Actions

Work Header

Comes Around Again

Chapter 7: The Last Homely House

Notes:

Thank you so much for your patience everybody, and thank you SO MUCH to livingmeatloaf for betaing! Here is the next chapter!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

In the morning, Gimli learned that they would be spending the next two weeks in Rivendell, and while he ached to continue on as quickly as possible, he knew crossing the mountains and the Wilderland beyond would be difficult enough. His love would have to wait, and Gimli would just have to trust that Radagast would not let Legolas fade in the meantime.

 

Breakfast had been served sometime before he had woken, large platters of venison sausage and eggs with the flakey, airy breakfast rolls with honey that Gimli first sampled here at Elrond's council. There was also, more importantly, a large platter of fresh fruit, including a basket of apples that were surprisingly ripe for being so early in the season. Gimli grabbed an apple as he filled his plate and set it carefully next to him as he sat.

"Morning, Gimli," Bilbo said from across the little table. His plate was less full than Gimli had come to expect from the hobbit and, after a moment, narrowed his eyes.

"Morning, Bilbo," he said. "And which breakfast are you eating?"

"Second!" Bilbo said, beaming. "I've always been a bit of a light sleeper, and as tired as I was last night, I woke when they brought the food, and since no one else was yet awake, save for poor Dwalin—and really, is a watch absolutely necessary? He glared so hard at the poor girl she nearly dropped the kettle!" He shook his head. "There's security and then there's paranoia, I fear. Either way, since no one else was up, I helped myself, seeing as there was more than enough to feed us all, including Bombur."

Gimli swallowed his bite of egg. "And how long ago was this? The food seems fresh."

"I know!" Bilbo said. "It's a bit of a marvel, really." He paused, then looked sidelong at Gimli, eyes twinkling. "Perhaps it's elvish magic."

Gimli snorted a laugh. "And I'm sure it's one even the most hobbitish of hobbits could get behind, am I right."

"Absolutely," Bilbo said, raising his cup in a toast. He waited patiently, nibbling on a morning roll, for Gimli to eat more of his breakfast. It was good, there was no denying it, though Gimli had always preferred his eggs with a bit of red pepper—the kind that could be dried and ground into a hot powder. Bombur would come to be known for skill with using this spice in his chocolate confections, a foreign treat made by local hands. "I was hoping to do a bit of wandering today," Bilbo said. "I've never been to an elvish city, and I would very much like to look around. Would you like to join me?"

"I'm afraid that won't be possible," Thorin announced, appearing as if summoned behind Gimli. "We have been granted an audience with Lord Elrond," he said, clear that he felt slighted by the assumption that he could be denied audience, "and he has requested Gimli's presence."

Bilbo sagged. "Oh." He sighed.

"I could go with you, Mister Bilbo," Ori said. "The library of Rivendell is well known, and I would much like to see it."

Bilbo grinned, nodding his head to Ori. "Then that's settled. Ori and I will quest for the library," he turned back to Gimli, "and perhaps you can walk with me another day."

"Perhaps," Thorin said, and Gimli paused, mouth open. He closed it and turned to look at Thorin. "But right now, we are expected. Eat quickly," he said, then paused. "But not too quickly."

Gimli raised an eyebrow. "Of course," he said, and returned to his food. Thorin went to talk to Balin, who was waiting by the door with Gandalf, and Bilbo leaned in to Gimli.

"What is his problem?" he asked.

"Thorin is not fond of elves," Gimli said, picking up the apple and examining its skin. It was smooth and unblemished, a young green-gold that faded to a delicate flushed pink. "Because when the mountain burned, the Elvenking in Mirkwood brought his troops to the mountain, then turned away, offering no aid. It was a betrayal of trust, and many dwarves see it as the elves' fault we lost the mountain." Gimli bit the apple, relishing in the resounding crunch and the burst of sweet-tart across his tongue.

Bilbo raised an eyebrow. "They don't blame the dragon?" he asked, dry.

Gimli stared back, chewing slowly, and Bilbo seemed to flinch, as if just realizing what he said. "We know full well that it was our own actions that brought the dragon, Bilbo," he said. "But it was the lack of action on behalf of the elves after the dragon that they blame. Many feel that with the elves' help, Smaug could have been beaten back and the many trials and travails that have fallen upon our people since would have been avoided."

Bilbo nodded, tightening his grip on his teacup. "But you don't agree with them, do you?" he asked.

Gimli smiled thinly, wiping the back of his hand across his mouth. "You caught that, did you? It's not a popular opinion, and it is one better kept to yourself for now, but the wrath of a dragon is fierce, and none there then knew that better than Thranduil." He popped the last piece of apple into his mouth, swallowing it down as he stood. He would have to get more before they left. "The Elvenking has many failings, Bilbo, but protecting his people has never been one of them." He bowed and joined the others by the door.

"Ready, Master Gimli?" Gandalf asked, but while his tone was one of impatience, there was something assessing—and approving—in his gaze, almost as if he had heard what Gimli said to Bilbo. Not for the first time, Gimli wondered just how keen Gandalf's hearing was. Gimli nodded, and Gandalf led the way to Elrond's chambers, Thorin and Balin keeping pace behind, and Gimli following after.

Thorin had Orcrist strapped to his back, Gimli noted, and Gandalf had Glamdring on his belt. For a brief moment, Gimli wondered if he should not have also gone armed, but Balin was not carrying his sword, so their business must be with the troll horde. It's not as if Elrond would meet them on the training grounds, as Dain occasionally met envoys from Mirkwood.

 

They made their way through the hallways, the ceiling arching high above them. Even during mid-morning, the light had an amber quality to it, as if the entire valley was in a state of perpetual early twilight. Gimli thought of the war and the mass exodus of the elves, and wondered if the valley wasn’t onto something.

Elrond’s offices were large, and one descended into them via a long staircase that spiraled along the rounded wall. Yet, even though they most definitely walked down stairs, there was no sense of descent. It felt just as airy and open as the rest of the house; even the furniture felt like it flowed organically through the room.

Typically elvish.

Elrond was standing by a pillar next to a grand opening to a small veranda. In his hands was a graceful pitcher, and he was gently watering the greenery that lined the path. He looked up when they arrived and smiled gently at them. “Welcome,” he said, putting down the pitcher. “I hope you are finding our hospitality to your liking.”

