Chapter Text
It was witching hour when Bilbo awoke in a cold sweat. His room was blacker than sin save for the moonlight which feathered around the edges of the curtains. He felt his stomach drop coldly and his skin pricked. There was a faint scratching of nails on glass and he thought it might have been the creaking of the house. But he wasn’t in a wooden house which would creak and crack with the expanding heat and shrink with the cool of the night.
Then there was tapping at the window. Several long nails were dragging across his windows pausing to tap occasionally. Bilbo had been disturbed and scared quite a lot over these last couple of days and begun to adjust to it. He remembered what Fili had told him his first night, “If you hear anything strange in the night don’t worry about it, it’s probably just the spectres.”
He tried to regulate his breathing and go back to sleep when he heard a disembodied voice beside his ear, where is my child? Bilbo’s whole body was paralyzed. Another voice, more masculine, also spoke from out of the darkness, clear and bodiless, will he love me? Then another voice, will anyone remember me? And another, I don’t think I can do this. More and more voices confided and questioned him, I would rather die. Will the food last? I’m a disgrace. What if I fail? Help! I want to run away. Where am I? The voices were no longer bodiless but filled his head and mind. The voices echoed like his own thoughts, I’m scared. I’m worthless. Soon it was his thoughts he heard, it all died with them.
“Stop! Stop! I don’t know! I’m sorry, I don’t know!” he begged and screamed.
Suddenly the voices stopped, his body wasn’t paralysed, and there was no scratching or tapping at the window. The room didn’t seem so dark anymore. Bilbo laid in bed shaking and whimpering, his eyes tearful and his body cold. He laid for probably an hour until he calmed down, his body no longer shaking and his eyes not so swollen. But he was still cold. He stepped out of the bed and walked down the stairway back down to the dining room and the kitchen. He didn’t bother with any lights but made his way slowly down the narrow and steep flight.
When he reached the landing he noticed a light in the foyer. He felt strongly the urge to speak to someone, but as friendly as his hosts were, they were still strangers. He wasn’t sure he was able to talk, anyways. Still, he needed to go through the foyer to reach the dining room, and he stepped into the room and the light.
A heavy candle illuminated parchments on table. He recognized a copy of Malleus Maleficarum and The Discoverie of Witchcraft. Thorin was scribbling notes as he followed the text of the latter.
“Witchcraft?” asked Bilbo in a croaking voice, surprised he was able to form the word at all.
Thorin jumped a little in surprise and for a second his head disconnected before falling back into place, “What are you doing awake? Lord, you step quietly.”
“Why are you awake? Kili said sleeping was for the dead, not the living, after all.”
Thorin rolled his eyes, “I thought after today’s incident you would know not to take him seriously at all. Besides, the cursed are restless in death.”
Bilbo nodded and gestured to the notes, “Why are you studying medieval writing on witches?”
“It’s more about the fear mongering than the supposed witches. It’s for an idea that Balin had for the haunted house,” he explained. Bilbo nodded interestedly and waited for Thorin to explain further but the king relented, “I won’t say because you’re going to be a visitor to the haunted house. Better to keep it a surprise, like your Danse Macabre costume.”
“Who else is going through? It takes a quite a lot of people to run a haunted house,” Bilbo asked.
“I thought this was explained to you. We of Erebor put on the haunted house and have guests go through. Usually, besides Gandalf, it’s the Elves,” he elaborated.
“Gandalf isn’t from Erebor?” remarked Bilbo in surprise.
Thorin raised an eyebrow, “I had no idea you were so ignorant. I thought my nephews would have explained these things on the tour at least. Gandalf is much older than any of us. He’s a wandering wizard, a magic user like the Necromancer, but not quite the same.”
Bilbo nodded tiredly.
“I answer many of your questions yet you haven’t answered mine. Why are you awake?” he asked again noticing Bilbo’s pallor.
“I was woken up by some noise at my window,” he replied.
Thorin looked at Bilbo intensely and set down his pencil, “The spectres?”
“I suppose so.”
