Chapter Text
There were few tales that either his cousin or his husband could tell that Gimli could not counter with one of his own, and where he lacked stories, Tauriel proved to be a surprisingly bountiful source. No one escaped that room unscathed.
So, it was with his pride bruised, but still intact, that Gimli found himself helping Kíli once more bring Fíli to the council chambers. Fíli, somewhere between laughing at their shared tales and being helped onto his litter, had fallen into a rather dark mood, and was churlish and snappish. He did not say much, perhaps realizing the sudden onset of his distemper, but his mood would not have been more obvious if there had been a black stormcloud over his head.
“Cheer up, brother,” Kíli said. “Cousin Óin said you’d be back on your feet before the end of winter.”
“I wouldn’t be so cross if you would hold be a bit higher,” Fíli said. “It has been decades since I was so low to the ground.”
“Has it?” Kíli asked. “I hadn’t noticed. To be honest, everyone below a certain height looks the same to me.”
“You’re only eight centimeters taller!”
“Yes,” Kíli said, grinning. “eight whole centimeters.”
Fíli sighed. “Gimli, please tell me you’ll grow taller than my dear brother, so you can put him in his proper place.”
“Afraid not,” Gimli said. “I’m not going to grow more than a centimeter or two, excepting in the shoulders.” Legolas’s face scrunched as he bit down on whatever comment he was going to make, and Gimli winked at him.
“It must be very strange,” Tauriel said. “To know just how you will grow.”
Gimli smiled at her as they passed through into the council chamber. “There is so much strange in my life now, lass, that knowing just how long my beard will grow ranks very low.”
“And just how long will it grow?” Dain called out gleefully from across the chamber. Thorin stood behind him and cuffed him about the back of the head in the familiar way of old families. The line was a clear allusion to one of the bawdier drinking songs that Dain had liked to hum in council when the slow machinations of court proved too tedious even for him. It was a song, however, that Gimli, at sixty-four, should have been too young to know. Of course Gimli, even at sixty-four, had two older cousins and therefore knew the entire song by heart.
”Lower than my stones do dangle,” Gimli called back, quick as a wink, to Dain’s uproarious laughter. Several of the dwarves laughed, though looked appalled that Gimli would know that song, and more that he would use their secret tongue before others when not on the battlefield. Gimli ignored the lot of ‘em. There were bigger issues than pointless secrecy at stake.
The room where the council was to be held was, in fact, King Thror’s stateroom, where he would meet with his councilors, ambassadors, and other dignitaries and diplomats. As such it was suitably grand, the ceilings high and the pillars elaborately carved to display the strength and cunning of the dwarven craftsmen. The King’s Seat, a lesser version of his throne, once stood at the eastern edge of a large stone table. Now, however, the seat was gone, replaced by one of many salvaged from the wreckage, and the table lay cracked and broken. It seemed like a portent to decide the future of middle earth around a broken table, but Gimli could not for the life of him tell if it was for good or ill.
Thorin was already present, as were Dís, Bilbo, and the sons of Fundin. Dís was already seated at the table, next to Dain, who had his iron foot propped up against a piece of stone, and the others stood behind them, speaking softly. Dain, in his half-reclined position, occasionally offered a comment to their conversation, while Dís seemed lost in thought as she ran a hand over her mustache in a move so reminiscent of her son that Gimli had to look twice.
Conversation stilled when they came close to help Fíli into the seat next to Dís, but it broke Dís from her reverie and she smiled at her elder son, knocking their foreheads together before she gently bussed the same spot while Fíli flushed.
“Amad,” Fíli protested, but there was nothing behind his words except habit. Kíli greeted their mother much more enthusiastically, and Gimli turned when Dain beckoned.
“Cousin Dain,” Gimli greeted. “I’m happy to be seeing less of you today.”
Dain grinned. “I’ve nothing to be ashamed of, even if I had shame left to have. It’s healthy to air out the tender bits—grows ‘em large, and keeps ‘em strong.”
Dís snorted. “From the many times I’ve seen your hairy arse, I feel for your wife.”
“Ah, me lovely has no complaints,” Dain said, brushing the comment aside.
The chamber doors opened again, and Gimli turned to see the representatives of the White Council enter the room. Gandalf was first, looking better than he had, though still worn and travel-stained. Following him was Lord Elrond, free of his armor and dressed in silver and green under tunics. Elrond as well seemed weary in his particular elven way, and that line of tension in his brow that Gimli remembered so keenly from before had returned. With Lord Elrond walked the Lady Galadriel, dressed in a gown of simple white and barefoot; she glided across the floor like a whip of fog over the surface of a still lake, and her hair shone with brilliance. Her eyes, however, sparkled with good humor, and hinted at the depths within. Last to enter was Glorfindel, his presence a shining, rosy gold. Good humor filled his face, and he seemed little burdened by the battle so recently ended. Then again, Gimli supposed, if he had fought and killed a balrog, only to die and return, he would not let himself get weighted down by a single battle.