Thorin was silent for just a beat to long, and Balin jumped in, “Very much so, thank you. A rest was sorely needed.” Thorin nodded in agreement, at last, and Gimli bowed low. He had grown to like Elrond by the end, even though his initial opinion of the Elf was somewhat low: it took time for Gimli to learn the wisdom of tactical inaction. It would never be his preferred method, but he could understand it, at least.

“Gandalf mentioned yesterday that you were in possession of some swords?” Elrond asked, and at Gandalf’s urging, Thorin unslung Orcrist and passed it to Elrond.

“We found them in a troll horde on the East Road,” Gandalf said. “We saw there were runes, but we could not make them out.”

“I can see why,” Elrond said. “These are old swords, and old Runes, rarely used any more, forged by the High Elves of the West, my kin. They were made in Gondolin for the Goblin-wars. They must have come from a dragon’s hoard or goblin plunder, for dragons and goblins destroyed that city many ages ago. This, Thorin, the runes name Orcrist, the Goblin-cleaver in the ancient tongue of Gondolin; it was a famous blade.” He passed it back, and Thorin took it with new reverence, his face far more open than Gimli had yet to see in the presence of elves. “This, Gandalf, was Glamdring, Foe-hammer that the king of Gondolin once wore. Keep them well!”

“Whence did the trolls get them, I wonder?” said Thorin securing his sword once more; it looked as if it had been made for him, and Gimli wondered how he had ever looked otherwise. Even Balin seemed to look at him with new eyes.

“I could not say,” said Elrond, “but one may guess that your trolls had plundered other plunderers, or come on the remnants of old robberies in some hold in the mountains.” He tilted his head in what Gimli had come to learn was an elvish shrug, and raised a pointed eyebrow. “I have heard that there are still forgotten treasures of old to be found in the deserted caverns of the mines of Moria, since the dwarf and goblin war.”

Thorin scowled. “There is not but misery in those old halls,” he rumbled. “Desecration and death are the only reward for those who enter there.” Balin closed his eyes and bowed his head. Gimli saw again the marble tomb, the flash of deep fire in the darkness, and had to shake himself.

“I will keep this sword in honour,” Thorin said at last, surprising a look out of Balin. “May it soon cleave goblins once again!”

“A wish that is likely to be granted soon enough in the mountains!” Elrond said. “But show me now your map!”

 

Reluctantly, Thorin pulled the map from inside his jerkin, brushing off Balin’s arm when he grabbed him with a soft, “Thorin, no!”

Elrond took the map with a nod of his head, and unrolled it gently, angling it in the morning light. “Strange,” he said. “There is much text missing, hidden, I assume. Nothing that reveals itself at the moment, but I wonder…” He handed the map back to Thorin. “Bring this here tonight at moonrise, and we will see if that changes things.”

Thorin nodded, and Elrond turned, at last, to Gimli. “And now, Son of Glóin, we turn to you.”

Gimli stood straighter as all eyes turned to him. This really was becoming an alarming habit. Had he realized, back in Ered Luin, that his little lie would come under such scrutiny, he never would have made it. Still, he was a dwarf. He would endure.

“The veil of time is not easily pierced,” he said. “And foresight is rarer still. Not many have possessed the ability, and for most the seeing is clouded and obscure." He stepped closer, and Gimli was forced to crane his neck to keep his eye. “Why you, Gimli of Ered Luin? Why have you been given this gift so denied to the rest of the world?”

Gimli thought, suddenly, of the gift at his breast, though he couldn’t say why, and he clenched his fist to keep from feeling for it, yet again.

“And why not him?” Thorin asked, breaking the spell. Elrond stepped backwards and Gimli breathed deeply, closing his eyes for a moment. “Gimli is a descendant of Durin himself, the first of our kind and Mahal’s most beloved.”

Elrond turned to Thorin. “Even the Lady Galadriel cannot tell the future with certainty, and she is the wisest of us all.”

“I doubt it’s escaped your notice,” Balin said. “But Gimli is not, in fact, an elf.” He tucked his thumb into his belt when they turned to look at him, a familiar mannerism Gimli remembered from his early tutoring. “Elves may have a hard time of it, but there is a strong tradition of far-sight among our people, and in Gimli’s line in particular. His uncle is a Reader of Stone, and one of no little skill.”

“’Reader of Stone,’” Elrond repeated. “That is not a title I’m familiar with.”

“That’s not surprising,” Gandalf cut in. “The dwarves are known for their secrecy about these matters.”

“And for good reason,” Balin retorted, but he did not say more. He crossed his arms, and glared mildly at the room at large. Gimli lowered his head. The dwarves guarded their secretly closely, true, but these traditions started only after they were burned by those they trusted. Why did no one else seem to remember this?

Gimli cleared his throat. “I do not know why I have these dreams,” he said. “Nor do I know how I have them. It is not my place to question the will of the Valar. All I know is what I see, and all I can do is my best to do good with the information I have been given.”

Elrond stood back. “Wise words,” he said. “But there is more to this than what we can know. You have been given a gift, Glóin’s son, and, I fear, a curse. The Valar do nothing without a reason, and they have chosen you. I only hope that we can discover why.”

***

Gimli left Elrond's offices at a brisk clip, too wrapped up in his own thoughts to see where he was going. At least, that's what he would say, later, to explain why he tripped over the human child crouched by the doorway.

They went down in a tangle of limbs, Gimli quickly rolling away and hoping that he hadn't crushed the boy. They were of a height, but Gimli knew he weighed a good deal more than even a grown man.

"Are you all right?" he asked, coming to his feet and crouching to help the boy up.

"I'm fine," the boy said, and shook the hair out of his face, and there was no mistaking those piercing grey eyes. Gimli's jaw dropped and he struggled to shake the expression before the lad--Aragorn! This is wee-Aragorn!--noticed. He grabbed Gimli's hand and let himself be pulled to his feet. He was rather lighter than Gimli was expecting and he nearly tossed the lad into the air. Young Aragorn's laughter was boyish and bright, and he was still giggling when he regained his footing.

"I am Estel," Young--Estel said.

"And I am Gimli, son of Glóin ," Gimli said, and bowed. "At your service."

Estel looked nonplussed. "My service?"