“It wasn’t just noise at the window then, was it?”
Bilbo shook his head, “No, it was whispering.”
“I’m sorry.”
He looked at the king in surprise, “Sorry?”
“Usually they only visit me, but I don’t think they like light,” he explained gesturing to the candle, “some dead are just desperate to air the grievances of their lives. Especially when no one grieved for them.”
Bilbo nodded gently and soberly, “They visit you every night?”
“No,” corrected Thorin, “they don’t need to grieve so often.”
“Still, it was terrible to hear that at all,” admitted Bilbo.
“I am their king, it’s natural they should come to me with their grievances. And since I bear the crown, I can answer back.”
Thorin watched Bilbo carefully as he nodded again then said, “I’m going to make some tea, do you want any?”
Thorin was embarrassed by the offer but replied, “Yes, alright, thank you.”
It took a while for Bilbo to locate the heavy kettle in the kitchen and for it to boil. To his pleasure there was a propane gas stove in the kitchen and in the meantime he prepared the tea pot which was still on the dining room table. After pouring the boiling water into the pot Thorin came into the dining room and Bilbo asked if he would want any cream or sugar.
“No, thank you, I’ll just take it as is,” he replied.
After a few minutes Bilbo poured the steeped tea and Thorin admitted it was certainly the best tea he ever had, though Bilbo wasn’t sure if that really meant much.
“Thank you,” Bilbo answered nonetheless.
They drank the tea in silence. Bilbo was tired but thoughtful. The fear and cold was being washed away by the tea. After pouring his second cup he asked Thorin, “Do you ever grieve your own death?”
Thorin set down his tea on the saucer and considered the question seriously. He didn’t look back up at Bilbo when he said, “No. I made mistakes in my life; this grave was one I dug myself. But I grieve for the others whose fates I sealed like my royal crest upon hot wax.”
“Are you maybe being too harsh?” asked Bilbo, “it certainly didn’t sound like it was all your fault.”
“I didn’t explain the events fully to you, and perhaps I should now,” said Thorin. He scratched his beard and looked back to him, “I found your questions annoying at first, but now I admit I’m thankful for someone to listen.”
“Well, I suppose you need someone to listen to your grievances like the spectres,” ventured Bilbo with a weak sympathetic smile. Thorin considered him carefully.
“There was a rebellion, like I said, but I never took it seriously. It was a middle class movement, a bunch of brawny students and professionals. They talked a lot but they never had anyone’s support but their own. They were such a small yet radical group and I refused to pay them any attention on principle. I thought I was keeping my head above their madness. But, as you can tell, my head is exactly what they got in the end. Somehow they got the support of a Necromancer. I thought it was ridiculous like everyone else but I learned its authenticity eventually.
The rebels had their base mostly in the largest city of Erebor a little farther south. They were called the Brotherhood of the White Wolf, which comes from an old Orcish legend. The Orcs were the original natives of Erebor before a group of Dwarves from Gundabad settled along the Running River. This group believed they were descendants from those Orcs and that they were reclaiming their land. My royal family, the Durins, are direct descendants of the Dwarrow royal family in Gundabad, you see, and the White Wolf was a sigil of an old and legendary leader of the Orcs, Azog.
It was ridiculous. No one in Erebor was pure Orcish or Dwarvish, there was no question of race or blood. Except, of course, for my family because of the care taken to preserve the royal bloodline in the past. I don’t know where the Necromancer came from but I’m convinced he used the White Wolves as a puppet cause. I think perhaps he wanted the kingdom for his own designs. Whatever the reason, he joined with the group and led them to the castle of Erebor. He raised the dead from the peasant cemeteries and blocked the roads and quarantined the castle. He made a speech before the gates, declaring himself as the Necromancer, and that he had put a curse on the entire castle grounds.
Obviously the peasants and nobles alike were terrified. When the White Wolves weren’t trying to break into the castle or demanding my head, they passed out propaganda and harassed the outlying populace. My guards held the castle fast while I desperately searched for some answer to the black magic.