Gimli expected the council to take their seats directly opposite where Gimli and the other dwarves stood, to offer a balance to their position and not allow Thranduil or Bard favor over the other. Instead, however, Galadriel led the others to sit beside the dwarves in a clear display of support, and she bowed her head to them. Nobody, it seemed, knew quite what to say, though they all, save for Fíli, stood to return the bow.
Galadriel broke the silence. ”Shamukh ra ghelekhur aimâ! I am Galadriel of Lorien. Already I am known to some of you,” she smiled at Dain, who returned her grin, and at Gimli, who bowed again. The others were too taken aback by her use of Khuzdul to respond. Thorin in particular looked like he had taken a blow to the back of the head, while Balin looked like he had sucked on a particularly bitter lemon. Kill simply stared, slack jawed, until Tauriel discreetly pushed his chin up with her forefinger.
”Shamukh ra ghelekhur aimâ! Lady of Lorien,” Gimli said, when no one else seemed able to speak. “I trust you have been well? I’m afraid our hospitality has been more lacking than we would like, though I hope you can excuse us.”
Galadriel twinkled at him. “I do believe a dragon is a good reason, my champion,” she said, and the room relaxed by degrees; this council may yet be a less formal affair than the last. Gimli felt himself flush painfully red across his cheeks and through his ears, but he bowed again all the same before taking his own seat on Fíli’s other side. Legolas stood next to him, his hip warm against Gimli’s shoulder, and his hand rested in Gimli’s hair, his fingertips just grazing Gimli’s ear. Gimli let his eyes slip half-shut at the pleasant touch. Legolas seemed unwilling to be far from Gimli again so soon, and Gimli wondered if he would be able to sit with his husband, or if Legolas would be needed to sit with the woodland delegation.
“Hopefully it will be an excuse we can never use again,” Fíli said, addressing Galadriel directly. She smiled at him, the same warm smile that secured her a place in Gimli’s heart so thoroughly. There was something knowing about that smile, however, and Gimli wondered just what other secrets lay in store.
Glorfindel looked at Fíli from where he had sat next to Dain, mirroring his position, much to Dain’s amusement. “Surely Smaug was the last of them?”
Dain groaned aloud. “Oh, whatdja have to say it out loud for? Now you’ve gone and jinxed it.”
“Come now, Glorfindel,” Elrond said with a teasing familiarity. “Or do you wish to add “dragonslayer” to your titles?”
“There will be no more dragons in Arda,” Thranduil announced from the door to the chamber as he strode through. “And King Bard will be the last to bear that title.” Bard, who was again walking with Thranduil, his attendants mixing with those from the greenwood, turned a bit red at the assertion. Still, he did not deny it.
Legolas tensed, and Gimli looked closer at his father-in-law (that was a thought that had never lost its strange nature). Thranduil looked drawn, pale even for an elf, and the pale colors of his robe did him no favors. He was once again wearing his woodland crown, though he was otherwise unadorned. Gimli could feel Legolas's concern as if it was a physical thing. Thranduil’s gaze swept about the room, his eyes passing over Galadriel as if she was not there, which Gimli did not like in the least, and came to rest on Legolas with an odd sort of hunger in his eyes. No, not hunger--regret. Grief.
“I thought you spoke with him,” Gimli murmured.
“I did,” Legolas said. “But we elves have long memories, and change takes longer still. My father will lose some of his grief in time.”
“Indeed, Glorfindel,” Lady Galadriel said, and Gimli blinked at her, coming back to the conversation. Until now, she had kept quiet with a look of pensive observation. To be honest, Gimli hadn’t expected her to speak until negotiations were through. “Lord Dain is a dwarf to be hearkened to. His perspective refreshing and his countenance is…revealing.”
Gimli choked on air and bent forward to hide his face. From the corner of his eye, he could see Legolas turning pink, though his expression remained mostly even. Gimli glanced up up see a twinkle in his Lady’s eye.
“Blunt, you mean,” Thorin said, his voice dry. He knew he was missing something, but was not willing to call them on it. “Aye, he can be.” He said no more, though Gimli could practically see Thorin think it: and he could be twice as canny, too, when the situation called for it. Dain had been a good king for Erebor, building her nearly back to where she had been in her heyday, and it was in part because of Dain’s ability to play the fool.
“Indeed.” Galadriel said.