"Indeed," Gimli said, and explained, "It is a traditional greeting, to be sure, and a bit old fashioned, but then again we dwarves are a bit old fashioned ourselves. It is meant to express no ill-intent, for if I am at your service, then I will offer you no harm. The proper response is to say your own name, and then 'at yours and your family's.'"

"Ah," Estel said, brightening. He then bowed, a near-perfect imitation of Gimli, and said, "I am Estel, son of Gilraen, at yours and your family's." He straightened. "Like that?"

Gimli grinned. "You'll make a proper dwarf yet!" he said, and laughed. Estel smiled wryly.

"And why not?" he said. "For I am to also be a proper Man and a proper Elf. Why should I not be a proper Dwarf, as well?" His smile faded and he looked away. Here he is, Gimli thought. It is no wonder that he grows into such a sour adult. At least Lady Arwen makes him smile. Estel sank to the floor once more, arms wrapped around his knees.

"It is not easy, is it?" Gimli asked quietly, "Learning to be Noble. There are many rules and many variations of those rules, and to break those rules means mortal offense to any number of people."

Estel sighed. “My parents were Rangers. One day, I will be a ranger, too. I’m never going to need this!” His pounded his fist against the floor.

Gimli raised his eyebrows. Aragorn had been reluctant to take up his birthright the first time Gimli had met him. It seemed as if those attitudes began early. “That may be so,” Gimli said. “But you never know what the future may bring. If you learn it, and never need it, what’s the harm in knowing? But if you don’t learn it, and do need it...”

“I know,” Estel said, sighing. “It still stinks.”

“Aye,” Gimli said. “It does.” Estel looked up at him, and smiled shyly. Gimli reached out and ruffled his hair, making Estel laugh and bat at Gimli’s hand. “So,” Gimli said. “What do you do for fun around here?”

“I really enjoy my riding lessons,” Estel said, brightening. Gimli considered him, and remembered his affection for Brego and the people of Rohan. “Sorry, lad,” he said. “Horses and I don’t really mix. What about games? You know, fun! Sport. Horse-less horseplay?”

Estel just shrugged. Gimli shook his head. “Oh, no, lad. That just won’t do. Come on. There are people whom you must meet.” He stood and held out a hand. “Come on.”

Estel took his hand, and let Gimli lead him through the halls.

Fíli and Kíli were sitting on a bench near a large fountain, smoking their pipes. Fíli was actually seated on the back of the bench, his boots braced on the seat, but Kíli was sitting properly, kicking his feet like a young dwarfling.

“Now,” Gimli said. “My cousins always made the best games. I am sure they will have some good ideas.”

Kíli saw them first, and thumped Fíli’s leg. “Gimmers!” Kíli called out. “You’ve caught yourself a shadow!”

“Hello shadow!” Fíli said. “Do you have a name?”

“I am Estel, son of Gilraen, at your service,” Estel said, bowing. The princes grinned.

“Fíli,”

“And Kíli,”

“Sons of Dís. At yours and your family's,” they said, and bowed in unison.

“And how may we be of service, Son of Gilraen?” Fíli asked.

Gimli cleared his throat. “Estel here has never played a game.”

“What?” Kíli asked, nearly dropping his pipe.

“Never?” Fíli asked. The brothers exchanged a look.

***

Lindir was a creature of habit, and it was his his habit to oversee the many gardens of Imladris. True, he could have delegated this task, as he did many others, but he enjoyed, no delighted in walking the garden paths, and made sure to do it at least once a day. It was a job he especially enjoyed now that they were playing host to a company of...dwarves. The dwarves did not walk the paths. The dwarves did not spend their time in the gardens. The gardens were then the perfect escape from--

Estel ran past, shouting with excited joy, and Lindir was glad to see the boy to happy. He was such a serious youth, and with the weight of his ancestry it was no wonder. Then, however, three--Three--of the dwarves ran after him, tossing some sort of ball around by some set of complicated rules, and Lindir turned tail and strode away at a stately, measured run.

***

Lord Elrond would have an easier time, Gimli thought later on, grabbing a moment for himself, if he knew the whole truth. I should tell him; he can be trusted to keep the secret. I just need to get away from Thorin. He can know nothing yet. Of that much I am sure.

Fíli walked by, fully armed, swords strapped to his back. Kíli walked swiftly beside him, with bow and full quiver. “Oi,” Gimli called out. “Where’s the battle?” They weren’t going to fight with Estel, were they?

They stopped, and Kíli broke into a grin. “Gimmers!” he said. “Estel had lessons, so we’ve the afternoon free.”

“We’re going to the training ground,” Fíli said. “Grab your axes, yeah? Come with us.”

Fíli didn’t need to ask twice; a good old fashioned sparring match or three was just what the physic ordered.

The training grounds in Rivendell were, like most elven setups, geared more towards archery than anything else. It was long said that elves learned the art of war through hunting, and Gimli thought that was nowhere clearer than in Mirkwood, where they still battled the darkness around them. Here, the grounds were—cleaner wasn’t the word. Less weathered was closer to it, even though Rivendell was far older than her cousin to the East.

Kíli looked over the archery range, shading his eyes with his hand. “We should have come at twilight,” he said. “I can barely see the targets in this glare.”

“It makes no sense,” Fíli said, mild. “How many battles are fought in the daylight, anyway? Orcs and Goblins only come out in darkness.”

“Elven eyes see better in daylight,” Gimli said. “Has something to do with the way their eyes were made, and the light before the sun.”

“Oh yeah?” Kíli said, arching an eyebrow. “And how do you know that?”

Gimli rolled his eyes. “When you were thinking of new ways to make Balin pull his beard out by the root, I was actually listening, that’s how,” he said. “Just because it was elven history doesn’t mean it wasn’t relevant. Elves ruled these lands for ages, and get rather fixated on themselves as a result. Sometimes, it doesn’t matter how relevant your own story is, you need to know the stories people actually tell.”

Fíli snorted. “Figures. You don’t see the elves learning two sets of history, do you? No. Just us.”

“If not us, then who?” Kíli asked. He turned back to the range. There were easily two dozen lanes, and most were empty. “But now, I think I’m going to show these elves who can really shoot.” He pulled himself up and sauntered over to the range.

