shoulder, and marveled. Thorin fell in love with Bilbo with a kind of love that Bilbo had never known and would never know and could never know except by outside experience, for Thorin loved like a striking match. His heart was inert; then, aflame. When it was done burning, it would be no more a match, just ash in the wind.
Bilbo didn’t love like that. Bilbo didn’t understand how anyone could.
Why had Bilbo come back to Thorin that day in the Misty Mountains? Because that was where safety lay. Why did Bilbo pledge to help Thorin retake his home? Because Bilbo so sorely missed his own. Why did he place himself between an orc and his kill? Because—and here the easy answers falter.
When Bilbo had lain awake the night after, up there on the Carrack with everyone too exhausted to even think about climbing down, he’d wondered himself to sleep chewing on that question. Because it was the right thing to do: that would be the obvious answer. Bilbo didn’t buy it. He knew the limits of his heroism. Or he thought he did, at any rate. Because Bilbo was the closest. Because after the orc killed Thorin, Bilbo and the company would have been next. Because this was Bilbo’s time to achieve some fraction of a hero’s greatness. Bilbo thought all these reasons, weighed them like a rock, flung them at the target of his thoughts. None struck bullseye. None felt right.
I did it for Thorin, Bilbo thought that night, and found to his surprise that the words felt like a stone that would skip across the water a dozen times until it bounced onto the far shore, never sinking.
Bilbo loved the way as writers love, as writers write. There are words and words and words and erasures and mistakes and torn out pages you wanted to keep and paragraphs you learn to live with, and then at some point a pile of papers becomes a story. Before it has a beginning, middle, or end, it is a story. There’s a moment when the story lives on its own, and the words are just only way you can think of to show to the story: a blanket thrown over an invisible figure to gain some sense of its shape.
This perhaps was the reason Bilbo had always known Thorin would come back. It wouldn’t be a very good story otherwise. And Bilbo knew the way writers know that Thorin was always going to be the best story Bilbo ever told.