Thranduil and Bard were the last to arrive, and they took that as their cue to begin. Everyone settled into a seat, and Gimli was happy to note that Legolas chose to sit next to him and pulled their chairs in close. Bard sat readily, with a heaviness that made Gimli wonder if Bard had slept at all. Thranduil took longer to find a seat, but he sat in it in his own way, sprawling possessively.
Thorin stood. “Welcome, all of you, to this council.” He looked about the room. “It may seem strange, to discuss such things as will come in the rubble of a recently occupied kingdom; it may seem overreaching when we should be focused on our own losses and licking our own wounds. It I have learned one thing, in my ears of exile, it was this: the world waits for no one.”
Bard cleared his throat, shifting uneasily in his seat. "I agree that there is much for us three to discuss, but what does the rest of the world have to do with us?”
Gimli snorted, drawing the attention of the room. “War,” he said, and longed for his pipe. Legolas threaded his fingers through Gimli’s. “A war to end all wars.”
“The end of an age,” Legolas said. “And the beginning of a new.”
Bard raised a skeptical eyebrow. “That seems like quite a lot.”
“Aye,” Gimli said. “And it’s hard to hear. Still, hear it we must, for our enemy in this great war is the greatest of enemies.”
Thranduil cocked his head. “And are we to believe you? You are no ordinary youth. That I have long since known, but what special gifts do you possess, that you claim to have fought the Shadow and won?
Galadriel leaned forward, ever so slightly, and Gimli bowed his head in deference to her when she spoke. “Once already the White Council and I have faced this enemy in what may well come to be the first of many skirmishes of this great war. We have beaten him back, and at great cost, but it has earned us some well-needed time. We can yet breathe and see to our wounded and our dead before we look to the next battle.” She looked around the table. “I pray you all, listen to Gimli and take heed; it was on his word that we were in position to stop the enemy’s advance when we did. I can vouch for his words.”
Gimli had to close his eyes for a long moment, or he would have leaked tears. As it was, his eyes were still shining when he stood to speak. He took a deep breath, and Legolas squeezed his fingers gently. “Many of you, by now, have heard of my ability to see the future; you have heard of my true-dreaming. In truth? No. I possess no special special gifts. My uncle is the truth-seer, not I. But the truth is much harder to explain. Still, i will endeavor to do so, though my tale may push the limits of what you believe.”
Reluctantly pulling his hand from Legolas’s, Gimli undid the front ties to his tunic. He had to make sure they believed him, and he had only the one proof.
He pulled the Lady’s Gift from his tunic and held it up by the chain, letting it dangle and spin, catching the light and setting it aflame.
“Oh,” Lady Dís said softly. Dain was silent, and when Gimli chanced a look, all stared at the jewel with bewildered awe. The jewel was smaller at second glance than it appeared at first, as if the mind was trying to fix what the eye could not; that the Lady’s Gift was more than the sum of it’s crystal. It was a small gem—smaller than the Arkenstone, certainly, and cut in such a way as to dazzle, while also clearly showing the contents inside. The jewel was set in pure mithril, and it shone with a glow like pure sunlight. Gimli considered all of this as he thought of what to say next.
“This is the Lady’s Gift,” he said, quietly. “And my tale is tied with it in a way most peculiar. The defeat of the dragon, the Quest for Erebor—these are but among the first moves of a chess match that has been ages in the making: the return of the Shadow. Some sixty years hence, after Erebor was reclaimed, I was sent with my father to a council in Rivendell, where it was revealed that the Enemy had returned, and that the One Ring had been found. I joined a company, its sole purpose to destroy the ring and defeat the enemy once and for all.”
Gimli pinched the top of the setting between his fingers, upending the jewel and turning it to make sure all could see the lock of hair inside. “On this quest, we were gifted many things. I was gifted this lock of hair from the head of the Lady Galadriel of Lorien,” he nodded at her, and she smiled. "As you have heard, she named me her champion, Silvertongue, and elf-friend. I kept the lock safe through many battles and many more wanderings. I set it in crystal in the caves of Aglarond. When I had reached the end of my life,” he paused here for a moment, and laid his hand on Legolas’s shoulder, offering comfort. Legolas turned into the grip, hiding his face as best he could. “When I died, I did not expect to see it again.” He chuckled to himself. “Imagine my surprise to wake up again in Ered Luin with only my memories and this.” He lifted the gem again, and sighed. “Not even my beard stayed, yet this had.”
He looked around the room, and put the Lady’s gift away. “So you see, I know what is coming because I have lived through it. My presence has changed some things, yes, but some things I have been unable to change, and some of the things to change were not of my doing, for the Enemy has returned as well, and he knows all I do about the coming events, if not more. Every move I make is countered by him, for well do I remember the movements of the war that defined my youth, and well does he remember the war that ended his last chance to rule.”