“’You don’t go against elves in archery,’” Fíli said under his breath. “He doesn’t really get it at all, does he?”

Gimli shook his head. Before them, Kíli approached the lanes, and was greeted by a tall elf with long golden hair and dressed in leathers dyed a deep blue. After a moment, the elf bowed, and Kíli strung his bow.

“I can’t watch this,” Fíli said. “Spar with me?”

“Aye,” Gimli said, and led them to the nearest sparring round. Elven fighting was by no means less deadly than dwarven styles, but it was lighter, for lack of a better word. Elven fighters danced their way through battle, where dwarves barreled through like a charging Oliphaunt. Thus, the round was little more than an half-inch trench in a circle on the hard earth floor. There were no pitfalls, no trench to prevent the spread of blood. There were no judges stands or seating at all.

Oh well. It would have to do.

Gimli unslung his axe, and Fíli readied his swords. They faced off, weapons braced in front of them and feet firmly rooted to the ground. So far, no one was paying them any attention.

Gimli smirked. That would change.

Without warning, Gimli let loose with a fierce war-cry, charging forward. Fíli side-stepped neatly and returned the cry as a taunt, but Gimli spun on his front foot, twisting to send his axe swinging past Fíli's head. Fíli’s sword came up and knocked Gimli’s axe aside, but the move had served its purpose and Gimli was once again facing Fíli and bearing down.

Fíli countered easily—he had always been the best of the three—and the two of them danced about the ring, dwarven steel clanging and echoing across the distant mountains.

Gimli had to keep reminding himself to pull his swings; he still wasn’t at his full adult strength, but his blade was so sharp that it did not matter. If Gimli wasn’t careful, he might slice something off of Fíli, something permanent.

Still, Fíli was undaunted, and Gimli quickly had to adapt, pulling old moves from his memory and hoping his body was on board. His new axe was a blessing, and the lessened weight meant he could move with his old speed, spinning out of the way of Fíli’s doubled swords. Gimli wasn’t sure how long they fought, matched more evenly than ever before, when he heard Nori call out “Odds on the prince!”

A quick glance revealed most of the Company and quite a few of the elves had been brought over by the display, and Nori was quickly running numbers for both dwarf and elf alike. The blond from before seemed very keen, and Kíli called out;

“I’ve got winner!”

“I’ll deal with you in a moment,” Fíli called back, and Gimli grinned, bearing his teeth as he felt the thrill of battle rise within him. He would make Fíli work for every amount of confidence he showed, and maybe, just maybe, by the time they reached Erebor, it would be enough.

Fíli faltered, and Gimli pressed his advantage, stepping in a disarming him far too easily. They stood, at last, with Gimli’s axe pressed close to Fíli’s throat and Gimli asked. “Do ye yield?”

“Aye,” Fíli said, softly. “I yield.”

Gimli frowned. Something was wrong. “Fíli?” he asked.

Fíli shook his head. “You won, little cousin,” he said, louder. “Good luck against my brother.”

“Not just yet,” Dwalin said, and Gimli turned. He hadn’t seen his teacher standing there. “It’s been months since you’ve had a proper lesson.” Dwalin unslung his axes, Grasper and Keeper. “And I’m in the teaching mood.”

Fíli quickly bowed out, going to stand by his brother, and Gimli turned to Dwalin, settling into the same ready stance he had used with Fíli.

This time, Dwalin attacked first, bellowing as he charged, spinning his axes in tight circles. Gimli had to dodge and jump, practically running in the face of Dwalin’s frenzied attack. His long axe would help him little here, and he jabbed the hilt at Dwalin’s feet, making him leap to avoid tripping, and it was just enough time for Gimli to unsling his own axes, countering Dwalin’s strike for strike. Sparks flew as the metal met, but Gimli stood his ground, flowing with the motions, but never retreating.

The crowd had gone silent, watching the display before them. Gimli could hear nothing but the roaring of time in his ears, could smell the stink of battle and feel its toll in the sweat running down his back and across his forehead.

Dwalin crowded in close and landed a blow to Gimli’s gut with the handle of Grasper, and Gimli dropped out of range of Keeper’s backswing, gasping for breath.

But he would not fall so easily.

He used his momentum to roll in, knocking into Dwalin’s legs like a boulder, and popping up over him, axe in hand and ready to mark the “kill.” But Dwalin was ready for him, and knocked his hand aside. His other hand shot out and grabbed Gimli by the neck, to the gasps of the audience. It was a tactic used by instructors on first year students, a lesson of humility.

Gimli stopped moving, and Dwalin said, “Do ye yield?”

“Never,” Gimli said, and cast his eyes downward. Dwalin followed the line, and there at Dwalin’s belt, was Gimli’s dagger, places well to spill his innards. “Do ye?”

Dwalin grit his teeth and sneered, but when Gimli simply raised an eyebrow, he barked a laugh and let Gimli loose. “Aye,” he said. “I yield.”

“No!” Nori called out. “No, not fair!” Apparently, the house had just lost.

Dwalin rocked to his feet, and held his hand out to Gimli. “Where did you learn that, lad? Not from me.” His voice was mild, for Dwalin, which meant there was only the threat of violence under his words. While Dwalin would never begrudge Gimli and skill that would aid him in battle, knifework was nearly as undwarven as, say, archery, requiring the fighter to move in much too elven a way for most dwarves. It didn’t stop Fíli, however, who was generally armed more like a metal porcupine than anything else, and thus it didn’t stop Kíli or Gimli, though neither had taken it to Fíli’s extreme.

“No,” Gimli said. “I didn’t.” It had been Legolas who inspired him to dust off his old set and learn more knife-work, so they could practice together. In his older days, he had been fond of using his skills to best Elladan and Elrohir; they never quite stopped being surprised when Gimli would pull knives on them, and the looks on their faces had always been worth it. Gimli grinned, and then the rest of them were crowding around, congratulating Gimli on his victory. Glóin was particularly proud, and Óin was nearly weeping.

Over the heads of the Company, Gimli caught sight of Thorin and Gandalf watching from the distance, and it caught him like ice. He nodded greeting, and Thorin returned it, face never breaking its stony expression.

There was a hand on his shoulder, much too long for a dwarf, and Gimli looked up into the face of the blond elf from the range. “Congratulations on your victory, Gimli son of Glóin.”

