Chapter Text
The Day of Divination was the laziest day of Hallowtide, no contest. Bilbo ate an omelet leisurely that morning while many of the residents of Erebor finished off some of the leftover candy with him in the dining room. Gloin, the greatest fire-starter and the tinder-master among them, had already begun to set up the bonfire later that evening with his son’s help, who was more than happy to hew some tree bark for him with his trusted axe. There were some of Gandalf’s fireworks for the bonfire event as well but the wizard himself was still visiting the Elves and would escort them to Erebor for their stay tomorrow morning.
“This year’s Day of Divination is going to be so much more interesting with you around, though, Bilbo,” commented Kili enthusiastically, candy still in his mouth, “being dead means you don’t have much a fate left, right? So we just get the same results every year.”
“Hm? But you certainly have some chance for fate, don’t you? It’s not like things can’t happen to you yet,” Bilbo replied, “being cursed and all.”
“Yeah,” said Kili, “I guess so, but we always get the same predictions from the Tarot cards every year either way. And they’re usually very dreary, too. You see uncle’s cards, two of them are reversed and one of them is the Tower.”
“I’ve never had my fortune told before by Tarot cards, I’m afraid I’m not very familiar with them,” admitted Bilbo.
“Oh, well!” said Bofur from Bilbo’s other side, “it’s straightforward if you’re the one having your fortune told, it’s up to the card reader to know all the different meanings and such. All you gotta do is ask a question, cut the deck, and listen: none too strenuous! And Oin is a fantastic card reader, he’s got centuries of practice.”
“Yeah, there’s two categories of cards, the Major Arcana and the Minor Arcana,” explained Kili, “The Minor arcana have four suits like playing cards and those are Cups, Swords, Pentacles, and… uh… Wands! Each suit has a theme sort of, like Pentacles are all about money and business. The Major Arcana are the like trump cards, though, and there’s stuff like Death and the Chariot and the Emperor. Oh! And the cards can be laid out in reverse, which gives like a negative spin on the meaning of the cards.”
“You can actually play a trump game with the cards, too, like a regular deck of playing cards,” said Bofur, “mind, Oin will have your head if you touch his cards for that.”
“Do you not get stuff like this at your pawn shop?” asked Kili.
“Oh, well, yes, lots of mystic and superstitious stuff to be sure, but people don’t usually care how they word, so long as you tell them they will,” he joked, “so I never bothered to study them much.”
Balin came into the dining room and started making rounds with slips of paper and a quill with milk inside an inkpot. Bofur explained that everyone takes turns writing one or more fortunes on a slip and after the milk ink dried then Ori and Balin would fit them into walnut shells to roast over the bonfire. The milk would brown from the heat revealing their fortunes. Most of them tried to make their fortunes humorous but Bilbo was stuck at what to write. Eventually he thought to write ominous warnings of small, everyday annoyances.
After Bilbo had finished his breakfast he made a large pot of tea to share around the table. He got many compliments but Dori was the most taken with his cup. Even Dwalin accepted some, although Bilbo saw him slip something undoubtedly alcoholic into it. Kili had snuck into the kitchen to nick a pair of apples and a paring knife. He convinced Bilbo to peel his apple with him and they tossed the peelings over their shoulders at the count of three. The idea was that the peelings would land in the shape of the first letter of the name of the person they were destined to marry.
“They both look like T,” remarked Kili.
“Perhaps we marry into the same family and T is for their surname,” suggested Bilbo.
“Oh, wow, I’ve never thought about the letter as the surname before. Most people here only have one name. Oh! But my father had a surname, so I guess I have one too,” Kili replied.
“What was his name?”
“Lt. Frederick Bullock!” Kili declared proudly.
“Lieutenant? He was in an officer?”
“Yup, he served twice! Oh, hey, we have the same first letter for our surnames!”
“I suppose we do,” answered Bilbo amusedly.
After they had finished eating their peeled apples they wished a good bye to the rest of the company at the table and went to visit Dis in her tower room. She and Fili had transformed it into a Divination Room for the day, with dark fabrics hung on the wall and two tables set up, one with a crystal ball and another at which sat Oin with his deck of Tarot cards.
“Hello Dis, Fili, Oin. Good day to you.”
Fili and Oin greeted Bilbo and Fili in return. There was a blinding flash and Dis appeared in front of them. She wore a dress with gold bangles from which smoke drifted across the floor of the room. “Welcome,” she greeted in a hushed voice, “to the Tower of the Third Eye. Here the cosmos parts and time folds to reveal the future to fearless seekers of premonition. Ask a question and we shall find the answer, slipping past every mortal boundary into the unknown workings of reality.”
“Hey mama,” greeted Kili.
“You do all that using deck of cards and a crystal ball?” asked Bilbo.