Silence fell. There was more Gimli could have said—more, perhaps, that he should have said, but Gimli was watching Thranduil and the way he just barely shook. He looked about the room, and none seemed inclined to dispute his story, at least not openly.
“So, it is to be war again,” Elrond said.
Gimli looked up, and met the sad and knowing eyes of Gandalf. He held them and remembered the depthless grey of Olorin in Aman. “If I have learned anything by my trials, it is that some things cannot be changed, for good or for ill.”
“The melody remains,” Glorfindel said, as if to himself, and he offered no explanation.
Gandalf tapped the bowl of his unlit pipe idly against the broken piece of tabletop that was before him. “You said that the destruction of the ring of power brought an end to the enemy.”
“It did,” Gimli said, and from the corner of his eye, he watched Bilbo shrink back in his seat. “The ringbearer and his closest companion traveled alone through the orc-infested hell of Mordor to deliver the ring at last to the fires of Mount Doom. We, Legolas and I, were at the gates when the ring was destroyed.”
“It took with it half the mountain,” Legolas said. “The orcs scattered, and it was as if the world could breathe again; the shadows were lifted before the face of the sun.”
“The ring is the key,” Gimli said. “It always has been. But now the Enemy knows our plan; it will not work the same way again.” Gimli’s words brought contemplative silence, and idly thought of the last time such a council had met; what would that Gimli think of this moment? That Elrond? He glanced at his husband. He had a good idea what that Legolas would have thought, and he had to hide a rather inappropriate smile at how happy he was to have this Legolas here, in this time.
It was Dain who put his finger on the problem. “You say out future must change, but you also say the future cannot change. How are we to fight?”
“We fight because we must,” Thorin started, and Dain waved him off, the boar teeth in his beard moving with his mouth as he spoke, making him look fierce when before he’d looked simply good-natured. For all his years, Gimli had never learned just how Dain was able to so easily switch between such different personas.
“Aye, aye, I know that. I’m not saying we don’t fight, Thorin. How long have you known me? I’m saying we seem to be facing a logically impossible situation.”
Dís looked up then. “Some things have already been changed,” she said, her voice filling the chamber, though she spoke softly. “My sons. My brother. They live, where before they did not.” She looked up at Gimli. “Is that not so?”
Gimli bowed to her. “Aye, my Lady. Though I fear I had little to do with that, in the end.”
“You have changed things more than you may yet realize, Gimli son of Glóin,” Galadriel said. Then, she turned to Dís. “It gladdens my heart to see your family survive.”
Dís smiled. “And mine,” she said.
Gimli cleared his throat. “I feel the need to point out that there were many trials along the way that I could not change.” He did not look at Bilbo. “I could not stop the ring from being found, nor could I stop its influence.”
Bard started. “Wait—it’s here? The ring?”
Gandalf nodded. “Let the ring be brought forth,” he said, and nobody moved. Gimli frowned, and finally looked back at the hobbit. Bilbo was staring at the table, twisting something in his fingers, and he didn’t appear to hear what was said around him.
Thorin touched his shoulder gently. “Bilbo?” he prompted, and Bilbo’s head snapped up, a snarl on his lips—and just as soon it was gone, and in its place Bilbo looked pale and frightened. Thorin looked equally shaken.
“Bilbo,” Gandalf repeated. “The ring.”
This time Bilbo stood, and he made his way carefully to the center of the table. He stood there for an extended moment, then thrust his hand forward, dropping something that glittered like gold and fell like lead. Bilbo breathed in sharply, like he was coming up for air, and staggered back. Thorin stood to catch him, and held Bilbo still while he regained his composure. Side conversations sprang up in its wake.
“There it is,” Galadriel said, and in her voice was an echo like the depths of the sea. “The ring of power.”
“Such a small thing,” Dulcan said, softly, to Bard, who nodded. His eyes never left the glittering ring.
“Pah,” Dain snorted, and the spell was broken. “I’ve seen better trinkets in my time.”
Legolas leaned in close; his husband had grown pale, and his eyes were haunted, but still he tried to smile. “It is a good thing you did not reach again for your axe, meleth,” he said. “I fear the table would not survive such a blow.”
Gimli hummed. “Save us all a lot of time and trouble.” He shook his head.
He looked up to find the eyes of the council on him. “You are not even tempted,” Elrond said, quietly, and there was an awed respect in his voice.
“What need have I of power?” Gimli said.
Legolas smiled at him. “My heart desires other things; I have passed this test, besides.”
“It feels foul,” Fíli said.
“Like bad air at the end of a tunnel,” Kíli said. “The kind that explodes.” Fíli nodded his agreement.
Tauriel shivered. “It slithers.”
Thorin called out over the chamber. “It is clear this must be dealt with. A strategy must be devised, a different plan with the same goal. A company must deliver the ring to Mount Doom.”