Gimli blinked up at him, remembering to bow only after the fact. “My thanks,” he said. “But how do you know my name?” There was something familiar about this elf. He had seen him before, but where? In Arda? In Rivendell?

The elf smiled, wider than any Gimli had yet seen in this time. “Why, your cousin told me,” he said, and gestured to Kíli behind him. “Your match was enough to draw him from our own competition.” He smiled at Kíli, who flushed through his ears. “He is quite the competitor himself.”

“He’s just saying that,” Kíli mumbled. “He had my score beat twice over.”

“I am sure you would have caught up eventually,” he said. “But I am being rude; I know your name but you do not yet know mine. I am Glorfindel of Rivendell.” Here, he laid his hand on his breast and bowed in elven fashion.

“The Balrog-slayer!” Gimli blurted out, memory connecting at last. Glorfindel had been at Elrond’s council, and had come at the climax of the war with Elrond’s sons. He was a legend of the first age, originally from Gondolin and reborn after defeating a Balrog of Morgoth—one of the few elves to live on, as well, in the dwarven histories. Glorfindel raised an eyebrow.

“I see you have heard of me,” he said.

“Of course he has,” Glóin said. “My son knows his histories well.”

“It’s true,” Fíli said. “Gimli has always had a head for words, story, and song.”

Glorfindel’s eyes light with a new light. “Do you indeed?” he asked. “Well, then you must come to The Hall of Fire! It is where we gather to share tales and song. None are turned away, and all may have their chance to speak.”

“Sounds like my kind of place,” Bofur said. “Is there ale?”

“Aye,” Glorfindel said. “Though wine is a more common choice.”

Bofur grinned. “Sounds perfect.” Gimli had to agree. He had planned on leading Bilbo to the Hall before they left, and this sounded like a perfect opportunity.

“Would we really be welcome?” Ori asked quietly, and the dwarves all quieted to hear the answer, looking first to Ori, who blushed. “I mean,” he said, “We have all been to welcoming places that are so to all but us.”

“Aye,” Dwalin added. “We heard your elven songcraft on our way through the valley.”

Glorfindel’s face softened, and his smile sobered. “You need not fear of your welcome,” he said. “The elves here care more for song than for the politics of this world. They truly welcome all with good intentioned hearts, even if they can be rather silly.”

“Then we would love to,” Fíli said, standing a little taller. “We’re long overdue for an evening of song, right lads?”

“Aye,” Gimli said, the Company chorusing around him.

“Then it is settled,” Glorfindel said. “You shall join us for story and song this evening.” He held out his hand in invitation for Gimli. Then, with the same hand, extended the gesture to Kíli, then the others. Kíli, who had begun to fall back, the disappointed expression on his face making him look his age, lifted his head and joined them. “Do you sing as well?” he asked, smiling at Kíli.

“All dwarves sing,” Kíli said, shrugging his shoulders. Gimli repressed a smile; if Glorfindel ever heard some of their sacred music, Gimli doubted he would think it singing.

“Really?” Glorfindel asked, eyes wide. He looked between the two of them. “I had no idea.”

“Not many do,” Kíli assured him, patting him on the arm then looking at his hand like it had a mind of its own.

“Not many sing like elves, that’s for sure,” Fíli said, joining his brother.

Glorfindel nodded at him. “That is true enough. Not many sing as elves do. Still, I would like to hear dwarven singing, if you are so inclined this evening.”

Gimli looked at his cousins. “I think we may be able to come up with something.”

Fíli raised his eyebrow at Gimli, while Glorfindel beamed.

***

“Singing!” Glóin near-shouted, back in their rooms. Gimli shook his finger in his ear to ease the slight ringing. It seemed like yelling was all his father had done since they came to Rivendell. “You would share our songs with them?” Glóin was nearly incoherent with rage. Nearly. “Gimli—they are elves!”

“Aye,” Gimli snapped. “Elves. Elves of Rivendell, not Mirkwood.”

“You think that really matters?” Glóin asked. “They will laugh. They will mock and insult, simply because you are a dwarf and to them you will always be less.”

“Naugrim they call us,” Óin said from where he sat at the table. “Stunted. As if we were not made to be exactly what we are.” He shook his head.

“They call hobbits periannath,” Bilbo said, voice dry, “and we certainly aren’t half of anything. I don’t think it’s personal.”

Balin patted Bilbo on the shoulder. “That doesn’t actually make it better, lad,” he said.

Bofur shook his head. “Well, I still think it’s a fine idea. We need more song on this journey, and the Hall of Fire seems like an ideal place to do it.”

“You’re not going!” Glóin said. “And that’s final.”

***

“We’re going to get in so much trouble,” Ori said as Kíli and Fíli peeked their head around the corner. Gimli patted Ori on the back. They had waited until the others had gone to bed, listening on the balcony to the distant strains of song from the hall. Luckily for them, Bofur had been on first watch, and turned a blind eye as they slipped out.

“No one’s coming,” Kíli said.

“Thorin and Balin left a long time ago, and could be back any minute,” Fíli said.

Gimli walked past them. “Then we’d best not dawdle,” he said, and then he was walking very quickly as his cousins chased after him. By the time they hit the end of the hall they were running flat out, as best they could while laughing, anyway.

Glorfindel was waiting for them by the main hall where they had dined their first night, and by his side was Bilbo, pipe unlit between his teeth and thumbs thrust importantly into the sides of his vest. Glorfindel greeted them with a smile, laughing as Kíli greeted Bilbo once more as "Master Boggins," to Bilbo's amused faux-displeasure, and ushered them through the doors.

They passed through several smaller halls, walking quickly to keep pace with the long-legged elf, and came at last to a large hall with no tables or chairs, but with a large fire burning merrily in the center of the room. The walls were draped with many fabrics of bright colors that reflected the light of the fire, and while many elves stood in clustered, speaking and laughing, and others danced gaily to music provided by an array of musicians, a few chose to lounge on the many cushions and pillows strewn about the room. It was a decadent design, made for long hours of opulence, and quite removed from any life his cousins and Ori had known. Even Gimli, with his long exposure to elven lifestyles, had rarely seen such places. The elves in Mirkwood tended towards more lively gatherings.

They paused in the entranceway, and looked about. Ori frowned. "Is that elvish dancing?" he asked.