“Well, the crystal ball doesn’t work, it’s mostly for show. But the cards are reliable,” answered Dis, “and hello you two, good afternoon.”
Bilbo laughed heartily and wandered over to look at the crystal ball, “It really does nothing?”
“No, it’s not even crystal, it’s just glass,” said Dis coming over to join him, “but I can use magic to make images and such appear. It’s kitschy, but fun.”
Dis waved her hand over the ball and mist formed inside. Looking carefully, Bilbo could see faces in the midst. He recognized them as various faces of the company at Erebor, but they were human and without any of the strange and grotesque features that he had such trouble stomaching at his arrival. “Is this when you were all alive?” he asked.
“Yes, it is. I still remember our living faces well,” answered Dis with only little wistfulness.
Bilbo was fascinated. He recognized Balin by his beard and tried to commit to memory his kindly face. Bofur, too, he was amazed to see as other than burlap and straw. To see Nori and Dori wholesome was also particularly mesmerizing.
Kili grabbed Bilbo by the arm and pulled him away from the crystal ball, “Come on! I want to see your Tarot card reading!”
“No need to pull, now,” he replied.
Fili smacked Kili across the back of his head and Oin shuffled the Tarot cards in anticipation. Bilbo took a seat opposite him and Dis and her sons crowded around the table excitedly.
Oin placed the deck on the table, “Think of a question now and cut the deck. I’m interpreting the answer, mind, so don’t think of a question you don’t want shared.”
“Alright, then”, pondered Bilbo, “Should I be worried about my shop sales?”
Bilbo cut the deck and Oin laid out four cards in a diamond pattern, moving clockwise from the top. His first card at the top of the diamond was the Three of Wands. On the right was the Four of Cups, then at the bottom was the Lovers, and to the Left was the Wheel of Fortune, but it was upside down from Bilbo’s perspective. He heard Kili inhale sharply and mutter, “A reversed card…”
“Well, lad, looks like you’ve have bigger things to have on your mind than your shop,” said Oin.
“What? Like what?”
“This card here,” said Oin tapping the Wheel of Fortune to the left, “represents career. Since it’s reversed I can see you’ve had some delays and unexpected interruptions and bad luck in your career. Ordinarily, I’d think this means you have difficulties coming, but from the rest of the cards, it makes me think it’s been in your past.”
“Yes, I’d say that’s about right,” replied Bilbo.
“This one here though,” he said tapping the Four of Cups to the right, “this one represents finance, and it says that it’s time to re-evaluate your lot in life right now. You’re bored perhaps, eh? Dwelling on the path, feeling dissatisfied, everything too familiar and routine now?”
Bilbo was hesitant to admit how spot on that was about the pawn shop. Bilbo had been spending most of his time remembering his history studies, longing to return to a museum basement, and putting the pawn shop behind him.
“Your bottom card here, the Lovers, isn’t necessarily about love,” continued Oin, “This is your only Major Arcana card, so I’d say it’s the most important. It means you have difficult decision to make, a struggle between two paths that needs to be resolved. But Bilbo, this card says that decision isn’t to be made intellectually, but with intuition. You need to feel your way through this. This card in the formation represents health and happiness. So it’s an important decision.”
“Now your top card is about love, and this one rounds out the picture,” he continued, pointing to the Three of Wands, “Your bad luck in career, your boredom, the difficult decision to make, well there’s a big reward for making the right choice. This card is the fulfillment of a dream. Plans and ventures moving ahead, successful enterprise, all coming from the coincidence of being in the right place at the right time and having the courage to follow your own convictions.”
“My own… convictions?” Bilbo asked.
“Aye, well, considering it’s in the placement for love, I’d say that means following the path or the person you love without letting your mind getting in the way of your heart, and that will lead you to your dream coming to fruition and to happiness.”
“What’s your dream, Bilbo?” asked Kili. Both Fili and Dis hushed him and Kili looked appropriately apologetic.
“Well, I always wanted to curate my own museum exhibition,” thought Bilbo. What he didn’t share was he thought the reading suggested leaving his parents’ pawn shop to continue his education. It’s certainly something he had thought about, but leaving the family store behind would be leaving the last part of his parents that seemed to still be alive. It certainly was a difficult decision.
“Well, then, follow your heart, and you’ll be curating in no time!” declared Kili.
“Do you want a reading next?” asked Bilbo.
“Oh, well, we get the same stuff every year, being dead and all. But I can get a reading done for you to see, if you want!”
He and Bilbo switched places and Oin reshuffled the deck. As Kili cut the deck he asked, “Will I get the most screams at the Marathon of Horror Tomorrow?”
Oin dealt the four cards and Dis gasped while Fili looked on in confusion. Kili went a little pale. After a moment Fili said to Bilbo, “This is a different hand than he’s ever been dealt before.”