“They cannot simply walk into Mordor,” Elrond advised. “The enemy is weakened, but his servants roam still. What’s more, knowing of the earlier defeat, he will have shored up his guard, especially in those places.”
Glorfindel shook his head. “We must still try, and quickly. There may not be a better time for it.”
“Gondor should be warned,” Gimli said. “Ever have they been the watchtower in the south; they will lose the most if Mordor marches.”
Legolas cocked his head. “A diversion…” he murmured. “Would a distraction work again, do you think?”
Gimli smiled softly at his husband. “It depends entirely upon the distraction, my love,” he said. It was a good question; a diversion would most likely be very necessary, but what would be more diverting than a battle at the gates?
“We take the fight to him,” Gimli said, softly. “We have to march on Mordor.”
That brought silence to the room.
After a moment, Bard spoke. “How?” He asked. “We should have three armies between us, if not four. Instead we have two, and they are long weary and lessened from battle. What strength do we have to march on Mordor?”
“The dwarves of the Blue Mountains will fight,” Dís said. “But they are far away. It would take months to bring them here.”
“Doesn’t Gondor have an army?” Kíli asked. “If they’re right there, the knowledge may prove invaluable.”
“What of the other dwarves?” Bilbo asked into a sudden lull, and the room fell quiet. Bilbo, noticing the attention, looked out evenly across the broken table. Gimli thought back to the Hobbit he had met in Bag End, the little fellow who stammered when addressing a room of 14 dwarves, let alone a council of wizards and kings. Then again, maybe this wasn't so new; he remembered Bilbo taking Gandalf to task for the guests that very nearly caught him unprepared. He cleared his throat and continued, looking at Thorin. “Before, in my dining room, you spoke of the armies of the dwarves, of the need for the arkenstone to rule. You have the arkenstone; can you not now raise the armies?”
Thorin did not speak for a moment, trapped as he was by Bilbo’s stare, and it was Balin who began to speak of the formalities, the logistics, the sheer distance needed to travel, and the time it would take to cross those many leagues, when Thorin interrupted.
“I have seen the chaos that stone can bring,” he said. “I will not stand to let it further corrupt the ruling of Erebor. Too long has our family been subject to the malicious whims of malevolent magics.” Thorin held his head high, and Gimli saw Fíli grin at his uncle, looking very proud.
Balin blinked. “Thorin,” he hissed. “You can’t just—“
“I just did, Balin,” Thorin said. “It is well within my powers, limited as they are, to remove such an insidious threat to the crown. The arkenstone was claimed by my grandfather, and he is dead, so the stone is mine by conquest—and I propose to drop it down the deepest, darkest mine shaft so that it may return to the earthly fires that forged it.”
Elrond was looking at Thorin, remembered pain mingled with respect on his still mostly stoic face. “You speak with great wisdom, King Under the Mountain.”
Thorin’s expression grew heavy, and he spoke slowly, as if only having just come to a decision that, while he was firm in his belief that it was the right choice, it was also a difficult one. “I thank you, but before we go any further, there is more that must come to light. I am not the King of Erebor.”
Even Gimli stared at Thorin in shock and surprise. “What?” he said, voice flat.
Balin sighed, and cleared his throat. “Technically, since King Thrain has disappeared, and we have no proof of his fate, Thorin is still prince regent—acting king. There are certain limitations to his authority until such a time has passed that King Thrain will be either found or assumed to have passed unto His halls.”
Gandalf leaned forward, folding his fingers together. They were dark against the dirty grey of the fingerless cuffs he wore, and looked as if they had been through much. There were healing cuts and a few new scars, and the nail on the third finger on his left hand was missing. Gimli stared and could not help himself. “I believe I may be of help with that,” he said.
Gandalf looked around the table, to make sure he had the attention of everyone. “I first became aware of the growing shadow several years ago, but it was only in the vaguest of whispers, and the smallest of moments where the actions of friends brought more ill than was wanted. Slowly, I began to notice a pattern of discord that only grew, and I began to investigate. All too soon, I came to fear the worst.” Gandalf looked at Thorin. “You father had already left by this time, and I am afraid that his departure was the final piece to this dark puzzle. That was when I came to you, to speak with you about reclaiming the Mountain.”
Thorin nodded. “I remember,” he said.
“And now you know why,” Gandalf said. “With your people displaced, the whole of Middle Earth is at risk of falling to the enemy. I only wish I had realized more quickly,” he looked away. “Either way, at the request of the council, I left the company bound for Erebor to head south, to investigate the rumors of a Necromancer. Instead I found Sauron himself, and in the dungeons, an old dwarf, nearly mindless in his grief and fear, but still, in his heart, himself.” Gandalf looked up at Thorin and Dís. “I am sorry, but Thrain is dead; he died at the hands of the enemy.”