"Aye, looks like," Gimli said. He knew why Ori was asking; Elves danced like branches in the wind, or sea-plants caught in a current, with many graceful sways and swoops. It was a far cry from the fast-paced athleticism of dwarven dancing.

"But how do they know who wins?" Ori asked.

"I don't think it's that kind of dancing," Bilbo said. Gimli looked over to him, and Bilbo shrugged. "It's nothing like hobbit dancing, either." He looked over the scene before them. "Nobody's doing a jig on the table, that's for sure." Gimli couldn't quite tell if Bilbo was disappointed by that or not.

"Come!" Glorfindel said suddenly, and then they were following him through the crowd, drawing strange looks but none of them were overtly hostile. Mainly, Gimli felt not unlike a trick pony, but one that was honestly admired for his ability. Ori hung to the back, unnerved by the attention, and Fíli didn't seem too keen on being the center of such attention. Kíli didn't seem to notice, and was openly ogling the male harpist from dinner, who thankfully didn't seem to notice him.

Bilbo, on the other hand, was in his element, and within minutes was discussing poetry with a trio of elves draped over themselves on a long amber colored cushion.

"Well," Glorfindel said, coming up to them. "What do you think of elven music?"

"It suits you," Gimli said, and Glorfindel laughed.

"You did not tell me your were training to be a diplomat, son of Glóin," he said.

"He's a cousin to kings," Fíli said. "Of course he'd being trained as a diplomat. He's quite good at it, too, when he can keep his temper." Gimli stuck his tongue at Fíli, who returned the gesture.

"I'm terrible at it," Kíli admitted. "Too many arbitrary rules. I'm a dwarf who likes function in his designs."

"To be fair," Gimli said, "Many of those rules had a function at one point." He turned to Glorfindel. "There is a calling in creating beauty in function, and the many rules of court are an example of such; it is as much a craft as any other, and it takes time and aptitude to learn."

"Gimli," Fíli said, a hint of warning in his voice, but Gimli waved him off.

"Relax, cousin. I've told nothing that any would find fault with. And remember why we are here, after all."

Glorfindel leaned in with excitement. "That's right! You are going to show us dwarven music!"

It was as if his words were a sort of signal, and the hall fell silent save for the crackling of the fire and the sort of hum that pervades the air when a crowd is quiet.

"I think that's our cue, Fíli."

"I think you're right, Kíli."

Gimli put an arm around Ori and led him over to where Bilbo was sitting. "What is it?" Bilbo asked.

"My cousins are about to show off," he said. Behind them, Fíli had pulled out his fiddle and was tuning the strings. Kíli, his own fiddle in his hands, was stomping his boot and listening intently, gauging the acoustics of the room.

Kíli stopped, and the brothers shared a look. Then, as one, they raised their bows to their instruments.

Kíli played first, a mournful little melody that Gimli recognized as a refrain from a lullaby from the East. Fíli followed, playing the same melody, but dropping half an octave. Kíli went again, playing another melody line, a little bit faster. Again, Fíli followed half an octave lower. Kíli played a third line, holding the last note for half a beat longer, then they were playing as one, fiddles flying as the melodies raced and soared, dancing around each other to the beat as Fíli and Kíli stomped their boots.

The elves were entranced, leaning in intently, they seemed to be swept away by the song, breath catching as the melody popped and tumbled. Fíli chased Kíli higher and higher until they reached the peak, dropped their bows to clap their hands against the back of the fiddle in a complicated rhythm, calling out "Hey!" and bringing the melody back without missing a beat as they swept their fiddles up once more.

The elf sitting next to Gimli gasped, and clapped his…her?...didn’t matter hands together excitedly as the brothers began to dance.

The thing about dwarven dancing, Gimli thought, is that when it’s done well, it looks incredibly easy. Much like the way the best warriors look natural as breathing when they wield their weapons, so too do the best dancers look as if they were born to move this way. In reality, it takes years, decades, to learn the dances, longer still to master them. Formal dwarven dancing was nearly a craft in itself, one in which all nobility were required to achieve at least journeyman status.

This was not formal dancing. This was the dancing of their people, the common born; the movements mimicked the rhythm of the work, and their stomping boots the heartbeat of the mountain. Together they danced the fiddler’s jig, knees high as they spun in circles around each other.

Across the room, a pair of elves sprung to their feet from the cushions, and so moved by song, began to dance themselves. It was unearthly graceful, as all elven dancing was, but there was an element of fire to their faces, an earthiness in their movements that was entirely dwarven by design.

Fíli and Kíli split, taking off in a skipping run around the fire, and where they went the elves danced. Some musicians, keen of ear, had picked up the melody and began to play along. Even Bilbo ended up on his feet, dancing in the unrestrained way of hobbits.

The brothers danced around the hall, and ended up at last where they had begun, and played the final racing chords up to the end of the song. They ended with a flourish, pausing for a moment, bows raised to the sky, and the entire hall cheered and filled with laughter.

“Oh, what fun!” Bilbo said, sitting once more, face flushed and breath heavy. “I think I’m developing quite the taste for dwarvish music. Though, it doesn’t quite compare what I heard in Bag End.”

“Of course not,” Gimli said. “This is not the deep music; that is not for the ears of any outside our mountains. This is inn-music, played wherever drink flows strongest.”

Bilbo nodded, thoughtfully.

A trio of elven musicians—one with a harp, one with a flute, and one with the oddest looking horn Gimli had ever seen—were pressing Fíli and Kíli for more song. Fíli looked ready to demur, he was not as keen as Gimli nor as reckless as Kíli when it came to sharing their culture, but Kíli had a look in his eyes.

“Well, this seems like a regular party,” said a familiar voice behind Gimli, and he turned to see Bofur with a mug of ale.

“Where did you get that?” Gimli asked, and then held up his hand. Who was he kidding? This was Bofur. “I don’t want to know.”

“Aye,” Nori said, appearing on Gimli’s other side. “Best not.”

Gimli shook his head, bemused, and turned back just in time to see Kíli's face light up with a plan. “Bofur!” he called out. “How about a song!”

“A song!” Bofur cried back. “Why do you think I’d sing a song?”

Kíli paused for a moment. “Because you’re…you?”