At the top, for love, was the Two of Cups. Oin explained how it foretold the beginning of a new romance, partnership, or friendship filled with trust and affection, even resolving conflict between opposites. To the left, for career, was the Two of Pentacles. It foretold vast and imminent changes and movement, which would take many skills to navigate and balance, but if done successfully will result in reward. They all laughed at his bottom card, the Fool, for health and happiness, which described Kili well as someone of innocence, spontaneity, and naivety. But once again it foretold great change and even a complete overturn of the status quo. However, it was optimistic; it was the beginning of a new life cycle and suggested happiness and energy. His last card, for finance, to the right, was the Ten of Cups. It promised lasting happiness and security, true friendship, happy family life, and perfect concord and fulfillment.
“Whatever the great change is, it’s probably what changed your card reading, too,” commented Fili.
“You go next,” encouraged Dis, “maybe your reading is different this year too.”
Fili took place next, and as he cut the deck, he asked, “Is there change coming for me as well?”
His bottom card (health and happiness) affirmed change for him as well. It was the Six of Swords, predicting a solution to current problems and the overcoming of obstacles: a gradual moving away from pain and difficulty. To the right (finance) was the Eight of Wands, which was a card of hope. It said the time and conditions were right for taking initiative and facilitating success, it promised an end to delays. To the left (career) was the Major Arcana card the Sun, which foretold contentment and happiness upon achieving success. It promised acclaim, academic achievement, approval, material happiness, and good health.
“Looks like you’ll have a good career, likely as result of this change. You’ll have it good in love too, see, the Three of Cups: great happiness from love or birth, something coming to fruition that was born out of love. It could mean marriage or perhaps it’s love in your work,” explained Oin.
Fili was overwhelmed by the good news of his cards, “Usually they just tell us how we’re frustrated, dwelling on the past, and at a standstill. What the hell is this great change?” He left the room with tears in his eyes.
Dis had a reading next but her cards were the same as always. They weren’t bad, however, and Dis wasn’t disappointed. “I had my greatest adventure in life with my husband, and I couldn’t be happier with Kili and Fili. I’m glad they now too seem to have a great opportunity coming forward to them,” she explained. Her fortune was a powerful deal of cards, with two Major Arcana and two Queens from the Minor Arcana. Her topmost card, for love, was the Star. It spoke of fresh hope and renewal, a healing of old wounds, and a mental and physical broadening of horizons. “That would be my sons,” she told Bilbo, “We never thought beforehand that we could have children. They changed everything. They brought so much happiness.”
Kili blushed deeply.
Her card for career was the Queen of Wands, which described her as capable, fair, generous, and that she enjoyed social ease and was protective of those in her circle. Her card for health and happiness, the Queen of Swords, described her as complex, courageous, and intelligent who had suffered deep sorrow or loss. “We all have suffered such things deeply,” elaborated Dis, “but I like to think this is about my husband, especially since it also describes balancing two opposing factions to fit my needs. I think those factions would be this world and his.”
Her last card, for finance, was Temperance, which described combination and innovation through co-operation, and harmony and balance. Once again Dis related this to her husband and sons, “I encouraged my husband to do renovations on the castle. He was a carpenter by trade; actually, he specialized in renovating old buildings, so it was perfect. But it was difficult to get all the supplies here since the door was open for such short of time. It took a lot of co-ordination and I did most of that.”
When Oin was reshuffling the deck after Dis’ reading Fili returned with Thorin in tow.
“Fili told me about his reading. And Kili got a different one too, is that right?” he asked.
“Yes, but I didn’t. You can try, though, of course. Who knows what this big change is,” replied Dis.
“Oh, yes, try it uncle, then I can tell you about my reading,” added Kili.
“Tell me if something new is afoot,” asked Thorin, cutting the deck. He stared with a tense jaw as a new hand was dealt. The top card for romance was the Knight of Cups, the bottom for health and happiness was the Three of Swords, and to the left for career was the Ten of Swords, and to the left for finance was Strength.
“The two Minor Arcana for the Swords suit both describe ruin, disruption, and sorrow, but unlike your usual hand both cards have an optimistic ending. The Ten of Swords tells you that you have reached the lowest point and that things can only get better from here. The Three of Swords tells you that this heartbreak lead to the establishment of something better. Strength is power under control. It is courage, self-control, and generosity. It is fortitude, resolve, and the power of love. It is the ultimate enemy of tyranny. And the Knight of Cups, well, good news Thorin, looks like there’s change and new opportunities of a romantic nature for you. This person is a bringer of opportunities and ideas, he is artistic, refined, amiable, and full of high principals, but be careful not to discourage him,” warned Oin.
“Oooo,” said Dis, “I’m going to get a brother-in-law.”
Thorin looked at her sharply.