Dís hung her head, and her sons held her on either side. Thorin stared at the table while the rest of the room kept their silence in there respect.
“My father had a ring,” Thorin said, his voice rough. Gimli looked at him, and knew, then, that Thorin knew, perhaps better than any of them, why the one ring had to be destroyed.
“It is now in the enemy’s hands,” Gandalf said.
“That is ill news,” Thorin said. He sighed. “I had much desire to throw it down into a pit with the arkenstone.”
There was a pause, and Dain began to laugh. It was as if some film over the world had been punctured, and the laughter spread from dwarf to dwarf. Even Legolas seemed to find the humor, and laughed wearily to himself, hiding most of his face behind his hand. It was a much needed salve to their frayed tempers, though they sobered quickly—save for Dain, who continued to shake and wipe at his eyes, though he stayed mostly silent.
Gimli saw Bard look to Thranduil, as if for an explanation, and Thranduil simply waved a hand, dismissing the question. He had no idea, either, but then again, how could he? Gimli had long since learned that not many shared a Dwarf’s sense of the absurd; elves were far too serious, too wrapped up in their own unchanging view of the world, and men were far too earnest, forever living in their own youth—and like a youth, desperate to prove themselves grown. No; the dwarves understood what the men and elves would not see, for they lived long enough for wisdom and died soon enough for mirth.
“The death of my father grieves me, though there is some comfort in an answer to a long asked question,” Thoin said, wiping his eyes dry with his knuckle. “Either way, I will not be crowned king.” He looked up at the table. “I plan to renounce my claim to the throne, and so does kingship pass to my heir, Fíli son of Dís.”
Fíli started. “Uncle!” he said, and seemed to catch himself. He swallowed, blinking rapidly. The room waited for him, watching as he composed his thoughts. “I am honored,” he said, at last. Gimli frowned as Thorin nodded. Fíli had grown quite pale, and did not react when Kíli tried for his attention. Lady Dís took her son’s hand and squeezed, and gave him a sad sigh when he clung tightly in return.
“How certain are we that we need an army as yet?” Glorfindel asked. His usual good humor had faded, revealing startlingly keen eyes. Here, even more than on the battlefield, was the great warrior of old. “Lady, you took much of Sauron’s power from him; he fled formless into the mists of this world. If we move quickly, we may yet be able to get the ring to the mountain without open battle.”
“It takes time to muster an army,” Dain said. “More time than to outfit a company for travel, that’s for certain.”
“But is it time we can afford to take?” Bard asked.
“We may have no choice,” Lord Elrond said.
There was silence for a moment, and then Galadriel spoke, her voice clear as silver bells. “Tell me, Gimli, is the future naught but worry and woe?”
Gimli blinked at her, surprised. “Well, no my lady. There was yet joy in the world, and all the more after such terrible darkness.”
Galadriel’s eyes were like midnight starfields, and Gimli was held in her stare. “Then tell us the good of the future.”
So Gimli did. He spoke of the return of glory to Erebor, of her loyalty to Bilbo and her steadfastness in the face of the enemy, holding the line of the north. He spoke of the glory of Rohan and the discovery of Aglarond. He spoke of Moria, once freed from the Balrog and again bearing the name of Khazad-Dum. He spoke of the peace and friendship between the elves, and the lasting friendships of the Shire. And most, he spoke of Aragorn, son of Arathorn, King Elessar Telcontar, the King of Gondor and the Golden Age of Man. There was quiet again after he spoke, as those who listened thought about what they had just heard.
“A terrible choice lies before us,” Galadriel said at last. "For there is much suffering ahead, and yet it is in the deepest darkness that the candle burns brightest. Do we act to end the suffering now and risk snuffing that candle before it can truly burn, therefore doing the enemy’s work for him? Or do we, with our knowledge, commit the world to suffering and torment on the promise of a glorious someday?” She bowed her head.
Gimli was aghast; would it all be for naught? Would his drive to save his kin and destroy the ring lead to greater darkness and prevent the Golden Age of Man? The scope of it all loomed before him, and he was nearly overwhelmed. There was so much to do, so much that could go wrong! HIs heart quailed. How could he possibly—
”Take heart, dear champion,” said the Lady’s voice in his mind, as he had once heard her long ago. “Great your part in this all is, but it is not the only part to be played. You must trust that those who got us through before will get us through again.”
Trust.
It was not in Gimli’s nature to be a grand manipulator of design, though this quest had given him much practice. Still, such machinations were the province of wizards, not dwarves. And the wizards could have it. Gimli would be Gimli, and that would have to be enough. He would offer his advice and help where he could, but even he could not control the outcome of rolled dice.