Bofur grinned. “Right you are!” he said, and hopped up onto a plush ottoman. “All right, lads! A true song for a true ale.” He lifted his mug and took a swig. “Sing along if you know it.” With a deep breath, he began:

There is an inn, a merry old inn
beneath an old grey hill,
And there they brew a beer so brown
That the Man in the Moon himself came down
One night to drink his fill!

Gimli sang along, as did Ori and Kíli and, surprisingly, Bilbo. The elves did not appear to know the words, but they picked up the rhythm easily enough, and clapped along, some of the braver ones laughing. At last, with a dramatic pause, Bofur sang the last of the song.
.
With a ping and a pong the fiddle-strings broke!
the cow jumped over the Moon,
And the little dog laughed to see such fun,
And the Saturday dish went off at a run
with the silver Sunday spoon.
The round Moon rolled behind the hill
as the Sun raised up her head.
She hardly believed her fiery eyes;
For though it was day, to her surprise
they all went back to bed!

He tipped back his ale at the end, drinking the rest down, and raised the empty mug high in victory. Gimli cheered, and was joined by Bombur, who had a surprisingly warm voice when he could be persuaded to speak.

“What fun!” Glorfindel said, returning to them from across the fire. “Dwarven song is full of such life! But tell me, is it all tavern songs and army chants?”

Gimli raised an eyebrow. “Is all elven song tragic? Melodic but with no drums to speak of?”

Glorfindel shook his head. “No, of course not.”

“Then why,” Gimli asked slowly, “would all dwarven song be the same? We sing for many reasons, and have many styles spread across our kingdoms. What’s more, we craft, and create, and build new styles as we continue on. We sing to remember, Master Balrog-Slayer. We sing our past, so we may hope for a better future.”

Glorfindel’s easy humor had faded, leaving behind a sincerity that would be easy to read as cold if one did not remember that elves burn with starlight, not with sunlight. “And there is much to sing of, I fear.”

“Aye,” Gimli agreed. “But we are lucky we do; all too often our books are lost. Ori could tell you.”

“The library of Erebor was immense,” Ori sighed. “One could wander for days and not reach every hallway. The collected knowledge of our people, our history; it was all there on silvered vellum wrapped in the finest leathers.” He sighed. “It’s all probably ash, now.”

Glorfindel looked surprised. “You speak as if you remember such a place. Surely you are too young to remember.”

“Oh, I wasn’t born yet,” Ori said, “Neither was Nori, and Dori was yet a dwarfling. No, Balin has told me tales.”

“Balin,” Glorfindel said softly. He shook his head. “Time has little meaning here,” he said. “I had not realized there would be those of you here who would remember.”

“We all remember,” Gimli said. “Whether we were there or not has no difference.” He stood. “If you’ll excuse me.” He walked over to Fíli and Kíli, who were quickly packing away their fiddles.

“We should sing it,” Gimli said. “Remind these elves that we are more than tavern songs and quick jokes.”

Fíli frowned. “Did something happen? You look mad.”

“How can you tell?” Kíli asked, but he looked concerned as well. “Did someone say something?”

“Yes—no,” Gimli shook his head. “I think we should.”

“Then we will,” Kíli said, grabbing an arm each. “The sound is best by the fire. Trust me.” He half-dragged them over to the fire in the middle of the room, and set them up in a triangle around the flames.

It wasn’t that Gimli didn’t trust Kíli, it’s just that he trusted his own ears a far sight more. He stopped his foot and cocked his head; the curve of the arch brought the sound around in a perfect echo; it was like they were back in Erebor already, the long sounds echoing off the polished walls.

“Ready?” Kíli asked, and Fíli and Gimli nodded. He cleared his throat and the near elves fell quiet. Bofur fell quiet, too, and watched them with intense eyes that read strange in his merry face.

Kíli raised his head first and began to sing, letting out a long, clear note. It radiated out and bounced off the walls, catching Gimli at all angles, and he listened to the resonance of each note. Fíli sang next, up half an octave, his voice blending seamlessly with his brother. Gimli sang last, the lowest note in the chord, and they held the harmony for a full three beats. When they fell quiet, the hall was silent, waiting. Three sets of dwarven eyes glittered at them from the half-dark, but none of the mattered. Gimli closed his eyes, and Fíli began to sing.

 

Oh, misty eye of the mountain below
Keep careful watch of my brothers’ souls
And should the sky be filled with fire and smoke
Keep watching over Durin's sons

They three sang, raising their voices together before Fíli sang again, Kíli echoing above.

If this is to end in fire
Then we should all burn together
Watch the flames climb high into the night
Calling out father oh stand by and we will
Watch the flames burn auburn on
The mountain side high

From the dimness of the hall, other dwarven voices raised up their chants, and someone, probably Bombur, began to drum. Gimli added his voice to the verse.

And if we should die tonight
We should all die together
Raise a glass of wine for the last time
Calling out father oh
Prepare as we will
Watch the flames burn auburn on
The mountain side
Desolation comes upon the sky

With the next verse they began to dance, stomping their boots with the drums, clapping their hands together, against their chests, snapping their fingers in time with the song as they began to circle the flames. Their hair flew behind them as they spun, the heat of the flames warm and dizzying.

Now I see fire
Inside the mountain
I see fire
Burning the trees
And I see fire
Hollowing souls
I see fire
Blood in the breeze

They stopped, and sang still to each other.

And I hope that you'll remember me

They spun away. The voices from the crowd were growing stronger. Gimli saw Dori, Óin and Glóin. Dwalin and Balin stood with Bifur. They all sang, proud and shining, and coming closer, ringing the fire. There was only one dwarf missing.

Oh, should my people fall then
Surely I'll do the same
Confined in mountain halls
We got too close to the flame
Calling out father oh
Hold fast and we will
Watch the flames burn auburn on
The mountain side
Desolation comes upon the sky

The ring began to dance, opposite to the three at the fire. It was a vision of what the dances in the Lonely Mountain used to be, circles within spirals, every step perfectly placed or it would send the entire dance grinding to a halt.

Now I see fire
Inside the mountains
I see fire
Burning the trees
And I see fire
Hollowing souls
I see fire
Blood in the breeze

There. Thorin. Inside the outer circle, and watching without moving, without singing until now, when he added his voice to the chorus…

And I hope that you'll remember me

…and joined them in the dance, lending his deep timbre to Fíli’s lead and they spun and spun and spun, the pain and determination in his voice captivating, crystallizing the moment, and it was all Gimli could do to keep up, swept along in th the power of his voice.