“Or a sister-in-law! Who knows who this mystery sweetheart is. Could be any new person you’ve met recently or in the near future. Maybe you’re going to share a very intimate moment with the love of your life this Halloween when you visit the world of the living. Very exciting!”
Thorin shook his head, “The Queen of Swords is supposed to be mature.”
After Thorin’s reading Dis staged visions in the crystal ball to fit the new Tarot readings and made many predictions about what the change was, what Fili’s career would be, and the many ridiculous lovers of Thorin. Dis got the most laughs with her version that Thorin’s head and body each had separate lovers and the body was enamoured with a headless mannequin. Throughout the shenanigans Thorin was distracted and surprisingly did not lose his temper.
After a while Bilbo left the family to get lunch from the kitchen. In the dining room Dori was reading tea leaves and Bilbo drank a cup in leisure while Dori told Bifur about the good luck in career soon to come his way. Afterwards, he joined up with Bofur, Nori, and Dwalin as they played cards in the courtyard.
“How is this related to the Day of Divination may I ask?”
“Well,” replied Nori, “we’re testing the fates, see. Trying to foresee our successes and failures. Broadening the horizons of our third eye and such.”
Bilbo only rolled his eyes and joined for a few hands.
When it was sundown everyone made their way to the bonfire which Gloin had already lit and had been stoking up to a mighty blaze. It had been set up a hilltop overlooking the farmlands, not actually too far from where Bilbo first woke up in Erebor. Poor Bofur and Balin had to keep their distances from the embers but were included in the merriment nonetheless. Bombur brought with him nuts for roasting as well as different kinds of cobblers. Ori came around with a bag filled with the walnuts and they all chose a couple at random and roasted them as well.
“‘You will not win the Marathon of Horror tomorrow. Too bad so sad,’” read Fili, “Nori I am about eighty percent sure you wrote this and you’re going to have to eat this note in twenty-four hours!”
“Yeah, right,” called Nori, “You haven’t won the title of Boogeyman for at least three decades now!”
“Aw, mine’s sad, it says, ‘You will meet a beautiful stranger this Halloween and you will become good friends but you will never see them again any other Halloween,’” read Bofur loudly from away the flames. Bifur had roasted his nuts for him.
Bilbo cracked his walnut open and read his fortune, “‘Something important to you will get broken before the end of the year,’ as a pawn shop owner, that is especially ominous.”
“Ey, I wrote that one!” called Gimli from across the bonfire.
As the others continued to share their fortunes Bilbo spotted that Thorin had moved away from the bonfire and was sitting down a bit lower on the hill facing the farms and castle. Bilbo snuck beside him, “You’ve been very distracted today.”
A bit startled, Thorin agreed, “Well, yes, our Tarot fortunes have never changed before. I’ve been thinking about that.”
“Hm, well, whatever caused it, at least it seems to be a good thing.”
“I haven’t been wondering what caused the change, I’ve only been wondering what the change is going to be,” he replied.
“What do you mean by that? What caused it?”
“Isn’t that obvious Bilbo?” he asked, his lips curving upwards.
“Well, if it was obvious then I wouldn’t be asking,” he bristled.
“Bilbo, it’s you of course. There’s nothing else new this year. The last time a living human came to Erebor it was also a big change. I got two nephews.”
“Oh, wow, but I don’t think I couldn’t make as big a change as that. I’m just, well, passing through.”
“You’re alive, Bilbo, that means a lot here. You have a power over fate that a dead man, cursed or not, cannot match. Life is made of changes and transformations.”
Bilbo considered this in embarrassed silence.
“I don’t think it’s been properly stated how happy we all are that you are here for Hallowtide. We met in strange circumstances, and it was by the inscrutable will of a wizard, I know, but you already have made changes here. You may not have come here by your own choice, but you have already made our home feel like a home again, and no longer like a cage.”
“I, wow, have I really done all that? Without even knowing it?”
“Yes, Bilbo, you have. Without even trying.”
“Well, I may just have been pulled along for the ride, but I am happy to be here, too. One of my Tarot cards said I was bored and, well, I admit that is true. This is the most fun I’ve had since my parents died, and honestly, the least lonely I’ve felt.”
The two sat in companionable silence for some time, the laughter and caucus of the company above filling the air between them. After a while Gloin, Balin, and Dori went off the light the fireworks. Gandalf had made some of them themed especially for Halloween, with orange, green, and purple illuminating the sky with shapes of skulls and pumpkins and bats. Mostly, though, they were all-occasion, but still spectacular.
“Thorin, I don’t know if you feel the same way, but I’m especially happy I met you. I know at times we have friction and all that, but you are good company.”
“Even when I lose my head?” he scoffed.
“Both your head and your body make good company,” Bilbo affirmed.
It was much later into the night, after both of them had returned to the bonfire, that Thorin managed to return the compliment.