Aye, my Lady, Gimli thought, and bowed his head to her.
It was Elrond who gave voice, at last, to the terrible truth. “We cannot yet destroy the ring,” he said, and his voice was heavy with sorrow. “Estel is yet a boy, and not ready to lead, crowned in Gondor. Without the White Tree, the war will not be won.”
Of course, it was Gandalf, in his wisdom, who offered up the only solution. “So we cut our losses," he said. “We cannot defeat the enemy quickly, but we can at least cripple his power. He knows what moves he makes, what resources he has. We take them away before he has chance to use them.”
“Like the dragon,” Thorin said, his voice echoing with something deep, like iron against anvil in a cavernous forge. “We cripple him the same way we did before, we take back his strongholds, make them our own.” Gandalf nodded, and Thorin sat back, considering.
Fill sat up a little straighter in his seat. “The war was an attack on two fronts,” he began, looking to Gimli for confirmation. “The might of Mordor in the south, and Gundabad and Angmar in the North. Erebor held, with Dale and the Greenwood and the Iron Hills, but if we were to focus on the North—“
“Change the war to one front,” Kíli said. “Fight the war in the North now.”
Bard blinked at them. “With what resources?” Bard asked. “Between the dragon and the bdattle we just fought, we don’t have the resources to lay siege to that land.”
“Lands,” Gimli said, quietly correcting. “Angmar rose up, too.”
“Winter is upon us,” Thorin said. “It would be folly to march north now; we would be battling the very seasons, let alone the ill creatures that live there. If we wait out the winter, rebuild our strength and rest, heal out our wounds, by spring we will be ready to march.”
There was a general assent from the table, from all but one corner. “And what of the Ring?” Thranduil asked. “These plans for battle are all well and good, but it is the ring’s destruction that will win us this war. If it is not to be destroyed, where shall it be kept? Surely not where it was kept before.”
Fíli said, mildly. “I wouldn’t underestimate our dear burglar, here. That was the dragon’s undoing.”
Bilbo snorted at the title, but his fingers fidgeted with his pocket, as if he was fondling something inside.
“Hobbits are surprisingly immune to the ring’s effects,” Gimli said. “Bilbo held the ring in the Shire for near sixty years, and not only did the Shire not feel its effects, Bilbo was able to give the ring up willingly. After sixty years, would any of you be able to claim the same?”
There was a quiet around the table, and Bard spoke. “Would the ring be safe in the Shire?” he asked. “Nothing against the place, but wouldn't the enemy know to find Bilbo there?”
“The ring cannot go to the Shire, true,” Glorfindel said. “I am sorry, Bilbo, but it would be too dangerous.”
Bilbo seemed to deflate a bit. “I understand, though I do not like it,” he said. "I had quite hoped to see my cozy little hobbit hole again. All these places I have seen, each grander and greater and stranger than the last, and all it has done has filled me with a longing for home.”
“So stay here," Dain said, to the surprise of everyone. “Well, why not?" he asked. “Wee Gimli here said it; the Mountain does not fall to the Enemy. We can withstand against his lies and treachery—Bilbo would be quite safe within these walls.” He raised his eyebrows at the assembled lot. “It may be the only place on Middle Earth where he could be safe. The Dwarves of Erebor owe him much, besides, and would offer him any comfort.”
“Aye,” Thorin said. “Tis true. You could make your home here, agyâdê. You could stay.” The ‘with me’ was not said, but Gimli was sure all could hear it anyway.
Bilbo swallowed several times before he could speak. “Well, perhaps I could at that,” he said, softly, his eyes shining. In view of everybody and not caring, Thorin took Bilbo’s hand in his own, and held on when Bilbo gripped it tightly.
“There it is then,” Dain said. “Love conquers all. The Ring will stay here, kept from enemy hands.”
“The enemy still knows Bilbo has the ring,” Legolas said, a shadow on his voice that Gimli had not heard in some time, and Gimli remembered just why Legolas had been in Rivendell all those years ago; it was from the Greenwood that Gollum had slipped his prison. “Long ago he learned his name as well as his home. If the enemy knows Erebor is his haven, the mountain will not get a moment’s peace, and even a mountain may crumble to the constant onslaught of a river.”
“What about a decoy?” Lady Dís said. “A distraction, to focus his attention there and not here.”
Thranduil raised an eyebrow. “It would be asking much; whatever land is chosen would face the full brunt of Mordor, and without the ring at hand, bitterness may grow that they must fight to keep another alive.”
“Well, your kingdom's out,” Gimli muttered under his breath, and refused to quake when Thranduil’s icy glare flicked towards him.