And if the night is burning
I will cover my eyes
For if the dark returns then
My brothers will die
And as the sky is falling down
It crashed into this lonely town
And with that shadow upon the ground
I hear my people screaming out

And they cried out! Voices raised to practically roaring,

And I see fire!
Inside the mountains
I see fire
Burning the trees
I see fire
Hollowing souls
I see fire
Blood in the breeze

They froze, stomping down with one final echo, lending their voices as as Fíli and Thorin sang together:

I see fire
Burn auburn on the mountain side.

Gimli realized he was practically panting, but he could not look away from Thorin, who looked more kingly than ever in the dimness in the hall, the beads in his hair and crags of his face etched with firelight. Thorin met his gaze, deep eyes glinting cat-green, and Gimli bowed.

Someone began to clap. “Excellent!” Gandalf called over. “Simply, excellent!” Gimli looked, and Gandalf stood next to Lord Elrond, who looked almost surprised, as if he hadn’t expected dwarves singing in his hall—no. As if he hadn’t expected Thorin to be in the thick of it. He resisted the urge to shake his head; it never ceased to surprise him how little elves really understood of them.

Thorin bowed, accepting the compliment, and clasped his hand to Fíli’s shoulder, passing the praise on to where it belonged. Fíli flashed a rare beaming grin, and Thorin bumped their foreheads together.

“Yes, it was,” Thorin said, still close. “But that is enough for tonight. Stay if you wish, but no more songs.”

“Yes, Uncle,” Fíli said, Kíli chorusing right behind him. Thorin paused, looking over at Gimli.

“I promise,” Gimli said quickly, and Thorin may have possibly given him the tiniest of smiles before disappearing back into the crowd, stopping only to nod at Bilbo and smack his hand across the back of Dwalin’s head.

“Well,” Bilbo said, popping up at Gimli’s side. “That was fun!”

***

It was as if that night marked something—an easing of hostility, if not an all-out cease fire. The elves that brought them food and drink thought now to ask for their preferences, and in turn the Company kept their tempers when faced with elvish frippery and nonsense. Thorin was even seen walking with Lord Elrond once or twice in their nearly three week stay, though they always had Gandalf walking with them. Still, they knew their time there was coming to an end, and once more then began to pack camp, ready to leave at any time.

One night, a little over week since their foray to the Halls of Fire, Bilbo wished to walk and asked Gimli for company. Honestly, Gimli was glad to have it; he loved his cousins, had missed them fiercely for most of his life, but absence had seemingly made him forget just how tiring it was to be in their constant presence. They left just after supper, when the sun was reaching towards the end of the sky, but the world was not yet turned to red and gold, and together they walked through the fires of sunset and into the blues of gathering twilight. They talked of many things: Rivendell, their journey, various family stories. Gimli made Bilbo laugh with tales of Fíli and Kíli before Fíli’s beard grew in, and Bilbo in turn made Gimli snort with laughter with tales of his exploits as a young hobbit with a tendency for Tookish pranks. It was good conversation, as Bilbo was quite quick witted when not overrun by unexpected company, and reminded Gimli so much of his friends that he longed to hear Pippin and Merry bickering, or Sam grumbling under his breath, or the rare bird of Frodo’s laughter.

Gimli hummed, laughter easing to a comfortable silence. "Truly,” he said after a moment. “There is not a dwarfling that I've yet met that wouldn't like the life of a hobbit, nothing to do but work and eat and simply live." Gimli paused. "Though, I do fear dwarves prefer to get their hands dirty in a different sort of earth than hobbits."

Bilbo chuckled. He had a high-pitched giggling sort of laughter that was very infectious, and Gimli could see why Thorin was so smitten. "True," Bilbo said. "Dwarves don't seem to take much of gardening, though they enjoy the spoils well enough. I saw you with those apples."

Gimli flushed. "Fresh fruit is rare in the mountain, and while only a fool would call gardening easy work, it's far too fleeting for many dwarves' taste. The work only lasts a season, maybe two, then all of nature works against you. And the result—what isn't eaten fades and rots. Metal and stone do not rot.

"Neither do pickles and preserves, and I have seen both in your packs," Bilbo countered. "And I've no doubt that if any on Middle Earth could find a way to grow food in winter, it would be a dwarf."

Gimli laughed. "Aye. You're probably right. But the Green and Growing are the providence of the Green Lady, and no dwarf would dare cross the wife of our Maker. It is often said that dwarf women were made in her image, and if you ever meet a dwarrowdam, you'll understand our hesitance."

Bilbo grinned. "I've got a pretty good idea already, of the letter from Thorin's sister is any indication."

"The Lady Dís is a force in her own right, and that she was chosen not to join us speaks highly to her wisdom," Gimli said. "And that both of her sons are...well, Fíli and Kíli..."

"Say no more," Bilbo said, laughing. "I am well aware that the foolishness of youth has little to do with the parent. Remind me to tell you of my Brandybuck cousins."

Gimli smiled, remembering a particular Brandybuck cousin, and his lifelong Took companion. "I'd like that," Gimli said.

"Are you sure?" Bilbo asked. "Get a hobbit talking about family..."

"Is like asking a dwarf about craft," Gimli said. "But that is for another time." They could see a merry little fire on the balcony above their heads. A cooking fire. Nori, standing by the edge, saw them and waved.

Bilbo sighed. "What are they burning?"

That better not be the furniture, Gimli thought. I thought we were past that! "Best not ask," he said. "It may be better if you do not know."

Bilbo opened his mouth, eyes narrowing, stopped, though better of it, then shook his head, wandering away. Gimli watched him go for a moment, seeing with his mind instead a weathered old hobbit, helped along by his younger nephew. He shook the image off, but before he could follow:

"Master Gimli," Gandalf said from behind him, and Gimli started.

"Gandalf," Gimli gasped, a hand to his chest. "How may I help you?"

"You may talk," Gandalf said. "The time has come."

Notes:

The link at the song is to Peter Hollens's cover of "I See Fire" because it sounds more dwarven to me, somehow.