The castle was under siege for three days before the Necromancer asked for parley with me. I refused the parley and spoke to him only from high above the castle gates. I told him to turn from my castle with his arms and rebels. He threatened to raise an undead army from my people unless I surrendered to execution and allowed for an Orcish king to take the throne. I did not even acknowledge these demands. I ordered my men only to hold the gate and protect the castle.
Soon after the White Riders began to slaughter the peasants indiscriminately. The dead would then rise again until the command of the Necromancer and in time the castle was breached. I was overpowered and taken to an execution block. It was my brother who killed the Necromancer.”
“Your brother?” asked Bilbo bewildered, “I haven’t met him, I assumed Dis was your only sibling!”
“He’s not with us. He followed the Necromancer off the castle grounds and killed him before he could curse an adjacent town to create more soldiers. But he sustained terrible wounds in the battle and died before he could return to the castle. After that I awoke from control of the Necromancer and the curse ripped the castle from the human world. Most of the bodies of the peasants rotted away and they were left as spectres. Anyone else who had still been alive died in the separation. If they didn’t become spectres then they rose again in odd ways, as monsters and half-human creatures, not just re-animated corpses like me.”
Bilbo felt immense pity for Thorin and his family, “So you can never see your brother again?”
“No. Like my parents who died much sooner than any of these events, his soul rests elsewhere,” he answered.
In a small cautious voice Bilbo tried to reassure, “It’s not your fault.”
Thorin jumped to his feet, “I should have never ignored the rebels! I should have realized they were extremists and a possible threat! I should have fought back against the Necromancer! I should have had him killed the moment he threatened any of my people! I was too proud and too scared to act appropriately! I led my castle into ruin, abandoned my kingdom! I should have been more like Frerin. Perhaps he would have been more fit to be king.” Thorin collapsed back onto the hair and put his hand to his head, “And now we’ll never see him again. If I was alive at least I could pray for a reunion in the afterlife. But once you die you can no longer hope for anything, only regret what you did in life.”
Thorin clenched his hands around his neck in frustration and agony. “No, Thorin, stop!” pleaded Bilbo. Thorin gritted his teeth, lost in his misery, and his nails started to draw blood when Bilbo quickly got up and pulled his head from his body.
“Stop that, don’t hurt your body any more than it’s already endured!” directed Bilbo.
“W-what stop! Put me back!” cried his head. His body had immediately pulled his hands away from his neck and was now massaging it.
“If the dead can’t hope, then I’ll hope for you. And if the dead needs someone to grieve, then I’ll grieve for you,” Bilbo told him.
Thorin looked at him in wonder and confusion, “Why? Why would you offer something like that?”
“Honestly,” answered Bilbo sheepishly, “you look a bit pathetic and it’s been centuries. I think it’s time you start to forgive yourself a little and try to grow instead of languish in regret.”
Thorin sighed, “It’s not the same when you’re dead—”
“Yes, well, I’ve been told being cursed isn’t quite the same as being dead, so I think you can manage,” he interrupted.
Thorin glared at Bilbo with soft and contemplative intensity. Suddenly Thorin’s body hugged Bilbo’s body by the middle and pulled him off his feet into the air.
“Wo-woah! Hey!” Bilbo called as he tried to keep his handle on Thorin’s head.
“Don’t drop me! Stop swaying me about! Put him down you loaf!” ordered the head.
The body squeezed Bilbo’s body gently and set him back on the ground. He took his own head from Bilbo’s hands and connected it back to his neck. Thorin straightened himself and said gruffly, “You’re a bit ridiculous, human. Go back to sleep now, the spectres won’t bother you again tonight.”
A little surprised at the sudden shift in topic Bilbo replied, “Yes, alright, I am rather tired.”
He picked up his cup and saucer to clean but Thorin ordered him off to bed directly, “No, just go to sleep!”
“Alright, alright, thank you, then.”
Thorin watched Bilbo leave the dining room and pass by the light from the foyer. He could still feel his warmth against his body from the hug.