“They may come to Lorien,” Galadriel said at last. “Our forces are fresh and our archers keen. They will break upon us like waves against a rock, and never shall they penetrate our lands. The secret will be kept safe with us.”
“Um, excuse me,” Bilbo said, raising his hand to the level of his ear. “Just how are we going to convince Sauron that I’m not where I am?”
“We shall beat him at his own game,” Galadriel said. “A company shall depart for Lorien with me, and bring with them a person in the guise of Bilbo, so the enemies spies will report that a hobbit returns south to Lorien.”
Gimli raised an eyebrow. “And just where are we going to get another hobbit to pretend to be Bilbo?” he asked.
“It would have to be a dwarf, lad,” Dain said, looking at Gimli with a queer expression in his eye.
“Well, I’d hardly think it’d be an elf,” Gimli snapped back.
“Ah, you don’t get it,” Dain said. “It has to be a dwarf lad.”
Gimli blinked at him for a—oh.
Oh.
“What?” Gimli said, flatly, as the whole of the council turned to look at him.
“It has to be you, I’m afraid,” Gandalf said, and the old bastard was laughing. “You're the closest in stature.”
“And you have no beard to worry about,” Kíli added.
“Why don’t we shave you; then you can do it,” Gimli growled, and Kíli’s hands smacked to his cheeks to cover the short growth.
“He’ll have to cut and dye his hair,” Thranduil said, and Gimli’s breath caught in his chest.
“It can be done,” Thorin said, and Gimli glared at him, betrayed. His hair, his beautiful, long hair.
Gimli felt slender fingers, touch the crown of his head, smoothing down the back. “It would be a shame to lose such beauty, however temporarily it may be.” Gimli pressed against Legolas’s hand, and when he looked, Legolas was just as sad as he.
Trust. He must trust those who had won before to win again.
“Aye,” he said, resigned. “I’ll do it.” Legolas’s grip tightened for a moment on his curls, as if he could keep them by sheer force of will, before his hand relaxed and began to stroke. Gimli wondered if Legolas would stop touching his hair at any point between now and when it was—cut off. Gimli shuddered.
“Now,” Dain said, clapping his hands together. “Who shall we send on this quest?”
“None may be chosen but those who themselves choose to go,” Lord Elrond proclaimed. “For they are taking danger upon themselves as if they were conveying the ring-bearer in truth. Great their danger will be.”
“Agreed,” Gandalf said, quietly.
“Agreed,” Lady Galadriel said. “Who, then, will walk with the Company?”
Elrond spoke again. “Nine companions, there should be—Nine to counter the wraiths that have risen in aid of their dark master. Already we have one. The others should be found among you from all the free peoples here today, for this is a matter that concerns us all.” He looked around the room. “Who will accompany the ‘ring bearer.’” He looked at Gimli with a small, commiserating smile, and Gimli felt something unhinge in his chest.
“I will go,” Legolas said. “So I have sworn, I will not be parted from my husband. Where he goes, I go.”
“I, as well,” Gandalf said. “The enemy would not believe it, I fear, if I were not present.”
Balin stood. “No dwarf of Thorin’s company would let you go without a dwarf by your side,” he said to Bilbo. “Therefore, I will go. You have my sword.”
“It is good you come,” Galadriel said. “For your destiny awaits near my borders.”
Balin looked startled, but nodded. “Aye, my lady.”
Destiny. Gimli looked startled, and watched Balin. Moria. They spoke of Moria. Gimli had told them the colony failed; why would they be so eager to go back to that fell place?
But now was not the time for such questions. Volunteers still came forth.
“You have my my bow,” Dulcan said, standing as well.
“I will go,” came a quiet voice, and Gimli looked to see one of the women of Dale, tall and slender with bright hair, stand next to Dulcan. She offered no weapon to their service, but then again, neither had any of the hobbits the first time around. Elrond nodded, accepting her pledge.
A dark-skinned elf dressed in the livery of the Greenwood stood. “I will also pledge my bow to the cause,” he said, “and so stand for the Greenwood.”
“I pledge my service,” said another dwarf, one of Dain’s from the Iron Hills, who had been standing silent sentry against the door. Galadriel nodded her acceptance. Gimli bit his lip and wondered if they would meet Haldir once more. That ponce pratling would get quite a nasty shock when his lady brought home with her three dwarves when, to his knowledge, none had set foot in Lorien for centuries.
“I would not be left behind,” Glorfindel said. “My path lies westward, and I can think of no better road to travel than one doing noble deeds.” He winked at Galadriel. “And I wouldn’t say no to seeing the beauty of your lands once more.”
Galadriel smiled. “You are always welcome, my friend.”
Elrond nodded, and there was a resignation in his posture, an expectation of grief that Gimli found all too familiar. “Then it is done; the Nine have been chosen.”
